Nova (1974–…): Season 41, Episode 10 - Inside Animal Minds: Who's the Smartest? - full transcript
From PBS - What makes an animal smart? Many scientists believe the secret lies in relationships. Throughout the animal kingdom, some of the cleverest creatures -- including humans -- seem to be those who live in complex social groups, like dolphins, elephants and apes. Could the skills required to keep track of friend and foe make animals smarter? To find out, NOVA goes inside the social lives of some of the smartest animals on the planet.
What are they thinking?
Oh, look at that face!
Is there any way to get inside
the animal mind?
What I really want to know is
what is it like to be an animal,
what are the problems
they have to solve,
and how do they think,
and are they like us
or are they like something
totally different?
They have some amazing abilities
Is it instinct, training
or something else?
Cutting-edge animal science
reveals new answers
We put different species
to the test
in search of the roots
of animal intelligence
Who are the best
problem solvers?
Who wins the battle
of the super senses?
In this episode,
what makes an animal smart?
Up until a million years ago,
the brainiest species
were dolphins and whales
What can we learn from their
language, relationships,
even emotions?
If you start giving
one of them grapes,
then the one who gets cucumber
becomes very upset
Are they more like us
than we ever thought possible?
We're not the only species
that has soap operas going on
every day in their lives
"Inside Animal Minds:
Who's the Smartest?"
Right now on NOVA.
Which animals are the smartest?
And how did they get this way?
Dolphins have long been hailed
as the cleverest creatures
in the sea
There's no doubt
they're quick learners
And in captivity,
they can be trained
to perform stunning tricks
Not only can they follow
hand signals
but they can even learn
the meaning of written symbols
Why would a mammal that spends
most of its time underwater
and has flippers
instead of hands
have these kinds of skills?
Throughout the animal kingdom,
you can find creatures
with extraordinary talents:
elephants with impressive
memories,
birds that solve
complicated puzzles
and tool-making chimpanzees
They inhabit
utterly different worlds
and come in a wide variety
of shapes and sizes
But is it possible
that these animals
could all get their smarts
in similar ways?
Because whether they walk,
swim or fly,
the cleverest animals on earth,
including us humans,
seem to have one thing
in common:
we live in groups
So could social living
be the key
to creating the most
powerful minds?
Around the world,
animal researchers
are trying to find out
And this is one
of their favorite subjects
Everyone knows that dolphins
can put on incredible shows
But their greatest performances
take place far from the crowds
because here in the wild,
these animals execute
the most amazing tricks
when they work as a team
In these shallow waters
off the coast of Florida,
dolphins band together to get
the better of fast-moving fish
Here's how their trickery works
One dolphin swims in a circle
It whips up a wall
of muddy water,
corralling any fish inside
Three other dolphins wait
just outside the ring of mud
As the fish try to leap out
of the muddy ring and escape,
they jump right into the open
mouths of the waiting dolphins
Soon, a dolphin swings around
again to create another corral
They seem in perfect synch,
as if they've planned
every move together
But what's really going on?
Are they strategizing and
communicating with each other
the way we would?
Or are they simply
drawn together on the hunt
by pure instinct?
One big reason to suspect
that something more complex
is going on is this:
the dolphin brain
When you look at the size
of most animal brains,
there's usually
a pretty direct link
to the size of their bodies
The bigger the body,
the bigger the brain
But some animals
defy expectations
Humans have much more
gray matter
than other animals our size
So do chimps and whales
And so do dolphins
So how did their brains get big?
The $6 million question
has always been,
why do dolphins and whales
have such large brains?
