One Of Us Is Lying (2021–…): Season 2, Episode 2 - Simon Says Tick Tock - full transcript
- What time is it?
- 7:00.
- I went to sleep two hours ago.
- I went to sleep never.
That's what this is for.
What were you
doing up till 5:00?
- I'll show you.
- What is this?
- It's a murder board,
everything I think we know
and everyone I
think it could be.
- You're the killer.
If we're doing murder
boards, I think your picture
should be up top, babe.
- Addy?
- Why are...
Why are Kris and Maeve up here?
- You know, trying
to be thorough.
And also I'm pretty
sure Maeve hates me now,
so that's motive.
- Janae, she doesn't hate you,
but I think you
should take it down
before Cooper and Bronwyn see.
Also, Janae, I have
someone to add.
- Who?
- Jake's brother, Cole.
He was waiting for me when
I got home last night.
- Oh, ew. What did he want?
- He said he wanted to know
what happened on Halloween,
but I think he already knows.
Janae, he could
totally be Simon Says.
He has motive to torture
us because he loved Jake,
so therefore would hate us.
He definitely had
access to the safe,
and I don't know where
it fits on the board,
but maybe being a
psychopath is genetic.
- Was he there on Halloween?
- We need to find out.
- New question.
What the actual fuck?
- Okay, so why would
someone want Jake's watch?
- What if it's about
the money again?
I mean, that watch
is worth at least 5K.
- Or Cole wants it for
sentimental reasons.
- But if it's at Jake's house,
Cole would already have it.
- Oh, my God, we can't get it.
Jake was wearing
it on Halloween.
- Which means it's at the bottom
of the ocean with his body.
- Okay, what about a duplicate?
- It was engraved.
If Cole is Simon Says,
he'll know it's a fake.
- What, so that's
it? Game over?
- We have to tell them.
- Tell us what?
- Technically speaking, we
could still get the watch.
- Did you take it off him?
- No, uh, no.
The watch is on Jake's body.
Just Jake's body never made
it to the bottom of the ocean.
- Are you fucking serious?
- How do we not know this?
- Your rules, everything
on a need-to-know basis.
- We obviously
needed to know this.
- Janae, where is he?
- In a safe place,
relatively safe.
- We're screwed.
We're screwed.
- Relatively safe?
- Getting rid of the body
was the most important thing
we had to do that night
or maybe any night of our lives,
and you screwed it up?
- We did not screw it up.
- No, when we left the harbor,
there were party boats
and people everywhere,
and there were high
rises with lights on,
and we would have
had to go way out
in the middle of the ocean.
There were big swells.
And I'm just not that
good at driving a boat.
- Yeah, I don't boat,
okay? I was useless.
- So you put our
lives in her hands?
- It seemed safer
to leave the body
in the subzero freezer on my
parents' very private yacht.
- You didn't think it'd be
that easy to get rid of me,
did you?
- And now I can't breathe
because there's a
body on my boat,
but on the bright side,
we can get the watch,
so you're welcome.
- Wait, what if
asking about the watch
is really about
following us to the body?
If they find it, we're done.
- They'll all go down
for what you did.
It's all your fault.
- I killed him.
I can own up to it and
make this nightmare end.
- No.
- Absolutely not.
- No.
- No.
- It's too late for that.
We made a decision.
We're in this together.
- If Simon Says follows
us, he'll turn us in.
- Yeah, but if we
don't get the watch,
they also turn us in.
- They have the video
of us in the woods.
- I have an idea.
- You didn't get
rid of the body.
Why should we listen to you?
- How about because
the body is on my boat?
I'm actually in the
most danger here?
- Janae, what's your idea?
- We can get the watch
and throw Simon Says
off our trail, but
it'll take all of us
working together tonight.
Can we do that?
- Tell me again,
why are we here?
- To throw Simon Says
off Janae's trail.
This is the kind of place
you would bury a body.
- Yeah, ours.
How do we know Simon
Says is not gonna
come here and kill us?
- We don't.
- This is crazy.
I can't believe I'm hoping
we're being followed by
an actual psychopath.
- Are we?
- I don't know.
Future Undercover
Agents of America met
at the same time
as cheerleading.
Shit.
- Did you see something?
Was it Simon says?
- No, no, sorry.
It was nothing.
- You think I'm nothing?
You really think ignoring
me is gonna make me go away?
That's not how
guilt works, babe.
You have to tell the truth.
- I don't like Janae's plan.
- I'd rather be us
than her right now.
- What if she
purposely kept the body
so she could turn on us?
- No, no.
- It wasn't that long
ago she hated all of us.
- Do you really think that?
- We should just go back
to the movie theater
and look for actual clues.
- Or we could get
on my bike and go,
leave this place,
never look back.
- You're serious?
I can't. I can't do that.
My parents, Maeve.
- Do you want to talk about it?
- About what?
- That night, Jake.
It's different for us
than for the others.
- Because we knew him?
- Because we had a
gun pointed at us.
I thought he was my friend.
I can't square the Jake I
knew with the monster who...
I thought I was gonna die.
- You did?
- Did you?
- I kept thinking,
"It's gonna be okay.
It's going to be fine,"
over and over, like some
demented cheerleader.
And then I looked in his eyes...
and I realized he could do it.
I could be dead.
- If Janae hadn't been there...
- Cooper?
Do you ever, um...
Do you ever, like, see him?
- I have nightmares.
Is that what you mean?
- Yeah, yeah, sure, nightmares.
- I'm concerned about Addy,
all that talk about confessing.
- You think she's gonna crack?
- It doesn't feel impossible.
- Yeah, we're in the
prisoner's dilemma.
- You know about that?
- People who committed
a crime together
are arrested.
If nobody talks,
everyone's safe.
But the one who talks
first gets the deal.
- If you don't trust each other,
the first one to
betray the others wins.
- You don't trust any of us.
- Is that really what you think?
You're the one that
doesn't trust me.
You followed me to the library.
You didn't tell
me about the boat.
- Hey, wanting to protect you
isn't the same as
not trusting you.
- I don't need protecting.
- And I didn't need saving.
So let's just get
through tonight.
- I hope Janae and her
stupid plan are okay.
- Oh, my God, what the
fuck are you doing here?
- I was at dinner
with my parents,
and I saw you, and
I just want to talk.
- Okay, it is not a good
time. You have to go.
- Yeah, it seems
like it never is.
You've been ignoring me.
- Maeve, I'm serious.
You can't be here.
- Okay, why not?
What did I do wrong?
- Nothing. You
didn't do anything.
You're amazing. It's
just... it's really bad.
It's a bad time.
- Is someone else here?
- No.
- Okay, then talk to me.
- It's too fucked up.
You were with Simon,
and then when I'm with
you, it's all I can see,
and I don't think
you actually like me.
I think you're
transferring your feelings
for Simon onto me.
- That's so not true.
- It's incestuous and weird,
and I can't feel
attracted to you, okay?
- Fuck you, Janae.
- She got it.
Let's go home.
- Cool.
- What's wrong?
- I followed Janae onto her boat
because I wanted to talk to her.
- What? What happened?
- It was terrible.
Did you know that she...
- It's not her fault.
