Nova (1974–…): Season 42, Episode 15 - Secrets of Noah's Ark - full transcript
A new version of the biblical flood story includes instructions for assembling an ark.
First came the rain
Then the flood
When you're telling the story
of the beginnings of humanity,
the flood story is
part of that story
Then, with the rising
waters, a life-saving vessel
In the book of Genesis,
God asks Noah to build an ark
The Noah story serves to
provide a platform of understanding
for all future disasters
It is the ultimate disaster
But where does
the story come from?
An ancient tablet
may hold the answer
I took one look at it, and to
my astonishment I realized
that this was another
retelling of the flood story
Far older than the Bible,
the text describes a vessel
very different from Noah's
Everyone has their
image of the ark,
and then suddenly we have
this one appear that says,
"Hey, it's round!
It's a basket boat!"
I think that's a
fascinating thing to look at
Now, a team of investigators
has set out to build the ark
described in the tablet,
traveling to the once
lush marshlands of Iraq,
near the site of
ancient Babylon...
A land that was
ravaged by regular floods
And to India, where craftspeople
skilled in ancient techniques
will attempt to construct
a vessel large enough
to withstand a major flood
I think if you brought a
Babylonian into the present
to see this boat
when it's finished,
that he would recognize it
as something coming
from his culture
The story of the ark... a
turning point in history,
when the Babylonian
empire collides
with the world of the Bible
This is the moment the history
of the Jewish people begins
Not at the beginning
of time... After the flood
Climb on board to discover
the "Secrets of Noah's
Ark"... Right now, on NOVA.
At the Israel
Museum in Jerusalem,
some of the oldest known
fragments of the Bible
are being recorded and preserved
The 2,000-year-old
Dead Sea Scrolls
contain the first
Biblical reference
to a cataclysmic flood
"The Lord saw how
great the wickedness
"of the human race
had become on the earth
"So the Lord said, 'I will
wipe from the face of the earth
"the human race I have created '
But Noah found favor
in the eyes of the Lord"
Genesis 6:5, 7 and 8
Today, the story of Noah
and the flood is central
to the scriptures of Judaism,
Christianity, and Islam
In the story, God sends a
great flood as punishment
for the sins of humanity
Because it is a
moral, ethical God,
the takeaway lesson, in effect,
is that you better do
what this God wants;
otherwise there
will be big trouble
The righteous Noah is
told by God to build an ark
to save his family and a
pair of every type of animal
When the storm subsides,
Noah offers a sacrifice to God,
who then makes a
covenant with Noah,
promising that humanity
will never again be destroyed
by flood
This pact between man and
God is the foundation of morality
in the biblical book of Genesis
When you're telling the story
of the beginnings of humanity,
the flood story is
part of that story
Without this
moment of the flood,
you have no framework within
which humans can develop
the life that will
permit their perpetuity
You have to have it there
But why is a defining
moral tale in the Bible,
forged in the
desert hills of Judea,
shaped by a flood and a ship?
Where did its
authors get the idea?
The answer lies in the
world's first writing system
At the British Museum,
Dr Irving Finkel is one
of the world's few experts
in the ancient script
called cuneiform
And he shares his
knowledge with all generations
This is an exercise tablet
from an ancient school
It's made of clay,
squashed flat,
and the writing is done
on the surface of the clay
So they never wrote on paper
or papyrus like the Egyptians
Cuneiform evolved in
what is today modern Iraq,
in an ancient area between
the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers:
Mesopotamia, the
cradle of civilization
The earliest examples are
from around 5,000 years ago
Originally used for bookkeeping,
its first marks are
symbols of commodities,
like these ears of barley
But soon this picture-based
system develops
into symbols
representing syllables
Divide the name
up into syllables
Henry will be He-en-ry
It was a tremendously
significant step
for the human race
because it meant suddenly
it became possible to
record language properly
Over the course
of two millennia,
cuneiform tablets
become widespread
throughout Mesopotamia
It's here, during
the 19th century,
that British archaeologists
discover 130,000 of them,
now under Irving's care
One of them told
an explosive story
In 1872, its secret was revealed
by a British museum assistant
named George Smith
George Smith is a
bit of a hero of mine
He turned out to have
an absolute genius
for understanding
cuneiform almost at sight
When Smith read
the story in this tablet,
he read something that no person
had read since remote antiquity
In the tablet from 700 BCE,
Smith was shocked to
read key parts of a flood story
that closely resembled Noah
He discovered there
was going to be a deluge
to destroy the world
The gods choose one
human being as a hero,
and this character
had to build a boat
in order to put life in it
to withstand the waters
so that afterwards everything
could start all over again
I think he had a proper fit
because of the shock
of discovering a text
which he knew from
the Hebrew Bible by heart
was suddenly
there in front of him
in this totally strange medium
Smith found parallels in
even the most obscure details
In both stories, the flood hero
releases three sets of birds
to find dry land
And both offer a sacrifice
that their god smells
The two texts were somehow
strongly wedded together
They had a literary relationship
One derived from the other
Over a thousand years,
several versions of the
Babylonian flood myth emerged
Could the parallels between all
these Mesopotamian flood myths
and Noah's story be
merely coincidence?
There's a borrowing here
They're all different pictures
of the same personage,
the same literary creation
There's an overall parallel
There are a number of very
specific points of parallel,
which suggest that this is
not just a random association
But there is one major
difference: the ark itself
In the Hebrew Bible, Noah
builds a massive rectangular boat
But in one of the earliest
Babylonian stories,
the ark description
is incomplete
It says, "The ark you
are to build be equal"
and then it's broken
Because the tablet
is missing a piece,
features of the Babylonian
ark were a mystery
It would be almost a century
before a key clue would emerge
In 1948, a Royal Air Force
officer named Leonard Simmonds
was serving in the Middle East
One day he went into a market
and bought an interesting
looking piece of clay
with strange inscriptions
The object lay forgotten
in his home for 40 years
until his son took it
to the British Museum
to see if it might
be of interest
Once in a while
manna from heaven
falls just when you need it
The tablet was from the
ancient Mesopotamian kingdom
of Babylonia
This is what the
tablet looks like
Nothing exceptional
until you start to read it
And I took one look at it,
and to my astonishment,
I realized... From
the first lines only...
That this was another
retelling of the flood story
But the inscription was squeezed
onto a 4,000-year old,
badly damaged piece of clay
To confirm his first analysis,
Irving takes the tablet
to the International
Manufacturing Centre
at Warwick University
They produce a perfect 3D model,
allowing him to re-examine
the text in forensic detail
The tablet begins with a
Babylonian god's instructions
to the hero of the
story, named Atra Hasis
He tells him
to tear down the house and
use the materials to build a boat
And then comes a detailed
description of this boat
"Draw it out
with the design of a circle"
As you wade through this
funny script, you cannot deny
that with was the idea...
It was a round boat
You think to yourself,
"How can this be?"
The ark is one of the
most familiar iconic things
in the whole world
But when you start
to think about it,
we know that on the
rivers of Mesopotamia...
The Euphrates and the Tigris
River... they had round boats
On a Mesopotamian seal dated
2500 BCE is the cross-section
of a round vessel
And at the British Museum are
other images of round boats...
Called coracles... from 700
BCE carrying cargoes of stone
So is the tablet
describing a real vessel?
It's supposed to be mythology
But as you go further
down the tablet,
you discover that the
detailed specifications
about how to build
this thing are given us
The tablet lists the ark's
components and proportions
in detail, suggesting real
boat-building knowledge
Instead of it being
made-up facts,
we actually have details
predicated on the idea
of building a real coracle
But the coracle described
in the tablet is enormous...
