Pretty Little Liars (2010–2017): Season 2, Episode 16 - Let the Water Hold Me Down - full transcript

With Lucas missing and questions surrounding what happened out on the lake, Hanna can barely catch her breath; Spencer follows a lead about "A" which guides her to an unexpected place and ...

Previously on
Pretty Little Liars...

Is there any way I could
take this on Monday?

What about
after school tomorrow?

I can't. I have
community service.

It's a community
crisis hotline.

This is a transcript of a call
that came in last night.

"I almost
got caught tonight.

"It's gone
and I can't get it back.

I might as well be dead"?

I never wanted to hurt anybody,
but now I have to.

Hello.
Ezra.



I really needed to hear your...
I know.

But you can't call
here anymore.

Oh, my God,
that's awesome!

Surprise party at the lake house.
I just need your help.

Caleb's probably never even
had a birthday party before.

I don't know
this Emily.

I think you'll
like her.

I want to make sure
she still likes me.

Hey. We thought you guys
were still overseas.

Oh, yeah, we just
got back last week.

Holden!
Look who's here?

Hey, how's it going?
Good.

Please don't do something
you're gonna regret, Lucas.

Hanna!
Do not answer that.



Forget the fireworks.
Forget everything!

This is not about
the stupid fireworks, Hanna!

Aah!

( Struggling )

Aah!

Where's Lucas?
Is he still out there?

♪ How'd it feel to get
it off of your chest ♪

♪ was it burning deep
within you... ♪

Here's some aspirin.

You want me to make
you some soup?

Thanks, but I'm
not hungry.

You want a blanket?

Sure.

Here's your bag.

I think Caleb called.
Your phone was making noise.

Han? Now, I know that you might
not be ready to talk about this,

but the sheriff said
that they're gonna drag

the lake first thing
in the morning.

Lucas isn't
in the lake.

He didn't come
up to shore.

We waited.

He knows how to swim,
all right?

He's out there somewhere.

I can feel it.

I-I still can't believe
that Lucas would help "a."

Why not? Jenna did
the same thing with Caleb.

"A" knows Lucas
is close to Hanna.

No, I-I get it,
I just... don't

really see Lucas as
being that violent.

He can be.

Lucas was the one who destroyed
Alison's memorial.

I found out the night
I got out of the hospital.

Why didn't you tell us?

Told me to keep a secret.

Why?

To protect him.

He's been through
a lot.

Alison really
tortured him.

Maybe it's time
to start protecting you.

I have a headache.

Hanna, don't drink that!

Aria: That's
lake water.

Too late.

How did that
get in there?

The bag was outside
in the car.

But all of us
were in here.

Yeah, Lucas wasn't.

Maybe he just wants
to finish what he started.

( Cell phone dings )

No fun chugging lake water,
is it?

Choke on this, bitch.
"A."

( Thunder rumbling )

♪ Got a secret,
can you keep it ♪

♪ swear this one
you'll save ♪

♪ better lock it
in your pocket ♪

♪ takin' this one
to the grave ♪

♪ if I show you
then I know you ♪

♪ won't tell what I said ♪

♪ 'cause two can keep a secret
if one of them is dead ♪

Okay, thanks.

Lucas called
his parents today.

And he's still not home?

( Sighs ) They must be
going out of their minds.

Did he say where he is,
where he's been?

Was there drinking
at this party?

No.

Did he argue
with someone? Hanna!

I don't know.

I should call them.

Can you give me
their home number?

No, why do you
have to call them?

Because my daughter
hosted a party

that their son has yet
to return from.

I should at least take
some responsibility for that.

Look, I know you're upset
and frustrated

that your friend
is going through something

and he ran off instead
of turning to you for help.

I'm sure when he's ready
what's going on with him.

Uh, we should go
to Spencer's.

Aren't you gonna
see her at school?

We have a group presentation,

and we need to run it
one more time.

"A" was definitely
in my lake house.

You found these
in the attic?

The picture Caleb decrypted
off "a" cell phone of the dolls,

that was taken
at the lake house.

