Your Worst Nightmare (2014–…): Season 3, Episode 4 - Secret Rage - full transcript

IT'S THE END
OF THE SUMMER

AND THE BEGINNING
OF A NEW CHAPTER

FOR RISING COLLEGE
FRESHMAN SARAH WISNOSKY.

- THANKS, GUYS.
- YOU MADE A WISH, RIGHT?

OF COURSE,
NO 8:00 A. M. CLASSES.

SO WHEN DO YOU
GET YOUR SCHEDULE?

MOVE-IN DAY.

I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU'RE GONNA
BE GONE IN A WEEK.

I WISH YOU COULD COME
FOR HOMECOMING WEEKEND.

IT'D BE SO MUCH FUN.
- ME, TOO.

I MET SARAH WISNOSKY



THE SUMMER BEFORE
MY 9th-GRADE YEAR,

AND ONCE I MET HER,
IT WAS LIKE I MET, LIKE,

A SOUL MATE, IN A WAY.

AND IT WAS JUST AWESOME
TO HAVE SOMEBODY LIKE THAT

WHO YOU COULD JUST
BE YOURSELF WITH.

SO HAVE YOU MADE UP
YOUR MIND ABOUT RUSH?

I THINK I'M GONNA WAIT A YEAR,
SEE HOW IT GOES.

FROM WHAT I HEAR, YOU CAN STILL
GO TO MOST OF THE PARTIES,

EVEN IF
YOU AREN'T PLEDGING.

JUST REMEMBER,
YOU'RE MAJORING IN PSYCHOLOGY,

NOT SOCIALIZING.

THAT'S SUCH
A MOM THING TO SAY.

WE HAD HIGH GPAS,
AND WHEN SHE GRADUATED,

SHE WAS IN NATIONAL
HONOR'S SOCIETY.



THIS IS YOUR FIRST TIME
LEAVING HOME.

AND I'M YOUR MOM.
I'M GONNA WORRY.

- THERE'S NOTHING TO WORRY ABOUT.
- I REMEMBER MY FRESHMAN YEAR.

A FEW KIDS REALLY
WENT OFF THE RAILS

AND GOT
INTO SOME TROUBLE.

NOT ME!

OF COURSE NOT.
WE ALL KNOW THAT.

ALL I'M SAYING IS
BE SAFE AND BE SMART.

BUT NOT TOO SMART.

THOUGH
OLD DOMINION UNIVERSITY

IS THREE HOURS FROM LYNCHBURG,

IT'S NOT LONG BEFORE
SARAH FEELS RIGHT AT HOME,

MAKING NEW FRIENDS,
INCLUDING HER ROOMMATE NICKI.

I AM SO GLAD THAT WE HAVE
SOME CLASSES TOGETHER.

- I KNOW.
- ESPECIALLY BIO.

WE ARE GONNA NEED
TO TRADE NOTES FOR THAT.

WE WERE THE ONLY TWO PEOPLE

FROM OUR HIGH SCHOOLS
TO ATTEND ODU,

SO WE JUST KIND OF
STUCK TOGETHER.

SHE WAS JUST A VERY FUN-LOVING,
GENUINE, WELCOMING SPIRIT.

HEY, DID YOU BRING AN IRON
BY ANY CHANCE?

IT'S SOMEWHERE
AROUND HERE.

MY MOM PACKED IT EVEN THOUGH
I TOLD HER I'D NEVER USE IT.

RIGHT. I HAVE, LIKE,
TWO SHIRTS THAT I IRON.

AND THAT'S IT.

- HERE YOU GO.
- THANKS.

WHO'S THIS GUY?

JASON,
MY BOYFRIEND, SORT OF.

- "SORT OF"?
- WE'RE TAKING A BREAK.

HE'S BACK HOME
AND I'M HERE.

- GOTCHA.
- HE'S A GREAT GUY.

BUT HE'S REALLY THE ONLY GUY
I'VE EVER DATED.

IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU'RE READY
FOR SOMETHING NEW.

EXACTLY.

SHE WAS JUST THE TYPICAL,
YOU KNOW, FRESHMAN.

FIRST TIME AWAY FROM HOME

IN A BIGGER CITY
THAN WHERE SHE GREW UP.

SO IT WAS PROBABLY A VERY
EXCITING TIME FOR HER.

WOW.
THIS ROOM IS HUGE.

- HI.
- HI. I'M NOELLE.

HI. THIS IS RACHEL.

- HEY. IT'S NICE TO MEET YOU.
- NICE TO MEET YOU. I'M AMY.

WE'RE IN THE ROOM NEXT DOOR.
WE JUST WANTED TO COME SAY HI.

THAT'S SO CUTE.
WHAT IS THAT?

THANKS.
IT'S A TURTLE.

I'VE HAD A THING FOR THEM
SINCE I WAS A KID.

RANDOM, I KNOW.

WELL, WE WERE GONNA
HIT THE CAFETERIA

FOR LUNCH THIS AFTERNOON.
DO YOU WANNA COME?

- YEAH. TOTALLY.
- GREAT.

SO LET'S MEET
DOWNSTAIRS AT 1.

- SOUND GOOD? YEAH.
- SOUNDS GOOD. PERFECT.