222 feet across
So Irving wanted to know,
could such an enormous
round boat actually be built?
Quite frankly it seemed to
me the only possible thing
you could do was to
take these instructions
about how to build
a giant coracle
and build a giant coracle
Very few boat builders in
the world have the expertise
to take up Irving's challenge
But if there's one person
who can build such a vessel,
it's maritime archaeologist
Dr Tom Vosmer
Tom has built a career from
resurrecting ancient boats
from literary evidence
Everyone has their
image of the ark,
and then suddenly we have
this one appear that says,
"Hey, it's round!
It's a basket boat!"
I think that's a
fascinating thing to look at
and see if we can make it work
With him is Eric Staples,
maritime historian
and boat builder
And Alessandro Ghidoni,
a world expert in
ancient boat technology
They've taken Irving's
translation of the tablet
and converted the
Babylonian measurements
Right away they see the
problem: the scale of the ark...
So big its structure could
never support its weight
Its size
It's obviously
physically impossible,
but let's try to see
how far we can push it,
how large we can
actually make it
Also, the tablet
lists materials,
but doesn't say
how the Babylonians
would have to put them together
Luckily, there is
more recent evidence
These images from the 1930s
show round Iraqi boats called quffas
ferrying passengers and goods
In 1934, a British boat
historian named James Hornell
carried out detailed
research on quffas
He wrote that they were
made of fibrous plants
found near waterways...
Either reeds or palm leaves...
Bound into ropes and
coiled into a basket-like hull
Wooden ribs held
the shape of the hull,
and a layer of bitumen,
or pitch, made it waterproof
These are the same
materials described
in the 4,000-year-old ark
tablet that Irving Finkel analyzed
If the team is going to build
the kind of round boat described
in the Babylonian myth,
they need to examine
a more modern example
These are the heavily
guarded oilfields of southern Iraq
For any outsider,
traveling here is risky
Coming into
what's described as an
unsecure environment
in order to flesh out the
details of how to build
a Babylonian ark
is definitely a new one
for me, that's for sure
Eric needs to reach
one of the few places
where there is evidence
of Iraq's traditional
boat-building skills:
the great marshes
of southern Iraq
This ancient aquatic
wilderness once covered
12,000 square miles
It was home to hundreds
of thousands of Marsh Arabs
But much of it was drained by
Saddam Hussein in the early '90s
to punish those
resisting his regime
Eric has come to
meet Azzam Alwash
Azzam is an expert in marsh
traditions and boat technology
And he also owns possibly
the last remaining quffa in Iraq
As modern roads, bridges
and river launches were built,
quffas became obsolete
This example exists only
because Azzam had it constructed
Hello, Azzam
Pleasure meeting you Likewise
How are you doing?
Good How are you?
Good, good
So here's our quffa
This is the quffa
Wonderful
The building of this quffa
started with weaving in circles
It's rings upon rings
upon rings woven together
with traditional
weaving techniques
Eric recognizes the components
described in the ark tablet...
The coiled rope of the hull,
made from marsh reeds;
the wooden ribs of its skeleton;
and waterproofing bitumen,
the asphalt-like substance
that's been used to
seal the hulls of boats
since antiquity
Do you think I
could give it a try?
Sure, why not? All right
Hey, nice little sailor!
It's very stable,
which is why it was once
used as an all-purpose ferry boat
But Eric wants to know
if it can be scaled up
And if so, how big can
he build a round boat?
The 20th century
historic record indicates
that the biggest quffas were
up to 18 feet in diameter,
much less than the 222
feet the tablet suggests
Could this be the limit of
the round boat technology,
today and in ancient times?
Azzam takes Eric to
see a building technique
that dates back more than
5,000 years... a reed house
So there it is
The entire rigidity of this
structure comes from the tension
built into these arches
There is no metal in the
building of these structures
It's reeds upon reeds upon reeds
They are brought together by
the tension of these twisted reeds
Could the ancient
Babylonians have used
this house-building technique
as the basis for constructing
their large, round ark?
The circle that runs around here
is one way of basically
holding it all in together
using the natural tension,
the strength of reeds, basically,
because they're flexible,
but there's still strength
within the flexibility,
particularly when you
bundle them like this
But you're saying here that
this is going to be ten, 15 meters?
Ten, 12 meters, yes, yes
Okay
Eric arrived with just the
4,000-year-old tablet details
Now he has the
beginnings of a design
for his large Babylonian coracle
But many obstacles remain,
beginning with where to build
I'd love to build it in Iraq,
but considering
the logistical issues
and the security issues as
well, um, it's not realistic here
So the question
is where if not Iraq?
Another question is
how credible is the tablet
in describing the flood?
Today, this region is desert
How likely is it that a great
flood could have inundated
this parched landscape
thousands of years ago
as the Babylonian
myth describes?
This is one of the places
that gave birth to that legend,
home of first the Sumerian,
then Babylonian Empires...
The ancient city of Ur
Just 20 miles from
the great marshes,
Ur dates back more
than 5,000 years
It's here in 1928
that British archaeologist
Sir Charles Leonard Woolley
made a startling discovery
In 1922, Woolley and
his team came in search
of early Mesopotamian
civilization
He found remains of
an entire royal dynasty,
a testament to the
sophistication and power
of the Sumerian elite
And then, he made an
equally stunning discovery
A distinctive layer of
river silt ten feet thick
It had been laid down
by a massive flood
The grandson of a
member of Woolley's team
relates how the discovery
evoked the biblical story of Noah
They found layer of
sand to the south of Ur,
north of Ur,
and east and west
That mean that
happen a big flood
and they thought that is
the same flood of
Noah, the great man,
the great prophet at that time
This connection to Noah's flood
made the layer of sand more
famous than Ur's treasures
Especially when other
archaeologists began finding
flood deposits in neighboring
cities like Uruk, Shuruppak,
and Kish
The idea of a single
great flood grew
But there was a problem
When the layers were dated,
they were found to be
caused by different events,
spread over a thousand years
So was there ever
really a single great flood?
Landscape archaeologist
Dr Jenny Pournelle
is looking for the answer
For over a decade, Jenny
has been investigating
how the landscape of Iraq has
changed over thousands of years
Today she is taking
a core sample,
part of a series that
covers a broad area
She's digging 68
miles south of Ur,
in a marshland that was
recently drained for oil exploitation
It's a chance for her to get a
piece of uncontaminated earth,
essential for accurate dating
You can see
this light, light grey
silt, and these little guys
are very typical of freshwater
marshes around here
It means that our core
will have been protected
by this marsh cover until
recently when it was drained
This core will help reveal if
ancient Mesopotamia was impacted
by a cataclysmic flood
This should be
something like year zero
And that may be 1,000 BC
And if we're lucky,
right about here is when
your ark tablet was written
So what does this sample show?
They open it to see
We've got layers,
quite clear ones
See that nice orange sediment?
It would suggest
that there was a river
that periodically flooded
and deposited sediment
Evidence from cores like this
indicates that in ancient times,
Mesopotamia was
criss-crossed by rivers and canals
that flooded constantly
Every year there
are two floods...
One in the spring,
one in the fall
As cities first grew,
floods were part of
not just a natural cycle
but an essential cycle
They were profoundly
dependent on the marshes
and all of the
wealth of products
that came out of them...