Looks like "a"
got pretty cozy.

Well, my family never uses
that house after labor day.

It's the perfect place
to set up an evil lair.

And look. Just look
at the date on this.

Wait, that's around the time
Caleb and I went up there.

"A" was in the lake house
when Caleb and I were...

"Fraternizing"
on my Nana's sofa.

Okay, who told?
It doesn't even matter.

There are, like,
four bedrooms up there

with actual beds
in them.

Did you guys see anybody,
hear anything?

Em, we were
kind of busy.

Yeah, you were
gettin' busy.

Okay, so, wait.
You said that Lucas went

up in the attic like
he knew his way around?

He was probably trying
to clean up

after Garrett and Jenna.

And look.

There's an address.

Smitty's.
801 Hyperion street.

Wait, Smitty's what?
Restaurant? Bar?

Hyperion street.
Isn't that in Philly?

Do you guys want to go
after school to check it out?

Okay. Yeah. If it means
you're not going alone,

then count me in.

Is it okay if I pass?

I still have the taste
of lake water in my mouth.

I could've sworn
that my mom caught me.

Told her I was making
a date with Holden.

Holden Strauss?
I thought he was in Portugal.

Wh... and why were you calling
Ezra from your own phone?

Because I couldn't think
of a good excuse

to get out of the house
and use yours.

Not that it really matters.
Ezra's stopped answering.

Dad threatened to turn
him into the police.

What? Aria,
I'm so sorry.

I thought
that my parents

would understand,
or at least try.

They both know how great
of a guy... hey, Holden.

Hey, Aria. Spencer,
hey, good to see you.

Yeah, how was
your year abroad?

Uh, my dad was studying algae
in a river delta.

I spent a lot of time
in hip waders,

which was... really lame.

Anyway, so, uh,
I was wondering

if you wanted
to go out tonight.

Oh. ( Chuckles )

I-I can't.
But thanks.

It's just that
I'm grounded.

Really? Your dad said
it wouldn't be a problem.

Oh, our parents
talked?

Did my mom call
to set us up?

No, I-I called
to ask permission.

What? Who even does
that anymore?

My parents have been
pushing this whole

"return to kinder,
gentler traditions" agenda.

No, I'm not saying
that it's...

laugh now, but I'll
be sending you

a handwritten thank-you note for letting
me interrupt your conversation.

I'm just kind
of confused.

Is this a date?

Is that weird?

No, uh...

It's just we've known each
other since preschool.

Is it the whole
glue thing?

'Cause if I remember
correctly, you dared me.

Okay, no, that was not a dare.
I was just misinformed.

I thought that if it looked
like ranch dressing...

Well, now we're both old enough
to know the difference, so...

Dinner, a movie?

Paste-free, I promise.

Okay. Yeah. It'd be
great to hang out.

I'll think of
something fun to do.

Great. Whatever you want.
Just text me the details.

Yeah, will do.

Um, how weird
is that?

I use him as my alibi and now
he actually wants to go out?

It's not that weird.
He likes you.

No, we've known
each other forever.

You're cute,
and he likes you.

He says it was
for chem lab,

but Noel was on
the phone with someone

all night at
Caleb's birthday party.

Did you notice him
acting sketchy at all?

I don't know.
I was kind of busy with other things.

What, Lucas?

Who care?

First Lucas ruins
Caleb's birthday party.

Then he gets everyone in a tizzy
because he's pretend-missing.

Need attention much?
He is so lame.

Mona...

Can we veer
back on topic?

I think I'm
losing Noel.

I had to take him
skinny-dipping that night

just to get
his full attention.

Then we got into this huge
fight on the way home.

Hanna!

Where are you
taking that?

Storage.

No, that's supposed to be
hanging in the South lobby.

The principal said
to take it down.

You didn't hear this
from me,

but the administration
doesn't think tiaras

and orange jumpsuits
are a good fit.

She's not giving up
the crown!

So, what
do you think?

