Catfish: The TV Show (2012–…): Season 7, Episode 20 - Rachael & Vance - full transcript
Nev and co-host Kamie Crawford fly to Iowa to help Rachael meet Vance, her decade long Myspace romance. As they dig into Vance's past, Rachael is left wondering if he really is the man she spent half her life in love with.
- Rachael met Vance online
11 years ago.
- His looks are just extra.
I'm in love with him.
- Whoa.
This guy's got a long
arrest record.
It's possible that
he may have been
communicating with you
from prison.
- What?
- Whoa.
- No.
No, no, no, no, no.
Oh, my God.
[dramatic musical sting]
- What's up, everybody?
We're back and this week
we have a very special co-host,
someone I'm very excited about.
And here she is,
Kamie Crawford.
- Hey, guys.
- Kamie really is all that.
Being crowned Miss Teen USA
was just the first step
in her unique journey
to awesomeness.
Modeling in a world that deems
anyone over a size 4
as plus-sized,
Kamie has been
a fashion disrupter.
She's the designer of her own
lifestyle brand,
a journalist, a beauty guru,
and this week I am thrilled
to have her here.
Welcome to the show.
- Thank you.
I'm a huge fan.
- What's your favorite episode?
- "You should have never
called me
a fat ass Kelly Price!"
- Should of never called me
a fat ass Kelly Price!
- [laughing] That's
my favorite.
- Yeah, Antwane and Carmen.
- Yes, and you couldn't
find Tony.
And you guys were out
in the cold.
That would have pissed me off.
- That was cold.
- I would have been so mad.
- Let's sit down.
Find out what's going on.
- God, I'm so excited.
I can't believe
it's actually happening.
I've been thinking
about it all night.
Just so you know.
I like, couldn't get to sleep.
- Aren't you tired?
- That's what
concealer's for.
- [laughing]
This is good, we're getting
to know each other.
Now comes a very
important part of the episode
where I bestow upon you...
- Oh.
- The responsibility
of the Max cam.
Basically, film me.
- Yeah.
- From the best angle.
All right.
Here we go.
We got an email here
from Samantha.
"Hi Nev and Kamie.
"I'm Samantha, I'm 19 years old
"and I'm from Iowa City, Iowa.
"I'm writing to tell you
about my sister, Rachael
And her mysterious MySpace
lover, Vance..."
- ♪ I've been spending ♪
- "From North Carolina."
- ♪ My attention on you ♪
- "Rachael is 23 years old
but met Vance online
when she was 12."
- ♪ I don't wait long ♪
- "He made my sister so happy
"And to this day has
brought out a side of her
that no other man has."
- Has she had another man?
She's been dating him
since she was 12.
- Well, she's 23.
Well, we don't know
that they've been dating.
- Okay.
- "The thing about Vance
"and Rachael's relationship
"Is that it has never gone
further than phone calls."
- Dun dun dun.
- "She asks to video chat,
"Vance goes from being
Mr. Wonderful
to the king of excuses."
- ♪ When you gonna
take me out? ♪
- "Rachael has also tried
"to meet him face-to-face
multiple times,
"but after making plans
there's always a sudden reason
he can't."
- ♪ So much talking ♪
♪ Swear that's all
you ever do ♪
- "Nothing about Vance adds up.
"And if he loves my sister
as much as he claims to,
why won't he meet her?"
- I'm asking
the same thing, girl.
- ♪ I know that you
would want it ♪
- "Rachael said
it was okay for me
to write in to you
after all these years."
- ♪ If I could sink my teeth
into you ♪
- "Rachael needs to decide
"if she's going to open
"a new chapter of her life
with him
or close the book completely."
- ♪ First you gotta
ask me out ♪
- "Please help my sister.
Thank you."
- Mm.
No.
- Wow. All right, so you're,
you're coming...
- No.
- Out of the gate
with a "No."
- It's a no for me, dawg.
- It's a no for you.
- No.
- Clearly something's up.
Here we go. Rachael.
[dialing]
- [gasps]
- Hey.
- Hi.
- Hi, Rachael.
How you doing?
- Good, how are you?
- Great.
- I love your hoops.
- Thank you.
[giggling]
- I want to introduce you
to Kamie.
She is helping me out
this episode.
- I'm excited.
- So your little sister...
- Yes.
- Wrote into us
on your behalf.
- You have to be
really close, obviously.
- Oh, yeah.
We actually live together.
And we're, like, inseparable.
If I can't speak up,
she's the person that's
gonna speak up for me.
- I have five sisters,
so I'm with you.
Can't beat that sisterly bond.
- So tell us how you
met Vance on MySpace
and sort of how this whole
situation has developed
over the last decade.
- We were young teenagers.
MySpace was the thing
back then.
[chuckling]
And he had reached out to me.
The connection that we have,
he just takes me to, like,
a whole 'nother place.
Like, when I talk to him
I can just feel like
I'm not being judged, and
just have a conversation
with someone.
Like, it was literally,
I would go to sleep
on the phone with him
and I would wake up
on the phone with him.
- I just remember having
a crush like that.
Oh, it was such a magical time.
- I've...yeah.
- Was it immediate
kind of crush,
"Oh, my--this boy's so cute."
- Well, of course.
It was MySpace
and his profile picture
was him
like, shirtless,
with, like, his abs out
and everything.
- At 12?
- Mm-hmm.
- See, none of the boys
I was talking to
at 12 or 13 had abs.
Let me tell you.
- Right.
- All right, so anyways, so
in the last 11 years
were you guys, like, together,
or sort of dating?
- To me that wasn't, like,
a logical
expectation,
because he's in North Carolina
and I'm in Iowa.
Like, especially, like,
we're teenagers.
I talked to other people
and I had relationships
just like he did.
But he's single right now,
I'm single right now, like,
there should be
no excuse at this point.
- And has he ever been,
like, serious,
where he's like, "Let's try
to make this work?"
- He's said that
multiple times.
We've talked about
us trying to build a life
together.
But we're both adults.
Why hasn't it happened yet?
- You've been talking
on the phone
pretty much the whole time
you've known each other.
- Yeah, but he changes
his number.
Sometimes he'll go ghost
and I won't talk to him
for a while
and all of the sudden
he'll call me off
a new number.
- Weird, why has he had
so many phone numbers?
- I have no idea.
But the last six months
like, I don't even talk to him
on a phone.
Like, it's strictly
Facebook messaging.
- But Facebook has, like,
you can call and...
video message, can't you?
- Call, right.
There's always an excuse.
He always says,
"I don't have a good enough
Wi-Fi connection"
or "My camera on my phone
is broke."
Like, we've tried to meet.
We've made plans.
Like, I've even offered, like,
to buy a plane ticket
for him to come here
and then he made up
an excuse of, like,
"Oh, I don't have an ID."
- But doesn't it concern you
that if he is who he is
that he can't get
his act together?
What's up with this dude?
- That's the big concern.
I don't want another child
to take care of.
- Do you have a child?
- I have three.
- Oh. Hey, girl.
- Yeah. [laughing]
- Yes. Girl.
- So you have three children.
- I do.
- How old are they?
- I have an eight-year-old.
My son will be four
in November.
And then I have
a five-week-old.
- What!
- Rachael.
- [laughing]
- Wait, and so, okay,
I guess it didn't
work out with...
the guys.
- Yeah, no.
- Wow, so you've got
your hands full.
- I do, and that's when
I say, like,
I don't want to have to
take care of another child.
Like, I don't.
Like, you're not gonna
be able to just
come sit on my couch.
That's not gonna happen.
- Does Vance know you have
three kids?
- Yes.
- Do you think that
the relationship with
your babies' fathers
so far hasn't worked
because you want it
to work with Vance?
- I definitely think so.
- Whoa.
- I love him. I, honest--like,
I honestly love him
and I care about him a lot.
- All right, well,
we are gonna hit the road.
- We got you.
Don't worry.
- Yay! I'm so excited.
- All right, Rachael.
See you soon.
- Bye.
- Bye.
- Bye.
- All right.
- Are you on board
with me now?
- Well, Vance
is hiding something.
- Yeah. I wonder
if it's just, like,
he doesn't like
the way that he looks,
or if it's like...
he's just not who
he says he is...
- Let's go find out.
- We're going to Iowa.
I feel like Dora the Explorer.
- ♪ Generation L ♪
♪ ♪
♪ Lost and low ♪
- Well. We made it
to Iowa City, Iowa.
- Yay.
- I don't know, there's just
something so...
perfectly American about Iowa.
- It's like, very homegrown.
- Yeah.
This little street
right here.
- Whoo.
- Let's do it.
- Look at you.
Got the diapers,
got the wipes.
You are ready to go.
[doorbell rings]
both: Hi!
- Hey!
Wait a second.
- I'm Samantha.
I called in to the show.
- Samantha! Oh!
- Yes.
- What's up, ladies?
- Nice to meet you.
- Hi.
- Hi.
We brought you some supplies.
- Oh, my gosh.
Nice to meet you.
- Nice to meet you.
- Got some diapers
and some wipes.
- Oh, my goodness.
- Just a little gift.
