Catfish: The TV Show (2012–…): Season 2, Episode 7 - Mike & Kristen - full transcript
Years ago, Mike met Kristen on Facebook. They quickly forged a deep connection, but Mike's frequent efforts to meet Kristen have been futile. He's convinced she could be the one. Will Mike finally get face-to-face with Kristen?
>> ALL COMES DOWN TO THIS.
>> YEAH, NO KIDDING.
>> [knocks]
HI.
HI, I'M NEV, AND THIS IS MY
FILMMAKER BUDDY MAX.
LAST YEAR, WE TRAVELED ACROSS
THE COUNTRY FIGURING OUT
THE TRUTH BEHIND ONLINE
ROMANCES.
I'M READY TO COME MEET YOU IF
YOU THINK YOU'RE REALLY READY.
>> I'M DEFINITELY READY.
>> ALONG THE WAY, WE OPENED
DOORS TO SOME BIG SURPRISES.
>> WAIT, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS.
>> WE MADE A FEW LOVE
CONNECTIONS...
>> FEELS AMAZING.
>> AND EVEN DID OUR FAIR SHARE
OF MENDING BROKEN HEARTS.
>> I'M SO HAPPY EVERY DAY WHEN I
WAKE UP NOW.
[sniffles]
>> SUDDENLY, THE IDEA OF
CATFISHING--HIDING WHO YOU
REALLY ARE TO HOOK SOMEONE INTO
AN ONLINE RELATIONSHIP...
>> PROBABLY A PAGEANT WINNER,
A MODEL.
>> WAS BEING TALKED ABOUT BY
A LOT OF YOU.
GOT AN EMAIL HERE.
"WHO DID I REALLY FALL IN LOVE
WITH?"
SO MAX AND I ARE HEADED BACK OUT
ON THE ROAD...
MAX, WE'VE GOT WORK TO DO.
TO INVESTIGATE STORIES THAT SEEM
TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE...
>> I AM IN DEREK'S DRIVEWAY.
>> OR TOO WILD TO MAKE UP.
>> HE WAS CARJACKED, AND HE WAS
RAN OVER BY THE CAR.
>> JESUS, MAN.
WILL HOPE BECOME LOVE...
>> OH, MY GOD.
>> OR IS LOVE IN FOR A GIANT
SHOCK?
>> [cries] I DON'T KNOW.
>> YOU CAN BE SURE THAT MAX AND
I WILL FIND OUT ALL
THE ANSWERS, BECAUSE SOMETIMES,
A LITTLE BIT OF FICTION...
>> WOW, CATFISH CURVE BALL.
>> LEADS TO A WHOLE LOT OF
REALITY.
THINGS WILL NEVER BE THE SAME.
>> [laughs]
>> ARE WE READY?
>> LET'S DO IT.
>> CATFISH THE MOVIE WAS MY
STORY.
CATFISH: THE TV SHOW IS YOURS.
>> LET ME JUST GET MY SHOT.
>> YOUR ROOM IS SURPRISINGLY
NEAT.
>> I'M LEARNING FROM YOU.
>> IS EVERYTHING--EVERYTHING
OKAY?
OH, WAIT A SECOND.
A GRAPE?
A GRAPE JUST FELL, SO THINGS ARE
NOT TOO FAR FROM DISORDERLY.
[both laugh]
EMAIL THAT JUST CAME IN.
SUBJECT--"SEPARATED BY LESS
THAN 40 MILES."
WOW. OKAY.
"HELLO, MY NAME IS MICHAEL.
I'M A 25-YEAR-OLD FROM STERLING
HEIGHTS, MICHIGAN."
UH-OH, MICHIGAN.
>> MICHIGAN IMPOSSIBLE.
>> "ABOUT THREE AND 1/2 YEARS
AGO, I STARTED TALKING TO A GIRL
NAMED KRISTEN.
SHE'S THE TYPE OF GIRL THAT YOU
INSTANTLY CONNECT WITH.
KRISTEN IS A 22-YEAR-OLD FROM
ST. CLAIR, MICHIGAN, WHICH IS
ABOUT AN HOUR NORTH OF MY CITY.
KRISTEN IS GOING TO BEAUTY
SCHOOL AND HOPES TO PURSUE
A CAREER IN COSMETOLOGY.
WE STARTED TALKING ON FACEBOOK
AFTER SHE LIKED A COMMENT I
POSTED.
AFTER ONLY A MONTH OF TALKING,
WE'D ALREADY BEGUN SAYING,
'I LOVE YOU.'"
>> L-BOMBS.
>> "AND I CONSIDERED HER MY
GIRLFRIEND."
>> G-BOMB.
>> "WE'VE EVEN TALKED ABOUT THE
NUMBER OF KIDS WE WANT TO HAVE."
>> K-BOMB.
>> "MY ATTEMPTS TO MEET HER HAVE
BEEN FREQUENT, BUT FUTILE.
THE BIGGEST REASON I FEEL SHE
WON'T SEE ME IS BECAUSE OF HER
PHYSICAL HANDICAP.
UP TO THIS POINT, OUR
RELATIONSHIP HAS CONSISTED ONLY
OF TEXT MESSAGES AND PHONE
CALLS.
NO VIDEO CHAT.
I'M NOT MUCH OF A COMPUTER GUY.
I'M AFRAID THAT WITHOUT YOUR
HELP I'LL NEVER GET A CHANCE TO
KNOW IF SHE AND I HAVE A FUTURE
TOGETHER.
I AM HOPEFUL AND WILL BE FOREVER
GRATEFUL IF YOU CAN HELP ME MAKE
THIS HAPPEN."
WHAT'S CRAZY IS THAT THEY LIVE
SO CLOSE AND THAT THIS GUY HAS
CONTINUED TO ENTERTAIN THE FACT
THAT THERE'S A CHANCE THEY'LL
MEET UP WHEN THEY HAVEN'T YET.
>> I KNOW.
>> YEAH, WE JUST GOTTA FIND OUT
MORE FROM THIS GUY.
[Skype chimes]
HELLO.
>> WHAT'S UP, MAN?
HOW YOU GUYS DOING?
>> TELL US EVERYTHING, MAN.
>> KRISTEN, SHE'S JUST
EVERYTHING I FEEL LIKE I WANT.
WE HAVE GREAT CHEMISTRY.
>> * I HAVE BEEN TRYING
* TO FIND HER
* WANNA GIVE WHAT I'VE GOT *
* SHE LIT A FIRE AND NOW
* SHE'S IN MY EVERY THOUGHT *
>> SHE'S FUNNY.
OUR SENSE OF HUMORS, I THINK,
ARE VERY SIMILAR.
>> YOU GOTTA EXPLAIN THIS
HANDICAP THAT SHE HAS, BECAUSE
OTHERWISE, I REALLY CAN'T
UNDERSTAND WHY YOU'D BE PUTTING
UP WITH SOMEBODY WHO LIVES SO
CLOSE NOT SEEING YOU FOR
3-1/2 YEARS.
>> IT WAS PROBABLY AROUND THE
SAME TIME THAT I MET HER--WAS
CLOSE TO THE TIME WHERE SHE WAS
INVOLVED IN A CAR ACCIDENT.
THEY GOT INTO A HEAD-ON
COLLISION WITH A SEMI TRUCK,
ACTUALLY.
THE WINDSHIELD BROKE, GLASS
SHATTERED, AND IT GOT INTO HER
EYE.
THE DOCTORS COULDN'T FIX IT, SO
SHE HAS A FAKE EYE NOW.
SHE MIGHT BE APPREHENSIVE TO
ACTUALLY MEET ME BECAUSE MAYBE
SHE FEELS LIKE I'M GONNA REJECT
HER BECAUSE OF THAT, BUT I TELL
HER TIME AND TIME AGAIN THAT'S
NOT THE CASE.
IT'S BEEN LONG ENOUGH.
THE DAY I MEET HER, I FEEL LIKE
WE'RE GONNA HIT A HOME RUN, MAN
AND I JUST--I WANT THAT TO
HAPPEN PRETTY BAD.
>> ALL RIGHT, WELL, LOOK.
I'M SO CURIOUS ABOUT THIS GIRL.
I'M IN.
I'M--I'M READY TO MAKE THIS
HAPPEN.
>> [claps] GOOD.
I LIKE TO HEAR THAT.
>> GREAT.
LATER, MAN.
>> PEACE.
>> THIS GUY, FOR THE LAST THREE
AND 1/2 YEARS, HE'S BEEN HOPING
THE WHOLE TIME THAT SOMETHING
WILL CHANGE AND HIM AND KRISTEN
WILL END UP TOGETHER.
>> HE'S IN--INVESTED IN THIS.
>> BIG TIME.
>> WELL, LET'S GO.
RIGHT? WE'RE GOING TO MICHIGAN.
>> YEAH, MAN.
>> * A WHITE LIGHT BURNED
* BY THE BURDEN OF PROOF
* AND LAST NIGHT YOU TOLD
* THE TERMINAL TRUTH
* OH I TOLD IT TO YOU
>> COOL.
IT WOULDN'T BE A SEASON OF
CATFISH IF WE DIDN'T END UP IN
MICHIGAN AT LEAST ONCE.
>> * IN THE BLACK LIGHT
* IN THE BLACK LIGHT
>> WEIRDEST THING ABOUT THIS
STORY IS NOT THAT SHE GOT INTO
AN ACCIDENT AND LOST AN EYE, AND
NOT THAT THEY'VE NEVER VIDEO
CHATTED IN THREE AND 1/2 YEARS.
IT'S THAT THEY LIVE LESS THAN AN
HOUR AWAY FROM EACH OTHER.
>> YEAH.
THE OLD KNOCK.
>> YO, MIKE.
>> JUST GO AHEAD?
>> HEY.
>> HEY, WHAT'S GOING ON, MAN?
>> HEY, WHAT'S UP, MAN?
>> HEY, GOOD TO SEE YOU, MAN.
GLAD YOU GUYS MADE IT.
HEY, GOOD TO MEET YOU, MAN.
>> AND THIS IS YOUR HOUSE?
>> THIS IS MY HOUSE, YES.
>> YOU OWN THIS HOUSE?
>> I OWN THIS HOUSE.
>> YOU OWN IT?
>> YES.
>> THIS IS GREAT.
>> THANK YOU.
>> SO THE BEDROOMS ARE OVER
HERE?
>> YEP, THAT'S WHERE THE MAGIC
HAPPENS.
>> DO YOU BELIEVE IN SEX BEFORE
MARRIAGE?
>> YES, I DO PRACTICE SEX BEFORE
MARRIAGE.
>> [laughs]
IT'S PRACTICE THOUGH?
>> YES.
>> JUST PRACTICE.
>> PRACTICE MAKES PERFECT.
>> LET'S HAVE A SEAT.
ALL RIGHT.
WHAT DO YOU THINK IS, UH,
DIFFERENT ABOUT KRISTEN THAN
OTHER GIRLS THAT YOU'VE BEEN
DATING?
>> SHE'S SHOWING YOU THE LOVE
AND THE COMPASSION AND THE
RESPECT THAT YOU'RE SHOWING HER.
IT MAKES YOU FEEL GOOD.
>> HAVE YOU GIVEN YOUR WORD IN
ANY WAY TO KRISTEN?
>> WE WERE EXCLUSIVE AT SOME
POINTS.
SHORT PERIODS OF TIME AND THEN,
FOR WHATEVER REASON, IT WOULD
STOP.
AND THEN AT THAT POINT IF I WAS
DATING SOMEBODY, KRISTEN ALWAYS
TOLD ME THAT SHE WANTS ME TO
STOP TALKING TO THIS GIRL
BECAUSE HER AND I ARE GONNA BE
TOGETHER.
AND THEN EVENTUALLY I WOULD
ALWAYS BREAK DOWN AND STOP
TALKING TO GIRLS I WAS TALKING
TO IN HOPES THAT HER AND I WOULD
FINALLY GET THE CHANCE TO MEET
EACH OTHER.
I DIDN'T WANNA JUST THROW
EVERYTHING AWAY THAT I FELT THAT
WE HAD ALREADY BUILT UP.
>> WOULD YOU SAY THAT--THAT YOU
LOVE HER?
>> YEAH.
YEAH, I'LL SAY THAT.
I HAVE SAID IT TO HER ON MANY
OCCASIONS.
THE WHOLE MYSTERY OF THE
SITUATION IS REALLY DRAWING ME
INTO IT.
SHE'S ELUDED ME THUS FAR.
>> YOU WANNA TRUST HER?
>> YES, I DEF--ABSOLUTELY DO.
I BELIEVE WHAT SHE'S TELLING ME,
AND I JUST REALLY, REALLY HOPE
THAT IT'S ALL TRUE.
>> SO MOST OF YOUR
COMMUNICATION'S WITH YOUR PHONE.
>> MOSTLY THE PHONE, YEAH.
>> ALL RIGHT, SO WHAT DO YOU
HAVE ON THERE?
>> I'VE GOT A FEW PICTURES OF
HER.
>> SO THESE ARE PICTURES SHE
TEXTED YOU?
>> YES.
>> THIS ONE'S FROM APRIL?
>> MM-HMM.
>> THIS IS INTERESTING.
SO I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT
GLASS EYES, BUT OBVIOUSLY I KNOW
THAT IF YOU HAVE TWO FUNCTIONING
EYES, YOUR PUPILS OPEN AND CLOSE
TOGETHER.
AND IN THIS PICTURE, BOTH OF HER
EYES, THE PUPIL'S THE EXACT
SAME SIZE.
IT'S POSSIBLE THAT--AND I'M SURE
YOU'VE CONSIDERED THIS--THAT
MAYBE SHE DOES IN FACT HAVE TWO
WORKING EYEBALLS.
>> SHE MADE IT UP.
I DON'T KNOW WHY WOULD YOU MAKE
SOMETHING LIKE THAT UP.
>> ARE YOU SEXUALLY ATTRACTED TO
HER?
>> YES, I AM SEXUALLY ATTRACTED
TO HER.
SHE'S GOT SOME NICE CURVES TO
HER FROM OTHER PICTURES I'VE
SEEN THAT I WILL NOT DISCLOSE
TO YOU GUYS, BUT--
>> REALLY?
>> WHAT?
>> EVERYTHING IS--IT'S GOOD.
>> WHAT PICTURES ARE THOSE?
>> THEY'RE JUST PROVOCATIVE
PHOTOS TO GET THE IMAGINATION
GOING.
>> SUGGESTED NUDITY.
>> WOW.
>> AND HAVE YOU, UH,
RECIPROCATED?
>> YEAH, I HAVE.
YEAH.
>> IN A SIMILAR FASHION?
>> A SIMILAR FASHION.
FULL FRONTAL NUDITY WITH MY FACE
INCLUDED ALSO.
YEAH.
>> UH, I'M--I'M A LITTLE--
>> [laughs]
>> I'M--I MEAN, NOT A LOT OF
PEOPLE--
>> THAT'S--
>> WELL, I GUESS PEOPLE DO THAT,
BUT--
>> THAT MEANS THAT YOU HAVE
TR--THAT YOU TRUST HER.
>> YEAH.
WE GOT WORK TO DO.
>> YEAH.
>> I HOPE THAT, UH, WE GET TO
THE BOTTOM OF THIS.
>> ALL RIGHT, MAN, LATER.
>> LATER, MIKE.
>> SEE YA.
>> HE'S PUT SO MUCH MORE INTO
THIS THAN HE EVEN REALLY WANTS
TO ADMIT.
WHAT HE'S GOT ON THE LINE HERE
ARE TWO THINGS.
ONE IS THIS LONG RELATIONSHIP
WITH THIS GIRL THAT HE'S PRETTY
CRAZY ABOUT.