Neuroscientist Lori Marino is
trying to answer that question
by hunting down
some very ancient clues
She travels
all over the country,
studying fossils to trace the
evolution of the dolphin brain
One of the things that we wanted
to find out
with this research
was exactly when they got
their large brains
Here at the Smithsonian
Institution,
she and her colleague Mark Uhen
are examining fossil skulls
of the dolphin's
ancient ancestors:
early whales called archaeocetes
Some archaeocetes were huge,
ferocious predators
with gigantic teeth
Compared to modern dolphins,
their bodies were massive
Growing up to 55 feet long,
in their day,
nearly 40 million years ago,
they were the biggest animals
on Earth
Today, examining fossil skulls
of early whales,
Lori is trying to estimate
the size of the brains
that once sat inside
In ancient fossils, the space
where the brain was housed
is often filled with sediment
But a CT scan can see
through the sediment
and reveal the exact dimensions
We were absolutely thrilled
to see the results of the study
because it gave us information
no one had before
When Lori examines the CT scans
of this giant killer's skull,
she discovers
not everything was big
This animal had a very big body
and a very small brain
But a few million years later,
things started to change
Something happened,
and what we see is a shift
When Lori looks at more recent
dolphin ancestors,
dating to about
30 million years ago,
she discovers, in evolutionary
terms, a fairly sudden shift
Bodies and teeth shrank,
but at the same time,
brains got bigger
The brain of the early dolphins
and whales increased in size,
sometimes manyfold
The dolphin brain got big
and stayed that way
In fact, for millions of years,
until early humans came along,
the dolphin had the most
powerful brain on the planet
Up until about
a million years ago,
the brainiest species
on the planet were not primates;
they were dolphins and whales
And we are just a very recent
kid on the block
The question is,
why did the brain change?
Everyone would like to know
why there was this shift
in relative brain size
with dolphins
It really is a mystery
It suggests that they embarked
on a very different evolutionary
path than their ancestors
Lori thinks that path
was a social one
No longer giant, toothy beasts,
individuals could increase
their chances for survival
by joining forces
Perhaps they needed
to hunt together,
to band together
against predators,
so these new animals were
smaller and not as formidable
They kind of needed each other
Today, more than 30 different
kinds of dolphins swim the seas,
including
the bottlenose dolphin,
the spotted dolphin
and the orca, or killer whale,
the largest of all dolphins
Most live in groups, or pods,
usually of a few dozen
individuals
Sometimes, pods will come
together, forming a mega-pod
numbering in the hundreds
or thousands
It seems clear that today's
dolphins need each other,
but why would they need
big brains, too?
To find out, we need to dive
deep into the dolphin world
Here, in the Caribbean waters
near the island of Bimini
Okay, Al, we're ready
when you are!
Researchers Kathleen Dudzinski
and Kelly Melillo Sweeting
have spent years tracking
wild spotted dolphins,
carefully observing and
recording their interactions,
trying to decipher the secrets
of dolphin society
Today, the scientists encounter
a gathering of dolphins
swimming together
There are about 16,
of mixed sexes and ages
What we definitely saw was a
socializing group of dolphins
They were interacting, playing,
they were affectionate
with one another
By observing these dolphins
year after year,
researchers are beginning
to get a clearer picture
of what dolphin society
is really like
Compared to many land mammals,
dolphin society is extremely
complex and dynamic,
and many of the relationships
they form might surprise you
The only connection that follows
a predictable pattern
is the one between a mother
and her calf
Among spotted dolphins,
the two will stay together
for about three years,
until the youngster is weaned
After that, almost anything goes
Males and females who mate don't
form long-term relationships
But sometimes adult females do
and help each other out
with babysitting duties
"White Blotch"
was one adult female
that we saw very consistently
for ten years,
and she was notorious
as what appeared to be
a babysitter
She'd come to the boat
with her own calf
and she'd have two or three
extras in tow
And we know they only have
one calf at a time,
so it was a very clear example
of that babysitting
and taking turns
And it's not just the females
who form close relationships
and collaborate
to make life easier
Male dolphins compete
with one another to find mates,
but sometimes two or three males
will form an alliance
to work together, to hunt
and to attract females
Often these relationships
last for many years,
even entire lifetimes
I do believe that dolphins
have friendships and favorites
and that their social
interactions
are developing the friendships
that they might have
that might last a lifetime
Those in close relationships
keep in touch... literally...