- Thank you guys.
- Yeah.
- You guys want some tea
or anything?
- Yeah, sure,
that would be great.
- I'm a big fan of "Catfish."
A lot of people look up
to your show.
- Oh, that's nice to hear.
- That's why she wrote in...
- Yeah, that's why
you trusted us
with your sister's love life.
- Little sister helping
the big sister, you know.
- I know, what would she do
without you?
- I have no idea.
- Nothing.
- Oh. [laughing]
- I'm just, like...
I'm playing.
- Well, let's take
our tea and, uh,
sit down.
To go get the kids.
- You're gonna go? Oh.
- Well, it was nice
meeting you.
- Nice meeting you.
- Thanks for writing us.
- I know, it's really--
- Hope we can figure this
all out.
- Thank you.
- Let's hope.
- I got you.
- Bye, guys.
- Bye.
- Let's sit down.
So. When you met Vance,
you were 12 years old.
What was going on in your life?
- I don't know how
to explain it. Um...
Um, I actually went through...
Um, I was sexually assaulted.
From, like, nine to ten.
And I shut down
for a long time.
And just excluded everybody.
And that's kind of where
Vance comes into play.
He came in at a time where
I was going through
some deep things.
And he was just there.
- I can imagine why
having somebody far away
who doesn't know anything
about all of that...
- Right.
- Would be really nice.
- Yeah.
- It's like a relief.
- Yeah.
- It was an escape
from reality.
- Right. Exactly.
It took me away from everything
that was going on.
- So over the 11 years
you guys have been talking
obviously there have been
ups and downs.
- Mm-hmm.
- But have you always
sort of maintained a--
some sort of communication?
Or is it just sort of like
you won't hear from each other
for a few months.
- There's always been, like,
communication there,
but there's been, like,
dips where it's
a couple months.
And then he'll pop back up.
It's been really heavy
the last six months.
But the last week and a half
he's been acting super,
super weird.
Like, I would send him
a text message
and he would read it,
and then a couple hours later
he sent my sister memes.
And I was like, "So..."
You can send my sister memes,
but you can't talk to me?
- Is it possible that
your sister and Vance
have something going on?
- No, she wouldn't.
I can trust her.
Like, I wasn't jealous.
- Is he mad at you?
Did you get into, like,
an argument?
Is he just a bad texter?
Does he send you pics?
- He's never sent me pictures.
- He's never sent you
a picture?
- That's what I'm saying,
all the pictures I see
is on Facebook.
- Right. Right.
- Or that was on MySpace.
- Not even a dick pic
real quick?
'Cause they always send those.
- No. [laughing]
- Little bit hard
to make a case
that a 24 or 25 year old guy
with a hot bod...
- Wouldn't show it off.
- Doesn't have
photos of himself
to send to you.
- Right.
- All right, so what about
your parents?
Do they know about Vance?
- Well, my mom, like,
had him on Facebook.
I'm not sure if she has him
on there anymore
'cause he switched,
um, Facebook accounts.
But, like, my mom would
talk to him.
- You said
he switched Facebooks.
How many times
has he done that?
- Um, like two or three times.
- Was there an explanation
for why he
changed, like,
made a new profile?
- Mm-mm.
No.
- All right.
I gotta see this guy.
- Yeah.
- All right, can we--
can you bring up
a photo of him?
All right. So
here's his pic.
- Okay.
He's cute.
- He definitely is
more of, like,
a regular-looking guy
than I thought he was gonna be.
Seems like a bro.
- [chuckling]
- [giggling] She's so in love.
- Which is cool.
You love him.
You think he's so hot.
- I do.
- Oh, my God.
- She does. Look at her face.
- He's so hot.
- I'm super red right now.
I can feel it.
[laughing]
- I mean...
- He's cute.
- Like, his looks
are just extra, I guess.
Like...
- Right.
- I'm in love with him.
As, like, a person,
not just his looks.
Like, just how
we can communicate
and how we talk.
- I mean, that's enough for me.
- Yeah.
[both laughing]
- All right, well,
send us an email
with anything you can think of
and we'll put an end to this
decade-long mystery.
- Yes.
- All right, let's do it.
- Thank you.
- Bye, girl.
- Bye.
- She was so sweet.
- Yeah, I like her a lot.
- She's so in love.
- Yeah, she really
has a big crush on this guy.
- My mind would be
so preoccupied.
I'd be like, "I'm changing
a diaper right now.
I don't have time
to Facebook message you."
- I don't know.
She's in pretty deep.
- For sure.
If this guy isn't real,
it's gonna destroy her.
[upbeat music]
- So let's start this
investigation.
- It's research time.
- Okay.
Rachael is on the
emotional rollercoaster
that's been her life.
She met Vance online
when she was 12.
Says she's in love.
But she's concerned
because there's been
so much drama
and so many excuses
throughout this relationship.
So first we need to figure out
if "Vance," or at least the guy
she thinks is Vance
is really him.
- After 12 years, please?
It's time.
- All right.
Let's see if we can crack
this case.
All right. "Hey, Nev and Kamie,
"Here's what I remember.
So "Vance lived in Coats,
North Carolina,
"But now says he's in Raleigh.
"I think he also
lived somewhere
in Florida for a bit."
All right, well, that's
the indication
that he's a catfish.
If they've ever even
been to Florida,
you know they're a catfish.
People--catfish love Florida.
- [laughs]
- Okay, so here's his Facebook.
"I put some of his pictures
on here
"and they're about the same
as the ones on his Facebook."
All right, so we've got that.
So I think we just,
for the heck of it,
run the photos.
- Mm-hmm.
- See if any of them come up.
- I'm nervous.
- Nope. No hit.
Try this next picture.
Just need one hit.
Kay, no.
I feel like this one
would show up.
This is, like,
the black and white one.
Nothing.
- Nothing.
- All right, so this
is his Facebook page.
All right, so let's just see
who his friends are.
I would say these people look
pretty real.
Relatively balanced.
- Yeah.
- What about "About?"
Is there anything in here?
- "No workplaces to show."
No surprise.
- He has family members listed.
Sarah [bleep].
Same last name.
Lives in...
both: Raleigh.
- Mm.
- This feels real.
There's another [bleep].
She's got one cover photo.
Everything is private.
But we're putting together
the family here.
I mean, this feels right.
It's got family listed,
it all links up.
What else do we have?
All right, so let's just search
"Vance [bleep],
North..."
All right. Vance [bleep].
What is this?
Whoa.
This is insane.
- Oh, my God.
- This guy's got five
possible criminal records.
- Wow.
- Wow.
- One in Florida.
- Where?
- Bottom. Sumter County.
- What?
- Combs.
Somebody named Combs
was on his Facebook.
I saw the last name Combs.
- So wait. Let's go back
to his page.
- Yes.
- Go to his friends.
And do a "Combs" search.
- Boom.
- Ooh.
- I told you I'm the FBI.
- Wow.
This is our guy.
So there is a Vance [bleep]
in North Carolina.
- Mm-hmm.
- Who has a criminal record.
Five different charges
from 2012, 13, 14, and 17.
- But if he's in jail
how is he doing this?
- You know in jail now
they've, like, upgraded
the system.
You can talk on Facebook.
- You can?
- Yeah.
You can post on Facebook.
Now search
"Vance [bleep] mug shot"
and see if that [bleep]comes up
'cause I have a feeling
it might.
[dramatic musical flair]
Yes!
- Wow.
- I knew it!
I knew it.
- Wow.
- I knew it.
- You nailed it.
There he is.
- Oh, my God.
- Wow.
He's a criminal.
- For six months
she hasn't been able
to talk to him
on the phone.
Why is that?
- Yeah.
- Because six months ago
his ass got locked up.
- Unless this Vance guy
is not who Rachael's
talking to.
Remember, she said
Vance changed profiles.
Maybe Rachael's not even
talking to this guy.
- No, no, no.
I think this is
who Rachael's talking to.
I think he's real.
He's really talking to her
from prison.
And for a woman with three kids
it's important for her to know.
- Right.
- She could be dealing with
someone really dangerous.
- Hello?
- Rachael.
We found some things
that we want to talk
to you about.
Maybe we should meet back up.
- Yeah, we can meet up
at my mom's house.
- Great. We'll see you soon.
- How do you think
Rachael's gonna take the news?
- Honestly, with kids,
this is the worst case
scenario for her.
- Yeah.
- This is it.
- Time to go break some hearts.
- Hi.
- Hi.
We can go back here.
- Go back?
- Yep.
- Have you heard from Vance
at all?
- No.
- Okay, so
let's just show you what
we found.
- Okay.
- And take it from there.
All right.
- Oh, my goodness.
- Okay. So here's
where we started.
With your email, which had
not a lot.
We searched all the pictures
and we got nothing.
- Which is a good sign.
- Yeah.
- For the most part.
- Yeah.
So then we Googled
"Vance [bleep],
North Carolina."
And the first hit
is a public records site.
Five possible criminal records.
- What?
- Once of which
was in Florida.
- Where he used to live.
- Right.
- Has he ever mentioned
any run-ins with the law?
Never?
- No.