- WE'LL SEE YA LATER.
- SEE YA. BYE, GUYS.

THEY SEEM COOL.

YEAH.

CLASSES START,

AND SARAH SOON HITS HER STRIDE.

SHE'S READY FOR ANYTHING
COLLEGE MIGHT THROW HER WAY.

OR SO SHE THINKS.

THE LESSON TODAY
IS FROM THE FIRST CHAPTER.

GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE.

WAIT.
WHAT WAS THE LAST ONE?

I'M PRETTY SURE
I GOT EVERYTHING.

YOU SURE DID.

YEAH. I'M GONNA
COPY THIS LATER.

I AM NOT EXCITED
ABOUT THAT LAB REPORT.

IT COULD BE WORSE.

UM, AM I GONNA SEE YOU
AT THE CAFETERIA LATER?

I MIGHT HEAD OVER
TO THE LIBRARY.

I'LL JUST GRAB
A SNACK OR SOMETHING.

OKAY.

SEE YA LATER.
- SEE YA.

HAPPY STUDYING.

SO GOT YOU.

MAN. YOU SHOULD'VE
SEEN YOUR FACE.

- THERE WE GO.
- SCREW YOU GUYS.

SO WHAT DO YOU GUYS
THINK ABOUT CHAD?

WHO? THE R. A.?

I THINK HE'S CUTE.
- YEAH.

HE KIND OF REMINDS ME
OF THE GUY FROM "MELROSE PLACE."

WHAT'S HIS NAME?
- YEAH, THE ONE WHO PLAYS BILLY.

YEP.

HELLO? WHAT DO YOU
THINK ABOUT CHAD?

UM, HE SEEMS NICE,
BUT KIND OF BORING.

WELL, IT'S A GOOD THING
I HATE BORING.

LISTEN, LADIES, I CAME BY

'CAUSE I'M THROWING
A PARTY SATURDAY NIGHT,

AND I WOULD LOVE TO SEE
ALL OF YOU THERE.

- OKAY.
- IT SHE BE A GOOD TIME.

JUST COME AND ENJOY YOURSELF.
THERE'LL BE LIVE MUSIC.

HE CALLED HIMSELF SERF AND SAID

THAT HE WAS A MEMBER
OF THE TKE FRATERNITY.

VERY DOMINANT PERSONALITY.

AND WHAT'S YOUR NAME?

SARAH.

WELL, SARAH.

PROMISE ME I'LL SEE
YOU SATURDAY NIGHT.

MAYBE. WE'LL SEE.

ALL RIGHT.

WELL, LADIES.
SEE YOU SATURDAY... MAYBE.

OKAY.

HE WAS PHYSICALLY FIT.

HE WAS VERY TAN.

IMMEDIATELY, I COULD TELL SHE
LIKED HIS PERSONALITY

FROM THE BEGINNING.

- WHO WAS THAT?
- THAT'S SERF.

- HOW DO YOU KNOW HIM?
- I DON'T.

I JUST HEARD SOME GIRLS
TALKING ABOUT HIM IN CLASS.

LOOKS LIKE SARAH'S
GOT A CRUSH.

WHATEVER.

I'M GONNA GO STUDY.

I'LL SEE YOU GUYS LATER.

THE SATURDAY
OF SERF'S PARTY,

SARAH CAN'T STAY AWAY.

SHE AND HER FRIENDS HEAD
FOR HIS HOUSE OFF CAMPUS.

- HEY.
- HEY, HEY.

HI. I'M LEE.
THIS IS DANIEL.

I'M NOELLE. THIS IS NICKI,
RACHEL, AND THAT'S SARAH.

- WELL, NICE TO MEET YOU ALL.
- UM, COOL HOUSE.

THANKS.
I - - ACTUALLY - -

I ACTUALLY
JUST MOVED IN THIS SUMMER.

BUT, DANIEL'S BEEN HERE
FOR A COUPLE YEARS NOW.

YEAH, YEAH, A COUPLE.

IT'S ALL YOURS
IF YOU WANT IT.

THANKS.

I TAKE IT YOU DON'T,
DRINK MUCH BEER?

- NOT REALLY.
- THAT'S OKAY.

WELL I CAN
GRAB YOU SOMETHING.

WE HAVE VODKA, TEQUILA.

GOT YOU.

- HEY.
- WHAT'S UP?

MAN.
YOU GOT HER THIS?

SERIOUSLY?

DO ME A FAVOR
AND GO GRAB TWO

PREMIUM COLD ONES
OUT OF THE FRIDGE.

- SHE DOESN'T LIKE...
- NO, NO.

I DIDN'T ASK YOU, MAN.
JUST GO AHEAD.

COME ON.
- THANKS.

- GLAD YOU COULD MAKE IT.
- SO YOU GO TO ODU?

NO, I ACTUALLY JUST GOT
MY ARCHITECTURAL

ENGINEER DEGREE
OVER AT RUTGERS.

THAT'S A REALLY
GOOD SCHOOL.

I HAD OFFERS ON THE TABLE
FROM NEW YORK, CHICAGO, BOSTON.

REALLY, YOU NAME IT.

BUT, NATIONAL CALLED ME,
AND THEY WERE LIKE,

"LOOK, SERF, WE NEED YOU
TO GO KINDLE A FIRE

UNDER THESE GUYS, YOU KNOW?
GET 'EM MOTIVATED."