Food for themselves,
food for livestock,
trade, commerce
Ur was one of many cities
that arose in this water world
The Euphrates River
was its life source
It delivered fertile
soil, fish, and wildfowl
But it could also bring disaster
The Tigris, the Euphrates
also had super floods every
ten years, every hundred years,
every thousand years
When we have the first
recorded stories of the flood myth,
the cities where these
were being written down
are exactly in that
precarious position
They created around
them fragile environments
With the right amount of water,
they can be
incredibly productive
and incredibly wealthy
But with the wrong
amount of water,
the very irrigation works they
need to produce that wealth
are blown away
Everyone has a vested
interest in this flood story
Everyone knows that it
makes or breaks their careers,
their livelihood
That would be the
power of the flood myth
in this part of the world
So it wasn't a single great
flood that inspired the myths,
but centuries of
periodic flooding
And would a large round boat
have helped these ancient people
to survive these floods?
The boat building team
is trying to figure out
if it could even
have been built at all
They found a place to
build their Babylonian coracle
in southern India,
where they can access the
materials listed in the tablet,
and the skills to
put them together
Construction begins on
the shore of Lake Vembanad
The fibrous plants
they will use for the hull
will be reeds from
a nearby marsh
Some of the 16 5 tons
of wood they will need
arrives at the boatyard
They've settled on
the size of their ark...
About 40 feet in diameter,
just a fifth the size of the
ark described in the tablet
But at 40 feet, it
will weigh 35 tons...
Right at the limit of what
they believe the materials
and the ancient
techniques will stand
Once the ark is in the water,
the bottom will flex,
straining the frame,
possibly causing it to break
The bigger the ark,
the bigger the pressure
The largest quffas
that I'm aware of
may be six meters
This we're pushing beyond that
It's actually eight times
as big as a six-meter one
So we're increasing the forces
we have to contend
with exponentially
To hold the frame
together, they will reinforce it,
combining basic engineering
with known Babylonian
carpentry techniques
The Ark Tablet states that
the flood vessel has 30 ribs
They lock these
ribs in a latticework
Tensioned bands will hold
the tops of the ribs together
The deck layer will
add further rigidity
And a forest of stanchions
will prevent the bottom
from collapsing upwards
Maybe it's all going to
fall apart, who knows?
But maybe it will
succeed and we'll think,
"Ah, we could have
pushed it a little bit more!"
The ark will contain more
than 800 pieces of wood
in 6,000 individual connections,
cut and shaped
using traditional tools
There will be no metal,
modern sealant or adhesive
As instructed by the
tablet, the team also begins
to bind reeds into tightly
packed lengths of rope
They'll need a mile and a
half to cover the entire hull
You have this little coil
that then starts spiraling out
The idea is that you
can gradually create
a gigantic basket,
basically made of grass
As the beginning of the
reed coil is lashed into place,
they turn their attention to
the next major challenge:
waterproofing
The tablet calls for
natural bitumen...
Which doesn't exist in India,
but is found oozing
out of the ground in Iraq
Natural bitumen
has unique impurities,
which make it adhesive
and resistant to heat
Alessandro, the team's expert
in ancient boat technology,
needs to re-create
these properties,
starting with refined
industrial bitumen
He adds animal fat and fish oil
to make it sticky,
and lime powder made
from burnt lake shells
to give it heat tolerance
Getting the balance of these
ingredients right is critical
If you put too much lime
powder it will get very hard,
it will resist at
high temperature,
but it won't stick
If you put too much
fish oil or animal fat,
it will stick easily
It's getting more dense
but it will melt under
the sun basically
Put it down
Alessandro's cooking
skills will determine
whether the ark
will float or not
Up, like this
They've given themselves
six months to build,
the recorded gap
between seasonal floods
in ancient Mesopotamia
Then, they'll face the
greatest challenge of all:
getting the ark into the lake
A boat usually has a keel
that can support it as
it slides into the water
A round boat has no keel
And this one will be covered
in a fragile layer of bitumen
You cannot drag the
boat on the ground,
you cannot pull it
The bitumen layer
is extremely delicate,
it's very soft, and you
don't want it damaged,
because it's the
only, basically, layer
that keeps the
whole boat waterproof
Without the bitumen,
the boat won't float
How would the Babylonians
have launched the boat?
The Ark Tablet doesn't say
The hero, Atra Hasis,
simply waits for the flood
It is one of the big questions,
sort of a burning
question of, you know,
if a boat this large could
actually have been built,
unless there was a
flood it would have been
incredibly difficult to launch
A vessel like this could
have meant survival
in a world of constant flooding
But at some point, those
floods become mythologized
into a single great deluge
and real coracles are turned
into a single
giant ark of legend
And somehow that
legend of the round ark
becomes the familiar boat
shape in the story of Noah
How does such
a transition occur?
The answer lies in a great
innovation of the ancient world:
cuneiform writing
Originally all these
stories circulated orally
And around 2000 BC,
we see for the first
time that these narratives
became reduced to writing
And from that moment
they are fixed rigidly
So you have an established
text which all the scribes copy
And in the process of
copying, errors creep in
Irving Finkel believes
one of these errors
changes the shape of the ark
The Ark Tablet, dated
around 1750 BCE...
4,000 years old...
Places the round
ark inside a square
to help define its dimensions
By 700 BCE, the Atra Hasis
flood tale has been absorbed
into a more famous story,
the exploits of a hero king
in The Epic of Gilgamesh.
But here, scribes omit
the mention of the circle
We have these later
scribes who have an old text
They look at it and they decide,
"Well, all this technical
stuff, we don't need it,"
and they don't read the
thing very carefully at all
because in the description
about how round it was,
they miss the point
As a result,
according to Irving,
the Gilgamesh ark has
a very strange shape
So it's like a
kind of skyscraper
What would happen if
you put that in the sea?
It would sink, wouldn't it?
Especially if it
was full of animals
It's absolutely hopeless
Over time, the
mythical ark loses touch
with the reality
that likely inspired it
It sets off on a
literary journey,
changing with
new interpretations
There is a rather
ironic consequence
You have the possibility of
an error being consolidated,
copied and recopied until
nobody thinks about it anymore
and they just
take it for granted
And that is surely what
happened with the shape of the ark
It eventually adopts
the boat shape we know
in the story of Noah
And the rest of the
story changes too
Almost 2,000 years after
the first Babylonian version,
the flood story is found
outside Mesopotamia,
in the Hebrew Bible
There's just no way
of explaining the story
in Genesis except as a borrowing
The question is,
when, how and why?
It's long been assumed that
trade and cultural exchange
bring the Babylonian
story to ancient Israel
But this doesn't explain why
biblical writers adopt the tale
and give it a moral twist
In the Mesopotamian myth,
pagan gods are
disturbed by human noise
and use the flood to
reduce their numbers
But in the book of Genesis,
the flood is a disaster
that God uses to punish
people for their sins
The Noah story serves
to provide a platform
of understanding
for all future disasters
It is the ultimate disaster
It was not just
natural disasters
that were attributed to God,
it was also historical disasters
The history of the people
to be known as Jews
is filled with disasters that
are reflected in the Bible
But many experts believe
there is one in particular
which provides an
explanation for the story of Noah
The Babylonian destruction
of Jerusalem in 587 BCE
A consequence of the
Judean kingdom's failure
to pay tribute
If somebody is not
paying their taxes,
not paying tribute as
they're supposed to,
you have to make
an example of them,
so you need to come
in and show the world
what your power is
capable of enforcing
Several thousand Judeans...
The educated and the
powerful of ancient Israel...