- So then we figured okay,
if this is him
and he's got this
mysterious criminal background,
we just figured,
let's do a search
just to confirm
it's actually him
and see what comes up.
So we did.
And there's a photo.
- Oh, my God.
- It's basically a mugshot.
- Oh, my God.
- It's him.
It is Vance.
- He has been arrested
at least five times.
[soft music]
♪ ♪
- It would explain
the disappearing acts
that keep on happening.
I mean, you said the last time
you talked to him on the phone
was six months ago, about?
That, that would definitely
tie back in.
You know, you're a mom
and you have three kids
to think about.
- Right.
- Like, do you want
somebody like this...
- That's top priority.
- In their lives?
Or in your life?
- It's so scary, though.
It, it still...
There's no...
I mean, it's still scary.
- ♪ I'll choose to remember ♪
♪ You this way ♪
- Well, I don't know
a lot about...
if he was or is in prison,
what it's like,
but I think I understand
you can access the internet.
- You can use Facebook.
- So it's possible
that he may have
been communicating with you
from prison.
- ♪ Summer came and wasted
all away ♪
- I don't even know
what to say right now, like...
[sniffling]
But I don't know,
I don't know, I...
[crying]
- [crying]
I can't.
[crying]
[soft music]
♪ ♪
- Hey.
Give me a hug.
- He knows everything...
- You've given him more
than enough opportunities
to be honest with you.
But I mean, maybe he thought
that if you knew,
you wouldn't want to talk
to him anymore.
- I have three kids
with three different people,
you know what I'm saying?
So I can't judge someone off of
what they had to go through
to learn how to get
through life.
- Yeah.
- But why lie about it?
- The same way you were saying
he was your escape.
- Right.
- From reality.
- Right, I could have been
that for him.
- Yeah.
- Right.
- Not that it's right.
At all.
- Right.
- But if he is being
thrown into the system
over and over and over again,
I'm sure he's looking
for an out.
You know?
At least you know.
- Right.
- And let's figure it out.
- Let's do it.
- You can do it, girl.
You're strong.
You're a mom of three.
- [sighs]
- You got this.
- [chuckling]
- Now we need to decide
based on how you're feeling
what you wanna do.
- It's past backing out
at this point.
Like, I want to know why.
And if that's really him...
- Right.
- Then, like, I need to know.
And I think he deservesa chance
to give explanations
and to give answers
before I'm like, "No."
- Right.
- Yeah.
- I imagine it'd be
difficult for you
to leave town
with everything you've got
going on here.
- Right.
- So
it'd probably be easier
to bring him here.
- Yeah.
- Assuming he's not
currently incarcerated.
- Right.
- Right.
We can message him together
from my account
and just say "We're here,
"We don't know what's going on.
We'd love you to explain it."
- Sounds like a plan.
- All right, so let's go back
to his page.
"Hey Vance, this is Nev
from the TV show "Catfish,"
"I'm here in Iowa
with your friend Rachael
"Making an episode.
"We would love to give
you guys an opportunity
"To finally meet each other
and talk
"After all these years.
"Please get back to me
when you can. Thanks, Nev.
- What are you thinking?
- I don't...
I don't know.
Like, I'm just, like,
lost for words right now.
Like, is he gonna disappear?
[video chat ringing]
What?
- Is he calling?
- He's calling you
on Facebook.
- Hello?
- Yeah, hey.
What's up, Vance?
How you doing?
- Very for real.
In fact, happy to turn on
my camera if that would help
prove that for you.
- All right.
- She is.
- Hi, Vance.
- We're here to make--
to do whatever we have to
to make it as easy as possible
for you and Rachael to finally
meet each other.
You know, if we can make
the arrangements
for you to get here,
are you down to do that?
- Right, well, I understand.
We can make
all the arrangements.
We'll pay for the ticket.
- [no audible dialogue]
- I don't like this plan.
I mean, look, I want
to make this happen
and I want you guys
to meet each other,
but it just feels weird that
this would be the way to do it.
It just...
It seems a little shady
to be perfectly honest
with you.
- Yep.
- Fine.
- All right.
- All right, so look.
I'll have one of our producers
message you.
You can give us
the information on--
with Caesar's name,
and how much money you'll need,
and, and...
hopefully it'll all work out.
- We'll make it happen.
- Does that sound like
it works?
- Okay, do you
currently have a phone
you can be reached on?
'Cause I know you're
calling us...
- All right.
- That, that, that's weird.
I-I--it's just
super sketchy to me.
- That was him?
- Yeah, that's who I've--
that voice and everything.
But how he was acting,
I've never dealt with that.
- "Wire me money
and I'll get the ticket.
But don't worry,
I'll be there."
- "And don't wire it to me."
- "My friend."
- "Wire it to my friend."
- I don't even know.
- You all right?
- Yeah.
I'm just ready to...
get answers.
- In the meantime, I guess,
you know, just don't
let yourself
get too wound up.
All right.
- See you guys later.
- See ya.
- Bye.
- Oh, man.
- I don't know.
I mean, the guy went
from being, like,
unreliable and a little shady
to, like, potentially,
like, a hardened...
- Criminal.
- Con artist, scammer,
I don't know.
- She's--she was hurt at first.
- Yeah.
- And then she just got angry.
Hopefully he shows up.
You know what they say.
"Hell hath no fury."
[knocking on door]
- I got an update.
We got work...
- Oh.
- To do.
- Great. I didn't get
any sleep.
I just am too, like, anxious.
- Look at this message
that came in from Vance.
- "Thanks, Nev,
"I think the plane
will get me there at 11."
- Has anyone confirmed?
- We sent the money.
He got, he got--The money
we sent to Caesar [bleep]
was received.
- Okay.
- Maybe this Caesar guy
is really who she's talking to?
Aye, dio mio.
[phone ringing]
- Rachael.
- We sent him the money
and Vance texted me and said
he's coming.
All that's left for him to do
is just get on the plane.
All right.
- See you soon.
[knocking]
- Hey!
- Hi.
- Oh, look at you!
- Oof.
- Okay.
- Here we are. It's now...
10:15.
We're in the hour of arrival.
- I'm just super nervous.
The unknown is scary.
So it's like I don't know
how I'm gonna handle it.
Like, he's gonna have
to be honest.
- Yeah.
- And if he's not,
and if he's not able
to answer questions,
then there's no reason for us
to continue any type
of communication.
He just texted me.
He said "I'm here.
Just landed."
- All right.
I mean, look,
why don't you tell him
"Meet us at Turkey Creek Park."
- It's getting real.
- Yeah, right?
- Very.
- It's, like, a 20-minute
drive from here.
So we should...
- Head out.
- Let's do it.
- ♪ Be your bleeding heart ♪
[phone ringing]
- Sam.
- So me, Nev, and Kamie
are on our way to the park
to meet Vance.
- I mean, I don't know if
that's what you would call it.
I'm just trying to keep, like,
a level head.
Like, I don't want
to get myself excited
and then it not be him.
I don't want to freeze up.
- Well, we'll see.
- All right, love you too.
♪ ♪
- Almost there.
- No.
- I guess we'll just
find a spot.
♪ ♪
You got this.
If you can handle three kids
you can handle this.
- Oh, my God.
- ♪ Over me ♪
- [exhales deeply]
- All right, well.
- It's a waiting game now.
- So he should be here.
- This is not okay.
I have never been
this nervous in my life.
- Oh.
- [gasps] Who's that?
- This looks like a...
Uber-esque type car.
- Oh, my God.
No.
- Oh, whoa.
- No, no, no, no, no.
- No.
No, no, no, no, no.
Shut the [bleep] up.
Oh, my God.
- Hey.
- Hey, how's it going?
- Nev.
- Vance.
- Good to meet you.
- I'm Kamie.
- Very nice to meet you, Kamie.
- Nice to meet you too.
- Oh, wow.
- Uh...
We'll just let her
come out when she's ready.
Well, thanks for showing up.
- Uh, not a problem.
Said I'd make it happen.
- You did.
- We're happy you're here.
- Yeah.
I got so many questions, but
I wanted Rachael to hear
everything, so,
Whenever you're ready.
We're--we're waiting.
- Should I walk her over?
- Yeah, maybe.
[soft music]
- I'm, like, so stuck
right now.
I'm like, I can't even think.
- It's time to boss up.
Let's get it together.
You owe it to yourself.
You want to know.
You can do it.
- Oh, my God.
I feel sick to my stomach.
- Well, if you throw up
I'll catch it for ya.
- [breathing hard]
Oh, my God.
- All right.
Why don't you say hello?
- Rachael, Vance.
- Hey, Rachael.
- Oh, my God.
- What's going on?
This is real.
- He's here.
He came a long way.
It's been a long time.
- Wow.
- She's a little shook
right now.
- All right, well.
Why don't we discuss
the elephant in the room?
She sort of told us that
you'll kind of
stop talking,
and she won't hear from you
for a while,
and then you'll pop back up.
Um, is that because
you were in some sort
of detention center
or...?
- No. Not at all.
- We found what looks to be
an arrest record.
- Maybe if you could just
shed a little bit of light
on, you know,
what's been going on with you.