SO PRETTY MUCH BEGGED ME
OVER THE PHONE.

- COULDN'T DENY IT.
- THAT'S SO AWESOME.

HE WAS CLAIMING TO BE

A REPRESENTATIVE OF
THE NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS

OF THIS FRATERNITY,

AND HE WAS VERY GOOD AT IT.

SARAH, THIS IS DREA.
DREA, THIS IS SARAH.

- HI.
- I'M THIRSTY.

CAN YOU GET ME
A DRINK, PLEASE?

YEAH. YEAH, YEAH,
YEAH, YEAH.

I WILL DO THAT.
I'LL BE RIGHT BACK.

I LIKE YOUR DRESS.
IT'S PRETTY.

YOU KNOW HE'S WAY
OUT OF YOUR LEAGUE.

SO, UM...

DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME.

IT'S THE FALL OF 1993.

AND AFTER AN AWKWARD RUN-IN
WITH A FLIRTY FRAT-BOY...

SARAH, THIS IS DREA.
DREA, THIS IS SARAH.

...COLLEGE FRESHMAN
SARAH WISNOSKY THINKS

THAT'S THE LAST OF HIM.

- DON'T DO THAT.
- I'M SORRY.

WHAT DO YOU WANT?

COME ON.
I'M JUST HAVING FUN.

SHE WAS KIND OF
CONSERVATIVE

WHEN IT CAME TO THE GUYS.

IF SHE GOT A BAD VIBE FROM YOU,
SHE WOULD IGNORE YOU.

PSYCH.

GOD, I HATED PSYCH.

I THOUGHT YOU SAID YOU STUDIED
ARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING?

YEAH, I DID, BUT...

ONE OF MY FRATERNITY BROTHERS
WAS A PSYCH MAJOR.

PRETTY MUCH WROTE
ALL OF HIS PAPERS.

POOR KID JUST
COULDN'T SWING IT.

LISTEN. I - -
I FEEL REALLY BAD

ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED
THE OTHER NIGHT.

AND I WANT TO MAKE IT UP TO YOU.
SO WHY DON'T I ORDER A PIZZA

AND YOU COME OVER
TO MY PLACE.

AND WE'LL WATCH A MOVIE
OR SOMETHING?

HANG OUT?
- I DON'T KNOW.

COME ON.
IT'LL BE FUN.

WHAT ABOUT
YOUR GIRLFRIEND?

WHO?

DREA?
NO, NO, NO.

SHE'S NOT MY GIRLFRIEND.
IT'S NOTHING SERIOUS.

I PROMISE.

LOOK, SARAH.
I'M NOT A BAD GUY.

REALLY, I'M NOT.

JUST GIVE ME
ANOTHER CHANCE, OKAY?

I DON'T KNOW HOW
TO SAY THIS REALLY,

- BUT I LIKE YOU.
- I... I DO.

SO... WHAT DO YOU SAY?

J- JUST A MOVIE
AND A PIZZA.

- A BIG PIZZA.
- A BIG PIZZA?

THE BIGGEST PIZZA.

- YEAH.
- WITH WHATEVER YOU WANT ON IT.

- YEAH.
- LET ME MAKE IT UP TO YOU.

OKAY.

SARAH WAS JUST GETTING
TO KNOW NEW PEOPLE,

MEETING, YOU KNOW, BOYS,

AND THAT'S JUST PART
OF THE LIFESTYLE

OF THE FIRST-YEAR FRESHMAN.

HEY.

HEY, HOW'D IT GO?

AWESOME.

I GOT AN A-MINUS
ON MY LIT TEST.

- THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
- CONGRATS.

SO, UM, THE GIRLS AND I,
NOELLE AND RACH,

WE'RE GONNA HEAD OVER
TO THE MALL IN A LITTLE BIT.

AND WE'RE GONNA GO GET
SOME SHOPPING DONE.

I NEED A BUNCH OF SHORTS.
YOU WANNA COME?

THANKS, I ALREADY
HAVE PLANS ACTUALLY.

WITH, UM, SERF?

WELL, UM, JUST PROMISE
YOU'LL CALL OR SOMETHING

IF YOU'RE GONNA BE OUT
ALL NIGHT, OKAY?

PROMISE.
I'LL SEE YOU LATER.

OKAY.

HAVE FUN.

I HAD NEGATIVE FEELINGS
TOWARDS SERF.

HE DID NOT GIVE ME
A GOOD FEELING,

YOU KNOW, IN MY GUT.

SARAH DID NOT FEEL THE SAME WAY.

SHE FELT VERY COMFORTABLE
AROUND HIM.

I LOOK PRETTY GOOD
IN A TUX, DON'T I?

- YEAH.
- HERE YOU GO.

- THANKS.
- CHEERS.

LOOK,
I'M REALLY GLAD YOU CAME.

ME, TOO.

UM, YOU MIND, -

YOU MIND HELPING ME
WITH SOMETHING REAL QUICK?

SURE.

I'VE BEEN TRYING TO HANG THIS
FOR THE LONGEST TIME.

BUT EVERYONE IN THIS
HOUSE IS SO LAZY.