Am I just
being paranoid?

Hanna, are you even
listening to me?

Yeah. Yeah, sure.
What did I just say?

You can't even
tell me, can you?

I listen to every
drawn-out whiny detail

when you have
a problem with Caleb,

and you can't even
bother to nod your head

and pretend
like you care!

I'm sorry! Okay, I have
a lot going on right now.

So do I.

I just poured
my heart out to someone

who cares more about her
homecoming photo than her friend.

Could you be
any more selfish?

( Thud )

( Footsteps )

( Phone ringing )

Hello?

I have a problem.

Who's calling.

You work
for the crisis line.

Don't I get
to stay anonymous?

Uh, this is
a private number.

Private? So, I can say
anything I want,

even something...
Dirty?

Maya?

Inappropriate, I know.

( Laughs )
Oh.

Well?

Aren't you gonna say it?

Say what?
Something dirty.

I'd rather whisper it
in your ear tonight.

We're still on to see
that band you like, right?

Sure thing. We just...
( Beep)

Oh, hold on a second.
Someone's on the other line.

Do you have
to take it?

It can go to voicemail.

Listen, you don't have
a fake I.D., do you?

I never use it, but yeah.

Do you have two?

My parents ransacked my room

after I got shipped off
to sober camp.

Guess what they found.

I think I can
get you one.

That was...
Easier than I thought.

Anything else I can
help you with?

Nope. I get to see
my girl tonight.

Problem solved.

( Deeper voice )
See you later.

Hello?

( Thud )

( Cell phone dings )

***

this train schedule,
we'll be good to go.

Ugh. Worst reception
out here.

What are you doing?

Oh, buying tickets
to the rangely playhouse.

Weren't you supposed
to go there with Ezra?

Wait, how are you getting
better service than I am?

Wait, switch places.
Come on.

Yeah, well, now I'm
going with Holden.

What happens
if Ezra's there.

That's the point.

Ezra bought his tickets,
like, two months ago,

and he loves
Arthur Miller,

so I'm pretty sure he's
looking forward to it...

Holden said that we could
do whatever I wanted.

Right. So, if Ezra
just happens to be there

and you happen
to see him...

And maybe we have
fate on our side.

I just wish I didn't have to
use Holden to figure that out.

Ugh!

Oh, come...

you're not...

next train is
in 20 minutes.

We should
probably get going.

What?

Lucas called again
this morning

before I left
for school.

Man, staying there
the last couple days

has been so awkward!

Did you talk to him?

His parents said
he didn't want

to talk to me,
or that he wouldn't.

I think we should just
go look for him.

Did they tell you
where he is?

Staying at
his cousin's house.

Said he didn't want
to come home,

that he had something
to work out.

So I called his cousin.

It's pretty obvious the
guy's covering for him.

I know a lie
when I hear one.

Lucas definitely
isn't there.

Well, there's not many
places he'd go, right?

I mean, for all we know,
he could be back in rosewood.

Why would you say that?
Have you heard from him?

No.

I was thinking
about checking out

Spencer's
lake house.

You know, maybe he
went back up there.

Whatever it is that
he's going through,

I just...
I want to help.

Caleb, when he's ready
to talk, he'll talk.

I don't know
that he will.

Look, are you gonna
come with me or not?

I don't know, I just
don't think that we

should go out
in the middle of nowhere.

You don't want
to find him.

Why?

I just don't think
it's a good idea

to push him right now.

Hanna, what happened
in that boat?

I already told you
what happened.

Not the whole story.
There is no story.

You're not being
honest with me.

Are you calling me
a liar?

Just stop, okay?
Tell me what you know.

We have always told
each other the truth.

If you want to go
find Lucas, then go.

No one's stopping you.

Caleb...

( Beep )

Ugh. This would be
so much easier

if we actually knew
what we were looking for.

Are you sure that we got
off at the right stop?

Yeah. The map says
it should be right around here.

Oh.

801 Hyperion.

But this... can't be right.

It says Smitty's
right on the sign.

