JAG (1995–2005): Season 5, Episode 12 - Into the Breech - full transcript
Ten years after an explosion took place inside a gun turret aboard a US Navy battleship, some student cadets at a naval academy conduct a mock trial to prosecute the sailor largely believed responsible for the 29 resulting deaths (including the supposed perpetrator). Admiral Chegwidden sends Harm and Mac to advise the students -- Harm on the prosecution, Mac on the defense. The students continue to investigate, and -- with some help from Harm, Mac, Bud, and Gunny Galindez -- discover a material witness who was never interviewed during the official investigation; the witness belatedly provides clarifying but devastating testimony about the cause of the explosion. Meanwhile a civilian advertising production team tries to shoot a Navy recruiting commercial onsite using Harm and Bud, with predictably less than easy sailing.
to congressional critics
who call these
battleships dinosaurs
that have outlived
their usefulness?
Ms. Conlan, these
battleships remain
one of the most powerful
weapons systems
in the history of warfare.
Our 16-inch guns can
hit a target 25 miles away
with a projectile as heavy as a
small car and a lot more lethal
as you shall see.
Lieutenant, pass the word
to man up gun stations.
Aye, aye, sir.
General quarters,
General quarters.
All hands man your battle
stations for gunnery exercise.
Load one round!
Load one round!
Aye, aye.
Keep it coming, keep it coming.
Whoa.
Gun turrets, are you
loaded and cycled?
Gun turret three,
rounds at the ready.
Gun turret two,
rounds at the ready.
Gun turret one...
rounds at the ready.
One round spotting.
Fire in rotation, local control.
One round spotting,
aye, aye, sir.
Gun turret three... fire.
Turret three, fire, aye.
Gun turret two... fire.
Turret two, fire, aye.
Gun turret one... fire.
Gun turret one... fire, aye.
(indistinct emergency
PA announcement)
RABB: Isn't it
true you confessed
to the FBI?
Yes, but...
but now, you deny selling
secrets... nuclear secrets...
To the north Koreans.
Yes, sir.
So, were you lying then
or are you lying now?
Then... uh, now.
But how do you...?
You know, I ca...
This is ridiculous.
I... this is really not real.
I can't do this.
Cut!
Reset!
Okay, back to one. Reset.
Hey, Brian, how we looking?
Of course, it isn't real.
With all due respect, Commander
your reality is boring.
Ma'am, this scenario
does not address
the fine points of military law.
Unauthorized absence,
insubordinate conduct?
It sounds like we're
back in high school.
Missing a movement...
What is that?
Is that a crime or
an intestinal ailment?
Miss Petersen, you apparently
don't understand
what JAG lawyers do.
You don't do anything.
You don't fire torpedoes
or storm beaches.
You... talk.
Is there a problem here?
Sir...
Yeah, I'll tell you, General.
Admiral.
Whatever.
The problem is that the Navy
is 18,000 sailors short
and can't fill its quota.
The problem is that
I have been hired to shoot
a recruiting commercial
and rather than
be given Navy pilots
or Navy Seals, like a
certain feature director
I was given Navy lawyers.
I see.
Miss Petersen, could you
excuse us for a moment?
Why not?
Lunch. Half hour.
That's lunch! One half hour.
Robert, what I'm trying to do...
Sir...
Uh, Commander,
listen, about your acting.
You need to find an
internal motivation
uh... different levels...
Colors, if you will.
Sir...
Well, I was technical
advisor on Field of Gold
and I picked up a few things.
Weren't you fired
from Field of Gold, sir?
With me, Commander.
Admiral... I-I-I
didn't mean to...
Admiral. Commander.
How would you two like to assist
in the court-martial
of Gunner's Mate Riordan?
Gregory Riordan,
sir? That's right.
Set the explosion aboard
the USS Minnesota.
Charged with 29 counts
of first-degree murder.
Riordan's been dead ten years.
He died in that explosion.
It's a mock court-martial
at Iron Forge Naval Academy.
Prep school, sir?
One that produces
outstanding candidates
for Annapolis, Colonel.