- You're taking her side?
- We all decided that...
- What, that she
shouldn't be with me?
How is that any
of your business?
- No, wait.
What happened on the boat?
- She said horrible
things to me.
She just doesn't
want to be with me.
Okay.
- Okay? How can you say that?
What, she just breaks my
heart, and you just don't care?
How self-centered are you?
- That's not how I meant it.
- How did you mean it, Bronwyn?
What do you think
she said to me?
- Nothing.
Just forget I said
anything. Please.
- I don't know why
I came in here.
All you ever do is
make things worse.
- Cole called me last night.
- Fuck.
Ouch. Why?
- Because apparently you
won't return his calls.
- I don't have
anything to say to him
after what Jake did to me.
- Well, his family still
owns half the town.
They can make our lives hell.
Vanessa might not be
the only one who thinks
that things don't add up.
You refusing to talk to Cole,
it's making him suspicious.
- Him, Mom?
Or you?
- I'm just looking out for you.
Your best move is to act normal.
You should be sympathetic
to his family's tragedy.
Addy, are you listening?
- Yeah, um,
sympathetic. Got it.
- Why the fuck would Simon
Says even want one of us
to wear the watch?
- Because if someone saw
Jake wear it on Halloween,
and one of us wears
it, we look guilty.
- Sure, but if
Cole is Simon Says,
how would he even know if
we're wearing the watch?
- Maybe he has
spies on the inside.
- Okay, we're getting paranoid.
- What should we be?
- Okay, Addy wearing it
would be the least suspicious
in terms of an explanation
because he could have
given it to you that night.
- I can't wear it.
I'm seeing Cole after school.
- You're seeing Cole?
Why?
- He won't stop calling.
And this way, I can see if
he was home on Halloween.
But somebody needs to take it.
- I've got it. It's just
a man's watch, right?
Done.
- Okay, but you have to
show it a little more.
We'll be watching
to see who notices.
- I was kind of hoping
nobody would notice.
- Coop?
Coop!
- Hey.
- I have amazing news.
- Okay.
- You are booked on the
Tom Prestin show today.
- Whoa, slow down. How?
- My internship.
It's mostly getting
people coffee,
but last week, one of
the producers asked
if I had any ideas for a
new spin on the Jake story,
because Tom is obsessed,
and don't be mad,
but I pitched you
as a unique angle,
the gay baseball
star outed by murder.
I thought they forgot until
today's guest canceled,
and, well, you're on.
- Um, wait, does it
have to be today?
- Yeah, it has to be today.
And I don't want to pull
the fake girlfriend card,
but you do owe me.
- Sure.
Yeah, why not?
- Okay, awesome.
Thank you.
Oh, wow, new bling, huh?
- Justice for Jake
rally tomorrow night.
We are crowdsourcing
the search for truth.
Bayview phenom Cooper Clay
and Jake's so-called
best friend,
do you want justice for Jake?
- Leave me alone, Vanessa.
- "Leave me alone, Vanessa"?
I will not.
- Hey, can I
possibly talk to you?
- Yeah, what more could
you possibly say, Janae?
- I'm really sorry,
was my opener.
- Okay.
You're sorry.
So then tell me what you were
doing last night, the truth.
- I...
- Great.
- Hey.
Janae, are you ready?
- Yeah.
- You sure you want
to go in there?
- No.
I have to.
Keep your phone in your pocket.
Mine will be on mute,
but I'll hear if anything
goes horribly wrong.
- Thank you.
Do we need a code word?
Like what if he's silently
pointing a gun at me and...
- Yes. How about,
"Don't kill me"?
- Yeah.
Yeah, that works.
Okay.
- Thank you for coming.
- Uh, for your mom.
I know she loves Blue Bell's.
- She actually hasn't eaten
anything since Jake left,
but thank you for the gesture.
- Sorry.
- Yeah, she's, um...
She's falling apart.
I'm getting pretty worried
that if we don't find him soon,
it'll actually kill her.
- Wow, more blood on your hands.
Addy, we need answers.
- I wish I could help.
- Well, he must
have said something.
You must have noticed
something, please?
Okay, no detail is too small.
- Are you really this cruel?
They deserve the truth, Addy.
Tell him.
- I can't.
- Where did you last see him?
- Uh...
um...
his room, I think.
- Well, what happened?
You were fighting?
- No, he was in a good mood.
You know how he loves
throwing a party.
I actually thought he said
you were coming home for it.
Did you?
- Why would I come home for a
high school Halloween party?
- I don't know.
So when was the last
time that you saw him?
- You're here to answer
my questions, okay?
Not the other way around.
- Can I use your bathroom?
- Addy?
What are you doing?
- Mrs. Riordan, um...
I was just talking to Cole.
- About Jake?
There's nothing worse than
not knowing, is there?
Not knowing if we'll
ever see him again.
You really haven't
heard from him?
- Look at her.
Look what you're
doing to my mother.
- I don't believe Jake would
leave without telling me.
- I don't understand it either.
- You miss him too, don't you?
Will you tell him?
Tell him you want
him to come home?
And maybe he'll listen to you.
- How would I...
- You can post it.
I'm sure he'll be watching you.
- Everything okay down here?
- Cole, Addy just said
she would make a plea
for Jake to come home.
- Why don't you go to bed, Mom?
Addy and I need to have a talk.
Whatever you're up to,
I'm gonna find out.
- My family's always
been so good to you.
You owe him the truth, Addy.
- I have to go.
- We're not done here.
- I think I am.
Excuse me.
Drive, please.
- Addy, you're not really
going to make a plea to Jake.
- No, no, but I couldn't
say that to her face.
She was unhinged.
- Oh, my God, and
Cole sounded insane.
- Yeah, but the opposite,
like very hinged,
like he would kill you,
but he'd know exactly
what he was doing.
- There will probably
be a few questions
about the events leading
up to World War II,
which were?
Nate.
- What?
- Playing dumb and looking
hot won't work on me.
- I am not playing dumb. I'm
just a little distracted.
- Anything I can help with?
- No, it's definitely
above your pay grade.
Just shit at home.
- Right, family.
- Yeah.
I gotta leave, but zero income.
- The drug thing dried up?
- Yeah, I had to get
out of that, so...
- My dad owns a restaurant.
High-end, great tips.
If you're looking
for an honest buck.
- I mean, he would hire a guy
just released from prison...
- You were exonerated.
You're #HotAndlnnocent.
- Oh, my God, please.
- Although, I suspect
you're not that innocent.
- And you'd be right about that.
But I didn't kill Simon.
- I know, but
honestly, if you had,
the guy was an asshole.
Yeah.
What are we onto next?
- I thought you had tutoring.
- It finished.
- Well, I'm really sorry
you wasted your time,
but we're too late.
- Too late, huh?
It's too late to get
into the theater.
But one thing criminals
get really good at
is finding security cameras.
- It's worth a try.
- Hell yeah.
- Well, we'll need a story.
So I'm walking out, right?
And then he came out of
nowhere, and he had a knife,
and he threatened me, and
I didn't know what to do.
- Sounds like you
should call the police.
- I did call them,
but they said they couldn't
do anything because...
- Shit. A little help, man?