AND TWO IS JUST HIS PRIDE.
THIS GUY REALLY WOULD BE CRUSHED
TO FIND THAT HE'D BEEN TAKEN
ADVANTAGE OF.
>> ALL RIGHT.
SO, HERE'S WHAT'S UP.
WE'VE GOT MIKE'S RELATIONSHIP
WITH KRISTEN.
THEY'VE BEEN TALKING FOR OVER
THREE YEARS.
WHAT IS KIND OF HARD TO BELIEVE
IS THAT THEY LIVE UNDER AN HOUR
AWAY, BUT SHE HASN'T BEEN ABLE
TO FIND AN AFTERNOON.
I MEAN, IT'S NOT LIKE SHE'S
GOTTA GIVE UP A WEEKEND.
LIKE, THEY COULD MEET FOR
DINNER.
>> THIS ACCIDENT THING, HUGE RED
FLAG.
>> WHY WOULD SHE PICK AN EXCUSE
THAT WOULD BE SO HARD TO FAKE
AND SEND PHOTOS?
>> WE NEED TO DO A FEW THINGS.
PROVE OR DISPROVE THAT SHE IS
THE GIRL IN THE PICTURES.
WE NEED TO SEE IF SHE IS LYING
TO HIM ABOUT WHO SHE IS.
NUMBER TWO IS TO FIND OUT WHO
SHE REALLY IS.
>> RIGHT.
>> BUT THE LEAST WE COULD DO
IS FIND OUT IF WHAT SHE'S TOLD
HIM IS TRUE.
>> HERE'S AN EMAIL FROM MIKE
WITH ALL OF THE NECESSARY INFO.
KRISTEN NICOLE PARKERS.
22-YEAR-OLD.
BIRTHDAY: MARCH.
LIVES IN ST. CLAIR, MICHIGAN
WITH HORSES.
>> SHE GOES TO BEAUTY SCHOOL IN
PORT HURON.
WE SHOULD CALL THE BEAUTY SCHOOL
AND SEE IF KRISTEN ACTUALLY DOES
ATTEND.
>> I WILL CALL KRISTEN'S
SUPPOSED BEAUTY SCHOOL.
HI, BRIANNA, MY NAME IS DEV AND
I MAKE A SHOW ONMTV CALLED
CATFISH.
>> YEAH, YEAH, I THINK I'VE
HEARD OF IT.
>> BASICALLY WHAT I'M TRYING TO
FIND OUT IS IF THERE IS
A STUDENT THERE BY THE NAME
KRISTEN PARKERS.
OH.
OKAY.
>> AND--AND SHE DOESN'T SEEM TO
HAVE A GLASS EYE?
>> YOU'VE MADE MY JOB MUCH
HARDER.
>> [laughs]
>> INTERESTING.
>> SO THERE'S A KRISTEN THAT
GOES THERE.
KRISTEN WITH A "K."
>> RIGHT.
>> NO GLASS EYE.
>> IF IT'S A GOOD GLASS EYE YOU
COULD NOT KNOW.
>> YES YOU KNOW.
>> NO, THAT'S NOT TRUE.
IT'S NOT A GUARANTEE THAT SHE
WOULD KNOW.
>> I WANNA DO A SPOKEO SEARCH
FOR--
>> I KNOW, WE CAN DO THAT.
>> FOR THE PHONE NUMBER THOUGH.
>> WELL, YEAH, 'CAUSE THAT COULD
GIVE US A LAST NAME.
AND THEN WE COULD ACTUALLY CALL
BACK AND ASK HER IF IT IS THAT
LAST NAME, RIGHT?
>> RIGHT.
>> OKAY, LET'S SEE IF WE GET
A HIT.
AND WHAT HAVE WE GOT?
HILLOCK.
>> THAT COULD BE HER FATHER.
>> SO MAYBE HER NAME IS KRISTEN
HILLOCK.
>> TRY THE WHITE PAGES.
ST. CLAIR.
THERE IS A HILLOCK IN ST. CLAIR.
THIS IS THE ADDRESS THAT
CAME UP AND IT SHOWS A FARM OF
SORTS IN A VERY RURAL
NEIGHBORHOOD AND WHAT LOOKS LIKE
A HORSE CORRAL--
>> A BARN.
>> A BARN WITH A HORSE PEN.
>> YEAH.
>> AND SEEMINGLY LARGE ANIMAL.
>> [laughs]
>> I MEAN, YOU KNOW.
>> IT LOOKS LIKE A HORSE.
>> I THINK IT'S WORTH RUNNING
THE ADDRESS.
>> OKAY.
KRISTYN HILLOCK, BOOM.
>> BUT SHE'S FEMALE, 57.
>> 57.
>> SO SHE COULD BE 57?
>> SO THE PICTURE SHE'S SENDING
COULD BE HER DAUGHTER.
>> SPELLED DIFFERENTLY THAN--
>> SPELLED "Y-N," KRISTYN WITH
A "Y."
SO NOW I'M JUST SEARCHING
KRISTYN WITH THE--WITH THE NEW
SPELLING, "HILLOCK," ON
FACEBOOK.
>> AND WHAT DID YOU GET?
>> NOTHING.
HERE'S A MYLIFE PAGE.
>> ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT.
>> IT SAYS SHE'S 22 HERE.
KRISTYN HILLOCK, 22, ST. CLAIR,
MICHIGAN.
THAT'S HER.
WE FOUND HER.
WHEN'S HER BIRTHDAY?
MARCH 27!
>> ST. CLAIR.
>> ST. CLAIR.
>> 22.
>> 22.
BORN IN MARCH.
CALL THE BEAUTY SCHOOL AND ASK
IF IT'S KRISTYN HILLOCK.
>> HEY, BRIANNA, IT'S NEV AGAIN.
HEY.
SO, DO YOU HAVE A STUDENT
CURRENTLY ENROLLED BY THE NAME
KRISTYN HILLOCK?
WOW.
OKAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
OKAY, BYE.
WE'RE OUT--WE'RE OUT.
WE'RE DONE.
>> NO, WE'RE NOT.
>> RECORD INVESTIGATION TIME.
>> NO--WELL, SO WHAT DO WE KNOW?
>> WE'RE DONE.
WE'RE DONE.
>> THAT IT IS HER?
>> IT'S KRISTYN HILLOCK.
>> BUT WE STILL DON'T KNOW IF
IT'S REALLY HER IN THE PICTURES.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW IF SHE GOT
INTO AN ACCIDENT.
>> OKAY, SO JUST SEARCHING
KRISTYN HILLOCK.
LET'S LOOK AT THIS PIPL THING.
>> KRISTYN NICOLE HILLOCK.
>> OOH.
>> SHE'S GOT SOME TATS.
>> WITH SCISSORS BECAUSE SHE'S
INTO BEAUTY SCHOOL.
HERE'S HER FACEBOOK PAGE.
>> ALL RIGHT.
>> OH, COME ON.
BE THE FACEBOOK PAGE.
YES!
>> A HORSE!
>> SHE GOES BY KRISTYN NICOLE
WITH THEN AN "H" IN PARENTHESES.
>> "H" IN PARENTHESES.
>> BECAUSE HER LAST NAME IS
HILLOCK.
THERE'S A PICTURE OF A HORSE.
LOOKS LIKE THE SAME HORSE IN THE
PHOTO.
>> YOU CAN'T TELL.
>> [laughs] I'M JUST KIDDING.
>> SHE'S GOT PHOTOS.
>> YEAH, BUT EVERYTHING IS
PRIVATE.
>> [bleep].
>> SO, IT'S ALMOST CERTAIN THAT
THE GIRL THAT MIKE'S TALKING
TO'S NAME IS KRISTYN NICOLE
HILLOCK AND THAT MOST, IF NOT
ALL OF THE DETAILS THAT SHE'S
GIVEN HIM ABOUT HER LIFE ARE
TOTALLY ACCURATE.
>> HE'LL BE RELIEVED.
BUT WE DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE
GLASS EYE.
>> YES.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW WHAT SHE
LOOKS LIKE.
>> TOTALLY.
IT'S A LITTLE CONCERNING THAT
SHE LIED ABOUT HER LAST NAME.
>> BUT EVERYTHING ELSE SEEMS TO
BE TRUE.
>> THE ONLY THING WE HAVEN'T
BEEN ABLE TO FIND IS ANY KIND OF
CONCLUSIVE PHOTOGRAPHIC
EVIDENCE.
WHAT IS SHE HIDING?
WHO KNOWS.
>> WE DO HAVE SOME REALLY
INTERESTING INFORMATION.
IT'S A LITTLE COMPLICATED.
IT'S TOO MUCH TO GET INTO OVER
THE PHONE.
WE WANTED TO MEET UP WITH YOU.
ALL RIGHT, THAT SOUNDS GREAT.
WE'RE LOOKING FOR THE LPGA TOUR.
>> YOU'RE GOING TO
THE WRONG SPOT.
[all laugh]
HOW YOU GUYS DOING, MAN?
>> GOOD, MAN.
LOOK AT YOU.
YOU'RE ALL COLOR COORDINATED
TODAY.
>> HEY, YOU KNOW, YOU GOTTA--
YOU GOTTA LOOK THE PART.
>> THE BOY IN BLUE.
>> SO HOW MUCH DOES EVERYONE
KNOW?
>> I DIDN'T REALLY TELL 'EM
ABOUT A LOT OF THE DETAILS ABOUT
IT.
IT'S NOBODY'S BUSINESS BUT MY
OWN, I FEE LIKE.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN?
AND IF I WANNA MAKE IT YOUR
BUSINESS, I WILL MAKE IT YOUR
BUSINESS.
AND THAT'S WHEN YOU KNOW THAT I
WANT YOU TO KNOW ABOUT IT.
>> YOU JUST MADE IT MY BUSINESS.
>> I DID MAKE IT YOUR BUSINESS.
SO YOU'RE COOL.
YOU'RE ALL RIGHT WITH
THE QUESTIONS.
YOU'RE GOOD, YOU'RE GOOD.
>> OH, THAT'S GOT A SHOT.
HAS MIKE EVER SAID THAT HE MET
HER?
>> HE TOLD ME LAST SUMMER HE WAS
LEAVING MY HOUSE TO GO MEET HER.
HE SAID IT A COUPLE OF TIMES SO
I BELIEVED HIM.
>> REALLY?
>> I WAS LIKE, "OKAY, MAYBE SHE
IS REAL."
>> AND?
>> AND I JUST WAS RECENTLY TOLD
THAT HE HAS NEVER.
HE TOLD ME THAT HE LIED TO ME
ABOUT IT.
>> DID THAT BOTHER YOU THAT--TO
FIND OUT THAT HE--
>> I WAS LIKE--I KINDA WAS LIKE,
WHY ARE YOU LYING TO ME?
>> RIGHT.
>> WHY'D YOU LIE?
>> VERY NICE.
WOULD YOU SAY HE'S, LIKE,
A PLAYER OR, LIKE, A...
>> NOT REALLY.
>> LIKE A ONE--KIND OF LIKE A
ROMANTIC?
LIKE A--
>> YEAH, I'D SAY HE'S
PROBABLY--PROBABLY A ROMANTIC.
BUT HE'S--HE'S A GOOD GUY.
HE'S A GOOD GUY.
HE'S GOT ALL THESE FEELINGS FOR
THIS GIRL HE NEVER EVEN MET YET.
YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING?
>> ARE YOU KIND OF, LIKE,
EMBARRASSED ABOUT IT?
>> YEAH, DEFINITELY.
>> WHY?
>> 'CAUSE IF PEOPLE CAN'T SEE
THE PERSON WHO I'M SAYING I'M
HAVING A RELATIONSHIP WITH, TO
THEM IT'S NOT REAL.
I COULD JUST BE MAKING IT UP.
I REALLY DON'T WANT THEM TO BE
LIKE, "OH, BRO.
YOU'RE [bleep] STUPID, YOU KNOW?
YOU'RE--YOU'RE DUMB.
WHAT ARE YOU DOING, YOU KNOW?
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING TO SOMEBODY
YOU NEVER MET BEFORE?
>> ALL RIGHT, WE'RE GONNA TAKE
THIS GUY, TALK TO HIM A LITTLE
BIT.
>> DON'T BE TOO ROUGH ON HIM.
>> I'M VERY FRAGILE.
I HAVE A HARD EXTERIOR, BUT ON
THE INSIDE--
>> VERY SOFT.
[all laugh]
>> ALL RIGHT, HERE'S WHAT'S UP.
SO WE LOOKED AT THE INFO THAT
YOU GAVE US.
WE THOUGHT WHY NOT CALL THE
BEAUTY SCHOOL THAT SHE GOES TO
AND ASK?
"YOU GUYS HAVE A KRISTEN PARKERS
REGISTERED?"
WE SPOKE TO A GIRL WHO WORKS
THE SORT OF FRONT DESK.
WE ASKED HER IF THERE WAS
A KRISTEN PARKERS.
SHE SAID NO.
>> WELL, THAT'S--THAT'S NICE.
>> BUT--BUT THERE IS A KRISTYN.
OKAY, SO, THE ONLY OTHER REAL
SORT OF HARD INFO THAT WE HAD
FOR HER WAS HER PHONE NUMBER.
SO WE RAN THAT AND IT CAME UP,
FIRST OF ALL, REGISTERED TO THE
NAME HILLOCK.
>> YEAH.
>> DOES THAT NAME MEAN ANYTHING
TO YOU?
>> NO. NOT AT ALL.
>> SO WE TOOK THE NAME HILLOCK
AND WE DID A SEARCH FOR IT IN
THE WHITE PAGES.
>> YEAH.
>> AND IT CAME UP WITH AN
ADDRESS.
AND AMAZINGLY, IT IS EXACTLY AS
SHE DESCRIBED.
RURAL AREA.
WE'VE GOT A BARN.
>> YEAH, THAT APPEARS TO BE A
BARN IN, LIKE, SOME PASTURE OR
WHATEVER.
>> LIKE, A HORSE PADDOCK.
WE SEARCHED THE ADDRESS.
BROUGHT US TO THIS.
NOW HERE WE GOT KRISTYN NICOLE
AND THEN IN PARENTHESES "H,"
WHICH WE PRESUME IS...
>> HILLOCK.
>> HILLOCK.
AND A HORSE.
THAT'S ALL WE CAN SEE 'CAUSE
IT'S PRIVATE.
WE ENDED UP CALLING THE BEAUTY
SCHOOL BACK.
>> YEAH.
>> AND NOW WE HAD SORT OF A LAST
NAME.
>> TRUE. YEAH. HILLOCK.
>> AND SO WE SAID TO THE
GIRL--WE SAID, "LOOK--"
>> "HOW ABOUT HILLOCK?"
HOW'S THAT, SON?
>> CAN YOU CONFIRM IF THERE'S A
GIRL NAMED HILLOCK?
>> AND THEY PROBABLY SAID NO.
THEY PROBABLY TOLD YOU NO,
RIGHT?
>> NO, THE ANSWER WAS YES.
SHE JUST HAS A DIFFERENT LAST
NAME.
>> WE DON'T KNOW WHAT SHE REALLY
LOOKS LIKE, IF SHE'S THE GIRL
FROM THE PICTURES.
>> YEAH.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW IF SHE
REALLY HAD AN ACCIDENT OR NOT.
MAYBE SHE DID.
>> YEP. MAYBE SHE DIDN'T.
>> MAYBE SHE DIDN'T.
>> YEP.
>> TO BE PERFECTLY HONEST, MOST
OF WHAT WE FOUND CONFIRMS
EVERYTHING SHE TOLD YOU.
