The Alzheimer's Project (2009–…): Season 1, Episode 4 - Caregivers - full transcript
The impact of Alzheimer's disease on those who provide care to these patients is the focus in this documentary. See five moving portraits of the sacrifices and successes made by people experiencing their loved one's gradual descent into dementia.
I KNEW ABOUT ALZHEIMER'S,
BUT I NEVER THOUGHT I'D GET IT.
AND WHEN IT HAPPENED,
I JUST...
THE FIRST THING I SAID TO CATHEE...
"ARE YOU GONNA LEAVE ME?"
THAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
THAT'S THE EXACT RIGHT MEMORY.
UH-HUH, I THOUGHT MY...
I WAS DOOMED.
IS THAT IT?
'CAUSE I THOUGHT
IT WAS THE END OF ME.
IF WE FAIL TO CURE OR
PREVENT ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN THE YEARS AND
DECADES TO COME,
WE'RE FACING
AN ENORMOUS INCREASE
IN THE HUMAN SUFFERING,
AS WELL AS THE FINANCIAL AND
SOCIETAL IMPACT THAT WILL OCCUR.
THERE'S BEEN AN
EXPONENTIAL INCREASE
IN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT
CAUSES ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
HOW WE CAN TARGET IT
AND HOW WE CAN TREAT IT.
Dr. Virginia Lee: IT
REALLY IS MIRACULOUS
THAT IN A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME...
WHICH IS REALLY 25 YEARS...
WE KNOW A LOT ABOUT THE DISEASE.
WE ARE AT THE BRINK
OF CONTROLLING
ONE OF THE MAJOR DISEASES
AFFECTING WORLD HEALTH.
Dr. Lennart Mucke: THERE'S A TRUE
EXPLOSION IN EXCITING NEW DISCOVERIES,
MANY OF WHICH AIMED AT THE
ROOT CAUSES OF THE DISEASE,
AND THEREFORE IMPLYING
ENORMOUS THERAPEUTIC POTENTIAL.
Dr. John C. Morris: WE DO HAVE
THE RESEARCH SCIENTISTS.
WE DO HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE.
AND I THINK WE CAN BEAT
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE HISTORY OF MODERN
MEDICINE IS REALLY TRACKED BACK
TO AROUND 500 YEARS
AGO WHEN PEOPLE DECIDED
THAT IT MIGHT BE A GOOD
IDEA TO CRACK OPEN THE BODY
AND ACTUALLY SEE
WHERE THE DISEASE IS.
IF SOMEONE IS BILIOUS,
IS HIS LIVER REALLY AFFECTED?
IF SOMEONE IS DEMENTED,
IS HIS BRAIN AFFECTED?
AND IT'S NOT THAT LONG AGO,
BUT THAT REALLY
GAVE RISE TO THIS IDEA
THAT WE ACTUALLY HAVE TO SEE
THE DISEASE TO UNDERSTAND IT.
ALOIS ALZHEIMER
WAS A GERMAN NEUROPATHOLOGIST.
HIS USE OF NOVEL
STAINING TECHNIQUES
IN DEAD BRAIN UNDER
THE MICROSCOPE
ALLOWED HIM FOR
THE FIRST TIME TO SEE
THIS CONSTELLATION
OF AMYLOID PLAQUES,
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
AND IT ULTIMATELY JUSTIFIED
CALLING THIS DISEASE
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
NOW IT'S INTERESTING
TO POINT OUT THAT,
IF YOU LOOK AT TEXTBOOKS OF
NEUROLOGY, PSYCHIATRY, MEDICINE...
FOR DECADES THEREAFTER,
INTO THE '30s, '40s, '50s,
THERE'S NARY A MENTION
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Steven DeKosky: SERIOUS AND FOCUSED
RESEARCH ON ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
REALLY BEGAN A LITTLE
OVER 20 YEARS AGO
WHEN THE NATIONAL
INSTITUTE OF AGING
AND A VARIETY OF OTHER
RESEARCHERS, BRAIN RESEARCHERS,
REALIZED THAT WHAT WE
HAD BEEN CALLING DEMENTIA,
OR SENILE DEMENTIA,
OR HARDENING OF THE ARTERIES,
OR ARTERIOSCLEROSIS IN LATE LIFE
THAT EVERYONE JUST
CALLED "DEMENTIA,"
ACTUALLY IN THE VAST MAJORITY
OF CASES WAS ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
WHEN WE STARTED, NO
ONE KNEW ANYTHING ABOUT
WHAT PLAQUES OR TANGLES...
THE THINGS WE SEE IN
THE BRAIN... WERE MADE OF.
WE BELIEVE THAT
THE BETA-AMYLOID,
THE BAD ACTOR IN PLAQUES,
LEADS TO THE DISRUPTION
OF TAU PROTEIN,
AND RESULTS IN
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
BOTH THE PLAQUE AND
THE TANGLE DO OCCUR
IN THE BRAINS OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE PATIENTS.
AND A GREAT ENIGMA
IS HOW THEY ARE LINKED.
DO THEY JUST EVOLVE
INDEPENDENTLY
OR IS THERE SOME SHARED PROCESS,
SOME SHARED
PATHOLOGICAL PROCESS?
WE KNOW THAT IN PATIENTS
WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
THAT PROBABLY
PLAQUES OCCUR FIRST AND
THEN TANGLES OCCUR LATER.
BUT SINCE PATIENTS
AT AUTOPSY HAVE BOTH,
THEN IT'S VERY DIFFICULT
TO REALLY TEASE OUT
HOW THIS HAPPENS.
JOHN AND I BELIEVE THAT
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES
PLAY A VERY IMPORTANT ROLE
IN THE DEMISE OF NEURONS.
AND AS IT TURNS OUT,
TAU IS A KNOWN PROTEIN.
AND IN FACT,
IT IS A VERY ABUNDANT
PROTEIN IN NERVE CELLS.
TAU ACTUALLY STABILIZES
THE TRANSPORT
SYSTEM IN NERVE CELLS.
HOWEVER, IN ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
TAU FALLS OFF THIS
TRANSPORT SYSTEM
AND BEGINS TO CLUMP TOGETHER
AND FORM
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
AND WHEN THE
TANGLES BEGIN TO FORM,
THESE EXTENSIONS
BEGIN TO SHRINK.
AND YOU CAN SEE THAT
THEY'RE SHRINKING.
AND EVENTUALLY
THEY'RE TOTALLY GONE.
AND THEN THESE THESE
NERVE CELLS EVENTUALLY DIE.
THE CONUNDRUM RIGHT NOW IS
THAT PEOPLE ARE DIAGNOSED
WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
WHEN THEY HAVE
SIGNIFICANT MEMORY FAILURE.
WE HAVE GOOD REASON TO BELIEVE
THAT ALREADY THEIR BRAINS
HAVE BEEN ACCUMULATING
PLAQUES AND TANGLES FOR
FIVE, 10, POSSIBLY 15 YEARS.
SO THE PATHOLOGY BEGINS
MANY MANY MORE YEARS
BEFORE SYMPTOMS APPEAR.
PITTSBURGH COMPOUND
B, OR PiB, AS IT'S KNOWN,
IS A RADIOACTIVE TRACER
THAT YOU GIVE IN A VEIN
THAT, WHEN YOU DO AN IMAGE,
SHOWS YOU THE AMYLOID
PLAQUES THAT ARE IN THE BRAIN
OF PEOPLE WITH
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Man: START.
Dr. William Klunk: THE BASIC
GOAL WAS TO BE ABLE TO SEE
THE AMYLOID PLAQUES
THAT ARE CHARACTERISTIC
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN A LIVING PERSON,
AND TO BE ABLE TO TELL
HOW MUCH OF IT WAS THERE.
IT WAS A GOAL OF OURS
TO DO THIS FOR MANY YEARS.
AND WE WANTED TO BE THE FIRST,
OR AMONG THE FIRST,
TO BE SUCCESSFUL AT IT.
WHAT'S THE VALUE OF SUCCEEDING?
THE MOST OBVIOUS IS,
WELL, IMPROVED DIAGNOSIS.
YOU KNOW, WE CAN DO NOW...
WE COULD DO IN A LIVING PERSON
WHAT YOU NOW HAVE TO WAIT
UNTIL AUTOPSY AFTER DEATH TO DO.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Dr. DeKosky: WE BEGAN
STUDYING FAMILIES
WHO HAVE EARLY-ONSET DISEASE.
WE KNEW THAT THEY WERE
DEVELOPING AMYLOID IN THEIR BRAINS,
AND CERTAINLY AT AN EARLIER
AGE THAN OTHERS... 30s AND 40s.
THERE ARE ONLY 200 TO
300 FAMILIES IN THE WORLD
WHO HAVE THESE
KINDS OF MUTATIONS
THAT LEAD TO FAMILIAL
EARLY-ONSET DISEASE.
AND THEREFORE WE
THOUGHT IT WOULD BE
A VERY GOOD TEST
OF PiB TO SEE AMYLOID
AND SHOW US WHAT HAPPENED
AS THE DISEASE PROGRESSED.
THE FIRST IMAGES
THAT I SAW OF PiB WERE
IN THE CLASSIC THREE DIMENSIONS.
AND IT WAS AN ABSOLUTELY
MOUTH-DROPPING MOMENT.
AND I KNEW INSTANTLY,
AS DID EVERY OTHER ONE
OF OUR RESEARCH TEAM,
THAT THIS WAS GOING TO CHANGE
THE WAY ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE WAS STUDIED FOREVER.
Dr. Klunk: ONE OF THE VALUES
OF STUDYING THIS FAMILY...
ALL SIX INDIVIDUALS
THAT PARTICIPATED,
THEY'VE COME BACK
FOR REPEATED SCANS.
AND WE HAVE A RANGE OF 14 YEARS
FROM THE YOUNGEST TO THE OLDEST.
THESE FAMILIES HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITY
TO LEAD US TO
EFFECTIVE TREATMENTS.
OKAY, THIS IS MY SIX
CHILDREN, TAKEN IN ABOUT 1977.
THIS IS BRIAN AND
KARLA... LITTLE KARLA...
SKINNY LORI THERE,
JAMIE, DEAN AND DOUG.
DOUG LOOKS JUST THE SAME.
MY HUSBAND HAD ALZHEIMER'S.
AND HIS MOTHER DID BEFORE HIM.
AND SHE DIED AT 53.
WE DIDN'T KNOW
WHAT IT WAS, DID WE?
YOU JUST THOUGHT YOU
WERE MAKING YOUR DAD MAD?
THERE WAS A LOT OF
COMMOTION AT HOME.
AND HIS MOOD CHANGED.
HE WAS VERY ANGRY A LOT.
AND YOU HAVE SIX
KIDS COMING AND GOING.
- A LOT OF ACTIVITY.
- THE ACTIVITY IS HARD.
- AND THAT'S HARD FOR THEM.
- THAT'S VERY HARD.
WHEN I GOT THE NEWS THAT I
DIDN'T CARRY THE MUTATED GENE,
I KNEW OF COURSE THEN,
THAT I WAS GOING TO BE,
YOU KNOW, WITHOUT
THEM ALL SOMEDAY.
AND I, YOU KNOW, MADE UP MY MIND
THAT I WAS GONNA DO
EVERYTHING IN MY POWER
TO MAKE SURE THAT MY SIBLINGS
GET THE RESPECT AND HELP
THAT THEY DESERVE THROUGH THIS.
WE STARTED WORKING
WITH THE FAMILIES
WHO HAVE EARLY-ONSET FAMILIAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE FOR TWO REASONS:
FIRST, WE KNOW THAT THEY
GET AMYLOID IN THEIR BRAINS.
AND THEY GET IT AT A MUCH
EARLIER TIME, OBVIOUSLY,
THAN PEOPLE WHO HAVE
LATE-ONSET DISEASE.
WE WANTED TO KNOW,
TO SEE, IF PiB REALLY WAS
WORKING, WHAT WOULD IT SHOW US?
THE ONLY WAY TO
BE ABLE TO DO THAT
WOULD BE WITH AN
IMAGING TRACER LIKE PiB
THAT WOULD LET US LOOK AT
THEM REPEATEDLY OVER TIME
AND BE ABLE TO
CORRELATE IT WITH THEIR
PAPER-AND-PENCIL
TESTING AT THE SAME TIME.
DRAW A CLOCK. PUT
ALL THE NUMBERS ON IT.
AND SET THE TIME
AT 10 AFTER 11:00.
OKAY. ALL DONE.
SINCE LAST YEAR WHEN WE
SAW HIM, HOW IS HE OVERALL?
IS HE BETTER, WORSE OR
THE SAME, DO YOU THINK?
I THINK HE HAS GOTTEN
A LITTLE BIT WORSE.
AND THEN HE'S SLOWED DOWN A LOT.
LET'S TALK ABOUT
LORI FOR A MINUTE.
HOW DO YOU THINK
SHE'S DIFFERENT?
- IS IT HER MEMORY? IS IT HER MOOD?
- YEAH.
- EVERYTHING?
- YEAH.
WE SAW HER LAST YEAR. SHE
REALLY HADN'T CHANGED VERY MUCH,
AT LEAST AS FAR AS HER
FORMAL TESTING WAS CONCERNED.
HER SHORT-TERM MEMORY IS...
IT SEEMS TO BE
REALLY HARD FOR HER.
THE THING IS, SHE KNOWS,
SHE RECOGNIZES IT.
I'M GOING TO NAME THREE OBJECTS.
AND I WANT YOU TO SAY
THEM BACK AFTER I STOP.
APPLE, PENNY, TABLE.
I KNOW THAT I'M PROGRESSING.
SO YOU JUST LIKE...
KINDA FEEL LIKE, "WELL, WHEN...
YOU KNOW, WHEN I AM GONNA
NOT BE ABLE TO DO THAT?"
IF WE WERE TO ASK YOUR HUSBAND
IF HE THOUGHT YOU
WERE BETTER, WORSE
OR THE SAME AS LAST YEAR,
WHAT DO YOU THINK HE'D SAY?
HE'D PROBABLY SAY
A LITTLE BIT WORSE.
- MAYBE A LITTLE BIT?
- YEAH.
KNOWING HOW EARLY
MY FATHER DIED,
SO, YOU KNOW, HE DIDN'T
GET TO ENJOY HIS GRANDKIDS.
IF MY DAUGHTERS GET MARRIED,
I ALWAYS KNEW I WOULD BE
A REALLY REALLY GOOD GRANDMA.
AND I PROBABLY WON'T GET TO.
WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT THE
RESULTS OF YOUR PiB SCANS.
SO THIS IS
A TYPICAL LATE-ONSET
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THESE FIVE ARE
YOUR FAMILY MEMBERS
FROM YOUNGEST TO OLDEST.
THIS IS DOUG'S SCAN.
AND THIS IS LORI'S SCAN.
IN LATE-ONSET ALZHEIMER'S
WE HAVE ALL THESE
AMYLOID DEPOSITS,
WHEREAS IN YOUR FAMILY
THERE'S THIS INTENSE
FOCAL DEPOSIT,
BUT THEN THERE'S LITTLE
BITS IN OTHER PLACES.
YOU'RE ALL SITTING HERE,
YOU'RE BEING VERY STRONG.
BUT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THINGS
THAT ARE, YOU KNOW,
INTIMATELY INVOLVED
WITH YOUR LIFE AND YOUR
PRESENT AND YOUR FUTURES.
AND, YOU KNOW, YOU'RE LOOKING
AT ONE REPRESENTATION
OF THE DISEASE
ON THE SCREEN
HERE... THE AMYLOID.
IT MAKES IT VERY
REAL AND VERY TOUGH.
- Lori: DOES IT MAKE YOU WONDER?
- YEAH.
Dr. Klunk: THIS ISN'T
AN EASY THING.
Gail: YEAH, PICTURE HER, THE ONLY
ONE THAT DOESN'T CARRY THE GENE,
TRYING TO DO SO MUCH
FOR THE REST OF US.
THERE'S A LOT OF
PAIN IN THAT TOO.
I DON'T KNOW, I THINK I'LL BE
SO ALONE WITHOUT THEM.
THERE'S TOO MANY...
TOO MANY OF THEM.
AND SOMETIMES YOU JUST NEED
YOUR BROTHERS AND SISTERS.
Lori: I UNDERSTAND THAT.
WHAT I HOPE... AND
I THINK ONE THING
THAT WE'RE LEARNING
FROM THIS RESEARCH
IS THAT WE CAN SEE AMYLOID
MUCH SOONER THAN
THE SYMPTOMS START.
SO THAT'S A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY.
THAT'S A TIME WHEN
YOU MAY BE ABLE
TO GET TO THE DISEASE WHEN
YOU CAN HAVE THE MOST SUCCESS.
Gail: I'M SO PROUD OF MY FAMILY
TO HAVE PARTICIPATED,
EACH ONE OF THEM,
AND DID IT SO WILLINGLY.
- YOU GUYS GO THROUGH A LOT.
- I'M REALLY PROUD OF THEM.
Dr. DeKosky: I THINK ONE OF
THE THINGS THE DeMOES SHOW
IS THE INCREDIBLE
DEDICATION OF THESE FAMILIES
WHO HAVE A VERY SERIOUS
DISEASE IN THEIR GENES
TO RESEARCH.
THEY COME TO US FROM FAR AWAY.
THEY COME BACK EVERY YEAR.
THEY UNDERSTAND THAT WE'RE
LEARNING ABOUT THE DISEASE,
AND THAT IT MAY HELP
THEIR NEXT GENERATION,
OR THE GENERATION AFTER THAT,
BUT IT ISN'T GOING TO HELP THEM.
AND YET THEY STILL COME.
THEY DO WHATEVER
WE ASK THEM TO DO.
THEY ARE REALLY
PARTNERS IN THIS FIGHT.
WELL, WE REALLY
APPRECIATE YOU COMING IN.
- WE APPRECIATE EVERYTHING.
- THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Dr. Hodes: THE IMAGING OF THE BRAIN
THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY ABLE TO DO
COULD NOT HAVE BEEN
IMAGINED 20 OR 30 YEARS AGO.
ALL OF THIS GIVES
US AN OPPORTUNITY
TO CARRY OUT RESEARCH OF A SORT
THAT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN
IMAGINED A DECADE OR TWO AGO,
AND ARE THE REASON
FOR THE EXCITEMENT
THAT I THINK PERVADES THE FIELD
AND GIVES APPROPRIATE AND
JUSTIFIED REASON FOR HOPE
TO SCIENTISTS AND
TO THE PUBLIC AS WELL.
AGE-RELATED MEMORY DECLINE
IS CHARACTERIZED BY AFFECTING
TWO GENERAL AREAS OF THE BRAIN:
THE FRONTAL LOBES,
THE PREFRONTAL CORTEX;
AND AN AREA CALLED
THE HIPPOCAMPUS,
WHICH IS DEEP WITHIN
THE TEMPORAL LOBES.
IF YOU MISPLACE YOUR KEYS,
IF YOU CAN'T REMEMBER
WHERE YOU PARKED YOUR CAR,
IF YOU CAN'T QUITE
REMEMBER THE NAME
OF A CLIENT YOU
JUST MET A WEEK AGO,
BUT YOU CAN REMEMBER CLIENTS
THAT YOU MET, YOU KNOW, YEARS AGO,
THAT'S A PROBLEM WITH
SAVING NEW INFORMATION.
AND THAT'S AN EXAMPLE OF
HIPPOCAMPAL DYSFUNCTION.
I'M WORRIED ABOUT THE
BEGINNING OF ALZHEIMER'S...
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S.
I JUST HAVE... I FEEL MY...
I KNOW EVERYBODY SAYS THEY
HAVE PROBLEMS WITH THEIR MEMORY,
BUT I'VE LIVED WITH SOMEONE
WHO HAD ALZHEIMER'S.
AND I SEE MYSELF IN HIM.
AND I'M VERY
APPREHENSIVE ABOUT IT.
THE EARLIEST STAGE
OF ALZHEIMER'S
IS ONE WHERE THE
CELLS ARE STILL THERE.
YOU MIGHT NOT HAVE
FULLY-FORMED PLAQUES AND TANGLES,
BUT THE CELLS ARE
JUST MALFUNCTIONING.
SO NOW WE'RE TRYING
TO USE TECHNOLOGIES
THAT CAPTURE CELL SICKNESS
TO ASK THE QUESTION, "WHEN
DOES ALZHEIMER'S BEGIN?"
- HELLO.
- Woman: HELLO, ANITA.
- HOW ARE YOU?
- IS DR. SMALL HERE?
AND THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
WE'RE CURRENTLY TESTING.