I just spilled a bunch
of wine back here.
I think it needs a mop.
- Yeah, here.
- You're gonna have
to pay for this.
- What do you mean? I'm
not paying for this.
It was a fucking accident.
- You broke it.
You own it.
- Shit, shit, shit, shit.
- What do you think I mean?
Because you broke
it, you own it.
- You don't accept checks
here. That's all I got, man.
- Do you have a check?
- Yeah.
- Was is it, 1995?
- Shit.
- It's my dad's checkbook.
- Your dad?
- Yeah, I don't have cash.
Yeah, you go do that.
- Hey!
- Sorry!
Thank you.
- Don't ever come back!
- There, there, there, there.
Holy shit.
That was fucking close.
- That was fucking awesome.
Okay, check this out.
Timestamp says two hours
before we got to the theater.
- Isn't that the mask Janae
was wearing on Halloween?
- Yes.
- Oh, no. You got me.
I'm Simon Says.
I put on that
weird fucking mask,
and then I made a deepfake
of my best friend,
and then I torched a theater,
yeah, mystery solved.
- Janae, stop.
We're not accusing you
of being Simon Says.
- She is.
- I just want to know
where the mask is.
- I gave it to Cooper
to give back to Kris.
- Kris?
- It's not Kris.
- I didn't say it was, okay?
But maybe we should talk to him.
- Yeah, yeah, we totally should.
And you know what?
I will do it.
Unless you don't trust me.
- Just let us know what he says.
- Okay, but besides the
shoes, how do I look?
- Actually, the watch,
it isn't really you.
- Where'd you get that from?
- It's just a gift
from a friend.
- It's just sort of flashy.
We want your brand
to be more relatable.
- Yeah, she's right.
Yeah, take it off.
- Take it off?
- Yeah, take it off.
- Come on, we got to go.
- Ready?
- One sec, thank you.
- Coop, seriously.
Hurry up.
- I want to keep the watch.
- Watch off now.
- I can cover it.
- Hey, buddy, it's gone.
It sends the wrong message.
- I like the watch.
Let me keep the watch.
- We really need you on set.
- Yeah, one sec.
- Okay, Coop.
- Okay, okay.
- Come on.
- Got it.
- Hurry.
- Okay, all right.
- Come on.
- Cooper Clay, a
senior at Bayview High,
should be known
for his fastball,
which has made him the number
eight prospect in the country
according to ESPN.
But lately, a shadow
has been cast over
this young phenom's bright star.
He was a person of interest
in the murder of Simon Kelleher,
and in the course of
the investigation,
was forced to come out as gay.
Cooper, we have a
lot to talk about,
but let's start there.
Do you think that
the police mishandled
their investigation?
- Look, everyone wants to
come out on their own terms,
and that right
was taken from me.
Okay, now I would be lying
if I said that wasn't hard,
but I also understand
that the police were
just trying to do
their job and find out
who killed Simon
Kelleher, which they did.
Now we just... we
need them to find Jake
and bring him home so
that justice can be served
and I can get back to
talking about being
the number eight
prospect in the country.
Right,
I'll take the hint.
- Yeah.
- So tell me about
your prospects.
There haven't been any
baseball players who were out
while playing in the majors.
Do you think that coming out
hurts your chances of going pro?
- I thought it would.
That's why I kept it
quiet for so long.
But thankfully,
people have been
really supportive,
my family, teammates, fans.
- Your boyfriend?
Tell us about him.
- Um...
Kris is the...
the kindest, most
beautiful person
I've ever met.
He's never been
anybody but himself.
He's an inspiration
to me every day.
- Oh, my God, Cooper.
It's open.
Girl, why is you in my room?
- Okay, um, look, the
masks from Halloween,
did Cooper give
them back to you?
Do you still have them?
- No, girl, you crazy?
I burned them.
And I'm really trying to be done
with all of this.
I don't want anything to
do with what y'all did.
- He told you?
- Look, just tell him
the masks are gone.
Okay, I don't have them.
And tell him he looked
cute on "Tom Prestin"
or whatever.
- Kris, did you guys break up?
- That's none of your...
Janae, you need to
go, please, please.
- Just, can you tell me
where you got the masks,
who else could have one?
- Baby, anybody who shops
at Party Depot, okay?
The mask's cheap.
Anybody could've got it.
Oh, my God.
- I'm still getting
used to living honestly.
I thought that I may never
get to live my real life.
Baseball is America's sport,
and America is changing.
That's a good thing.
- Fuck yeah, Cooper.
- Take your time.
- Oh, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- All I want is to play
the game that I love
and love who I love,
plain and simple.
- Yes, please.
Oh, fuck.
- Janae?
Ah, no, no, stop! Please!
Mom, help! Please let me go!
Please let me go! I
didn't do anything!
Mom, ahh!
No,
wait, wait, wait.
- Cooper took it off.
It's not my fault.
Please, stop!
No, please!
Tell me what you
want. I can explain!
No!
Surprise!
- What we want is for you
to come back to cheer.
- Keely.
- Yeah?
- What the fuck?
- We thought it would be funny.
- Who thought it
would... Vanessa.
- When I couldn't
convince you, she said,
"Let's remind Addy how
much fun we have in cheer."
Come on, please?
- Come on, please?
- Come on, Addy.
- Come on.
- Oh, come on.
- Okay, yeah.
- Hey, Adds, you're definitely
gonna want to watch
my live tonight.
It's major.
Welcome back to the squad.
- It's so good to have you back.
- #HomeRunCooper.
You got, like, 200
more followers tonight.
- Since when are you on Twitter?
- You know, I'm trying.
- Hey, kiddo, you
said some things,
you know, um...
Tom threw some curveballs
at you, you know?
But you handled it.
You did good.
Internet's loving you, Coop.
Ready to eat?
Buddy? Food?
- Yeah, I'll be right there.
Yeah.
- Okay, you guys, I
just got a hot tip
from an incredibly perceptive
member of our army,
and it looks pretty fucking
bad for Murder Club.
This was at Jake's
Halloween party,
mere hours before
he disappeared.
See, he's holding up
his glass of whiskey.
He's having a good time,
but what I want you to
look at is his wrist.
See that watch?
Guess who was wearing
that same watch
today at school.
Cooper Clay.
And he was flaunting
it, honestly.
I mean, what is that,
some sort of sick trophy?
What really happened
to Jake on Halloween?
If you have photos
from that night,
we want them, in focus, out
of focus, sober, wasted.
I don't care.
And remember, come
show your support
at the Justice for Jake
rally tomorrow night.
- Why the fuck is Cooper
wearing Jake's watch?
- I don't know.
I don't even think
it's Jake's watch.
Vanessa's full of shit.
- Yeah, or it might
be Jake's exact watch
that Janae got off of
her boat last night
'cause Jake's not in Mexico.
He's in her fucking freezer.
Oh, I'm right, aren't I?
Oh, this is so much worse
than anything I imagined.
- Maeve, please,
just leave it alone, okay?
You don't want to know.
- But I already know, Bronwyn.
I saw your text with Janae,
and then I went on her boat,
and I saw the lock
on the freezer.
Who the fuck puts a
lock on their freezer?