Were marched about
1,000 miles to Babylon
The Babylonians needed manpower
They had fields that
needed to be cultivated
and craftsmen that
needed to be imported
to make the tremendous
buildings and other things
that they did, so you
imported manpower
to do those kinds of things
I think for a lot of people
there probably was a sense
that this is the end of
the world as we know it
"Our tormentors
demanded songs of joy
"They said, 'Sing us
one of the songs of Zion!'
"But how can we sing
the songs of the Lord
while in a foreign land?"
Psalm 137:3 and 4
Yet this traumatic uprooting
brought the Judeans
into direct contact
with Babylonian culture
And that would shape
the destiny of their scripture
and the story of Noah
One of the greatest
collections of Babylonian relics
in the world is found here,
at the Pergamon Museum in Berlin
It includes a reconstruction
of the entrance to Babylon
The newly arrived Judeans
would have walked through this gate
On the other side was a world
they could scarcely
have imagined
In the sixth century BCE,
Babylon was the most
cosmopolitan city on earth
But what was the
Judean experience?
Dr Cornelia Wunsch is an expert
in Neo-Babylonian culture
She has evidence
suggesting exile in Babylon
wasn't as bad as the
Judeans might have feared
They have been allotted land
and they are tilling the
land, building houses
and they are doing
reasonably well there
It may have been
awful at the beginning
and nobody
wanted to be in exile,
but very quickly,
things got good
Judea made it after
one or two generations
They were well ensconced
into the Babylonian economies
They did well
- A - Babylonian-style
personal seal
of a Judean merchant
named Arricam
suggests how assimilated
some Judeans were
in this new society
He certainly led
a dual existence
Arricam is clearly
showing himself
as a person of Judean
descent, but on the other hand
as a typical Babylonian
businessman
Many Judeans in Babylon
were well integrated
into Babylonian culture
But they also preserved
their own traditions
This was the case
for Judean scribes,
who were editing
traditional stories and prayers
and writing new ones
that would ultimately
become the Hebrew Bible
These priestly
authors, obviously,
had the exile on their minds
And one of the most
significant aspects of this event
was the formation of the Bible
It began in Babylon
Some of these books were already
in process but seem to have been
shaped by the
experience of the exile
In the center of Babylon
is a giant ziggurat
In the book of Genesis it
becomes the ultimate symbol
of human folly...
The Tower of Babel
For Irving Finkel,
this borrowing is
just one of many
In collaboration with the
Archaeological Institute
in Berlin, he examines
extraordinary evidence
that links some elements
of Babylonian literature
with the beginnings
of the Hebrew Bible
One is the story of King
Sargon, who was cast adrift
by his mother in a round basket
to save him from
being discovered
She made a little ark
out of reeds and bitumen
and she put the baby in this
ark and she put the ark in the river
and away it went
Now, this is a story which has
a certain familiar ring about it
from the book of
Exodus point of view
because Moses was
given the same kind of origin
There's also a list
of Babylonian kings
before the flood,
very similar to Adam's genealogy
described in the book of Genesis
But the most amazing
piece of evidence is written
on a Babylonian school
tablet... A retelling of Gilgamesh,
the epic poem that
contains the flood story
What does it tell us?
It tells us that you have
at this time in Babylonia,
schoolrooms where
the Gilgamesh story,
undoubtedly including the
flood story, was on the curriculum
Could Judean children have
read these same stories?
A detail in the Bible's book
of Daniel suggests they did
According to the story,
Daniel was the son of an
exiled Judean nobleman
In Babylon, the Bible
says, he and his friends
were taught to read cuneiform
Just as these children discover,
learning cuneiform isn't hard
It would have made
Babylonian stories easy to absorb
These kids suddenly
find themselves
learning these very narratives
which seem to us the
essential Babylonian narratives
that ended up embedded
in Judean Hebrew
The idea that it was Judeans
in Babylonian captivity
who learned cuneiform
and adopted the flood story
is to me the only decent
explanation that you can have
If this theory is correct,
stories like Noah and the Flood
were widespread
in Babylonian culture
and absorbed into
Judean scripture
They would eventually
become the moral teaching
for three great faiths
But not until the Judeans
emerged from exile
In India, the Babylonian
ark is almost complete
And unlike the Babylonians...
Who would have just waited
for the floodwaters to rise...
The building team has had
to find a way to launch the ark
without dragging its fragile
hull across the ground
We have two rails running
straight underneath the ark
into the water
So on top of these rails,
we are going to put rollers
And then on top of the rollers,
we're going to have
another set of runners
And then sitting on
top of these runners,
we have the launch platform
And then on top of the platform
Is the ark
Once she's all ready go,
basically just
roll into the lake
It's a traditional boat
launching technique
But they've had to resort
to modern machinery
to build the launch platform
Once in the water,
the platform will sink,
leaving the coracle
to float away
Except, as things stand,
it probably won't
Alessandro's version
of Babylonian bitumen
is melting and dropping off
It's quite catastrophic
at this stage
Once we launch the
boat, the water can push
through the gaps and holes
and then we're going
to have a major leak
Just before launch, the
ark is still not waterproof
In 539 BCE,
over 50 years in exile,
the Judeans were
allowed to return home
They began rebuilding
the Israel of old,
with a new temple and
a single text, the Torah
One of the most
remarkable things
about ancient Israelite
religion is that it survives
The Babylonians
conquered Jerusalem
But the exiles from
Jerusalem did not give up belief
in their God
The Babylonian flood myth is
now retold as a moral lesson
In some ways, it's a
metaphor for the exile
The foreign agent
comes, punishes,
as a tool of God's wrath
There's a cataclysm to
be survived by a select few
And for them, the
promise of a new beginning
is echoed in the Noah story
"God blessed Noah and
his sons, saying to them,
"" Be fruitful and increase
in number and fill the earth
"" I establish my
covenant with you
"" Never again will
all life be destroyed
by the waters of a flood ""
Genesis 9:1 and 11
This covenant defines
man's relationship with God
and marks the birth of Judaism
The great Israeli scholar
Yehezkel Kaufmann said,
"The exile is the watershed
"With the exile, the religion
of Israel comes to an end
and Judaism begins"
This is the moment
at which the history
of the Jewish people begins
Not at the beginning of time,
but after the flood
In India, Irving's theory
that the legend was based
on an authentic
boat-building tradition
is about to be put to the test
The big question is
Alessandro's bitumen recipe
Will it work?
For Irving, the culmination
of years of translation,
study and investigation
is this moment
I can hardly believe my eyes!
Amazing
After all this imagination,
it's really here in
the flesh so to speak
It's incredible,
it's incredible!
The ark is raised
on inflatable rollers
On its launch platform,
it begins its journey
down to the lake
Alessandro is standing by to
plug any leaks from the outside
But before he can,
a roller slips free,
pitching the ark in the water
Start pulling!
Below decks, it's clear
their non-Babylonian
waterproof mix isn't working
So we are now floating,
which is the good news
The potentially
bad news, however,
is that we have a
heck of a lot of water
coming in at the moment
They had hoped to
get animals on board
But right now they're
consumed with saving the ark
They plug the gaps and put
a collection of pumps to work
By the time Irving
climbs on board,
the problem is under control
Welcome aboard
Thank you!
I'm proud to be here
How wonderful, how
absolutely wonderful!
The boat-building
team never managed
to duplicate Babylonian bitumen,
but the structure
of the ark is sound
At the root of the
story may have been
a flood vessel like this one
Behind the legend
of a great flood
were thousands of real floods
And behind the
myth of a giant ark
is a genuine tradition
of round boat building
All this from a
Babylonian tablet...