BUT IT'S NOT THAT SIMPLE,
BECAUSE THE HIPPOCAMPUS
COULD BE AFFECTED
BOTH BY NORMAL AGING AND
BY EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THAT'S ONE OF THE
REASONS WHY WE FOCUS SO MUCH
ON THE SYMPTOMS THAT
RELATE TO THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
BECAUSE AS CLINICIANS WE WORRY...
MIGHT THAT BE AN INDICATOR
OF EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE?
VERY NICE OF YOU
TO INVITE ME IN.
- HAVE A SEAT.
- THANK YOU.
- HOW HAVE YOU BEEN?
- PRETTY GOOD, CONSIDERING.
SO GIVE ME SOME EXAMPLES
OF FORGETFULNESS.
I DON'T LIKE THIS FEELING OF...
WHEN I'M SPEAKING TO PEOPLE,
IN THE MIDDLE OF WHATEVER
WE'RE SPEAKING ABOUT,
I GO COMPLETELY BLANK,
AND I CAN'T PULL UP...
- AND IT COMES BACK LATER.
- MAYBE.
YOU KNOW, I MEAN,
WHEN IT'S NOT IMPORTANT.
- RIGHT.
- BUT NOT ONLY THAT,
I DO THE SAME THING WITH WORDS.
I CAN'T FIND... MY VOCABULARY
HAS ABSOLUTELY DISINTEGRATED.
AS YOU KNOW, WE DO
OCCASIONALLY A MEMORY TEST.
I'M GONNA GIVE YOU
THREE OBJECTS...
APPLE, TABLE, PENNY.
APPLE, TABLE, PENNY.
KEEP THEM IN YOUR MEMORY.
I'M GONNA ASK YOU TO
REPEAT THEM IN A FEW MINUTES.
BUT FOR NOW
I'M GONNA ASK YOU TO
REPEAT SOME NUMBERS,
BUT YOU DON'T NEED TO
REMEMBER THE NUMBERS, OKAY?
SIX, TWO, NINE.
SIX, TWO, NINE.
FOUR, TWO, SEVEN, THREE, ONE.
- FOUR, TWO, SEVEN, THREE, ONE.
- GOOD.
WHAT WERE THOSE THREE
OBJECTS I ASKED YOU TO REMEMBER?
VERY EASY. I HAVE
A WAY OF DOING IT.
- THAT'S OKAY. TRICKS ARE ACCEPTED.
- OKAY?
I PUT THE APPLE ON TOP
OF THE PENNY ON THE TABLE.
EXCELLENT. SO WHO WAS
THE PRESIDENT BEFORE BUSH?
- IT WASN'T CLINTON?
- YES.
- OH, IT WAS?
- SEE? TRUST YOURSELF.
WHO WAS BEFORE CLINTON?
- OH, BUSH.
- GOOD.
AND WHO WAS BEFORE BUSH?
OH...
JOHNSON? NO.
- YES?
- NO.
WE'RE CURRENTLY
FUNDED BY THE N.I.H.
TO IMAGE HUNDREDS
OF HEALTHY ELDERS,
GENERATE THESE PATTERNS
IN THE HIPPOCAMPAL FORMATION
AND FOLLOW THESE
SUBJECTS PROSPECTIVELY.
AND THE QUESTION TO US WILL BE...
"CAN WE DETECT THE EARLIEST
STAGES OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
VERSUS NORMAL AGING ITSELF?"
SO WE NOW HAVE OPTIMIZED
AN M.R.I.-BASED TECHNOLOGY
THAT ALLOWS US
TO REALLY VISUALIZE
THE HIPPOCAMPAL SUBREGIONS
IN MICE AND HUMANS.
AND WE'VE BEEN APPLYING
THAT TECHNOLOGY
ACROSS NUMEROUS STUDIES
TO REALLY TRY TO
TEST THIS QUESTION,
OR TEST THIS HYPOTHESIS...
DOES ALZHEIMER'S
AND NORMAL AGING
TARGET DIFFERENT SUBREGIONS
OF THE HIPPOCAMPUS?
SO REMEMBER THAT THIS IS
A RESEARCH PROJECT
THAT YOU'VE PARTICIPATED IN.
THERE'S A BASIC
ASSUMPTION WE'RE MAKING
THAT ALZHEIMER'S STARTS
IN ONE PART OF THE
HIPPOCAMPAL FORMATION.
THE ENTORHINAL CORTEX
WILL BE TARGETED BY ALZHEIMER'S,
WHEREAS THIS NEIGHBORING
AREA SHOWN IN WHITE...
THE DENTATE GYRUS...
SHOULD BE TARGETED
BY NORMAL AGING.
THESE TWO AREAS SEEM
TO GIVE US THE MOST...
- INFORMATION? -... INFORMATION
IN TRYING TO DISSOCIATE
ALZHEIMER'S FROM AGING.
IT'S THIS AREA OF THE
HIPPOCAMPUS... THE DENTATE GYRUS...
THAT WE FIND, IN YOUR
BRAIN IS RELATIVELY DOWN.
CAN WE IDENTIFY
AT THE MOLECULAR LEVEL
WHAT'S WRONG IN THE
ENTORHINAL CORTEX
IN ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
WHAT'S WRONG WITH THE
DENTATE GYRUS IN NORMAL AGING,
AS A WAY TO BEGIN
TO GET AT CLUES
AT AN UNDERLYING
MOLECULAR MECHANISM?
IN THE ENTORHINAL CORTEX
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO
UNCOVER A NEW MECHANISM
THAT PLAYS A ROLE IN
THE PRODUCTION OF A BETA.
AND THIS IN TURN
SUGGESTS NEW WAYS
IN WHICH WE COULD
BEGIN TO EXPLORE
DIFFERENT THERAPIES
BASED ON THIS FINDING.
YOU KNOW, YOUR CHIEF COMPLAINT
IS FORGETFULNESS, RIGHT?
- REMIND ME, HOW OLD ARE YOU?
- 81.
I THINK THAT YOU
HAVE NORMAL AGING.
I DON'T THINK THAT YOU HAVE
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
GOOD. GOOD.
WE KNOW THAT NORMAL AGING ITSELF
ALSO CAUSES CELL SICKNESS,
BUT NEVER PROGRESSES OUTSIDE
OF THE CELL-SICKNESS STAGE.
BECAUSE IF YOU THINK
ABOUT ALL THE SUCCESSES
THAT WE'VE MADE IN
MEDICINE, THEY'VE REALLY COME
ON THE HEELS OF BEING ABLE
TO VISUALIZE THE PROBLEM,
WHETHER IT'S CANCER,
HEART DISEASE,
AND, IN FACT, BRAIN DISORDERS...
STROKE, M.S... MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS... TUMORS.
ONE OF THE GREAT CHALLENGES
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IS THE FACT THAT UNTIL RECENTLY
IT'S BEEN RELATIVELY
INVISIBLE TO OUR TECHNOLOGIES.
AND I THINK THAT'S WHY IT'S
BEEN SUCH A GREAT CHALLENGE.
BUT THAT, I THINK,
IS SHIFTING NOW.
ALL RIGHT, COME ON
IN TO THE MAGNET.
JUST WHAT I NEED.
SO THE FIRST PART...
YOU'RE GONNA CLIMB
ALL THE WAY UP THESE STAIRS.
AND WE WANT YOU TO
BE VERY STEADY HERE.
WE GOT INTERESTED IN THIS IDEA
OF LOOKING AT MEMORY FORMATION
BECAUSE I THINK IN
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
THE MEMORY TROUBLE
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS EXPERIENCE
ACTUALLY BEGINS AT THE
FIRST MOMENT THEY ENCODE,
OR TRY TO LEARN,
NEW INFORMATION.
SO WE KNOW THAT
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS
LOSE INFORMATION
MORE QUICKLY OVER TIME.
BUT WE ALSO THINK THAT
EVEN THE WAY THEIR BRAIN
LEARNS THAT INFORMATION
IS UNFORTUNATELY ABNORMAL.
SO REMEMBER, THESE ARE
GONNA GO IN YOUR EARS.
ALL RIGHT. THAT'S GOOD.
MAKE SURE IT'S NOT
PUSHING ON YOUR...
WE'RE FOLLOWING
OLDER INDIVIDUALS
BECAUSE WE ARE ABLE
NOW TO LOOK AT INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE STILL NORMAL,
OR JUST HAVE A LITTLE
BIT OF MEMORY TROUBLE,
AND SEE IF THEY HAVE ONE OF THE HALLMARK
PATHOLOGIES OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
BECAUSE IN THE SETTING
OF ALZHEIMER'S PATHOLOGY,
THE BRAIN WILL WORK DIFFERENTLY.
AND WE SEE EVIDENCE
THAT THE BRAIN HAS TO USE
COMPENSATORY AREAS
OF NETWORKS TO ACTIVATE
IN THE SETTING OF
THIS EARLY PATHOLOGY.
AND WE MAY BE ABLE
TO SEE THAT THREE, FIVE,
MAYBE EVEN 10 YEARS BEFORE
SOMEONE'S GONNA DEVELOP DEMENTIA.
- DO YOU FEEL OKAY?
- MM-HMM.
COME ON RIGHT OVER
HERE, MRS. HAMILTON.
SO HE'S IN THERE, AND YOU CAN
SEE IF YOU LOOK IN THE BACK...
YOU CAN ACTUALLY SEE THE
SCREEN FLASHING ON AND OFF.
AND THIS IS ACTUALLY
WHAT HE'S SEEING...
- THESE PICTURES OF NAMES AND FACES.
- OH, NAMES AND FACES.
RIGHT, AND THERE'S A FEW OF THEM
- THAT REPEAT AGAIN AND AGAIN.
- VERY INTERESTING.
FOR EACH FACE NAME YOU SEE,
TRY TO REMEMBER
WHICH NAME GOES WITH WHICH FACE.
AND THE HIPPOCAMPUS
IS REALLY IN THE CENTER,
DEEP IN THE BRAIN, AND
INTEGRATES ALL OF THE INFORMATION
FROM VISUAL CENTERS COMING IN,
AUDITORY CENTERS AND
ALSO THOUGHT CENTERS
THAT ARE IMPORTANT FOR KNOWING
WHETHER OR NOT
SOMETHING IS NEW AND OLD.
AND WE THINK THAT THE
HIPPOCAMPUS BINDS TOGETHER
THIS INFORMATION IN A NEW,
COHESIVE MEMORY TRACE.
OKAY, I KNOW HE NEEDS
EVERY SECOND. AND GO. GO NOW.
OKAY, WE'RE ALL DONE. WE'RE
COMING IN TO GET YOU NOW.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S GET HIM OUT
AND MAKE SURE HE'S COMFORTABLE.
WE'RE GONNA HAVE YOU
DO THE FUN PART NOW...
THE TESTING OF HOW YOUR
MEMORY IS FOR THE NAMES AND FACES.
Mr. Hamilton: I DON'T
REMEMBER LOUIS OR ISAAC.
"GAIL." I DON'T
REMEMBER HER AT ALL.
THEY'RE MIXING TOGETHER
IN MY MIND SO QUICKLY.
YOU CAN SEE EVIDENCE
THAT HE'S GOT A LOT OF LOSS
OF CORTICAL TISSUE, AS WELL
AS HIPPOCAMPAL ATROPHY.
SO HERE YOU SEE MORE BLACK.
THERE'S LOSS OF TISSUE
IN THE HIPPOCAMPUS
AND LOSS OF TISSUE
ALL AROUND THE CORTEX,
PARTICULARLY IN THE
PARIETAL LOBE HERE.
HERE'S A PERSON WHO WAS ONE
OF THE MOST PROLIFIC WRITERS
IN THE WHOLE LAW
SCHOOL... 70-80 PEOPLE.
BUT HIS EVALUATIONS
BEGAN TO FALL OFF.
AND FOR BOB HAVING
HIS EVALUATIONS
DROP TO 80th PERCENTILE
OR 75th PERCENTILE
WAS UNTHINKABLE,
WAS HUMILIATING.
IT WAS A BIT PAINFUL.
I WOULD DESCRIBE IT THAT WAY.
IT WASN'T, YOU KNOW, "OH
MY GOD, MY LIFE HAS ENDED."
BUT IT WAS A BIT OF A SHOCK.
ONE OF THE MOST
SURPRISING THINGS WE FOUND
WHEN WE STARTED TO STUDY
OLDER INDIVIDUALS
WITH FUNCTIONAL IMAGING
IS THAT SOME PARTS OF THE BRAIN
ACTUALLY HYPER TURN
ON, OR HYPERACTIVATE.
THAT WAS REALLY SURPRISING,
BECAUSE THE
ORIGINAL IDEA WAS THAT
AS A PROGRESSION OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
THAT YOU JUST LOSE EVERYTHING
AND EVERYTHING GOES
DOWN IN A NICE LINEAR FASHION.
BUT IT ACTUALLY TURNS OUT
THAT SOME PARTS OF THE BRAIN,
PARTICULARLY
EARLY IN THE DISEASE
WHEN PEOPLE ARE AT A PHASE OF
WHAT WE CALL MILD COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT
WHERE THEY'VE GOT A LITTLE
BIT OF MEMORY TROUBLE
BUT ARE STILL ABLE TO FUNCTION,
WHAT WE'VE SEEN
USING FUNCTIONAL M.R.I.
IS THAT THESE
PARTS OF THE BRAIN,
IN PARTICULAR THE HIPPOCAMPUS
THAT'S SO IMPORTANT FOR MEMORY,
GOES INTO HYPERDRIVE.
AND IN ORDER TO
FORM A NEW MEMORY
IT ACTUALLY WORKS HARDER.
AND WE THOUGHT THAT PERHAPS
THIS IS EVIDENCE OF COMPENSATION,
OR TRYING TO COMPENSATE FOR
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S PATHOLOGY.
SO IT'S REVVING AND
DRIVING AS FAST AS IT CAN,
AND DURING THAT
PHASE OF HYPERACTIVITY
YOU'RE ABLE TO MAINTAIN MEMORY.
AND UNFORTUNATELY,
WHAT WE'VE SEEN IS THAT,
AS PEOPLE PROGRESS,
THEY LOSE ACTIVATION
IN EXACTLY THE AREA
THAT WAS HYPERACTIVATING.
SO ALTHOUGH THIS MAY BE
COMPENSATORY EARLY ON,
IT'S ALSO A SIGN OF IMPENDING
FAILURE OF THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
AND MORE AND MORE WE'VE
SEEN THAT THIS HYPERACTIVATION
IS ACTUALLY A VERY
GOOD PREDICTOR
OF WHO'S GONNA DECLINE
OVER THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
UNFORTUNATELY... YOU CAN SEE
HIS HIPPOCAMPUS OVER HERE...
VERY VERY LITTLE
HIPPOCAMPAL ACTIVATION.
NO HIPPOCAMPAL ACTIVATION,
NO PRECUNEUS DEACTIVATION.
OKAY.
HERE, EVEN IN A SINGLE
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENT,
IT'S JUST A VERY GOOD EXAMPLE
OF HOW THIS MEMORY NETWORK
IS REALLY NOT
FUNCTIONING AT ALL.
YOU CAN SEE THAT
ALTHOUGH PARTS OF HIS BRAIN...
THE PARTS THAT ARE IMPORTANT
FOR VISION AND BASIC ATTENTION...
ARE WORKING, HIS HIPPOCAMPUS,
THIS MEMORY CENTER'S REALLY
NOT ABLE TO TURN ON AT ALL.
YOU GUYS HAVE BEEN REAL TROUPERS
ALL THE WAY THROUGH THIS TRIAL.
WELL, WE JUST FEEL
LUCKY TO BE PART OF IT.
I THINK BOB FEELS THAT WAY TOO.
EVEN THOUGH I CLEARLY HAVE
ALZHEIMER'S PROBLEMS,
THEY REALLY HAVE NOT
SLOWED ME DOWN SIGNIFICANTLY.
SEE, I KEEP SEEING YOUR WIFE
HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT OPINION.
- I KNOW SHE DOES.
- I HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE.
- AND I CAN TELL YOU THAT... - BECAUSE
SHE CORRECTS ALL MY MISTAKES.
BUT, YOU KNOW, THAT'S
SO COMMON THAT OFTEN
IT DOESN'T BOTHER THE
PATIENT NEARLY AS MUCH
AS IT BOTHERS THE FAMILY
MEMBERS AND OTHERS.
I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY TRUE.
SHE FEELS THAT, I'M QUITE SURE.
ULTIMATELY, USING SINGLE
SUBJECT DATA LIKE THIS,
WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO
ASSESS TREATMENT.
SO IF WE CAN LOOK
IN A GIVEN PERSON
WHO'S NOT ABLE TO
ACTIVATE THEIR HIPPOCAMPUS,
AND THEY'RE FAILING
AT THIS MEMORY TASK,
IF WE COULD GIVE
THEM A TREATMENT,
AN ANTI-AMYLOID TREATMENT
SUCH AS AN ANTIBODY
OR ANOTHER WAY OF
REDUCING AMYLOID IN THE BRAIN,
AND SEE IF WE CAN
ACTUALLY RESTORE FUNCTION
TO THAT PART OF THE BRAIN,
THAT'S THE HOLY GRAIL.
AND SO IT'S THE COMBINATION
BETWEEN THE BRAINWAVES
AND THE MAGNETIC FIELDS
THAT THIS INSTRUMENT RECORDS.
THIS IS A VERY
EXCITING DAY FOR US
BECAUSE THIS IS
THE FIRST PATIENT
WE'RE ENROLLING IN OUR
CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
TO LOOK FOR SUBCLINICAL
EPILEPTIC FORM ACTIVITY,
OR ABNORMAL BRAINWAVE
ACTIVITY IN PEOPLE
WITH EARLY-STAGE ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE OR RELATED DEMENTIAS.
HOW'S THAT? ARE YOUR EARS OKAY?
THE STUDY INCLUDES
THE ADMISSION OF
PATIENTS TO THE HOSPITAL
FOR A 36-HOUR PERIOD.
AND DURING THAT PERIOD
THEIR BRAINWAVES ARE
CONTINUALLY RECORDED
AND THEN ANALYZED FOR
ANY ABNORMAL FREQUENCIES
OR EVEN PERHAPS BURSTS
THAT MIGHT REFLECT
SUBCLINICAL SEIZURE ACTIVITY.
WE WERE IMPRESSED CLINICALLY
BY THE VERY SIGNIFICANT
FLUCTUATIONS
THAT PEOPLE WITH
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
AND OTHER DEMENTIAS
SHOW IN THEIR FUNCTIONING.
SO SOMETIMES ONE
COMES IN THE ROOM
AND THE PATIENT HAS
REASONABLY GOOD ORIENTATION
AND EVEN RECOGNIZES
THEIR RELATIVES JUST FINE.
AND YOU CAN COME BACK
SOMETIMES IN THE AFTERNOON
AND THE PATIENT IS
UTTERLY CONFUSED
AND DOESN'T RECOGNIZE HIS
OR HER DAUGHTER ANYMORE.
AND WE THINK THAT THE
LIKELIEST EXPLANATION
FOR THESE FLUCTUATIONS
ARE INSTABILITIES IN
NEURAL NETWORK FUNCTION.
NOW I'D LIKE YOU TO COUNT
BACKWARDS FROM 100.
96, 95,
94, 93,
92, 91...
UH... ( chuckles )
- 90.
- 90.
LET'S SEE...
WE SUSPECT THAT
AN IMPORTANT PART
OF THE CELL DEATH PROCESS
IS ENERGY DEPLETION,
WHICH CAN COME ABOUT
EITHER BECAUSE NEURONS
ARE OVERSTIMULATED
AND CAN'T KEEP UP
WITH ALL THE DISCHARGING
THAT THEY HAVE TO DO.
SO THIS WOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH
WHAT HAS BEEN REFERRED
TO AS "EXCITOTOXICITY"...
TOO MUCH EXCITATION
RUNNING THE CELL INTO THE GROUND
BECAUSE IT JUST CAN'T KEEP
UP WITH ITS OWN ACTIVITY.
AND I THINK A KEY
PLAYER VERY LIKELY IS
THE AMYLOID BETA PEPTIDE...
A SMALL FRAGMENT
OF A LARGER PROTEIN
THAT WE ALL MAKE.
AND WE KNOW THAT IT IS
GENERATED AND CLEARED
VERY RAPIDLY THROUGHOUT THE DAY
MULTIPLE TIMES UNDER
NORMAL CIRCUMSTANCES.
AND IT LOOKS LIKE
EXCESS AMYLOID BETA
CAN GET THE CELL INTO OVERDRIVE.
- DEBORAH.
- YES?
HI, I'M DR. MUCKE.
- HOW ARE YOU DOING?
- FINE, THANK YOU.