>> THIS IS DIFFERENT ABOUT HER.
THE WHOLE SITUATION BEHIND IT.
DON'T GET ME WRONG.
I'VE--I'VE--I'VE TURNED DOWN
OTHER GIRLS.
I'VE SAID "NO, I CAN'T."
I'VE TOLD THEM I HAVE A
GIRLFRIEND.
I'M SORRY.
CAN'T DO IT.
YOU COME UP TO ME AT THE BAR,
"HEY, WHAT'S UP?"
"SORRY, I-I'M NOT INTO YOU.
GO AWAY."
>> BUT DESPITE--
>> THAT HAPPENS.
>> DESPITE WHO SHE IS, YOUR
FEELINGS ABOUT HER, THAT'S REAL.
>> I'M SORT OF SURPRISED THAT
YOU'RE HAVING SUCH A STRONG
REACTION JUST TO THE FACT THAT
HER NAME ISN'T HER NAME.
SHE WAS, FOR THE MOST PART,
TELLING THE TRUTH.
>> I KINDA ALREADY FEEL LIKE I
HAVE MY CLOSURE TO TELL YOU
THE TRUTH RIGHT NOW.
AS WE SPEAK RIGHT NOW.
I KINDA FEEL LIKE I HAVE IT
ALREADY.
>> WH--
>> IN ENOUGH OF A WAY FOR ME TO
MOVE ON WITH MY LIFE.
I'M JUST GONNA WALK AWAY.
STRAIGHT UP, THAT'S HOW IT'S
GONNA BE.
I'M GONNA WALK AWAY.
>> IT'S NOT BREAKING NEWS TO YOU
THAT THERE WAS A CHANCE THIS
GIRL COULD HAVE BEEN LYING TO
YOU.
>> WELL, IT KIND OF IS, MAN,
'CAUSE I-I TRUSTED HER.
LIKE, COMPLETELY.
FULL-FLEDGED, I BELIEVED WHAT
SHE WAS TELLING ME.
ALL OF IT.
SO YEAH.
AND TO FIND OUT THAT SHE WAS
LYING EVEN ABOUT CERTAIN THINGS
IS--IT'S NOT--NOT COOL, YOU
KNOW?
>> YOU'RE IN A SITUATION RIGHT
NOW WHERE YOU'VE SHARED
FEELINGS, YOU'VE INVESTED TIME.
I DO THINK IT'S WORTH SORT OF
CONSIDERING IN THE BIG PICTURE
OF THINGS.
>> I'D LOVE TO SIT DOWN AND SEE
HER AND TALK TO HER AND ASK HER
WHY.
I'M NOT GONNA QUIT UNTIL I GET
THAT.
>> I KNOW THIS WAS INTENSE AND
NOT EXACTLY WHAT YOU WERE
HOPING FOR.
HANG IN THERE.
WE ARE GONNA SEE THIS THING
THROUGH.
>> YOU GUYS, TAKE CARE.
SAFE--SAFE TRAVELS.
ALL THAT STUFF.
>> HE HAS KINDA BEEN IN DENIAL.
AND I THINK THAT, LIKE, THIS WAS
THE FIRST MOMENT WHERE HE HAD TO
FACE THE FACTS.
>> THE PERSON HE SEEMS TO BE THE
CLOSEST WITH IS THIS GIRL.
>> RIGHT.
>> WHO HE JUST FOUND OUT HASN'T
BEEN TELLING HIM THE WHOLE
TRUTH.
LIKE, NO WONDER HE'S SO PISSED.
>> HAVE YOU HEARD ANYTHING NEW
TODAY?
>> NO.
>> THERE IS A MIKE FACTOR HERE.
WE SHOULD TALK ABOUT THAT.
HE'S INTENSE.
>> WHICH IS WHY I THINK IT'S
PROBABLY BEST TO GET HIM AS
PREPARED AS WE CAN SO THAT
THERE'S NO SURPRISES.
>> SO WHAT'S THE PLAN?
I MEAN, WHAT ARE WE GONNA DO?
>> THIS IS THE FIRST TIME WE'VE
EVER HAD A SPECIFIC ADDRESS AND
EXACT NAME.
>> RIGHT.
>> BUT WE STILL NEED TO FIND OUT
WHAT SHE LOOKS LIKE.
I DON'T IMAGINE THERE'S TOO MANY
HIGH SCHOOLS AND THERE'S
PROBABLY A YEARBOOK SOMEWHERE.
>> SO A YEARBOOK?
>> I'M JUST TRYING TO--
>> THAT'S--THAT'S YOUR BIG IDEA?
>> I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE WOULD
HAVE, LIKE, A PUBLISHED PHOTO OF
SOMEONE'S FACE.
ALL RIGHT, HERE WE GO.
ST. CLAIR HIGH SCHOOL.
OKAY.
>> I DON'T THINK THEY DIGITIZE
THE YEARBOOK.
>> WAIT A SECOND.
LOOK AT THIS.
HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF MICHIGAN.
YEAH, LOOK.
ST. CLAIR HIGH SCHOOL YEARBOOKS.
THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE WE CAN
OUR HANDS ON A YEARBOOK THAT'LL
HAVE HER IN IT.
AND WE'LL KNOW WHO SHE IS AND
WE CAN CALL HER.
AND JUST SAY, LIKE, "LOOK, JIG
IS UP."
>> SO LET'S PICK UP MIKE.
>> RIGHT.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S DO IT.
>> HER STORY ABOUT WHERE SHE
LIVES AND WHERE SHE GREW UP
SEEMS TO BE TRUE.
WE'RE NOT SURE IF SHE'S THE GIRL
IN THE PICTURES THAT SHE SENT
YOU.
>> YEP.
>> AND THAT'S KIND OF A BIG
PIECE OF THE PUZZLE.
>> THERE'S THE ST. CLAIR
HISTORICAL MUSEUM.
>> IT'S OPEN.
THE FLAG IS OUT.
THIS IS HOW REAL DETECTIVES
USED TO DO IT BEFORE THE
INTERNET.
THEY HAD TO--HAD TO GO PLACES.
AFTERNOON.
WE'RE TRYING TO LOCATE SOME
YEARBOOKS...
>> OKAY.
>> FROM ST. CLAIR HIGH
SCHOOL.
>> ON THE SECOND SHELF THERE
OVER TO THE RIGHT.
>> OH, LOOK AT THAT.
HERE WE GO.
ALL RIGHT, 2007 ST. CLAIR HIGH
SCHOOL YEARBOOK.
>> SO THIS IS KINDA THE MOMENT
OF TRUTH.
HILLOCK. BOOM.
>> IS THAT HER?
>> CAN YOU GET OUT THE PICTURE
OF HER ON YOUR PHONE?
>> YEAH.
>> IT DOESN'T REALLY LOOK LIKE
THE SAME PERSON.
>> I-IT LOOKS LIKE A COMPLETELY
DIFFERENT PERSON TO ME.
IN MY OPINION.
>> WHAT DO YOU THINK, MIKE?
>> I DON'T KNOW.
EVERYTHING YOU GUYS COME UP WITH
SO FAR IS--KNOCKING ME DOWN
FARTHER AND FARTHER.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN?
>> WELL, WE ARE GETTING CLOSER
AND CLOSER.
WE KNOW EVERYTHING WE'RE GONNA
KNOW ABOUT THIS GIRL.
AND GUESS WE GOTTA CALL HER.
[phone rings]
>> YEAH, HI.
KRISTYN?
HEY, UH, MY NAME IS NEV AND I
HAVE--HAVE A SHOW ON MTV CALLED
CATFISH YOU MAY HAVE HEARD OF.
OKAY, COOL.
UM, WELL, I'M HERE WITH YOUR
FRIEND, MIKE.
>> HEY, KRISTYN, THIS IS MIKE.
>> OKAY, SO YEAH, LET ME EXPLAIN
WHAT'S GOING ON.
SO BASICALLY MIKE GOT IN TOUCH
WITH ME.
WE'RE ACTUALLY NOW IN ST. CLAIR,
NOT TOO FAR FROM WHERE YOU LIVE
AND WE WERE HOPING THAT WE COULD
HELP YOU GUYS FINALLY MEET FOR
THE FIRST TIME AND HAVE A CHANCE
TO HANG OUT.
YEAH.
I MEAN, HERE.
I'LL LET YOU GUYS TALK FOR
A SECOND.
>> YEAH, I DO STILL WANNA MEET
YOU.
I'D REALLY LIKE TO SEE YOU AND
JUST CHAT FOR A LITTLE BIT.
GOT A--GOT SOME QUESTIONS I'D
LIKE TO ASK YOU AND I'M LOOKING
FORWARD FOR YOU TO BE UP FRONT
AND HONEST WITH ME.
YEAH, YOU BEEN SAYING THAT TO
ME--
IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME COMING,
KRISTYN.
I THINK YOU OWE IT TO ME.
AT LEAST A LITTLE TINY BIT.
AND NOT EVEN JUST TO ME.
YOU OWE IT TO YOURSELF TOO.
ALL RIGHT, WELL, THAT'S
UNDERSTANDABLE.
I'M SCARED TOO.
WE CAN BE SCARED TOGETHER.
WELL, CAN WE TALK ABOUT IT IN
PERSON?
CAN WE MEET UP AND TALK ABOUT
IT?
ME TOO.
ME TOO.
I GUESS THEN, SEE YOU SOON.
>> OKAY.
>> GOOD JOB.
I THINK YOU HANDLED THAT
INCREDIBLY WELL.
>> THANK YOU.
>> YOU GOOD?
>> I THINK SO.
>> ALL COMES DOWN TO THIS.
>> YEAH, NO KIDDING.
>> * I SPENT MY TIME WATCHING
* THE SPACES THAT
* HAD GROWN BETWEEN US
* AND I CUT MY MIND
* ON SECOND BEST
* OR THE SCARS THAT COME
* WITH THE GREENNESS
* AND I GIVE MY EYES
* TO THE BOREDOM
* STILL THE SEABED
* WOULDN'T LET ME IN *
* AND I TRIED MY BEST
* TO EMBRACE THE DARKNESS
* IN WHICH I SWIM
>> THAT'S THE ONE.
LET'S GO.
>> JUST HANG HERE FOR A MINUTE.
>> RIGHT HERE?
>> YEAH, YES.
[knocks]
HI.
>> HI.
>> KRISTYN?
>> I'M KRISTYN, YEP.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU. NEV.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU TOO.
>> UH, COME--COME ON DOWNSTAIRS.
>> I'M SORRY.
>> THIS IS MIKE.
>> I'M REALLY SORRY.
I DON'T KNOW.
>> I DON'T KNOW EITHER.
>> I KNOW YOU'RE UPSET.
LIKE, I LIED.
>> YEAH, YOU DID.
>> BUT THERE'S A LOT I DIDN'T
LIE ABOUT.
>> OKAY, WELL, YOU LIED ABOUT
SOME PRETTY IMPORTANT THINGS.
>> ABOUT WHAT I LOOK LIKE AND MY
NAME.
>> YEAH.
THOSE ARE BOTH VERY IMPORTANT
THINGS.
>> YES, I UNDERSTAND,
I UNDERSTAND.
>> THAT WAS COMPLETELY BASED ON
A LIE, WHICH WAS WHY I WAS IN
THIS IN THE FIRST PLACE.
I ENDED RELATIONSHIPS IN THE
HOPES I WAS GONNA MEET YOU
AND YOU WERE GONNA BE WHO YOU
SAID YOU WERE.
I ENDED REAL RELATIONSHIPS, REAL
CONNECTIONS WITH REAL PEOPLE
OVER YOU.
THE THOUGHT THAT YOU WERE WHO
YOU WERE.
I FEEL STUPID JUST FOR BEING
STANDING HERE RIGHT NOW TO TELL
YOU THE TRUTH.
>> I WASN'T TRYING TO PLAY YOU.
THAT WASN'T MY INTENTION.
>> WHAT--WHAT WAS YOUR
INTENTION?
>> TO GET THROUGH EVERYTHING
I'VE BEEN THROUGH, BASICALLY.
>> SO YOU WERE JUST USING ME...
>> I WASN'T USING YOU. NO.
>> TO MAKE YOU FEEL BETTER ABOUT
YOURSELF?
>> IT WASN'T EVEN THAT.
I'VE BEEN THROUGH A LOT.
AND YOU'VE HELPED ME THROUGH
A LOT.
I DON'T WANNA CRY.
>> IF IT'S ALL RIGHT, I HAVE
A COUPLE SORT OF QUESTIONS.
>> GO AHEAD, YEAH.
YEAH, SURE.
>> I MEAN, UM...
>> THAT'S FINE WITH ME.
>> ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE
WERE VERY CURIOUS ABOUT WAS YOUR
ACCIDENT WHICH YOU ORIGINALLY
SAID, YOU KNOW, WAS A BIG PART
OF YOUR LIFE AND...
>> MM-HMM.
>> IS THAT SOMETHING THAT
HAPPENED OR?
>> THAT IS ALL TRUE.
I HAVE A FAKE LEFT EYE.
UM, AND HE TALKED ME THROUGH,
LIKE THE WHOLE THING.
>> AND WHEN DID YOU START
THE FAKE PROFILE?
>> LIKE, RIGHT AFTER.
SO RIGHT AFTER JULY 31, 2009.
I WAS AT A REALLY LOW POINT.
YOU KNOW, I WAS REALLY AT A LOW
POINT, AND I NEEDED A MASK.
AND THAT WAS MY MASK.
>> I GUESS I'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT
YOUR FEELINGS TOWARDS MIKE ARE.
>> I MEAN, ALL MY FEELINGS WERE
REAL.
HE THINKS IT ALL WAS A LIE AND
IT WASN'T ALL A LIE.
LIKE, YEAH, WHAT I LOOK LIKE WAS
A LIE AND THAT IS COMPLETELY
WRONG.
AND MY NAME WAS A LIE AND THAT
WAS COMPLETELY WRONG.
BUT THOSE, LIKE, WERE THE ONLY
THING I LIED ABOUT.
LIKE, EVERYTHING ELSE,
EVERYTHING I'VE BEEN THROUGH,
EVERYTHING WAS TRUE.
THE FEELINGS WERE TRUE.
AND THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU
DID.
I MEAN...
I WAS THAT GIRL SITTING THERE,
LIKE, ABOUT TO TAKE HER LIFE.
AND YOU WERE THE ONLY ONE THAT
STOPPED THAT.
THE ONLY ONE.
I WOULD CALL YOU AND I WAS
BAWLING MY EYES OUT AND YOU
TOLD ME I'D BE OKAY.
AND WE TALKED ABOUT MY EYE
A LOT.
>> YEAH.
>> AND YOU SAID IF SOMEBODY
JUDGED ME ON IT, IT WASN'T
RIGHT.
THE NIGHTS I COULDN'T SLEEP
BECAUSE I HAD NIGHTMARES OF ME
DYING IN CAR ACCIDENTS, YOU WERE
THE ONLY ONE THERE.
FRIENDS THAT I THOUGHT I HAD
WEREN'T.
>> I UNDERSTAND.
>> I NEVER USED TO BE THE FAT
GIRL.
I WAS THIS LITTLE SKINNY CHICK
THAT GOT WHAT SHE WANTED.
AND THEN I GOT IN MY ACCIDENT
AND EVERYTHING CHANGED.
EVERYTHING.
I WOULDN'T STILL BE HERE IF IT
WASN'T FOR YOU.
JUST BY TALKING TO ME.
>> I'M REALLY GLAD THAT I COULD
HELP YOU.
THAT DOES MEAN SOMETHING TO ME,
THAT I COULD HELP YOU.