Commandant Haden's
a retired JAG officer
and old friend of mine looking
for a couple of volunteers
to put his students
through their paces.
Colonel, why don't you
assist with the... defense.
Commander...
You can assist with prosecution.
Well, second-chair to
a high school student.
Well, second-chair there.
First-chair with Ms.
Petersen. Your choice.
♪ I wanna be a Navy pilot ♪
CADETS: ♪ I wanna
be a Navy pilot ♪
♪ I wanna fly an F-14 ♪
CADETS: ♪ I
wanna fly an F-14... ♪
We will prove beyond
a reasonable doubt
that the defendant
Gunner's Mate, Second
Class, Gregory Riordan
that man right there
intentionally
caused the explosion
in gun turret one
in a twisted attempt to get
back at shipmates who hazed him
and made him the
butt of cruel jokes.
He placed a homemade
ignition device
between the propellant bags
causing a cataclysmic explosion
in the breech of the gun barrel.
Twenty-nine...
29 of his crew members
died horrible deaths
at that despicable
coward's hands.
Imagine the horror
as a wave of scalding heat
and explosive gases swept
through the turret.
Put yourself in the position
of those brave but
doomed sailors...
Objection.
Improper opening statement.
Sustained.
(WHISPERS): It's
prejudicial to ask the members
to put themselves into
anyone else's shoes.
Counselor?
I'll rephrase, Your Honor.
When considering all the facts
presented in this case
without putting yourself
in anyone else's
shoes, I'm confident
that you'll return with
verdicts of guilty as charged.
Thank you.
The propellant used
in the Minnesota's guns
was manufactured
during World War II
and the summer
before the explosion
had been stored on an
open barge in the sun.
Neither the rammerman
nor the cradle operator
had ever taken part
in a live fire exercise.
Neither was PQS-qualified
and neither attended
a pre-firing briefing that day.
These are only a few
of the factors that could
have caused that explosion...
accidentally.
It was so lame.
You were fine, Luisa.
A little technical, maybe.
Remember, you have
to humanize your client.
Jurors acquit people they like
and convict those
they don't like.
Oh, in that case, we're screwed.
Billy.
Look, Riordan's a scapegoat.
Isn't it obvious?
Well, that's one way to go.
Colonel?
Commander.
We were just going over
the flaws in your case.
What flaws, ma'am?
Try motive... Riordan
blew up the ship
because they hazed him?
Right. Riordan couldn't take it
so he got even the
only way he could.
Ah, I've been punked.
I'm not gonna
blow up the library.
No, you're just
the guy that nearly
kills everyone
at the rifle range.
Commander, have you
ever seen someone try to fire
a rifle with the cleaning
rod still in the barrel?
I'm not sure if I'd want to.
Certainly not at close range.
I never thanked
you for that, did I?
Tompkins, don't make accusations
unless you've got proof
to back it up.
Gentlemen, this pretrial
conference is over.
Commander, see you at lunch?
Mess hall meat loaf?
Wouldn't miss it.
CADET: Riordan's guilty.
It's all in the Board
of Inquiry report, sir.
Those investigators
had it easy, Steve.
They didn't have to submit
to cross examination or a jury.
You're going to have
to prove your case.
MAN (IMITATING GERMAN
ACCENT): I am professor Heinrich Zoeller
Director of Forensics
at the Naval Research
Laboratory in Washington.
I supervised the investigation
into the explosion aboard
the USS Minnesota.
Cadet Armstrong...
I realize that you
are playing a role
but there is no need to sound
like Arnold Schwarzenegger.
(laughing)
Yes, sir.
Professor Zoeller, did you reach
any conclusions as to the cause
of the explosion?
Our tests showed
that the explosion
could be duplicated
only by inserting a chemical
ignition device between the...
What do you call it, Steve?
Propellant bags.
Right.
How would that work, Professor?
A device flexible and small
enough to fit between the bags
would ignite the propellant,
causing the explosion
and we knew that it had
to be made from materials
obtainable on the ship
but couldn't figure
out what was used
until investigators found this.