Yeah, 803's right there.

800's across the street, so...

Well, is there
anything else on the receipt

that would say what "a"
or its helper was here for?

No, it's just
magazines.

( Sighs )

Well, there's
a toy store down the road.

Maybe "a" sent Lucas
down here to pick up

that four-pack
of Chucky dolls.

Your parents work
in the city.

Maybe they just stopped here
for some gum and magazines.

Yeah, maybe, but what
about those cell phones?

Those didn't look like
they belonged to my parents.

Wait, isn't Melissa's condo,
like, ten blocks from here?

I'm starting to think
this is kind of a bust.

Do you want
to grab a coffee?

Mm, I can't.

I promised Holden
I'd meet him at 7:30.

Am I doing
the right thing?

Yes! I mean,
you're taking a chance,

but you're being bold
and romantic.

You call me later to let me
know how it turns out?

I will.

Okay.
Okay.

( Beeping )

The calls come in
on this line,

and I log
the numbers here.

And this manual has
all the emergency numbers

and organizations
that we can refer people to.

I think it's so cool
that you're helping people.

They're lucky they get you
on the other end of the line.

I need to run home
and change,

and we can grab dinner
before we go out.

Sounds like a plan.

( Ding )

It's me.

Everything okay?

Yeah, yeah.

Actually, I'm sorry, I sort
of have to deal with this.

Yeah, no worries.
I need to go sign out.

Um, would it be okay
if I caught up with you later?

Sure.
Okay.

I will get dinner and meet
you back at your house.

Can I help you?

Um, I'm not sure.

I've been away
for a few years,

and I was just trying to locate
a former friend of mine.

She was a patient here.
Her name's Jenna Marshall.

Patient records
are confidential.

I don't need
her medical information.

I just know that she went to a school
for the blind in Philadelphia,

so I thought it might
be this one.

I can't even tell you which
chair she used to sit in.

Something else
I can help you with?

No. I guess that's it.

Excuse me.

You're looking
for Jenna?

I know her.

Hey, Hanna.

Haven't you
washed that already?

Four times?

Yeah, but it still
smells wretched.

Where's Maya?

She's meeting me
later... I think.

Maya's keeping
something from me.

I mean, she keeps
getting these calls

and these
text messages,

and I can tell it's
making her upset.

I should just ask
her about it, right?

I mean, I'm a part
of her life again.

I should know what's
going on, shouldn't I?

God, why isn't anyone allowed
to have a damn secret?

Because the calls,
the texts?

I'm starting
to worry

that it's "a"
going after her.

Em, just because we want
to throw up

every time
our phone rings,

doesn't mean everyone else
is living in fear.

You think
I'm paranoid?

I think that Maya
could be bugging up

for a hundred
different reasons

that have nothing
to do with "a."

And besides, if she is
keeping something from you,

maybe it's for
your own good.

Okay, Hanna, promise
me that you never

take a job
at a crisis center.

I'm sorry. It's just
Caleb and I got in a fight,

and I'm just trying
to protect him.

But it sucks being the
girlfriend who knows too much.

Yeah, well, it sucks
just as bad

being the girlfriend
who doesn't know enough.

Here.

Do you like
real sugar or fake?

Real. I'll get it.

Just tell me...
tell me what time it's at.

Oh, uh, 11:00.

Neat trick, huh?

Yeah.

Here.

Feel the difference?

Yeah, the grains of sugar
are bigger. Huh.

So, you went to school
with Jenna in rosewood?

Uh, no. I knew her
from before.

When she moved
to rosewood,

we kind of
lost touch.

You and Jenna got here
around the same time?

I was here a while
before Jenna showed up.

I have a genetic condition.

I've been going blind slowly
since I was born.

Literally
saw it coming.

When the lights
went out,

I wasn't ready.

I got angry,
depressed.

Meeting Jenna
pulled me out of it.

She helped you?

She was so focused.

No, determined.

I think she learned
more in a year

than most people
learn here in four.

I guess she was motivated
to get out of here.