I FEEL GOOD ABOUT THAT.
I DON'T--I DON'T HATE YOU, FOR
WHAT IT'S WORTH.
EVEN IF I DID, WHAT WOULD IT
MATTER ANYWAY?
BUT--
>> IT WOULD STILL MATTER.
>> YOU DIDN'T RUIN MY LIFE.
YOU KNOW, GOOD LUCK IN
EVERYTHING THAT YOU DO.
I-I REALLY MEAN THAT.
>> THANK YOU. YOU TOO.
>> I HOPE EVERYTHING--
I HOPE--HOPE STUFF TURNS AROUND
FOR YOU.
>> THIS WAS THE FIRST STEP,
I THINK.
GOOD NIGHT.
>> GOOD NIGHT, KRISTYN.
WHY DO YOU SAY THAT, BY THE WAY?
WHY DO YOU ALWAYS SAY GOOD NIGHT
INSTEAD OF GOOD-BYE?
>> GOOD-BYE MEANS FOREVER, AND I
CAN'T SAY IT TO ANYBODY.
>> OKAY.
>> EVER SINCE MY CAR ACCIDENT,
I DO NOT SAY GOOD-BYE.
IT MEANS FOREVER.
SEE YOU, KRISTYN.
>> SEE YA.
>> * SOON WE'LL BE *
* HERE ALONE
>> DOES THIS FEEL LIKE A BREAK
UP?
>> KIND OF.
I'M DISAPPOINTED.
LET DOWN.
>> YOU THINK YOU'D EVER BE OPEN
TO TALKING TO HER AGAIN?
>> WHY WOULD I--I'VE GOT NOTHING
ELSE TO SAY TO HER.
>> * OUT OF TIME
>> ARE YOU GUYS GONNA GO BACK
AND TALK TO HER?
>> WE MIGHT.
>> YOU'RE NOT GONNA GET ME TO GO
WITH YOU THOUGH, ARE YOU?
IF YOU WERE TO ASK ME, I
WOULD--I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
DECLINE THAT INVITATION.
>> ARE YOU DOING SOMETHING ON
CONTACTS?
>> YEAH, I'M DELETING HER.
>> * OH, THERE YOU WERE
>> ALL RIGHT, THAT'S IT.
WOW.
>> THAT'S ALL SHE WROTE.
>> IF ANYONE REALLY NEEDS SOME
KIND OF SUPPORT, IT'S KRISTYN.
>> SHE FEELS REALLY BAD AND
GUILTY.
>> THE BEST THING WE CAN DO IS,
LIKE, OFFER HER A REALLY SAFE
PLATFORM.
>> HI.
>> HEY.
>> YOU GUYS CAN COME IN.
>> COOL.
>> REALLY NICE, WOW.
>> SO YOU HAD THE ACCIDENT.
>> HOW DID YOUR LIFE CHANGE?
>> WELL, I GOT KICKED OUT OF
HIGH SCHOOL BECAUSE I WAS HAVING
TOO MANY SURGERIES.
I WAS MISSING TOO MUCH SCHOOL.
>> AND WHAT WOULD YOU DO ALL DAY
LONG?
>> SLEEP.
THEY HAD ME PRETTY DRUGGED UP,
THE DOCTORS DID.
>> SO YOU WERE ON A LOT OF MEDS?
>> YEAH, THOSE STEROIDS ARE NOT
YOUR FRIEND.
>> NO.
>> [laughs] THEY ARE NOT.
I FEEL LIKE THAT'S WHY I GAINED
ALL THE WEIGHT.
I GAINED ABOUT 130 POUNDS.
I HAD A BOYFRIEND WHO LEFT ME
THAT I HAD, LIKE, THOUGHT I HAD
A FUTURE WITH.
HE WAS ACTUALLY DRIVING THE CAR
WE WERE IN.
HE WAS FINE AFTER THE ACCIDENT
AND IT TOOK HIM TWO WEEKS TO
COME SEE ME.
AND HE TOLD ME TO HAVE FUN
LOOKING LIKE A PIRATE FOR THE
NEXT SIX MONTHS.
THAT WAS, LIKE, IT.
I WAS AT ROCK BOTTOM AND I
DIDN'T WANNA BE ON THIS WORLD
ANYMORE.
AND I FOUND MIKE AND...
ON ACCIDENT, REALLY.
HE HAD TALKED ME OUT OF IT, NOT
KNOWING HE TALKED ME OUT OF IT.
>> MIKE IS NOT KIND OF, UH, THE
WARMEST, CUDDLIEST GUY IN THE
WORLD.
>> BUT HE WAS...TOWARDS ME.
>> THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SORT OF
REALIZING.
>> HE USED TO TELL ME PRINCESS
STORIES TO GO TO BED.
ABOUT, LIKE, PRINCE MIKE--
[laughs]
AND PRINCESS KRISTYN IN A
CASTLE, YOU KNOW.
>> I THINK YOU'RE HEADING IN A
NEW, MUCH BETTER DIRECTION NOW.
AND I REALLY DON'T SEE ANY
REASON WHY ANYBODY WOULDN'T
ACCEPT YOU.
>> I'M REALLY TRYING TO MOVE
FORWARD AND GET BETTER.
EVEN, LIKE, I'M STARTING TO
BECOME MY GOOFY SELF AGAIN.
LIKE, BEING WACKY.
TAKING MY EYE OUT.
BEFORE I WOULD NEVER.
I WAS...SCARED.
BUT NOW I'M JUST LIKE, "HEY,
WANNA HOLD MY EYE?"
>> WHAT'S INVOLVED IN TAKING IT
OUT?
>> MY FINGER.
>> YOU JUST--YOU CAN JUST POP IT
OUT?
WAIT--
>> [laughs]
YEAH.
>> YOU DON'T NEED TO, LIKE,
RINSE OR SANITIZE?
>> NO, NO.
>> THERE'S REALLY ONLY ONE THING
LEFT TO DO.
>> ARE YOU READY.
DON'T SCREAM.
>> [chuckles]
UH, YES.
>> OKAY.
>> OH, MY GOD.
CAN I TOUCH IT?
>> YEAH.
>> YEAH.
>> BEAUTY IS IN THE EYE OF THE
BEHOLDER.
>> [laughs]
>> YOU ARE [indistinct].
>> WOW. HERE YOU GO.
>> ABOUT, UH--
>> AND THEN YOU JUST POP IT BACK
IN.
>> WELL, THANKS FOR LETTING US
HELP YOU TELL THE TRUTH, GIVING
MIKE AN OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE ON
IN HIS LIFE.
I THINK VERY CLEARLY FOR YOU TO
NOW MOVE ON IN YOUR OWN.
>> THANK YOU.
I GOT THIS.
LIKE, I CAN DO IT.
>> * HEARTACHE IS A COLD PLACE
>> THANK YOU FOR KIND OF
SHARING WITH US.
>> IT WAS A CRAZY STORY.
REAL LIFE STORY.
>> SORROW IS A FREEING SPACE *
* WHERE TEARS
* HAVE A GOOD TASTE
>> GOOD NIGHT.
>> TALK SOON.
>> [laughs]
>> AND NOW MORE
CATFISH: THE TV SHOW.
STICK AROUND.
>> HEY, MIKE.
>> I WOULDN'T MIND IF WE COULD
JUST COME OVER TO YOUR PLACE
AND CHAT FOR A MINUTE.
YEAH, I THINK THAT WOULD BE
PERFECT.
HOW YOU DOING?
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> MIKE.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU, MAX.
>> SO HOW WAS IT?
TELL ME WHAT HAPPENED, BRO?
I WANNA KNOW WHAT HAPPENED.
>> GIVE US SOME DETAILS, MAN.
>> YEAH, WELL, EVERYTHING BUT
HER, YEAH.
>> BUT YOU LIKED HER
PERSONALITY.
>> YEAH, YEAH.
BUT I ALSO THOUGHT THERE WAS A
DIFFERENT--THERE WAS A DIFFERENT
PERSON BEHIND THE PERSONALITY.
SHE CAME OUT, SHE LOOKED AT ME,
I LOOKED AT HER, AND SHE SAID
"I'M SORRY."
THAT WAS THE FIRST THING THAT
CAME OUT OF HER MOUTH.
SHE SHOWED REGRET AND REMORSE
FOR HER ACTIONS, AND I BELIEVED
HER.
>> WAS THE EYE THING TRUE OR
WHAT?
>> YEAH.
>> IT WAS?
>> I WAS SURPRISE THAT THE WHOLE
ACCIDENT WAS REAL AND THAT SHE
DOES HAVE A FAKE EYE.
THAT WAS CRAZY.
SHE LOST A LOT OF HER FRIENDS.
IT WAS SENIOR YEAR OF HIGH
SCHOOL.
>> SHE WAS HAVING A SERIOUS
RELATIONSHIP WITH THE GUY WHO
WAS DRIVING THE CAR.
THE GUY BROKE UP WITH HER.
>> YEAH.
>> SHE WAS NO LONGER POPULAR.
SHE'S HAD SOME REALLY BAD
BREAKS.
SHE MADE THIS FAKE PROFILE SO
SHE COULD KIND OF FEED HER
SELF ESTEEM A LITTLE BIT.
>> AND BASICALLY THAT'S WHAT I
DID, YEAH, FOR WHENEVER I WAS
TALKING TO HER.
I WAS JUST MAKING HER FEEL GOOD
ABOUT HERSELF AND THAT'S WHY SHE
KEPT, UH, YOU KNOW--SHE WANTED
ME AROUND.
YEAH, SHE WANTED ME AROUND
BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WHEN SHE HAD
A BAD DAY SHE'D CALL ME AND I'D
MAKE HER FEEL BETTER ABOUT IT.
SHE SAID IF IT WASN'T FOR ME
TALKING TO HER THAT IT WAS
LIKELY THAT SHE WOULD HAVE
KILLED HERSELF.
>> YOU MIGHT HONESTLY HAVE SAVED
HER LIFE, DUDE.
THINK OF IT LIKE THAT.
>> EXACTLY.
>> DON'T BE EMBARRASSED BY IT.
>> EVERYTHING THAT YOU DID WAS
THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
>> YOU WERE A GOOD GUY AND GAVE
HER THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT.
THERE'S NO REASON TO BE
EMBARRASSED ABOUT THAT.
>> THANKS, BRO.
>> THAT'S WHAT I'M TELLING HIM,
SEE?
>> YOU'RE RIGHT.
>> WHAT DO YOU FEEL?
>> I FEEL GOOD.
I FEEL--I FEEL GOOD, YEAH.
HONESTLY.
>> SOMETHING OFF YOUR SHOULDERS.
>> YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.
YEAH. NO, FOR REAL. YEAH.
>> YOU'RE A YOUNG GUY, GOT
A GOOD JOB.
>> YOU GOT YOUR--YOU GOT YOUR
LIFE ON TRACK.
>> YOU GOT YOUR LIFE, YOU KNOW
WHAT I MEAN?
>> YOU GONNA TALK TO HER STILL?
>> NO.
>> ARE YOU DONE?
>> I ALREADY DELETED THE
CONTACT, YEAH.
DELETED HER NUMBER.
I MEAN, I STILL KNOW IT BY
HEART, BUT I'M NOT GONNA--
[all laugh]
IT'S GONE. IT'S GONE.
IT'S GONE.
>> I THINK YOU'LL STILL CALL HER
AND TALK TO HER.
>> I HONESTLY FEEL LIKE TOO.
>> I THINK YOU WILL.
>> I FEEL LIKE I WILL TOO.
>> YOU'RE NOT JUST GONNA GO COLD
TURKEY AND NOT TALK TO THIS
GIRL.
>> YEAH, I KNOW, I KNOW.
I KNOW, I KNOW.
YEAH.
>> WELL, LISTEN, FELLAS.
HE'S GONNA GO THROUGH SOME WEIRD
THINGS OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF
DAYS.
IT'S GONNA SUCK FOR A LITTLE
BIT, YOU KNOW?
YEAH.
>> YEAH.
>> ALL RIGHT, SO WE'RE GONNA GET
OUT OF HERE.
HEAD BACK.
>> ALL RIGHT, YOU GUYS TAKE IT
EASY.
>> ENJOY YOURSELVES.
>> GENTLEMEN.
>> TAKE IT EASY.
>> ALL RIGHT, MAX.
>> DON'T GET UP, DON'T GET UP.
I'M PROUD OF YOU, MIKE.
YOU HANDLED YOUR BUSINESS LIKE
A GENTLEMAN.
SO THANKS FOR THAT.
>> YOU'RE WELCOME.
>> LATER, FELLAS.
>> TAKE IT EASY.
>> HEY.
>> OH.
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> I'M DOING PRETTY WELL, MAN.
NO MORE MYSTERY ANYMORE SO IT'S
GOOD, MAN.
>> SO ARE YOU AND KRISTYN ON
PRETTY GOOD TERMS THEN, I GUESS?
>> YEAH, WE'RE ON--WE'RE ON GOOD
TERMS.
I MEAN WE'VE TALKED A FEW TIMES.
I TOLD HER, YOU KNOW, SHE
CAN--SHE STILL HAS MY NUMBER.
SHE, YOU KNOW--SHE CAN STILL
TEXT ME, CALL ME, WHENEVER.
BUT, YOU KNOW, YOU TALK TO
SOMEBODY FOR THAT LONG YOU STILL
WANNA TIE UP A FEW LOOSE ENDS
OR WHATEVER AND THAT'S PRETTY
MUCH WHAT WE'VE DONE.
>> SO WHAT'S GOING ON WITH YOU
ON THE GIRL FRONT?
>> I DON'T HAVE A GIRLFRIEND,
BUT, YOU KNOW, I'M OUT THERE
STILL DANGLING MY, UH--DANGLING
MY BAIT OUT THERE SO TO SPEAK.
BUT, UH, I'VE HAD A FEW NIBBLES,
I'VE HAD A FEW NIBBLES.
BUT, UH, WE'LL SEE, WE'LL SEE.
I HAVEN'T FOUND THE ONE YET.
>> I'M SURE SOMETHING GOOD WILL
COME OUT OF THIS FOR YOU.
>> YEAH, I THINK SO TOO.
>> WELL, IT WAS GOOD TALKING TO
YOU.
>> ALWAYS, MAN.
GOOD TO SEE YOU GUYS AGAIN.
>> ALL RIGHT, DUDE.
TAKE IT EASY.
>> LATER.
>> LATER.
HEY, KRISTYN.
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> HI.
>> HOW IS EVERYTHING?
>> EVERYTHING'S GOOD.
UM, I'M DATING NOW.
I HAVE A BOYFRIEND.
>> WHAT?
>> THAT WAS FAST.
>> YEAH.
HE'S GONNA MOVE WITH ME TOO.
>> WOW.
>> WOW.
>> YEAH.
>> MY FAMILY IS GONNA BE
BUYING A SALON.
>> THAT'S INCREDIBLE.
>> I KNOW.
IT'S EXCITING.
I'M READY TO START MY LIFE.
>> ALL RIGHT, KRISTYN.
AWESOME TALKING TO YOU,
AND, UH, YEAH, WE'LL TALK SOON.
>> OKAY.
>> BYE, KRISTYN.
>> BYE.
>> GOOD NIGHT.
>> WHY DO YOU LIKE THIS GUY SO
MUCH?
>> HE'S JUST SO SWEET AND
GENUINE.
>> BUT YOU'RE REALLY SUSPICIOUS
THERE'S SOMETHING BIG THAT YOU
DON'T KNOW.
>> YEAH AND IT SCARES ME.
>> WAIT, WHAT'S THIS.
>> THAT'S A MUG SHOT.
