One Of Us Is Lying (2021–…): Season 2, Episode 3 - Simon Says Let's Get Personal - full transcript
The job's easy enough.
Might not be as lucrative
as selling drugs,
but at least you won't
get arrested, huh?
- Right.
- Unless those murder
charges come back.
- Which they won't.
Because Jake did it.
- I remember when
you thought I did it.
- Whatever, TJ.
- Table ten could
use some water.
Why don't you go take
care of that me, huh?
- So that's why we're
here? Stalking Nate?
- No. You wanna
know why we're here?
Because as soon as
his shift is over,
we're gonna go out to your boat
and clean out the freezer.
- Are you insane?
- The Riordans put
out a cash reward,
Addy's outburst drew a
lot of unwanted attention,
and Wheeler has the watch, okay?
It's only a matter of time
before the police know Jake...
Isn't in Mexico.
- Bronwyn, I know
that you like to think
that you're smarter
than everyone,
but maybe take a look around.
There's people everywhere.
There's bars, there's
clubs, there's restaurants.
People are down
on the promenade,
people are on the other boats.
- Okay, at night?
- Especially at night.
Plus this asshole.
We
have to say something.
- No. Be cool.
- Yes, we do.
You're Jake's brother, right?
- We can save time
and cut the bullshit.
I know you're friends with Addy.
So I assume you knew she was
gonna pull that little stunt
at Vanessa's rally.
- We don't know anything
about anything, really.
- Mm. Let me fill you in.
My family's been through enough.
You're either with us
or you're against us,
and you made your choice.
So I just hope you're ready
to live with the consequences.
- Coach Kilton, please
report to the AV lab.
Your reactions
from the Tom Prestin interview
are so positive.
There's GIFs.
Look, you're a GIF.
- Yeah, but there's
also comments
about me wearing the watch.
- Only a few.
The watch story is getting
buried by Addy's freakout.
- Really?
- Yeah. She's a GIF, too.
Though not the kind I
wanna tell her about.
- Damn.
- Um, Coop?
- Coop.
- Yeah?
- Why didn't you tell me
that it was Jake's watch?
- Oh, um...
I guess I thought that you
might think it was weird.
- Well, it's kind...
- Like...
I know I'm not
supposed to miss Jake,
because of what he did, but
Jake was my friend, okay?
It's... it's almost
like there are
two versions of him in my mind.
- I don't think that's weird.
I know exactly what you mean.
- Not to objectify you, but
you look really hot today.
- Don't be weird.
- Weird?
Would it be weird if I
kissed you right now?
So that's a yes?
- It's just like, if
people see you with me,
then they're gonna think...
- What?
That I'm massively into you?
Good.
- Oh, wow.
Okay, what do you think
Simon would hate more?
That you're, like, besties
with the people he despised?
Or you're hooking up with
the girl that he liked?
Wow.
Just a little food for thought.
- So you guys got
different messages?
- "Simon Says skip your
math midterm today."
- "Kiss your tutor
at lunch tomorrow."
- And the rest of
us got nothing.
- Right.
- Guys, it doesn't make sense.
Simon Says knows what we did.
Why would they want
us to kiss someone?
- They want you to kiss someone.
- Look, I know it may
seem random, right?
But think about the watch.
One second I'm wearing it
to school, no big deal.
Next thing I know,
the cops have it.
- Nothing's random.
- No.
They're getting personal.
Trying to hit us
where it hurts most.
- By making you
skip a math test?
- Midterm.
- And make Nate kiss Fiona?
I mean, is that really
gonna torture you?
- Maybe this one's
aimed at Bronwyn, too.
- Why would I care?
- I think this kind of petty
torture screams Vanessa.
- Guys, what about Cole?
- But why would he care
if I skip a midterm,
or who Nate kisses?
- If both of these are aimed
at Bronwyn, what if it's Evan?
No, no.
He's the least dangerous
person I've ever met.
- Well, he is nerdy
enough to consider
skipping a math test torture.
- Whoever it is, they'll
be watching, right?
- Evan is in my calculus class,
so I guess he would
see if I skip.
- Okay.
So we see if Evan's in
the cafeteria tomorrow
watching for Nate to...
kiss Fiona.
- So we're actually doing these?
- Looks like it.
- You coming?
- Um...
no, I'm not.
- Are you sure you're
okay with this?
- We don't have a choice,
and my Yale application's
already in, so...
- No, no, I meant with mine.
- Oh, um... Well, it's
not optional, so...
And we're not together, right?
So you can kiss who you want.
- Right.
Yeah, we're not.
Yeah.
- Do you really think
Evan could be Simon Says?
- I mean, he has motive
to hurt Bronwyn and Nate
and he's really smart, so...
- Yeah, but what
about hurting us?
- Well, we didn't get asks.
- Maybe they're still coming.
- Okay. Don't love that take.
But I guess our lives can't
really get much worse.
- Um, your life has been
pretty great lately.
In some ways.
- In the "non-blackmail,
non-murder" ways?
Yes.
And, you know,
in the Maeve ways.
- Yeah.
I don't really see what
she sees in me, but...
- Are you kidding?
Janae, do you need a list?
'Cause I can give you a list.
- Please don't.
- Okay, well, now I have to.
First, you are the most
take-no-bullshit person
I have ever met, which
is incredibly sexy.
Second, you have this
weird dry sense of humor.
And maybe I'm not supposed to
say this, because feminism,
but you are so pretty
and I really feel like...
- Okay, you...
Stop.
- Sorry.
Should I have not
have said that?
- No.
Or...
I don't know.
"Pretty" just feels...
weird.
- But you are. You're
so pretty, Janae.
- Just feels really gendered.
- What does that mean, for you?
- It means that sometimes...
I feel like a girl
and sometimes I don't.
And then sometimes I feel like
a boy and sometimes I don't.
And then sometimes I
wish that gender...
didn't exist.
You know?
Yeah, totally.
That makes sense for you.
- Really?
- Yeah.
I can't
believe I'm saying this
out loud to Addy Prentiss.
- Hey!
- And it's going well.
It's going so well.
But what about Maeve?
- Yeah, I haven't told her,
but I'm gonna tell her.
Just not yet.
Are you sure? 'Cause...
- Mm-hmm.
- Oh, my God,
Vanessa's going live.
We don't have to watch this.
We can keep talking about...
- Oh, about me?
Absolutely not.
No, thank you.
Oh, God.
- Today, I am here with a guest
who's going to change everything
you thought you knew
about this case.
- What is she doing?
- Army, meet Giselle.
- Thanks, Vanessa.
- Oh, no, thank you, girl,
for coming forward.
Why don't you tell
everyone about yourself?