IT'S UNBELIEVABLE.

ALL RIGHT, SO IF YOU WOULD
JUST KIND OF, LIKE,

HOLD IT RIGHT HERE?

- RIGHT HERE? YEAH.
- KIND OF, LIKE, RIGHT THERE.

NICE.

OKAY, NOW JUST RAISE IT
UP A LITTLE BIT.

- IS IT STRAIGHT?
- YEAH. I THINK IT'LL DO.

- WELL, THANK YOU.
- YOU'RE WELCOME.

SO THE MOVIE?

- YEAH.
- ALL RIGHT.

- IS THAT OKAY?
- YEAH.

STILL OKAY?

IS THAT OKAY?

THINGS APPEAR TO BE
GOING WELL FOR SERF AND SARAH.

THAT IS UNTIL LATER THAT WEEK,

WHEN SERF AND HIS FRIENDS
HOST A PARTY.

SARAH, MYSELF
AND OUR SUITE-MATES

ALL ATTENDED A TOGA PARTY.

I HAD NEVER BEEN
TO A TOGA PARTY BEFORE.

I'D ONLY SEEN "ANIMAL HOUSE."

DO ME A FAVOR, RUN

INTERFERENCE FOR ME TONIGHT
- COME ON, MAN.

- YOU'RE ALWAYS GOING THIS.
- JUST DO IT FOR ME, ALL RIGHT?

COME ON, MAN.
I THOUGHT YOU LIKED HER.

HEY, SARAH.

SHOTS.

YEAH.

FILL HER UP.

ALL RIGHT. IT'S LATE.

WE SAID WE WEREN'T
GONNA DRINK TOO MUCH.

COME ON. LET'S GO.

- NO.
- NICKI. SARAH.

I'M HAVING FUN.

- SARAH.
- I'M FINE.

PLEASE, JUST GO.

I'M FINE.
- SHE'S FINE.

SHE WANTED TO STAY.
I MEAN, SHE'S A GROWN WOMAN.

SO I COULDN'T SAY, YOU KNOW...

I HAD NO RIGHT TO TELL HER
SHE HAD TO COME HOME.

- HEY.
- HEY.

YOU GOT SOMETHING
BEHIND YOUR EAR.

WHAT YOU DOING OUT HERE
BY YOURSELF?

I JUST WISH I NEVER
WOULD HAVE MET HIM.

I'M SORRY.

IT SUCKS.

AT LEAST YOU'RE NOT
THE ONLY ONE, RIGHT?

DUDE.

YOU WANNA KNOW
SOMETHING ABOUT SERF?

YEAH, SURE.

I'VE HAD BETTER.

- OUCH.
- IT WAS GROSS.

THE NEXT DAY,
SARAH'S DETERMINED

TO FORGET ALL ABOUT SERF,
BUT HE WON'T LET THAT HAPPEN.

SHE LOVES TURTLES.
SHE LIKED THIS GUY.

AND SHE WAS
INTERESTED IN HIM.

BUT SHE'S MAKING
A DANGEROUS MISTAKE.

SARAH WAS NAIVE,
BUT PROBABLY NO MORE NAIVE

THAN ANY OTHER
17-YEAR-OLD FRESHMAN.

THERE ARE PEOPLE OUT THERE
THAT ARE HORRIBLE HUMAN BEINGS.

HE WOULDN'T LET HER GO.

AFTER A TUMULTUOUS 24 HOURS...

- I'VE HAD BETTER.
- OUCH.

...COLLEGE FRESHMAN
SARAH WISNOSKY

IS READY TO GIVE IT ANOTHER TRY
WITH FRAT-BOY SERF BARNABY.

HEY. SERF.

- WHAT THE HELL?
- I'M SORRY, I KNOCKED.

BUT YOU DIDN'T HEAR ME
'CAUSE YOUR HEADPHONES WERE ON.

ARE YOU OKAY?

YEAH. I'M GOOD.

UM, BESIDES, MY MOM SAID

IF I KEPT IT UP
IT BE DEAF BEFORE I'M 30.

SO YOU'RE DOING ME A FAVOR.
IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU.

WHAT?!

- HEY, MAN.
- LOOK..

HEY.
- HI.

WE JUST WANTED TO SEE
IF YOU WANTED TO RIDE WITH US

TO THE MEETING, MAN.

THAT'S TONIGHT?

YEAH. COME ON.
LET'S GET GOING.

HEY, A LITTLE SPACE,
PLEASE?

COME ON.

GIVE US TIME.

- SEE YA, SARAH.
- BYE

LOOK, I...
I'M SORRY.

I, I HAVE
TO GO TO THIS THING.

- I'LL JUST SEE YOU LATER.
- I HAVE TO DO IT.

THESE THINGS NEVER LAST LONGER
THAN, LIKE, 20 MINUTES.

IN FACT, HERE.
WHY DON'T YOU JUST ORDER A PIZZA

AND I'LL BE BACK
BEFORE YOU KNOW IT.

COOL.

- BYE.
- BYE.

SEE YOU LATER.

- BROTHERS.
- WHAT'S GOING ON?

- IT'S ABOUT DAMN TIME.
- 'SUP?

WHAT'S GOING ON,
BROTHERS?