I WANTED TO HEAR FROM
YOU A LITTLE BIT ABOUT
HOW YOU SEE THINGS
ARE DIFFERENT NOW
COMPARED TO, SAY, HOW THEY WERE
10-15 YEARS AGO.
I DON'T KNOW.
IT WAS VERY GRADUAL.
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IF
YOU CAN COPY THAT FOR ME.
YOU CAN START
ANYWHERE ON THE PAGE.
BUT IF YOU CAN TRY TO
COPY THAT CUBE FOR ME...
- NO.
- IT'S TOUGH, RIGHT?
- THAT'S A REAL TOUGH ONE FOR YOU, I KNOW.
- ( laughs )
AND HER MINI MENTAL-STATE EXAM...
OVERALL SCORE
WAS A 20 OUT OF 30.
SHE GOT A 27 ABOUT A YEAR AGO.
SO THAT'S QUITE
A DROP, ACTUALLY.
THAT'S QUITE A DROP
OVER THAT TIME FRAME.
- YEAH.
- YEAH.
BASICALLY THE BOTTOM LINE IS
THAT THERE WERE ONLY
SOME SHARP TRANSIENTS,
BUT NOT ANY REAL CLEAR-CUT
EPILEPTIC FORM ACTIVITY.
NOT WHAT WE WOULD
CALL A JUICY SPIKE.
I THINK WHAT WE WOULD BE KIND OF
INTERESTED IN MOSTLY
IS THE SHARP ACTIVITY.
I BELIEVE THAT THE
DISEASE REALLY REQUIRES
A VERY OPEN-MINDED
APPROACH, IF YOU WILL,
WHERE ONE HAS TO UNDERSTAND
THAT IT COMES ABOUT
VIA DIFFERENT PROCESSES,
AND THAT ONE MAY
HAVE TO BLOCK IT ALSO
FROM MANY DIFFERENT ANGLES.
SO DIFFERENT
PATIENTS MAY REQUIRE
A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT
THERAPEUTIC APPROACH
FROM THE NEXT PERSON.
AND WE'RE BEGINNING NOW
IN OUR ANIMAL MODELS TO TEST
ALL THE DIFFERENT
ANTI-EPILEPTIC DRUGS THAT EXIST
TO FIND OUT
IF ANY OF THEM
ACTUALLY CAN INHIBIT
THE EPILEPTIC FORM,
EPILEPSYLIKE ACTIVITY
THAT THE AMYLOID
PROTEINS SEEM TO INDUCE.
- WE HAVE ENOUGH MATERIAL.
- WE DO.
AND WE ALSO NEED TO MAKE SURE
THAT OUR
DRUG-DEVELOPMENT PORTFOLIO
THAT THE COMMUNITY IS
BUILDING OVER THE YEARS
IS NOT TOO SINGLE-MINDED,
BECAUSE WE MAY BE BETTING
ON THE WRONG HORSE.
SO IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR US
TO DIVERSIFY
THE DRUG-DEVELOPMENT PORTFOLIO.
A CATEGORY OF
STUDY WHICH HAS BEEN
ENORMOUSLY IMPORTANT
TO ALZHEIMER'S RESEARCH
HAS BEEN THE LONGITUDINAL
STUDY OF HUMANS,
IN WHICH A GROUP OF PEOPLE
ARE EXTENSIVELY
WELL-CHARACTERIZED
AND THEN FOLLOWED THROUGH
MANY YEARS AND DECADES OF LIFE
IN AN EFFORT TO
BETTER UNDERSTAND
THE VARIABLES WHICH AFFECT THEM,
THE RISK FACTORS
IN THEIR BIOLOGICAL
OR LIFESTYLE BEHAVIORS,
AND HOW THESE TRANSLATE
INTO THE LIKELIHOOD OF RISK
OR PROTECTION AGAINST
A VARIETY OF DISEASES.
( tower bell chiming )
( organ playing )
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
Dr. David Benne IN THE
RELIGIOUS ORDER STUDY,
WE HAD ONE OF THE
FIRST PUBLICATIONS
SHOWING THAT ENGAGING
IN MENTALLY STIMULATING ACTIVITY
MAY DELAY THE TIME
UNTIL YOU REACH GETTING
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Sister Caulfield: GOOD MORNING.
I'M APOLOGIZING
FOR INTERRUPTING.
SISTER CATHERINE,
WHO DIED IN IOWA
CITY TWO DAYS AGO,
GAVE HER BODY TO SCIENCE.
THE FAMILY WILL COME TOGETHER
FOR A MEMORIAL MASS AUGUST 23rd.
I WANT YOU TO KNOW
THAT I'M IN THE STUDY.
- Woman: ARE YOU?
- OH YEAH.
AND IT HELPS THE RESEARCH.
OH, IT HELPS RESEARCH. OH, SURE.
THAT'S RIGHT. THAT'S
THE IMPORTANT PART.
- THAT'S THE REASON WE DO IT.
- THAT'S TRUE.
- QUITE LARGE, ISN'T IT?
- SO THESE ARE TWO NUNS
FROM DUBUQUE, RIGHT?
RIGHT, THEY'RE TWO
NUNS FROM DUBUQUE.
OKAY.
THEY BOTH HAVE
SIGNIFICANT ATROPHY.
YOU CAN SEE THE ATROPHY HERE.
THIS ONE DOES LOOK
MORE SEVERE TO ME.
THE RELIGIOUS
ORDER STUDY INVOLVES
OLDER NUNS, PRIESTS AND
BROTHERS WITHOUT DEMENTIA
WHO AGREE TO BE
TESTED EVERY YEAR
TO TELL US ALL KINDS OF
THINGS ABOUT THEMSELVES.
AND A CONDITION OF ENTRY
IS THAT THEY HAVE TO AGREE
TO ORGAN DONATION
AT THE TIME OF DEATH.
WE'RE INTERESTED IN:
WHAT ARE THE COMMON
CHANGES IN THE BRAIN
THAT CAUSE PEOPLE
TO LOSE MEMORY
AS THEY GET OLDER?
HOW ARE DIFFERENT
RISK FACTORS THAT ARE
CAUSING MEMORY LOSS...
WHAT'S THE PATHWAY?
HOW ARE THEY DOING THAT?
WHAT ARE THEY DOING TO THE BRAIN
TO ACTUALLY CAUSE
THE MEMORY LOSS?
AND WE'RE OFTEN VERY SURPRISED,
WITH A LOT OF PATHOLOGY
WITH A PERSON WITH NO
COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT,
OR VERY LITTLE PATHOLOGY
IF THE PERSON DID HAVE
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO THIS IS A NUN FROM DUBUQUE.
SHE DIED. SHE WAS
ABOUT 80 YEARS OLD.
SHE HAD 18 YEARS OF EDUCATION.
AND SHE CLEARLY
HAD A MILD DEMENTIA
AT THE TIME THAT
WE LAST SAW HER...
PROBABLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND LET'S SEE WHAT
IT DID SHOW HERE.
AND YOU CAN ALREADY SEE
THE ABNORMALITY OF THE PLAQUES.
ALL OF THESE BLACK
STRUCTURES HERE
ARE PLAQUES WITHIN HER BRAIN.
OKAY, SO THE FIRST CASE...
PRETTY TYPICAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THE SECOND CASE...
SHE WAS OVER 90 OVER YEARS OLD.
SHE HAD 20 YEARS OF EDUCATION,
NO DECLINE OVER THE YEARS
OVER THREE YEARS OF FOLLOW-UP.
WHAT DO YOU THINK
WE'RE GONNA SEE HERE?
IT LOOKS LIKE SHE SHOULD HAVE
A SOMEWHAT NORMAL BRAIN.
SHE HAS A SIGNIFICANT
NUMBER OF PLAQUES,
AND ENOUGH PLAQUES TO CONFIRM
A DIAGNOSIS OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO HER BRAIN LOOKS VERY SIMILAR
TO THE NUN THAT WE SAW
THAT DID HAVE DEMENTIA.
AND YET THIS WAS
SOMEBODY WHO WAS OLDER,
FUNCTIONING PRETTY WELL,
AND HAD REALLY NO
REASON FOR US TO SUSPECT
THAT SHE HAD
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
WE'RE DEVELOPING THIS IDEA
THAT CERTAIN TYPES
OF THINKING ABILITIES
CAN ACTUALLY HELP YOU TOLERATE
THE PATHOLOGY OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
SO IT'S NOT EXPRESSED
AS MEMORY LOSS.
AND WE TALK ABOUT MEMORY
LOSS 'CAUSE THAT IS REALLY
THE HALLMARK OF CLINICAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE BASIC IDEA BEHIND
COGNITIVE RESERVE
IS THAT TWO PEOPLE WITH THE SAME
AMOUNT OF ALZHEIMER'S CHANGES...
ONE WILL HAVE MEMORY
LOSS AND DEMENTIA,
AND THE OTHER ONE COULD
BE COMPLETELY NORMAL.
SO WHAT UNDERLIES THAT?
WHY IS IT THAT PATHOLOGY
OF, YOU KNOW, SO
MUCH IN ONE PERSON
IS HAVING SUCH A
DEVASTATING EFFECT,
AND THE SAME AMOUNT IS
NOT HAVING THAT EFFECT
IN ANOTHER PERSON?
AND SO THE IDEA OF A RESERVE
IS THAT PATHOLOGY IS DEVELOPING
IN THE CONTEXT OF AN INDIVIDUAL
THAT CAN SOMEHOW PROTECT IT.
AND THE QUESTION THEN BECOMES...
WHAT'S THE NATURE
OF THE PROTECTION?
ONE THING WE'VE
LOOKED AT, FOR EXAMPLE,
IS THE EXTENT OF
YOUR SOCIAL NETWORK,
SO HOW MANY PEOPLE YOU
FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH
TALKING TO AND CONFIDING IN.
AND THE LARGER THAT NETWORK,
THE LESS LIKELY
YOU ARE TO DECLINE,
AND THE LESS LIKELY
YOU ARE TO EXPERIENCE
CLINICAL ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO I ACTUALLY HAVE SOME DATA.
THE ONE THAT DID NOT
SHOW ANY MEMORY LOSS
HAD A SOCIAL NETWORK
THAT WAS 10 TIMES LARGER
THAN THE OTHER SISTER.
ALL RIGHT.
AND THE ONE THAT DID NOT
SHOW ANY COGNITIVE LOSS
ALSO WAS LESS LIKELY
TO BE DISTRESSED.
THERE'S SOMETHING
ABOUT THOSE FACTORS
IN THESE TWO WOMEN
WHERE THEY DIFFERED.
AND SOMEHOW THEY CHANGED
THE WAY THE BRAINS TOLERATED
AND RESPONDED TO THE
PATHOLOGY OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
IF YOU THINK ABOUT PEOPLE
THAT HAVE LARGER NETWORKS
VERSUS PEOPLE WITH
SMALLER NETWORKS...
I MEAN, WHAT'S DIFFERENT
ABOUT THOSE INDIVIDUALS?
IT'S HARD TO DEVELOP
A LARGE NETWORK.
IT TAKES WORK
AND IT TAKES SKILL.
ENGAGEMENT IN COGNITIVELY
STIMULATING ACTIVITIES...
TURNS OUT THAT PEOPLE
THAT SPEND MORE TIME
IN MORE VARIETIES OF
PROCESSING INFORMATION
ACTUALLY MAINTAIN
THEIR COGNITIVE ABILITIES.
AND, IN PARTICULAR,
THEY MAINTAIN
THEIR BRAIN EFFICIENCY.
THEY'RE QUEEN
ANNE'S LACE, WE CALL IT.
- QUEEN...?
- QUEEN ANNE'S LACE.
Together: QUEEN ANNE'S LACE.
ALL RIGHT.
EVERYTHING IN THIS
LESSON IS PERFECT.
"THE LITTLE GIRL
HAS PINK CHEEKS."
- PINK CHEEKS.
- SO THE DOUBLE VOWEL MAKES IT LONG.
WHAT IS CHEEKS? ( laughs )
- AH, HERE.
- MM-HMM.
- PINK CHEEKS, OKAY.
- ALL RIGHT, GOT IT.
Dr. Benne IN THE EVENT THAT
SOME CATASTROPHE COMES...
NOT AN ACCIDENT, BUT
ALZHEIMER'S CHANGES,
IF YOU TAKE YOUR BRAIN WITH YOU
INTO YOUR 10TH DECADE, AS
YOU ENTER THAT 10TH DECADE,
YOU WANT THE MOST
ROBUST, EFFICIENT,
RAPID-DECISION-MAKING,
MULTITASKING BRAIN THAT
YOU POSSIBLY CAN HAVE.
BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT'S
GONNA ALLOW YOU
TO MAINTAIN YOUR COGNITION,
DESPITE ALL THE OTHER THINGS
THAT'S GONNA HAPPEN TO IT.
( birds chirping )
Mrs. Galvani: I KNOW
FROM LIVING WITH HIM
HOW HE JUST LOVED BEING
OUT AND DOING ALL THE WORK
HE WAS DOING ON
COMMITTEES AND LOCAL CLUBS,
AND PLAYING CARDS...
A LITTLE DIVERSION...
BUT ALSO BEING TOASTMASTER
AT MANY MANY FUNCTIONS.
HE HAD A LOT OF ENERGY TO
KEEP DOING ALL THESE THINGS.
AND I HAD B.C. FOOTBALL TICKETS
UNTIL THREE YEARS AGO
WHEN I COULDN'T SEE OR
CLIMB THE STAIRS ANYMORE.
SO I GAVE UP MY SEASON TICKETS
THREE YEARS AGO. I WAS 91.
( both laugh )
WITH THE INCREASE IN LONGEVITY
THAT WE ARE OBSERVING
IN THE PAST DECADES
COMES A GREAT DEAL OF CONCERN
WHETHER INCREASED LIFESPAN
IS GOING TO BE ACCOMPANIED
BY A GREATER PERIOD
OF TIME WITH DISABILITY,
WITH LOSS OF DEPENDENCE,
WITH POOR QUALITY OF LIFE,
OR WHETHER INCREASED
LIFE EXPECTANCY
CAN BE ACCOMPANIED BY A
LONGER PERIOD IN GOOD HEALTH.
IN THAT REGARD, THERE'VE
BEEN SOME VERY GRATIFYING
RESULTS OF STUDIES
OVER THE PAST YEARS,
WHICH HAVE INDICATED
THAT IN THE YEARS
FROM 1982 THROUGH PRESENT...
THE LAST COUPLE OF DECADES...
THERE IN FACT HAVE BEEN
SUBSTANTIAL DECREASES
IN THE RATES OF DISABILITY
IN OLDER MEN AND WOMEN.
THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT
BECAUSE IT
INDICATES THAT IN FACT
DISABILITY WITH OLD AGE
IS BY NO MEANS INEVITABLE.
AND THERE IS REAL PROMISE
FOR BEING ABLE TO INCREASE
THE QUALITY OF INDEPENDENCE
AND DISABILITY-FREE
LIFE WITH AGE.
( people chattering )
MARY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
HI, VIC. HOW ARE YOU
DOING? WHAT'S GOING ON?
- GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- VIC LOOKS FANTASTIC.
- OF COURSE HE DOES.
ONE OF THE STUDIES WHICH
HAS BEEN PARTICULARLY VALUABLE
HAS BEEN THE
FRAMINGHAM HEART STUDY...
A STUDY WHICH WAS INITIATED TO
FOCUS ON CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES...
DISEASES OF THE HEART... BUT
HAS PROVEN TO BE AN ASSET
TO THE GATHERING OF INFORMATION
IN THE FUNCTION OF THE BRAIN
AND BRING IT TO BEAR IN
A BETTER UNDERSTANDING
OF DEMENTIA AND
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
USING THE FRAMINGHAM
DATA, WE'RE ABLE TO ESTIMATE
WHAT IS THE PROBABILITY
THAT A MAN OR WOMAN AT AGE 65
WILL DEVELOP A
STROKE OR DEMENTIA
DURING THE REMAINDER
OF THEIR LIFE.
AND THE PROBABILITY
COMES OUT TO BE
ONE CHANCE IN THREE
THAT A MAN WILL DEVELOP
STROKE OR DEMENTIA
AND ONE CHANCE IN TWO
THAT A WOMAN WILL
DEVELOP STROKE OR DEMENTIA
DURING THE REMAINDER
OF THEIR LIFE,
WHICH IS A REALLY
TERRIFYING STATISTIC.
OKAY, THIS FIRST ONE GOES
FOR A MINUTE AND A HALF.
JUST HOLD VERY STILL, OKAY?
Man: IT'S REALLY WONDERFUL TO
SEE WHAT OUR BRAIN LOOKS LIKE,
AND WHAT HAPPENS
TO IT OVER THE YEARS.
- HAVE YOU EVER SEEN AN M.R.I. LIKE THIS BEFORE?
- NO, NEVER.
WE OFTEN EXPECT...
WHEN YOU HAVE PEOPLE
WHO ARE ABOUT 70 YEARS OLD,
YOU FIND THAT OVER HALF OF THEM
WOULD HAVE A LOT OF CHANGES,
MORE CHANGES IN
THEIR WHITE MATTER
- THAN WHAT YOU DO.
- I SEE.
SO THAT'S GOOD.
THAT EXPLAINS TO SOME EXTENT
WHY YOU'RE DOING SO WELL
IN TERMS OF BEING
QUICK IN YOUR THINKING,
BEING ABLE TO
REMEMBER THINGS WELL.
THIS IS A PART OF THE BRAIN
CALLED THE HIPPOCAMPUS,
- WHERE WE FORM MEMORIES.
- RIGHT.
AND THIS IS SOMETHING
THAT SHRINKS
- WHEN YOU HAVE ALZHEIMER'S.
- I SEE.
NOW THIS IS FROM A
MORE RECENT SCAN.
IF IT HAD SHRUNK, YOU WOULD SEE
- MORE OF THIS WHITE FLUID
AROUND IT... - OF THE WHITE, YES.
AND MUCH LESS
OF THE GREY MATTER.
WE LIKE THE FACT THAT
WE ARE ABLE TO SEE
HOW BIG YOUR HIPPOCAMPI ARE,
HOW THEY CHANGED OVER
TIME, AND THAT HASN'T CHANGED.
Dr. Hodes: THERE'S GREAT HOPE
THAT THESE EXAMPLES
OF SUCCESSFUL AGING,
EVEN IF IT'S IN THE
EXCEPTIONAL FEW,
ARE REASON TO HOPE
THAT MANY MORE OF US,
IF NOT ALL OF US, CAN
ACHIEVE THAT SAME OUTCOME
ONCE WE ARE CAPABLE
OF BETTER UNDERSTANDING
WHAT DISTINGUISHES THIS
SUCCESSFUL BRAIN AGING
FROM LESS SUCCESSFUL
BRAIN AGING,
AND DETERMINE WHAT MANIPULATIONS
ARE CAPABLE OF TRANSFORMING
THE UNSUCCESSFUL
INTO THE SUCCESSFUL.
THERE'S ENORMOUS INTEREST NOW
IN WHAT THE EFFECTS OF
LIFESTYLE INTERVENTIONS
SUCH AS EXERCISE AND DIET
MAY HAVE ON THE RISK
FOR ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
OR ON BRAIN HEALTH
AND FUNCTION IN GENERAL.
IN ANIMAL MODELS...
MOUSE MODELS OF ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE, FOR EXAMPLE...
THERE IS RECENT
EVIDENCE SUGGESTING
THAT EXERCISE AND DIET
CAN MODIFY THE
PROGRESSION OF THE LESIONS
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN THESE ANIMAL MODELS.
ONE OF THE BREAKTHROUGHS
IN THE FIELD IS TO BE ABLE
TO HAVE A MOUSE MODEL
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
CALLED A TRANSGENIC MOUSE.
AND IT SIMULATES A
LOT OF THE PATHOLOGY
THAT DEVELOPS IN THE HUMAN
BRAIN WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
I HAD THIS IDEA THAT
MAYBE A GROWTH FACTOR,
OR NEUROTROPHIC FACTOR,
WHICH IS KIND OF A NUTRIENT
OR A FERTILIZER TO NEURONS,
WHICH ALSO MAKES THEM SMARTER,
MIGHT BE NATURALLY
INCREASED WITH EXERCISE.
WE TAKE TWO GROUPS...
ONE IS JUST SORT
OF IN THEIR CAGE
AND DON'T HAVE ACCESS
TO A SORT OF A RUNNING GYM;
AND THE OTHERS GET IN THEIR
RUNNING WHEELS AT NIGHT
AND THEY EXERCISE.
IN ORDER TO TEST THEIR LEARNING,
WE BASICALLY TAKE THE TWO GROUPS
AND PUT THEM IN THIS
MORRIS WATER MAZE.