- Well, I'm a senior,
like you, from Slo,
and I guess I'm here
because I'm pissed off.
- Mmm, girl, say more.
- I saw your Justice
for Jake rally
and what Addy said about Jake...
- Mmm, yeah, that mess.
That pissed a lot of people off.
- I'm so sick of hearing
people talk about Jake
like he was this
evil mastermind.
That's not the person I knew.
- And how did you know Jake?
- We met over the
summer in Greece,
and we fell in love.
Addy?
- But Jake was still with Addy?
- Yes, he wanted to
end things with Addy
but he was scared of
her and her new friends,
scared of what they
were capable of.
And then he disappeared.
- The police say he's in Mexico.
Do you believe that?
- No, he wouldn't just
vanish on me like this
without telling me.
I'm afraid the
worst has happened
and that's why I'm here.
To help you find the truth.
- And we will find
the truth, together.
And we will get our
#JusticeForJake.
Thank you, Giselle.
Thanks.
- I knew I forgot to
tell you something.
Oops.
- The police say he's in Mexico.
Do you believe that?
- No, he wouldn't
just vanish on me
like this without telling me.
- Oh, yeah.
- I'm afraid the
worst has happened.
- Everyone definitely
thinks I'm dead.
Pretty soon, they're gonna
wonder who killed me.
- To help you find the truth.
- Gosh.
Who would they look at
first?
- And we will find the truth.
- Addy, you need to
stop watching it.
Besides, what do we really
know about this chick, anyway?
She could be making it all up,
looking for her 15 minutes.
- Eh, she's not making it up.
Just look at her.
She could give me
everything you couldn't.
- No wonder he cheated.
Look at her.
- That sounds like Jake talking.
Not you.
You are every bit as
hot when you wanna be.
I know this playbook
all too well, baby.
Shitty men make themselves
feel less shitty
by shitting on amazing women.
Their voices get in your head.
- How do I not hear that voice?
- Look, sometimes you can't
block it out completely,
but you can make
your voice louder.
And I know you can be, like...
loud as hell.
Plus, if what she's
saying is true,
then you're not the cheater.
If Jake cheated first,
you didn't do anything wrong.
- Hmm.
Yeah.
Yeah, I like that take.
What the hell?
- Coop. Hey.
- Hey.
- Have you seen Addy?
- Sadly, I doubt
she'll come to school.
She'll wanna avoid
the attention.
- Or maybe not.
- Whoa.
- Okay, this is a choice.
- And not a good one.
It looks like she's
saying Jake's dead.
- It was a Simon Says ask.
Obviously not my idea.
- Oh, my God.
- Move along.
- The worst part
is that everyone's
just gonna think I'm
upset about Giselle.
- And you're not?
- I mean, kind of.
But also it's good news.
'Cause if it's true and
Jake did cheat on me,
then TJ and I didn't
really do anything wrong.
- That is an
interesting reframe.
- I just need to talk to her,
find out when it happened.
- Wait, Addy, hold on.
Does any of this make sense?
- Yeah. Because if
Jake cheated first,
then I'm in the clear.
- No, no.
I mean about Giselle.
She shows up here, she says
she's Jake's true love,
and that she thinks he's dead.
What if Simon Says
put her up to this?
- If the goal was
to torture us...
- Giselle could be
part of the plan.
- Even more reason I
need to talk to her.
We need to find
out if she's legit.
Vanessa, I need you to
introduce me to Giselle.
I have to find out
if she's for real.
- Okay, Addy, I'm
sorry Jake cheated,
but you're just
gonna have to deal.
- Just give me her number or
tell me where I can find her.
- Why? So you can stalk her?
- Please?
We used to be friends.
- What do I get if
I introduce you?
- What do you get?
How's this?
You introduce us,
and I won't fucking kill you.
- Wow.
You really are psycho.
But at least you give
me great material.
So, yeah, sure.
I'll text you!
- Are you sure you
wanna be here for this?
- Yes, I'm fine.
Seriously.
It's not like it has
anything to do with
what's going on
with me and Nate.
- Right. Which is?
- Not the point.
We should really be
looking for Simon Says.
- Which we still think is Evan?
- Yeah.
- Is this like a kink of his?
Did Evan have a thing
for Jackie Kennedy?
- Is that who I am?
- Addy, yes.
- Has anyone actually seen Evan?
- Oh, yeah.
- What?
- That's weird.
- That's very weird.
- What if they're
working together?
- Evanessa.
- Huh. He's the brains,
and she's the bitch.
- Shh.
- Nate. Hey.
- Just go with me on this.
- What?
- Watch your back,
Nate. She's crazy!
- Nate, is this
some kind of joke?
Why would you...
- I'm sorry.
- Oh, my God!
Oh, my God. Oh, my
God. Oh, my God.
- Okay, but what was weirder?
Nate kissing Fiona or
Vanessa kissing Evan?
- Neither.
Both.
I don't know.
- Yep, those are all
the possible answers.
You're definitely fine.
- Maybe I was wrong
about Evan the whole time
'cause he's definitely
not the person
I thought he was if he's
hooking up with her.
I've always been better
than him at debate,
so I am gonna trip him up,
get him to confess to something.
- What, that he's Simon Says
or that he's hooking
up with Vanessa?
- Well, it's the
same thing, isn't it?
- Simon Says I need to
post to all of my followers
that I got a text from Jake.
That he's in Mexico and
he doesn't wanna be found.
- Whoa, what?
- If I do this, the
cops and Jake's family
is gonna want to proof.
I've got potential
sponsors keeping tabs
on my social media,
and something...
Something like this
could ruin everything.
- Okay, we'll figure it out.
- "Figure it out"? How?
This is my life. This
is my family's future.
It's not some stupid math test.
- Okay,
it was a midterm and
I can't retake it.
- Are you being serious?
- School is my sport!
- Okay.
I feel like you're not really
reading the room here, um...
What if I sent you a text
so that you have something
to show when people ask?
I could use a VPN and make it
look like it came from Mexico.
- Is that something you can do?
- Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Thank you.
- Hey.
- Hey.
- You okay?
- Fine.
- We talked about this.
You told me to go
through with the kiss.
- Yeah, and you, like,
really kissed her.
Went above and
beyond. Good job.
- I don't know what you
want from me, Rojas.
- Figure it out, Macauley.
Here's a debate topic for you:
is torture ever justified?
- What?
Today's topic is
whether climate change
is the greatest threat
facing humanity today.
- It is. Debate over. Now
let's talk about mine.
Is torture ever justified?
Yes or no?
- That's not really how
debate works, Bronwyn.
But if you're at all
confused about it,
maybe you shouldn't join us
for regionals next month.
- Are you enjoying this?
Is this what you get off on?
- Seeing you
spiral? Not exactly.