Your Honor, we'd
like to submit this
as government's exhibit seven.
That's Gregory
Riordan, with a souvenir
he bought on leave in Portugal.
The bota bag is made
from untanned goat skin.
I filled a similar bota
bag with... ethial...?
Ethyl acetate, C4H802
a solvent in common
use on the ship.
Right.
I placed it between two
propellant bags in the lab.
It ate through the
goatskin in minutes
and ignited the propellant.
Kaboom.
And did the investigators
ever find Riordan's bota bag?
They searched the
ship, but never found it.
And that's why your report
named Gregory Riordan
as causing the explosion?
Not only that.
A week before the explosion,
Riordan told a shipmate
he knew how terrorists
could sink the ship...
by causing an explosion
in the gun turret.
Objection. Hearsay.
Technically, you are
correct, Cadet Vasquez
but the statement is contained
in the official inquiry report
which I have
admitted into evidence
for purposes of our exercise.
I'm out of questions.
I mean... your witness.
Gunner's Mate Riordan wasn't
the only one in the gun turret
with access to the propellant
bags, was he, Professor?
No. The cradle operator,
primerman, rammerman
a bunch of others
were around there.
Professor, is it your testimony
that the only way to cause
an explosion in the gun turret
is with a flammable solvent
found inside a bota bag?
It's the only one we found.
What about static electricity
igniting the propellant?
Or a misfire where the breech
is prematurely open?
We couldn't duplicate
those in the lab.
But are they possible?
I don't know.
(shuffling papers)
Uh... I guess.
I want to thank you both.
I don't think that there's
a military academy
in the country that could
duplicate the experience
that you're giving my cadets.
Actually, Commander,
we're enjoying it.
It's a relief to try a case
when the verdict doesn't matter.
Oh, it matters to them.
(knocking)
Come in.
At ease.
Sorry to interrupt,
sirs, ma'am, but...
We found a real witness.
Go on.
Terence Conner, sir.
He was a gunner's
mate on the Minnesota.
He's Scott
Armstrong's uncle, sir.
He knew Riordan, and
he's willing to testify.
What do our JAG officers
think about this?
It would add a dose of reality.
And unpredictability.
All right.
Let's have the trial
the Navy never did.
Terence Conner,
Gunner's Mate First Class
honorably discharged.
Aye, aye, sir.
I served aboard the
Minnesota in 1989 and 1990.
So you knew Gregory Riordan?
Sure. I was gun
captain in turret two.
He was captain in one.
You might say
we were competitors.
In what way?
Riordan's team
set the speed record
for loading the 16-inch
gun... 37 seconds.
And did that make him popular?
No. He was a loner
and a perfectionist.
He made extra work
for his crew and everyone else.
That's probably
why he was hazed.
Tell us about the hazing.
Well, it's not much to tell.
He got some blanket
parties thrown in his honor.
Had a blanket
tossed over his head
while a couple of guys
pounded him. And, uh... well...
I heard a few guys
gave him a swirly...
Shoved his head in
the toilet, and flushed.
Objection. (chuckling)
And move to strike as hearsay.
Sustained.
JUDGE: Mr. Conner
you can't repeat what you heard.
Were you present at any hazings?
Well, once or twice, Your Honor.
Well, you can tell us
what you saw or did.
Well, I... I played a
couple of tricks on Riordan
but nothing dangerous.
Nothing that would make him
blow up the ship.
What kind of tricks?
Well, little stuff.
He had this... this
wine bag he liked.
Kind of a souvenir
from Spain or Portugal
or somewhere.
What do I do?
What's the rule?
Never ask a question
unless you know the answer.
Thank you, Mr. Conner.
That's... that's all.
What about the wine
bag, Mr. Conner?
Well, he was proud of the thing.
He used to drink out of it
like it was a canteen
so, uh...
well, I messed with it.
Go on.
I filled it with grease
when he wasn't looking,
and a few of us waited around
and saw him take
a swig out of it.
He cursed all of us out and
threw the bag overboard.
So Riordan no longer
had the wine bag
on the day of the explosion?