Just to give her some clarity
so she--so she knows.
- The arrest is just
what it is.
It only happened one time
and it was all dismissed, so.
- So you did not serve time?
- No.
- You haven't been
in jail or anything.
- I went to jail.
They held me overnight.
- Oh, well, that's--
- So the next morning
they released me.
- Right. Right.
- There were a few listed
from different years.
- In North Carolina mostly
and then once in Florida.
- That wasn't me.
I've never been arrested--
- So you've never been
arrested in Florida?
- No.
The only thing I ever
got in Florida
was a speeding ticket.
- Okay, so maybe
those other things
were just those speeding
tickets you mentioned.
Good to clear all this up.
So.
So you live in North Carolina.
- Yes.
- And what is it
that you mostly do
in terms of work
or school...?
- I mean, I kinda just
been living life
bouncing around, you know.
My parents
weren't there for me,
I kinda just been struggling.
I don't go to school,
but work, I just kinda do
like, cash jobs, you know?
You know, like...
Whatever comes my way.
Little gigs off of maybe
Craigslist or whatnot.
It hasn't been easy for me.
- At the moment you have
a place with friends, or...
- I'm actually staying
with a friend
as of right now.
- Okay.
And you're not hiding
some secret life, or...
- You don't have a girlfriend
or a wife or...
- Kids...
- No.
- Everything you've told her
this last...whole time
has been true.
- Yeah.
- Either your phones
have been broken,
or you haven't had a place,
or you've been in between work,
or you just haven't had money
to come visit.
That's all legit?
- That's all legit.
- But...
I mean, the funds were
never really an issue.
'Cause I've offered.
- You did on the funds,
but still wouldn't have bought,
like, the ID.
It's not that easy.
- But, I mean, you need
to have an ID.
- I don't have
a lot of things.
- What about the times
I tried to come out there?
- Did you come?
You can't blame me
for something
that you didn't do.
- Not like it's easy for me
just to pack up
and just come.
Like, I have to plan out
child care.
- But, like, you spoke that--
- He's saying that he felt like
you sort of would bring it up
but never really
follow through.
- It never went past,
"Oh, yeah, well,
I can come there."
And then it was never really
talked about again.
Okay, so that day
when I wrote you
and you literally read it
and did not say anything
back to me
Why could you just up and send
my sister Sam a message
like it was nothing?
- You're talking about the time
he texted Sam
but didn't get back
to you right away?
- Right. Which is fine,
like, I wasn't jealous,
it was more of
you weren't talking to me,
you weren't responding to me,
you were leaving
my messages unread
but you were writing her.
- Was that just one day?
- It's been a couple times.
- Time out.
This sort of sounds like
a bunch of stupid,
petty [bleep].
Okay, look.
Let's get back to the
strange, but still, I think,
lovely reality that, like,
you guys have been talking
for a really long time.
Since you were kids.
You've had your life.
He's had his.
They've been very complicated
in their own ways.
But now you're here finally.
Let's not let
this, little sort of details
totally ruin this.
- This is the moment
you both have been waiting for
for over a decade.
- It's not that I'm not happy
to see him.
I don't know what to say.
I don't, I don't know
how I'm feeling right now.
Like, it's just a lot.
- He's here.
- Right.
- And if there's no big, crazy,
messed up secret...
This is the guy you've been
talking to
for a long time
and he came here to see you.
It doesn't have to all be
happy butterflies and rainbows
but can, like, can there be
a little bit of relief?
I feel like
maybe we need to just,
like...
- Hug it out?
- All right. What do you
want me to do?
- Just stand in front of him.
And look at him.
He's here.
He, he's, he wants to
look at you,
you want to look at him.
Just look at each other
and acknowledge that, like,
wow, here we are.
- Come on, Rachael.
- I don't even want
a handshake.
- Never mind.
Give me a hug.
- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
There we go.
- I'm here.
- Oh, I love love so much.
[giggling]
- I'm real.
- Oh, my God.
- You're real.
- Didn't that feel nice?
- This is great.
I would love to just
let you guys talk
without our...
awkward supervision.
I mean, you could even just
sit right here on a bench.
You guys have a lot
to talk about.
- Get to know each other.
In real life.
IRL, as they say online.
- IRL.
- Okay, well, let's sit down.
We're gonna go hang in the car.
- Holler if you need us.
- Yeah, we'll just be
right over there.
[thoughtful music]
- This is crazy.
On the phone it's different.
'Cause, like, I can
just talk to you.
- It's very different.
Very different.
It don't seem real, does it?
- No.
- Whoo.
- I mean...
- Wow.
It was weird.
- Is it usually that awkward?
- No.
Obviously she's very nervous.
- She was going through a lot
of emotions.
- Yeah.
And I think he is too.
I mean, I could see
he was shake--
he was trembling a little bit.
I think he was
definitely nervous.
- Yeah.
- But that's okay, I mean,
they'll...
they'll recover from that,
I think.
- I feel like I just, like,
dropped my daughter off
at her first date
and now I'm just, like...
trying to see what goes down.
- Um, what do you think?
- What do you mean?
- I came all the way out here.
I'm obviously interestedin you.
Are you excited,
are you happy--
- Well, yeah,
I've been excited.
It wasn't even that
I wasn't excited. I just--
- I didn't know, like...
- I keep things bottled up.
And, like, and it's weird--
- Well, un-bottle it.
Pop the top.
- [laughing]
- I get the sense that, like,
he's down.
- Yeah, he seemed open.
- I just think he's
a little too proud
to admit that, like,
he's broke.
- Yeah.
- He's struggling.
- Yeah.
- Sleeping on a friend's couch.
And bus tickets aren't cheap.
- Yeah.
- You know, that's probably
$250 or more, you know.
That's a lot of money for him.
- Yeah.
- What do you want to happen?
What do you think?
- I mean, I definitely
don't expect you to
just be like, "Oh, yeah,
Move in tomorrow."
Like, that's--it's
not realistic
like, for neither you or I.
But I think that we should
I mean, maybe plan...
[sighs]
like, a trip,
maybe me and the kids
and Sam or whatever.
- I mean, I'm open
to doing all that.
I care about you.
I love you.
- Yeah. I love you, too.
- Knock, knock.
- Hey, guys.
- Hello.
- Why don't we go
get a bite to eat?
Let you guys hang out.
- First date vibes.
Perhaps?
- Oh, yeah.
- Great. Let's go.
- ♪ You may not look like me ♪
♪ You may feel differently ♪
- All right.
We survived.
- We definitely did.
- [chuckling]
- For a moment there
it was iffy.
- ♪ Everybody everybody
everybody ♪
♪ Want to have a good life ♪
♪ Too many get a hard knock ♪
- All right, guys.
- We're just gonna
drop you off here.
- Good to meet you.
- Good to meet you.
- Enjoy.
- Have fun, guys.
- Well, thank you guys.
Enjoy.
- He seems great.
- Okay.
- ♪ Give us that real love ♪
- Well, I think our work hereis done.
- I'm very satisfied.
- We got 'em through
the rough patch.
I have a good feeling
about them.
- I do too.
- I'm excited I got
to meet you.
I'm really excited.
- It wasn't that I wasn't
excited to see you
'cause I was.
But I was stuck.
- Well, I think that
we should kinda just take it
step by step.
- I mean, we talked about
building a house
and having a family.
Is that something
you want to do?
- That is something
I want to do.
- Down the road?
- Yeah.
- Really?
- Yeah.
- [laughing]
I do, too.
- I'll get my ducks in a row.
- Yeah?
♪ ♪
- ♪ Give us that real love ♪
[dialing]
- Hey!
- Hey.
What's up, Rachael?
What's up with you and Vance?
- [sighs]
- Uh-oh.
- I mean...
We were talking a little bit.
And he was just acting
super weird.
And I was just like,
I'm not gonna sit here
and I'm not gonna keep
like, trying to beg you
to be in my life.
- I'm so sorry.
It felt like there was
some optimism
in that maybe he was going
to get his act together.
- No.
Right after we saw each other
he had asked me to, like,
send him money, so--
And I, of course,
said, like, no.
- I mean, I was bummed,
but then once you said that,
I mean, like...
- Yeah.
I'm over it.
- Right.
I don't want to have to
take care of another person.
Like, I just had to, like,
snap out of it.
- Good for you, girl.
You seem, like, freer.
- Yeah, now I can, like,
get myself together
and move on
and not have that "what if"
in the back of my head.
- And what about your sister?
How's everything going
with her?
- She's actually right here.
- Hey, guys.
- Hey, girl.
- Hey.
At least you got your sister
through all this.
Just be there for you,
so that's awesome.
- We're family.
Me and my sister have been
through so much.
Come on.
- All right, girls.
Be good.
all: Bye.
- You never know
what you might do.
- Very special cohost. the one
and only Nick Young.
- How's it going, man?
- "I watch the show
"Love & Hip Hop"
"and I've fallen for one
of the guys on there,
Rich Dollaz."
- Seen him on TV
and my heart jumped out
of my chest.
This is the most
convincing catfish
I'll have ever seen.