- Or is it for the attention?
Because if there's one
thing you know about me,
and you don't,
it's I desperately need to
be the center of attention.
- Yeah, maybe not you,
but your girlfriend
certainly does.
- My what?
- Yeah, I saw you
making out with
Vanessa at lunchtime.
Keep
your voice down!
- Where were you
on Halloween night?
- Of course you don't remember.
I was at the Fright Night
movie marathon at the Ritz,
the one that I'd
bought us tickets to,
when we were dating.
I don't know who you
think I am, Bronwyn,
but I finally see you
for who you really are,
and it sucks.
- Hey, G. Um, so this is Addy.
- If you have a confession,
take it to the police.
I didn't hurt him.
- Then you drove
him out of town.
He wouldn't just disappear on
me like this without a word.
- Does that sound like Jake?
Running scared of
me, of all people?
Can we have a few
minutes to talk?
Please?
- We're good, Vanessa.
- Okay.
- I think Evan's telling
the truth about Halloween.
The screening was
at midnight in L.A.,
so he couldn't have
made it there and back
in time to be in the woods.
- Great, so we're
back to square one.
Maybe Addy can find
out Giselle's lying.
Maybe she is a Simon Says plant.
God.
I don't know how she can do this
and I couldn't even sit
through Nate kissing Fiona
for his stupid Simon Says ask.
- Oh, my God.
She is human.
- Ha ha.
- Seriously, it would've
messed with anyone.
- Right? I thought he was
actually gonna, I don't know,
give her, like, a peck.
- I don't think Nate Macauley
knows what a peck is.
I should have seen it
coming though because
I know I was never
gonna be enough for him.
- I'm sorry, what?
Bronwyn Rojas thinks that
Nate Macauley is too good?
Oh, my God! I can't!
- So, what do you want?
- I just want to know
what really happened.
- You think I'm lying?
Do I have to tell you about
the scar on his inner thigh,
how he sounds when he comes?
I don't owe you anything.
- Giselle, I just...
I just want to know
when it started.
When he was with you, he was
sending me these pictures.
I feel so stupid, I just need
to stop torturing myself.
I just need you to
tell me the full truth.
- I took this one.
I loved that photo.
He looks so...
- Goofy.
- Yeah. Exactly.
- It was the second
day of the trip.
Athens.
I couldn't stop looking at him.
And he looked up and saw me,
and it was lightning.
- Two days?
Weeks before me and TJ.
- I didn't plan it, okay?
Even after we got
back to California
and things were
still complicated...
it felt worth it.
I told you what
you wanted to know.
You tell me what I wanna know.
Is he dead?
- You know Jake.
If he wants
something, he gets it.
If he wanted to disappear,
make sure no one can find him,
he could.
Thanks, Giselle.
- She's nothing like me.
But maybe Jake's nothing
like I thought he was either,
so it makes sense.
- You really think
she's telling the truth?
- Simon Says is good.
She could be part of the set up.
- No.
No, she said stuff that
you would only know
if you really knew Jake, so...
Oh, ew!
- I'm so sorry. That
must've been so shitty.
- It was.
Also, it wasn't.
I know this isn't the best
thing to admit, but...
there's always been this
small part of me that thought
maybe this is all my fault.
I thought I'd cheated on Jake
and it turned then
into this monster.
And he took it out on all of us.
And Simon.
- That's fucked up.
- And you know it's not true.
- No, I know. Logically.
It's hard to shake
the feeling sometimes.
Jake really fucked me up.
It's taken me a long time
to be able to say that.
I'm okay.
Oh, fuck.
Cooper's going live.
- Hey, guys.
Coop here.
Look, I know I'm usually on
here talking about workouts
and fastballs and, I don't know,
my pick to win the
World Series, but...
today I wanna talk
about something else.
- I can't believe he's
actually doing this.
- I received a text
from Jake Riordan today.
And he informed that
he was in Mexico
and that he doesn't
wanna be found.
But I want his family and the
police to know he's out there.
If anybody has heard
anything from him,
or anybody has seen him
or knows any information,
please, please come forward.
- This is so fucked up.
- Be a good teammate,
look out for each other,
take care of your friends,
and never lose hope.
- Whoever Simon Says is,
they're getting more
and more twisted.
- Janae's the only one left.
- Do you think it'll get worse?
- Are you not worried?
- No, I... or, I guess
not. This... sort of.
I don't know.
- Those are all the
possible answers.
- Janae?
- What?
- Why are you being weird?
- I got mine.
But you can save your breath
because I'm not gonna do it.
- What do you...
What do you mean?
What was it?
- Simon Says wants me to
graffiti someone's grave,
so obviously I'm
just gonna, like,
deal with the
consequences of that
because I am never doing that.
- I'm so sorry, Janae.
But the consequences
are we all go to jail.
All of our lives are over.
So you'll have to do this
because we all did ours.
- We're all in this
together, Janae.
- We're your friends.
- No.
If you were my friend,
you would never
ask me to do that.
Janae...
- You haven't been fired yet.
I guess Victor hasn't
heard about you
and his daughter, huh?
- Do you want to
do the tasting menu
or do you wanna do à la carte?
- You know, it seems
like you have a type.
Smart, hot,
way too good for you.
- Fuck off, TJ.
Bronwyn.
I really wish I was surprised.
- I... I don't want
you to have to do this,
but I just knew Simon
Says was gonna check
to make sure it got
done, so, um, yeah.
I'm sorry for how
I reacted earlier.
"Beloved son and
friend to all."
- I mean, not how
I'd describe him.
I guess I'm not the
best judge, right?
- You were his best friend.
- Yeah.
Yeah, I was.
I was best friends with the guy
who planned this insane prank
gone wrong and who
cared more about
fucking over the people he
hated than staying alive.
It's like I didn't
really know him.
And it feels like he's
dying all over again.
- I didn't know him as well as
you did, but I do one thing.
I think that he'd
find this hilarious.
You and me,
hanging out, working together,
cuddling in a graveyard.
- I think he'd fucking hate it.
- Okay, but imagine how
much it's gonna cost
his parents to clean this up.
I think he'd be on
board for that alone.
Yeah.
You're right on that one.
His mom is gonna freak out.
And he would love that.
I'm gonna need some help.
It, um... it could be
something meaningful,
like a tribute almost.
- It's supposed to be a dick.
Okay.
Um...
- Hey! What's going
on over there?
- Shit! Go.
- The graveyard is closed!
- Um...
- Go! Run!
- No, we both go.
- Bronwyn, it's my
ass, I've got it.
- Okay.
- You, there!
- Hello, good evening,
uh, sir. Officer.
- This your work?
- Can I plead the fifth?