THEY ARE PUT IN THE TANK.
AND THEY DON'T LIKE THE WATER.
AND WHAT THEY HAVE TO DO IS
THEY HAVE TO FIND
A LITTLE PLATFORM
THAT'S SORT OF
BELOW THE SURFACE.
IT'S REALLY KIND OF
EQUIVALENT TO FINDING YOUR CAR
IN A PARKING LOT AT AN AIRPORT
WHEN YOU CAN'T REALLY SEE IT,
BUT YOU SORT OF HAVE TO LEARN
FROM THE CUES AROUND THE AIRPORT
OF WHERE YOU PARKED.
Man: THE SEDENTARY ANIMAL
STILL HAS NOT LOCATED
THE PLATFORM AT THIS POINT.
ALL RIGHT.
WE FIND CONSISTENTLY
THAT THE ANIMALS
THAT HAVE EXERCISED
ARE ABLE TO LEARN
FASTER AND BETTER
THAN THE ANIMALS
THAT HAVEN'T EXERCISED.
- Woman: ALL RIGHT!
- Dr. Cotman: YAY!
Man: HE DID IT.
WE LOOKED AT THEIR
BRAIN, AND LO AND BEHOLD,
BDNF WAS INCREASED
IN THE PART OF THE BRAIN
THAT IS CONTROLLING
THINKING AND LEARNING
AND IS VULNERABLE TO
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND ALL I CAN SAY TO MYSELF,
AND MY STUDENTS WOULD SAY,
"HOLY KAMOLEY, THAT IS SO SMART.
THE BRAIN KNEW SOMETHING
IN HOW TO LOOK OUT FOR ITSELF
THAT WE HAD NO IDEA ABOUT."
SO IT KINDA HAS A
SELF-PRESERVATION MECHANISM
THAT ALSO MAKES IT
SMARTER AND TO LEARN BETTER.
CERTAINLY IN ANIMAL MODELS
THERE'S NO QUESTION ABOUT IT...
EXERCISE CAN INDUCE
GROWTH FACTORS IN THE BRAIN.
IT CAN HELP BUILD
NEW NEURONS INTO THE CIRCUITS.
IT CAN BUILD SYNAPSES,
IMPROVE LEARNING.
AND IT CAN BASICALLY
IMPROVE VASCULAR FUNCTION.
OH MY GOSH, YOU KNOW,
WHAT DRUG WILL DO THAT?
NOTHING.
AND, YOU KNOW,
IT'S SIMPLE EXERCISE.
YOU CAN IDENTIFY NEW NEURONS
BY STAINS, YOU
KNOW, THAT HIGHLIGHT
THE NEW CELLS
THAT ARE JUST BORN.
AND WHEN YOU LOOK,
THERE'S FEWER OF THEM
IN THE ANIMALS THAT
ARE JUST SEDENTARY
THAN IN THE EXERCISED ANIMALS.
AND IT'S REALLY QUITE DRAMATIC.
SO EXERCISE ACTUALLY INCREASES
THE NUMBER OF NEW NEURONS
THAT COULD BE ADDED
TO THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
THE EXCITING CONCLUSION IS
THAT WHEN WE TESTED THE ANIMALS
THAT DEVELOP ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE IN THE BRAIN,
THEY BENEFIT AS
WELL FROM EXERCISE,
JUST LIKE THE WILD TYPE.
SO THEY LEARN FASTER AND BETTER,
WHICH IS VERY ENCOURAGING
BECAUSE IT MEANS
THAT MAY HELP DELAY THE
ONSET OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
FROM THE EXPERIENCE OF EXERCISE.
IF YOU ASKED
SOMEBODY 10 YEARS AGO,
"HOW ARE YOU GOING
TO FIX BRAIN AGING?"
OR "WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DO?"
THEY WOULD HAVE TOLD
YOU IT'S A MEDICATION.
NOW WE KNOW
THERE'S GREAT PROMISE
IN TERMS OF BEHAVIORAL
INTERVENTIONS
THAT CAN BE ADJUNCTS
TO MEDICATIONS
AND GOOD HEALTH POLICY.
NICE YOU SEE YOU.
HOW ARE YOU DOING?
OH, IT'S SO GOOD TO SEE YOU.
I'M GONNA CHECK A FEW THINGS,
LISTEN TO YOUR HEART AND LUNGS.
NO SPINNING
SENSATION, NO NAUSEA,
- VOMITING, NOTHING LIKE THAT?
- NO NO.
IF THINGS GO WELL, YOU'LL BE
ABLE TO STAY ON THE MEDICINE,
AND THEN HOPEFULLY
THIS WILL BE APPROVED
FOR THE GENERAL
PUBLIC DOWN THE ROAD
FOR TREATING THIS DISEASE, OKAY?
WELL, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE
HOPING AND PRAYING FOR.
ONE OF THE BEST
PIECES OF NEWS IS
THAT THERE ARE MANY
CLINICAL TRIALS NOW
WITH VERY PROMISING AGENTS
FOR ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE... DOZENS.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED BY
THE ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
COOPERATIVE STUDY... THE ADCS.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED BY
THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED IN THIS
COUNTRY AND IN OTHER COUNTRIES.
YOU'LL START WITH
THE EVENING DOSE.
THE EVENING. OKAY.
- THANKS FOR COMING. SEE YOU IN THREE MONTHS.
- SEE YOU IN THREE MONTHS.
- HOW'RE YOU FEELING TODAY?
- GOOD.
BEEN AN OKAY EXPERIENCE FOR YOU?
VERY VERY MUCH SO.
TWO IN THE MORNING,
TWO AT NIGHT.
THE PIVOTAL TRIALS
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
THAT ARE OCCURRING NOW... TRIALS
OF DISEASE-MODIFYING TREATMENTS,
OF ANTI-AMYLOID TREATMENTS,
BECAUSE THEY ARE TRYING
TO SLOW THE PROGRESSION
OF THIS DISEASE
OVER THE LONG TERM,
AND BECAUSE THE PROGRESSION
VARIES FROM ONE
PERSON TO ANOTHER,
IN FACT THEY REQUIRE
MANY MANY PARTICIPANTS
IN THESE TRIALS.
YOU CAN DIRECTLY PLUG
THIS MACHINE INTO THE WALL.
OKAY, PUT IT UP TO YOUR NOSE.
Man: NO MATTER WHERE I HAVE
TO TAKE THIS WOMAN IN THE WORLD
TO FIND SOMETHING
THAT CAN HELP HER
MAINTAIN A LIFESTYLE,
AND A GOOD
LIFESTYLE, I WILL DO IT.
WITHOUT THE COOPERATION
OF INDIVIDUALS
AND THEIR FAMILIES
WE HAVE A ROADBLOCK,
WE WILL NOT PROGRESS
TO TREATMENTS.
- CAN YOU PICK UP YOUR FOOT?
- UH-HUH.
AND BRING IT OVER. THERE YOU GO.
OKAY.
WE GOT INVOLVED
IN THE ELAN TRIALS,
THE 2001 ELAN TRIALS,
BECAUSE OUR SON-IN-LAW
SAW IT ADVERTISED IN THE PAPER
AND HE CALLED US AND SAID,
"I THINK THIS MAY BE SOMETHING
YOU'D BE INTERESTED IN."
- YEAH.
- AND WE WERE INTERESTED IN IT.
SO EARL AND I RAN OUT THERE
TO GET INVOLVED IN IT,
AND EXCITED ABOUT IT.
I WAS JUST HOPING
THAT SOMETHING
WOULD SURFACE
THAT WOULD HELP ME.
THERE'S A VARIETY OF APPROACHES
TO TRY AND BLOCK
THE PROGRESSION OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
ONCE YOU HAVE IT, HOW CAN YOU...
HOW CAN YOU GO AFTER
THE PLAQUES OR THE TANGLES,
TRY AND REDUCE
THEM, REMOVE THEM,
SO THAT YOU CAN CHANGE
THE COURSE OF THE DISEASE?
ONE OF THE LOGICAL WAYS TO DO IT
IS TO REDUCE THE PRODUCTION
OF BETA-AMYLOID FROM THE GET-GO.
THE MORE SURPRISING WAY TO DO IT
THAT WE DISCOVERED
IN THE LATE '90s
IS THAT, IF YOU ACTUALLY
IMMUNIZE OR VACCINATE
WITH THE BETA-AMYLOID
PEPTIDE ITSELF,
AND STIMULATE THE IMMUNE SYSTEM,
THAT THE IMMUNE SYSTEM
CAN THEN ACTUALLY EITHER
PREVENT... TOTALLY PREVENT...
OR REVERSE THE PLAQUES
IN THE BRAIN TISSUE.
THE IDEA WAS TO VACCINATE
JUST LIKE YOU GET
VACCINATED FOR POLIO...
VACCINATE WITH
A SYNTHETIC PIECE,
A LITTLE PEPTIDE
PROTEIN FRAGMENT
OF THE BETA-AMYLOID
INTO THE MICE.
AND WHEN YOU GET
VACCINATED, WHAT DO YOU DO?
YOU RAISE ANTIBODIES
IN YOUR BLOOD.
AND THAT'S WHAT PROTECTS YOU
IF YOU'RE BEING VACCINATED
AGAINST SOME INFECTION.
HERE IT'S A LITTLE
DIFFERENT. WHAT WE HOPED IS
THAT THOSE ANTIBODIES WOULD
CIRCULATE THROUGH THE BODY.
AND WHAT ANTIBODIES DO IS THEY BIND
TO WHATEVER THEY'VE BEEN MADE TO.
AND WE HOPED THESE ANTIBODIES
WOULD BIND TO THE BETA-AMYLOID
AND HELP CLEAR IT,
HELP GET RID OF IT...
A VERY SIMPLE IDEA, AN
EXTREMELY SIMPLE IDEA.
AND THIS IS WHAT YOU SEE
IN UNTREATED
MICE. THIS IS A BRAIN.
THE BROWN MATERIAL
IS THE PLAQUES.
THEN AFTER THEY'VE
BEEN VACCINATED,
THIS IS WHAT YOU
SEE INSTEAD OF THAT
IN THE TREATED ANIMALS.
AND IT WAS SO
BLACK-AND-WHITE AND SO OBVIOUS
THAT I REMEMBER...
DORA SAW THIS FIRST.
YOU COULD WITH
100% ACCURACY SAY,
"THIS ANIMAL WAS TREATED
AND THIS ONE WASN'T."
ONCE WE REALIZED THAT
WE COULD ACTUALLY TREAT
OUR MOUSE MODEL OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
WITH THE BETA-AMYLOID PEPTIDE...
IN OTHER WORDS BY
VACCINATING THEM,
OR IMMUNIZING THEM WITH
THE BETA-AMYLOID PEPTIDE...
WE IMMEDIATELY REALIZED
THAT THAT HAD POTENTIAL
FOR TREATMENT OF
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS.
WE BEGAN WHAT WE
CALL CLINICAL TRIALS.
AND THAT'S A VERY
LONG PROCESS, ACTUALLY.
AND THE WAY IT'S DONE IS,
MOST OF WHAT YOU DO IS MAKE SURE
THAT WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS SAFE.
SO YOU DO A FEW
NUMBER OF PATIENTS,
A VERY CONTROLLED ENVIRONMENT,
VERY CAREFUL AMOUNTS, ET CETERA,
AND SHOW THAT IT'S SAFE.
AND WE CALL THAT PHASE
I TRIALS. SO WE DID THAT
AND EVERYTHING LOOKED FINE.
AND THEN WE WENT
ONTO LARGE STUDIES.
AND NOW WE'RE TALKING
SEVERAL HUNDRED PATIENTS,
370 PATIENTS,
WHERE WE DID WHAT'S
CALLED A PHASE II STUDY
WHERE AGAIN A LOT
OF IT IS ABOUT SAFETY.
MOST OF IT'S ABOUT SAFETY.
BUT YOU'RE STARTING TO LOOK
AT THINGS LIKE, "GEE,
IS THIS WORKING?
ARE THE PATIENTS PERFORMING
FUNCTIONS BETTER? HOW ARE THEY DOING?"
HE HAD THREE INJECTIONS
PROBABLY OVER A
PERIOD OF THREE MONTHS
OR SOMETHING LIKE
THAT, MAYBE EVEN LONGER.
WHEN HE WAS GIVEN
THE FIRST INJECTION,
HE HAD A BIT OF A
REACTION TO A PROTEIN,
AN ALLERGEN TYPE REACTION.
AND I SAID, "I THINK
YOU GOT THE VACCINE."
AND SURE ENOUGH, HE DID.
AND SO IT WAS EXCITING
BECAUSE WE WERE ACTUALLY FEELING
LIKE IT WAS DOING SOME GOOD...
- YEAH YEAH.
- EVEN INITIALLY.
IT GAVE ME A LOT OF HOPE.
WE WERE JUST WELL UNDERWAY.
EVERYTHING WAS GOING FINE.
AND AFTER THE SECOND DOSE
WE RAN INTO A PROBLEM
WITH ENCEPHALITIS
IN A VERY SMALL
SUBSET OF PATIENTS...
ABOUT 5% OR 6% OF THEM.
AND ALTHOUGH IT WAS
TRANSIENT, IT WAS SEVERE ENOUGH
THAT WE FELT IT WAS
PRUDENT TO STOP DOSING.
- WHEN THEY ENDED THE TRIALS...
- UH-HUH.
WELL, WE WERE CUSSING.
WE ACTUALLY WERE ANGRY.
I KEPT SAYING, "OH, THAT
WAS A MOSQUITO IN FRANCE.
IT DOESN'T HAVE ANYTHING
TO DO WITH THIS VACCINE."
BUT I THINK BACK,
AND I KEPT SAYING
TO EVERYONE WHO ASKED,
"SO HOW'S EARL DOING?"
I WOULD SAY, "HE'S
MAINTAINING. HE'S MAINTAINING."
- AND THAT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT.
- YEAH.
BECAUSE YOU WERE
FUNCTIONING WELL AT THAT TIME.
- OH, YEAH.
- AND JUST TO STAY THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN A BLESSING.
BECAUSE IT WAS WORKING.
AND WE SAID THAT
FOR MANY MANY YEARS.
- YEAH.
- I'M THINKING BACK NOW...
WE PROBABLY FOR THREE
OR FOUR OR FIVE YEARS SAID,
"HE'S MAINTAINING.
EVERYTHING IS GOOD."
TO OUR AMAZEMENT,
IF YOU LOOK AT THE BOTTOM ROW
HERE AND COMPARE IT WITH THE TOP,
AT THE TOP IS THE TYPICAL
SORT OF PATHOLOGY
THAT ONE SEES IN PATIENTS
WHO HAVE ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE TOP THREE ARE BRAIN SECTIONS
WHERE THE BROWN
IS THE BETA-AMYLOID...
THE TYPICAL
PLAQUELIKE APPEARANCE.
ON THE BOTTOM IS THE
COMPARISON OF WHAT YOU SEE
AFTER THE PATIENT
HAS BEEN VACCINATED,
WHERE THERE'S BRAIN REGIONS
THAT ARE NEARLY COMPLETELY
VOID. THE PLAQUES ARE GONE.
WE ARE REALLY VERY
EXCITED THAT WE CAN REMOVE...
LITERALLY REMOVE AMYLOID
PLAQUES FROM PATIENTS
SUFFERING FROM
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND AS WE MOVE FORWARD
NOW, WHAT THIS MEANS IS,
SINCE WE CAN DO IT, WE'RE
DELIVERING NEW TREATMENTS,
THINGS LIKE BAPINEUZUMAB,
WHICH IS A VERY LONG
WORD, A FANCY WORD
FOR A HUMAN ANTIBODY
THAT IS MOVING
THROUGH THE PROCESS
OF CLINICAL TRIAL.
INSTEAD OF THE PATIENT
HAVING TO MAKE THE
ANTIBODIES AND DO THE WORK,
WE'RE PROVIDING THE PATIENT
DIRECTLY WITH THE ANTIBODIES.
NOW THE GOOD PART ABOUT
DOING THIS IS THAT YOU CAN GIVE
EXACTLY THE AMOUNT AND THE
DOSE THAT YOU WANT TO GIVE.
IN OTHER WORDS, IT'S MUCH MORE
CONTROLLED WHEN YOU GIVE THE ANTIBODIES.
AND SO THAT'S WHAT
BAPINEUZUMAB IS.
ONCE IT'S IN THE BLOODSTREAM,
THE ANTIBODY WILL LAST
AS LONG AS THREE WEEKS.
Dr. Marwan Sabbagh: THIS IS
ONE OF THE LEADING DRUGS
THAT'S IN THE HORSE
RACE TO GET AN APPROVAL.
THIS IS THE END OF
THE PHASE II STUDY.
AND THE SPONSORS
ACTUALLY HAVE MOVED
THIS DRUG BAPINEUZUMAB
INTO PHASE III,
BECAUSE THEY ARE VERY
EXCITED ABOUT ITS PROGRESS.
Dr. Schenk: AND SO THAT
ANTIBODY CIRCULATES AROUND,
AND A LITTLE BIT OF
IT, THIS BAPINEUZUMAB,
GETS THROUGH INTO THE BRAIN.
AND IF THERE'S PLAQUES THERE,
IT WILL BIND TO THOSE PLAQUES
AND NEUTRALIZE THEM
OR STIMULATE THE
CLEARANCE OF THEM.
DR. GARGAS WAS A SURGEON IN
WISCONSIN FOR MANY MANY YEARS.
WELL, YEAH.
I THINK I'M VERY...
I WALKED INTO
SOMETHING THAT WAS VERY GOOD.
OUR DECISION TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE TRIAL
SEEMED LIKE A NO-BRAINER.
IF WE COULD DO ANYTHING
TO HELP OUR FAMILIES,
AND ALL THE OTHER
FIVE MILLION FAMILIES
OF THE PEOPLE
AFFECTED BY ALZHEIMER'S,
IT'S THE LEAST WE CAN DO.
AND WE HOPE FOR GOOD RESULTS.
I THINK ONE OF THE FEW THINGS
THAT EXPERIENCE CAN TEACH YOU
IS YOU ACTUALLY GET A SENSE
FOR WHEN THE
SCIENCE IS VERY RICH.
AND IT'S A MAGICAL TIME.
AND IT DOESN'T
HAPPEN VERY OFTEN.
AND I THINK THE FIELD
IS AT THAT POINT...
THE DIAGNOSTIC TOOLS,
THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE
DISEASE AT SO MANY LEVELS.
ACTUALLY, PERHAPS THE
MOST IMPORTANT THING IS
THAT THE BIOLOGY AND THE
CLINICAL UNDERSTANDING
ARE, AS WE SPEAK, GETTING
PUT TOGETHER AT LAST.
IT'S FINALLY GETTING
PUT TOGETHER.
AND WE'RE GONNA SEE REAL
TREATMENTS HAPPEN AS A RESULT OF THAT.
IT'S A MAGIC TIME. IT'S
A MAGICAL TIME FOR US.
AND WE REALLY HOPE
THE PATIENTS ARE
GONNA BENEFIT FROM THIS.
Dr. Bateman: WE THINK
THAT THESE DRUGS
THAT ARE COMING
THROUGH THE CLINICAL TRIALS
HAVE A VERY GOOD CHANCE
OF REALLY CHANGING THE
COURSE OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Morris: THERE IS HOPE.
AND WE WANT TO MAKE A COMMITMENT
TO SEEING IF WE CAN'T
PREVENT THE ILLNESS.
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
ON ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. DeKosky: IF WE COULD
ACTUALLY DELAY IT 10 YEARS,
WE COULD WIPE OUT
MOST OF THE DISEASE
IN THE COUNTRY, IN THE WORLD.
BUT I THINK FOR ALL OF THIS,
WE WILL NEED MORE ENERGY,
MORE PEOPLE, MORE PROGRAMS,
MORE FUNDING TO
SUPPORT THESE EFFORTS.
IT REALLY MATTERS
TO ME THAT SOMEDAY
I'M GONNA TAKE A PRESCRIPTION
PAD OUT OF MY DRAWER
AND WRITE A PRESCRIPTION
THAT'S GONNA PREVENT YOU
FROM GETTING ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Hodes: OUR COMMITMENT
IS TO PURSUE AND ANSWER
AS RAPIDLY, AS
EXPEDITIOUSLY AS WE CAN,
SO THAT WE MINIMIZE
THE PROBABILITY
THAT A FEW YEARS FROM NOW
SOMEONE ELSE IS GONNA TURN
AND ASK US THE
VERY SAME QUESTION,
"WHY IS IT WE STILL
DON'T HAVE THE ANSWER?"