By tapping each other's
pectoral fins
But even if they're in some kind
of alliance or friendship,
dolphins like these will
regularly mingle with others
This flexible social structure
is known as
a "fission-fusion" society
Human society
is also fission-fusion
During an average day,
we will move
from small family groups
to larger groups of colleagues
to mid-size gatherings
of friends
Dolphins form
all sorts of relationships,
just like we do
And they change over time
It's a complicated
and bustling social world
And it's this social complexity
that some scientists think
could hold the key to the
evolution of bigger brains
When you're a social animal,
there's a lot that you need
to keep track of
There's all kinds
of relationships,
all kinds of interactions,
hierarchies,
collaborations that may occur
There's a very nice relationship
between social complexity
that you observe
in a species organization
and the size of their brain
So how do dolphins
use their big brains
to navigate their social lives?
Is it possible
that some of that brain
is powering a complex system
of communication?
After all, whenever
dolphins get together,
the water can get very noisy
Dolphins make
all kinds of sounds:
fast-paced clicks
that sound like a creaky door
Loud outbursts that resemble
squawking birds
And high-pitched whistles
For decades, researchers
have been trying to figure out
what it all means
But in the 1960s,
one controversial scientist
took an alternative approach
Neuroscientist John Lilly
was convinced that dolphins
were much more intelligent than
people had previously thought
John Lilly was
a neurophysiologist
who was the first
to really suggest
that dolphins might be
highly intelligent
He was the first to really
sort of light the fire
and get a lot of us interested
He talked about them
as humans of the sea
And I just want to talk
to such ancient characters
and find out, you know,
if they have any wisdom for us
Rather than deciphering
their language,
Lilly decided the quickest route
to communicating with dolphins
would be to teach one of them
how to speak English
And he set out to do just that,
with one of the strangest
animal experiments ever devised
John Lilly did an experiment
that involved building
a dolphin house
And what he did was
he bought property
and he flooded the first floor
so the dolphin could actually
live in this first floor area
With the dolphin, named Peter,
living in less than
four feet of water,
it wasn't a very humane approach
But the idea was to keep Peter
in close contact
with his teacher
He actually had a woman
living there with the dolphin
in a very intense time,
where she tried to teach
this dolphin English
The young woman
was Margaret Howe,
and she lived, ate and slept
here for two and a half months,
trying to teach Peter every day
This is a sound recording
of Margaret counting while
Peter attempts to imitate her
One, two, three, four, five.
One, two, three,
four, five, six.
It's safe to say
the dolphin house experiment
was both unethical
and a complete failure
What the dolphins did
was not English
They could imitate the numbers
of syllables they were hearing,
but they couldn't
formulate English
They don't have the same kind of
articulatory system we have
In spite of its shortcomings,
Lilly's work
got a lot of attention
and inspired the Hollywood film
The Day of the Dolphin.
What do you know
about linguistics?
The fictional scientist,
played by George C Scott,
seemed to have better luck
teaching his dolphin
to count "one, two, three"
in English
than John Lilly ever did
One
Two
Three!
For real-life scientists,
Lilly's work
showed that any idea
of teaching dolphins human
language was probably a fantasy
Today, researchers are focused
intently on trying to decipher
the dolphin's own system
of communication,
and they've been using
underwater microphones
to record all those clicks,
squawks and whistles,
hoping to find patterns
and discover
what they actually mean
But there's a problem
Dolphins make sounds underwater
by vibrating tissues
in their nasal cavities,
a bit like the way we humans
vibrate our vocal cords
They usually don't
open their mouths
or make any visible signs
Dolphins are essentially
ventriloquists
They produce sound
and you can't see anything
Nothing changes
on their facial expression,
or even their blowholes
So they can be making sounds
without moving,
and you have no idea
who made the sound
But now researchers have come up
with a pioneering new technique
to listen in
on dolphin conversations
We're going out today
to try to find wild dolphins
and attach tags to them
Biologist Vincent Janik
is on a quest
to eavesdrop on wild dolphins
and try to decipher
the dolphin communication code
They are little recording tags
that can give us information
about their sounds
that they're making
and also give us information
about their behavior
as they're in the bay,
their own wild environment
Today, a bottlenose dolphin's
been captured in shallow water
Are you going to put
the acoustic on?
The researchers work rapidly to
minimize distress to the animal
To solve the problem
of capturing the exact sounds
made by a particular dolphin,
Vincent's team uses suction cups
to attach a recording device
directly to the animal's head
It's small enough
for a dolphin to ignore
Nicholas, Nicholas, get signal?