- You had enough fun for
one day, don't you think?
- I'm here to
apologize about that.
- I'd really rather not
keep talking about it, Nate.
- Look, Fiona, I...
I feel horrible.
I didn't... I didn't mean
to embarrass you, okay?
You've been super good to me.
- Who put you up to it?
It was a prank, right?
Some John Hughes movie dare?
I hate this school.
It was supposed to
be my fresh start,
but that was ruined on day one.
I was just gonna keep my
head down till graduation.
- Look, Fiona.
I get it, okay?
I'm so sorry.
- I feel so stupid.
I thought we were friends.
- We are.
- I even kinda liked you.
- I even kinda liked
you too, Jennings.
- Past tense?
- Well, I'm...
- Now we're even.
- Can I...
- Yes.
- Coop.
Hey. What's this video?
Did Jake text you?
Is this for real?
Listen, you hear from that
kid, you come tell me.
You don't go broadcasting it
for the whole world like that,
calling him your teammate.
What were you thinking?
- I was thinking
that maybe someone else
has heard from him.
Or maybe that it'll help
the cops find him, or...
- Or maybe it'll make
you look like you're
trying to help a fugitive.
- Dad, it doesn't
have to be a big deal.
- Boy, you know
better than that.
You know everything we built
can disappear in a second.
Use your...
Get it.
Go on.
- Cooper. How you doing?
Saw your post about
hearing from Jake,
and I would love to
look at your phone.
- Go away. He doesn't
have to give you anything.
We're not involved
in any of this.
- Actually, your
son claims that he
heard from Jake in Mexico,
so extremely involved.
And I've got a warrant.
The Riordans were only too
happy to use their connections
to get us in front
of a judge quickly
and get that signed off, so...
- Go ahead.
Give it to her. Go on.
- This could help us
find a killer on the run.
You're
not in trouble.
- I'm sorry, can I read
that? That could be, like,
school or it could be
practice or it could be...
- Actually, no.
We can't have you delete
anything that might be useful.
- I thought you said
he wasn't in trouble.
- I'm gonna take this
down to the station
and I'm gonna use it to
look for the true origin
of that text.
I'll get it back to you
as soon as possible.
- So my Simon Says ask was
to deface Simon's grave.
- Which I did.
- What?
- Yeah.
And then I got caught by a very
enthusiastic and self-serious
guard person at the cemetery
who notified Simon's parents
as well as my parents about
my artistic expressions.
And, well, the upshot
is that my dad's
coming home from Paris early.
- What? When?
- Mmm, he's getting on
a plane pretty soon,
so he'll be home
late tomorrow night
so the dead body on
his boat's gotta go!
- Do you not remember what
happened last time, Janae?
It's too busy on the water.
There's too many
people to see us.
- Once my dad gets
back, there will be
no more chances to
take the boat out,
so it's gonna have to be tonight
and we're gonna have to risk it.
- We're gonna need Cooper.
Where is he?
- We'll meet at the
dock by midnight.
Can we find Cooper?
Okay, it's after
midnight. We have to go.
- Addy and Cooper are not here.
- We don't have time
to wait, Bronwyn.
We have to be back by
the time the sun is up.
- Okay.
- Hey, I see them.
Wait, guys. Wait.
Come on, hurry up!
- Let's fuckin' go!
- Let's go!
- You good?
- We're good.
- Let's go. Go, go, go.
- How could you make
this plan without me?
- Cooper, we couldn't
get a hold of you.
- Because the cops
have my phone.
- What?
- Detective Wheeler took
my phone into evidence
to see where the text
really came from.
To find out where
Jake really is.
- We texted you
where to meet us.
- Wait, so Wheeler
knows we're out here.
- Guys, we have to
go back to the dock.
- No. No.
- Please.
- We have to see this through.
- The cops could
be waiting for us
by the time we get back there.
- Well, good thing that
we won't have a dead body
on the boat!
- How could you guys
drag me back into this?
Addy, why didn't
you come find me?
I'd be better of dealing
with this shit on my own.
- Then do it.
Start tomorrow.
- Is this the spot?
- Yeah.
Let's go.
- Can I have a second
alone with him?
- Are you sure?
- Yeah.
- The code for the lock
is 3241.
- Hey.
- Hey.
I saw your texts.
Sorry I didn't get back to you.
Kind of did what you would
call a very Bronwyn thing
and tried doing Janae's
Simon Says ask for her.
Turned into this whole thing.
I hated seeing you kiss her.
I know I said I didn't care,
but it made me crazy.
You make me crazy.
And I know I told
you to figure it out,
but if you haven't already,
what I want...
is to be the only girl you kiss.
- We have really bad
timing, don't we?
- You mean pouring my heart
out on a boat with a dead body
isn't the best timing?
I love you.
- Look what you've done.
- What I've done?
I built my whole
world around you.
And you were a lie.
You never loved me.
You loved controlling me.
- And you had no part in that?
You never had a thought
of you own, Addy.
Always waiting around for
me to tell you what to do.
- I knew something was off
when you were in Greece.
I knew in my gut that you
were with someone else,
but I didn't know how to
listen to my own instincts.
- And whose fault is that?
- All you ever did was lie.
And I got so used to
listening to your story
that I didn't know
how to hear my own.
I'm not sorry that I shot you.
But I am sorry
that you're dead...
'cause I would've loved to
see the look on your face
when I become the person
I'm meant to be without you.
- Guys.
You okay?
Yeah, I will be.
- Kind of wish we had
something to burn.
As, like, a ritual.
Like, cleansing.
- Yeah.
- Cleansing sounds right.
Maybe I should delete
all of Jake's pictures.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
Giselle
took this one.
Can you believe that?
He was sending me
pictures that she took.
- Wait.
Addy, this isn't Greece.
- What? Yes, it is.
He sent it to me from that
trip and Giselle recognized it.
- No, I recognize this site.
It was a final question in
last year's academic decathlon.
This is the Second
Temple of Hera.
It's in Italy.
- Are you sure?
- Yes.
- This is also Photoshopped.
Do you see how his
shadow doesn't match
the buildings in the back?
Someone constructed this image.
- But if Jake was
never in Greece...
- Then Giselle was lying.
- Why would he lie to
me about being there?
- And why would Giselle
prop up the same lie?
- I don't know. None
of it makes any sense.
- Unless... unless
Giselle is Simon Says.
She's obsessed with
Jake, wants revenge...
- And she starts toying
with us from a distance
but then she wants to escalate,
so she comes into town
and steps up the torture.
- And manipulates us
into moving the body.
- Which we do as the cops are
going through Cooper's phone.
- Is that possible?
That Giselle set us up?
- If we go back to shore
and the cops are there...
Then we'll know.