- Can I wait in the car?
I'm scared.
- He should be here.
- Oh, my God, oh, my God,
oh, my God.
- This is crazy.
1325
00:41:37.
11 years ago.
- His looks are just extra.
I'm in love with him.
- Whoa.
This guy's got a long
arrest record.
It's possible that
he may have been
communicating with you
from prison.
- What?
- Whoa.
- No.
No, no, no, no, no.
Oh, my God.
[dramatic musical sting]
- What's up, everybody?
We're back and this week
we have a very special co-host,
someone I'm very excited about.
And here she is,
Kamie Crawford.
- Hey, guys.
- Kamie really is all that.
Being crowned Miss Teen USA
was just the first step
in her unique journey
to awesomeness.
Modeling in a world that deems
anyone over a size 4
as plus-sized,
Kamie has been
a fashion disrupter.
She's the designer of her own
lifestyle brand,
a journalist, a beauty guru,
and this week I am thrilled
to have her here.
Welcome to the show.
- Thank you.
I'm a huge fan.
- What's your favorite episode?
- "You should have never
called me
a fat ass Kelly Price!"
- Should of never called me
a fat ass Kelly Price!
- [laughing] That's
my favorite.
- Yeah, Antwane and Carmen.
- Yes, and you couldn't
find Tony.
And you guys were out
in the cold.
That would have pissed me off.
- That was cold.
- I would have been so mad.
- Let's sit down.
Find out what's going on.
- God, I'm so excited.
I can't believe
it's actually happening.
I've been thinking
about it all night.
Just so you know.
I like, couldn't get to sleep.
- Aren't you tired?
- That's what
concealer's for.
- [laughing]
This is good, we're getting
to know each other.
Now comes a very
important part of the episode
where I bestow upon you...
- Oh.
- The responsibility
of the Max cam.
Basically, film me.
- Yeah.
- From the best angle.
All right.
Here we go.
We got an email here
from Samantha.
"Hi Nev and Kamie.
"I'm Samantha, I'm 19 years old
"and I'm from Iowa City, Iowa.
"I'm writing to tell you
about my sister, Rachael
And her mysterious MySpace
lover, Vance..."
- ♪ I've been spending ♪
- "From North Carolina."
- ♪ My attention on you ♪
- "Rachael is 23 years old
but met Vance online
when she was 12."
- ♪ I don't wait long ♪
- "He made my sister so happy
"And to this day has
brought out a side of her
that no other man has."
- Has she had another man?
She's been dating him
since she was 12.
- Well, she's 23.
Well, we don't know
that they've been dating.
- Okay.
- "The thing about Vance
"and Rachael's relationship
"Is that it has never gone
further than phone calls."
- Dun dun dun.
- "She asks to video chat,
"Vance goes from being
Mr. Wonderful
to the king of excuses."
- ♪ When you gonna
take me out? ♪
- "Rachael has also tried
"to meet him face-to-face
multiple times,
"but after making plans
there's always a sudden reason
he can't."
- ♪ So much talking ♪
♪ Swear that's all
you ever do ♪
- "Nothing about Vance adds up.
"And if he loves my sister
as much as he claims to,
why won't he meet her?"
- I'm asking
the same thing, girl.
- ♪ I know that you
would want it ♪
- "Rachael said
it was okay for me
to write in to you
after all these years."
- ♪ If I could sink my teeth
into you ♪
- "Rachael needs to decide
"if she's going to open
"a new chapter of her life
with him
or close the book completely."
- ♪ First you gotta
ask me out ♪
- "Please help my sister.
Thank you."
- Mm.
No.
- Wow. All right, so you're,
you're coming...
- No.
- Out of the gate
with a "No."
- It's a no for me, dawg.
- It's a no for you.
- No.
- Clearly something's up.
Here we go. Rachael.
[dialing]
- [gasps]
- Hey.
- Hi.
- Hi, Rachael.
How you doing?
- Good, how are you?
- Great.
- I love your hoops.
- Thank you.
[giggling]
- I want to introduce you
to Kamie.
She is helping me out
this episode.
- I'm excited.
- So your little sister...
- Yes.
- Wrote into us
on your behalf.
- You have to be
really close, obviously.
- Oh, yeah.
We actually live together.
And we're, like, inseparable.
If I can't speak up,
she's the person that's
gonna speak up for me.
- I have five sisters,
so I'm with you.
Can't beat that sisterly bond.
- So tell us how you
met Vance on MySpace
and sort of how this whole
situation has developed
over the last decade.
- We were young teenagers.
MySpace was the thing
back then.
[chuckling]
And he had reached out to me.
The connection that we have,
he just takes me to, like,
a whole 'nother place.
Like, when I talk to him
I can just feel like
I'm not being judged, and
just have a conversation
with someone.
Like, it was literally,
I would go to sleep
on the phone with him
and I would wake up
on the phone with him.
- I just remember having
a crush like that.
Oh, it was such a magical time.
- I've...yeah.
- Was it immediate
kind of crush,
"Oh, my--this boy's so cute."
- Well, of course.
It was MySpace
and his profile picture
was him
like, shirtless,
with, like, his abs out
and everything.
- At 12?
- Mm-hmm.
- See, none of the boys
I was talking to
at 12 or 13 had abs.
Let me tell you.
- Right.
- All right, so anyways, so
in the last 11 years
were you guys, like, together,
or sort of dating?
- To me that wasn't, like,
a logical
expectation,
because he's in North Carolina
and I'm in Iowa.
Like, especially, like,
we're teenagers.
I talked to other people
and I had relationships
just like he did.
But he's single right now,
I'm single right now, like,
there should be
no excuse at this point.
- And has he ever been,
like, serious,
where he's like, "Let's try
to make this work?"
- He's said that
multiple times.
We've talked about
us trying to build a life
together.
But we're both adults.
Why hasn't it happened yet?
- You've been talking
on the phone
pretty much the whole time
you've known each other.
- Yeah, but he changes
his number.
Sometimes he'll go ghost
and I won't talk to him
for a while
and all of the sudden
he'll call me off
a new number.
- Weird, why has he had
so many phone numbers?
- I have no idea.
But the last six months
like, I don't even talk to him
on a phone.
Like, it's strictly
Facebook messaging.
- But Facebook has, like,
you can call and...
video message, can't you?
- Call, right.
There's always an excuse.
He always says,
"I don't have a good enough
Wi-Fi connection"
or "My camera on my phone
is broke."
Like, we've tried to meet.
We've made plans.
Like, I've even offered, like,
to buy a plane ticket
for him to come here
and then he made up
an excuse of, like,
"Oh, I don't have an ID."
- But doesn't it concern you
that if he is who he is
that he can't get
his act together?
What's up with this dude?
- That's the big concern.
I don't want another child
to take care of.
- Do you have a child?
- I have three.
- Oh. Hey, girl.
- Yeah. [laughing]
- Yes. Girl.
- So you have three children.
- I do.
- How old are they?
- I have an eight-year-old.
My son will be four
in November.
And then I have
a five-week-old.
- What!
- Rachael.
- [laughing]
- Wait, and so, okay,
I guess it didn't
work out with...
the guys.
- Yeah, no.
- Wow, so you've got
your hands full.
- I do, and that's when
I say, like,
I don't want to have to
take care of another child.
Like, I don't.
Like, you're not gonna
be able to just
come sit on my couch.
That's not gonna happen.
- Does Vance know you have
three kids?
- Yes.
- Do you think that
the relationship with
your babies' fathers
so far hasn't worked
because you want it
to work with Vance?
- I definitely think so.
- Whoa.
- I love him. I, honest--like,
I honestly love him
and I care about him a lot.
- All right, well,
we are gonna hit the road.
- We got you.
Don't worry.
- Yay! I'm so excited.
- All right, Rachael.
See you soon.
- Bye.
- Bye.
- Bye.
- All right.
- Are you on board
with me now?
- Well, Vance
is hiding something.
- Yeah. I wonder
if it's just, like,
he doesn't like
the way that he looks,
or if it's like...
he's just not who
he says he is...
- Let's go find out.
- We're going to Iowa.
I feel like Dora the Explorer.
- ♪ Generation L ♪
♪ ♪
♪ Lost and low ♪
- Well. We made it
to Iowa City, Iowa.
- Yay.
- I don't know, there's just
something so...
perfectly American about Iowa.
- It's like, very homegrown.
- Yeah.
This little street
right here.
- Whoo.
- Let's do it.
- Look at you.
Got the diapers,
got the wipes.
You are ready to go.
[doorbell rings]
both: Hi!
- Hey!
Wait a second.
- I'm Samantha.
I called in to the show.
- Samantha! Oh!
- Yes.
- What's up, ladies?
- Nice to meet you.
- Hi.
- Hi.
We brought you some supplies.
- Oh, my gosh.
Nice to meet you.
- Nice to meet you.
- Got some diapers
and some wipes.
- Oh, my goodness.
- Just a little gift.
- Thank you guys.
- Yeah.
- You guys want some tea
or anything?
- Yeah, sure,
that would be great.
- I'm a big fan of "Catfish."