- HUNGRY.
- HOW'S IT GOING? ALL RIGHT.

THIS IS A LIST
OF EVENTS FOR HOMECOMING,

INCLUDING THE ALUMNI COOKOUT.

LOOK IT OVER.
TELL ME WHAT YOU GUYS THINK.

LOOKS PRETTY GOOD.

BUT CAN'T WE JUST HIRE
SOMEONE TO CLEAN UP FOR US?

IF YOU WANNA PAY FOR IT.

YEAH, I'LL PASS.

HAS ANYONE
SEEN JAKE LATELY?

HE'S SUPPOSED TO GO OVER
THE NEW PLEDGE LIST.

YOU KNOW, I ACTUALLY
SAW HIM A COUPLE DAYS AGO.

TOLD ME HIS GIRLFRIEND
DUMPED HIM.

HE WAS LOOKING
PRETTY ROUGH ABOUT IT.

- THAT'S PATHETIC, MAN.
- WHAT?

SHE SUCKS.

LIKE, THAT GUY NEEDS
TO SACK UP AND BE HERE.

WHATEVER, MAN. LOOK, THEY WERE
TOGETHER FOR A WHILE.

ALL RIGHT?
IT SUCKS BEING DUMPED.

COME ON.

AND PERSONALLY,
I DON'T KNOW THE FEELING

BECAUSE I'VE
NEVER BEEN DUMPED.

I USUALLY DO
THE DUMPING MYSELF,

- SO...
- HEY. HEY.

YOU KNOW, NOT EVERY GIRL
THINKS YOU'RE THE MAN.

YEAH? NAME ONE GIRL
ON THIS CAMPUS.

- JUST FORGET IT. JUST FORGET IT.
- THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT.

JUST PULLING STUFF
OUT OF YOUR ASS AS NORMAL?

GUYS! THIS IS STUPID!

- COME ON.
- OKAY.

IT WAS SARAH
AT THE TOGA PARTY.

YOU KNOW WHAT SHE SAID?
SHE SAID, "I'VE HAD BETTER."

OOH!

YEAH, I WAS THERE.
I HEARD IT TOO.

- THAT'S COOL.
- I WAS THERE, MAN.

HEY.

I THINK HE WAS STARTING
TO FEEL THE PRESSURE.

AND HIS STATUS WITHIN THIS GROUP
WAS STARTING TO WANE.

- WANT SOME PIZZA, MAN?
- CHILL OUT.

I DON'T NEED THIS.

Y'ALL ENJOY YOUR LITTLE,
LITTLE MEETING.

I'M OUTTA HERE.

YOU OWE ME A SLICE
FOR THAT ONE.

I GUESS SOME PEOPLE JUST CAN'T
HANDLE THE HEAT, RIGHT?

THEY HECKLED HIM
A LITTLE BIT PUBLICLY.

SO THAT MAY HAVE LED
TO HIS FRUSTRATION

AND HIS ANGST TOWARDS SARAH.

BACK AT SERF'S HOUSE,
SARAH GROWS RESTLESS

WAITING FOR HIM TO RETURN.

SHE GOT LEFT IN HIS ROOM,

AND MAYBE SHE WENT THROUGH
SOME OF HIS STUFF.

I RECEIVED A PHONE CALL
FROM SARAH SHORTLY AFTER DARK.

HELLO?

HEY, IT'S ME.
I'M HERE. I'M OKAY.

SARAH AND I
HAD ALWAYS HAD A PACT

THAT IF YOU'RE GONNA SPEND
THE NIGHT OUT OF THE ROOM,

THE OTHER PERSON NEEDS TO KNOW.

WE JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE

WE WERE WATCHING OUT
FOR EACH OTHER.

SARAH,
WHY ARE YOU WHISPERING?

WHERE ARE YOU?

SERF'S.

AT THE TIME,
I DIDN'T FIND IT ODD

THAT SHE WAS WHISPERING.

AND I DIDN'T REALLY
THINK TWICE ABOUT IT.

RIGHT.

WELL, ARE YOU
HAVING A GOOD TIME?

SARAH?

SARAH? ARE YOU THERE?

I GOT A STRANGE FEELING.

BUT I SAID, "OKAY.
I KNOW EXACTLY WHERE YOU ARE.

IT'S NOT A PROBLEM,"
AND THAT WAS BASICALLY IT.

WHAT THE HELL
ARE YOU DOING?

- NOTHING.
- NOTHING?

WHO GAVE YOU PERMISSION
TO READ THIS?

ANSWER ME.

SERF, STOP.

YOU'RE SCARING ME.

COLLEGE FRESHMAN
SARAH WISNOSKY

HAS JUST STUMBLED
ACROSS A SECRET SIDE

OF HER NEW MAN SERF.

WHAT THE HELL
ARE YOU DOING?

A SECRET THAT HE'S NOT TOO HAPPY

TO HAVE OUT IN THE OPEN.

YOU'RE SCARING ME.

- WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
- LOOK.

I THINK IT'S TIME FOR ME
TO TELL YOU THE TRUTH.

- WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?
- JUST LISTEN.

LISTEN TO ME.

OKAY?

LISTEN.
YOU HAVE TO TRUST ME.

IT'S NOT RIGHT THAT I HAVEN'T
BEEN HONEST TO YOU.