No. It was a thousand feet
down and a thousand miles away.
CHEGWIDDEN: You want
to reopen the investigation?
The Navy conducted
hundreds of interviews
performed a countless
number of tests
and spent millions of dollars
and now you want
to do it all over again
based on some sort of evidence
from a kiddie court-martial?
Admiral, the Navy claims
that Riordan used the bota bag
as a combination
timer-ignition device.
If the bag was thrown
overboard prior to the explosion
there's no case.
You two have seen
enough investigations
to know that not all loose ends
are tied up in
pretty, neat bows.
Hell, Riordan was a...
was a gunner's mate.
He could have used
some other method
to ignite the propellant.
Then, respectfully, sir
let the Navy prove it.
What the hell is
going on down there?
You're supposed to be teaching
a bunch of high school students
the basics of military justice
not fomenting some
damn revolution.
Now, just finish the mock trial
get your butts back here
and get back to work
like everybody else.
Ms. Petersen
is this... is this
really necessary?
Well, we could tell everyone
you're the Navy's secret weapon.
You blind your enemies
with the glare from your head.
Look at this, Admiral.
Navy Seals.
Someone who can
go hard or go home.
Not a lot of people
know what the Seal does.
I kind of like the idea of that.
How am I supposed
to compete with that?
Ms. Petersen...
the Navy is not just
about its warriors.
Most of the 400,000
men and women in
uniform will never see
a single day of combat
God willing.
Now, maybe their
expertise is engineering
or electronics or
nuclear propulsion.
Whatever their specialty
they are essential to
our national security.
The Navy can't function
without its cooks.
They can't function
without its...
its doctors
its mechanics, its lawyers...
trained in the art of war
and the profession of peace.
Admiral, you have
great presence.
But it's too hokey
it would never sell.
Okay, ready to go again.
Hugo, let's tilt the
light off his head.
Is there a mocha on the set?
Right face!
Forward, halt!
Order, halt!
Platoon, dismissed!
Aye, aye, sir!
Tompkins, are you sure
you want to be a Marine?
No, sir, my father
wants me to be a Marine.
I want to be a lawyer.
Commander, what
did the admiral say?
The admiral has told
us to put a lid on it.
Well, that's not fair.
It is disappointing, sir.
An order is an order.
No use crying about it.
It's not an order to us. We
don't work for that admiral.
We're still running
a court-martial here.
You're always looking
for a loophole, Tompkins.
It is true.
You could keep doing
what you're doing.
Going over documents,
looking for inconsistencies,
new leads, possible witnesses...
at the very least, it would be
a good learning experience.
Yeah, especially if
we get court-martialed.
Well, I don't
understand, Commander.
Why would we want
to find witnesses
who will trash our case?
We should all have
the same goal...
To find the truth.
We have names and
social security numbers
of all 1,500 crew members.
I can use people
search on the internet.
There have to be some
within driving distance.
Ma'am...
sir.
Luisa...
so am I going to
see you tonight?
I don't know, Steve.
Billy and I have to
prepare for tomorrow.
You've been spending a
lot of time with that loser.
He's my client.
Teenagers.
STEVE: Hey, Luisa, wait up!
Yeah.
Remember what it was like, Harm?
Trying to figure out who
you are? Where you fit in?
Or did that just
come easy to you?
You know, sometimes I think
I missed out on being a kid.
Having a father that was M.I.A.
I was always trying to be the
man of the house, you know
and I guess I should
have been at a disco.
Yeah, I know what you mean.
I've seen you dance.
He's here.
Your Honor.
The defense has
found a crew member
who was outside the gun
turret on the day of the explosion.
We'd like permission
to call him out of order.
This is getting
complicated, Cadet Vasquez.
Are there any objections?
No. Yes, sir.
Call your witness.
Shepard Carman.
They call me Shep.
I was a master chief
on the Minnesota
'till they mothballed her.
So, you were aboard the ship
the morning of March 20, 1990?
That's right, Miss.
I was down on deck five
checking out some
refrigeration equipment.