So yeah, I put it together.
You guys killed him,
and now you're trying
to cover it up.
Why wouldn't you tell me?
- I'm so sorry, Maeve.
- Did Janae do it?
Which one of you...
- It was all of us, okay?
He was gonna kill us,
and we had no choice.
And you're not the
only one that knows.
Someone else knows too,
and they're blackmailing us.
And all I wanted
was to protect you
because this is fucked up!
And once you know this,
you cannot unknow it.
And you can't tell anyone else
that you know about this, okay?
Not even Janae.
Are you okay?
Maeve?
Please say something.
- Obviously I'm
not okay, Bronwyn.
But I will be...
because you clearly
need my help.
- Why did you take
the watch off?
- It was Keely's idea.
Okay, she insisted on it, and
I couldn't exactly explain
why I wanted to keep it on.
- Keely told you to take it off?
- Yeah.
- Could it have been a test?
- Keely's not Simon
Says. Cole is.
- We don't know that.
- Okay, here's what we do know.
Vanessa got sent that
photo as a consequence
for taking the watch off,
so the answer to who Simon
Says is is on her phone.
- Great, yeah, our lives
are in Vanessa's hands.
This is truly the
worst timeline.
- Okay, so do we just go
to Vanessa's Justice
for Jake rally tonight
and, in the midst of all
the bullshit and chaos,
try to get her phone?
- I have to be there anyway.
- What?
- Why?
- Fiona got me a
job at Victor's.
I start tonight.
Victor is her dad.
- Oh, wow.
That's extremely nice of her.
- We should all go.
Okay, make it look like
we have nothing to hide.
- Even though we do.
- I liked it better
when you were in denial.
I'm with Cooper. I
think we should go.
- Wait, I have to say something.
I don't want to be a narc,
but I think it's important
that we're all on the
same page about some shit
since our lives are
literally on the line.
Somebody here broke the most
important rule of Murder Club.
Someone told what
happened on Halloween.
- Okay, I didn't tell
Maeve. She figured it out.
- Wait, Maeve knows?
I was talking about Cooper
because he told Kris.
- Wait, you saw Kris? Why
didn't you come to me?
- See? They told.
You can too.
- Okay, look, I was
supposed to be done lying.
I had to tell Kris.
- We really suck at this.
- You and Janae
lied about the body.
- And you and Nate went
rogue to the bodega,
and then you thought
that I was Simon Says
because of the mask.
- What mask?
- Guys, stop.
If we act like this,
we're all doomed.
- She's right.
We need to hold
our shit together
long enough to catch Simon Says.
Then we can get on
with our fucking lives
and never talk to
each other ever again.
- That's the spirit.
- Whatever.
- You can end this torment
tonight for everyone,
Addy, if you just
tell the truth.
- What are you doing?
- Following you.
- There's really no need.
- I know you know about
Jake, which means you know
why I had to say what
I said on the boat
and that I didn't
mean any of it.
- Yeah, well, sometimes,
people say the truth
when they're trying
to lie, so...
- Not me.
The truth is I cannot
stop thinking about you.
And I...
I hate myself for what I did.
- It really fucking hurt.
- I don't deserve
to be forgiven.
- What if I am transferring
my feelings for
Simon onto you...
and it is weird and fucked up?
- I don't care.
- What are you doing tonight?
- I'm going to the
Justice for Jake rally.
- Oh, my God, you guys, what
a great fucking turnout,
Justice for Jake
fans and followers.
Let's thank Victor
for hosting us.
This is not just
a party, you guys.
This is an organized
search for truth,
to answer one question.
What really happened
on Halloween night?
And, army, we can find
the truth together.
We won't give up, and
we won't let the haters
tell us we're wrong.
- Wheeler's here.
- Should she really be
legitimizing this whole thing?
- I just don't think she wants
to admit she got it wrong.
She really wants
us to be guilty.
- I'm sure it would
mean the world to Jake.
Now I'm going to
hand the mic off
to Jake's brother, Cole,
who has a huge announcement
to get us started.
- Thank you, Vanessa,
Victor, all of you.
You know, when Jake
and I were younger,
I used to think,
why would I want
my annoying little
brother around?
But now I would do anything...
To have him by my side again.
So my family is offering
a $100,000 reward
for any information
that leads to finding him.
- Thank you, Cole.
$100,000, you guys.
That is a lot of money.
- Want to split it?
- That's not funny.
- It's kind of funny.
- Okay, Bronwyn's
going for the phone.
- Oh, well, if it
isn't the president
of Murder Club herself.
- I have something
to say to your army.
- By all means, Bronwyn.
Whoa, what are you doing?
- I want to hold it, so I
can have the right angle,
make sure it's on my good side.
You would know.
- I would know.
Yeah, no, we all
know that you're bad
through and through, Bronwyn,
so what do you want to say?
- Fuck you, Vanessa.
That was rude.
- Of course, that
looked like a disaster.
Okay, uh, wish me luck.
- Why?
- I am joining Vanessa's army.
- I want to say thank you.
- Justice for Jake,
shouldn't be here.
- How you doing, bro?
- Hey, easy, my pitching arm.
- Oh, I just want
to see the watch.
- There.
- Take it off.
- Excuse me?
- I can't see it.
So why do you have
my brother's watch?
Just not one like it, his watch.
- He gave it to me on Halloween.
- Bullshit.
- No, I saw him give
Cooper the watch.
He was drunk.
Maybe he already knew he
was going off to Mexico.
He was being sentimental.
Drunk
does sound like Jake.
Sentimental?
Hmm.
Addy, don't you
think now would be
a good time for you
to make your appeal
to Jake to come home?
- Uh, I don't think
Vanessa would want
me to step on her event.
- Oh, no, I already asked her.
She thinks it's a great idea.
Great.
- You good?
- Mm-hmm.
- You know, I just love
how you used that picture
of Jake that I sent in.
- You?
- You said there was plenty
of room in your army,
so here I am.
Right.
I'm supposed to believe
you're Evilseed69?
How dumb do you
think I am, Maeve?
- Honestly, dumber than
you even know, Vanessa.
- Hmm.
- So Vanessa's source
for the Halloween photo
was someone named Evilseed69.
And it looks like it
came from a troll farm,
which means that
whoever sent it in
clearly doesn't
want to be found.
- So we think that's Simon Says?
- If I could have
everybody's attention,
if you want to join
us in the room,
everyone outside
as well, please.
I would like to take this moment
to introduce Addy Prentiss.
She's the love of Jake's life,
and she has something that
she wants to say to him.
I know we all hope
that he's listening,
wherever he is.
- Oh, no.
- What?
- No, she said she
wasn't gonna do that.
- This is your moment, babe.
Just tell the truth.
It's the only way
to get rid of me.
- There have been so many lies
and rumors about Jake
since he disappeared.
And I understand
the Riordan family
want him to come home.
So tonight...
I think it's time for
me to tell the truth...
To them and to myself.
- That's my girl.
- This is hard for
me to say, but...
Jake killed Simon.
Yeah, Jake is a
horrible, damaged person.
So, Jake, wherever you are,
don't come home.
Don't come back.
I never want to see you again.
- They are hiding something.