- Oh, shit.
You ready?
- It's over.
- I think it's just
getting started.
Might not be as lucrative
as selling drugs,
but at least you won't
get arrested, huh?
- Right.
- Unless those murder
charges come back.
- Which they won't.
Because Jake did it.
- I remember when
you thought I did it.
- Whatever, TJ.
- Table ten could
use some water.
Why don't you go take
care of that me, huh?
- So that's why we're
here? Stalking Nate?
- No. You wanna
know why we're here?
Because as soon as
his shift is over,
we're gonna go out to your boat
and clean out the freezer.
- Are you insane?
- The Riordans put
out a cash reward,
Addy's outburst drew a
lot of unwanted attention,
and Wheeler has the watch, okay?
It's only a matter of time
before the police know Jake...
Isn't in Mexico.
- Bronwyn, I know
that you like to think
that you're smarter
than everyone,
but maybe take a look around.
There's people everywhere.
There's bars, there's
clubs, there's restaurants.
People are down
on the promenade,
people are on the other boats.
- Okay, at night?
- Especially at night.
Plus this asshole.
We
have to say something.
- No. Be cool.
- Yes, we do.
You're Jake's brother, right?
- We can save time
and cut the bullshit.
I know you're friends with Addy.
So I assume you knew she was
gonna pull that little stunt
at Vanessa's rally.
- We don't know anything
about anything, really.
- Mm. Let me fill you in.
My family's been through enough.
You're either with us
or you're against us,
and you made your choice.
So I just hope you're ready
to live with the consequences.
- Coach Kilton, please
report to the AV lab.
Your reactions
from the Tom Prestin interview
are so positive.
There's GIFs.
Look, you're a GIF.
- Yeah, but there's
also comments
about me wearing the watch.
- Only a few.
The watch story is getting
buried by Addy's freakout.
- Really?
- Yeah. She's a GIF, too.
Though not the kind I
wanna tell her about.
- Damn.
- Um, Coop?
- Coop.
- Yeah?
- Why didn't you tell me
that it was Jake's watch?
- Oh, um...
I guess I thought that you
might think it was weird.
- Well, it's kind...
- Like...
I know I'm not
supposed to miss Jake,
because of what he did, but
Jake was my friend, okay?
It's... it's almost
like there are
two versions of him in my mind.
- I don't think that's weird.
I know exactly what you mean.
- Not to objectify you, but
you look really hot today.
- Don't be weird.
- Weird?
Would it be weird if I
kissed you right now?
So that's a yes?
- It's just like, if
people see you with me,
then they're gonna think...
- What?
That I'm massively into you?
Good.
- Oh, wow.
Okay, what do you think
Simon would hate more?
That you're, like, besties
with the people he despised?
Or you're hooking up with
the girl that he liked?
Wow.
Just a little food for thought.
- So you guys got
different messages?
- "Simon Says skip your
math midterm today."
- "Kiss your tutor
at lunch tomorrow."
- And the rest of
us got nothing.
- Right.
- Guys, it doesn't make sense.
Simon Says knows what we did.
Why would they want
us to kiss someone?
- They want you to kiss someone.
- Look, I know it may
seem random, right?
But think about the watch.
One second I'm wearing it
to school, no big deal.
Next thing I know,
the cops have it.
- Nothing's random.
- No.
They're getting personal.
Trying to hit us
where it hurts most.
- By making you
skip a math test?
- Midterm.
- And make Nate kiss Fiona?
I mean, is that really
gonna torture you?
- Maybe this one's
aimed at Bronwyn, too.
- Why would I care?
- I think this kind of petty
torture screams Vanessa.
- Guys, what about Cole?
- But why would he care
if I skip a midterm,
or who Nate kisses?
- If both of these are aimed
at Bronwyn, what if it's Evan?
No, no.
He's the least dangerous
person I've ever met.
- Well, he is nerdy
enough to consider
skipping a math test torture.
- Whoever it is, they'll
be watching, right?
- Evan is in my calculus class,
so I guess he would
see if I skip.
- Okay.
So we see if Evan's in
the cafeteria tomorrow
watching for Nate to...
kiss Fiona.
- So we're actually doing these?
- Looks like it.
- You coming?
- Um...
no, I'm not.
- Are you sure you're
okay with this?
- We don't have a choice,
and my Yale application's
already in, so...
- No, no, I meant with mine.
- Oh, um... Well, it's
not optional, so...
And we're not together, right?
So you can kiss who you want.
- Right.
Yeah, we're not.
Yeah.
- Do you really think
Evan could be Simon Says?
- I mean, he has motive
to hurt Bronwyn and Nate
and he's really smart, so...
- Yeah, but what
about hurting us?
- Well, we didn't get asks.
- Maybe they're still coming.
- Okay. Don't love that take.
But I guess our lives can't
really get much worse.
- Um, your life has been
pretty great lately.
In some ways.
- In the "non-blackmail,
non-murder" ways?
Yes.
And, you know,
in the Maeve ways.
- Yeah.
I don't really see what
she sees in me, but...
- Are you kidding?
Janae, do you need a list?
'Cause I can give you a list.
- Please don't.
- Okay, well, now I have to.
First, you are the most
take-no-bullshit person
I have ever met, which
is incredibly sexy.
Second, you have this
weird dry sense of humor.
And maybe I'm not supposed to
say this, because feminism,
but you are so pretty
and I really feel like...
- Okay, you...
Stop.
- Sorry.
Should I have not
have said that?
- No.
Or...
I don't know.
"Pretty" just feels...
weird.
- But you are. You're
so pretty, Janae.
- Just feels really gendered.
- What does that mean, for you?
- It means that sometimes...
I feel like a girl
and sometimes I don't.
And then sometimes I feel like
a boy and sometimes I don't.
And then sometimes I
wish that gender...
didn't exist.
You know?
Yeah, totally.
That makes sense for you.
- Really?
- Yeah.
I can't
believe I'm saying this
out loud to Addy Prentiss.
- Hey!
- And it's going well.
It's going so well.
But what about Maeve?
- Yeah, I haven't told her,
but I'm gonna tell her.
Just not yet.
Are you sure? 'Cause...
- Mm-hmm.
- Oh, my God,
Vanessa's going live.
We don't have to watch this.
We can keep talking about...
- Oh, about me?
Absolutely not.
No, thank you.
Oh, God.
- Today, I am here with a guest
who's going to change everything
you thought you knew
about this case.
- What is she doing?
- Army, meet Giselle.
- Thanks, Vanessa.
- Oh, no, thank you, girl,
for coming forward.
Why don't you tell
everyone about yourself?
- Well, I'm a senior,
like you, from Slo,
and I guess I'm here
because I'm pissed off.