Uh, you get much lower than that
and you'll be
hanging on to the keel.
What did you observe?
The powder flat hatch flew open
and this sailor... I
don't know his name...
Came running out of turret
one with a bloody nose.
Well, 15 minutes later
that turret blew up.
I figured that was
the luckiest nosebleed
in this man's Navy.
Did you tell the
Navy's investigators
what you saw that morning?
You bet... about that
and that old gal's steam
leaks and corroded hatches
and electrical short
circuits and, uh...
and the bad brakes
on the hoist cars.
So, you're a safety
expert, Mr. Carman?
Self-taught.
The Navy considered me
a "mess management specialist."
I ran the galley.
Nothing further.
That's it?
Don't you want to see
the documentation?
Now, I wrote the captain
and the fleet commander
and the SecNav.
I told them
what caused that explosion.
It was a "HERF" gun.
"High energy radio frequency."
You see, the Ruskies
had a sub in the area.
Well, they surfaced
and bleeped us
with those electro gizmos.
(phone ringing)
Lieutenant Roberts.
Bud, it's Harm.
You think you could locate
the medical records
of the Minnesota?
Uh, sure, they'd be archived
at the Navy Yard in D.C.
The index system
there isn't the best
but I have a friend there
who owes me a favor.
See if anybody
reported to Sick Bay
with a bloody nose
on March 20, 1990?
I'll do my best.
Sir, isn't that the day...
That's right, Bud.
That's the day the Sick
Bay became the morgue.
I can't believe Bill
even brought in
that tweaker Carman.
If this was a real court-martial
would you check out his story?
You always follow leads.
Sometimes witnesses who
can hardly find the courthouse
have important information.
All right, flex your knees.
Here, watch me.
Okay?
I can't do that.
MACKENZIE: Okay,
all right, try this.
Double up on the jab,
stick and move, okay?
Try that.
Keep your hands up.
Good.
You're so together, Colonel.
I wish I could be like you.
I'm trying to beat
Steve in court
and he's hitting on me.
I don't know how you do it.
You can compete with men
and retain your femininity.
Well, it's easy.
You just have to do
everything better than they do.
But don't rub their noses in it.
Be smart.
Think like a woman,
but act like a man.
Right... easy.
Anyway, it's better
not to get involved with someone
who you have to see all the time
no matter how you
feel about them.
TOMPKINS: Luisa!
You're not gonna believe it.
What?
I was right.
About what?
Martians did blow
up the gun turret.
Commander Rabb just
heard from his friend at JAG.
And?
15 minutes before the explosion
Petty Officer Michael
Saunders, a gunner's mate
reported to Sick Bay
with a broken nose.
So what?
Maybe he walked into a bulkhead
in the gun turret.
No, no. Saunders
told the corpsman
he tripped over a knee-knocker
near his compartment
which is nowhere near the turret
where Master Chief
Carman saw him
running out bleeding.
So Saunders lied?
Right. And when
we figure out why
we'll know what
happened that day.
Oh, Billy!
(laughs)
Whoo!
Come on. Come on.
"Michael Saunders,
United States Navy, retired
born 8 August, 1911."
I don't think so.
Using the internet to try
and find someone, sir?
Oh, trying. Not succeeding.
When I was a deputy sheriff
I rounded up a few
missing persons
including some who
didn't want to be found.
Gunner's Mate Michael
Saunders discharged from the Navy
ten years ago.
The Bureau of Navy Personnel
doesn't have a current address
and I've already gone through
all the people-search
sites on the net.
That's just a glorified
phone book, sir.
Why don't you try finding him
the old-fashioned way?
Driver's license, court
files, auto registration
real estate records.
I once found a fugitive
by looking in hunting licenses.
The guy never
missed a deer season.
Interesting.
I'd be happy to help you, sir.
BILLY: There were a number of
safety problems aboard the Minnesota.
The guns were over 40 years old.
So was the propellant.
The hoist cars
sometimes crashed.
Training was haphazard.
Petty Officer Riordan
were you a victim of
hazing aboard ship?