POSSESSION OF A WEAPON OF MASS
DESTRUCTION?
>> WHOA.
>> I'M SCARED.
1582
00:40:57.
>> YEAH, NO KIDDING.
>> [knocks]
HI.
HI, I'M NEV, AND THIS IS MY
FILMMAKER BUDDY MAX.
LAST YEAR, WE TRAVELED ACROSS
THE COUNTRY FIGURING OUT
THE TRUTH BEHIND ONLINE
ROMANCES.
I'M READY TO COME MEET YOU IF
YOU THINK YOU'RE REALLY READY.
>> I'M DEFINITELY READY.
>> ALONG THE WAY, WE OPENED
DOORS TO SOME BIG SURPRISES.
>> WAIT, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS, GUYS.
>> WE MADE A FEW LOVE
CONNECTIONS...
>> FEELS AMAZING.
>> AND EVEN DID OUR FAIR SHARE
OF MENDING BROKEN HEARTS.
>> I'M SO HAPPY EVERY DAY WHEN I
WAKE UP NOW.
[sniffles]
>> SUDDENLY, THE IDEA OF
CATFISHING--HIDING WHO YOU
REALLY ARE TO HOOK SOMEONE INTO
AN ONLINE RELATIONSHIP...
>> PROBABLY A PAGEANT WINNER,
A MODEL.
>> WAS BEING TALKED ABOUT BY
A LOT OF YOU.
GOT AN EMAIL HERE.
"WHO DID I REALLY FALL IN LOVE
WITH?"
SO MAX AND I ARE HEADED BACK OUT
ON THE ROAD...
MAX, WE'VE GOT WORK TO DO.
TO INVESTIGATE STORIES THAT SEEM
TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE...
>> I AM IN DEREK'S DRIVEWAY.
>> OR TOO WILD TO MAKE UP.
>> HE WAS CARJACKED, AND HE WAS
RAN OVER BY THE CAR.
>> JESUS, MAN.
WILL HOPE BECOME LOVE...
>> OH, MY GOD.
>> OR IS LOVE IN FOR A GIANT
SHOCK?
>> [cries] I DON'T KNOW.
>> YOU CAN BE SURE THAT MAX AND
I WILL FIND OUT ALL
THE ANSWERS, BECAUSE SOMETIMES,
A LITTLE BIT OF FICTION...
>> WOW, CATFISH CURVE BALL.
>> LEADS TO A WHOLE LOT OF
REALITY.
THINGS WILL NEVER BE THE SAME.
>> [laughs]
>> ARE WE READY?
>> LET'S DO IT.
>> CATFISH THE MOVIE WAS MY
STORY.
CATFISH: THE TV SHOW IS YOURS.
>> LET ME JUST GET MY SHOT.
>> YOUR ROOM IS SURPRISINGLY
NEAT.
>> I'M LEARNING FROM YOU.
>> IS EVERYTHING--EVERYTHING
OKAY?
OH, WAIT A SECOND.
A GRAPE?
A GRAPE JUST FELL, SO THINGS ARE
NOT TOO FAR FROM DISORDERLY.
[both laugh]
EMAIL THAT JUST CAME IN.
SUBJECT--"SEPARATED BY LESS
THAN 40 MILES."
WOW. OKAY.
"HELLO, MY NAME IS MICHAEL.
I'M A 25-YEAR-OLD FROM STERLING
HEIGHTS, MICHIGAN."
UH-OH, MICHIGAN.
>> MICHIGAN IMPOSSIBLE.
>> "ABOUT THREE AND 1/2 YEARS
AGO, I STARTED TALKING TO A GIRL
NAMED KRISTEN.
SHE'S THE TYPE OF GIRL THAT YOU
INSTANTLY CONNECT WITH.
KRISTEN IS A 22-YEAR-OLD FROM
ST. CLAIR, MICHIGAN, WHICH IS
ABOUT AN HOUR NORTH OF MY CITY.
KRISTEN IS GOING TO BEAUTY
SCHOOL AND HOPES TO PURSUE
A CAREER IN COSMETOLOGY.
WE STARTED TALKING ON FACEBOOK
AFTER SHE LIKED A COMMENT I
POSTED.
AFTER ONLY A MONTH OF TALKING,
WE'D ALREADY BEGUN SAYING,
'I LOVE YOU.'"
>> L-BOMBS.
>> "AND I CONSIDERED HER MY
GIRLFRIEND."
>> G-BOMB.
>> "WE'VE EVEN TALKED ABOUT THE
NUMBER OF KIDS WE WANT TO HAVE."
>> K-BOMB.
>> "MY ATTEMPTS TO MEET HER HAVE
BEEN FREQUENT, BUT FUTILE.
THE BIGGEST REASON I FEEL SHE
WON'T SEE ME IS BECAUSE OF HER
PHYSICAL HANDICAP.
UP TO THIS POINT, OUR
RELATIONSHIP HAS CONSISTED ONLY
OF TEXT MESSAGES AND PHONE
CALLS.
NO VIDEO CHAT.
I'M NOT MUCH OF A COMPUTER GUY.
I'M AFRAID THAT WITHOUT YOUR
HELP I'LL NEVER GET A CHANCE TO
KNOW IF SHE AND I HAVE A FUTURE
TOGETHER.
I AM HOPEFUL AND WILL BE FOREVER
GRATEFUL IF YOU CAN HELP ME MAKE
THIS HAPPEN."
WHAT'S CRAZY IS THAT THEY LIVE
SO CLOSE AND THAT THIS GUY HAS
CONTINUED TO ENTERTAIN THE FACT
THAT THERE'S A CHANCE THEY'LL
MEET UP WHEN THEY HAVEN'T YET.
>> I KNOW.
>> YEAH, WE JUST GOTTA FIND OUT
MORE FROM THIS GUY.
[Skype chimes]
HELLO.
>> WHAT'S UP, MAN?
HOW YOU GUYS DOING?
>> TELL US EVERYTHING, MAN.
>> KRISTEN, SHE'S JUST
EVERYTHING I FEEL LIKE I WANT.
WE HAVE GREAT CHEMISTRY.
>> * I HAVE BEEN TRYING
* TO FIND HER
* WANNA GIVE WHAT I'VE GOT *
* SHE LIT A FIRE AND NOW
* SHE'S IN MY EVERY THOUGHT *
>> SHE'S FUNNY.
OUR SENSE OF HUMORS, I THINK,
ARE VERY SIMILAR.
>> YOU GOTTA EXPLAIN THIS
HANDICAP THAT SHE HAS, BECAUSE
OTHERWISE, I REALLY CAN'T
UNDERSTAND WHY YOU'D BE PUTTING
UP WITH SOMEBODY WHO LIVES SO
CLOSE NOT SEEING YOU FOR
3-1/2 YEARS.
>> IT WAS PROBABLY AROUND THE
SAME TIME THAT I MET HER--WAS
CLOSE TO THE TIME WHERE SHE WAS
INVOLVED IN A CAR ACCIDENT.
THEY GOT INTO A HEAD-ON
COLLISION WITH A SEMI TRUCK,
ACTUALLY.
THE WINDSHIELD BROKE, GLASS
SHATTERED, AND IT GOT INTO HER
EYE.
THE DOCTORS COULDN'T FIX IT, SO
SHE HAS A FAKE EYE NOW.
SHE MIGHT BE APPREHENSIVE TO
ACTUALLY MEET ME BECAUSE MAYBE
SHE FEELS LIKE I'M GONNA REJECT
HER BECAUSE OF THAT, BUT I TELL
HER TIME AND TIME AGAIN THAT'S
NOT THE CASE.
IT'S BEEN LONG ENOUGH.
THE DAY I MEET HER, I FEEL LIKE
WE'RE GONNA HIT A HOME RUN, MAN
AND I JUST--I WANT THAT TO
HAPPEN PRETTY BAD.
>> ALL RIGHT, WELL, LOOK.
I'M SO CURIOUS ABOUT THIS GIRL.
I'M IN.
I'M--I'M READY TO MAKE THIS
HAPPEN.
>> [claps] GOOD.
I LIKE TO HEAR THAT.
>> GREAT.
LATER, MAN.
>> PEACE.
>> THIS GUY, FOR THE LAST THREE
AND 1/2 YEARS, HE'S BEEN HOPING
THE WHOLE TIME THAT SOMETHING
WILL CHANGE AND HIM AND KRISTEN
WILL END UP TOGETHER.
>> HE'S IN--INVESTED IN THIS.
>> BIG TIME.
>> WELL, LET'S GO.
RIGHT? WE'RE GOING TO MICHIGAN.
>> YEAH, MAN.
>> * A WHITE LIGHT BURNED
* BY THE BURDEN OF PROOF
* AND LAST NIGHT YOU TOLD
* THE TERMINAL TRUTH
* OH I TOLD IT TO YOU
>> COOL.
IT WOULDN'T BE A SEASON OF
CATFISH IF WE DIDN'T END UP IN
MICHIGAN AT LEAST ONCE.
>> * IN THE BLACK LIGHT
* IN THE BLACK LIGHT
>> WEIRDEST THING ABOUT THIS
STORY IS NOT THAT SHE GOT INTO
AN ACCIDENT AND LOST AN EYE, AND
NOT THAT THEY'VE NEVER VIDEO
CHATTED IN THREE AND 1/2 YEARS.
IT'S THAT THEY LIVE LESS THAN AN
HOUR AWAY FROM EACH OTHER.
>> YEAH.
THE OLD KNOCK.
>> YO, MIKE.
>> JUST GO AHEAD?
>> HEY.
>> HEY, WHAT'S GOING ON, MAN?
>> HEY, WHAT'S UP, MAN?
>> HEY, GOOD TO SEE YOU, MAN.
GLAD YOU GUYS MADE IT.
HEY, GOOD TO MEET YOU, MAN.
>> AND THIS IS YOUR HOUSE?
>> THIS IS MY HOUSE, YES.
>> YOU OWN THIS HOUSE?
>> I OWN THIS HOUSE.
>> YOU OWN IT?
>> YES.
>> THIS IS GREAT.
>> THANK YOU.
>> SO THE BEDROOMS ARE OVER
HERE?
>> YEP, THAT'S WHERE THE MAGIC
HAPPENS.
>> DO YOU BELIEVE IN SEX BEFORE
MARRIAGE?
>> YES, I DO PRACTICE SEX BEFORE
MARRIAGE.
>> [laughs]
IT'S PRACTICE THOUGH?
>> YES.
>> JUST PRACTICE.
>> PRACTICE MAKES PERFECT.
>> LET'S HAVE A SEAT.
ALL RIGHT.
WHAT DO YOU THINK IS, UH,
DIFFERENT ABOUT KRISTEN THAN
OTHER GIRLS THAT YOU'VE BEEN
DATING?
>> SHE'S SHOWING YOU THE LOVE
AND THE COMPASSION AND THE
RESPECT THAT YOU'RE SHOWING HER.
IT MAKES YOU FEEL GOOD.
>> HAVE YOU GIVEN YOUR WORD IN
ANY WAY TO KRISTEN?
>> WE WERE EXCLUSIVE AT SOME
POINTS.
SHORT PERIODS OF TIME AND THEN,
FOR WHATEVER REASON, IT WOULD
STOP.
AND THEN AT THAT POINT IF I WAS
DATING SOMEBODY, KRISTEN ALWAYS
TOLD ME THAT SHE WANTS ME TO
STOP TALKING TO THIS GIRL
BECAUSE HER AND I ARE GONNA BE
TOGETHER.
AND THEN EVENTUALLY I WOULD
ALWAYS BREAK DOWN AND STOP
TALKING TO GIRLS I WAS TALKING
TO IN HOPES THAT HER AND I WOULD
FINALLY GET THE CHANCE TO MEET
EACH OTHER.
I DIDN'T WANNA JUST THROW
EVERYTHING AWAY THAT I FELT THAT
WE HAD ALREADY BUILT UP.
>> WOULD YOU SAY THAT--THAT YOU
LOVE HER?
>> YEAH.
YEAH, I'LL SAY THAT.
I HAVE SAID IT TO HER ON MANY
OCCASIONS.
THE WHOLE MYSTERY OF THE
SITUATION IS REALLY DRAWING ME
INTO IT.
SHE'S ELUDED ME THUS FAR.
>> YOU WANNA TRUST HER?
>> YES, I DEF--ABSOLUTELY DO.
I BELIEVE WHAT SHE'S TELLING ME,
AND I JUST REALLY, REALLY HOPE
THAT IT'S ALL TRUE.
>> SO MOST OF YOUR
COMMUNICATION'S WITH YOUR PHONE.
>> MOSTLY THE PHONE, YEAH.
>> ALL RIGHT, SO WHAT DO YOU
HAVE ON THERE?
>> I'VE GOT A FEW PICTURES OF
HER.
>> SO THESE ARE PICTURES SHE
TEXTED YOU?
>> YES.
>> THIS ONE'S FROM APRIL?
>> MM-HMM.
>> THIS IS INTERESTING.
SO I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT
GLASS EYES, BUT OBVIOUSLY I KNOW
THAT IF YOU HAVE TWO FUNCTIONING
EYES, YOUR PUPILS OPEN AND CLOSE
TOGETHER.
AND IN THIS PICTURE, BOTH OF HER
EYES, THE PUPIL'S THE EXACT
SAME SIZE.
IT'S POSSIBLE THAT--AND I'M SURE
YOU'VE CONSIDERED THIS--THAT
MAYBE SHE DOES IN FACT HAVE TWO
WORKING EYEBALLS.
>> SHE MADE IT UP.
I DON'T KNOW WHY WOULD YOU MAKE
SOMETHING LIKE THAT UP.
>> ARE YOU SEXUALLY ATTRACTED TO
HER?
>> YES, I AM SEXUALLY ATTRACTED
TO HER.
SHE'S GOT SOME NICE CURVES TO
HER FROM OTHER PICTURES I'VE
SEEN THAT I WILL NOT DISCLOSE
TO YOU GUYS, BUT--
>> REALLY?
>> WHAT?
>> EVERYTHING IS--IT'S GOOD.
>> WHAT PICTURES ARE THOSE?
>> THEY'RE JUST PROVOCATIVE
PHOTOS TO GET THE IMAGINATION
GOING.
>> SUGGESTED NUDITY.
>> WOW.
>> AND HAVE YOU, UH,
RECIPROCATED?
>> YEAH, I HAVE.
YEAH.
>> IN A SIMILAR FASHION?
>> A SIMILAR FASHION.
FULL FRONTAL NUDITY WITH MY FACE
INCLUDED ALSO.
YEAH.
>> UH, I'M--I'M A LITTLE--
>> [laughs]
>> I'M--I MEAN, NOT A LOT OF
PEOPLE--
>> THAT'S--
>> WELL, I GUESS PEOPLE DO THAT,
BUT--
>> THAT MEANS THAT YOU HAVE
TR--THAT YOU TRUST HER.
>> YEAH.
WE GOT WORK TO DO.
>> YEAH.
>> I HOPE THAT, UH, WE GET TO
THE BOTTOM OF THIS.
>> ALL RIGHT, MAN, LATER.
>> LATER, MIKE.
>> SEE YA.
>> HE'S PUT SO MUCH MORE INTO
THIS THAN HE EVEN REALLY WANTS
TO ADMIT.
WHAT HE'S GOT ON THE LINE HERE
ARE TWO THINGS.
ONE IS THIS LONG RELATIONSHIP
WITH THIS GIRL THAT HE'S PRETTY
CRAZY ABOUT.
AND TWO IS JUST HIS PRIDE.
THIS GUY REALLY WOULD BE CRUSHED
TO FIND THAT HE'D BEEN TAKEN
ADVANTAGE OF.