A story that emerged
4,000 years ago
It continues to resonate today
as one of the world's
most enduring tales
Then the flood
When you're telling the story
of the beginnings of humanity,
the flood story is
part of that story
Then, with the rising
waters, a life-saving vessel
In the book of Genesis,
God asks Noah to build an ark
The Noah story serves to
provide a platform of understanding
for all future disasters
It is the ultimate disaster
But where does
the story come from?
An ancient tablet
may hold the answer
I took one look at it, and to
my astonishment I realized
that this was another
retelling of the flood story
Far older than the Bible,
the text describes a vessel
very different from Noah's
Everyone has their
image of the ark,
and then suddenly we have
this one appear that says,
"Hey, it's round!
It's a basket boat!"
I think that's a
fascinating thing to look at
Now, a team of investigators
has set out to build the ark
described in the tablet,
traveling to the once
lush marshlands of Iraq,
near the site of
ancient Babylon...
A land that was
ravaged by regular floods
And to India, where craftspeople
skilled in ancient techniques
will attempt to construct
a vessel large enough
to withstand a major flood
I think if you brought a
Babylonian into the present
to see this boat
when it's finished,
that he would recognize it
as something coming
from his culture
The story of the ark... a
turning point in history,
when the Babylonian
empire collides
with the world of the Bible
This is the moment the history
of the Jewish people begins
Not at the beginning
of time... After the flood
Climb on board to discover
the "Secrets of Noah's
Ark"... Right now, on NOVA.
At the Israel
Museum in Jerusalem,
some of the oldest known
fragments of the Bible
are being recorded and preserved
The 2,000-year-old
Dead Sea Scrolls
contain the first
Biblical reference
to a cataclysmic flood
"The Lord saw how
great the wickedness
"of the human race
had become on the earth
"So the Lord said, 'I will
wipe from the face of the earth
"the human race I have created '
But Noah found favor
in the eyes of the Lord"
Genesis 6:5, 7 and 8
Today, the story of Noah
and the flood is central
to the scriptures of Judaism,
Christianity, and Islam
In the story, God sends a
great flood as punishment
for the sins of humanity
Because it is a
moral, ethical God,
the takeaway lesson, in effect,
is that you better do
what this God wants;
otherwise there
will be big trouble
The righteous Noah is
told by God to build an ark
to save his family and a
pair of every type of animal
When the storm subsides,
Noah offers a sacrifice to God,
who then makes a
covenant with Noah,
promising that humanity
will never again be destroyed
by flood
This pact between man and
God is the foundation of morality
in the biblical book of Genesis
When you're telling the story
of the beginnings of humanity,
the flood story is
part of that story
Without this
moment of the flood,
you have no framework within
which humans can develop
the life that will
permit their perpetuity
You have to have it there
But why is a defining
moral tale in the Bible,
forged in the
desert hills of Judea,
shaped by a flood and a ship?
Where did its
authors get the idea?
The answer lies in the
world's first writing system
At the British Museum,
Dr Irving Finkel is one
of the world's few experts
in the ancient script
called cuneiform
And he shares his
knowledge with all generations
This is an exercise tablet
from an ancient school
It's made of clay,
squashed flat,
and the writing is done
on the surface of the clay
So they never wrote on paper
or papyrus like the Egyptians
Cuneiform evolved in
what is today modern Iraq,
in an ancient area between
the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers:
Mesopotamia, the
cradle of civilization
The earliest examples are
from around 5,000 years ago
Originally used for bookkeeping,
its first marks are
symbols of commodities,
like these ears of barley
But soon this picture-based
system develops
into symbols
representing syllables
Divide the name
up into syllables
Henry will be He-en-ry
It was a tremendously
significant step
for the human race
because it meant suddenly
it became possible to
record language properly
Over the course
of two millennia,
cuneiform tablets
become widespread
throughout Mesopotamia
It's here, during
the 19th century,
that British archaeologists
discover 130,000 of them,
now under Irving's care
One of them told
an explosive story
In 1872, its secret was revealed
by a British museum assistant
named George Smith
George Smith is a
bit of a hero of mine
He turned out to have
an absolute genius
for understanding
cuneiform almost at sight
When Smith read
the story in this tablet,
he read something that no person
had read since remote antiquity
In the tablet from 700 BCE,
Smith was shocked to
read key parts of a flood story
that closely resembled Noah
He discovered there
was going to be a deluge
to destroy the world
The gods choose one
human being as a hero,
and this character
had to build a boat
in order to put life in it
to withstand the waters
so that afterwards everything
could start all over again
I think he had a proper fit
because of the shock
of discovering a text
which he knew from
the Hebrew Bible by heart
was suddenly
there in front of him
in this totally strange medium
Smith found parallels in
even the most obscure details
In both stories, the flood hero
releases three sets of birds
to find dry land
And both offer a sacrifice
that their god smells
The two texts were somehow
strongly wedded together
They had a literary relationship
One derived from the other
Over a thousand years,
several versions of the
Babylonian flood myth emerged
Could the parallels between all
these Mesopotamian flood myths
and Noah's story be
merely coincidence?
There's a borrowing here
They're all different pictures
of the same personage,
the same literary creation
There's an overall parallel
There are a number of very
specific points of parallel,
which suggest that this is
not just a random association
But there is one major
difference: the ark itself
In the Hebrew Bible, Noah
builds a massive rectangular boat
But in one of the earliest
Babylonian stories,
the ark description
is incomplete
It says, "The ark you
are to build be equal"
and then it's broken
Because the tablet
is missing a piece,
features of the Babylonian
ark were a mystery
It would be almost a century
before a key clue would emerge
In 1948, a Royal Air Force
officer named Leonard Simmonds
was serving in the Middle East
One day he went into a market
and bought an interesting
looking piece of clay
with strange inscriptions
The object lay forgotten
in his home for 40 years
until his son took it
to the British Museum
to see if it might
be of interest
Once in a while
manna from heaven
falls just when you need it
The tablet was from the
ancient Mesopotamian kingdom
of Babylonia
This is what the
tablet looks like
Nothing exceptional
until you start to read it
And I took one look at it,
and to my astonishment,
I realized... From
the first lines only...
That this was another
retelling of the flood story
But the inscription was squeezed
onto a 4,000-year old,
badly damaged piece of clay
To confirm his first analysis,
Irving takes the tablet
to the International
Manufacturing Centre
at Warwick University
They produce a perfect 3D model,
allowing him to re-examine
the text in forensic detail
The tablet begins with a
Babylonian god's instructions
to the hero of the
story, named Atra Hasis
He tells him
to tear down the house and
use the materials to build a boat
And then comes a detailed
description of this boat
"Draw it out
with the design of a circle"
As you wade through this
funny script, you cannot deny
that with was the idea...
It was a round boat
You think to yourself,
"How can this be?"
The ark is one of the
most familiar iconic things
in the whole world
But when you start
to think about it,
we know that on the
rivers of Mesopotamia...
The Euphrates and the Tigris
River... they had round boats
On a Mesopotamian seal dated
2500 BCE is the cross-section
of a round vessel
And at the British Museum are
other images of round boats...
Called coracles... from 700
BCE carrying cargoes of stone
So is the tablet
describing a real vessel?
It's supposed to be mythology
But as you go further
down the tablet,
you discover that the
detailed specifications
about how to build
this thing are given us
The tablet lists the ark's
components and proportions
in detail, suggesting real
boat-building knowledge
Instead of it being
made-up facts,
we actually have details
predicated on the idea
of building a real coracle
But the coracle described
in the tablet is enormous...