I know it.
- I'm starting to
think you're right.
We're gonna find out what.
- 7:00.
- I went to sleep two hours ago.
- I went to sleep never.
That's what this is for.
What were you
doing up till 5:00?
- I'll show you.
- What is this?
- It's a murder board,
everything I think we know
and everyone I
think it could be.
- You're the killer.
If we're doing murder
boards, I think your picture
should be up top, babe.
- Addy?
- Why are...
Why are Kris and Maeve up here?
- You know, trying
to be thorough.
And also I'm pretty
sure Maeve hates me now,
so that's motive.
- Janae, she doesn't hate you,
but I think you
should take it down
before Cooper and Bronwyn see.
Also, Janae, I have
someone to add.
- Who?
- Jake's brother, Cole.
He was waiting for me when
I got home last night.
- Oh, ew. What did he want?
- He said he wanted to know
what happened on Halloween,
but I think he already knows.
Janae, he could
totally be Simon Says.
He has motive to torture
us because he loved Jake,
so therefore would hate us.
He definitely had
access to the safe,
and I don't know where
it fits on the board,
but maybe being a
psychopath is genetic.
- Was he there on Halloween?
- We need to find out.
- New question.
What the actual fuck?
- Okay, so why would
someone want Jake's watch?
- What if it's about
the money again?
I mean, that watch
is worth at least 5K.
- Or Cole wants it for
sentimental reasons.
- But if it's at Jake's house,
Cole would already have it.
- Oh, my God, we can't get it.
Jake was wearing
it on Halloween.
- Which means it's at the bottom
of the ocean with his body.
- Okay, what about a duplicate?
- It was engraved.
If Cole is Simon Says,
he'll know it's a fake.
- What, so that's
it? Game over?
- We have to tell them.
- Tell us what?
- Technically speaking, we
could still get the watch.
- Did you take it off him?
- No, uh, no.
The watch is on Jake's body.
Just Jake's body never made
it to the bottom of the ocean.
- Are you fucking serious?
- How do we not know this?
- Your rules, everything
on a need-to-know basis.
- We obviously
needed to know this.
- Janae, where is he?
- In a safe place,
relatively safe.
- We're screwed.
We're screwed.
- Relatively safe?
- Getting rid of the body
was the most important thing
we had to do that night
or maybe any night of our lives,
and you screwed it up?
- We did not screw it up.
- No, when we left the harbor,
there were party boats
and people everywhere,
and there were high
rises with lights on,
and we would have
had to go way out
in the middle of the ocean.
There were big swells.
And I'm just not that
good at driving a boat.
- Yeah, I don't boat,
okay? I was useless.
- So you put our
lives in her hands?
- It seemed safer
to leave the body
in the subzero freezer on my
parents' very private yacht.
- You didn't think it'd be
that easy to get rid of me,
did you?
- And now I can't breathe
because there's a
body on my boat,
but on the bright side,
we can get the watch,
so you're welcome.
- Wait, what if
asking about the watch
is really about
following us to the body?
If they find it, we're done.
- They'll all go down
for what you did.
It's all your fault.
- I killed him.
I can own up to it and
make this nightmare end.
- No.
- Absolutely not.
- No.
- No.
- It's too late for that.
We made a decision.
We're in this together.
- If Simon Says follows
us, he'll turn us in.
- Yeah, but if we
don't get the watch,
they also turn us in.
- They have the video
of us in the woods.
- I have an idea.
- You didn't get
rid of the body.
Why should we listen to you?
- How about because
the body is on my boat?
I'm actually in the
most danger here?
- Janae, what's your idea?
- We can get the watch
and throw Simon Says
off our trail, but
it'll take all of us
working together tonight.
Can we do that?
- Tell me again,
why are we here?
- To throw Simon Says
off Janae's trail.
This is the kind of place
you would bury a body.
- Yeah, ours.
How do we know Simon
Says is not gonna
come here and kill us?
- We don't.
- This is crazy.
I can't believe I'm hoping
we're being followed by
an actual psychopath.
- Are we?
- I don't know.
Future Undercover
Agents of America met
at the same time
as cheerleading.
Shit.
- Did you see something?
Was it Simon says?
- No, no, sorry.
It was nothing.
- You think I'm nothing?
You really think ignoring
me is gonna make me go away?
That's not how
guilt works, babe.
You have to tell the truth.
- I don't like Janae's plan.
- I'd rather be us
than her right now.
- What if she
purposely kept the body
so she could turn on us?
- No, no.
- It wasn't that long
ago she hated all of us.
- Do you really think that?
- We should just go back
to the movie theater
and look for actual clues.
- Or we could get
on my bike and go,
leave this place,
never look back.
- You're serious?
I can't. I can't do that.
My parents, Maeve.
- Do you want to talk about it?
- About what?
- That night, Jake.
It's different for us
than for the others.
- Because we knew him?
- Because we had a
gun pointed at us.
I thought he was my friend.
I can't square the Jake I
knew with the monster who...
I thought I was gonna die.
- You did?
- Did you?
- I kept thinking,
"It's gonna be okay.
It's going to be fine,"
over and over, like some
demented cheerleader.
And then I looked in his eyes...
and I realized he could do it.
I could be dead.
- If Janae hadn't been there...
- Cooper?
Do you ever, um...
Do you ever, like, see him?
- I have nightmares.
Is that what you mean?
- Yeah, yeah, sure, nightmares.
- I'm concerned about Addy,
all that talk about confessing.
- You think she's gonna crack?
- It doesn't feel impossible.
- Yeah, we're in the
prisoner's dilemma.
- You know about that?
- People who committed
a crime together
are arrested.
If nobody talks,
everyone's safe.
But the one who talks
first gets the deal.
- If you don't trust each other,
the first one to
betray the others wins.
- You don't trust any of us.
- Is that really what you think?
You're the one that
doesn't trust me.
You followed me to the library.
You didn't tell
me about the boat.
- Hey, wanting to protect you
isn't the same as
not trusting you.
- I don't need protecting.
- And I didn't need saving.
So let's just get
through tonight.
- I hope Janae and her
stupid plan are okay.
- Oh, my God, what the
fuck are you doing here?
- I was at dinner
with my parents,
and I saw you, and
I just want to talk.
- Okay, it is not a good
time. You have to go.
- Yeah, it seems
like it never is.
You've been ignoring me.
- Maeve, I'm serious.
You can't be here.
- Okay, why not?
What did I do wrong?
- Nothing. You
didn't do anything.
You're amazing. It's
just... it's really bad.
It's a bad time.
- Is someone else here?
- No.
- Okay, then talk to me.
- It's too fucked up.
You were with Simon,
and then when I'm with
you, it's all I can see,
and I don't think
you actually like me.
I think you're
transferring your feelings
for Simon onto me.
- That's so not true.
- It's incestuous and weird,
and I can't feel
attracted to you, okay?
- Fuck you, Janae.
- She got it.
Let's go home.
- Cool.
- What's wrong?
- I followed Janae onto her boat
because I wanted to talk to her.
- What? What happened?
- It was terrible.
Did you know that she...
- It's not her fault.
- You're taking her side?
- We all decided that...
- What, that she
shouldn't be with me?