- Mmm, girl, say more.
- I saw your Justice
for Jake rally
and what Addy said about Jake...
- Mmm, yeah, that mess.
That pissed a lot of people off.
- I'm so sick of hearing
people talk about Jake
like he was this
evil mastermind.
That's not the person I knew.
- And how did you know Jake?
- We met over the
summer in Greece,
and we fell in love.
Addy?
- But Jake was still with Addy?
- Yes, he wanted to
end things with Addy
but he was scared of
her and her new friends,
scared of what they
were capable of.
And then he disappeared.
- The police say he's in Mexico.
Do you believe that?
- No, he wouldn't just
vanish on me like this
without telling me.
I'm afraid the
worst has happened
and that's why I'm here.
To help you find the truth.
- And we will find
the truth, together.
And we will get our
#JusticeForJake.
Thank you, Giselle.
Thanks.
- I knew I forgot to
tell you something.
Oops.
- The police say he's in Mexico.
Do you believe that?
- No, he wouldn't
just vanish on me
like this without telling me.
- Oh, yeah.
- I'm afraid the
worst has happened.
- Everyone definitely
thinks I'm dead.
Pretty soon, they're gonna
wonder who killed me.
- To help you find the truth.
- Gosh.
Who would they look at
first?
- And we will find the truth.
- Addy, you need to
stop watching it.
Besides, what do we really
know about this chick, anyway?
She could be making it all up,
looking for her 15 minutes.
- Eh, she's not making it up.
Just look at her.
She could give me
everything you couldn't.
- No wonder he cheated.
Look at her.
- That sounds like Jake talking.
Not you.
You are every bit as
hot when you wanna be.
I know this playbook
all too well, baby.
Shitty men make themselves
feel less shitty
by shitting on amazing women.
Their voices get in your head.
- How do I not hear that voice?
- Look, sometimes you can't
block it out completely,
but you can make
your voice louder.
And I know you can be, like...
loud as hell.
Plus, if what she's
saying is true,
then you're not the cheater.
If Jake cheated first,
you didn't do anything wrong.
- Hmm.
Yeah.
Yeah, I like that take.
What the hell?
- Coop. Hey.
- Hey.
- Have you seen Addy?
- Sadly, I doubt
she'll come to school.
She'll wanna avoid
the attention.
- Or maybe not.
- Whoa.
- Okay, this is a choice.
- And not a good one.
It looks like she's
saying Jake's dead.
- It was a Simon Says ask.
Obviously not my idea.
- Oh, my God.
- Move along.
- The worst part
is that everyone's
just gonna think I'm
upset about Giselle.
- And you're not?
- I mean, kind of.
But also it's good news.
'Cause if it's true and
Jake did cheat on me,
then TJ and I didn't
really do anything wrong.
- That is an
interesting reframe.
- I just need to talk to her,
find out when it happened.
- Wait, Addy, hold on.
Does any of this make sense?
- Yeah. Because if
Jake cheated first,
then I'm in the clear.
- No, no.
I mean about Giselle.
She shows up here, she says
she's Jake's true love,
and that she thinks he's dead.
What if Simon Says
put her up to this?
- If the goal was
to torture us...
- Giselle could be
part of the plan.
- Even more reason I
need to talk to her.
We need to find
out if she's legit.
Vanessa, I need you to
introduce me to Giselle.
I have to find out
if she's for real.
- Okay, Addy, I'm
sorry Jake cheated,
but you're just
gonna have to deal.
- Just give me her number or
tell me where I can find her.
- Why? So you can stalk her?
- Please?
We used to be friends.
- What do I get if
I introduce you?
- What do you get?
How's this?
You introduce us,
and I won't fucking kill you.
- Wow.
You really are psycho.
But at least you give
me great material.
So, yeah, sure.
I'll text you!
- Are you sure you
wanna be here for this?
- Yes, I'm fine.
Seriously.
It's not like it has
anything to do with
what's going on
with me and Nate.
- Right. Which is?
- Not the point.
We should really be
looking for Simon Says.
- Which we still think is Evan?
- Yeah.
- Is this like a kink of his?
Did Evan have a thing
for Jackie Kennedy?
- Is that who I am?
- Addy, yes.
- Has anyone actually seen Evan?
- Oh, yeah.
- What?
- That's weird.
- That's very weird.
- What if they're
working together?
- Evanessa.
- Huh. He's the brains,
and she's the bitch.
- Shh.
- Nate. Hey.
- Just go with me on this.
- What?
- Watch your back,
Nate. She's crazy!
- Nate, is this
some kind of joke?
Why would you...
- I'm sorry.
- Oh, my God!
Oh, my God. Oh, my
God. Oh, my God.
- Okay, but what was weirder?
Nate kissing Fiona or
Vanessa kissing Evan?
- Neither.
Both.
I don't know.
- Yep, those are all
the possible answers.
You're definitely fine.
- Maybe I was wrong
about Evan the whole time
'cause he's definitely
not the person
I thought he was if he's
hooking up with her.
I've always been better
than him at debate,
so I am gonna trip him up,
get him to confess to something.
- What, that he's Simon Says
or that he's hooking
up with Vanessa?
- Well, it's the
same thing, isn't it?
- Simon Says I need to
post to all of my followers
that I got a text from Jake.
That he's in Mexico and
he doesn't wanna be found.
- Whoa, what?
- If I do this, the
cops and Jake's family
is gonna want to proof.
I've got potential
sponsors keeping tabs
on my social media,
and something...
Something like this
could ruin everything.
- Okay, we'll figure it out.
- "Figure it out"? How?
This is my life. This
is my family's future.
It's not some stupid math test.
- Okay,
it was a midterm and
I can't retake it.
- Are you being serious?
- School is my sport!
- Okay.
I feel like you're not really
reading the room here, um...
What if I sent you a text
so that you have something
to show when people ask?
I could use a VPN and make it
look like it came from Mexico.
- Is that something you can do?
- Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Thank you.
- Hey.
- Hey.
- You okay?
- Fine.
- We talked about this.
You told me to go
through with the kiss.
- Yeah, and you, like,
really kissed her.
Went above and
beyond. Good job.
- I don't know what you
want from me, Rojas.
- Figure it out, Macauley.
Here's a debate topic for you:
is torture ever justified?
- What?
Today's topic is
whether climate change
is the greatest threat
facing humanity today.
- It is. Debate over. Now
let's talk about mine.
Is torture ever justified?
Yes or no?
- That's not really how
debate works, Bronwyn.
But if you're at all
confused about it,
maybe you shouldn't join us
for regionals next month.
- Are you enjoying this?
Is this what you get off on?
- Seeing you
spiral? Not exactly.
- Or is it for the attention?