>> ALL RIGHT.
SO, HERE'S WHAT'S UP.
WE'VE GOT MIKE'S RELATIONSHIP
WITH KRISTEN.
THEY'VE BEEN TALKING FOR OVER
THREE YEARS.
WHAT IS KIND OF HARD TO BELIEVE
IS THAT THEY LIVE UNDER AN HOUR
AWAY, BUT SHE HASN'T BEEN ABLE
TO FIND AN AFTERNOON.
I MEAN, IT'S NOT LIKE SHE'S
GOTTA GIVE UP A WEEKEND.
LIKE, THEY COULD MEET FOR
DINNER.
>> THIS ACCIDENT THING, HUGE RED
FLAG.
>> WHY WOULD SHE PICK AN EXCUSE
THAT WOULD BE SO HARD TO FAKE
AND SEND PHOTOS?
>> WE NEED TO DO A FEW THINGS.
PROVE OR DISPROVE THAT SHE IS
THE GIRL IN THE PICTURES.
WE NEED TO SEE IF SHE IS LYING
TO HIM ABOUT WHO SHE IS.
NUMBER TWO IS TO FIND OUT WHO
SHE REALLY IS.
>> RIGHT.
>> BUT THE LEAST WE COULD DO
IS FIND OUT IF WHAT SHE'S TOLD
HIM IS TRUE.
>> HERE'S AN EMAIL FROM MIKE
WITH ALL OF THE NECESSARY INFO.
KRISTEN NICOLE PARKERS.
22-YEAR-OLD.
BIRTHDAY: MARCH.
LIVES IN ST. CLAIR, MICHIGAN
WITH HORSES.
>> SHE GOES TO BEAUTY SCHOOL IN
PORT HURON.
WE SHOULD CALL THE BEAUTY SCHOOL
AND SEE IF KRISTEN ACTUALLY DOES
ATTEND.
>> I WILL CALL KRISTEN'S
SUPPOSED BEAUTY SCHOOL.
HI, BRIANNA, MY NAME IS DEV AND
I MAKE A SHOW ONMTV CALLED
CATFISH.
>> YEAH, YEAH, I THINK I'VE
HEARD OF IT.
>> BASICALLY WHAT I'M TRYING TO
FIND OUT IS IF THERE IS
A STUDENT THERE BY THE NAME
KRISTEN PARKERS.
OH.
OKAY.
>> AND--AND SHE DOESN'T SEEM TO
HAVE A GLASS EYE?
>> YOU'VE MADE MY JOB MUCH
HARDER.
>> [laughs]
>> INTERESTING.
>> SO THERE'S A KRISTEN THAT
GOES THERE.
KRISTEN WITH A "K."
>> RIGHT.
>> NO GLASS EYE.
>> IF IT'S A GOOD GLASS EYE YOU
COULD NOT KNOW.
>> YES YOU KNOW.
>> NO, THAT'S NOT TRUE.
IT'S NOT A GUARANTEE THAT SHE
WOULD KNOW.
>> I WANNA DO A SPOKEO SEARCH
FOR--
>> I KNOW, WE CAN DO THAT.
>> FOR THE PHONE NUMBER THOUGH.
>> WELL, YEAH, 'CAUSE THAT COULD
GIVE US A LAST NAME.
AND THEN WE COULD ACTUALLY CALL
BACK AND ASK HER IF IT IS THAT
LAST NAME, RIGHT?
>> RIGHT.
>> OKAY, LET'S SEE IF WE GET
A HIT.
AND WHAT HAVE WE GOT?
HILLOCK.
>> THAT COULD BE HER FATHER.
>> SO MAYBE HER NAME IS KRISTEN
HILLOCK.
>> TRY THE WHITE PAGES.
ST. CLAIR.
THERE IS A HILLOCK IN ST. CLAIR.
THIS IS THE ADDRESS THAT
CAME UP AND IT SHOWS A FARM OF
SORTS IN A VERY RURAL
NEIGHBORHOOD AND WHAT LOOKS LIKE
A HORSE CORRAL--
>> A BARN.
>> A BARN WITH A HORSE PEN.
>> YEAH.
>> AND SEEMINGLY LARGE ANIMAL.
>> [laughs]
>> I MEAN, YOU KNOW.
>> IT LOOKS LIKE A HORSE.
>> I THINK IT'S WORTH RUNNING
THE ADDRESS.
>> OKAY.
KRISTYN HILLOCK, BOOM.
>> BUT SHE'S FEMALE, 57.
>> 57.
>> SO SHE COULD BE 57?
>> SO THE PICTURE SHE'S SENDING
COULD BE HER DAUGHTER.
>> SPELLED DIFFERENTLY THAN--
>> SPELLED "Y-N," KRISTYN WITH
A "Y."
SO NOW I'M JUST SEARCHING
KRISTYN WITH THE--WITH THE NEW
SPELLING, "HILLOCK," ON
FACEBOOK.
>> AND WHAT DID YOU GET?
>> NOTHING.
HERE'S A MYLIFE PAGE.
>> ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT.
>> IT SAYS SHE'S 22 HERE.
KRISTYN HILLOCK, 22, ST. CLAIR,
MICHIGAN.
THAT'S HER.
WE FOUND HER.
WHEN'S HER BIRTHDAY?
MARCH 27!
>> ST. CLAIR.
>> ST. CLAIR.
>> 22.
>> 22.
BORN IN MARCH.
CALL THE BEAUTY SCHOOL AND ASK
IF IT'S KRISTYN HILLOCK.
>> HEY, BRIANNA, IT'S NEV AGAIN.
HEY.
SO, DO YOU HAVE A STUDENT
CURRENTLY ENROLLED BY THE NAME
KRISTYN HILLOCK?
WOW.
OKAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
OKAY, BYE.
WE'RE OUT--WE'RE OUT.
WE'RE DONE.
>> NO, WE'RE NOT.
>> RECORD INVESTIGATION TIME.
>> NO--WELL, SO WHAT DO WE KNOW?
>> WE'RE DONE.
WE'RE DONE.
>> THAT IT IS HER?
>> IT'S KRISTYN HILLOCK.
>> BUT WE STILL DON'T KNOW IF
IT'S REALLY HER IN THE PICTURES.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW IF SHE GOT
INTO AN ACCIDENT.
>> OKAY, SO JUST SEARCHING
KRISTYN HILLOCK.
LET'S LOOK AT THIS PIPL THING.
>> KRISTYN NICOLE HILLOCK.
>> OOH.
>> SHE'S GOT SOME TATS.
>> WITH SCISSORS BECAUSE SHE'S
INTO BEAUTY SCHOOL.
HERE'S HER FACEBOOK PAGE.
>> ALL RIGHT.
>> OH, COME ON.
BE THE FACEBOOK PAGE.
YES!
>> A HORSE!
>> SHE GOES BY KRISTYN NICOLE
WITH THEN AN "H" IN PARENTHESES.
>> "H" IN PARENTHESES.
>> BECAUSE HER LAST NAME IS
HILLOCK.
THERE'S A PICTURE OF A HORSE.
LOOKS LIKE THE SAME HORSE IN THE
PHOTO.
>> YOU CAN'T TELL.
>> [laughs] I'M JUST KIDDING.
>> SHE'S GOT PHOTOS.
>> YEAH, BUT EVERYTHING IS
PRIVATE.
>> [bleep].
>> SO, IT'S ALMOST CERTAIN THAT
THE GIRL THAT MIKE'S TALKING
TO'S NAME IS KRISTYN NICOLE
HILLOCK AND THAT MOST, IF NOT
ALL OF THE DETAILS THAT SHE'S
GIVEN HIM ABOUT HER LIFE ARE
TOTALLY ACCURATE.
>> HE'LL BE RELIEVED.
BUT WE DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE
GLASS EYE.
>> YES.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW WHAT SHE
LOOKS LIKE.
>> TOTALLY.
IT'S A LITTLE CONCERNING THAT
SHE LIED ABOUT HER LAST NAME.
>> BUT EVERYTHING ELSE SEEMS TO
BE TRUE.
>> THE ONLY THING WE HAVEN'T
BEEN ABLE TO FIND IS ANY KIND OF
CONCLUSIVE PHOTOGRAPHIC
EVIDENCE.
WHAT IS SHE HIDING?
WHO KNOWS.
>> WE DO HAVE SOME REALLY
INTERESTING INFORMATION.
IT'S A LITTLE COMPLICATED.
IT'S TOO MUCH TO GET INTO OVER
THE PHONE.
WE WANTED TO MEET UP WITH YOU.
ALL RIGHT, THAT SOUNDS GREAT.
WE'RE LOOKING FOR THE LPGA TOUR.
>> YOU'RE GOING TO
THE WRONG SPOT.
[all laugh]
HOW YOU GUYS DOING, MAN?
>> GOOD, MAN.
LOOK AT YOU.
YOU'RE ALL COLOR COORDINATED
TODAY.
>> HEY, YOU KNOW, YOU GOTTA--
YOU GOTTA LOOK THE PART.
>> THE BOY IN BLUE.
>> SO HOW MUCH DOES EVERYONE
KNOW?
>> I DIDN'T REALLY TELL 'EM
ABOUT A LOT OF THE DETAILS ABOUT
IT.
IT'S NOBODY'S BUSINESS BUT MY
OWN, I FEE LIKE.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN?
AND IF I WANNA MAKE IT YOUR
BUSINESS, I WILL MAKE IT YOUR
BUSINESS.
AND THAT'S WHEN YOU KNOW THAT I
WANT YOU TO KNOW ABOUT IT.
>> YOU JUST MADE IT MY BUSINESS.
>> I DID MAKE IT YOUR BUSINESS.
SO YOU'RE COOL.
YOU'RE ALL RIGHT WITH
THE QUESTIONS.
YOU'RE GOOD, YOU'RE GOOD.
>> OH, THAT'S GOT A SHOT.
HAS MIKE EVER SAID THAT HE MET
HER?
>> HE TOLD ME LAST SUMMER HE WAS
LEAVING MY HOUSE TO GO MEET HER.
HE SAID IT A COUPLE OF TIMES SO
I BELIEVED HIM.
>> REALLY?
>> I WAS LIKE, "OKAY, MAYBE SHE
IS REAL."
>> AND?
>> AND I JUST WAS RECENTLY TOLD
THAT HE HAS NEVER.
HE TOLD ME THAT HE LIED TO ME
ABOUT IT.
>> DID THAT BOTHER YOU THAT--TO
FIND OUT THAT HE--
>> I WAS LIKE--I KINDA WAS LIKE,
WHY ARE YOU LYING TO ME?
>> RIGHT.
>> WHY'D YOU LIE?
>> VERY NICE.
WOULD YOU SAY HE'S, LIKE,
A PLAYER OR, LIKE, A...
>> NOT REALLY.
>> LIKE A ONE--KIND OF LIKE A
ROMANTIC?
LIKE A--
>> YEAH, I'D SAY HE'S
PROBABLY--PROBABLY A ROMANTIC.
BUT HE'S--HE'S A GOOD GUY.
HE'S A GOOD GUY.
HE'S GOT ALL THESE FEELINGS FOR
THIS GIRL HE NEVER EVEN MET YET.
YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING?
>> ARE YOU KIND OF, LIKE,
EMBARRASSED ABOUT IT?
>> YEAH, DEFINITELY.
>> WHY?
>> 'CAUSE IF PEOPLE CAN'T SEE
THE PERSON WHO I'M SAYING I'M
HAVING A RELATIONSHIP WITH, TO
THEM IT'S NOT REAL.
I COULD JUST BE MAKING IT UP.
I REALLY DON'T WANT THEM TO BE
LIKE, "OH, BRO.
YOU'RE [bleep] STUPID, YOU KNOW?
YOU'RE--YOU'RE DUMB.
WHAT ARE YOU DOING, YOU KNOW?
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING TO SOMEBODY
YOU NEVER MET BEFORE?
>> ALL RIGHT, WE'RE GONNA TAKE
THIS GUY, TALK TO HIM A LITTLE
BIT.
>> DON'T BE TOO ROUGH ON HIM.
>> I'M VERY FRAGILE.
I HAVE A HARD EXTERIOR, BUT ON
THE INSIDE--
>> VERY SOFT.
[all laugh]
>> ALL RIGHT, HERE'S WHAT'S UP.
SO WE LOOKED AT THE INFO THAT
YOU GAVE US.
WE THOUGHT WHY NOT CALL THE
BEAUTY SCHOOL THAT SHE GOES TO
AND ASK?
"YOU GUYS HAVE A KRISTEN PARKERS
REGISTERED?"
WE SPOKE TO A GIRL WHO WORKS
THE SORT OF FRONT DESK.
WE ASKED HER IF THERE WAS
A KRISTEN PARKERS.
SHE SAID NO.
>> WELL, THAT'S--THAT'S NICE.
>> BUT--BUT THERE IS A KRISTYN.
OKAY, SO, THE ONLY OTHER REAL
SORT OF HARD INFO THAT WE HAD
FOR HER WAS HER PHONE NUMBER.
SO WE RAN THAT AND IT CAME UP,
FIRST OF ALL, REGISTERED TO THE
NAME HILLOCK.
>> YEAH.
>> DOES THAT NAME MEAN ANYTHING
TO YOU?
>> NO. NOT AT ALL.
>> SO WE TOOK THE NAME HILLOCK
AND WE DID A SEARCH FOR IT IN
THE WHITE PAGES.
>> YEAH.
>> AND IT CAME UP WITH AN
ADDRESS.
AND AMAZINGLY, IT IS EXACTLY AS
SHE DESCRIBED.
RURAL AREA.
WE'VE GOT A BARN.
>> YEAH, THAT APPEARS TO BE A
BARN IN, LIKE, SOME PASTURE OR
WHATEVER.
>> LIKE, A HORSE PADDOCK.
WE SEARCHED THE ADDRESS.
BROUGHT US TO THIS.
NOW HERE WE GOT KRISTYN NICOLE
AND THEN IN PARENTHESES "H,"
WHICH WE PRESUME IS...
>> HILLOCK.
>> HILLOCK.
AND A HORSE.
THAT'S ALL WE CAN SEE 'CAUSE
IT'S PRIVATE.
WE ENDED UP CALLING THE BEAUTY
SCHOOL BACK.
>> YEAH.
>> AND NOW WE HAD SORT OF A LAST
NAME.
>> TRUE. YEAH. HILLOCK.
>> AND SO WE SAID TO THE
GIRL--WE SAID, "LOOK--"
>> "HOW ABOUT HILLOCK?"
HOW'S THAT, SON?
>> CAN YOU CONFIRM IF THERE'S A
GIRL NAMED HILLOCK?
>> AND THEY PROBABLY SAID NO.
THEY PROBABLY TOLD YOU NO,
RIGHT?
>> NO, THE ANSWER WAS YES.
SHE JUST HAS A DIFFERENT LAST
NAME.
>> WE DON'T KNOW WHAT SHE REALLY
LOOKS LIKE, IF SHE'S THE GIRL
FROM THE PICTURES.
>> YEAH.
>> AND WE DON'T KNOW IF SHE
REALLY HAD AN ACCIDENT OR NOT.
MAYBE SHE DID.
>> YEP. MAYBE SHE DIDN'T.
>> MAYBE SHE DIDN'T.
>> YEP.
>> TO BE PERFECTLY HONEST, MOST
OF WHAT WE FOUND CONFIRMS
EVERYTHING SHE TOLD YOU.
>> THIS IS DIFFERENT ABOUT HER.
THE WHOLE SITUATION BEHIND IT.
DON'T GET ME WRONG.
I'VE--I'VE--I'VE TURNED DOWN
OTHER GIRLS.