Roger that
Okay
If it were uncomfortable,
the dolphin could easily use
the seabed to knock it off
It will now record all the
sounds that the dolphin makes
and, using GPS, will keep track
of its movements
The dolphin's released
and soon joins some other
tagged dolphins
The scientists will
constantly observe them
so later they'll be able
to match their behavior
to the sounds they're making
What's going on over there?
There's lots of splashing
I think that's a dorsal fin
Yeah, they're two dolphins
What we can look at is
what the animal's doing...
Whether it's traveling,
whether it's foraging,
whether it's socializing
with others
Those kinds of things
we can observe from the surface
After a few hours, the devices
fall off on their own
and float to the surface
so the team can retrieve them
and begin analyzing
the dolphin's sounds
At first hearing,
it's a cacophony:
a whole range of dolphin clicks,
whistles and pulses
Today, we know that
the creaky-door clicks
are the sounds dolphins use
for echolocation
They work like sonar pings
Dolphins listen for the echoes
of the clicks
as they bounce off objects
in their environment
This plays a crucial role in
helping them locate their prey
and navigate in murky water
But Vincent is interested in
other kinds of dolphin sounds:
the ones they use
for communication
Sometimes, there are patterns:
certain sounds consistently made
when a dolphin is doing
a particular action,
like this one
One sound that we've found
is the so-called bray sound,
which dolphins produce
when they find fish
And it's a sound that brings in
other dolphins as well
And when dolphins are
aggressive, playful or not,
they often produce
lower frequency sounds
known as burst pulses
These kinds of calls are common
in the animal kingdom
But there is one kind of sound
dolphins make
that is much more unusual
It's called
the signature whistle
Every dolphin
has its own signature whistle
that's different from all others
So within a population,
you have very,
very different whistles
for every animal
The function of the whistle
really is to broadcast
its identity
and also to stay in touch
with other group members
The closest
in our language perhaps
is really if I would say,
"I'm Vincent and I'm over here"
Dolphins have good vision,
but if the water is murky
or individuals get separated,
Vincent believes they use
signature whistles
to help keep a group together
If an animal gets lost,
it will also produce
that whistle
to try to make contact again,
and that's something
that we often see
between mothers and calves
When the calf wanders off
and is far away
and eventually wants to get back
to the mother,
what it does is it starts to
produce its signature whistle
It is rare for animals
to have unique calls
that correspond
to particular individuals,
but dolphins aren't
the only animals
to use vocal calls as a way
of identifying each other
One other animal
known to do this
inhabits a world
completely different
from the dolphins'
underwater domain
The Amboseli National Park
in Kenya
is home to some of the most
social animals on the planet:
elephants
KAREN McCOMB:
The thing about this park
that's outstanding is the
visibility of the elephants,
a population of more than
a thousand elephants,
which we know individually
Karen McComb has been observing
elephants here for decades,
trying to unlock the secrets
of elephant society
and communication
McCOMB:
It's being able
to get inside animal minds,
get into a social world
that's actually
rather different from ours
that will tell us what elephants
are really thinking
Elephant society is a family
affair, especially for females
They stay with their mothers,
sisters, aunts and cousins
for their entire lives
The oldest female,
known as the matriarch,
is the leader
Young males stick
with their mothers
until they're
about ten years old,
and then they leave the social
group to live independently
And elephants
are always on the move
Elephants have
this really unusual
and complex social system
So instead of just staying put
and communicating
with their immediate neighbors,
they sort of move
in relation to one another
in a very fluid,
fission-fusion way
Females and young males spend
time with lots of elephants
in groups of different sizes
And they communicate with dozens
of different kinds of calls
Some rumbles
are such low frequency
they're out of range
of human hearing,
but elephants can detect them
from miles away
Karen believes that their calls
are crucial
for the elephants to keep track
of friend and foe
McCOMB:
They'll come into contact
with many, many other families
as they move and feed,
and they will be
making decisions
about which families
it's safe to feed next to
and which they should avoid
To find out how elephants
make those decisions,
Karen designed an experiment
It involves years
of painstaking research
and some very powerful speakers
Karen has made a library
of elephant contact calls
and is going to play some
to a group of elephants
who are on the move
and see how they react
First, she plays a call
from an elephant
from a different group,
but a friendly one
The elephants
just keep on walking
and their behavior
doesn't change
But when Karen plays a call
from an elephant
they don't know well,
their behavior is very different
The elephants abruptly
stop their march
They turn toward
the unfamiliar voice,
gather closer together and move
directly toward the sound
in what Karen says
is a defensive show of force
Karen tested 21 families
and found that the elephants
consistently distinguished
between friend and stranger,
recognizing
up to 100 different voices
She believes that a lot
of their brain power and memory
is going into keeping track
of other elephants:
the ones they do and do not know
Who is safe to be around
and who might pose a threat?