For, like,
field trips?

It's not like
we're in jail.

And they encourage us
to get out on our own

and practice
or whatever.

It's nice to have
a change of scenery.

It's a joke, Spencer!
You can laugh.

No, I'm sorry.
Uh, I...

I guess I was just
wondering where she went.

Did she ever
tell you

where she went
or who she met?

She kept saying
she had things

she had to do
back home.

I haven't talked
to her in a while.

Whatever it is,
I hope she did it.

So, when do you get
out of here?

Oh, I'm done
with rehab now.

I help out in the art studio
a couple times a week.

If Jenna hadn't dragged
me in there,

I might've lost myself.

Now I have some of what
she gave me to give back.

Electronic voice:
It is 6:14.

That would be
my next class about to start.

Um, it was nice meeting you.

Yeah, you too.

Is everything okay?

Your pulse
is kind of racing.

No, I just don't
want to miss my train.

Sorry. The pulse thing

is another little trick
Jenna taught me.

She's full of surprises,
that one.

I know.

I think that's part
of what makes her so special.

She's really good
at reading people.

Have a good one.

You too.
Thanks.

Hold on, miss.
You need to sign in.

Uh, I was
just leaving.

You sat. You had coffee.
That makes you a visitor.

What does
that sign say?

All visitors
must sign in.

Jada! Can you
come back here?

Good night.

Yeah, thank you.
Have a good evening.

Don't you have
your own fake I.D.?

We all got
new ones together.

It's for Maya.

I look nothing
like Maya.

You're 5'2"
and brunette.

So is she.

It's the best I can do
on short notice.

Besides, we're going to
the bluebird in Camden.

Oh, Jersey?
Yeah, that'll totally work.

Okay, so all the windows
and doors are locked.

You can still
call Mona,

see if she'll
sleep over.

She's mad
at me, too.

Well, maybe Caleb
will calm down

and come over later.
How bad was your fight?

Bad. He thinks Lucas
needs our help.

Well, Caleb won't believe
Lucas is dangerous

until he knows what Lucas
did to Ali's memorial.

Yeah, well,
I can't spill that

without, like, spilling
a million other beans.

Meanwhile, I'm home
alone and Lucas

is out there
waiting for me.

You know what?

I'm just gonna call
Holden and cancel.

Maybe Maya can go
with someone else.

No. No, my mom will be home
before you and Maya leave,

and, Aria, don't cancel
just for me.

You sure?

Yeah.

I'll be fine
if someone's around.

Okay.

Well, I should probably
get going, then.

I'm gonna go upstairs
and get changed.

Scream if you need me.

You know
what I mean.

S.O.S., okay?

Yeah.

Hey.

Hi.

I thought your parents
were driving you here.

Oh, well, I convinced
my mom to drop

me off at the corner.
It's progress.

Sounds tough.

What'd you do to bring on
the parental wrath?

It's a really
long story.

Brought you something.

Oh! Gummy bears?

Yeah, when we were little you'd always
smuggle some into our playdates.

Oh, that's right!

Yeah, when your mom was
in her no-sugar phase.

My mom's had
a lot of phases.

Anyway, I figured
I owe you.

Oh. Thank you.

I'm gonna go grab
the tickets.

Hi. Two
for Montgomery.

Thanks.

Um, are there two
for Fitz?

Oh, no.
They're not mine.

I just thought that my
friend would be here by now.

Thanks.

Look who I found!

Oh, Mrs. Welch. Hi.

Hi. Hey, I didn't know you
kids were Arthur Miller fans.

You know, view from the
brid is one of my favorites.

What's it about?
You've never seen it?

Oh, I don't want
to ruin it for you,

but let's just say it's got
a lot of misplaced passion.

Well, we should probably
go find our seats.

Hey, Ezra, when did
you get here?

Spencer?

H-hi!

How random! Were you just on
the train in from the city?

Yeah. I didn't
see you.

I know! We could've
sat together.

So, what took
you downtown?

Um, just
running errands.