I'VE SAID "NO, I CAN'T."
I'VE TOLD THEM I HAVE A
GIRLFRIEND.
I'M SORRY.
CAN'T DO IT.
YOU COME UP TO ME AT THE BAR,
"HEY, WHAT'S UP?"
"SORRY, I-I'M NOT INTO YOU.
GO AWAY."
>> BUT DESPITE--
>> THAT HAPPENS.
>> DESPITE WHO SHE IS, YOUR
FEELINGS ABOUT HER, THAT'S REAL.
>> I'M SORT OF SURPRISED THAT
YOU'RE HAVING SUCH A STRONG
REACTION JUST TO THE FACT THAT
HER NAME ISN'T HER NAME.
SHE WAS, FOR THE MOST PART,
TELLING THE TRUTH.
>> I KINDA ALREADY FEEL LIKE I
HAVE MY CLOSURE TO TELL YOU
THE TRUTH RIGHT NOW.
AS WE SPEAK RIGHT NOW.
I KINDA FEEL LIKE I HAVE IT
ALREADY.
>> WH--
>> IN ENOUGH OF A WAY FOR ME TO
MOVE ON WITH MY LIFE.
I'M JUST GONNA WALK AWAY.
STRAIGHT UP, THAT'S HOW IT'S
GONNA BE.
I'M GONNA WALK AWAY.
>> IT'S NOT BREAKING NEWS TO YOU
THAT THERE WAS A CHANCE THIS
GIRL COULD HAVE BEEN LYING TO
YOU.
>> WELL, IT KIND OF IS, MAN,
'CAUSE I-I TRUSTED HER.
LIKE, COMPLETELY.
FULL-FLEDGED, I BELIEVED WHAT
SHE WAS TELLING ME.
ALL OF IT.
SO YEAH.
AND TO FIND OUT THAT SHE WAS
LYING EVEN ABOUT CERTAIN THINGS
IS--IT'S NOT--NOT COOL, YOU
KNOW?
>> YOU'RE IN A SITUATION RIGHT
NOW WHERE YOU'VE SHARED
FEELINGS, YOU'VE INVESTED TIME.
I DO THINK IT'S WORTH SORT OF
CONSIDERING IN THE BIG PICTURE
OF THINGS.
>> I'D LOVE TO SIT DOWN AND SEE
HER AND TALK TO HER AND ASK HER
WHY.
I'M NOT GONNA QUIT UNTIL I GET
THAT.
>> I KNOW THIS WAS INTENSE AND
NOT EXACTLY WHAT YOU WERE
HOPING FOR.
HANG IN THERE.
WE ARE GONNA SEE THIS THING
THROUGH.
>> YOU GUYS, TAKE CARE.
SAFE--SAFE TRAVELS.
ALL THAT STUFF.
>> HE HAS KINDA BEEN IN DENIAL.
AND I THINK THAT, LIKE, THIS WAS
THE FIRST MOMENT WHERE HE HAD TO
FACE THE FACTS.
>> THE PERSON HE SEEMS TO BE THE
CLOSEST WITH IS THIS GIRL.
>> RIGHT.
>> WHO HE JUST FOUND OUT HASN'T
BEEN TELLING HIM THE WHOLE
TRUTH.
LIKE, NO WONDER HE'S SO PISSED.
>> HAVE YOU HEARD ANYTHING NEW
TODAY?
>> NO.
>> THERE IS A MIKE FACTOR HERE.
WE SHOULD TALK ABOUT THAT.
HE'S INTENSE.
>> WHICH IS WHY I THINK IT'S
PROBABLY BEST TO GET HIM AS
PREPARED AS WE CAN SO THAT
THERE'S NO SURPRISES.
>> SO WHAT'S THE PLAN?
I MEAN, WHAT ARE WE GONNA DO?
>> THIS IS THE FIRST TIME WE'VE
EVER HAD A SPECIFIC ADDRESS AND
EXACT NAME.
>> RIGHT.
>> BUT WE STILL NEED TO FIND OUT
WHAT SHE LOOKS LIKE.
I DON'T IMAGINE THERE'S TOO MANY
HIGH SCHOOLS AND THERE'S
PROBABLY A YEARBOOK SOMEWHERE.
>> SO A YEARBOOK?
>> I'M JUST TRYING TO--
>> THAT'S--THAT'S YOUR BIG IDEA?
>> I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE WOULD
HAVE, LIKE, A PUBLISHED PHOTO OF
SOMEONE'S FACE.
ALL RIGHT, HERE WE GO.
ST. CLAIR HIGH SCHOOL.
OKAY.
>> I DON'T THINK THEY DIGITIZE
THE YEARBOOK.
>> WAIT A SECOND.
LOOK AT THIS.
HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF MICHIGAN.
YEAH, LOOK.
ST. CLAIR HIGH SCHOOL YEARBOOKS.
THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE WE CAN
OUR HANDS ON A YEARBOOK THAT'LL
HAVE HER IN IT.
AND WE'LL KNOW WHO SHE IS AND
WE CAN CALL HER.
AND JUST SAY, LIKE, "LOOK, JIG
IS UP."
>> SO LET'S PICK UP MIKE.
>> RIGHT.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S DO IT.
>> HER STORY ABOUT WHERE SHE
LIVES AND WHERE SHE GREW UP
SEEMS TO BE TRUE.
WE'RE NOT SURE IF SHE'S THE GIRL
IN THE PICTURES THAT SHE SENT
YOU.
>> YEP.
>> AND THAT'S KIND OF A BIG
PIECE OF THE PUZZLE.
>> THERE'S THE ST. CLAIR
HISTORICAL MUSEUM.
>> IT'S OPEN.
THE FLAG IS OUT.
THIS IS HOW REAL DETECTIVES
USED TO DO IT BEFORE THE
INTERNET.
THEY HAD TO--HAD TO GO PLACES.
AFTERNOON.
WE'RE TRYING TO LOCATE SOME
YEARBOOKS...
>> OKAY.
>> FROM ST. CLAIR HIGH
SCHOOL.
>> ON THE SECOND SHELF THERE
OVER TO THE RIGHT.
>> OH, LOOK AT THAT.
HERE WE GO.
ALL RIGHT, 2007 ST. CLAIR HIGH
SCHOOL YEARBOOK.
>> SO THIS IS KINDA THE MOMENT
OF TRUTH.
HILLOCK. BOOM.
>> IS THAT HER?
>> CAN YOU GET OUT THE PICTURE
OF HER ON YOUR PHONE?
>> YEAH.
>> IT DOESN'T REALLY LOOK LIKE
THE SAME PERSON.
>> I-IT LOOKS LIKE A COMPLETELY
DIFFERENT PERSON TO ME.
IN MY OPINION.
>> WHAT DO YOU THINK, MIKE?
>> I DON'T KNOW.
EVERYTHING YOU GUYS COME UP WITH
SO FAR IS--KNOCKING ME DOWN
FARTHER AND FARTHER.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN?
>> WELL, WE ARE GETTING CLOSER
AND CLOSER.
WE KNOW EVERYTHING WE'RE GONNA
KNOW ABOUT THIS GIRL.
AND GUESS WE GOTTA CALL HER.
[phone rings]
>> YEAH, HI.
KRISTYN?
HEY, UH, MY NAME IS NEV AND I
HAVE--HAVE A SHOW ON MTV CALLED
CATFISH YOU MAY HAVE HEARD OF.
OKAY, COOL.
UM, WELL, I'M HERE WITH YOUR
FRIEND, MIKE.
>> HEY, KRISTYN, THIS IS MIKE.
>> OKAY, SO YEAH, LET ME EXPLAIN
WHAT'S GOING ON.
SO BASICALLY MIKE GOT IN TOUCH
WITH ME.
WE'RE ACTUALLY NOW IN ST. CLAIR,
NOT TOO FAR FROM WHERE YOU LIVE
AND WE WERE HOPING THAT WE COULD
HELP YOU GUYS FINALLY MEET FOR
THE FIRST TIME AND HAVE A CHANCE
TO HANG OUT.
YEAH.
I MEAN, HERE.
I'LL LET YOU GUYS TALK FOR
A SECOND.
>> YEAH, I DO STILL WANNA MEET
YOU.
I'D REALLY LIKE TO SEE YOU AND
JUST CHAT FOR A LITTLE BIT.
GOT A--GOT SOME QUESTIONS I'D
LIKE TO ASK YOU AND I'M LOOKING
FORWARD FOR YOU TO BE UP FRONT
AND HONEST WITH ME.
YEAH, YOU BEEN SAYING THAT TO
ME--
IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME COMING,
KRISTYN.
I THINK YOU OWE IT TO ME.
AT LEAST A LITTLE TINY BIT.
AND NOT EVEN JUST TO ME.
YOU OWE IT TO YOURSELF TOO.
ALL RIGHT, WELL, THAT'S
UNDERSTANDABLE.
I'M SCARED TOO.
WE CAN BE SCARED TOGETHER.
WELL, CAN WE TALK ABOUT IT IN
PERSON?
CAN WE MEET UP AND TALK ABOUT
IT?
ME TOO.
ME TOO.
I GUESS THEN, SEE YOU SOON.
>> OKAY.
>> GOOD JOB.
I THINK YOU HANDLED THAT
INCREDIBLY WELL.
>> THANK YOU.
>> YOU GOOD?
>> I THINK SO.
>> ALL COMES DOWN TO THIS.
>> YEAH, NO KIDDING.
>> * I SPENT MY TIME WATCHING
* THE SPACES THAT
* HAD GROWN BETWEEN US
* AND I CUT MY MIND
* ON SECOND BEST
* OR THE SCARS THAT COME
* WITH THE GREENNESS
* AND I GIVE MY EYES
* TO THE BOREDOM
* STILL THE SEABED
* WOULDN'T LET ME IN *
* AND I TRIED MY BEST
* TO EMBRACE THE DARKNESS
* IN WHICH I SWIM
>> THAT'S THE ONE.
LET'S GO.
>> JUST HANG HERE FOR A MINUTE.
>> RIGHT HERE?
>> YEAH, YES.
[knocks]
HI.
>> HI.
>> KRISTYN?
>> I'M KRISTYN, YEP.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU. NEV.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU TOO.
>> UH, COME--COME ON DOWNSTAIRS.
>> I'M SORRY.
>> THIS IS MIKE.
>> I'M REALLY SORRY.
I DON'T KNOW.
>> I DON'T KNOW EITHER.
>> I KNOW YOU'RE UPSET.
LIKE, I LIED.
>> YEAH, YOU DID.
>> BUT THERE'S A LOT I DIDN'T
LIE ABOUT.
>> OKAY, WELL, YOU LIED ABOUT
SOME PRETTY IMPORTANT THINGS.
>> ABOUT WHAT I LOOK LIKE AND MY
NAME.
>> YEAH.
THOSE ARE BOTH VERY IMPORTANT
THINGS.
>> YES, I UNDERSTAND,
I UNDERSTAND.
>> THAT WAS COMPLETELY BASED ON
A LIE, WHICH WAS WHY I WAS IN
THIS IN THE FIRST PLACE.
I ENDED RELATIONSHIPS IN THE
HOPES I WAS GONNA MEET YOU
AND YOU WERE GONNA BE WHO YOU
SAID YOU WERE.
I ENDED REAL RELATIONSHIPS, REAL
CONNECTIONS WITH REAL PEOPLE
OVER YOU.
THE THOUGHT THAT YOU WERE WHO
YOU WERE.
I FEEL STUPID JUST FOR BEING
STANDING HERE RIGHT NOW TO TELL
YOU THE TRUTH.
>> I WASN'T TRYING TO PLAY YOU.
THAT WASN'T MY INTENTION.
>> WHAT--WHAT WAS YOUR
INTENTION?
>> TO GET THROUGH EVERYTHING
I'VE BEEN THROUGH, BASICALLY.
>> SO YOU WERE JUST USING ME...
>> I WASN'T USING YOU. NO.
>> TO MAKE YOU FEEL BETTER ABOUT
YOURSELF?
>> IT WASN'T EVEN THAT.
I'VE BEEN THROUGH A LOT.
AND YOU'VE HELPED ME THROUGH
A LOT.
I DON'T WANNA CRY.
>> IF IT'S ALL RIGHT, I HAVE
A COUPLE SORT OF QUESTIONS.
>> GO AHEAD, YEAH.
YEAH, SURE.
>> I MEAN, UM...
>> THAT'S FINE WITH ME.
>> ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE
WERE VERY CURIOUS ABOUT WAS YOUR
ACCIDENT WHICH YOU ORIGINALLY
SAID, YOU KNOW, WAS A BIG PART
OF YOUR LIFE AND...
>> MM-HMM.
>> IS THAT SOMETHING THAT
HAPPENED OR?
>> THAT IS ALL TRUE.
I HAVE A FAKE LEFT EYE.
UM, AND HE TALKED ME THROUGH,
LIKE THE WHOLE THING.
>> AND WHEN DID YOU START
THE FAKE PROFILE?
>> LIKE, RIGHT AFTER.
SO RIGHT AFTER JULY 31, 2009.
I WAS AT A REALLY LOW POINT.
YOU KNOW, I WAS REALLY AT A LOW
POINT, AND I NEEDED A MASK.
AND THAT WAS MY MASK.
>> I GUESS I'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT
YOUR FEELINGS TOWARDS MIKE ARE.
>> I MEAN, ALL MY FEELINGS WERE
REAL.
HE THINKS IT ALL WAS A LIE AND
IT WASN'T ALL A LIE.
LIKE, YEAH, WHAT I LOOK LIKE WAS
A LIE AND THAT IS COMPLETELY
WRONG.
AND MY NAME WAS A LIE AND THAT
WAS COMPLETELY WRONG.
BUT THOSE, LIKE, WERE THE ONLY
THING I LIED ABOUT.
LIKE, EVERYTHING ELSE,
EVERYTHING I'VE BEEN THROUGH,
EVERYTHING WAS TRUE.
THE FEELINGS WERE TRUE.
AND THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU
DID.
I MEAN...
I WAS THAT GIRL SITTING THERE,
LIKE, ABOUT TO TAKE HER LIFE.
AND YOU WERE THE ONLY ONE THAT
STOPPED THAT.
THE ONLY ONE.
I WOULD CALL YOU AND I WAS
BAWLING MY EYES OUT AND YOU
TOLD ME I'D BE OKAY.
AND WE TALKED ABOUT MY EYE
A LOT.
>> YEAH.
>> AND YOU SAID IF SOMEBODY
JUDGED ME ON IT, IT WASN'T
RIGHT.
THE NIGHTS I COULDN'T SLEEP
BECAUSE I HAD NIGHTMARES OF ME
DYING IN CAR ACCIDENTS, YOU WERE
THE ONLY ONE THERE.
FRIENDS THAT I THOUGHT I HAD
WEREN'T.
>> I UNDERSTAND.
>> I NEVER USED TO BE THE FAT
GIRL.
I WAS THIS LITTLE SKINNY CHICK
THAT GOT WHAT SHE WANTED.
AND THEN I GOT IN MY ACCIDENT
AND EVERYTHING CHANGED.
EVERYTHING.
I WOULDN'T STILL BE HERE IF IT
WASN'T FOR YOU.
JUST BY TALKING TO ME.
>> I'M REALLY GLAD THAT I COULD
HELP YOU.
THAT DOES MEAN SOMETHING TO ME,
THAT I COULD HELP YOU.
I FEEL GOOD ABOUT THAT.
I DON'T--I DON'T HATE YOU, FOR
WHAT IT'S WORTH.
EVEN IF I DID, WHAT WOULD IT
MATTER ANYWAY?