There were some guys who
seemed to enjoy tormenting me
but I didn't try to get even.
I would never hurt
innocent people.
Do you know what caused
the explosion in the gun turret?
I only know I didn't do it.
Your witness.
Did you have a lot of friends
on the Minnesota,
Petty Officer Riordan?
A few.
I'm, I'm not all that sociable.
And did you have any enemies?
Well, there were some guys
who didn't seem to like me.
They're all dead
now, aren't they?
Objection: argumentative.
Withdrawn.
Petty Officer Riordan,
back home in Arkansas
did you explode homemade bombs?
I blew up tree stumps
on my family's farm.
So, you know all
about explosives?
I am a gunner's mate, Counselor.
Why did you blow
up those tree stumps?
Well, they're hell on a plow.
The shipmates made your
life hell on earth, didn't they?
What?
Didn't you write
letters home saying that
the hazing was so bad
that your life was
"hell on earth"?
I refer to exhibits 38, "A"
through "F," Your Honor.
Well, I was upset at the time.
And when you were
upset with those shipmates
you blew them up just
like those tree stumps.
No, I didn't have
to seek revenge.
I always knew I was
better than anyone
who tried to hurt me.
ROBERTS: I'm
amazed you found her.
Missing men usually
have ex-wives.
This is the same
address that was listed
on the divorce docket.
What about Saunders' address?
We'll ask her.
Lieutenant, we'll
play Mutt and Jeff.
You want to be
good cop or bad cop?
Well, ah, let's see.
Good cop, absolutely.
Mom!
Go finish your breakfast, honey.
Kimberly Saunders?
What's this about?
Sorry to bother you, ma'am.
We're looking for
Michael Saunders.
Why? Does he owe you money
or did he steal
an aircraft carrier?
We're not at liberty
to say, ma'am.
Neither am I.
We can get a warrant, lady.
Why don't you do that, Sergeant?
Actually, ma'am,
the Navy owes him
three months' pay
and we just want to make
sure that he's going to get it.
And you need a warrant for that?
Ah, he's new. There's nothing
to worry about, ma'am.
Mr. Saunders
isn't in any trouble.
That would be a first.
Try the Little Creek
Tavern in Hampton.
He'll be on one side
of the bar or the other.
Thank you.
PETERSEN: Just what does a
yeoman do, Petty Officer Tiner?
The yeomen are the glue
who hold the Navy together.
In my case, I handle
file management
type the admiral's
correspondence
and arrange his appointments.
You're a clerk?
Yes, but with managerial duties.
The gunny and I reorganized
the entire filing system
from an alphabetical
to a numerical base.
Cut.
And I took this gig over
a job on Animal Planet.
Ms. Petersen?
Let me guess.
You sort the paper clips?
I'm an attorney.
Lieutenant Loren Singer.
I was wondering
if Admiral Chegwidden told
you about the court-martial
I just prosecuted?
No, why would he?
For your recruiting
commercial, of course.
I convicted two
Marines of dueling.
"Dueling"?
As in flintlock
pistols at 20 paces?
More like nine-millimeter
Berettas outside a Newport bar.
So, what was the body count?
The Marines missed each other
but mortally
wounded a traffic light.
They'll each do six
months in the brig.
But the case shows
how versatile JAG
lawyers have to be.
The Marines had a friend
videotape the whole thing.
Have you tried Jerry Springer?
Slow night.
Can't tell one from another.
What can I get you?
Whatever's on tap.
You ever in the Navy?
Ah, I got one of those faces.
A lot of folks think
they know me.
Served on the
Minnesota, didn't you?
You got me mixed up.
Gunner's Mate Saunders.
And you'd be a cop, right?
You got NCIS
written all over you.
I'm with JAG,
but it's not official.
Well, how'd you find me?
My ex?
My boy doing okay?
He's good.
I haven't been
out there in a while.
This is about the
Minnesota, Mr. Saunders.
Oh, man, that was
a long time ago.
March 20, 1990
you broke your nose.
Yeah.
You told a corpsman in
Sick Bay that you broke it
near your berthing compartment.