How is that any
of your business?
- No, wait.
What happened on the boat?
- She said horrible
things to me.
She just doesn't
want to be with me.
Okay.
- Okay? How can you say that?
What, she just breaks my
heart, and you just don't care?
How self-centered are you?
- That's not how I meant it.
- How did you mean it, Bronwyn?
What do you think
she said to me?
- Nothing.
Just forget I said
anything. Please.
- I don't know why
I came in here.
All you ever do is
make things worse.
- Cole called me last night.
- Fuck.
Ouch. Why?
- Because apparently you
won't return his calls.
- I don't have
anything to say to him
after what Jake did to me.
- Well, his family still
owns half the town.
They can make our lives hell.
Vanessa might not be
the only one who thinks
that things don't add up.
You refusing to talk to Cole,
it's making him suspicious.
- Him, Mom?
Or you?
- I'm just looking out for you.
Your best move is to act normal.
You should be sympathetic
to his family's tragedy.
Addy, are you listening?
- Yeah, um,
sympathetic. Got it.
- Why the fuck would Simon
Says even want one of us
to wear the watch?
- Because if someone saw
Jake wear it on Halloween,
and one of us wears
it, we look guilty.
- Sure, but if
Cole is Simon Says,
how would he even know if
we're wearing the watch?
- Maybe he has
spies on the inside.
- Okay, we're getting paranoid.
- What should we be?
- Okay, Addy wearing it
would be the least suspicious
in terms of an explanation
because he could have
given it to you that night.
- I can't wear it.
I'm seeing Cole after school.
- You're seeing Cole?
Why?
- He won't stop calling.
And this way, I can see if
he was home on Halloween.
But somebody needs to take it.
- I've got it. It's just
a man's watch, right?
Done.
- Okay, but you have to
show it a little more.
We'll be watching
to see who notices.
- I was kind of hoping
nobody would notice.
- Coop?
Coop!
- Hey.
- I have amazing news.
- Okay.
- You are booked on the
Tom Prestin show today.
- Whoa, slow down. How?
- My internship.
It's mostly getting
people coffee,
but last week, one of
the producers asked
if I had any ideas for a
new spin on the Jake story,
because Tom is obsessed,
and don't be mad,
but I pitched you
as a unique angle,
the gay baseball
star outed by murder.
I thought they forgot until
today's guest canceled,
and, well, you're on.
- Um, wait, does it
have to be today?
- Yeah, it has to be today.
And I don't want to pull
the fake girlfriend card,
but you do owe me.
- Sure.
Yeah, why not?
- Okay, awesome.
Thank you.
Oh, wow, new bling, huh?
- Justice for Jake
rally tomorrow night.
We are crowdsourcing
the search for truth.
Bayview phenom Cooper Clay
and Jake's so-called
best friend,
do you want justice for Jake?
- Leave me alone, Vanessa.
- "Leave me alone, Vanessa"?
I will not.
- Hey, can I
possibly talk to you?
- Yeah, what more could
you possibly say, Janae?
- I'm really sorry,
was my opener.
- Okay.
You're sorry.
So then tell me what you were
doing last night, the truth.
- I...
- Great.
- Hey.
Janae, are you ready?
- Yeah.
- You sure you want
to go in there?
- No.
I have to.
Keep your phone in your pocket.
Mine will be on mute,
but I'll hear if anything
goes horribly wrong.
- Thank you.
Do we need a code word?
Like what if he's silently
pointing a gun at me and...
- Yes. How about,
"Don't kill me"?
- Yeah.
Yeah, that works.
Okay.
- Thank you for coming.
- Uh, for your mom.
I know she loves Blue Bell's.
- She actually hasn't eaten
anything since Jake left,
but thank you for the gesture.
- Sorry.
- Yeah, she's, um...
She's falling apart.
I'm getting pretty worried
that if we don't find him soon,
it'll actually kill her.
- Wow, more blood on your hands.
Addy, we need answers.
- I wish I could help.
- Well, he must
have said something.
You must have noticed
something, please?
Okay, no detail is too small.
- Are you really this cruel?
They deserve the truth, Addy.
Tell him.
- I can't.
- Where did you last see him?
- Uh...
um...
his room, I think.
- Well, what happened?
You were fighting?
- No, he was in a good mood.
You know how he loves
throwing a party.
I actually thought he said
you were coming home for it.
Did you?
- Why would I come home for a
high school Halloween party?
- I don't know.
So when was the last
time that you saw him?
- You're here to answer
my questions, okay?
Not the other way around.
- Can I use your bathroom?
- Addy?
What are you doing?
- Mrs. Riordan, um...
I was just talking to Cole.
- About Jake?
There's nothing worse than
not knowing, is there?
Not knowing if we'll
ever see him again.
You really haven't
heard from him?
- Look at her.
Look what you're
doing to my mother.
- I don't believe Jake would
leave without telling me.
- I don't understand it either.
- You miss him too, don't you?
Will you tell him?
Tell him you want
him to come home?
And maybe he'll listen to you.
- How would I...
- You can post it.
I'm sure he'll be watching you.
- Everything okay down here?
- Cole, Addy just said
she would make a plea
for Jake to come home.
- Why don't you go to bed, Mom?
Addy and I need to have a talk.
Whatever you're up to,
I'm gonna find out.
- My family's always
been so good to you.
You owe him the truth, Addy.
- I have to go.
- We're not done here.
- I think I am.
Excuse me.
Drive, please.
- Addy, you're not really
going to make a plea to Jake.
- No, no, but I couldn't
say that to her face.
She was unhinged.
- Oh, my God, and
Cole sounded insane.
- Yeah, but the opposite,
like very hinged,
like he would kill you,
but he'd know exactly
what he was doing.
- There will probably
be a few questions
about the events leading
up to World War II,
which were?
Nate.
- What?
- Playing dumb and looking
hot won't work on me.
- I am not playing dumb. I'm
just a little distracted.
- Anything I can help with?
- No, it's definitely
above your pay grade.
Just shit at home.
- Right, family.
- Yeah.
I gotta leave, but zero income.
- The drug thing dried up?
- Yeah, I had to get
out of that, so...
- My dad owns a restaurant.
High-end, great tips.
If you're looking
for an honest buck.
- I mean, he would hire a guy
just released from prison...
- You were exonerated.
You're #HotAndlnnocent.
- Oh, my God, please.
- Although, I suspect
you're not that innocent.
- And you'd be right about that.
But I didn't kill Simon.
- I know, but
honestly, if you had,
the guy was an asshole.
Yeah.
What are we onto next?
- I thought you had tutoring.
- It finished.
- Well, I'm really sorry
you wasted your time,
but we're too late.
- Too late, huh?
It's too late to get
into the theater.
But one thing criminals
get really good at
is finding security cameras.
- It's worth a try.
- Hell yeah.
- Well, we'll need a story.
So I'm walking out, right?
And then he came out of
nowhere, and he had a knife,
and he threatened me, and
I didn't know what to do.
- Sounds like you
should call the police.
- I did call them,
but they said they couldn't
do anything because...
- Shit. A little help, man?
I just spilled a bunch
of wine back here.
I think it needs a mop.