( instrumental music playing )
BUT I NEVER THOUGHT I'D GET IT.
AND WHEN IT HAPPENED,
I JUST...
THE FIRST THING I SAID TO CATHEE...
"ARE YOU GONNA LEAVE ME?"
THAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
THAT'S THE EXACT RIGHT MEMORY.
UH-HUH, I THOUGHT MY...
I WAS DOOMED.
IS THAT IT?
'CAUSE I THOUGHT
IT WAS THE END OF ME.
IF WE FAIL TO CURE OR
PREVENT ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN THE YEARS AND
DECADES TO COME,
WE'RE FACING
AN ENORMOUS INCREASE
IN THE HUMAN SUFFERING,
AS WELL AS THE FINANCIAL AND
SOCIETAL IMPACT THAT WILL OCCUR.
THERE'S BEEN AN
EXPONENTIAL INCREASE
IN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT
CAUSES ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
HOW WE CAN TARGET IT
AND HOW WE CAN TREAT IT.
Dr. Virginia Lee: IT
REALLY IS MIRACULOUS
THAT IN A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME...
WHICH IS REALLY 25 YEARS...
WE KNOW A LOT ABOUT THE DISEASE.
WE ARE AT THE BRINK
OF CONTROLLING
ONE OF THE MAJOR DISEASES
AFFECTING WORLD HEALTH.
Dr. Lennart Mucke: THERE'S A TRUE
EXPLOSION IN EXCITING NEW DISCOVERIES,
MANY OF WHICH AIMED AT THE
ROOT CAUSES OF THE DISEASE,
AND THEREFORE IMPLYING
ENORMOUS THERAPEUTIC POTENTIAL.
Dr. John C. Morris: WE DO HAVE
THE RESEARCH SCIENTISTS.
WE DO HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE.
AND I THINK WE CAN BEAT
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE HISTORY OF MODERN
MEDICINE IS REALLY TRACKED BACK
TO AROUND 500 YEARS
AGO WHEN PEOPLE DECIDED
THAT IT MIGHT BE A GOOD
IDEA TO CRACK OPEN THE BODY
AND ACTUALLY SEE
WHERE THE DISEASE IS.
IF SOMEONE IS BILIOUS,
IS HIS LIVER REALLY AFFECTED?
IF SOMEONE IS DEMENTED,
IS HIS BRAIN AFFECTED?
AND IT'S NOT THAT LONG AGO,
BUT THAT REALLY
GAVE RISE TO THIS IDEA
THAT WE ACTUALLY HAVE TO SEE
THE DISEASE TO UNDERSTAND IT.
ALOIS ALZHEIMER
WAS A GERMAN NEUROPATHOLOGIST.
HIS USE OF NOVEL
STAINING TECHNIQUES
IN DEAD BRAIN UNDER
THE MICROSCOPE
ALLOWED HIM FOR
THE FIRST TIME TO SEE
THIS CONSTELLATION
OF AMYLOID PLAQUES,
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
AND IT ULTIMATELY JUSTIFIED
CALLING THIS DISEASE
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
NOW IT'S INTERESTING
TO POINT OUT THAT,
IF YOU LOOK AT TEXTBOOKS OF
NEUROLOGY, PSYCHIATRY, MEDICINE...
FOR DECADES THEREAFTER,
INTO THE '30s, '40s, '50s,
THERE'S NARY A MENTION
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Steven DeKosky: SERIOUS AND FOCUSED
RESEARCH ON ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
REALLY BEGAN A LITTLE
OVER 20 YEARS AGO
WHEN THE NATIONAL
INSTITUTE OF AGING
AND A VARIETY OF OTHER
RESEARCHERS, BRAIN RESEARCHERS,
REALIZED THAT WHAT WE
HAD BEEN CALLING DEMENTIA,
OR SENILE DEMENTIA,
OR HARDENING OF THE ARTERIES,
OR ARTERIOSCLEROSIS IN LATE LIFE
THAT EVERYONE JUST
CALLED "DEMENTIA,"
ACTUALLY IN THE VAST MAJORITY
OF CASES WAS ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
WHEN WE STARTED, NO
ONE KNEW ANYTHING ABOUT
WHAT PLAQUES OR TANGLES...
THE THINGS WE SEE IN
THE BRAIN... WERE MADE OF.
WE BELIEVE THAT
THE BETA-AMYLOID,
THE BAD ACTOR IN PLAQUES,
LEADS TO THE DISRUPTION
OF TAU PROTEIN,
AND RESULTS IN
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
BOTH THE PLAQUE AND
THE TANGLE DO OCCUR
IN THE BRAINS OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE PATIENTS.
AND A GREAT ENIGMA
IS HOW THEY ARE LINKED.
DO THEY JUST EVOLVE
INDEPENDENTLY
OR IS THERE SOME SHARED PROCESS,
SOME SHARED
PATHOLOGICAL PROCESS?
WE KNOW THAT IN PATIENTS
WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
THAT PROBABLY
PLAQUES OCCUR FIRST AND
THEN TANGLES OCCUR LATER.
BUT SINCE PATIENTS
AT AUTOPSY HAVE BOTH,
THEN IT'S VERY DIFFICULT
TO REALLY TEASE OUT
HOW THIS HAPPENS.
JOHN AND I BELIEVE THAT
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES
PLAY A VERY IMPORTANT ROLE
IN THE DEMISE OF NEURONS.
AND AS IT TURNS OUT,
TAU IS A KNOWN PROTEIN.
AND IN FACT,
IT IS A VERY ABUNDANT
PROTEIN IN NERVE CELLS.
TAU ACTUALLY STABILIZES
THE TRANSPORT
SYSTEM IN NERVE CELLS.
HOWEVER, IN ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
TAU FALLS OFF THIS
TRANSPORT SYSTEM
AND BEGINS TO CLUMP TOGETHER
AND FORM
NEUROFIBRILLARY TANGLES.
AND WHEN THE
TANGLES BEGIN TO FORM,
THESE EXTENSIONS
BEGIN TO SHRINK.
AND YOU CAN SEE THAT
THEY'RE SHRINKING.
AND EVENTUALLY
THEY'RE TOTALLY GONE.
AND THEN THESE THESE
NERVE CELLS EVENTUALLY DIE.
THE CONUNDRUM RIGHT NOW IS
THAT PEOPLE ARE DIAGNOSED
WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
WHEN THEY HAVE
SIGNIFICANT MEMORY FAILURE.
WE HAVE GOOD REASON TO BELIEVE
THAT ALREADY THEIR BRAINS
HAVE BEEN ACCUMULATING
PLAQUES AND TANGLES FOR
FIVE, 10, POSSIBLY 15 YEARS.
SO THE PATHOLOGY BEGINS
MANY MANY MORE YEARS
BEFORE SYMPTOMS APPEAR.
PITTSBURGH COMPOUND
B, OR PiB, AS IT'S KNOWN,
IS A RADIOACTIVE TRACER
THAT YOU GIVE IN A VEIN
THAT, WHEN YOU DO AN IMAGE,
SHOWS YOU THE AMYLOID
PLAQUES THAT ARE IN THE BRAIN
OF PEOPLE WITH
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Man: START.
Dr. William Klunk: THE BASIC
GOAL WAS TO BE ABLE TO SEE
THE AMYLOID PLAQUES
THAT ARE CHARACTERISTIC
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN A LIVING PERSON,
AND TO BE ABLE TO TELL
HOW MUCH OF IT WAS THERE.
IT WAS A GOAL OF OURS
TO DO THIS FOR MANY YEARS.
AND WE WANTED TO BE THE FIRST,
OR AMONG THE FIRST,
TO BE SUCCESSFUL AT IT.
WHAT'S THE VALUE OF SUCCEEDING?
THE MOST OBVIOUS IS,
WELL, IMPROVED DIAGNOSIS.
YOU KNOW, WE CAN DO NOW...
WE COULD DO IN A LIVING PERSON
WHAT YOU NOW HAVE TO WAIT
UNTIL AUTOPSY AFTER DEATH TO DO.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Dr. DeKosky: WE BEGAN
STUDYING FAMILIES
WHO HAVE EARLY-ONSET DISEASE.
WE KNEW THAT THEY WERE
DEVELOPING AMYLOID IN THEIR BRAINS,
AND CERTAINLY AT AN EARLIER
AGE THAN OTHERS... 30s AND 40s.
THERE ARE ONLY 200 TO
300 FAMILIES IN THE WORLD
WHO HAVE THESE
KINDS OF MUTATIONS
THAT LEAD TO FAMILIAL
EARLY-ONSET DISEASE.
AND THEREFORE WE
THOUGHT IT WOULD BE
A VERY GOOD TEST
OF PiB TO SEE AMYLOID
AND SHOW US WHAT HAPPENED
AS THE DISEASE PROGRESSED.
THE FIRST IMAGES
THAT I SAW OF PiB WERE
IN THE CLASSIC THREE DIMENSIONS.
AND IT WAS AN ABSOLUTELY
MOUTH-DROPPING MOMENT.
AND I KNEW INSTANTLY,
AS DID EVERY OTHER ONE
OF OUR RESEARCH TEAM,
THAT THIS WAS GOING TO CHANGE
THE WAY ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE WAS STUDIED FOREVER.
Dr. Klunk: ONE OF THE VALUES
OF STUDYING THIS FAMILY...
ALL SIX INDIVIDUALS
THAT PARTICIPATED,
THEY'VE COME BACK
FOR REPEATED SCANS.
AND WE HAVE A RANGE OF 14 YEARS
FROM THE YOUNGEST TO THE OLDEST.
THESE FAMILIES HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITY
TO LEAD US TO
EFFECTIVE TREATMENTS.
OKAY, THIS IS MY SIX
CHILDREN, TAKEN IN ABOUT 1977.
THIS IS BRIAN AND
KARLA... LITTLE KARLA...
SKINNY LORI THERE,
JAMIE, DEAN AND DOUG.
DOUG LOOKS JUST THE SAME.
MY HUSBAND HAD ALZHEIMER'S.
AND HIS MOTHER DID BEFORE HIM.
AND SHE DIED AT 53.
WE DIDN'T KNOW
WHAT IT WAS, DID WE?
YOU JUST THOUGHT YOU
WERE MAKING YOUR DAD MAD?
THERE WAS A LOT OF
COMMOTION AT HOME.
AND HIS MOOD CHANGED.
HE WAS VERY ANGRY A LOT.
AND YOU HAVE SIX
KIDS COMING AND GOING.
- A LOT OF ACTIVITY.
- THE ACTIVITY IS HARD.
- AND THAT'S HARD FOR THEM.
- THAT'S VERY HARD.
WHEN I GOT THE NEWS THAT I
DIDN'T CARRY THE MUTATED GENE,
I KNEW OF COURSE THEN,
THAT I WAS GOING TO BE,
YOU KNOW, WITHOUT
THEM ALL SOMEDAY.
AND I, YOU KNOW, MADE UP MY MIND
THAT I WAS GONNA DO
EVERYTHING IN MY POWER
TO MAKE SURE THAT MY SIBLINGS
GET THE RESPECT AND HELP
THAT THEY DESERVE THROUGH THIS.
WE STARTED WORKING
WITH THE FAMILIES
WHO HAVE EARLY-ONSET FAMILIAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE FOR TWO REASONS:
FIRST, WE KNOW THAT THEY
GET AMYLOID IN THEIR BRAINS.
AND THEY GET IT AT A MUCH
EARLIER TIME, OBVIOUSLY,
THAN PEOPLE WHO HAVE
LATE-ONSET DISEASE.
WE WANTED TO KNOW,
TO SEE, IF PiB REALLY WAS
WORKING, WHAT WOULD IT SHOW US?
THE ONLY WAY TO
BE ABLE TO DO THAT
WOULD BE WITH AN
IMAGING TRACER LIKE PiB
THAT WOULD LET US LOOK AT
THEM REPEATEDLY OVER TIME
AND BE ABLE TO
CORRELATE IT WITH THEIR
PAPER-AND-PENCIL
TESTING AT THE SAME TIME.
DRAW A CLOCK. PUT
ALL THE NUMBERS ON IT.
AND SET THE TIME
AT 10 AFTER 11:00.
OKAY. ALL DONE.
SINCE LAST YEAR WHEN WE
SAW HIM, HOW IS HE OVERALL?
IS HE BETTER, WORSE OR
THE SAME, DO YOU THINK?
I THINK HE HAS GOTTEN
A LITTLE BIT WORSE.
AND THEN HE'S SLOWED DOWN A LOT.
LET'S TALK ABOUT
LORI FOR A MINUTE.
HOW DO YOU THINK
SHE'S DIFFERENT?
- IS IT HER MEMORY? IS IT HER MOOD?
- YEAH.
- EVERYTHING?
- YEAH.
WE SAW HER LAST YEAR. SHE
REALLY HADN'T CHANGED VERY MUCH,
AT LEAST AS FAR AS HER
FORMAL TESTING WAS CONCERNED.
HER SHORT-TERM MEMORY IS...
IT SEEMS TO BE
REALLY HARD FOR HER.
THE THING IS, SHE KNOWS,
SHE RECOGNIZES IT.
I'M GOING TO NAME THREE OBJECTS.
AND I WANT YOU TO SAY
THEM BACK AFTER I STOP.
APPLE, PENNY, TABLE.
I KNOW THAT I'M PROGRESSING.
SO YOU JUST LIKE...
KINDA FEEL LIKE, "WELL, WHEN...
YOU KNOW, WHEN I AM GONNA
NOT BE ABLE TO DO THAT?"
IF WE WERE TO ASK YOUR HUSBAND
IF HE THOUGHT YOU
WERE BETTER, WORSE
OR THE SAME AS LAST YEAR,
WHAT DO YOU THINK HE'D SAY?
HE'D PROBABLY SAY
A LITTLE BIT WORSE.
- MAYBE A LITTLE BIT?
- YEAH.
KNOWING HOW EARLY
MY FATHER DIED,
SO, YOU KNOW, HE DIDN'T
GET TO ENJOY HIS GRANDKIDS.
IF MY DAUGHTERS GET MARRIED,
I ALWAYS KNEW I WOULD BE
A REALLY REALLY GOOD GRANDMA.
AND I PROBABLY WON'T GET TO.
WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT THE
RESULTS OF YOUR PiB SCANS.
SO THIS IS
A TYPICAL LATE-ONSET
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THESE FIVE ARE
YOUR FAMILY MEMBERS
FROM YOUNGEST TO OLDEST.
THIS IS DOUG'S SCAN.
AND THIS IS LORI'S SCAN.
IN LATE-ONSET ALZHEIMER'S
WE HAVE ALL THESE
AMYLOID DEPOSITS,
WHEREAS IN YOUR FAMILY
THERE'S THIS INTENSE
FOCAL DEPOSIT,
BUT THEN THERE'S LITTLE
BITS IN OTHER PLACES.
YOU'RE ALL SITTING HERE,
YOU'RE BEING VERY STRONG.
BUT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THINGS
THAT ARE, YOU KNOW,
INTIMATELY INVOLVED
WITH YOUR LIFE AND YOUR
PRESENT AND YOUR FUTURES.
AND, YOU KNOW, YOU'RE LOOKING
AT ONE REPRESENTATION
OF THE DISEASE
ON THE SCREEN
HERE... THE AMYLOID.
IT MAKES IT VERY
REAL AND VERY TOUGH.
- Lori: DOES IT MAKE YOU WONDER?
- YEAH.
Dr. Klunk: THIS ISN'T
AN EASY THING.
Gail: YEAH, PICTURE HER, THE ONLY
ONE THAT DOESN'T CARRY THE GENE,
TRYING TO DO SO MUCH
FOR THE REST OF US.
THERE'S A LOT OF
PAIN IN THAT TOO.
I DON'T KNOW, I THINK I'LL BE
SO ALONE WITHOUT THEM.
THERE'S TOO MANY...
TOO MANY OF THEM.
AND SOMETIMES YOU JUST NEED
YOUR BROTHERS AND SISTERS.
Lori: I UNDERSTAND THAT.
WHAT I HOPE... AND
I THINK ONE THING
THAT WE'RE LEARNING
FROM THIS RESEARCH
IS THAT WE CAN SEE AMYLOID
MUCH SOONER THAN
THE SYMPTOMS START.
SO THAT'S A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY.
THAT'S A TIME WHEN
YOU MAY BE ABLE
TO GET TO THE DISEASE WHEN
YOU CAN HAVE THE MOST SUCCESS.
Gail: I'M SO PROUD OF MY FAMILY
TO HAVE PARTICIPATED,
EACH ONE OF THEM,
AND DID IT SO WILLINGLY.
- YOU GUYS GO THROUGH A LOT.
- I'M REALLY PROUD OF THEM.
Dr. DeKosky: I THINK ONE OF
THE THINGS THE DeMOES SHOW
IS THE INCREDIBLE
DEDICATION OF THESE FAMILIES
WHO HAVE A VERY SERIOUS
DISEASE IN THEIR GENES
TO RESEARCH.
THEY COME TO US FROM FAR AWAY.
THEY COME BACK EVERY YEAR.
THEY UNDERSTAND THAT WE'RE
LEARNING ABOUT THE DISEASE,
AND THAT IT MAY HELP
THEIR NEXT GENERATION,
OR THE GENERATION AFTER THAT,
BUT IT ISN'T GOING TO HELP THEM.
AND YET THEY STILL COME.
THEY DO WHATEVER
WE ASK THEM TO DO.
THEY ARE REALLY
PARTNERS IN THIS FIGHT.
WELL, WE REALLY
APPRECIATE YOU COMING IN.
- WE APPRECIATE EVERYTHING.
- THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Dr. Hodes: THE IMAGING OF THE BRAIN
THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY ABLE TO DO
COULD NOT HAVE BEEN
IMAGINED 20 OR 30 YEARS AGO.
ALL OF THIS GIVES
US AN OPPORTUNITY
TO CARRY OUT RESEARCH OF A SORT
THAT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN
IMAGINED A DECADE OR TWO AGO,
AND ARE THE REASON
FOR THE EXCITEMENT
THAT I THINK PERVADES THE FIELD
AND GIVES APPROPRIATE AND
JUSTIFIED REASON FOR HOPE
TO SCIENTISTS AND
TO THE PUBLIC AS WELL.
AGE-RELATED MEMORY DECLINE
IS CHARACTERIZED BY AFFECTING
TWO GENERAL AREAS OF THE BRAIN:
THE FRONTAL LOBES,
THE PREFRONTAL CORTEX;
AND AN AREA CALLED
THE HIPPOCAMPUS,
WHICH IS DEEP WITHIN
THE TEMPORAL LOBES.
IF YOU MISPLACE YOUR KEYS,
IF YOU CAN'T REMEMBER
WHERE YOU PARKED YOUR CAR,
IF YOU CAN'T QUITE
REMEMBER THE NAME
OF A CLIENT YOU
JUST MET A WEEK AGO,
BUT YOU CAN REMEMBER CLIENTS
THAT YOU MET, YOU KNOW, YEARS AGO,
THAT'S A PROBLEM WITH
SAVING NEW INFORMATION.
AND THAT'S AN EXAMPLE OF
HIPPOCAMPAL DYSFUNCTION.
I'M WORRIED ABOUT THE
BEGINNING OF ALZHEIMER'S...
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S.
I JUST HAVE... I FEEL MY...
I KNOW EVERYBODY SAYS THEY
HAVE PROBLEMS WITH THEIR MEMORY,
BUT I'VE LIVED WITH SOMEONE
WHO HAD ALZHEIMER'S.
AND I SEE MYSELF IN HIM.
AND I'M VERY
APPREHENSIVE ABOUT IT.
THE EARLIEST STAGE
OF ALZHEIMER'S
IS ONE WHERE THE
CELLS ARE STILL THERE.
YOU MIGHT NOT HAVE
FULLY-FORMED PLAQUES AND TANGLES,
BUT THE CELLS ARE
JUST MALFUNCTIONING.
SO NOW WE'RE TRYING
TO USE TECHNOLOGIES
THAT CAPTURE CELL SICKNESS
TO ASK THE QUESTION, "WHEN
DOES ALZHEIMER'S BEGIN?"
- HELLO.
- Woman: HELLO, ANITA.
- HOW ARE YOU?
- IS DR. SMALL HERE?
AND THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
WE'RE CURRENTLY TESTING.
BUT IT'S NOT THAT SIMPLE,
BECAUSE THE HIPPOCAMPUS
COULD BE AFFECTED
BOTH BY NORMAL AGING AND
BY EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THAT'S ONE OF THE
REASONS WHY WE FOCUS SO MUCH
ON THE SYMPTOMS THAT
RELATE TO THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
BECAUSE AS CLINICIANS WE WORRY...