YOU'RE SCARING ME.

- I SHOULD JUST - - JUST GO.
- NO.

LET GO OF ME.
- SHUT UP!

SERF!

- DANIEL! HELP!
- SHUT UP!

YOU DID THIS
TO YOURSELF.

SERF'S RAGE CAME TO A POINT - -

CAME TO A HIT
THAT NIGHT WITH SARAH.

YOU DESERVE THIS.

THE FOLLOWING DAY,
SARAH'S ROOMMATE NICKI ARRIVES

AT SCHOOL ANXIOUS TO HEAR

ABOUT THE REST
OF HER ROOMMATE'S NIGHT.

HER AND I WERE SUPPOSED
TO HAVE A CLASS TOGETHER.

SHE NEVER SHOWED UP
FOR THAT CLASS.

IT WAS NOT NORMAL
FOR HER TO SKIP CLASS.

SO I WAS CONCERNED
WHEN SHE DID NOT SHOW UP.

I WOULD LIKE FOR YOU
TO VIEW FIGURE

5.6 ON PAGE 88
IN YOUR TEXTBOOKS.

AND WHEN I WENT IN
TO THE DORM ROOM,

I NOTICED NOTHING HAD CHANGED.
NOTHING HAD MOVED.

IT WAS VERY OBVIOUS
THAT SHE HAD NOT BEEN

BACK TO THE DORM ROOM
THAT ENTIRE DAY.

WORD OF A BODY
DISCOVERED ALONG

KNITTING MILL CREEK
QUICKLY SPREADS.

AND DETECTIVES FROM THE CITY
OF NORFOLK POLICE DEPARTMENT

ARE SOON ON THE SCENE.

I WAS CALLED,

NOTIFIED THAT THERE
WAS SOMETHING IN THE WATER

THAT APPEARED TO BE A BODY.

OVER THERE?

IT WAS VERY UNUSUAL
TO FIND A BODY

IN THIS AREA OF THE RIVER.

IT'S NOT AN AREA WHERE
THERE'S MUCH CRIMINAL ACTIVITY.

FINDING A BODY THERE
WAS VERY ALARMING.

SO WE HAD STARTED OUR NORMAL
CRIME-SCENE PROCESSES

WHERE WE ASSUME NOTHING,
CAPTURE EVERYTHING,

EXPAND OUT AS FAR
AS WE COULD.

HEY.

HEY.

WHAT YOU GOT
FOR ME?

WE GOT A BROWN SHOE,
WOMEN'S SIZE EIGHT.

WE FOUND A SHOE THAT
BELONGED TO SARAH.

AT THAT TIME, HAD NO - -

NO INKLING THAT IT WAS
RELATED TO THE CASE.

BUT AS A MATTER OF THOROUGHNESS,

WE NATURALLY PRESERVED IT
AND RECOVERED IT.

YOU EVER SEEN
ONE OF THOSE BEFORE?

DOESN'T LOOK
LIKE IT'S FROM

ONE OF THE HIGH SCHOOLS
AROUND HERE.

THE YOUNG FEMALE WAS WEARING
A RING ON HER FINGER.

AND IT WAS FROM
HERITAGE HIGH SCHOOL,

AND IT DID HAVE
THE INITIALS S. J. W.

WE KNEW THAT
OLD DOMINION UNIVERSITY

WAS VERY CLOSE TO THE CREEK.

SO WE ASSUMED
THAT MAYBE SHE WAS

A COLLEGE STUDENT
AT OLD DOMINION UNIVERSITY

THAT HAD RECENTLY GRADUATED
FROM HERITAGE HIGH SCHOOL.

SHE HAS A WATCH
AND A NECKLACE.

I NEED YOU TO BAG THEM
AND MAKE SURE

THEY'RE LOGGED PROPERLY.

CONSIDER IT DONE.

I GOTTA MAKE A CALL.

I REACHED OUT TO THE OLD
DOMINION UNIVERSITY POLICE,

WHO STOPPED EVERYTHING
TO HELP US,

AND THEIR INVESTIGATORS

RESEARCHED THEIR RECORDS
FOR THE INCOMING STUDENTS.

AND THEY FOUND A
SARAH JEAN WISNOSKY - - S. J. W.

POLICE OBTAINED
SARAH'S DORM ROOM NUMBER

AND HEAD STRAIGHT TO CAMPUS

IN HOPES OF FINDING
THEIR FIRST LEAD

TO THE PERSON RESPONSIBLE.

HI.

ARE YOU NICKI VANBELKUM?

YEAH.

CAN WE COME IN?

SURE.

NICKI, WE'RE HERE ABOUT
YOUR ROOMMATE SARAH.

WHEN'S THE LAST TIME
YOU SAW HER?

THE OTHER DAY,
BUT SHE CALLED LAST NIGHT.

- IS THIS HER?
- YEAH.

SHE SOUNDED KIND OF WEIRD
ON THE PHONE, THOUGH.

SHE WAS
AT SERF'S HOUSE.

WHO'S SERF?

IT'S THIS GUY
SHE'S BEEN SEEING.

- I MEAN, SORT OF.
- WHO IS THIS SERF GUY?

WHAT DO YOU KNOW
ABOUT HIM?