And it could be the same with us
We have these relationships
that we need to maintain
throughout our lives
with friends and enemies
You have to remember
who owes you a favor
And that sort of complexity
seems to go hand in hand
with the evolution
of larger brains
It's not enough
to be simply social
The animal world
is full of social creatures,
and plenty of them have some
of the tiniest brains around
There's lots of different
kinds of social behavior
of social animals
Insects, for example,
termites and ants
are extremely social,
and they can't live
by themselves
They need each other
for everything that they do
Ants live in colonies, sometimes
with millions of members,
and divide labor
between workers and soldiers
The collective might of termites
can result in the construction
of huge, elaborate mounds
And social living,
along with an intricate
communication system,
is crucial to bees,
with tens of thousands
of individuals working together
to find food
and raise their young
All these animals
are highly social,
and together,
they can accomplish wonders
But each individual
has a miniscule brain
Ants are always essentially
working together
toward one goal:
to help each other out
to make the colony a success
Now, dolphins are on the other
end of the spectrum
Sometimes they cooperate,
sometimes they are competing
with each other
So when you enter this element
of both cooperating
and competing at the same time
in order to survive,
this new kind
of social complexity
and intelligence blossoms
Cooperation and competition,
side by side
This is the recipe for a really
complicated social life
And animals who live this way
often have big brains
But whether one leads
to the other is still unclear
Part of the challenge
for scientists is figuring out
how much animals like dolphins
might understand
about their social lives
Dolphin cognition expert
Diana Reiss
has spent years
trying to find out
She works with dolphins at the
National Aquarium in Baltimore
Keeping dolphins in captivity
is controversial,
and aquariums in the U S
haven't captured wild dolphins
for two decades
Diana believes
it's only in the controlled
environment of aquariums
that you can unlock some of the
secrets of the dolphin mind
Here, she can
carry out experiments
not possible in the wild
The aquarium has
an observation chamber,
nicknamed "The Pit"
It's cramped
But from here,
Diana has an excellent view
of the dolphins'
underwater behavior
This dolphin is making
bubble rings,
a behavior observed both
in captivity and in the wild
A dolphin blows out
an air bubble from its blowhole,
then flicks it with its tail
to create a ring shape
Bubble rings appear
to have no practical purpose,
except for entertainment
It's another dolphin behavior
we can relate to:
the ability to play
Diana wants to find out
what else we share
on an even more
fundamental level
She's investigating
whether dolphins
recognize themselves
as individuals
Do they each have
a sense of self?
Diana places a one-way mirror
inside the observation window
So now we're looking
through a window
and they'll be seeing a mirror
The dolphins can't see people
inside The Pit
All they see
are their own reflections
Dolphins don't behave like this,
staying in one place
and staring,
if they simply meet
another dolphin
Another extremely unusual action
is this curious fin wiggling
This looks nothing like
what they do
when they're socially
interacting with another
They also look inside their
mouths or closely at their eyes
They perform all sorts
of odd behaviors
much like we might do
in front of a mirror
to see what we look like
when we do that new dance step
or when we just want to see
how we look in a new outfit
They seem to be using the mirror
like a tool
to see parts of their bodies
that are usually out of view
This all supports the idea
that dolphins must be aware
they're looking at themselves
Dolphins share this ability to
recognize themselves in a mirror
with just a few other animals
Elephants do it
So do chimpanzees
But the vast majority,
including dogs, don't
And interestingly,
neither do young humans
Before they're 18 months old,
most children fail to point out
a red dot painted on their cheek
This boy assumes
he's looking at another child
Only when they're about two
does a child first realize
that the mark
is on her own cheek
and she knows the reflection
is of herself
Eventually, a human child's
self-awareness
will go far beyond recognizing
her own body in a mirror
She'll be aware
of her own thoughts
and be able to contemplate
the thoughts of others
But is the same true for other
animals, like dolphins?