MIGHT THAT BE AN INDICATOR
OF EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE?
VERY NICE OF YOU
TO INVITE ME IN.
- HAVE A SEAT.
- THANK YOU.
- HOW HAVE YOU BEEN?
- PRETTY GOOD, CONSIDERING.
SO GIVE ME SOME EXAMPLES
OF FORGETFULNESS.
I DON'T LIKE THIS FEELING OF...
WHEN I'M SPEAKING TO PEOPLE,
IN THE MIDDLE OF WHATEVER
WE'RE SPEAKING ABOUT,
I GO COMPLETELY BLANK,
AND I CAN'T PULL UP...
- AND IT COMES BACK LATER.
- MAYBE.
YOU KNOW, I MEAN,
WHEN IT'S NOT IMPORTANT.
- RIGHT.
- BUT NOT ONLY THAT,
I DO THE SAME THING WITH WORDS.
I CAN'T FIND... MY VOCABULARY
HAS ABSOLUTELY DISINTEGRATED.
AS YOU KNOW, WE DO
OCCASIONALLY A MEMORY TEST.
I'M GONNA GIVE YOU
THREE OBJECTS...
APPLE, TABLE, PENNY.
APPLE, TABLE, PENNY.
KEEP THEM IN YOUR MEMORY.
I'M GONNA ASK YOU TO
REPEAT THEM IN A FEW MINUTES.
BUT FOR NOW
I'M GONNA ASK YOU TO
REPEAT SOME NUMBERS,
BUT YOU DON'T NEED TO
REMEMBER THE NUMBERS, OKAY?
SIX, TWO, NINE.
SIX, TWO, NINE.
FOUR, TWO, SEVEN, THREE, ONE.
- FOUR, TWO, SEVEN, THREE, ONE.
- GOOD.
WHAT WERE THOSE THREE
OBJECTS I ASKED YOU TO REMEMBER?
VERY EASY. I HAVE
A WAY OF DOING IT.
- THAT'S OKAY. TRICKS ARE ACCEPTED.
- OKAY?
I PUT THE APPLE ON TOP
OF THE PENNY ON THE TABLE.
EXCELLENT. SO WHO WAS
THE PRESIDENT BEFORE BUSH?
- IT WASN'T CLINTON?
- YES.
- OH, IT WAS?
- SEE? TRUST YOURSELF.
WHO WAS BEFORE CLINTON?
- OH, BUSH.
- GOOD.
AND WHO WAS BEFORE BUSH?
OH...
JOHNSON? NO.
- YES?
- NO.
WE'RE CURRENTLY
FUNDED BY THE N.I.H.
TO IMAGE HUNDREDS
OF HEALTHY ELDERS,
GENERATE THESE PATTERNS
IN THE HIPPOCAMPAL FORMATION
AND FOLLOW THESE
SUBJECTS PROSPECTIVELY.
AND THE QUESTION TO US WILL BE...
"CAN WE DETECT THE EARLIEST
STAGES OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
VERSUS NORMAL AGING ITSELF?"
SO WE NOW HAVE OPTIMIZED
AN M.R.I.-BASED TECHNOLOGY
THAT ALLOWS US
TO REALLY VISUALIZE
THE HIPPOCAMPAL SUBREGIONS
IN MICE AND HUMANS.
AND WE'VE BEEN APPLYING
THAT TECHNOLOGY
ACROSS NUMEROUS STUDIES
TO REALLY TRY TO
TEST THIS QUESTION,
OR TEST THIS HYPOTHESIS...
DOES ALZHEIMER'S
AND NORMAL AGING
TARGET DIFFERENT SUBREGIONS
OF THE HIPPOCAMPUS?
SO REMEMBER THAT THIS IS
A RESEARCH PROJECT
THAT YOU'VE PARTICIPATED IN.
THERE'S A BASIC
ASSUMPTION WE'RE MAKING
THAT ALZHEIMER'S STARTS
IN ONE PART OF THE
HIPPOCAMPAL FORMATION.
THE ENTORHINAL CORTEX
WILL BE TARGETED BY ALZHEIMER'S,
WHEREAS THIS NEIGHBORING
AREA SHOWN IN WHITE...
THE DENTATE GYRUS...
SHOULD BE TARGETED
BY NORMAL AGING.
THESE TWO AREAS SEEM
TO GIVE US THE MOST...
- INFORMATION? -... INFORMATION
IN TRYING TO DISSOCIATE
ALZHEIMER'S FROM AGING.
IT'S THIS AREA OF THE
HIPPOCAMPUS... THE DENTATE GYRUS...
THAT WE FIND, IN YOUR
BRAIN IS RELATIVELY DOWN.
CAN WE IDENTIFY
AT THE MOLECULAR LEVEL
WHAT'S WRONG IN THE
ENTORHINAL CORTEX
IN ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
WHAT'S WRONG WITH THE
DENTATE GYRUS IN NORMAL AGING,
AS A WAY TO BEGIN
TO GET AT CLUES
AT AN UNDERLYING
MOLECULAR MECHANISM?
IN THE ENTORHINAL CORTEX
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO
UNCOVER A NEW MECHANISM
THAT PLAYS A ROLE IN
THE PRODUCTION OF A BETA.
AND THIS IN TURN
SUGGESTS NEW WAYS
IN WHICH WE COULD
BEGIN TO EXPLORE
DIFFERENT THERAPIES
BASED ON THIS FINDING.
YOU KNOW, YOUR CHIEF COMPLAINT
IS FORGETFULNESS, RIGHT?
- REMIND ME, HOW OLD ARE YOU?
- 81.
I THINK THAT YOU
HAVE NORMAL AGING.
I DON'T THINK THAT YOU HAVE
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
GOOD. GOOD.
WE KNOW THAT NORMAL AGING ITSELF
ALSO CAUSES CELL SICKNESS,
BUT NEVER PROGRESSES OUTSIDE
OF THE CELL-SICKNESS STAGE.
BECAUSE IF YOU THINK
ABOUT ALL THE SUCCESSES
THAT WE'VE MADE IN
MEDICINE, THEY'VE REALLY COME
ON THE HEELS OF BEING ABLE
TO VISUALIZE THE PROBLEM,
WHETHER IT'S CANCER,
HEART DISEASE,
AND, IN FACT, BRAIN DISORDERS...
STROKE, M.S... MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS... TUMORS.
ONE OF THE GREAT CHALLENGES
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IS THE FACT THAT UNTIL RECENTLY
IT'S BEEN RELATIVELY
INVISIBLE TO OUR TECHNOLOGIES.
AND I THINK THAT'S WHY IT'S
BEEN SUCH A GREAT CHALLENGE.
BUT THAT, I THINK,
IS SHIFTING NOW.
ALL RIGHT, COME ON
IN TO THE MAGNET.
JUST WHAT I NEED.
SO THE FIRST PART...
YOU'RE GONNA CLIMB
ALL THE WAY UP THESE STAIRS.
AND WE WANT YOU TO
BE VERY STEADY HERE.
WE GOT INTERESTED IN THIS IDEA
OF LOOKING AT MEMORY FORMATION
BECAUSE I THINK IN
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
THE MEMORY TROUBLE
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS EXPERIENCE
ACTUALLY BEGINS AT THE
FIRST MOMENT THEY ENCODE,
OR TRY TO LEARN,
NEW INFORMATION.
SO WE KNOW THAT
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS
LOSE INFORMATION
MORE QUICKLY OVER TIME.
BUT WE ALSO THINK THAT
EVEN THE WAY THEIR BRAIN
LEARNS THAT INFORMATION
IS UNFORTUNATELY ABNORMAL.
SO REMEMBER, THESE ARE
GONNA GO IN YOUR EARS.
ALL RIGHT. THAT'S GOOD.
MAKE SURE IT'S NOT
PUSHING ON YOUR...
WE'RE FOLLOWING
OLDER INDIVIDUALS
BECAUSE WE ARE ABLE
NOW TO LOOK AT INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE STILL NORMAL,
OR JUST HAVE A LITTLE
BIT OF MEMORY TROUBLE,
AND SEE IF THEY HAVE ONE OF THE HALLMARK
PATHOLOGIES OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
BECAUSE IN THE SETTING
OF ALZHEIMER'S PATHOLOGY,
THE BRAIN WILL WORK DIFFERENTLY.
AND WE SEE EVIDENCE
THAT THE BRAIN HAS TO USE
COMPENSATORY AREAS
OF NETWORKS TO ACTIVATE
IN THE SETTING OF
THIS EARLY PATHOLOGY.
AND WE MAY BE ABLE
TO SEE THAT THREE, FIVE,
MAYBE EVEN 10 YEARS BEFORE
SOMEONE'S GONNA DEVELOP DEMENTIA.
- DO YOU FEEL OKAY?
- MM-HMM.
COME ON RIGHT OVER
HERE, MRS. HAMILTON.
SO HE'S IN THERE, AND YOU CAN
SEE IF YOU LOOK IN THE BACK...
YOU CAN ACTUALLY SEE THE
SCREEN FLASHING ON AND OFF.
AND THIS IS ACTUALLY
WHAT HE'S SEEING...
- THESE PICTURES OF NAMES AND FACES.
- OH, NAMES AND FACES.
RIGHT, AND THERE'S A FEW OF THEM
- THAT REPEAT AGAIN AND AGAIN.
- VERY INTERESTING.
FOR EACH FACE NAME YOU SEE,
TRY TO REMEMBER
WHICH NAME GOES WITH WHICH FACE.
AND THE HIPPOCAMPUS
IS REALLY IN THE CENTER,
DEEP IN THE BRAIN, AND
INTEGRATES ALL OF THE INFORMATION
FROM VISUAL CENTERS COMING IN,
AUDITORY CENTERS AND
ALSO THOUGHT CENTERS
THAT ARE IMPORTANT FOR KNOWING
WHETHER OR NOT
SOMETHING IS NEW AND OLD.
AND WE THINK THAT THE
HIPPOCAMPUS BINDS TOGETHER
THIS INFORMATION IN A NEW,
COHESIVE MEMORY TRACE.
OKAY, I KNOW HE NEEDS
EVERY SECOND. AND GO. GO NOW.
OKAY, WE'RE ALL DONE. WE'RE
COMING IN TO GET YOU NOW.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S GET HIM OUT
AND MAKE SURE HE'S COMFORTABLE.
WE'RE GONNA HAVE YOU
DO THE FUN PART NOW...
THE TESTING OF HOW YOUR
MEMORY IS FOR THE NAMES AND FACES.
Mr. Hamilton: I DON'T
REMEMBER LOUIS OR ISAAC.
"GAIL." I DON'T
REMEMBER HER AT ALL.
THEY'RE MIXING TOGETHER
IN MY MIND SO QUICKLY.
YOU CAN SEE EVIDENCE
THAT HE'S GOT A LOT OF LOSS
OF CORTICAL TISSUE, AS WELL
AS HIPPOCAMPAL ATROPHY.
SO HERE YOU SEE MORE BLACK.
THERE'S LOSS OF TISSUE
IN THE HIPPOCAMPUS
AND LOSS OF TISSUE
ALL AROUND THE CORTEX,
PARTICULARLY IN THE
PARIETAL LOBE HERE.
HERE'S A PERSON WHO WAS ONE
OF THE MOST PROLIFIC WRITERS
IN THE WHOLE LAW
SCHOOL... 70-80 PEOPLE.
BUT HIS EVALUATIONS
BEGAN TO FALL OFF.
AND FOR BOB HAVING
HIS EVALUATIONS
DROP TO 80th PERCENTILE
OR 75th PERCENTILE
WAS UNTHINKABLE,
WAS HUMILIATING.
IT WAS A BIT PAINFUL.
I WOULD DESCRIBE IT THAT WAY.
IT WASN'T, YOU KNOW, "OH
MY GOD, MY LIFE HAS ENDED."
BUT IT WAS A BIT OF A SHOCK.
ONE OF THE MOST
SURPRISING THINGS WE FOUND
WHEN WE STARTED TO STUDY
OLDER INDIVIDUALS
WITH FUNCTIONAL IMAGING
IS THAT SOME PARTS OF THE BRAIN
ACTUALLY HYPER TURN
ON, OR HYPERACTIVATE.
THAT WAS REALLY SURPRISING,
BECAUSE THE
ORIGINAL IDEA WAS THAT
AS A PROGRESSION OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE,
THAT YOU JUST LOSE EVERYTHING
AND EVERYTHING GOES
DOWN IN A NICE LINEAR FASHION.
BUT IT ACTUALLY TURNS OUT
THAT SOME PARTS OF THE BRAIN,
PARTICULARLY
EARLY IN THE DISEASE
WHEN PEOPLE ARE AT A PHASE OF
WHAT WE CALL MILD COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT
WHERE THEY'VE GOT A LITTLE
BIT OF MEMORY TROUBLE
BUT ARE STILL ABLE TO FUNCTION,
WHAT WE'VE SEEN
USING FUNCTIONAL M.R.I.
IS THAT THESE
PARTS OF THE BRAIN,
IN PARTICULAR THE HIPPOCAMPUS
THAT'S SO IMPORTANT FOR MEMORY,
GOES INTO HYPERDRIVE.
AND IN ORDER TO
FORM A NEW MEMORY
IT ACTUALLY WORKS HARDER.
AND WE THOUGHT THAT PERHAPS
THIS IS EVIDENCE OF COMPENSATION,
OR TRYING TO COMPENSATE FOR
EARLY ALZHEIMER'S PATHOLOGY.
SO IT'S REVVING AND
DRIVING AS FAST AS IT CAN,
AND DURING THAT
PHASE OF HYPERACTIVITY
YOU'RE ABLE TO MAINTAIN MEMORY.
AND UNFORTUNATELY,
WHAT WE'VE SEEN IS THAT,
AS PEOPLE PROGRESS,
THEY LOSE ACTIVATION
IN EXACTLY THE AREA
THAT WAS HYPERACTIVATING.
SO ALTHOUGH THIS MAY BE
COMPENSATORY EARLY ON,
IT'S ALSO A SIGN OF IMPENDING
FAILURE OF THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
AND MORE AND MORE WE'VE
SEEN THAT THIS HYPERACTIVATION
IS ACTUALLY A VERY
GOOD PREDICTOR
OF WHO'S GONNA DECLINE
OVER THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
UNFORTUNATELY... YOU CAN SEE
HIS HIPPOCAMPUS OVER HERE...
VERY VERY LITTLE
HIPPOCAMPAL ACTIVATION.
NO HIPPOCAMPAL ACTIVATION,
NO PRECUNEUS DEACTIVATION.
OKAY.
HERE, EVEN IN A SINGLE
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENT,
IT'S JUST A VERY GOOD EXAMPLE
OF HOW THIS MEMORY NETWORK
IS REALLY NOT
FUNCTIONING AT ALL.
YOU CAN SEE THAT
ALTHOUGH PARTS OF HIS BRAIN...
THE PARTS THAT ARE IMPORTANT
FOR VISION AND BASIC ATTENTION...
ARE WORKING, HIS HIPPOCAMPUS,
THIS MEMORY CENTER'S REALLY
NOT ABLE TO TURN ON AT ALL.
YOU GUYS HAVE BEEN REAL TROUPERS
ALL THE WAY THROUGH THIS TRIAL.
WELL, WE JUST FEEL
LUCKY TO BE PART OF IT.
I THINK BOB FEELS THAT WAY TOO.
EVEN THOUGH I CLEARLY HAVE
ALZHEIMER'S PROBLEMS,
THEY REALLY HAVE NOT
SLOWED ME DOWN SIGNIFICANTLY.
SEE, I KEEP SEEING YOUR WIFE
HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT OPINION.
- I KNOW SHE DOES.
- I HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE.
- AND I CAN TELL YOU THAT... - BECAUSE
SHE CORRECTS ALL MY MISTAKES.
BUT, YOU KNOW, THAT'S
SO COMMON THAT OFTEN
IT DOESN'T BOTHER THE
PATIENT NEARLY AS MUCH
AS IT BOTHERS THE FAMILY
MEMBERS AND OTHERS.
I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY TRUE.
SHE FEELS THAT, I'M QUITE SURE.
ULTIMATELY, USING SINGLE
SUBJECT DATA LIKE THIS,
WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO
ASSESS TREATMENT.
SO IF WE CAN LOOK
IN A GIVEN PERSON
WHO'S NOT ABLE TO
ACTIVATE THEIR HIPPOCAMPUS,
AND THEY'RE FAILING
AT THIS MEMORY TASK,
IF WE COULD GIVE
THEM A TREATMENT,
AN ANTI-AMYLOID TREATMENT
SUCH AS AN ANTIBODY
OR ANOTHER WAY OF
REDUCING AMYLOID IN THE BRAIN,
AND SEE IF WE CAN
ACTUALLY RESTORE FUNCTION
TO THAT PART OF THE BRAIN,
THAT'S THE HOLY GRAIL.
AND SO IT'S THE COMBINATION
BETWEEN THE BRAINWAVES
AND THE MAGNETIC FIELDS
THAT THIS INSTRUMENT RECORDS.
THIS IS A VERY
EXCITING DAY FOR US
BECAUSE THIS IS
THE FIRST PATIENT
WE'RE ENROLLING IN OUR
CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
TO LOOK FOR SUBCLINICAL
EPILEPTIC FORM ACTIVITY,
OR ABNORMAL BRAINWAVE
ACTIVITY IN PEOPLE
WITH EARLY-STAGE ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE OR RELATED DEMENTIAS.
HOW'S THAT? ARE YOUR EARS OKAY?
THE STUDY INCLUDES
THE ADMISSION OF
PATIENTS TO THE HOSPITAL
FOR A 36-HOUR PERIOD.
AND DURING THAT PERIOD
THEIR BRAINWAVES ARE
CONTINUALLY RECORDED
AND THEN ANALYZED FOR
ANY ABNORMAL FREQUENCIES
OR EVEN PERHAPS BURSTS
THAT MIGHT REFLECT
SUBCLINICAL SEIZURE ACTIVITY.
WE WERE IMPRESSED CLINICALLY
BY THE VERY SIGNIFICANT
FLUCTUATIONS
THAT PEOPLE WITH
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
AND OTHER DEMENTIAS
SHOW IN THEIR FUNCTIONING.
SO SOMETIMES ONE
COMES IN THE ROOM
AND THE PATIENT HAS
REASONABLY GOOD ORIENTATION
AND EVEN RECOGNIZES
THEIR RELATIVES JUST FINE.
AND YOU CAN COME BACK
SOMETIMES IN THE AFTERNOON
AND THE PATIENT IS
UTTERLY CONFUSED
AND DOESN'T RECOGNIZE HIS
OR HER DAUGHTER ANYMORE.
AND WE THINK THAT THE
LIKELIEST EXPLANATION
FOR THESE FLUCTUATIONS
ARE INSTABILITIES IN
NEURAL NETWORK FUNCTION.
NOW I'D LIKE YOU TO COUNT
BACKWARDS FROM 100.
96, 95,
94, 93,
92, 91...
UH... ( chuckles )
- 90.
- 90.
LET'S SEE...
WE SUSPECT THAT
AN IMPORTANT PART
OF THE CELL DEATH PROCESS
IS ENERGY DEPLETION,
WHICH CAN COME ABOUT
EITHER BECAUSE NEURONS
ARE OVERSTIMULATED
AND CAN'T KEEP UP
WITH ALL THE DISCHARGING
THAT THEY HAVE TO DO.
SO THIS WOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH
WHAT HAS BEEN REFERRED
TO AS "EXCITOTOXICITY"...
TOO MUCH EXCITATION
RUNNING THE CELL INTO THE GROUND
BECAUSE IT JUST CAN'T KEEP
UP WITH ITS OWN ACTIVITY.
AND I THINK A KEY
PLAYER VERY LIKELY IS
THE AMYLOID BETA PEPTIDE...
A SMALL FRAGMENT
OF A LARGER PROTEIN
THAT WE ALL MAKE.
AND WE KNOW THAT IT IS
GENERATED AND CLEARED
VERY RAPIDLY THROUGHOUT THE DAY
MULTIPLE TIMES UNDER
NORMAL CIRCUMSTANCES.
AND IT LOOKS LIKE
EXCESS AMYLOID BETA
CAN GET THE CELL INTO OVERDRIVE.
- DEBORAH.
- YES?
HI, I'M DR. MUCKE.
- HOW ARE YOU DOING?
- FINE, THANK YOU.
I WANTED TO HEAR FROM
YOU A LITTLE BIT ABOUT
HOW YOU SEE THINGS
ARE DIFFERENT NOW
COMPARED TO, SAY, HOW THEY WERE
10-15 YEARS AGO.
I DON'T KNOW.