WHAT DO I THINK
ABOUT HIM?

YEAH.

I DON'T TRUST HIM AS FAR
AS I CAN THROW HIM.

I THINK WE NEED YOU
TO COME DOWN TO THE STATION.

BUT SHE'S OKAY, RIGHT?

AFTER DISCOVERING
THE BODY OF 17-YEAR-OLD

SARAH WISNOSKY ALONG
A VIRGINIA CREEK,

DETECTIVES ARRIVE AT HER
LAST KNOWN WHEREABOUTS.

NICKI TOLD US THAT SARAH
WAS STAYING THE NIGHT

WITH A FRIEND NAMED SERF.

WE RESPONDED TO THE
HOUSE WHERE SERF LIVED.

WHEN WE GOT THERE,
ONE TEAM WENT TO THE SIDE DOOR.

I WENT TO THE FRONT DOOR.

BOSS.

WHAT DO YOU GOT?

FOUND THIS.

LOOKS LIKE
SOMEONE TRIED TO THROW IT

IN THE GARBAGE CAN
AND MISSED.

IT'S A MATCH TO THE ONE
BY THE LAKE.

I'LL BE DAMNED.

IT IS THE MATCHING SHOE

TO THE ONE
THAT WE FOUND IN THE WATER.

AND IT HAS BLOOD ON IT.

ALL RIGHT. KEEP SEARCHING.
I'LL CALL IN A WARRANT.

GUYS. DOWN HERE.

THIS HAS CHANGED EVERYTHING.

WE HAVE SOME
VERY DEFINITIVE EVIDENCE

THAT THIS MAY HAVE
HAPPENED HERE.

SO WE'RE GONNA GO
THROUGH THIS DOOR.

INSIDE THE HOUSE,
DETECTIVES SEE

WHAT THEY CAN LEARN
ABOUT SARAH'S DATE

FOR THE EVENING.

IT APPEARED TO BE ABANDONED - -
HASTILY ABANDONED.

AND SO WE STARTED
LOOKING VERY CLOSELY.

LOOK, MAN.
I TOLD YOU BEFORE.

I DON'T KNOW WHERE HE IS.

IS THIS HIM?

YEAH.

YEAH. THAT'S HIM.

- WHAT HAPPENED?
- HEY, MAN.

I THINK SOMETHING
HAPPENED WITH SARAH.

- I DON'T KNOW WHAT.
- SARAH?

- WHAT?
- I DON'T KNOW.

GUYS, I NEED YOU
TO GET OUTTA HERE. OKAY.

ALL RIGHT. LET'S GO.
COME ON, MAN.

IT'S GONNA BE ALL RIGHT.
ALL RIGHT? COME ON.

IT'S GONNA BE
ALL RIGHT.

AS DETECTIVES
CONTINUE THEIR SEARCH,

THEY SOON MAKE EVEN
MORE DISTURBING DISCOVERIES.

WE DID NOTICE THAT THERE WAS

WHAT APPEARED TO BE BLOOD
ON SOME DRAWINGS.

THERE WAS ALSO, ON THE WALLS,
SIMILAR BLOOD SPLATTER.

NOW MY FOCUS IS,
WHO IS THIS PERSON SERF?

WHO IS HE?
AND ALL I KNOW IS A NICKNAME.

WE FOUND A NOTEBOOK
INSIDE HIS BEDROOM.

WE FOUND SOME INFORMATION

INDICATING A NAME
OF SERAFINO BARNABY

IN NEW JERSEY.

CALL HEADQUARTERS.

WE NEED APB
FOR SERAFINO BARNABY,

WHO GOES BY SERF.

SERF. ON IT.

SERF HAD FLED.

IT WAS BASICALLY
A NATIONAL - -

NATIONAL MANHUNT
TRYING TO LOCATE HIM.

SORRY TO KEEP YOU HERE
SO LONG, NICKI.

WE REALLY APPRECIATE
YOUR HELP.

WHAT IS GOING ON? PLEASE.
YOU HAVE TO TELL ME.

ALL OF THIS DID NOT SET WELL,

AND I KIND OF HAD A REALLY
BAD FEELING IN MY STOMACH.

EARLIER TODAY, WE FOUND A BODY,
AND WE BELIEVE IT WAS SARAH.

WHAT?

CAN YOU PLEASE COME
TO THE MORGUE WITH US

AND HELP US ID THE BODY?

I IMMEDIATELY ASKED IF HER
MOTHER HAD BEEN CONTACTED.

AND THEY SAID NO, THEY NEEDED
A POSITIVE IDENTIFICATION

ON THE BODY
BEFORE THEY COULD DO THAT.

SO I AGREED TO GO TO THE MORGUE

AND VIEW THE BODY
THAT THEY HAD FOUND.

THEY PULLED BACK THE SHEET

SO I COULD ONLY SEE
HER FACE AND SHOULDERS.

AND WITHOUT A DOUBT,
IT WAS SARAH.

I IMMEDIATELY KNEW IN MY GUT

THAT HE HAD KILLED HER.

DETECTIVES AGREE.

THERE'S LITTLE DOUBT
SERF'S THE MAN RESPONSIBLE

FOR THIS KILLING.

BUT NOW THEY NEED TO FIND HIM.