Diana thinks it might be
Having a sense of self
would go hand in hand,
I could say flipper to flipper,
with complex understanding
of others
So if animals like dolphins
recognize themselves
as individuals,
how much do they understand
about the other creatures
around them?
It's a question debated
by animal researchers
The big question is not,
"Do animals think?"
The big question is, "Do they
think about others thinking?"
"Thinking about others thinking"
is something we humans do
all the time
As humans, we are remarkable
because we can imagine
what it's like,
in some context,
to be someone else
That's an amazing ability
that we see in humans
This ability we have
to imagine what it's like
to be another person
is known as "theory of mind"
The theory of mind is the idea
that all humans normally develop
an understanding
that other people have
different minds than our own:
that what I know is different
than what you know
and that what I want
is different than what you want
And that's a big question
for animal researchers:
whether any non-human animal
also eventually, or at all,
develops a theory of mind
It's extremely difficult
to prove that an animal "thinks"
about other animals' "thoughts,"
but some of the most interesting
research has been done
with our closest relatives:
the chimpanzees
Primatologist Frans de Waal
works with chimpanzees
at the Yerkes Primate Center
in Atlanta
When an animal like a chimp
is aware that another chimp
has a different perspective
on the world,
it could give it an advantage
Chimpanzee groups have a strict
ranking system
At the very top
is the most powerful chimp:
the alpha male
He's in charge of the group,
and every other chimp has
a position of rank below him,
from the most dominant
to the most subordinate
Frans has set up
an interesting experiment
to find out how
a low-ranking animal behaves
when it gets
valuable information
that a more dominant member
does not know
Could one chimp
actively deceive another?
Most studies that are
on deception
are observational,
anecdotal studies
But nowadays,
we do experiments also on it,
and so you can,
for example, hide food
One chimp knows where it is,
the other one doesn't know
where it is,
and then you can see if
deception goes on between them
The experiment involves
two chimps: Rita and Missy
Rita is the more dominant
At the start of the experiment,
the chimps are
in their sleeping quarters
One of the keepers goes
into the outdoor enclosure
and hides a banana
under the red tube
Missy is allowed to watch
through a window,
so she sees the keeper
hide the banana
Rita can see Missy watching
through the window,
but she can't see
what's going on outside
Then they let the chimps out
Rita, the dominant chimp,
comes out first
If she knew where
the banana was hidden,
she'd simply help herself
But only Missy, the subordinate,
saw the banana being placed
under the red tube
Rita just saw Missy watching
So the two have very
different perspectives
on the same situation
Missy notices Rita
close to the food
and sits on top of the tube
She seems to be playing it cool
Rita now wanders off
When she's far enough away,
Missy goes for the banana
Frans believes that Missy
has successfully deceived Rita
He's observed
this kind of behavior in chimps,
but it's rare in other animals
So if animals
can deceive others,
what would that say
about their minds?
When we think about deception,
you have to sort of understand
the rules of the game
Deception is manipulating
the rules of the game,
so a highly social animal
who understands
the rules of the game
and then changes it somehow
for its own benefit
or to make a joke, perhaps,
or to achieve something
shows a level of sophistication
We humans are very good at it
So, are the most successful
animals natural born liars?