A lot of people look up
to your show.
- Oh, that's nice to hear.
- That's why she wrote in...
- Yeah, that's why
you trusted us
with your sister's love life.
- Little sister helping
the big sister, you know.
- I know, what would she do
without you?
- I have no idea.
- Nothing.
- Oh. [laughing]
- I'm just, like...
I'm playing.
- Well, let's take
our tea and, uh,
sit down.
To go get the kids.
- You're gonna go? Oh.
- Well, it was nice
meeting you.
- Nice meeting you.
- Thanks for writing us.
- I know, it's really--
- Hope we can figure this
all out.
- Thank you.
- Let's hope.
- I got you.
- Bye, guys.
- Bye.
- Let's sit down.
So. When you met Vance,
you were 12 years old.
What was going on in your life?
- I don't know how
to explain it. Um...
Um, I actually went through...
Um, I was sexually assaulted.
From, like, nine to ten.
And I shut down
for a long time.
And just excluded everybody.
And that's kind of where
Vance comes into play.
He came in at a time where
I was going through
some deep things.
And he was just there.
- I can imagine why
having somebody far away
who doesn't know anything
about all of that...
- Right.
- Would be really nice.
- Yeah.
- It's like a relief.
- Yeah.
- It was an escape
from reality.
- Right. Exactly.
It took me away from everything
that was going on.
- So over the 11 years
you guys have been talking
obviously there have been
ups and downs.
- Mm-hmm.
- But have you always
sort of maintained a--
some sort of communication?
Or is it just sort of like
you won't hear from each other
for a few months.
- There's always been, like,
communication there,
but there's been, like,
dips where it's
a couple months.
And then he'll pop back up.
It's been really heavy
the last six months.
But the last week and a half
he's been acting super,
super weird.
Like, I would send him
a text message
and he would read it,
and then a couple hours later
he sent my sister memes.
And I was like, "So..."
You can send my sister memes,
but you can't talk to me?
- Is it possible that
your sister and Vance
have something going on?
- No, she wouldn't.
I can trust her.
Like, I wasn't jealous.
- Is he mad at you?
Did you get into, like,
an argument?
Is he just a bad texter?
Does he send you pics?
- He's never sent me pictures.
- He's never sent you
a picture?
- That's what I'm saying,
all the pictures I see
is on Facebook.
- Right. Right.
- Or that was on MySpace.
- Not even a dick pic
real quick?
'Cause they always send those.
- No. [laughing]
- Little bit hard
to make a case
that a 24 or 25 year old guy
with a hot bod...
- Wouldn't show it off.
- Doesn't have
photos of himself
to send to you.
- Right.
- All right, so what about
your parents?
Do they know about Vance?
- Well, my mom, like,
had him on Facebook.
I'm not sure if she has him
on there anymore
'cause he switched,
um, Facebook accounts.
But, like, my mom would
talk to him.
- You said
he switched Facebooks.
How many times
has he done that?
- Um, like two or three times.
- Was there an explanation
for why he
changed, like,
made a new profile?
- Mm-mm.
No.
- All right.
I gotta see this guy.
- Yeah.
- All right, can we--
can you bring up
a photo of him?
All right. So
here's his pic.
- Okay.
He's cute.
- He definitely is
more of, like,
a regular-looking guy
than I thought he was gonna be.
Seems like a bro.
- [chuckling]
- [giggling] She's so in love.
- Which is cool.
You love him.
You think he's so hot.
- I do.
- Oh, my God.
- She does. Look at her face.
- He's so hot.
- I'm super red right now.
I can feel it.
[laughing]
- I mean...
- He's cute.
- Like, his looks
are just extra, I guess.
Like...
- Right.
- I'm in love with him.
As, like, a person,
not just his looks.
Like, just how
we can communicate
and how we talk.
- I mean, that's enough for me.
- Yeah.
[both laughing]
- All right, well,
send us an email
with anything you can think of
and we'll put an end to this
decade-long mystery.
- Yes.
- All right, let's do it.
- Thank you.
- Bye, girl.
- Bye.
- She was so sweet.
- Yeah, I like her a lot.
- She's so in love.
- Yeah, she really
has a big crush on this guy.
- My mind would be
so preoccupied.
I'd be like, "I'm changing
a diaper right now.
I don't have time
to Facebook message you."
- I don't know.
She's in pretty deep.
- For sure.
If this guy isn't real,
it's gonna destroy her.
[upbeat music]
- So let's start this
investigation.
- It's research time.
- Okay.
Rachael is on the
emotional rollercoaster
that's been her life.
She met Vance online
when she was 12.
Says she's in love.
But she's concerned
because there's been
so much drama
and so many excuses
throughout this relationship.
So first we need to figure out
if "Vance," or at least the guy
she thinks is Vance
is really him.
- After 12 years, please?
It's time.
- All right.
Let's see if we can crack
this case.
All right. "Hey, Nev and Kamie,
"Here's what I remember.
So "Vance lived in Coats,
North Carolina,
"But now says he's in Raleigh.
"I think he also
lived somewhere
in Florida for a bit."
All right, well, that's
the indication
that he's a catfish.
If they've ever even
been to Florida,
you know they're a catfish.
People--catfish love Florida.
- [laughs]
- Okay, so here's his Facebook.
"I put some of his pictures
on here
"and they're about the same
as the ones on his Facebook."
All right, so we've got that.
So I think we just,
for the heck of it,
run the photos.
- Mm-hmm.
- See if any of them come up.
- I'm nervous.
- Nope. No hit.
Try this next picture.
Just need one hit.
Kay, no.
I feel like this one
would show up.
This is, like,
the black and white one.
Nothing.
- Nothing.
- All right, so this
is his Facebook page.
All right, so let's just see
who his friends are.
I would say these people look
pretty real.
Relatively balanced.
- Yeah.
- What about "About?"
Is there anything in here?
- "No workplaces to show."
No surprise.
- He has family members listed.
Sarah [bleep].
Same last name.
Lives in...
both: Raleigh.
- Mm.
- This feels real.
There's another [bleep].
She's got one cover photo.
Everything is private.
But we're putting together
the family here.
I mean, this feels right.
It's got family listed,
it all links up.
What else do we have?
All right, so let's just search
"Vance [bleep],
North..."
All right. Vance [bleep].
What is this?
Whoa.
This is insane.
- Oh, my God.
- This guy's got five
possible criminal records.
- Wow.
- Wow.
- One in Florida.
- Where?
- Bottom. Sumter County.
- What?
- Combs.
Somebody named Combs
was on his Facebook.
I saw the last name Combs.
- So wait. Let's go back
to his page.
- Yes.
- Go to his friends.
And do a "Combs" search.
- Boom.
- Ooh.
- I told you I'm the FBI.
- Wow.
This is our guy.
So there is a Vance [bleep]
in North Carolina.
- Mm-hmm.
- Who has a criminal record.
Five different charges
from 2012, 13, 14, and 17.
- But if he's in jail
how is he doing this?
- You know in jail now
they've, like, upgraded
the system.
You can talk on Facebook.
- You can?
- Yeah.
You can post on Facebook.
Now search
"Vance [bleep] mug shot"
and see if that [bleep]comes up
'cause I have a feeling
it might.
[dramatic musical flair]
Yes!
- Wow.
- I knew it!
I knew it.
- Wow.
- I knew it.
- You nailed it.
There he is.
- Oh, my God.
- Wow.
He's a criminal.
- For six months
she hasn't been able
to talk to him
on the phone.
Why is that?
- Yeah.
- Because six months ago
his ass got locked up.
- Unless this Vance guy
is not who Rachael's
talking to.
Remember, she said
Vance changed profiles.
Maybe Rachael's not even
talking to this guy.
- No, no, no.
I think this is
who Rachael's talking to.
I think he's real.
He's really talking to her
from prison.
And for a woman with three kids
it's important for her to know.
- Right.
- She could be dealing with
someone really dangerous.
- Hello?
- Rachael.
We found some things
that we want to talk
to you about.
Maybe we should meet back up.
- Yeah, we can meet up
at my mom's house.
- Great. We'll see you soon.
- How do you think
Rachael's gonna take the news?
- Honestly, with kids,
this is the worst case
scenario for her.
- Yeah.
- This is it.
- Time to go break some hearts.
- Hi.
- Hi.
We can go back here.
- Go back?
- Yep.
- Have you heard from Vance
at all?
- No.
- Okay, so
let's just show you what
we found.
- Okay.
- And take it from there.
All right.
- Oh, my goodness.
- Okay. So here's
where we started.
With your email, which had
not a lot.
We searched all the pictures
and we got nothing.
- Which is a good sign.
- Yeah.
- For the most part.
- Yeah.
So then we Googled
"Vance [bleep],
North Carolina."
And the first hit
is a public records site.
Five possible criminal records.
- What?
- Once of which
was in Florida.
- Where he used to live.
- Right.
- Has he ever mentioned
any run-ins with the law?
Never?
- No.
- So then we figured okay,
if this is him
and he's got this
mysterious criminal background,
we just figured,
let's do a search
just to confirm
it's actually him
and see what comes up.
So we did.