ALL RIGHT, THANKS.
THAT WAS NEW JERSEY P. D.

THEY'RE FAXING OVER
HIS REPORT RIGHT NOW.

WHAT'D THEY SAY?

REAL NAME,
DEREK ROCCO BARNABY.

SERAFINO BARNABEI
IS HIS DAD.

SERF BARNABEI WAS A GUY
WHO PREYED UPON COLLEGE KIDS.

HE WAS A CON MAN
THAT TRAVELED PROBABLY UP

AND DOWN THE EAST COST,

DUPING FRATERNITY KIDS
INTO GIVING HIM MONEY

AND LIVING A LIFESTYLE PARTYING

AND BEING THE BIG MAN ON CAMPUS.

HE WAS USING HIS WHOLE SCAM,
HIS WHOLE CON,

TO, UM, DATE GIRLS.

AND THERE WERE NUMEROUS GIRLS
THAT HE HAD HIT ON,

SOME THAT HE HAD ACTUALLY DATED
IN THAT SHORT PERIOD OF TIME.

NOT ONLY THAT,
HE'S GOT MULTIPLE ASSAULTS.

HE BEAT UP HIS MOM.
HE BEAT UP HIS EX-WIFE.

APPARENTLY SHE GOT
SO AFRAID OF HIM,

SHE TOOK THE KID
AND WENT INTO HIDING.

I DON'T BLAME HER.
SHE'S LUCKY TO BE ALIVE.

HEY, THIS GUY'S
STILL OUT THERE.

WE GOTTA FOCUS.
WE GOTTA GET HIM.

BUT MONTHS GO BY

AND DEREK BARNABEI
REMAINS IN HIDING.

THAT IS UNTIL DECEMBER 19th.

A POLICE OFFICER
IN CUYAHOGA FALLS, OHIO,

SPOTTED HIS VEHICLE
IN THE REAR OF A PARKING LOT

OF AM APARTMENT COMPLEX.

LATER ON THAT MORNING,
HE WAS ACTUALLY APPREHENDED.

DEREK "SERF" BARNABEI IS CHARGED

WITH SECOND DEGREE
MURDER AND RAPE.

AT HIS TRIAL, THE TRUE EXTENT
OF HIS RAGE COMES TO LIGHT.

I SHOULD JUST - - JUST GO.
NO.

- LET GO OF ME!
- SHUT UP!

SERF! DANIEL!

- SHUT UP!
- HELP!

- YOU DID THIS TO YOURSELF.
- NO!

THERE WAS DNA EVIDENCE
FROM SERF UNDER HER FINGERNAILS,

WHICH WOULD LEAD US TO BELIEVE

THAT SHE CERTAINLY
PUT UP A STRUGGLE.

YOU DESERVE THIS.

SHE WAS RAPED.
SHE WAS STRANGLED,

AND BEAT WITH A HAMMER
NUMEROUS TIMES IN THE HEAD.

AND IT WAS JUST A VERY
BRUTAL, SAVAGE ASSAULT.

AND THENM HER BODY WAS,
I BELIEVE,

PUT INTO HIS CAR
WRAPPED UP IN THE BED LINENS.

AND HE TOOK HER TO JUST
A FEW BLOCKS AWAY

TO DUMP HER BODY IN THE WATER.

ON JUNE 14th, 1995,
DEREK BARNABEI IS CONVICTED.

ONCE HE IS CONVICTED,
THEN THE - -

THE JURY GOT TO HEAR
THE PROSECUTION'S

EVIDENCE ABOUT
HIS PRIOR VILENESS,

HIS PRIOR CONDUCT, HIS POTENTIAL
FOR FUTURE VIOLENCE.

AND HE WAS GIVEN
A DEATH SENTENCE.

FIVE YEARS,
3 MONTHS LATER,

DEREK BARNABEI IS EXECUTED.

AT THE TIME
FOR DEREK'S EXECUTION,

I FELT A SENSE OF CLOSURE
AND A SENSE OF RELIEF.

I THINK THAT DEREK BARNABEI
WAS A JEKYLL AND HYDE.

I DON'T THINK HE SPECIFICALLY
PINPOINTED SARAH.

I THINK SHE WAS AT THE WRONG
PLACE AT THE WRONG TIME.

A SET OF PARENTS SENT
THEIR 17-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER

TO OLD DOMINION UNIVERSITY
TO GET AN EDUCATION.

AND THEN, THEY'RE GETTING
NOTIFIED BY A POLICE DEPARTMENT

THAT THEIR DAUGHTER
HAD BEEN BRUTALLY RAPED

AND VIOLENTLY MURDERED

AND THROWN IN A RIVER.

AND THAT'S - -
THAT'S JUST SAD.

IT'S JUST - - IT'S VERY SAD
THAT SHE'S GONE.

SHE WAS SO FULL
OF LIFE AND SPIRIT.

AND SHE HAD SO MUCH
POTENTIAL IN LIFE.

ALL THOSE DREAMS OF BEING THERE

AND GROWING OLD TOGETHER
WERE ALL TORN AWAY.

IT'S NEVER BEEN THE SAME.

'CAUSE YOU CAN
NEVER REPLACE HER.

YOU CAN NEVER REPLACE SARAH.