IT WAS VERY GRADUAL.
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IF
YOU CAN COPY THAT FOR ME.
YOU CAN START
ANYWHERE ON THE PAGE.
BUT IF YOU CAN TRY TO
COPY THAT CUBE FOR ME...
- NO.
- IT'S TOUGH, RIGHT?
- THAT'S A REAL TOUGH ONE FOR YOU, I KNOW.
- ( laughs )
AND HER MINI MENTAL-STATE EXAM...
OVERALL SCORE
WAS A 20 OUT OF 30.
SHE GOT A 27 ABOUT A YEAR AGO.
SO THAT'S QUITE
A DROP, ACTUALLY.
THAT'S QUITE A DROP
OVER THAT TIME FRAME.
- YEAH.
- YEAH.
BASICALLY THE BOTTOM LINE IS
THAT THERE WERE ONLY
SOME SHARP TRANSIENTS,
BUT NOT ANY REAL CLEAR-CUT
EPILEPTIC FORM ACTIVITY.
NOT WHAT WE WOULD
CALL A JUICY SPIKE.
I THINK WHAT WE WOULD BE KIND OF
INTERESTED IN MOSTLY
IS THE SHARP ACTIVITY.
I BELIEVE THAT THE
DISEASE REALLY REQUIRES
A VERY OPEN-MINDED
APPROACH, IF YOU WILL,
WHERE ONE HAS TO UNDERSTAND
THAT IT COMES ABOUT
VIA DIFFERENT PROCESSES,
AND THAT ONE MAY
HAVE TO BLOCK IT ALSO
FROM MANY DIFFERENT ANGLES.
SO DIFFERENT
PATIENTS MAY REQUIRE
A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT
THERAPEUTIC APPROACH
FROM THE NEXT PERSON.
AND WE'RE BEGINNING NOW
IN OUR ANIMAL MODELS TO TEST
ALL THE DIFFERENT
ANTI-EPILEPTIC DRUGS THAT EXIST
TO FIND OUT
IF ANY OF THEM
ACTUALLY CAN INHIBIT
THE EPILEPTIC FORM,
EPILEPSYLIKE ACTIVITY
THAT THE AMYLOID
PROTEINS SEEM TO INDUCE.
- WE HAVE ENOUGH MATERIAL.
- WE DO.
AND WE ALSO NEED TO MAKE SURE
THAT OUR
DRUG-DEVELOPMENT PORTFOLIO
THAT THE COMMUNITY IS
BUILDING OVER THE YEARS
IS NOT TOO SINGLE-MINDED,
BECAUSE WE MAY BE BETTING
ON THE WRONG HORSE.
SO IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR US
TO DIVERSIFY
THE DRUG-DEVELOPMENT PORTFOLIO.
A CATEGORY OF
STUDY WHICH HAS BEEN
ENORMOUSLY IMPORTANT
TO ALZHEIMER'S RESEARCH
HAS BEEN THE LONGITUDINAL
STUDY OF HUMANS,
IN WHICH A GROUP OF PEOPLE
ARE EXTENSIVELY
WELL-CHARACTERIZED
AND THEN FOLLOWED THROUGH
MANY YEARS AND DECADES OF LIFE
IN AN EFFORT TO
BETTER UNDERSTAND
THE VARIABLES WHICH AFFECT THEM,
THE RISK FACTORS
IN THEIR BIOLOGICAL
OR LIFESTYLE BEHAVIORS,
AND HOW THESE TRANSLATE
INTO THE LIKELIHOOD OF RISK
OR PROTECTION AGAINST
A VARIETY OF DISEASES.
( tower bell chiming )
( organ playing )
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
♪ HALLELUJAH ♪
Dr. David Benne IN THE
RELIGIOUS ORDER STUDY,
WE HAD ONE OF THE
FIRST PUBLICATIONS
SHOWING THAT ENGAGING
IN MENTALLY STIMULATING ACTIVITY
MAY DELAY THE TIME
UNTIL YOU REACH GETTING
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Sister Caulfield: GOOD MORNING.
I'M APOLOGIZING
FOR INTERRUPTING.
SISTER CATHERINE,
WHO DIED IN IOWA
CITY TWO DAYS AGO,
GAVE HER BODY TO SCIENCE.
THE FAMILY WILL COME TOGETHER
FOR A MEMORIAL MASS AUGUST 23rd.
I WANT YOU TO KNOW
THAT I'M IN THE STUDY.
- Woman: ARE YOU?
- OH YEAH.
AND IT HELPS THE RESEARCH.
OH, IT HELPS RESEARCH. OH, SURE.
THAT'S RIGHT. THAT'S
THE IMPORTANT PART.
- THAT'S THE REASON WE DO IT.
- THAT'S TRUE.
- QUITE LARGE, ISN'T IT?
- SO THESE ARE TWO NUNS
FROM DUBUQUE, RIGHT?
RIGHT, THEY'RE TWO
NUNS FROM DUBUQUE.
OKAY.
THEY BOTH HAVE
SIGNIFICANT ATROPHY.
YOU CAN SEE THE ATROPHY HERE.
THIS ONE DOES LOOK
MORE SEVERE TO ME.
THE RELIGIOUS
ORDER STUDY INVOLVES
OLDER NUNS, PRIESTS AND
BROTHERS WITHOUT DEMENTIA
WHO AGREE TO BE
TESTED EVERY YEAR
TO TELL US ALL KINDS OF
THINGS ABOUT THEMSELVES.
AND A CONDITION OF ENTRY
IS THAT THEY HAVE TO AGREE
TO ORGAN DONATION
AT THE TIME OF DEATH.
WE'RE INTERESTED IN:
WHAT ARE THE COMMON
CHANGES IN THE BRAIN
THAT CAUSE PEOPLE
TO LOSE MEMORY
AS THEY GET OLDER?
HOW ARE DIFFERENT
RISK FACTORS THAT ARE
CAUSING MEMORY LOSS...
WHAT'S THE PATHWAY?
HOW ARE THEY DOING THAT?
WHAT ARE THEY DOING TO THE BRAIN
TO ACTUALLY CAUSE
THE MEMORY LOSS?
AND WE'RE OFTEN VERY SURPRISED,
WITH A LOT OF PATHOLOGY
WITH A PERSON WITH NO
COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT,
OR VERY LITTLE PATHOLOGY
IF THE PERSON DID HAVE
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO THIS IS A NUN FROM DUBUQUE.
SHE DIED. SHE WAS
ABOUT 80 YEARS OLD.
SHE HAD 18 YEARS OF EDUCATION.
AND SHE CLEARLY
HAD A MILD DEMENTIA
AT THE TIME THAT
WE LAST SAW HER...
PROBABLY ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND LET'S SEE WHAT
IT DID SHOW HERE.
AND YOU CAN ALREADY SEE
THE ABNORMALITY OF THE PLAQUES.
ALL OF THESE BLACK
STRUCTURES HERE
ARE PLAQUES WITHIN HER BRAIN.
OKAY, SO THE FIRST CASE...
PRETTY TYPICAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND THE SECOND CASE...
SHE WAS OVER 90 OVER YEARS OLD.
SHE HAD 20 YEARS OF EDUCATION,
NO DECLINE OVER THE YEARS
OVER THREE YEARS OF FOLLOW-UP.
WHAT DO YOU THINK
WE'RE GONNA SEE HERE?
IT LOOKS LIKE SHE SHOULD HAVE
A SOMEWHAT NORMAL BRAIN.
SHE HAS A SIGNIFICANT
NUMBER OF PLAQUES,
AND ENOUGH PLAQUES TO CONFIRM
A DIAGNOSIS OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO HER BRAIN LOOKS VERY SIMILAR
TO THE NUN THAT WE SAW
THAT DID HAVE DEMENTIA.
AND YET THIS WAS
SOMEBODY WHO WAS OLDER,
FUNCTIONING PRETTY WELL,
AND HAD REALLY NO
REASON FOR US TO SUSPECT
THAT SHE HAD
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
WE'RE DEVELOPING THIS IDEA
THAT CERTAIN TYPES
OF THINKING ABILITIES
CAN ACTUALLY HELP YOU TOLERATE
THE PATHOLOGY OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
SO IT'S NOT EXPRESSED
AS MEMORY LOSS.
AND WE TALK ABOUT MEMORY
LOSS 'CAUSE THAT IS REALLY
THE HALLMARK OF CLINICAL
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE BASIC IDEA BEHIND
COGNITIVE RESERVE
IS THAT TWO PEOPLE WITH THE SAME
AMOUNT OF ALZHEIMER'S CHANGES...
ONE WILL HAVE MEMORY
LOSS AND DEMENTIA,
AND THE OTHER ONE COULD
BE COMPLETELY NORMAL.
SO WHAT UNDERLIES THAT?
WHY IS IT THAT PATHOLOGY
OF, YOU KNOW, SO
MUCH IN ONE PERSON
IS HAVING SUCH A
DEVASTATING EFFECT,
AND THE SAME AMOUNT IS
NOT HAVING THAT EFFECT
IN ANOTHER PERSON?
AND SO THE IDEA OF A RESERVE
IS THAT PATHOLOGY IS DEVELOPING
IN THE CONTEXT OF AN INDIVIDUAL
THAT CAN SOMEHOW PROTECT IT.
AND THE QUESTION THEN BECOMES...
WHAT'S THE NATURE
OF THE PROTECTION?
ONE THING WE'VE
LOOKED AT, FOR EXAMPLE,
IS THE EXTENT OF
YOUR SOCIAL NETWORK,
SO HOW MANY PEOPLE YOU
FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH
TALKING TO AND CONFIDING IN.
AND THE LARGER THAT NETWORK,
THE LESS LIKELY
YOU ARE TO DECLINE,
AND THE LESS LIKELY
YOU ARE TO EXPERIENCE
CLINICAL ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
SO I ACTUALLY HAVE SOME DATA.
THE ONE THAT DID NOT
SHOW ANY MEMORY LOSS
HAD A SOCIAL NETWORK
THAT WAS 10 TIMES LARGER
THAN THE OTHER SISTER.
ALL RIGHT.
AND THE ONE THAT DID NOT
SHOW ANY COGNITIVE LOSS
ALSO WAS LESS LIKELY
TO BE DISTRESSED.
THERE'S SOMETHING
ABOUT THOSE FACTORS
IN THESE TWO WOMEN
WHERE THEY DIFFERED.
AND SOMEHOW THEY CHANGED
THE WAY THE BRAINS TOLERATED
AND RESPONDED TO THE
PATHOLOGY OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
IF YOU THINK ABOUT PEOPLE
THAT HAVE LARGER NETWORKS
VERSUS PEOPLE WITH
SMALLER NETWORKS...
I MEAN, WHAT'S DIFFERENT
ABOUT THOSE INDIVIDUALS?
IT'S HARD TO DEVELOP
A LARGE NETWORK.
IT TAKES WORK
AND IT TAKES SKILL.
ENGAGEMENT IN COGNITIVELY
STIMULATING ACTIVITIES...
TURNS OUT THAT PEOPLE
THAT SPEND MORE TIME
IN MORE VARIETIES OF
PROCESSING INFORMATION
ACTUALLY MAINTAIN
THEIR COGNITIVE ABILITIES.
AND, IN PARTICULAR,
THEY MAINTAIN
THEIR BRAIN EFFICIENCY.
THEY'RE QUEEN
ANNE'S LACE, WE CALL IT.
- QUEEN...?
- QUEEN ANNE'S LACE.
Together: QUEEN ANNE'S LACE.
ALL RIGHT.
EVERYTHING IN THIS
LESSON IS PERFECT.
"THE LITTLE GIRL
HAS PINK CHEEKS."
- PINK CHEEKS.
- SO THE DOUBLE VOWEL MAKES IT LONG.
WHAT IS CHEEKS? ( laughs )
- AH, HERE.
- MM-HMM.
- PINK CHEEKS, OKAY.
- ALL RIGHT, GOT IT.
Dr. Benne IN THE EVENT THAT
SOME CATASTROPHE COMES...
NOT AN ACCIDENT, BUT
ALZHEIMER'S CHANGES,
IF YOU TAKE YOUR BRAIN WITH YOU
INTO YOUR 10TH DECADE, AS
YOU ENTER THAT 10TH DECADE,
YOU WANT THE MOST
ROBUST, EFFICIENT,
RAPID-DECISION-MAKING,
MULTITASKING BRAIN THAT
YOU POSSIBLY CAN HAVE.
BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT'S
GONNA ALLOW YOU
TO MAINTAIN YOUR COGNITION,
DESPITE ALL THE OTHER THINGS
THAT'S GONNA HAPPEN TO IT.
( birds chirping )
Mrs. Galvani: I KNOW
FROM LIVING WITH HIM
HOW HE JUST LOVED BEING
OUT AND DOING ALL THE WORK
HE WAS DOING ON
COMMITTEES AND LOCAL CLUBS,
AND PLAYING CARDS...
A LITTLE DIVERSION...
BUT ALSO BEING TOASTMASTER
AT MANY MANY FUNCTIONS.
HE HAD A LOT OF ENERGY TO
KEEP DOING ALL THESE THINGS.
AND I HAD B.C. FOOTBALL TICKETS
UNTIL THREE YEARS AGO
WHEN I COULDN'T SEE OR
CLIMB THE STAIRS ANYMORE.
SO I GAVE UP MY SEASON TICKETS
THREE YEARS AGO. I WAS 91.
( both laugh )
WITH THE INCREASE IN LONGEVITY
THAT WE ARE OBSERVING
IN THE PAST DECADES
COMES A GREAT DEAL OF CONCERN
WHETHER INCREASED LIFESPAN
IS GOING TO BE ACCOMPANIED
BY A GREATER PERIOD
OF TIME WITH DISABILITY,
WITH LOSS OF DEPENDENCE,
WITH POOR QUALITY OF LIFE,
OR WHETHER INCREASED
LIFE EXPECTANCY
CAN BE ACCOMPANIED BY A
LONGER PERIOD IN GOOD HEALTH.
IN THAT REGARD, THERE'VE
BEEN SOME VERY GRATIFYING
RESULTS OF STUDIES
OVER THE PAST YEARS,
WHICH HAVE INDICATED
THAT IN THE YEARS
FROM 1982 THROUGH PRESENT...
THE LAST COUPLE OF DECADES...
THERE IN FACT HAVE BEEN
SUBSTANTIAL DECREASES
IN THE RATES OF DISABILITY
IN OLDER MEN AND WOMEN.
THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT
BECAUSE IT
INDICATES THAT IN FACT
DISABILITY WITH OLD AGE
IS BY NO MEANS INEVITABLE.
AND THERE IS REAL PROMISE
FOR BEING ABLE TO INCREASE
THE QUALITY OF INDEPENDENCE
AND DISABILITY-FREE
LIFE WITH AGE.
( people chattering )
MARY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
HI, VIC. HOW ARE YOU
DOING? WHAT'S GOING ON?
- GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- VIC LOOKS FANTASTIC.
- OF COURSE HE DOES.
ONE OF THE STUDIES WHICH
HAS BEEN PARTICULARLY VALUABLE
HAS BEEN THE
FRAMINGHAM HEART STUDY...
A STUDY WHICH WAS INITIATED TO
FOCUS ON CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES...
DISEASES OF THE HEART... BUT
HAS PROVEN TO BE AN ASSET
TO THE GATHERING OF INFORMATION
IN THE FUNCTION OF THE BRAIN
AND BRING IT TO BEAR IN
A BETTER UNDERSTANDING
OF DEMENTIA AND
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
USING THE FRAMINGHAM
DATA, WE'RE ABLE TO ESTIMATE
WHAT IS THE PROBABILITY
THAT A MAN OR WOMAN AT AGE 65
WILL DEVELOP A
STROKE OR DEMENTIA
DURING THE REMAINDER
OF THEIR LIFE.
AND THE PROBABILITY
COMES OUT TO BE
ONE CHANCE IN THREE
THAT A MAN WILL DEVELOP
STROKE OR DEMENTIA
AND ONE CHANCE IN TWO
THAT A WOMAN WILL
DEVELOP STROKE OR DEMENTIA
DURING THE REMAINDER
OF THEIR LIFE,
WHICH IS A REALLY
TERRIFYING STATISTIC.
OKAY, THIS FIRST ONE GOES
FOR A MINUTE AND A HALF.
JUST HOLD VERY STILL, OKAY?
Man: IT'S REALLY WONDERFUL TO
SEE WHAT OUR BRAIN LOOKS LIKE,
AND WHAT HAPPENS
TO IT OVER THE YEARS.
- HAVE YOU EVER SEEN AN M.R.I. LIKE THIS BEFORE?
- NO, NEVER.
WE OFTEN EXPECT...
WHEN YOU HAVE PEOPLE
WHO ARE ABOUT 70 YEARS OLD,
YOU FIND THAT OVER HALF OF THEM
WOULD HAVE A LOT OF CHANGES,
MORE CHANGES IN
THEIR WHITE MATTER
- THAN WHAT YOU DO.
- I SEE.
SO THAT'S GOOD.
THAT EXPLAINS TO SOME EXTENT
WHY YOU'RE DOING SO WELL
IN TERMS OF BEING
QUICK IN YOUR THINKING,
BEING ABLE TO
REMEMBER THINGS WELL.
THIS IS A PART OF THE BRAIN
CALLED THE HIPPOCAMPUS,
- WHERE WE FORM MEMORIES.
- RIGHT.
AND THIS IS SOMETHING
THAT SHRINKS
- WHEN YOU HAVE ALZHEIMER'S.
- I SEE.
NOW THIS IS FROM A
MORE RECENT SCAN.
IF IT HAD SHRUNK, YOU WOULD SEE
- MORE OF THIS WHITE FLUID
AROUND IT... - OF THE WHITE, YES.
AND MUCH LESS
OF THE GREY MATTER.
WE LIKE THE FACT THAT
WE ARE ABLE TO SEE
HOW BIG YOUR HIPPOCAMPI ARE,
HOW THEY CHANGED OVER
TIME, AND THAT HASN'T CHANGED.
Dr. Hodes: THERE'S GREAT HOPE
THAT THESE EXAMPLES
OF SUCCESSFUL AGING,
EVEN IF IT'S IN THE
EXCEPTIONAL FEW,
ARE REASON TO HOPE
THAT MANY MORE OF US,
IF NOT ALL OF US, CAN
ACHIEVE THAT SAME OUTCOME
ONCE WE ARE CAPABLE
OF BETTER UNDERSTANDING
WHAT DISTINGUISHES THIS
SUCCESSFUL BRAIN AGING
FROM LESS SUCCESSFUL
BRAIN AGING,
AND DETERMINE WHAT MANIPULATIONS
ARE CAPABLE OF TRANSFORMING
THE UNSUCCESSFUL
INTO THE SUCCESSFUL.
THERE'S ENORMOUS INTEREST NOW
IN WHAT THE EFFECTS OF
LIFESTYLE INTERVENTIONS
SUCH AS EXERCISE AND DIET
MAY HAVE ON THE RISK
FOR ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
OR ON BRAIN HEALTH
AND FUNCTION IN GENERAL.
IN ANIMAL MODELS...
MOUSE MODELS OF ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE, FOR EXAMPLE...
THERE IS RECENT
EVIDENCE SUGGESTING
THAT EXERCISE AND DIET
CAN MODIFY THE
PROGRESSION OF THE LESIONS
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
IN THESE ANIMAL MODELS.
ONE OF THE BREAKTHROUGHS
IN THE FIELD IS TO BE ABLE
TO HAVE A MOUSE MODEL
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
CALLED A TRANSGENIC MOUSE.
AND IT SIMULATES A
LOT OF THE PATHOLOGY
THAT DEVELOPS IN THE HUMAN
BRAIN WITH ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
I HAD THIS IDEA THAT
MAYBE A GROWTH FACTOR,
OR NEUROTROPHIC FACTOR,
WHICH IS KIND OF A NUTRIENT
OR A FERTILIZER TO NEURONS,
WHICH ALSO MAKES THEM SMARTER,
MIGHT BE NATURALLY
INCREASED WITH EXERCISE.
WE TAKE TWO GROUPS...
ONE IS JUST SORT
OF IN THEIR CAGE
AND DON'T HAVE ACCESS
TO A SORT OF A RUNNING GYM;
AND THE OTHERS GET IN THEIR
RUNNING WHEELS AT NIGHT
AND THEY EXERCISE.
IN ORDER TO TEST THEIR LEARNING,
WE BASICALLY TAKE THE TWO GROUPS
AND PUT THEM IN THIS
MORRIS WATER MAZE.
THEY ARE PUT IN THE TANK.
AND THEY DON'T LIKE THE WATER.