And there's a photo.
- Oh, my God.
- It's basically a mugshot.
- Oh, my God.
- It's him.
It is Vance.
- He has been arrested
at least five times.
[soft music]
♪ ♪
- It would explain
the disappearing acts
that keep on happening.
I mean, you said the last time
you talked to him on the phone
was six months ago, about?
That, that would definitely
tie back in.
You know, you're a mom
and you have three kids
to think about.
- Right.
- Like, do you want
somebody like this...
- That's top priority.
- In their lives?
Or in your life?
- It's so scary, though.
It, it still...
There's no...
I mean, it's still scary.
- ♪ I'll choose to remember ♪
♪ You this way ♪
- Well, I don't know
a lot about...
if he was or is in prison,
what it's like,
but I think I understand
you can access the internet.
- You can use Facebook.
- So it's possible
that he may have
been communicating with you
from prison.
- ♪ Summer came and wasted
all away ♪
- I don't even know
what to say right now, like...
[sniffling]
But I don't know,
I don't know, I...
[crying]
- [crying]
I can't.
[crying]
[soft music]
♪ ♪
- Hey.
Give me a hug.
- He knows everything...
- You've given him more
than enough opportunities
to be honest with you.
But I mean, maybe he thought
that if you knew,
you wouldn't want to talk
to him anymore.
- I have three kids
with three different people,
you know what I'm saying?
So I can't judge someone off of
what they had to go through
to learn how to get
through life.
- Yeah.
- But why lie about it?
- The same way you were saying
he was your escape.
- Right.
- From reality.
- Right, I could have been
that for him.
- Yeah.
- Right.
- Not that it's right.
At all.
- Right.
- But if he is being
thrown into the system
over and over and over again,
I'm sure he's looking
for an out.
You know?
At least you know.
- Right.
- And let's figure it out.
- Let's do it.
- You can do it, girl.
You're strong.
You're a mom of three.
- [sighs]
- You got this.
- [chuckling]
- Now we need to decide
based on how you're feeling
what you wanna do.
- It's past backing out
at this point.
Like, I want to know why.
And if that's really him...
- Right.
- Then, like, I need to know.
And I think he deservesa chance
to give explanations
and to give answers
before I'm like, "No."
- Right.
- Yeah.
- I imagine it'd be
difficult for you
to leave town
with everything you've got
going on here.
- Right.
- So
it'd probably be easier
to bring him here.
- Yeah.
- Assuming he's not
currently incarcerated.
- Right.
- Right.
We can message him together
from my account
and just say "We're here,
"We don't know what's going on.
We'd love you to explain it."
- Sounds like a plan.
- All right, so let's go back
to his page.
"Hey Vance, this is Nev
from the TV show "Catfish,"
"I'm here in Iowa
with your friend Rachael
"Making an episode.
"We would love to give
you guys an opportunity
"To finally meet each other
and talk
"After all these years.
"Please get back to me
when you can. Thanks, Nev.
- What are you thinking?
- I don't...
I don't know.
Like, I'm just, like,
lost for words right now.
Like, is he gonna disappear?
[video chat ringing]
What?
- Is he calling?
- He's calling you
on Facebook.
- Hello?
- Yeah, hey.
What's up, Vance?
How you doing?
- Very for real.
In fact, happy to turn on
my camera if that would help
prove that for you.
- All right.
- She is.
- Hi, Vance.
- We're here to make--
to do whatever we have to
to make it as easy as possible
for you and Rachael to finally
meet each other.
You know, if we can make
the arrangements
for you to get here,
are you down to do that?
- Right, well, I understand.
We can make
all the arrangements.
We'll pay for the ticket.
- [no audible dialogue]
- I don't like this plan.
I mean, look, I want
to make this happen
and I want you guys
to meet each other,
but it just feels weird that
this would be the way to do it.
It just...
It seems a little shady
to be perfectly honest
with you.
- Yep.
- Fine.
- All right.
- All right, so look.
I'll have one of our producers
message you.
You can give us
the information on--
with Caesar's name,
and how much money you'll need,
and, and...
hopefully it'll all work out.
- We'll make it happen.
- Does that sound like
it works?
- Okay, do you
currently have a phone
you can be reached on?
'Cause I know you're
calling us...
- All right.
- That, that, that's weird.
I-I--it's just
super sketchy to me.
- That was him?
- Yeah, that's who I've--
that voice and everything.
But how he was acting,
I've never dealt with that.
- "Wire me money
and I'll get the ticket.
But don't worry,
I'll be there."
- "And don't wire it to me."
- "My friend."
- "Wire it to my friend."
- I don't even know.
- You all right?
- Yeah.
I'm just ready to...
get answers.
- In the meantime, I guess,
you know, just don't
let yourself
get too wound up.
All right.
- See you guys later.
- See ya.
- Bye.
- Oh, man.
- I don't know.
I mean, the guy went
from being, like,
unreliable and a little shady
to, like, potentially,
like, a hardened...
- Criminal.
- Con artist, scammer,
I don't know.
- She's--she was hurt at first.
- Yeah.
- And then she just got angry.
Hopefully he shows up.
You know what they say.
"Hell hath no fury."
[knocking on door]
- I got an update.
We got work...
- Oh.
- To do.
- Great. I didn't get
any sleep.
I just am too, like, anxious.
- Look at this message
that came in from Vance.
- "Thanks, Nev,
"I think the plane
will get me there at 11."
- Has anyone confirmed?
- We sent the money.
He got, he got--The money
we sent to Caesar [bleep]
was received.
- Okay.
- Maybe this Caesar guy
is really who she's talking to?
Aye, dio mio.
[phone ringing]
- Rachael.
- We sent him the money
and Vance texted me and said
he's coming.
All that's left for him to do
is just get on the plane.
All right.
- See you soon.
[knocking]
- Hey!
- Hi.
- Oh, look at you!
- Oof.
- Okay.
- Here we are. It's now...
10:15.
We're in the hour of arrival.
- I'm just super nervous.
The unknown is scary.
So it's like I don't know
how I'm gonna handle it.
Like, he's gonna have
to be honest.
- Yeah.
- And if he's not,
and if he's not able
to answer questions,
then there's no reason for us
to continue any type
of communication.
He just texted me.
He said "I'm here.
Just landed."
- All right.
I mean, look,
why don't you tell him
"Meet us at Turkey Creek Park."
- It's getting real.
- Yeah, right?
- Very.
- It's, like, a 20-minute
drive from here.
So we should...
- Head out.
- Let's do it.
- ♪ Be your bleeding heart ♪
[phone ringing]
- Sam.
- So me, Nev, and Kamie
are on our way to the park
to meet Vance.
- I mean, I don't know if
that's what you would call it.
I'm just trying to keep, like,
a level head.
Like, I don't want
to get myself excited
and then it not be him.
I don't want to freeze up.
- Well, we'll see.
- All right, love you too.
♪ ♪
- Almost there.
- No.
- I guess we'll just
find a spot.
♪ ♪
You got this.
If you can handle three kids
you can handle this.
- Oh, my God.
- ♪ Over me ♪
- [exhales deeply]
- All right, well.
- It's a waiting game now.
- So he should be here.
- This is not okay.
I have never been
this nervous in my life.
- Oh.
- [gasps] Who's that?
- This looks like a...
Uber-esque type car.
- Oh, my God.
No.
- Oh, whoa.
- No, no, no, no, no.
- No.
No, no, no, no, no.
Shut the [bleep] up.
Oh, my God.
- Hey.
- Hey, how's it going?
- Nev.
- Vance.
- Good to meet you.
- I'm Kamie.
- Very nice to meet you, Kamie.
- Nice to meet you too.
- Oh, wow.
- Uh...
We'll just let her
come out when she's ready.
Well, thanks for showing up.
- Uh, not a problem.
Said I'd make it happen.
- You did.
- We're happy you're here.
- Yeah.
I got so many questions, but
I wanted Rachael to hear
everything, so,
Whenever you're ready.
We're--we're waiting.
- Should I walk her over?
- Yeah, maybe.
[soft music]
- I'm, like, so stuck
right now.
I'm like, I can't even think.
- It's time to boss up.
Let's get it together.
You owe it to yourself.
You want to know.
You can do it.
- Oh, my God.
I feel sick to my stomach.
- Well, if you throw up
I'll catch it for ya.
- [breathing hard]
Oh, my God.
- All right.
Why don't you say hello?
- Rachael, Vance.
- Hey, Rachael.
- Oh, my God.
- What's going on?
This is real.
- He's here.
He came a long way.
It's been a long time.
- Wow.
- She's a little shook
right now.
- All right, well.
Why don't we discuss
the elephant in the room?
She sort of told us that
you'll kind of
stop talking,
and she won't hear from you
for a while,
and then you'll pop back up.
Um, is that because
you were in some sort
of detention center
or...?
- No. Not at all.
- We found what looks to be
an arrest record.
- Maybe if you could just
shed a little bit of light
on, you know,
what's been going on with you.
Just to give her some clarity
so she--so she knows.
- The arrest is just
what it is.
It only happened one time
and it was all dismissed, so.