The ship blew up that day.
29 men died.
Why are you worried about
where I broke my nose?
Where did you break it?
In my berthing compartment.
We have witness who says
you broke it in gun turret one.
Why would you lie?
'Cause I broke it in a fight.
Who'd you fight?
Greg Riordan, the guy
who blew up the ship.
The night before,
that was the worst.
(grunts)
We threw a little blanket party.
Pounded him pretty good.
Then we carried him
up on the main deck.
He was crying like a baby.
(sobbing)
We picked him up by the ankles
had him over the rails
let him dangle there,
right over the screws.
Do it. Do it.
SAUNDERS: He was
sobbing, swearing, yelling...
He said he'd get even.
He swore he'd kill us all.
(knocking)
Enter.
Excuse me, Admiral,
I know you're busy
with the law of the sea
or the Treaty of
Versailles or whatever...
What is it, Ms. Peterson?
I've won two Cleos.
I directed an independent film
that was shown at Sundance
and yet still I can't find a way
to make this work, so I quit.
Ms. Peterson, have you
explored every option?
Lieutenant Roberts here
he's third-generation Navy.
His grandfather served
on a battleship.
His father was a master chief.
I'm not doing the
Pillsbury Doughboy.
Oh, oh.
I am, I am so sorry.
I'm not usually like this.
Look, your Commander
Rabb almost works
if only he'd done something
else besides practice law.
Well, actually...
Female on deck.
Luisa, what are
you doing in here?
Thinking like a woman,
acting like a man.
Did Steve do this to you?
Can we talk about
this someplace else?
You should report him.
No.
You can't let him
get away with this.
He won't.
I'll beat him in the courtroom.
Not if that means winning
an acquittal for Riordan.
At ease.
What happened, Commander?
Did you find Michael Saunders?
We did.
Billy, what happened
to your eye?
I saluted too hard, ma'am.
What did he say, sir?
He buried Riordan.
TOMPKINS: Maybe he's lying, sir?
Could he have told a different
story to anyone else, sir?
His ex-wife Kimberly in Norfolk.
Norfolk?
Wait, wait, wait a minute, sir.
Okay, here it is.
Exhibit 477-B: a postcard sent
to Greg Riordan in March 1990
a few days before the explosion.
Investigators
found it in his locker.
Postmarked Norfolk.
"See you in port. Can't wait!
I love you, Kimberly."
Kimberly loves Riordan.
Kimberly marries
Saunders after Riordan dies.
Saunders told me
that he and Riordan
were fighting over hazing.
Hi, is your mom home?
Ma'am?
Reinforcements?
I'm Commander Rabb, ma'am.
This is Lieutenant
Colonel McKenzie.
We're with the JAG Corps.
We'd like to ask you a
few questions if we could.
Look, I have to help my
son finish his homework.
This won't take long.
We have questions
about Greg Riordan.
About me? No,
son, not about you.
But I'm Greg Riordan.
Why don't you two come
in for a cup of coffee.
I was young and I
thought it was fun
having two sailors
fight over me.
Michael Saunders
and Greg Riordan?
Hmm.
One boyfriend too many.
When I finally figured
that out, I chose Greg.
An odd time to kill yourself
when you finally get
the woman you want.
That's what I always thought.
But it's tough to
argue with the Navy.
So far, I've shielded Greg, Jr.
From what they
say about his father.
Saunders led me to believe
that he was the child's father.
He wasn't a bad substitute...
when he was sober.
Michael is the only
father that Greg knows
and they love each other.
He stops by once in a while
and takes him fishing or camping.
You married Saunders
after the explosion?
I was four months pregnant
when Greg came
home in a body bag.
Greg, Jr. needed a father
and I needed somebody, too.
Did Saunders ever talk about
what happened that
morning in the gun turret?
He wasn't there.
Yes, he was.
Oh, my God.
Ah, you I'm done with.
Hi, Dad, can I have a root beer?
Greg, over here.
You know, the boy
shouldn't be in here.
He shouldn't be
seeing me like this.
I'm sure you look great to him.
His other father is
a mass murderer.