AND WHAT THEY HAVE TO DO IS
THEY HAVE TO FIND
A LITTLE PLATFORM
THAT'S SORT OF
BELOW THE SURFACE.
IT'S REALLY KIND OF
EQUIVALENT TO FINDING YOUR CAR
IN A PARKING LOT AT AN AIRPORT
WHEN YOU CAN'T REALLY SEE IT,
BUT YOU SORT OF HAVE TO LEARN
FROM THE CUES AROUND THE AIRPORT
OF WHERE YOU PARKED.
Man: THE SEDENTARY ANIMAL
STILL HAS NOT LOCATED
THE PLATFORM AT THIS POINT.
ALL RIGHT.
WE FIND CONSISTENTLY
THAT THE ANIMALS
THAT HAVE EXERCISED
ARE ABLE TO LEARN
FASTER AND BETTER
THAN THE ANIMALS
THAT HAVEN'T EXERCISED.
- Woman: ALL RIGHT!
- Dr. Cotman: YAY!
Man: HE DID IT.
WE LOOKED AT THEIR
BRAIN, AND LO AND BEHOLD,
BDNF WAS INCREASED
IN THE PART OF THE BRAIN
THAT IS CONTROLLING
THINKING AND LEARNING
AND IS VULNERABLE TO
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND ALL I CAN SAY TO MYSELF,
AND MY STUDENTS WOULD SAY,
"HOLY KAMOLEY, THAT IS SO SMART.
THE BRAIN KNEW SOMETHING
IN HOW TO LOOK OUT FOR ITSELF
THAT WE HAD NO IDEA ABOUT."
SO IT KINDA HAS A
SELF-PRESERVATION MECHANISM
THAT ALSO MAKES IT
SMARTER AND TO LEARN BETTER.
CERTAINLY IN ANIMAL MODELS
THERE'S NO QUESTION ABOUT IT...
EXERCISE CAN INDUCE
GROWTH FACTORS IN THE BRAIN.
IT CAN HELP BUILD
NEW NEURONS INTO THE CIRCUITS.
IT CAN BUILD SYNAPSES,
IMPROVE LEARNING.
AND IT CAN BASICALLY
IMPROVE VASCULAR FUNCTION.
OH MY GOSH, YOU KNOW,
WHAT DRUG WILL DO THAT?
NOTHING.
AND, YOU KNOW,
IT'S SIMPLE EXERCISE.
YOU CAN IDENTIFY NEW NEURONS
BY STAINS, YOU
KNOW, THAT HIGHLIGHT
THE NEW CELLS
THAT ARE JUST BORN.
AND WHEN YOU LOOK,
THERE'S FEWER OF THEM
IN THE ANIMALS THAT
ARE JUST SEDENTARY
THAN IN THE EXERCISED ANIMALS.
AND IT'S REALLY QUITE DRAMATIC.
SO EXERCISE ACTUALLY INCREASES
THE NUMBER OF NEW NEURONS
THAT COULD BE ADDED
TO THE HIPPOCAMPUS.
THE EXCITING CONCLUSION IS
THAT WHEN WE TESTED THE ANIMALS
THAT DEVELOP ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE IN THE BRAIN,
THEY BENEFIT AS
WELL FROM EXERCISE,
JUST LIKE THE WILD TYPE.
SO THEY LEARN FASTER AND BETTER,
WHICH IS VERY ENCOURAGING
BECAUSE IT MEANS
THAT MAY HELP DELAY THE
ONSET OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
FROM THE EXPERIENCE OF EXERCISE.
IF YOU ASKED
SOMEBODY 10 YEARS AGO,
"HOW ARE YOU GOING
TO FIX BRAIN AGING?"
OR "WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DO?"
THEY WOULD HAVE TOLD
YOU IT'S A MEDICATION.
NOW WE KNOW
THERE'S GREAT PROMISE
IN TERMS OF BEHAVIORAL
INTERVENTIONS
THAT CAN BE ADJUNCTS
TO MEDICATIONS
AND GOOD HEALTH POLICY.
NICE YOU SEE YOU.
HOW ARE YOU DOING?
OH, IT'S SO GOOD TO SEE YOU.
I'M GONNA CHECK A FEW THINGS,
LISTEN TO YOUR HEART AND LUNGS.
NO SPINNING
SENSATION, NO NAUSEA,
- VOMITING, NOTHING LIKE THAT?
- NO NO.
IF THINGS GO WELL, YOU'LL BE
ABLE TO STAY ON THE MEDICINE,
AND THEN HOPEFULLY
THIS WILL BE APPROVED
FOR THE GENERAL
PUBLIC DOWN THE ROAD
FOR TREATING THIS DISEASE, OKAY?
WELL, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE
HOPING AND PRAYING FOR.
ONE OF THE BEST
PIECES OF NEWS IS
THAT THERE ARE MANY
CLINICAL TRIALS NOW
WITH VERY PROMISING AGENTS
FOR ALZHEIMER'S
DISEASE... DOZENS.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED BY
THE ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
COOPERATIVE STUDY... THE ADCS.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED BY
THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY.
THEY'RE BEING CONDUCTED IN THIS
COUNTRY AND IN OTHER COUNTRIES.
YOU'LL START WITH
THE EVENING DOSE.
THE EVENING. OKAY.
- THANKS FOR COMING. SEE YOU IN THREE MONTHS.
- SEE YOU IN THREE MONTHS.
- HOW'RE YOU FEELING TODAY?
- GOOD.
BEEN AN OKAY EXPERIENCE FOR YOU?
VERY VERY MUCH SO.
TWO IN THE MORNING,
TWO AT NIGHT.
THE PIVOTAL TRIALS
OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
THAT ARE OCCURRING NOW... TRIALS
OF DISEASE-MODIFYING TREATMENTS,
OF ANTI-AMYLOID TREATMENTS,
BECAUSE THEY ARE TRYING
TO SLOW THE PROGRESSION
OF THIS DISEASE
OVER THE LONG TERM,
AND BECAUSE THE PROGRESSION
VARIES FROM ONE
PERSON TO ANOTHER,
IN FACT THEY REQUIRE
MANY MANY PARTICIPANTS
IN THESE TRIALS.
YOU CAN DIRECTLY PLUG
THIS MACHINE INTO THE WALL.
OKAY, PUT IT UP TO YOUR NOSE.
Man: NO MATTER WHERE I HAVE
TO TAKE THIS WOMAN IN THE WORLD
TO FIND SOMETHING
THAT CAN HELP HER
MAINTAIN A LIFESTYLE,
AND A GOOD
LIFESTYLE, I WILL DO IT.
WITHOUT THE COOPERATION
OF INDIVIDUALS
AND THEIR FAMILIES
WE HAVE A ROADBLOCK,
WE WILL NOT PROGRESS
TO TREATMENTS.
- CAN YOU PICK UP YOUR FOOT?
- UH-HUH.
AND BRING IT OVER. THERE YOU GO.
OKAY.
WE GOT INVOLVED
IN THE ELAN TRIALS,
THE 2001 ELAN TRIALS,
BECAUSE OUR SON-IN-LAW
SAW IT ADVERTISED IN THE PAPER
AND HE CALLED US AND SAID,
"I THINK THIS MAY BE SOMETHING
YOU'D BE INTERESTED IN."
- YEAH.
- AND WE WERE INTERESTED IN IT.
SO EARL AND I RAN OUT THERE
TO GET INVOLVED IN IT,
AND EXCITED ABOUT IT.
I WAS JUST HOPING
THAT SOMETHING
WOULD SURFACE
THAT WOULD HELP ME.
THERE'S A VARIETY OF APPROACHES
TO TRY AND BLOCK
THE PROGRESSION OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
ONCE YOU HAVE IT, HOW CAN YOU...
HOW CAN YOU GO AFTER
THE PLAQUES OR THE TANGLES,
TRY AND REDUCE
THEM, REMOVE THEM,
SO THAT YOU CAN CHANGE
THE COURSE OF THE DISEASE?
ONE OF THE LOGICAL WAYS TO DO IT
IS TO REDUCE THE PRODUCTION
OF BETA-AMYLOID FROM THE GET-GO.
THE MORE SURPRISING WAY TO DO IT
THAT WE DISCOVERED
IN THE LATE '90s
IS THAT, IF YOU ACTUALLY
IMMUNIZE OR VACCINATE
WITH THE BETA-AMYLOID
PEPTIDE ITSELF,
AND STIMULATE THE IMMUNE SYSTEM,
THAT THE IMMUNE SYSTEM
CAN THEN ACTUALLY EITHER
PREVENT... TOTALLY PREVENT...
OR REVERSE THE PLAQUES
IN THE BRAIN TISSUE.
THE IDEA WAS TO VACCINATE
JUST LIKE YOU GET
VACCINATED FOR POLIO...
VACCINATE WITH
A SYNTHETIC PIECE,
A LITTLE PEPTIDE
PROTEIN FRAGMENT
OF THE BETA-AMYLOID
INTO THE MICE.
AND WHEN YOU GET
VACCINATED, WHAT DO YOU DO?
YOU RAISE ANTIBODIES
IN YOUR BLOOD.
AND THAT'S WHAT PROTECTS YOU
IF YOU'RE BEING VACCINATED
AGAINST SOME INFECTION.
HERE IT'S A LITTLE
DIFFERENT. WHAT WE HOPED IS
THAT THOSE ANTIBODIES WOULD
CIRCULATE THROUGH THE BODY.
AND WHAT ANTIBODIES DO IS THEY BIND
TO WHATEVER THEY'VE BEEN MADE TO.
AND WE HOPED THESE ANTIBODIES
WOULD BIND TO THE BETA-AMYLOID
AND HELP CLEAR IT,
HELP GET RID OF IT...
A VERY SIMPLE IDEA, AN
EXTREMELY SIMPLE IDEA.
AND THIS IS WHAT YOU SEE
IN UNTREATED
MICE. THIS IS A BRAIN.
THE BROWN MATERIAL
IS THE PLAQUES.
THEN AFTER THEY'VE
BEEN VACCINATED,
THIS IS WHAT YOU
SEE INSTEAD OF THAT
IN THE TREATED ANIMALS.
AND IT WAS SO
BLACK-AND-WHITE AND SO OBVIOUS
THAT I REMEMBER...
DORA SAW THIS FIRST.
YOU COULD WITH
100% ACCURACY SAY,
"THIS ANIMAL WAS TREATED
AND THIS ONE WASN'T."
ONCE WE REALIZED THAT
WE COULD ACTUALLY TREAT
OUR MOUSE MODEL OF
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE
WITH THE BETA-AMYLOID PEPTIDE...
IN OTHER WORDS BY
VACCINATING THEM,
OR IMMUNIZING THEM WITH
THE BETA-AMYLOID PEPTIDE...
WE IMMEDIATELY REALIZED
THAT THAT HAD POTENTIAL
FOR TREATMENT OF
ALZHEIMER'S PATIENTS.
WE BEGAN WHAT WE
CALL CLINICAL TRIALS.
AND THAT'S A VERY
LONG PROCESS, ACTUALLY.
AND THE WAY IT'S DONE IS,
MOST OF WHAT YOU DO IS MAKE SURE
THAT WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS SAFE.
SO YOU DO A FEW
NUMBER OF PATIENTS,
A VERY CONTROLLED ENVIRONMENT,
VERY CAREFUL AMOUNTS, ET CETERA,
AND SHOW THAT IT'S SAFE.
AND WE CALL THAT PHASE
I TRIALS. SO WE DID THAT
AND EVERYTHING LOOKED FINE.
AND THEN WE WENT
ONTO LARGE STUDIES.
AND NOW WE'RE TALKING
SEVERAL HUNDRED PATIENTS,
370 PATIENTS,
WHERE WE DID WHAT'S
CALLED A PHASE II STUDY
WHERE AGAIN A LOT
OF IT IS ABOUT SAFETY.
MOST OF IT'S ABOUT SAFETY.
BUT YOU'RE STARTING TO LOOK
AT THINGS LIKE, "GEE,
IS THIS WORKING?
ARE THE PATIENTS PERFORMING
FUNCTIONS BETTER? HOW ARE THEY DOING?"
HE HAD THREE INJECTIONS
PROBABLY OVER A
PERIOD OF THREE MONTHS
OR SOMETHING LIKE
THAT, MAYBE EVEN LONGER.
WHEN HE WAS GIVEN
THE FIRST INJECTION,
HE HAD A BIT OF A
REACTION TO A PROTEIN,
AN ALLERGEN TYPE REACTION.
AND I SAID, "I THINK
YOU GOT THE VACCINE."
AND SURE ENOUGH, HE DID.
AND SO IT WAS EXCITING
BECAUSE WE WERE ACTUALLY FEELING
LIKE IT WAS DOING SOME GOOD...
- YEAH YEAH.
- EVEN INITIALLY.
IT GAVE ME A LOT OF HOPE.
WE WERE JUST WELL UNDERWAY.
EVERYTHING WAS GOING FINE.
AND AFTER THE SECOND DOSE
WE RAN INTO A PROBLEM
WITH ENCEPHALITIS
IN A VERY SMALL
SUBSET OF PATIENTS...
ABOUT 5% OR 6% OF THEM.
AND ALTHOUGH IT WAS
TRANSIENT, IT WAS SEVERE ENOUGH
THAT WE FELT IT WAS
PRUDENT TO STOP DOSING.
- WHEN THEY ENDED THE TRIALS...
- UH-HUH.
WELL, WE WERE CUSSING.
WE ACTUALLY WERE ANGRY.
I KEPT SAYING, "OH, THAT
WAS A MOSQUITO IN FRANCE.
IT DOESN'T HAVE ANYTHING
TO DO WITH THIS VACCINE."
BUT I THINK BACK,
AND I KEPT SAYING
TO EVERYONE WHO ASKED,
"SO HOW'S EARL DOING?"
I WOULD SAY, "HE'S
MAINTAINING. HE'S MAINTAINING."
- AND THAT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT.
- YEAH.
BECAUSE YOU WERE
FUNCTIONING WELL AT THAT TIME.
- OH, YEAH.
- AND JUST TO STAY THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN A BLESSING.
BECAUSE IT WAS WORKING.
AND WE SAID THAT
FOR MANY MANY YEARS.
- YEAH.
- I'M THINKING BACK NOW...
WE PROBABLY FOR THREE
OR FOUR OR FIVE YEARS SAID,
"HE'S MAINTAINING.
EVERYTHING IS GOOD."
TO OUR AMAZEMENT,
IF YOU LOOK AT THE BOTTOM ROW
HERE AND COMPARE IT WITH THE TOP,
AT THE TOP IS THE TYPICAL
SORT OF PATHOLOGY
THAT ONE SEES IN PATIENTS
WHO HAVE ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
THE TOP THREE ARE BRAIN SECTIONS
WHERE THE BROWN
IS THE BETA-AMYLOID...
THE TYPICAL
PLAQUELIKE APPEARANCE.
ON THE BOTTOM IS THE
COMPARISON OF WHAT YOU SEE
AFTER THE PATIENT
HAS BEEN VACCINATED,
WHERE THERE'S BRAIN REGIONS
THAT ARE NEARLY COMPLETELY
VOID. THE PLAQUES ARE GONE.
WE ARE REALLY VERY
EXCITED THAT WE CAN REMOVE...
LITERALLY REMOVE AMYLOID
PLAQUES FROM PATIENTS
SUFFERING FROM
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
AND AS WE MOVE FORWARD
NOW, WHAT THIS MEANS IS,
SINCE WE CAN DO IT, WE'RE
DELIVERING NEW TREATMENTS,
THINGS LIKE BAPINEUZUMAB,
WHICH IS A VERY LONG
WORD, A FANCY WORD
FOR A HUMAN ANTIBODY
THAT IS MOVING
THROUGH THE PROCESS
OF CLINICAL TRIAL.
INSTEAD OF THE PATIENT
HAVING TO MAKE THE
ANTIBODIES AND DO THE WORK,
WE'RE PROVIDING THE PATIENT
DIRECTLY WITH THE ANTIBODIES.
NOW THE GOOD PART ABOUT
DOING THIS IS THAT YOU CAN GIVE
EXACTLY THE AMOUNT AND THE
DOSE THAT YOU WANT TO GIVE.
IN OTHER WORDS, IT'S MUCH MORE
CONTROLLED WHEN YOU GIVE THE ANTIBODIES.
AND SO THAT'S WHAT
BAPINEUZUMAB IS.
ONCE IT'S IN THE BLOODSTREAM,
THE ANTIBODY WILL LAST
AS LONG AS THREE WEEKS.
Dr. Marwan Sabbagh: THIS IS
ONE OF THE LEADING DRUGS
THAT'S IN THE HORSE
RACE TO GET AN APPROVAL.
THIS IS THE END OF
THE PHASE II STUDY.
AND THE SPONSORS
ACTUALLY HAVE MOVED
THIS DRUG BAPINEUZUMAB
INTO PHASE III,
BECAUSE THEY ARE VERY
EXCITED ABOUT ITS PROGRESS.
Dr. Schenk: AND SO THAT
ANTIBODY CIRCULATES AROUND,
AND A LITTLE BIT OF
IT, THIS BAPINEUZUMAB,
GETS THROUGH INTO THE BRAIN.
AND IF THERE'S PLAQUES THERE,
IT WILL BIND TO THOSE PLAQUES
AND NEUTRALIZE THEM
OR STIMULATE THE
CLEARANCE OF THEM.
DR. GARGAS WAS A SURGEON IN
WISCONSIN FOR MANY MANY YEARS.
WELL, YEAH.
I THINK I'M VERY...
I WALKED INTO
SOMETHING THAT WAS VERY GOOD.
OUR DECISION TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE TRIAL
SEEMED LIKE A NO-BRAINER.
IF WE COULD DO ANYTHING
TO HELP OUR FAMILIES,
AND ALL THE OTHER
FIVE MILLION FAMILIES
OF THE PEOPLE
AFFECTED BY ALZHEIMER'S,
IT'S THE LEAST WE CAN DO.
AND WE HOPE FOR GOOD RESULTS.
I THINK ONE OF THE FEW THINGS
THAT EXPERIENCE CAN TEACH YOU
IS YOU ACTUALLY GET A SENSE
FOR WHEN THE
SCIENCE IS VERY RICH.
AND IT'S A MAGICAL TIME.
AND IT DOESN'T
HAPPEN VERY OFTEN.
AND I THINK THE FIELD
IS AT THAT POINT...
THE DIAGNOSTIC TOOLS,
THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE
DISEASE AT SO MANY LEVELS.
ACTUALLY, PERHAPS THE
MOST IMPORTANT THING IS
THAT THE BIOLOGY AND THE
CLINICAL UNDERSTANDING
ARE, AS WE SPEAK, GETTING
PUT TOGETHER AT LAST.
IT'S FINALLY GETTING
PUT TOGETHER.
AND WE'RE GONNA SEE REAL
TREATMENTS HAPPEN AS A RESULT OF THAT.
IT'S A MAGIC TIME. IT'S
A MAGICAL TIME FOR US.
AND WE REALLY HOPE
THE PATIENTS ARE
GONNA BENEFIT FROM THIS.
Dr. Bateman: WE THINK
THAT THESE DRUGS
THAT ARE COMING
THROUGH THE CLINICAL TRIALS
HAVE A VERY GOOD CHANCE
OF REALLY CHANGING THE
COURSE OF ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Morris: THERE IS HOPE.
AND WE WANT TO MAKE A COMMITMENT
TO SEEING IF WE CAN'T
PREVENT THE ILLNESS.
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
ON ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. DeKosky: IF WE COULD
ACTUALLY DELAY IT 10 YEARS,
WE COULD WIPE OUT
MOST OF THE DISEASE
IN THE COUNTRY, IN THE WORLD.
BUT I THINK FOR ALL OF THIS,
WE WILL NEED MORE ENERGY,
MORE PEOPLE, MORE PROGRAMS,
MORE FUNDING TO
SUPPORT THESE EFFORTS.
IT REALLY MATTERS
TO ME THAT SOMEDAY
I'M GONNA TAKE A PRESCRIPTION
PAD OUT OF MY DRAWER
AND WRITE A PRESCRIPTION
THAT'S GONNA PREVENT YOU
FROM GETTING ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE.
Dr. Hodes: OUR COMMITMENT
IS TO PURSUE AND ANSWER
AS RAPIDLY, AS
EXPEDITIOUSLY AS WE CAN,
SO THAT WE MINIMIZE
THE PROBABILITY
THAT A FEW YEARS FROM NOW
SOMEONE ELSE IS GONNA TURN
AND ASK US THE
VERY SAME QUESTION,
"WHY IS IT WE STILL
DON'T HAVE THE ANSWER?"
( instrumental music playing )