Because if there's one
thing you know about me,
and you don't,
it's I desperately need to
be the center of attention.
- Yeah, maybe not you,
but your girlfriend
certainly does.
- My what?
- Yeah, I saw you
making out with
Vanessa at lunchtime.
Keep
your voice down!
- Where were you
on Halloween night?
- Of course you don't remember.
I was at the Fright Night
movie marathon at the Ritz,
the one that I'd
bought us tickets to,
when we were dating.
I don't know who you
think I am, Bronwyn,
but I finally see you
for who you really are,
and it sucks.
- Hey, G. Um, so this is Addy.
- If you have a confession,
take it to the police.
I didn't hurt him.
- Then you drove
him out of town.
He wouldn't just disappear on
me like this without a word.
- Does that sound like Jake?
Running scared of
me, of all people?
Can we have a few
minutes to talk?
Please?
- We're good, Vanessa.
- Okay.
- I think Evan's telling
the truth about Halloween.
The screening was
at midnight in L.A.,
so he couldn't have
made it there and back
in time to be in the woods.
- Great, so we're
back to square one.
Maybe Addy can find
out Giselle's lying.
Maybe she is a Simon Says plant.
God.
I don't know how she can do this
and I couldn't even sit
through Nate kissing Fiona
for his stupid Simon Says ask.
- Oh, my God.
She is human.
- Ha ha.
- Seriously, it would've
messed with anyone.
- Right? I thought he was
actually gonna, I don't know,
give her, like, a peck.
- I don't think Nate Macauley
knows what a peck is.
I should have seen it
coming though because
I know I was never
gonna be enough for him.
- I'm sorry, what?
Bronwyn Rojas thinks that
Nate Macauley is too good?
Oh, my God! I can't!
- So, what do you want?
- I just want to know
what really happened.
- You think I'm lying?
Do I have to tell you about
the scar on his inner thigh,
how he sounds when he comes?
I don't owe you anything.
- Giselle, I just...
I just want to know
when it started.
When he was with you, he was
sending me these pictures.
I feel so stupid, I just need
to stop torturing myself.
I just need you to
tell me the full truth.
- I took this one.
I loved that photo.
He looks so...
- Goofy.
- Yeah. Exactly.
- It was the second
day of the trip.
Athens.
I couldn't stop looking at him.
And he looked up and saw me,
and it was lightning.
- Two days?
Weeks before me and TJ.
- I didn't plan it, okay?
Even after we got
back to California
and things were
still complicated...
it felt worth it.
I told you what
you wanted to know.
You tell me what I wanna know.
Is he dead?
- You know Jake.
If he wants
something, he gets it.
If he wanted to disappear,
make sure no one can find him,
he could.
Thanks, Giselle.
- She's nothing like me.
But maybe Jake's nothing
like I thought he was either,
so it makes sense.
- You really think
she's telling the truth?
- Simon Says is good.
She could be part of the set up.
- No.
No, she said stuff that
you would only know
if you really knew Jake, so...
Oh, ew!
- I'm so sorry. That
must've been so shitty.
- It was.
Also, it wasn't.
I know this isn't the best
thing to admit, but...
there's always been this
small part of me that thought
maybe this is all my fault.
I thought I'd cheated on Jake
and it turned then
into this monster.
And he took it out on all of us.
And Simon.
- That's fucked up.
- And you know it's not true.
- No, I know. Logically.
It's hard to shake
the feeling sometimes.
Jake really fucked me up.
It's taken me a long time
to be able to say that.
I'm okay.
Oh, fuck.
Cooper's going live.
- Hey, guys.
Coop here.
Look, I know I'm usually on
here talking about workouts
and fastballs and, I don't know,
my pick to win the
World Series, but...
today I wanna talk
about something else.
- I can't believe he's
actually doing this.
- I received a text
from Jake Riordan today.
And he informed that
he was in Mexico
and that he doesn't
wanna be found.
But I want his family and the
police to know he's out there.
If anybody has heard
anything from him,
or anybody has seen him
or knows any information,
please, please come forward.
- This is so fucked up.
- Be a good teammate,
look out for each other,
take care of your friends,
and never lose hope.
- Whoever Simon Says is,
they're getting more
and more twisted.
- Janae's the only one left.
- Do you think it'll get worse?
- Are you not worried?
- No, I... or, I guess
not. This... sort of.
I don't know.
- Those are all the
possible answers.
- Janae?
- What?
- Why are you being weird?
- I got mine.
But you can save your breath
because I'm not gonna do it.
- What do you...
What do you mean?
What was it?
- Simon Says wants me to
graffiti someone's grave,
so obviously I'm
just gonna, like,
deal with the
consequences of that
because I am never doing that.
- I'm so sorry, Janae.
But the consequences
are we all go to jail.
All of our lives are over.
So you'll have to do this
because we all did ours.
- We're all in this
together, Janae.
- We're your friends.
- No.
If you were my friend,
you would never
ask me to do that.
Janae...
- You haven't been fired yet.
I guess Victor hasn't
heard about you
and his daughter, huh?
- Do you want to
do the tasting menu
or do you wanna do à la carte?
- You know, it seems
like you have a type.
Smart, hot,
way too good for you.
- Fuck off, TJ.
Bronwyn.
I really wish I was surprised.
- I... I don't want
you to have to do this,
but I just knew Simon
Says was gonna check
to make sure it got
done, so, um, yeah.
I'm sorry for how
I reacted earlier.
"Beloved son and
friend to all."
- I mean, not how
I'd describe him.
I guess I'm not the
best judge, right?
- You were his best friend.
- Yeah.
Yeah, I was.
I was best friends with the guy
who planned this insane prank
gone wrong and who
cared more about
fucking over the people he
hated than staying alive.
It's like I didn't
really know him.
And it feels like he's
dying all over again.
- I didn't know him as well as
you did, but I do one thing.
I think that he'd
find this hilarious.
You and me,
hanging out, working together,
cuddling in a graveyard.
- I think he'd fucking hate it.
- Okay, but imagine how
much it's gonna cost
his parents to clean this up.
I think he'd be on
board for that alone.
Yeah.
You're right on that one.
His mom is gonna freak out.
And he would love that.
I'm gonna need some help.
It, um... it could be
something meaningful,
like a tribute almost.
- It's supposed to be a dick.
Okay.
Um...
- Hey! What's going
on over there?
- Shit! Go.
- The graveyard is closed!
- Um...
- Go! Run!
- No, we both go.
- Bronwyn, it's my
ass, I've got it.
- Okay.
- You, there!
- Hello, good evening,
uh, sir. Officer.
- This your work?
- Can I plead the fifth?
- You had enough fun for
one day, don't you think?
- I'm here to
apologize about that.