BUT--
>> IT WOULD STILL MATTER.
>> YOU DIDN'T RUIN MY LIFE.
YOU KNOW, GOOD LUCK IN
EVERYTHING THAT YOU DO.
I-I REALLY MEAN THAT.
>> THANK YOU. YOU TOO.
>> I HOPE EVERYTHING--
I HOPE--HOPE STUFF TURNS AROUND
FOR YOU.
>> THIS WAS THE FIRST STEP,
I THINK.
GOOD NIGHT.
>> GOOD NIGHT, KRISTYN.
WHY DO YOU SAY THAT, BY THE WAY?
WHY DO YOU ALWAYS SAY GOOD NIGHT
INSTEAD OF GOOD-BYE?
>> GOOD-BYE MEANS FOREVER, AND I
CAN'T SAY IT TO ANYBODY.
>> OKAY.
>> EVER SINCE MY CAR ACCIDENT,
I DO NOT SAY GOOD-BYE.
IT MEANS FOREVER.
SEE YOU, KRISTYN.
>> SEE YA.
>> * SOON WE'LL BE *
* HERE ALONE
>> DOES THIS FEEL LIKE A BREAK
UP?
>> KIND OF.
I'M DISAPPOINTED.
LET DOWN.
>> YOU THINK YOU'D EVER BE OPEN
TO TALKING TO HER AGAIN?
>> WHY WOULD I--I'VE GOT NOTHING
ELSE TO SAY TO HER.
>> * OUT OF TIME
>> ARE YOU GUYS GONNA GO BACK
AND TALK TO HER?
>> WE MIGHT.
>> YOU'RE NOT GONNA GET ME TO GO
WITH YOU THOUGH, ARE YOU?
IF YOU WERE TO ASK ME, I
WOULD--I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
DECLINE THAT INVITATION.
>> ARE YOU DOING SOMETHING ON
CONTACTS?
>> YEAH, I'M DELETING HER.
>> * OH, THERE YOU WERE
>> ALL RIGHT, THAT'S IT.
WOW.
>> THAT'S ALL SHE WROTE.
>> IF ANYONE REALLY NEEDS SOME
KIND OF SUPPORT, IT'S KRISTYN.
>> SHE FEELS REALLY BAD AND
GUILTY.
>> THE BEST THING WE CAN DO IS,
LIKE, OFFER HER A REALLY SAFE
PLATFORM.
>> HI.
>> HEY.
>> YOU GUYS CAN COME IN.
>> COOL.
>> REALLY NICE, WOW.
>> SO YOU HAD THE ACCIDENT.
>> HOW DID YOUR LIFE CHANGE?
>> WELL, I GOT KICKED OUT OF
HIGH SCHOOL BECAUSE I WAS HAVING
TOO MANY SURGERIES.
I WAS MISSING TOO MUCH SCHOOL.
>> AND WHAT WOULD YOU DO ALL DAY
LONG?
>> SLEEP.
THEY HAD ME PRETTY DRUGGED UP,
THE DOCTORS DID.
>> SO YOU WERE ON A LOT OF MEDS?
>> YEAH, THOSE STEROIDS ARE NOT
YOUR FRIEND.
>> NO.
>> [laughs] THEY ARE NOT.
I FEEL LIKE THAT'S WHY I GAINED
ALL THE WEIGHT.
I GAINED ABOUT 130 POUNDS.
I HAD A BOYFRIEND WHO LEFT ME
THAT I HAD, LIKE, THOUGHT I HAD
A FUTURE WITH.
HE WAS ACTUALLY DRIVING THE CAR
WE WERE IN.
HE WAS FINE AFTER THE ACCIDENT
AND IT TOOK HIM TWO WEEKS TO
COME SEE ME.
AND HE TOLD ME TO HAVE FUN
LOOKING LIKE A PIRATE FOR THE
NEXT SIX MONTHS.
THAT WAS, LIKE, IT.
I WAS AT ROCK BOTTOM AND I
DIDN'T WANNA BE ON THIS WORLD
ANYMORE.
AND I FOUND MIKE AND...
ON ACCIDENT, REALLY.
HE HAD TALKED ME OUT OF IT, NOT
KNOWING HE TALKED ME OUT OF IT.
>> MIKE IS NOT KIND OF, UH, THE
WARMEST, CUDDLIEST GUY IN THE
WORLD.
>> BUT HE WAS...TOWARDS ME.
>> THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SORT OF
REALIZING.
>> HE USED TO TELL ME PRINCESS
STORIES TO GO TO BED.
ABOUT, LIKE, PRINCE MIKE--
[laughs]
AND PRINCESS KRISTYN IN A
CASTLE, YOU KNOW.
>> I THINK YOU'RE HEADING IN A
NEW, MUCH BETTER DIRECTION NOW.
AND I REALLY DON'T SEE ANY
REASON WHY ANYBODY WOULDN'T
ACCEPT YOU.
>> I'M REALLY TRYING TO MOVE
FORWARD AND GET BETTER.
EVEN, LIKE, I'M STARTING TO
BECOME MY GOOFY SELF AGAIN.
LIKE, BEING WACKY.
TAKING MY EYE OUT.
BEFORE I WOULD NEVER.
I WAS...SCARED.
BUT NOW I'M JUST LIKE, "HEY,
WANNA HOLD MY EYE?"
>> WHAT'S INVOLVED IN TAKING IT
OUT?
>> MY FINGER.
>> YOU JUST--YOU CAN JUST POP IT
OUT?
WAIT--
>> [laughs]
YEAH.
>> YOU DON'T NEED TO, LIKE,
RINSE OR SANITIZE?
>> NO, NO.
>> THERE'S REALLY ONLY ONE THING
LEFT TO DO.
>> ARE YOU READY.
DON'T SCREAM.
>> [chuckles]
UH, YES.
>> OKAY.
>> OH, MY GOD.
CAN I TOUCH IT?
>> YEAH.
>> YEAH.
>> BEAUTY IS IN THE EYE OF THE
BEHOLDER.
>> [laughs]
>> YOU ARE [indistinct].
>> WOW. HERE YOU GO.
>> ABOUT, UH--
>> AND THEN YOU JUST POP IT BACK
IN.
>> WELL, THANKS FOR LETTING US
HELP YOU TELL THE TRUTH, GIVING
MIKE AN OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE ON
IN HIS LIFE.
I THINK VERY CLEARLY FOR YOU TO
NOW MOVE ON IN YOUR OWN.
>> THANK YOU.
I GOT THIS.
LIKE, I CAN DO IT.
>> * HEARTACHE IS A COLD PLACE
>> THANK YOU FOR KIND OF
SHARING WITH US.
>> IT WAS A CRAZY STORY.
REAL LIFE STORY.
>> SORROW IS A FREEING SPACE *
* WHERE TEARS
* HAVE A GOOD TASTE
>> GOOD NIGHT.
>> TALK SOON.
>> [laughs]
>> AND NOW MORE
CATFISH: THE TV SHOW.
STICK AROUND.
>> HEY, MIKE.
>> I WOULDN'T MIND IF WE COULD
JUST COME OVER TO YOUR PLACE
AND CHAT FOR A MINUTE.
YEAH, I THINK THAT WOULD BE
PERFECT.
HOW YOU DOING?
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> MIKE.
>> NICE TO MEET YOU, MAX.
>> SO HOW WAS IT?
TELL ME WHAT HAPPENED, BRO?
I WANNA KNOW WHAT HAPPENED.
>> GIVE US SOME DETAILS, MAN.
>> YEAH, WELL, EVERYTHING BUT
HER, YEAH.
>> BUT YOU LIKED HER
PERSONALITY.
>> YEAH, YEAH.
BUT I ALSO THOUGHT THERE WAS A
DIFFERENT--THERE WAS A DIFFERENT
PERSON BEHIND THE PERSONALITY.
SHE CAME OUT, SHE LOOKED AT ME,
I LOOKED AT HER, AND SHE SAID
"I'M SORRY."
THAT WAS THE FIRST THING THAT
CAME OUT OF HER MOUTH.
SHE SHOWED REGRET AND REMORSE
FOR HER ACTIONS, AND I BELIEVED
HER.
>> WAS THE EYE THING TRUE OR
WHAT?
>> YEAH.
>> IT WAS?
>> I WAS SURPRISE THAT THE WHOLE
ACCIDENT WAS REAL AND THAT SHE
DOES HAVE A FAKE EYE.
THAT WAS CRAZY.
SHE LOST A LOT OF HER FRIENDS.
IT WAS SENIOR YEAR OF HIGH
SCHOOL.
>> SHE WAS HAVING A SERIOUS
RELATIONSHIP WITH THE GUY WHO
WAS DRIVING THE CAR.
THE GUY BROKE UP WITH HER.
>> YEAH.
>> SHE WAS NO LONGER POPULAR.
SHE'S HAD SOME REALLY BAD
BREAKS.
SHE MADE THIS FAKE PROFILE SO
SHE COULD KIND OF FEED HER
SELF ESTEEM A LITTLE BIT.
>> AND BASICALLY THAT'S WHAT I
DID, YEAH, FOR WHENEVER I WAS
TALKING TO HER.
I WAS JUST MAKING HER FEEL GOOD
ABOUT HERSELF AND THAT'S WHY SHE
KEPT, UH, YOU KNOW--SHE WANTED
ME AROUND.
YEAH, SHE WANTED ME AROUND
BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WHEN SHE HAD
A BAD DAY SHE'D CALL ME AND I'D
MAKE HER FEEL BETTER ABOUT IT.
SHE SAID IF IT WASN'T FOR ME
TALKING TO HER THAT IT WAS
LIKELY THAT SHE WOULD HAVE
KILLED HERSELF.
>> YOU MIGHT HONESTLY HAVE SAVED
HER LIFE, DUDE.
THINK OF IT LIKE THAT.
>> EXACTLY.
>> DON'T BE EMBARRASSED BY IT.
>> EVERYTHING THAT YOU DID WAS
THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
>> YOU WERE A GOOD GUY AND GAVE
HER THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT.
THERE'S NO REASON TO BE
EMBARRASSED ABOUT THAT.
>> THANKS, BRO.
>> THAT'S WHAT I'M TELLING HIM,
SEE?
>> YOU'RE RIGHT.
>> WHAT DO YOU FEEL?
>> I FEEL GOOD.
I FEEL--I FEEL GOOD, YEAH.
HONESTLY.
>> SOMETHING OFF YOUR SHOULDERS.
>> YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.
YEAH. NO, FOR REAL. YEAH.
>> YOU'RE A YOUNG GUY, GOT
A GOOD JOB.
>> YOU GOT YOUR--YOU GOT YOUR
LIFE ON TRACK.
>> YOU GOT YOUR LIFE, YOU KNOW
WHAT I MEAN?
>> YOU GONNA TALK TO HER STILL?
>> NO.
>> ARE YOU DONE?
>> I ALREADY DELETED THE
CONTACT, YEAH.
DELETED HER NUMBER.
I MEAN, I STILL KNOW IT BY
HEART, BUT I'M NOT GONNA--
[all laugh]
IT'S GONE. IT'S GONE.
IT'S GONE.
>> I THINK YOU'LL STILL CALL HER
AND TALK TO HER.
>> I HONESTLY FEEL LIKE TOO.
>> I THINK YOU WILL.
>> I FEEL LIKE I WILL TOO.
>> YOU'RE NOT JUST GONNA GO COLD
TURKEY AND NOT TALK TO THIS
GIRL.
>> YEAH, I KNOW, I KNOW.
I KNOW, I KNOW.
YEAH.
>> WELL, LISTEN, FELLAS.
HE'S GONNA GO THROUGH SOME WEIRD
THINGS OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF
DAYS.
IT'S GONNA SUCK FOR A LITTLE
BIT, YOU KNOW?
YEAH.
>> YEAH.
>> ALL RIGHT, SO WE'RE GONNA GET
OUT OF HERE.
HEAD BACK.
>> ALL RIGHT, YOU GUYS TAKE IT
EASY.
>> ENJOY YOURSELVES.
>> GENTLEMEN.
>> TAKE IT EASY.
>> ALL RIGHT, MAX.
>> DON'T GET UP, DON'T GET UP.
I'M PROUD OF YOU, MIKE.
YOU HANDLED YOUR BUSINESS LIKE
A GENTLEMAN.
SO THANKS FOR THAT.
>> YOU'RE WELCOME.
>> LATER, FELLAS.
>> TAKE IT EASY.
>> HEY.
>> OH.
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> I'M DOING PRETTY WELL, MAN.
NO MORE MYSTERY ANYMORE SO IT'S
GOOD, MAN.
>> SO ARE YOU AND KRISTYN ON
PRETTY GOOD TERMS THEN, I GUESS?
>> YEAH, WE'RE ON--WE'RE ON GOOD
TERMS.
I MEAN WE'VE TALKED A FEW TIMES.
I TOLD HER, YOU KNOW, SHE
CAN--SHE STILL HAS MY NUMBER.
SHE, YOU KNOW--SHE CAN STILL
TEXT ME, CALL ME, WHENEVER.
BUT, YOU KNOW, YOU TALK TO
SOMEBODY FOR THAT LONG YOU STILL
WANNA TIE UP A FEW LOOSE ENDS
OR WHATEVER AND THAT'S PRETTY
MUCH WHAT WE'VE DONE.
>> SO WHAT'S GOING ON WITH YOU
ON THE GIRL FRONT?
>> I DON'T HAVE A GIRLFRIEND,
BUT, YOU KNOW, I'M OUT THERE
STILL DANGLING MY, UH--DANGLING
MY BAIT OUT THERE SO TO SPEAK.
BUT, UH, I'VE HAD A FEW NIBBLES,
I'VE HAD A FEW NIBBLES.
BUT, UH, WE'LL SEE, WE'LL SEE.
I HAVEN'T FOUND THE ONE YET.
>> I'M SURE SOMETHING GOOD WILL
COME OUT OF THIS FOR YOU.
>> YEAH, I THINK SO TOO.
>> WELL, IT WAS GOOD TALKING TO
YOU.
>> ALWAYS, MAN.
GOOD TO SEE YOU GUYS AGAIN.
>> ALL RIGHT, DUDE.
TAKE IT EASY.
>> LATER.
>> LATER.
HEY, KRISTYN.
>> HOW YOU DOING?
>> HI.
>> HOW IS EVERYTHING?
>> EVERYTHING'S GOOD.
UM, I'M DATING NOW.
I HAVE A BOYFRIEND.
>> WHAT?
>> THAT WAS FAST.
>> YEAH.
HE'S GONNA MOVE WITH ME TOO.
>> WOW.
>> WOW.
>> YEAH.
>> MY FAMILY IS GONNA BE
BUYING A SALON.
>> THAT'S INCREDIBLE.
>> I KNOW.
IT'S EXCITING.
I'M READY TO START MY LIFE.
>> ALL RIGHT, KRISTYN.
AWESOME TALKING TO YOU,
AND, UH, YEAH, WE'LL TALK SOON.
>> OKAY.
>> BYE, KRISTYN.
>> BYE.
>> GOOD NIGHT.
>> WHY DO YOU LIKE THIS GUY SO
MUCH?
>> HE'S JUST SO SWEET AND
GENUINE.
>> BUT YOU'RE REALLY SUSPICIOUS
THERE'S SOMETHING BIG THAT YOU
DON'T KNOW.
>> YEAH AND IT SCARES ME.
>> WAIT, WHAT'S THIS.
>> THAT'S A MUG SHOT.
POSSESSION OF A WEAPON OF MASS
DESTRUCTION?
>> WHOA.
>> I'M SCARED.
1582
00:40:57.