- Yeah, here.
- You're gonna have
to pay for this.
- What do you mean? I'm
not paying for this.
It was a fucking accident.
- You broke it.
You own it.
- Shit, shit, shit, shit.
- What do you think I mean?
Because you broke
it, you own it.
- You don't accept checks
here. That's all I got, man.
- Do you have a check?
- Yeah.
- Was is it, 1995?
- Shit.
- It's my dad's checkbook.
- Your dad?
- Yeah, I don't have cash.
Yeah, you go do that.
- Hey!
- Sorry!
Thank you.
- Don't ever come back!
- There, there, there, there.
Holy shit.
That was fucking close.
- That was fucking awesome.
Okay, check this out.
Timestamp says two hours
before we got to the theater.
- Isn't that the mask Janae
was wearing on Halloween?
- Yes.
- Oh, no. You got me.
I'm Simon Says.
I put on that
weird fucking mask,
and then I made a deepfake
of my best friend,
and then I torched a theater,
yeah, mystery solved.
- Janae, stop.
We're not accusing you
of being Simon Says.
- She is.
- I just want to know
where the mask is.
- I gave it to Cooper
to give back to Kris.
- Kris?
- It's not Kris.
- I didn't say it was, okay?
But maybe we should talk to him.
- Yeah, yeah, we totally should.
And you know what?
I will do it.
Unless you don't trust me.
- Just let us know what he says.
- Okay, but besides the
shoes, how do I look?
- Actually, the watch,
it isn't really you.
- Where'd you get that from?
- It's just a gift
from a friend.
- It's just sort of flashy.
We want your brand
to be more relatable.
- Yeah, she's right.
Yeah, take it off.
- Take it off?
- Yeah, take it off.
- Come on, we got to go.
- Ready?
- One sec, thank you.
- Coop, seriously.
Hurry up.
- I want to keep the watch.
- Watch off now.
- I can cover it.
- Hey, buddy, it's gone.
It sends the wrong message.
- I like the watch.
Let me keep the watch.
- We really need you on set.
- Yeah, one sec.
- Okay, Coop.
- Okay, okay.
- Come on.
- Got it.
- Hurry.
- Okay, all right.
- Come on.
- Cooper Clay, a
senior at Bayview High,
should be known
for his fastball,
which has made him the number
eight prospect in the country
according to ESPN.
But lately, a shadow
has been cast over
this young phenom's bright star.
He was a person of interest
in the murder of Simon Kelleher,
and in the course of
the investigation,
was forced to come out as gay.
Cooper, we have a
lot to talk about,
but let's start there.
Do you think that
the police mishandled
their investigation?
- Look, everyone wants to
come out on their own terms,
and that right
was taken from me.
Okay, now I would be lying
if I said that wasn't hard,
but I also understand
that the police were
just trying to do
their job and find out
who killed Simon
Kelleher, which they did.
Now we just... we
need them to find Jake
and bring him home so
that justice can be served
and I can get back to
talking about being
the number eight
prospect in the country.
Right,
I'll take the hint.
- Yeah.
- So tell me about
your prospects.
There haven't been any
baseball players who were out
while playing in the majors.
Do you think that coming out
hurts your chances of going pro?
- I thought it would.
That's why I kept it
quiet for so long.
But thankfully,
people have been
really supportive,
my family, teammates, fans.
- Your boyfriend?
Tell us about him.
- Um...
Kris is the...
the kindest, most
beautiful person
I've ever met.
He's never been
anybody but himself.
He's an inspiration
to me every day.
- Oh, my God, Cooper.
It's open.
Girl, why is you in my room?
- Okay, um, look, the
masks from Halloween,
did Cooper give
them back to you?
Do you still have them?
- No, girl, you crazy?
I burned them.
And I'm really trying to be done
with all of this.
I don't want anything to
do with what y'all did.
- He told you?
- Look, just tell him
the masks are gone.
Okay, I don't have them.
And tell him he looked
cute on "Tom Prestin"
or whatever.
- Kris, did you guys break up?
- That's none of your...
Janae, you need to
go, please, please.
- Just, can you tell me
where you got the masks,
who else could have one?
- Baby, anybody who shops
at Party Depot, okay?
The mask's cheap.
Anybody could've got it.
Oh, my God.
- I'm still getting
used to living honestly.
I thought that I may never
get to live my real life.
Baseball is America's sport,
and America is changing.
That's a good thing.
- Fuck yeah, Cooper.
- Take your time.
- Oh, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- All I want is to play
the game that I love
and love who I love,
plain and simple.
- Yes, please.
Oh, fuck.
- Janae?
Ah, no, no, stop! Please!
Mom, help! Please let me go!
Please let me go! I
didn't do anything!
Mom, ahh!
No,
wait, wait, wait.
- Cooper took it off.
It's not my fault.
Please, stop!
No, please!
Tell me what you
want. I can explain!
No!
Surprise!
- What we want is for you
to come back to cheer.
- Keely.
- Yeah?
- What the fuck?
- We thought it would be funny.
- Who thought it
would... Vanessa.
- When I couldn't
convince you, she said,
"Let's remind Addy how
much fun we have in cheer."
Come on, please?
- Come on, please?
- Come on, Addy.
- Come on.
- Oh, come on.
- Okay, yeah.
- Hey, Adds, you're definitely
gonna want to watch
my live tonight.
It's major.
Welcome back to the squad.
- It's so good to have you back.
- #HomeRunCooper.
You got, like, 200
more followers tonight.
- Since when are you on Twitter?
- You know, I'm trying.
- Hey, kiddo, you
said some things,
you know, um...
Tom threw some curveballs
at you, you know?
But you handled it.
You did good.
Internet's loving you, Coop.
Ready to eat?
Buddy? Food?
- Yeah, I'll be right there.
Yeah.
- Okay, you guys, I
just got a hot tip
from an incredibly perceptive
member of our army,
and it looks pretty fucking
bad for Murder Club.
This was at Jake's
Halloween party,
mere hours before
he disappeared.
See, he's holding up
his glass of whiskey.
He's having a good time,
but what I want you to
look at is his wrist.
See that watch?
Guess who was wearing
that same watch
today at school.
Cooper Clay.
And he was flaunting
it, honestly.
I mean, what is that,
some sort of sick trophy?
What really happened
to Jake on Halloween?
If you have photos
from that night,
we want them, in focus, out
of focus, sober, wasted.
I don't care.
And remember, come
show your support
at the Justice for Jake
rally tomorrow night.
- Why the fuck is Cooper
wearing Jake's watch?
- I don't know.
I don't even think
it's Jake's watch.
Vanessa's full of shit.
- Yeah, or it might
be Jake's exact watch
that Janae got off of
her boat last night
'cause Jake's not in Mexico.
He's in her fucking freezer.
Oh, I'm right, aren't I?
Oh, this is so much worse
than anything I imagined.
- Maeve, please,
just leave it alone, okay?
You don't want to know.
- But I already know, Bronwyn.
I saw your text with Janae,
and then I went on her boat,
and I saw the lock
on the freezer.
Who the fuck puts a
lock on their freezer?
So yeah, I put it together.
You guys killed him,
and now you're trying
to cover it up.