- I'd really rather not
keep talking about it, Nate.
- Look, Fiona, I...
I feel horrible.
I didn't... I didn't mean
to embarrass you, okay?
You've been super good to me.
- Who put you up to it?
It was a prank, right?
Some John Hughes movie dare?
I hate this school.
It was supposed to
be my fresh start,
but that was ruined on day one.
I was just gonna keep my
head down till graduation.
- Look, Fiona.
I get it, okay?
I'm so sorry.
- I feel so stupid.
I thought we were friends.
- We are.
- I even kinda liked you.
- I even kinda liked
you too, Jennings.
- Past tense?
- Well, I'm...
- Now we're even.
- Can I...
- Yes.
- Coop.
Hey. What's this video?
Did Jake text you?
Is this for real?
Listen, you hear from that
kid, you come tell me.
You don't go broadcasting it
for the whole world like that,
calling him your teammate.
What were you thinking?
- I was thinking
that maybe someone else
has heard from him.
Or maybe that it'll help
the cops find him, or...
- Or maybe it'll make
you look like you're
trying to help a fugitive.
- Dad, it doesn't
have to be a big deal.
- Boy, you know
better than that.
You know everything we built
can disappear in a second.
Use your...
Get it.
Go on.
- Cooper. How you doing?
Saw your post about
hearing from Jake,
and I would love to
look at your phone.
- Go away. He doesn't
have to give you anything.
We're not involved
in any of this.
- Actually, your
son claims that he
heard from Jake in Mexico,
so extremely involved.
And I've got a warrant.
The Riordans were only too
happy to use their connections
to get us in front
of a judge quickly
and get that signed off, so...
- Go ahead.
Give it to her. Go on.
- This could help us
find a killer on the run.
You're
not in trouble.
- I'm sorry, can I read
that? That could be, like,
school or it could be
practice or it could be...
- Actually, no.
We can't have you delete
anything that might be useful.
- I thought you said
he wasn't in trouble.
- I'm gonna take this
down to the station
and I'm gonna use it to
look for the true origin
of that text.
I'll get it back to you
as soon as possible.
- So my Simon Says ask was
to deface Simon's grave.
- Which I did.
- What?
- Yeah.
And then I got caught by a very
enthusiastic and self-serious
guard person at the cemetery
who notified Simon's parents
as well as my parents about
my artistic expressions.
And, well, the upshot
is that my dad's
coming home from Paris early.
- What? When?
- Mmm, he's getting on
a plane pretty soon,
so he'll be home
late tomorrow night
so the dead body on
his boat's gotta go!
- Do you not remember what
happened last time, Janae?
It's too busy on the water.
There's too many
people to see us.
- Once my dad gets
back, there will be
no more chances to
take the boat out,
so it's gonna have to be tonight
and we're gonna have to risk it.
- We're gonna need Cooper.
Where is he?
- We'll meet at the
dock by midnight.
Can we find Cooper?
Okay, it's after
midnight. We have to go.
- Addy and Cooper are not here.
- We don't have time
to wait, Bronwyn.
We have to be back by
the time the sun is up.
- Okay.
- Hey, I see them.
Wait, guys. Wait.
Come on, hurry up!
- Let's fuckin' go!
- Let's go!
- You good?
- We're good.
- Let's go. Go, go, go.
- How could you make
this plan without me?
- Cooper, we couldn't
get a hold of you.
- Because the cops
have my phone.
- What?
- Detective Wheeler took
my phone into evidence
to see where the text
really came from.
To find out where
Jake really is.
- We texted you
where to meet us.
- Wait, so Wheeler
knows we're out here.
- Guys, we have to
go back to the dock.
- No. No.
- Please.
- We have to see this through.
- The cops could
be waiting for us
by the time we get back there.
- Well, good thing that
we won't have a dead body
on the boat!
- How could you guys
drag me back into this?
Addy, why didn't
you come find me?
I'd be better of dealing
with this shit on my own.
- Then do it.
Start tomorrow.
- Is this the spot?
- Yeah.
Let's go.
- Can I have a second
alone with him?
- Are you sure?
- Yeah.
- The code for the lock
is 3241.
- Hey.
- Hey.
I saw your texts.
Sorry I didn't get back to you.
Kind of did what you would
call a very Bronwyn thing
and tried doing Janae's
Simon Says ask for her.
Turned into this whole thing.
I hated seeing you kiss her.
I know I said I didn't care,
but it made me crazy.
You make me crazy.
And I know I told
you to figure it out,
but if you haven't already,
what I want...
is to be the only girl you kiss.
- We have really bad
timing, don't we?
- You mean pouring my heart
out on a boat with a dead body
isn't the best timing?
I love you.
- Look what you've done.
- What I've done?
I built my whole
world around you.
And you were a lie.
You never loved me.
You loved controlling me.
- And you had no part in that?
You never had a thought
of you own, Addy.
Always waiting around for
me to tell you what to do.
- I knew something was off
when you were in Greece.
I knew in my gut that you
were with someone else,
but I didn't know how to
listen to my own instincts.
- And whose fault is that?
- All you ever did was lie.
And I got so used to
listening to your story
that I didn't know
how to hear my own.
I'm not sorry that I shot you.
But I am sorry
that you're dead...
'cause I would've loved to
see the look on your face
when I become the person
I'm meant to be without you.
- Guys.
You okay?
Yeah, I will be.
- Kind of wish we had
something to burn.
As, like, a ritual.
Like, cleansing.
- Yeah.
- Cleansing sounds right.
Maybe I should delete
all of Jake's pictures.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
Giselle
took this one.
Can you believe that?
He was sending me
pictures that she took.
- Wait.
Addy, this isn't Greece.
- What? Yes, it is.
He sent it to me from that
trip and Giselle recognized it.
- No, I recognize this site.
It was a final question in
last year's academic decathlon.
This is the Second
Temple of Hera.
It's in Italy.
- Are you sure?
- Yes.
- This is also Photoshopped.
Do you see how his
shadow doesn't match
the buildings in the back?
Someone constructed this image.
- But if Jake was
never in Greece...
- Then Giselle was lying.
- Why would he lie to
me about being there?
- And why would Giselle
prop up the same lie?
- I don't know. None
of it makes any sense.
- Unless... unless
Giselle is Simon Says.
She's obsessed with
Jake, wants revenge...
- And she starts toying
with us from a distance
but then she wants to escalate,
so she comes into town
and steps up the torture.
- And manipulates us
into moving the body.
- Which we do as the cops are
going through Cooper's phone.
- Is that possible?
That Giselle set us up?
- If we go back to shore
and the cops are there...
Then we'll know.
- Oh, shit.
You ready?
- It's over.
- I think it's just
getting started.