- So you did not serve time?
- No.
- You haven't been
in jail or anything.
- I went to jail.
They held me overnight.
- Oh, well, that's--
- So the next morning
they released me.
- Right. Right.
- There were a few listed
from different years.
- In North Carolina mostly
and then once in Florida.
- That wasn't me.
I've never been arrested--
- So you've never been
arrested in Florida?
- No.
The only thing I ever
got in Florida
was a speeding ticket.
- Okay, so maybe
those other things
were just those speeding
tickets you mentioned.
Good to clear all this up.
So.
So you live in North Carolina.
- Yes.
- And what is it
that you mostly do
in terms of work
or school...?
- I mean, I kinda just
been living life
bouncing around, you know.
My parents
weren't there for me,
I kinda just been struggling.
I don't go to school,
but work, I just kinda do
like, cash jobs, you know?
You know, like...
Whatever comes my way.
Little gigs off of maybe
Craigslist or whatnot.
It hasn't been easy for me.
- At the moment you have
a place with friends, or...
- I'm actually staying
with a friend
as of right now.
- Okay.
And you're not hiding
some secret life, or...
- You don't have a girlfriend
or a wife or...
- Kids...
- No.
- Everything you've told her
this last...whole time
has been true.
- Yeah.
- Either your phones
have been broken,
or you haven't had a place,
or you've been in between work,
or you just haven't had money
to come visit.
That's all legit?
- That's all legit.
- But...
I mean, the funds were
never really an issue.
'Cause I've offered.
- You did on the funds,
but still wouldn't have bought,
like, the ID.
It's not that easy.
- But, I mean, you need
to have an ID.
- I don't have
a lot of things.
- What about the times
I tried to come out there?
- Did you come?
You can't blame me
for something
that you didn't do.
- Not like it's easy for me
just to pack up
and just come.
Like, I have to plan out
child care.
- But, like, you spoke that--
- He's saying that he felt like
you sort of would bring it up
but never really
follow through.
- It never went past,
"Oh, yeah, well,
I can come there."
And then it was never really
talked about again.
Okay, so that day
when I wrote you
and you literally read it
and did not say anything
back to me
Why could you just up and send
my sister Sam a message
like it was nothing?
- You're talking about the time
he texted Sam
but didn't get back
to you right away?
- Right. Which is fine,
like, I wasn't jealous,
it was more of
you weren't talking to me,
you weren't responding to me,
you were leaving
my messages unread
but you were writing her.
- Was that just one day?
- It's been a couple times.
- Time out.
This sort of sounds like
a bunch of stupid,
petty [bleep].
Okay, look.
Let's get back to the
strange, but still, I think,
lovely reality that, like,
you guys have been talking
for a really long time.
Since you were kids.
You've had your life.
He's had his.
They've been very complicated
in their own ways.
But now you're here finally.
Let's not let
this, little sort of details
totally ruin this.
- This is the moment
you both have been waiting for
for over a decade.
- It's not that I'm not happy
to see him.
I don't know what to say.
I don't, I don't know
how I'm feeling right now.
Like, it's just a lot.
- He's here.
- Right.
- And if there's no big, crazy,
messed up secret...
This is the guy you've been
talking to
for a long time
and he came here to see you.
It doesn't have to all be
happy butterflies and rainbows
but can, like, can there be
a little bit of relief?
I feel like
maybe we need to just,
like...
- Hug it out?
- All right. What do you
want me to do?
- Just stand in front of him.
And look at him.
He's here.
He, he's, he wants to
look at you,
you want to look at him.
Just look at each other
and acknowledge that, like,
wow, here we are.
- Come on, Rachael.
- I don't even want
a handshake.
- Never mind.
Give me a hug.
- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
There we go.
- I'm here.
- Oh, I love love so much.
[giggling]
- I'm real.
- Oh, my God.
- You're real.
- Didn't that feel nice?
- This is great.
I would love to just
let you guys talk
without our...
awkward supervision.
I mean, you could even just
sit right here on a bench.
You guys have a lot
to talk about.
- Get to know each other.
In real life.
IRL, as they say online.
- IRL.
- Okay, well, let's sit down.
We're gonna go hang in the car.
- Holler if you need us.
- Yeah, we'll just be
right over there.
[thoughtful music]
- This is crazy.
On the phone it's different.
'Cause, like, I can
just talk to you.
- It's very different.
Very different.
It don't seem real, does it?
- No.
- Whoo.
- I mean...
- Wow.
It was weird.
- Is it usually that awkward?
- No.
Obviously she's very nervous.
- She was going through a lot
of emotions.
- Yeah.
And I think he is too.
I mean, I could see
he was shake--
he was trembling a little bit.
I think he was
definitely nervous.
- Yeah.
- But that's okay, I mean,
they'll...
they'll recover from that,
I think.
- I feel like I just, like,
dropped my daughter off
at her first date
and now I'm just, like...
trying to see what goes down.
- Um, what do you think?
- What do you mean?
- I came all the way out here.
I'm obviously interestedin you.
Are you excited,
are you happy--
- Well, yeah,
I've been excited.
It wasn't even that
I wasn't excited. I just--
- I didn't know, like...
- I keep things bottled up.
And, like, and it's weird--
- Well, un-bottle it.
Pop the top.
- [laughing]
- I get the sense that, like,
he's down.
- Yeah, he seemed open.
- I just think he's
a little too proud
to admit that, like,
he's broke.
- Yeah.
- He's struggling.
- Yeah.
- Sleeping on a friend's couch.
And bus tickets aren't cheap.
- Yeah.
- You know, that's probably
$250 or more, you know.
That's a lot of money for him.
- Yeah.
- What do you want to happen?
What do you think?
- I mean, I definitely
don't expect you to
just be like, "Oh, yeah,
Move in tomorrow."
Like, that's--it's
not realistic
like, for neither you or I.
But I think that we should
I mean, maybe plan...
[sighs]
like, a trip,
maybe me and the kids
and Sam or whatever.
- I mean, I'm open
to doing all that.
I care about you.
I love you.
- Yeah. I love you, too.
- Knock, knock.
- Hey, guys.
- Hello.
- Why don't we go
get a bite to eat?
Let you guys hang out.
- First date vibes.
Perhaps?
- Oh, yeah.
- Great. Let's go.
- ♪ You may not look like me ♪
♪ You may feel differently ♪
- All right.
We survived.
- We definitely did.
- [chuckling]
- For a moment there
it was iffy.
- ♪ Everybody everybody
everybody ♪
♪ Want to have a good life ♪
♪ Too many get a hard knock ♪
- All right, guys.
- We're just gonna
drop you off here.
- Good to meet you.
- Good to meet you.
- Enjoy.
- Have fun, guys.
- Well, thank you guys.
Enjoy.
- He seems great.
- Okay.
- ♪ Give us that real love ♪
- Well, I think our work hereis done.
- I'm very satisfied.
- We got 'em through
the rough patch.
I have a good feeling
about them.
- I do too.
- I'm excited I got
to meet you.
I'm really excited.
- It wasn't that I wasn't
excited to see you
'cause I was.
But I was stuck.
- Well, I think that
we should kinda just take it
step by step.
- I mean, we talked about
building a house
and having a family.
Is that something
you want to do?
- That is something
I want to do.
- Down the road?
- Yeah.
- Really?
- Yeah.
- [laughing]
I do, too.
- I'll get my ducks in a row.
- Yeah?
♪ ♪
- ♪ Give us that real love ♪
[dialing]
- Hey!
- Hey.
What's up, Rachael?
What's up with you and Vance?
- [sighs]
- Uh-oh.
- I mean...
We were talking a little bit.
And he was just acting
super weird.
And I was just like,
I'm not gonna sit here
and I'm not gonna keep
like, trying to beg you
to be in my life.
- I'm so sorry.
It felt like there was
some optimism
in that maybe he was going
to get his act together.
- No.
Right after we saw each other
he had asked me to, like,
send him money, so--
And I, of course,
said, like, no.
- I mean, I was bummed,
but then once you said that,
I mean, like...
- Yeah.
I'm over it.
- Right.
I don't want to have to
take care of another person.
Like, I just had to, like,
snap out of it.
- Good for you, girl.
You seem, like, freer.
- Yeah, now I can, like,
get myself together
and move on
and not have that "what if"
in the back of my head.
- And what about your sister?
How's everything going
with her?
- She's actually right here.
- Hey, guys.
- Hey, girl.
- Hey.
At least you got your sister
through all this.
Just be there for you,
so that's awesome.
- We're family.
Me and my sister have been
through so much.
Come on.
- All right, girls.
Be good.
all: Bye.
- You never know
what you might do.
- Very special cohost. the one
and only Nick Young.
- How's it going, man?
- "I watch the show
"Love & Hip Hop"
"and I've fallen for one
of the guys on there,
Rich Dollaz."
- Seen him on TV
and my heart jumped out
of my chest.
This is the most
convincing catfish
I'll have ever seen.
- Can I wait in the car?
I'm scared.
- He should be here.
- Oh, my God, oh, my God,
oh, my God.
- This is crazy.
1325
00:41:37.