Why wouldn't you tell me?
- I'm so sorry, Maeve.
- Did Janae do it?
Which one of you...
- It was all of us, okay?
He was gonna kill us,
and we had no choice.
And you're not the
only one that knows.
Someone else knows too,
and they're blackmailing us.
And all I wanted
was to protect you
because this is fucked up!
And once you know this,
you cannot unknow it.
And you can't tell anyone else
that you know about this, okay?
Not even Janae.
Are you okay?
Maeve?
Please say something.
- Obviously I'm
not okay, Bronwyn.
But I will be...
because you clearly
need my help.
- Why did you take
the watch off?
- It was Keely's idea.
Okay, she insisted on it, and
I couldn't exactly explain
why I wanted to keep it on.
- Keely told you to take it off?
- Yeah.
- Could it have been a test?
- Keely's not Simon
Says. Cole is.
- We don't know that.
- Okay, here's what we do know.
Vanessa got sent that
photo as a consequence
for taking the watch off,
so the answer to who Simon
Says is is on her phone.
- Great, yeah, our lives
are in Vanessa's hands.
This is truly the
worst timeline.
- Okay, so do we just go
to Vanessa's Justice
for Jake rally tonight
and, in the midst of all
the bullshit and chaos,
try to get her phone?
- I have to be there anyway.
- What?
- Why?
- Fiona got me a
job at Victor's.
I start tonight.
Victor is her dad.
- Oh, wow.
That's extremely nice of her.
- We should all go.
Okay, make it look like
we have nothing to hide.
- Even though we do.
- I liked it better
when you were in denial.
I'm with Cooper. I
think we should go.
- Wait, I have to say something.
I don't want to be a narc,
but I think it's important
that we're all on the
same page about some shit
since our lives are
literally on the line.
Somebody here broke the most
important rule of Murder Club.
Someone told what
happened on Halloween.
- Okay, I didn't tell
Maeve. She figured it out.
- Wait, Maeve knows?
I was talking about Cooper
because he told Kris.
- Wait, you saw Kris? Why
didn't you come to me?
- See? They told.
You can too.
- Okay, look, I was
supposed to be done lying.
I had to tell Kris.
- We really suck at this.
- You and Janae
lied about the body.
- And you and Nate went
rogue to the bodega,
and then you thought
that I was Simon Says
because of the mask.
- What mask?
- Guys, stop.
If we act like this,
we're all doomed.
- She's right.
We need to hold
our shit together
long enough to catch Simon Says.
Then we can get on
with our fucking lives
and never talk to
each other ever again.
- That's the spirit.
- Whatever.
- You can end this torment
tonight for everyone,
Addy, if you just
tell the truth.
- What are you doing?
- Following you.
- There's really no need.
- I know you know about
Jake, which means you know
why I had to say what
I said on the boat
and that I didn't
mean any of it.
- Yeah, well, sometimes,
people say the truth
when they're trying
to lie, so...
- Not me.
The truth is I cannot
stop thinking about you.
And I...
I hate myself for what I did.
- It really fucking hurt.
- I don't deserve
to be forgiven.
- What if I am transferring
my feelings for
Simon onto you...
and it is weird and fucked up?
- I don't care.
- What are you doing tonight?
- I'm going to the
Justice for Jake rally.
- Oh, my God, you guys, what
a great fucking turnout,
Justice for Jake
fans and followers.
Let's thank Victor
for hosting us.
This is not just
a party, you guys.
This is an organized
search for truth,
to answer one question.
What really happened
on Halloween night?
And, army, we can find
the truth together.
We won't give up, and
we won't let the haters
tell us we're wrong.
- Wheeler's here.
- Should she really be
legitimizing this whole thing?
- I just don't think she wants
to admit she got it wrong.
She really wants
us to be guilty.
- I'm sure it would
mean the world to Jake.
Now I'm going to
hand the mic off
to Jake's brother, Cole,
who has a huge announcement
to get us started.
- Thank you, Vanessa,
Victor, all of you.
You know, when Jake
and I were younger,
I used to think,
why would I want
my annoying little
brother around?
But now I would do anything...
To have him by my side again.
So my family is offering
a $100,000 reward
for any information
that leads to finding him.
- Thank you, Cole.
$100,000, you guys.
That is a lot of money.
- Want to split it?
- That's not funny.
- It's kind of funny.
- Okay, Bronwyn's
going for the phone.
- Oh, well, if it
isn't the president
of Murder Club herself.
- I have something
to say to your army.
- By all means, Bronwyn.
Whoa, what are you doing?
- I want to hold it, so I
can have the right angle,
make sure it's on my good side.
You would know.
- I would know.
Yeah, no, we all
know that you're bad
through and through, Bronwyn,
so what do you want to say?
- Fuck you, Vanessa.
That was rude.
- Of course, that
looked like a disaster.
Okay, uh, wish me luck.
- Why?
- I am joining Vanessa's army.
- I want to say thank you.
- Justice for Jake,
shouldn't be here.
- How you doing, bro?
- Hey, easy, my pitching arm.
- Oh, I just want
to see the watch.
- There.
- Take it off.
- Excuse me?
- I can't see it.
So why do you have
my brother's watch?
Just not one like it, his watch.
- He gave it to me on Halloween.
- Bullshit.
- No, I saw him give
Cooper the watch.
He was drunk.
Maybe he already knew he
was going off to Mexico.
He was being sentimental.
Drunk
does sound like Jake.
Sentimental?
Hmm.
Addy, don't you
think now would be
a good time for you
to make your appeal
to Jake to come home?
- Uh, I don't think
Vanessa would want
me to step on her event.
- Oh, no, I already asked her.
She thinks it's a great idea.
Great.
- You good?
- Mm-hmm.
- You know, I just love
how you used that picture
of Jake that I sent in.
- You?
- You said there was plenty
of room in your army,
so here I am.
Right.
I'm supposed to believe
you're Evilseed69?
How dumb do you
think I am, Maeve?
- Honestly, dumber than
you even know, Vanessa.
- Hmm.
- So Vanessa's source
for the Halloween photo
was someone named Evilseed69.
And it looks like it
came from a troll farm,
which means that
whoever sent it in
clearly doesn't
want to be found.
- So we think that's Simon Says?
- If I could have
everybody's attention,
if you want to join
us in the room,
everyone outside
as well, please.
I would like to take this moment
to introduce Addy Prentiss.
She's the love of Jake's life,
and she has something that
she wants to say to him.
I know we all hope
that he's listening,
wherever he is.
- Oh, no.
- What?
- No, she said she
wasn't gonna do that.
- This is your moment, babe.
Just tell the truth.
It's the only way
to get rid of me.
- There have been so many lies
and rumors about Jake
since he disappeared.
And I understand
the Riordan family
want him to come home.
So tonight...
I think it's time for
me to tell the truth...
To them and to myself.
- That's my girl.
- This is hard for
me to say, but...
Jake killed Simon.
Yeah, Jake is a
horrible, damaged person.
So, Jake, wherever you are,
don't come home.
Don't come back.
I never want to see you again.
- They are hiding something.
I know it.
- I'm starting to
think you're right.
We're gonna find out what.