If you live in a complex
social group,
you're competing against others
who eat the same thing you do,
who mate
with the same individuals
that you might
want to mate with,
so if you can somehow manipulate
the behavior of others,
then you're going
to have potentially
a competitive advantage
But social living is not
just about lies and deceit
Deception can only get you
so far
There's a big disadvantage
to deception
and that's why it is not
so often used,
is that if I do that too often
to you, you may catch on
and at some point,
you don't trust me anymore
Frans believes that primates,
as they negotiate
their social lives,
are very aware
of the competition
And so he's come up
with another experiment,
this one to test
their sense of justice
Do they realize if they're
being treated fairly or not,
compared to others?
Normally, you would think
the only thing an animal
should care about is,
"What do I get for my task?
I work, I get rewards"
But no, they're comparing with
what the other one is getting
Frans begins the fairness test
with the capuchin monkey
These small, clever animals
are kept in large enclosures,
but for the short duration
of the test,
they're in a lab area
Each monkey carries out
a simple task:
they have to give a small stone
to the experimenter
in exchange for a reward
When both get a reward
of cucumber, everyone's happy
But watch what happens
when the one on the right
receives a grape reward instead
FRANS de WAAL:
If you start giving
one of them grapes,
which are far better
than cucumber,
then the one who gets cucumber
becomes very upset
and becomes agitated...
Emotionally agitated
It turns out
quite a few creatures,
including ravens and dogs,
will protest if they get
the short end of the stick,
as if they know that they're
being treated unfairly
But what about a concern
for injustice for the other guy?
Research with one
of our closest relatives,
a highly social chimp
called a bonobo,
is revealing some surprises
At the Lola ya Bonobo orphanage
in the Congo,
animals spend most of their days
in the forest,
but come inside
for short periods of time
for experiments like this
One bonobo is inside
an enclosure
The door is locked and can only
be opened from the other side
Here, another bonobo...
A stranger...
Is given a delicious
pile of fruit
So what will she do?
We recently discovered
that bonobos can share
with strangers...
That they actually
will sacrifice their own food
for the opportunity to interact
with another bonobo
they've never met before
That's not something
that we thought
another species would do
When we think about nature
as red in tooth and claw,
that you would share
with somebody
you don't share any genes with,
that's not in your family,
they're not even in your group?
I thought that was something
that humans did
So the fact that a bonobo
does that is remarkable
It's the closest thing
that you can think of
to doing charity in animals
Among the most social animals,
there's growing evidence
for active concern
for the well-being of others
Recently, it was reported
that elephants
will console an animal
in distress
by gently touching it
with their trunks
And elephants do something else
which might demonstrate
powerful feelings of connection
to others of their species
Elephants,
through observational evidence,
seem to have a really
unusual interest
in the dead
of their own species,
either fresh carcasses or skulls
The very interesting thing
is actually
the interest seems to persist
after death
Karen McComb has devised
an experiment to find out more
She takes the skulls
of elephants killed by poachers
to make a miniature graveyard
in the path
of an approaching herd
Now she just observes
McCOMB:
Yep, I think
we've definitely got
the beginnings
of a reaction here
Some of the younger females
starting to respond
They've picked up a whiff
of the skulls
The male is swinging his trunk
towards the skulls
and the jawbones as well
A few animals, including chimps,
will be curious about the corpse
of a companion,
touching and investigating
the body
But only elephants
take an interest
in the skulls and bones
of their own kind
long after death
McCOMB:
We've got the females
clustering around the skull,
touching the jawbones
You see the way the ends
of the trunks are moist there?
That's enhancing the scent
that they're getting
You wouldn't see that
in any other species,
except for humans
To test whether
this intense response
was specific to elephant skulls
and not just a reaction
to a new object,
Karen has done
exactly the same thing
with skulls from other animals
McCOMB:
If you present elephants
with the skulls
of other large herbivores,
the biggest herbivores
you can get...
Rhino, buffalo skulls...
You do not get
that level of interest
Given the choice
between the three,
they make a beeline
for the elephant skull
And they're particularly
interested actually
in elephant ivory
That, they will spend a massive
amount of time investigating,
picking it up, carrying it off,
touching it
They are definitely able
to recognize,
distinguish the skulls
and other remains of elephants
from other species
This kind of behavior seems
very familiar to us humans
McCOMB:
Obviously, we are intensely
involved and interested in death
in the sense
that our relationships continue
beyond that,
and it's very interesting
that this highly social animal
seems to also have
a social interest
that extends beyond death
As we watch these elephants
gently touch the remains
of their dead,
it's impossible to know exactly
what is driving their curiosity
Or whether these animals
might be experiencing
emotions similar to what
we would feel, like grief
What scientists
like Karen do know
is that for highly
social creatures,
relationships are essential
for survival
So, with so much time
and brain power spent
reading social situations,
could these animals
be better prepared
to gauge an interaction
with another species?