He doesn't know about that.
He will.
Someone at school will tell him.
They might even beat him up.
You'd know about
that, wouldn't you?
What do you want from me?
Tell the boy the truth.
Don't let this lie
ruin his life, too.
It's too late.
It's not too late for him.
MAN: It's an honor to
have a distinguished visitor
with us today.
Rear Admiral A.J. Chegwidden
the Judge Advocate General
of the United States Navy.
Are you ready to
proceed, Cadet Vasquez?
Your Honor, although
both sides have rested
we move to reopen the evidence
to present a final
defense witness.
This has gone on long enough.
Motion Denied.
Commandant Haden,
may I be heard?
Of course, Admiral.
I came here today
because I understood
that you might
hear from a witness
who never spoke to
the Board of Inquiry.
The Navy did the
best job it could
but if there's a chance
that we committed a
miscarriage of justice
no matter how innocently
we want it corrected.
Call your witness.
Thank you, Your Honor.
The defense calls
Michael Saunders.
Raise your right hand.
Do you swear the evidence
you are about to give
is the truth, the whole truth
and nothing but the
truth, so help you God?
I do.
Be seated.
State your name and
rank for the record, sir.
Michael Saunders.
I was gunner's
mate, second class
aboard the USS Minnesota.
Were you aboard ship
on March 20, 1990?
Yes, ma'am.
Did you know Gunner's
Mate Gregory Riordan?
Yes, ma'am.
Ah, we had hazed him...
I hazed him, but
that had nothing to do
with what happened that day.
It was about a woman.
I wanted her. He had her.
What happened in the
gun turret, Mr. Saunders?
Riordan was gun captain
doing a better job than
anybody else, as usual.
I don't know why
I went in there.
I didn't belong there.
I didn't really belong anywhere.
Load one round.
Load one round, aye.
They'd already
loaded the projectile
and the propellant bags
were coming off
the spanning tray.
Riordan put the lead foils
between the first
and second bags
just the way he was supposed to.
And then he saw me...
What are you doing here?
I'm just checking up on you.
I heard they threw
you a little blanket party
last night.
Get out of my turret.
Relax, I'm just
here to help you.
You want to help me? Get out.
And I told him that Kim
had been seeing me
behind his back.
What did you say?
Don't fool yourself, son.
She's only marrying you
because I wouldn't marry her.
It was all a lie.
I just wanted to hurt him.
Anyway, it was the
cradle operator's
first live fire exercise and
he was nervous enough
but I'm sure I didn't
help it by busting in.
Now, I'm not so sure...
but I thought I saw him...
load six bags of
propellant instead of five.
Now, Riordan would
have caught the mistake
but he never saw
it because of me.
Yeah, I could have warned him.
I could have stopped
it, but in that...
split second
I didn't want to.
I never loaded the gun.
It wasn't my fault, right?
VASQUEZ: Mr. Saunders,
what is the effect
of six propellant
bags instead of five?
Too much propellant
over-pressurizes the gun.
I am sorry.
Petty Officer Riordan, on
all specifications against you
this court-martial
finds you not guilty.
This court-martial is adjourned.
Thank you.
Hey, good work.
Nice work, Steven.
Billy...
Congratulations
Cadet Vasquez.
Well done, Cadet Tompkins.
Thanks.
Billy, I was wrong about you.
I know.
What's going to happen to him?
Well...
dereliction of duty
and manslaughter
would both be barred by
the statute of limitations
so the only punishment he'll get
is what he has to
live with every day
for the rest of his life.
Thanks, A.J.
Jerry, good to see you.
You bet.
Colonel, Commander,
correct me if I'm wrong
but didn't I advise you
to drop the investigation?
It wasn't our investigation
to drop, Admiral.
It wasn't?
No, sir. We were simply
sitting second-chair.
Oh, uh, Commander
I almost forgot.
Can you be at the
Washington Monument at 1700?
The Washington
Monument at 1700, sir? Why?
I think she called
it "magic hour."
Ms. Peterson, she says
the light is just perfect then.
Colonel.