I was just doing
a little shopping.

A little?

It was therapeutic.

Especially since I can't
get in touch with Hanna.

She's fully awol.

Sorry, I haven't seen
her since school.

Oh. ( Chuckles )

Well, if you see her,
could you just...

You know what,
never mind.

Do you want me
to give her a message?

It's no big deal.
It's just...

Noel broke up
with me, and...

I don't even know why
so I hit these amazing sales

thinking I could just
shop the pain away.

And I bought, like, five
cashmere-blend sweater sets.

Have you ever seen me
in a sweater set?

No, because I don't
wear sweater sets. Or blends.

I think he broke me.

Wait. Here.

I don't that you
didn't ask me,

but I think that you can
raise the bar a little bit.

I know that there
are plenty of guys...

do you know how hard
I have to work

to get a guy like Noel kahn
to go out with me?

Well, if you've become
the Mona you want to be,

why are you letting
Noel kahn tell you

that you're not
good enough?

You cannot let him send you
spinning backwards like that.

You're, like, smart smart.

I always thought you
were just book smart.

You want a sweater set?
Cashmere blend.

Um, I'm cool, thanks.

Spencer.

Thanks.

It's so nice to see young
people enjoying live theater.

Most of your peers are probably
watching their youtubes right now.

You'd be surprised
to find that some of us

are able to actually connect
with the real world.

So, what brings
you here?

Uh, oh, a friend of mine
had an extra ticket.

Holden, you probably missed
him while you were abroad,

but, Aria, you remember
Mr. Fitz, don't you?

Oh. Is he here?

No, I just feel
terrible about it.

He had to leave
about ten minutes in.

Said he didn't
feel well.

♪ I can hardly hold
myself together ♪

Caleb, call me back
when you get this.

♪ This day
this night ♪

I made you some.

It's on
the counter.

Take a bath.

♪ I never wanna leave ♪

Is everything okay?

Yeah.

♪ No more words
from my lips ♪

You know where
to find me.

♪ Just the look in your eyes
says it all ♪

♪ so much more
than I could ever ♪

♪ I won't try ♪

Hey. It's me again.

I'm sorry
we argued earlier.

Now it's getting dark,
and...

And I'm getting worried.

I just don't think
that you should be

out there by yourself
looking for Lucas.

So, can you just
call me or something

so I can at least know
that you're okay?

I get it.
You're still mad at me.

Just... can you
at least text me?

( Door banging )

( Wind whistling )

Ashley: Hanna,
what was that noise?

Uh, just the wind, mom.
I think the latch is broken.

What?

The latch
on the back door.

I think we need
to fix it.

Did you bring
an umbrella?

( Chuckles )
Line's moving.

( Phone ringing ) Just
hope it doesn't rain.

Maya? Is someone
bothering you?

Do you want me
to answer it?

No, no. I just...

um, I should probably
turn my phone off, right?

Emily...

You don't have
to explain.

Whatever it is, just tell
me when you're ready.

I hooked up
with someone...

When I was away.

Remember when you called
and I was sort of distant?

Yeah. You didn't
want to talk to me.

I was lonely.

It didn't last
very long,

and I ended it.

You didn't have to be
scared to tell me.

We were apart.

Yeah, but I should
have said something.

I mean, we promised to get
to know each other again,

and that can't happen
when I'm not telling the truth.

I was scared
that telling you

would get
in the way of this.

Us.

Well, it
doesn't have to.

You said it was
over, right?

Ugh, it is, but...

It looks like he won't
take no for an answer.



Taxi!

♪ What you doing here
at this late hour? ♪

♪ put to bed
the dreams... ♪

It's about to get
crazy out here.

You wanna grab
a coffee or something?

Oh. Yeah.
We can do that.

Only if you want to.

Or...

Maybe you went out with
the wrong person tonight.

What? No. I...

I'm guessing your
parents don't approve.

I saw the way you looked
at him before the show,

and the look
on your face

when you found out
he'd gone.

I'm sorry.