222 feet across
So Irving wanted to know,
could such an enormous
round boat actually be built?
Quite frankly it seemed to
me the only possible thing
you could do was to
take these instructions
about how to build
a giant coracle
and build a giant coracle
Very few boat builders in
the world have the expertise
to take up Irving's challenge
But if there's one person
who can build such a vessel,
it's maritime archaeologist
Dr Tom Vosmer
Tom has built a career from
resurrecting ancient boats
from literary evidence
Everyone has their
image of the ark,
and then suddenly we have
this one appear that says,
"Hey, it's round!
It's a basket boat!"
I think that's a
fascinating thing to look at
and see if we can make it work
With him is Eric Staples,
maritime historian
and boat builder
And Alessandro Ghidoni,
a world expert in
ancient boat technology
They've taken Irving's
translation of the tablet
and converted the
Babylonian measurements
Right away they see the
problem: the scale of the ark...
So big its structure could
never support its weight
Its size
It's obviously
physically impossible,
but let's try to see
how far we can push it,
how large we can
actually make it
Also, the tablet
lists materials,
but doesn't say
how the Babylonians
would have to put them together
Luckily, there is
more recent evidence
These images from the 1930s
show round Iraqi boats called quffas
ferrying passengers and goods
In 1934, a British boat
historian named James Hornell
carried out detailed
research on quffas
He wrote that they were
made of fibrous plants
found near waterways...
Either reeds or palm leaves...
Bound into ropes and
coiled into a basket-like hull
Wooden ribs held
the shape of the hull,
and a layer of bitumen,
or pitch, made it waterproof
These are the same
materials described
in the 4,000-year-old ark
tablet that Irving Finkel analyzed
If the team is going to build
the kind of round boat described
in the Babylonian myth,
they need to examine
a more modern example
These are the heavily
guarded oilfields of southern Iraq
For any outsider,
traveling here is risky
Coming into
what's described as an
unsecure environment
in order to flesh out the
details of how to build
a Babylonian ark
is definitely a new one
for me, that's for sure
Eric needs to reach
one of the few places
where there is evidence
of Iraq's traditional
boat-building skills:
the great marshes
of southern Iraq
This ancient aquatic
wilderness once covered
12,000 square miles
It was home to hundreds
of thousands of Marsh Arabs
But much of it was drained by
Saddam Hussein in the early '90s
to punish those
resisting his regime
Eric has come to
meet Azzam Alwash
Azzam is an expert in marsh
traditions and boat technology
And he also owns possibly
the last remaining quffa in Iraq
As modern roads, bridges
and river launches were built,
quffas became obsolete
This example exists only
because Azzam had it constructed
Hello, Azzam
Pleasure meeting you Likewise
How are you doing?
Good How are you?
Good, good
So here's our quffa
This is the quffa
Wonderful
The building of this quffa
started with weaving in circles
It's rings upon rings
upon rings woven together
with traditional
weaving techniques
Eric recognizes the components
described in the ark tablet...
The coiled rope of the hull,
made from marsh reeds;
the wooden ribs of its skeleton;
and waterproofing bitumen,
the asphalt-like substance
that's been used to
seal the hulls of boats
since antiquity
Do you think I
could give it a try?
Sure, why not? All right
Hey, nice little sailor!
It's very stable,
which is why it was once
used as an all-purpose ferry boat
But Eric wants to know
if it can be scaled up
And if so, how big can
he build a round boat?
The 20th century
historic record indicates
that the biggest quffas were
up to 18 feet in diameter,
much less than the 222
feet the tablet suggests
Could this be the limit of
the round boat technology,
today and in ancient times?
Azzam takes Eric to
see a building technique
that dates back more than
5,000 years... a reed house
So there it is
The entire rigidity of this
structure comes from the tension
built into these arches
There is no metal in the
building of these structures
It's reeds upon reeds upon reeds
They are brought together by
the tension of these twisted reeds
Could the ancient
Babylonians have used
this house-building technique
as the basis for constructing
their large, round ark?
The circle that runs around here
is one way of basically
holding it all in together
using the natural tension,
the strength of reeds, basically,
because they're flexible,
but there's still strength
within the flexibility,
particularly when you
bundle them like this
But you're saying here that
this is going to be ten, 15 meters?
Ten, 12 meters, yes, yes
Okay
Eric arrived with just the
4,000-year-old tablet details
Now he has the
beginnings of a design
for his large Babylonian coracle
But many obstacles remain,
beginning with where to build
I'd love to build it in Iraq,
but considering
the logistical issues
and the security issues as
well, um, it's not realistic here
So the question
is where if not Iraq?
Another question is
how credible is the tablet
in describing the flood?
Today, this region is desert
How likely is it that a great
flood could have inundated
this parched landscape
thousands of years ago
as the Babylonian
myth describes?
This is one of the places
that gave birth to that legend,
home of first the Sumerian,
then Babylonian Empires...
The ancient city of Ur
Just 20 miles from
the great marshes,
Ur dates back more
than 5,000 years
It's here in 1928
that British archaeologist
Sir Charles Leonard Woolley
made a startling discovery
In 1922, Woolley and
his team came in search
of early Mesopotamian
civilization
He found remains of
an entire royal dynasty,
a testament to the
sophistication and power
of the Sumerian elite
And then, he made an
equally stunning discovery
A distinctive layer of
river silt ten feet thick
It had been laid down
by a massive flood
The grandson of a
member of Woolley's team
relates how the discovery
evoked the biblical story of Noah
They found layer of
sand to the south of Ur,
north of Ur,
and east and west
That mean that
happen a big flood
and they thought that is
the same flood of
Noah, the great man,
the great prophet at that time
This connection to Noah's flood
made the layer of sand more
famous than Ur's treasures
Especially when other
archaeologists began finding
flood deposits in neighboring
cities like Uruk, Shuruppak,
and Kish
The idea of a single
great flood grew
But there was a problem
When the layers were dated,
they were found to be
caused by different events,
spread over a thousand years
So was there ever
really a single great flood?
Landscape archaeologist
Dr Jenny Pournelle
is looking for the answer
For over a decade, Jenny
has been investigating
how the landscape of Iraq has
changed over thousands of years
Today she is taking
a core sample,
part of a series that
covers a broad area
She's digging 68
miles south of Ur,
in a marshland that was
recently drained for oil exploitation
It's a chance for her to get a
piece of uncontaminated earth,
essential for accurate dating
You can see
this light, light grey
silt, and these little guys
are very typical of freshwater
marshes around here
It means that our core
will have been protected
by this marsh cover until
recently when it was drained
This core will help reveal if
ancient Mesopotamia was impacted
by a cataclysmic flood
This should be
something like year zero
And that may be 1,000 BC
And if we're lucky,
right about here is when
your ark tablet was written
So what does this sample show?
They open it to see
We've got layers,
quite clear ones
See that nice orange sediment?
It would suggest
that there was a river
that periodically flooded
and deposited sediment
Evidence from cores like this
indicates that in ancient times,
Mesopotamia was
criss-crossed by rivers and canals
that flooded constantly
Every year there
are two floods...
One in the spring,
one in the fall
As cities first grew,
floods were part of
not just a natural cycle
but an essential cycle
They were profoundly
dependent on the marshes
and all of the
wealth of products
that came out of them...