Look, when my mom
gets here,

can you not
mention this to her?

Aria, we're not
five any more.

I don't have to tell
your mom anything,

as long as you promise
to do the same.

You're not the only one
who's got stuff

they wanna keep
from their parents.

So, how long have you
been seeing each other?

A while.

Hey, I'm so sorry.
This...

This was a mistake.

Maybe it's
an opportunity.

You busy
next friday?

Ashley: Hanna!

Where did you put
my bath salts?

Did you find them
by the hand towels?

Found 'em!

Lucas!

♪♪

I never wanted
to hurt you, Hanna.

Where's Caleb?

What did
you do to him?

Just listen to me, Hanna. No, no!
Don't come any closer!

Hanna.

( Phone ringing )

Who'd you just call?
No one, I swear.

Give me the phone
and listen to me, Hanna!

I can't let you
leave this room.

Hanna.

Caleb. You're here.

Are you okay?

I'm fine.

Lucas, what's
going on?

Where were you?

I don't know how Emily
found out that it was me

on that crisis hotline,

but I knew that she
was going to tell you

if I did it, so I took
you out onto the lake

so we could be alone.

I needed your help.

Yeah, well,
it didn't seem like that.

Probably because
of was scared myself.

I was just afraid about
how you would react,

and I need you to soften the
blow when I tell Caleb.

When you tell me what?

Your money... is gone.

What money?

When I left to go
visit my mom,

I left a bunch of cash
stashed around.

I asked Lucas to put it
in his checking account

until I got back.
So, wait, all of it?

And most of mine, too.

How much?
$4,000.

That's a lot
of money, Lucas.

It took me a long time
to make that.

It was supposed to be
a sure thing.

A sure thing?

I was just betting
on a basketball tournament.

What?
What were you thinking?

It was just
for fun at first,

a bunch of math
and probability stuff,

seeing if I could figure out
a formula to beat the odds.

I was so sure that I would
win your money back.

The team got
disqualified,

threw my bracket off.

The payoff
never happened.

And then suddenly you were
just back from California

and I had lost everything.

Is that why you didn't
come back after the lake?

You were just gonna
run away?

I just want
to make things right.

It's not everything,
but it's...

Where did you get this?

I was driving around to
different comic book stores

here, downstate,
and in new Jersey.

Sold a bunch
of my collectibles.

I know it's not everything,
but it's a start.

I'm really sorry, Caleb.

We'll work it out.

Hanna?

Please say something.

You're not who
I thought you were.

So wait, somebody else
showed up at the greenhouse

when we set
that trap for "a"?

It wasn't Lucas?

What about
the water bottle?

And the stunt
with the rowboat?

No, Lucas wasn't
even in rosewood.

He was driving around
all night trying

to sell his collectibles
to pay Caleb back.

Spence, what did you
want to show us?

Oh, yeah.

- Hey, did you order dumplings?
- Two orders.

What is this?

This is the sign-in book
from Jenna's blind rehab center.

This is the day before
Alison went missing.

Mm. Jenna said that Alison
came to visit her that day.

I don't see
Ali's name.

Wait, so that story
she told us, that was a lie?

Well, who knows,
but that's not all.

Look who did visit.

Garrett Reynolds.
He was there for,

like, what, 20 minutes
that night?

And not only do guests
have to sign in,

they also keep track
of when the patients leave.

Garrett signed Jenna out
at 10:15 P.M.

And there's no time
that they signed back in.

She could've been
gone all night.

Can we just look
at this later?

If I don't eat something,
my head is going to explode.

Aria, would you please
pass those plates?

Yeah, sure.

Jenna said that Alison
blackmailed her

and that she stayed
in rehab

until the day
of Alison's funeral.

So where was she
the night Ali went missing?

She could've
been anywhere.

How much do you want to bet
she was in rosewood?

( Gasping )
Oh, my God!

Oh, I'm gonna be sick.

( Cell phone dings )

"This is what live bait
looks like.

Now we're
even, bitches. - 'A.'"

( ratcheting )