Food for themselves,
food for livestock,
trade, commerce
Ur was one of many cities
that arose in this water world
The Euphrates River
was its life source
It delivered fertile
soil, fish, and wildfowl
But it could also bring disaster
The Tigris, the Euphrates
also had super floods every
ten years, every hundred years,
every thousand years
When we have the first
recorded stories of the flood myth,
the cities where these
were being written down
are exactly in that
precarious position
They created around
them fragile environments
With the right amount of water,
they can be
incredibly productive
and incredibly wealthy
But with the wrong
amount of water,
the very irrigation works they
need to produce that wealth
are blown away
Everyone has a vested
interest in this flood story
Everyone knows that it
makes or breaks their careers,
their livelihood
That would be the
power of the flood myth
in this part of the world
So it wasn't a single great
flood that inspired the myths,
but centuries of
periodic flooding
And would a large round boat
have helped these ancient people
to survive these floods?
The boat building team
is trying to figure out
if it could even
have been built at all
They found a place to
build their Babylonian coracle
in southern India,
where they can access the
materials listed in the tablet,
and the skills to
put them together
Construction begins on
the shore of Lake Vembanad
The fibrous plants
they will use for the hull
will be reeds from
a nearby marsh
Some of the 16 5 tons
of wood they will need
arrives at the boatyard
They've settled on
the size of their ark...
About 40 feet in diameter,
just a fifth the size of the
ark described in the tablet
But at 40 feet, it
will weigh 35 tons...
Right at the limit of what
they believe the materials
and the ancient
techniques will stand
Once the ark is in the water,
the bottom will flex,
straining the frame,
possibly causing it to break
The bigger the ark,
the bigger the pressure
The largest quffas
that I'm aware of
may be six meters
This we're pushing beyond that
It's actually eight times
as big as a six-meter one
So we're increasing the forces
we have to contend
with exponentially
To hold the frame
together, they will reinforce it,
combining basic engineering
with known Babylonian
carpentry techniques
The Ark Tablet states that
the flood vessel has 30 ribs
They lock these
ribs in a latticework
Tensioned bands will hold
the tops of the ribs together
The deck layer will
add further rigidity
And a forest of stanchions
will prevent the bottom
from collapsing upwards
Maybe it's all going to
fall apart, who knows?
But maybe it will
succeed and we'll think,
"Ah, we could have
pushed it a little bit more!"
The ark will contain more
than 800 pieces of wood
in 6,000 individual connections,
cut and shaped
using traditional tools
There will be no metal,
modern sealant or adhesive
As instructed by the
tablet, the team also begins
to bind reeds into tightly
packed lengths of rope
They'll need a mile and a
half to cover the entire hull
You have this little coil
that then starts spiraling out
The idea is that you
can gradually create
a gigantic basket,
basically made of grass
As the beginning of the
reed coil is lashed into place,
they turn their attention to
the next major challenge:
waterproofing
The tablet calls for
natural bitumen...
Which doesn't exist in India,
but is found oozing
out of the ground in Iraq
Natural bitumen
has unique impurities,
which make it adhesive
and resistant to heat
Alessandro, the team's expert
in ancient boat technology,
needs to re-create
these properties,
starting with refined
industrial bitumen
He adds animal fat and fish oil
to make it sticky,
and lime powder made
from burnt lake shells
to give it heat tolerance
Getting the balance of these
ingredients right is critical
If you put too much lime
powder it will get very hard,
it will resist at
high temperature,
but it won't stick
If you put too much
fish oil or animal fat,
it will stick easily
It's getting more dense
but it will melt under
the sun basically
Put it down
Alessandro's cooking
skills will determine
whether the ark
will float or not
Up, like this
They've given themselves
six months to build,
the recorded gap
between seasonal floods
in ancient Mesopotamia
Then, they'll face the
greatest challenge of all:
getting the ark into the lake
A boat usually has a keel
that can support it as
it slides into the water
A round boat has no keel
And this one will be covered
in a fragile layer of bitumen
You cannot drag the
boat on the ground,
you cannot pull it
The bitumen layer
is extremely delicate,
it's very soft, and you
don't want it damaged,
because it's the
only, basically, layer
that keeps the
whole boat waterproof
Without the bitumen,
the boat won't float
How would the Babylonians
have launched the boat?
The Ark Tablet doesn't say
The hero, Atra Hasis,
simply waits for the flood
It is one of the big questions,
sort of a burning
question of, you know,
if a boat this large could
actually have been built,
unless there was a
flood it would have been
incredibly difficult to launch
A vessel like this could
have meant survival
in a world of constant flooding
But at some point, those
floods become mythologized
into a single great deluge
and real coracles are turned
into a single
giant ark of legend
And somehow that
legend of the round ark
becomes the familiar boat
shape in the story of Noah
How does such
a transition occur?
The answer lies in a great
innovation of the ancient world:
cuneiform writing
Originally all these
stories circulated orally
And around 2000 BC,
we see for the first
time that these narratives
became reduced to writing
And from that moment
they are fixed rigidly
So you have an established
text which all the scribes copy
And in the process of
copying, errors creep in
Irving Finkel believes
one of these errors
changes the shape of the ark
The Ark Tablet, dated
around 1750 BCE...
4,000 years old...
Places the round
ark inside a square
to help define its dimensions
By 700 BCE, the Atra Hasis
flood tale has been absorbed
into a more famous story,
the exploits of a hero king
in The Epic of Gilgamesh.
But here, scribes omit
the mention of the circle
We have these later
scribes who have an old text
They look at it and they decide,
"Well, all this technical
stuff, we don't need it,"
and they don't read the
thing very carefully at all
because in the description
about how round it was,
they miss the point
As a result,
according to Irving,
the Gilgamesh ark has
a very strange shape
So it's like a
kind of skyscraper
What would happen if
you put that in the sea?
It would sink, wouldn't it?
Especially if it
was full of animals
It's absolutely hopeless
Over time, the
mythical ark loses touch
with the reality
that likely inspired it
It sets off on a
literary journey,
changing with
new interpretations
There is a rather
ironic consequence
You have the possibility of
an error being consolidated,
copied and recopied until
nobody thinks about it anymore
and they just
take it for granted
And that is surely what
happened with the shape of the ark
It eventually adopts
the boat shape we know
in the story of Noah
And the rest of the
story changes too
Almost 2,000 years after
the first Babylonian version,
the flood story is found
outside Mesopotamia,
in the Hebrew Bible
There's just no way
of explaining the story
in Genesis except as a borrowing
The question is,
when, how and why?
It's long been assumed that
trade and cultural exchange
bring the Babylonian
story to ancient Israel
But this doesn't explain why
biblical writers adopt the tale
and give it a moral twist
In the Mesopotamian myth,
pagan gods are
disturbed by human noise
and use the flood to
reduce their numbers
But in the book of Genesis,
the flood is a disaster
that God uses to punish
people for their sins
The Noah story serves
to provide a platform
of understanding
for all future disasters
It is the ultimate disaster
It was not just
natural disasters
that were attributed to God,
it was also historical disasters
The history of the people
to be known as Jews
is filled with disasters that
are reflected in the Bible
But many experts believe
there is one in particular
which provides an
explanation for the story of Noah
The Babylonian destruction
of Jerusalem in 587 BCE
A consequence of the
Judean kingdom's failure
to pay tribute
If somebody is not
paying their taxes,
not paying tribute as
they're supposed to,
you have to make
an example of them,
so you need to come
in and show the world
what your power is
capable of enforcing
Several thousand Judeans...
The educated and the
powerful of ancient Israel...
Were marched about
1,000 miles to Babylon
The Babylonians needed manpower
They had fields that
needed to be cultivated
and craftsmen that
needed to be imported
to make the tremendous
buildings and other things
that they did, so you
imported manpower
to do those kinds of things
I think for a lot of people
there probably was a sense
that this is the end of
the world as we know it
"Our tormentors
demanded songs of joy
"They said, 'Sing us
one of the songs of Zion!'
"But how can we sing
the songs of the Lord
while in a foreign land?"
Psalm 137:3 and 4
Yet this traumatic uprooting
brought the Judeans
into direct contact
with Babylonian culture
And that would shape
the destiny of their scripture
and the story of Noah
One of the greatest
collections of Babylonian relics
in the world is found here,
at the Pergamon Museum in Berlin
It includes a reconstruction
of the entrance to Babylon
The newly arrived Judeans
would have walked through this gate
On the other side was a world
they could scarcely
have imagined
In the sixth century BCE,
Babylon was the most
cosmopolitan city on earth
But what was the
Judean experience?
Dr Cornelia Wunsch is an expert
in Neo-Babylonian culture
She has evidence
suggesting exile in Babylon
wasn't as bad as the
Judeans might have feared
They have been allotted land
and they are tilling the
land, building houses
and they are doing
reasonably well there
It may have been
awful at the beginning
and nobody
wanted to be in exile,
but very quickly,
things got good
Judea made it after
one or two generations
They were well ensconced
into the Babylonian economies
They did well
- A - Babylonian-style
personal seal
of a Judean merchant
named Arricam
suggests how assimilated
some Judeans were
in this new society
He certainly led
a dual existence
Arricam is clearly
showing himself
as a person of Judean
descent, but on the other hand
as a typical Babylonian
businessman
Many Judeans in Babylon
were well integrated
into Babylonian culture
But they also preserved
their own traditions
This was the case
for Judean scribes,
who were editing
traditional stories and prayers
and writing new ones
that would ultimately
become the Hebrew Bible
These priestly
authors, obviously,
had the exile on their minds
And one of the most
significant aspects of this event
was the formation of the Bible
It began in Babylon
Some of these books were already
in process but seem to have been
shaped by the
experience of the exile
In the center of Babylon
is a giant ziggurat
In the book of Genesis it
becomes the ultimate symbol
of human folly...
The Tower of Babel
For Irving Finkel,
this borrowing is
just one of many
In collaboration with the
Archaeological Institute
in Berlin, he examines
extraordinary evidence
that links some elements
of Babylonian literature
with the beginnings
of the Hebrew Bible
One is the story of King
Sargon, who was cast adrift
by his mother in a round basket
to save him from
being discovered
She made a little ark
out of reeds and bitumen
and she put the baby in this
ark and she put the ark in the river
and away it went
Now, this is a story which has
a certain familiar ring about it
from the book of
Exodus point of view
because Moses was
given the same kind of origin
There's also a list
of Babylonian kings
before the flood,
very similar to Adam's genealogy
described in the book of Genesis
But the most amazing
piece of evidence is written
on a Babylonian school
tablet... A retelling of Gilgamesh,
the epic poem that
contains the flood story
What does it tell us?
It tells us that you have
at this time in Babylonia,
schoolrooms where
the Gilgamesh story,
undoubtedly including the
flood story, was on the curriculum
Could Judean children have
read these same stories?
A detail in the Bible's book
of Daniel suggests they did
According to the story,
Daniel was the son of an
exiled Judean nobleman
In Babylon, the Bible
says, he and his friends
were taught to read cuneiform
Just as these children discover,
learning cuneiform isn't hard
It would have made
Babylonian stories easy to absorb
These kids suddenly
find themselves
learning these very narratives
which seem to us the
essential Babylonian narratives
that ended up embedded
in Judean Hebrew
The idea that it was Judeans
in Babylonian captivity
who learned cuneiform
and adopted the flood story
is to me the only decent
explanation that you can have
If this theory is correct,
stories like Noah and the Flood
were widespread
in Babylonian culture
and absorbed into
Judean scripture
They would eventually
become the moral teaching
for three great faiths
But not until the Judeans
emerged from exile
In India, the Babylonian
ark is almost complete
And unlike the Babylonians...
Who would have just waited
for the floodwaters to rise...
The building team has had
to find a way to launch the ark
without dragging its fragile
hull across the ground
We have two rails running
straight underneath the ark
into the water
So on top of these rails,
we are going to put rollers
And then on top of the rollers,
we're going to have
another set of runners
And then sitting on
top of these runners,
we have the launch platform
And then on top of the platform
Is the ark
Once she's all ready go,
basically just
roll into the lake
It's a traditional boat
launching technique
But they've had to resort
to modern machinery
to build the launch platform
Once in the water,
the platform will sink,
leaving the coracle
to float away
Except, as things stand,
it probably won't
Alessandro's version
of Babylonian bitumen
is melting and dropping off
It's quite catastrophic
at this stage
Once we launch the
boat, the water can push
through the gaps and holes
and then we're going
to have a major leak
Just before launch, the
ark is still not waterproof
In 539 BCE,
over 50 years in exile,
the Judeans were
allowed to return home
They began rebuilding
the Israel of old,
with a new temple and
a single text, the Torah
One of the most
remarkable things
about ancient Israelite
religion is that it survives
The Babylonians
conquered Jerusalem
But the exiles from
Jerusalem did not give up belief
in their God
The Babylonian flood myth is
now retold as a moral lesson
In some ways, it's a
metaphor for the exile
The foreign agent
comes, punishes,
as a tool of God's wrath
There's a cataclysm to
be survived by a select few
And for them, the
promise of a new beginning
is echoed in the Noah story
"God blessed Noah and
his sons, saying to them,
"" Be fruitful and increase
in number and fill the earth
"" I establish my
covenant with you
"" Never again will
all life be destroyed
by the waters of a flood ""
Genesis 9:1 and 11
This covenant defines
man's relationship with God
and marks the birth of Judaism
The great Israeli scholar
Yehezkel Kaufmann said,
"The exile is the watershed
"With the exile, the religion
of Israel comes to an end
and Judaism begins"
This is the moment
at which the history
of the Jewish people begins
Not at the beginning of time,
but after the flood
In India, Irving's theory
that the legend was based
on an authentic
boat-building tradition
is about to be put to the test
The big question is
Alessandro's bitumen recipe
Will it work?
For Irving, the culmination
of years of translation,
study and investigation
is this moment
I can hardly believe my eyes!
Amazing
After all this imagination,
it's really here in
the flesh so to speak
It's incredible,
it's incredible!
The ark is raised
on inflatable rollers
On its launch platform,
it begins its journey
down to the lake
Alessandro is standing by to
plug any leaks from the outside
But before he can,
a roller slips free,
pitching the ark in the water
Start pulling!
Below decks, it's clear
their non-Babylonian
waterproof mix isn't working
So we are now floating,
which is the good news
The potentially
bad news, however,
is that we have a
heck of a lot of water
coming in at the moment
They had hoped to
get animals on board
But right now they're
consumed with saving the ark
They plug the gaps and put
a collection of pumps to work
By the time Irving
climbs on board,
the problem is under control
Welcome aboard
Thank you!
I'm proud to be here
How wonderful, how
absolutely wonderful!
The boat-building
team never managed
to duplicate Babylonian bitumen,
but the structure
of the ark is sound
At the root of the
story may have been
a flood vessel like this one
Behind the legend
of a great flood
were thousands of real floods
And behind the
myth of a giant ark
is a genuine tradition
of round boat building
All this from a
Babylonian tablet...
A story that emerged
4,000 years ago
It continues to resonate today
as one of the world's
most enduring tales