One such interaction
was reported not long ago
in the waters near Hawaii,
where a group of divers
was swimming at night,
photographing manta rays
Unexpectedly, a lone dolphin
swims close to the divers
They notice that the dolphin is
tangled in a thin fishing line
and has a hook stuck in its fin
Without help,
he will probably perish
And it approaches this diver
as if it knows
that the diver can possibly
help out
And that's in fact
what the diver does:
very gently cuts away
the fishing line
It takes quite awhile
The dolphin actually
has to go up for air
and then come back down again
The entire process
takes about seven minutes
So the question is,
what was the dolphin thinking?
My guess is the dolphin
was just approaching the diver
and then probably figured out
that the diver
was intending to help
at that stage
So did it come
swimming out of the deep
to solicit a diver's help?
Probably not, but it certainly
was smart enough
to figure out that
the diver could help
once the diver started helping
When the fishing line has been
removed, he swims away
It is a remarkable encounter
between two species
Witnessing the behavior
of all these social animals,
it's hard not to connect...
To see some parallels
with our own complicated lives
Part of the experience
of being human as a species
is a bit lonely
And I think one
of the really fun things
about studying other animals
is over time,
we learn that actually,
we're not the only
really social species
We're not the only species
that has literally
soap operas going on
every day in their lives,
and we're not the only species
that has many of the same
problems we experience
Whether it's that,
"Oh, my gosh, I have to deal
with my family member
"who is driving me crazy,
but they're my family
so I have to support them,"
or, you know,
"Gosh, I have this friend
that I like to hang out with
but they keep taking
advantage of me,"
or the fact that,
"Oh, this guy who thinks
he's so much bigger than me
"and he can do
whatever he wants,
"I have to get
my friends together
and be nice to them
so they'll help me"
These are all things
that we experience together
with lots of other
social animals on the planet,
so I think it's not just trying
to understand
what the life
of animals are like
I think part of it is that
it makes us feel part of nature
and that we're not here alone
There are other animals
that experience things
that we also experience
And it could be that
these kinds of experiences,
these challenges we face
every day as social animals,
have played a key role
in the evolution
of bigger and smarter brains
Because in certain situations,
the creature who can
cleverly negotiate,
who can lend or extend
a helping hand,
is often the one with the best
chance of survival
I think we often
think about evolution
as always the biggest,
strongest,
most competitive individual
is the one that's going
to survive and reproduce
But I think we see
again and again
and again and again in evolution
that that's not the case at all
Other times,
what's going to be favored
is things that lead
to better cooperation
so that you can work together
to solve problems
you otherwise couldn't solve
on your own
And that requires tolerance
That requires actually
not dominance,
but sometimes
a lack of dominance
So when we study
a wide variety of species,
you see things beyond just "it's
always the big guy that wins"
Oh, look at that face!
Is there any way to get inside
the animal mind?
What I really want to know is
what is it like to be an animal,
what are the problems
they have to solve,
and how do they think,
and are they like us
or are they like something
totally different?
They have some amazing abilities
Is it instinct, training
or something else?
Cutting-edge animal science
reveals new answers
We put different species
to the test
in search of the roots
of animal intelligence
Who are the best
problem solvers?
Who wins the battle
of the super senses?
In this episode,
what makes an animal smart?
Up until a million years ago,
the brainiest species
were dolphins and whales
What can we learn from their
language, relationships,
even emotions?
If you start giving
one of them grapes,
then the one who gets cucumber
becomes very upset
Are they more like us
than we ever thought possible?
We're not the only species
that has soap operas going on
every day in their lives
"Inside Animal Minds:
Who's the Smartest?"
Right now on NOVA.
Which animals are the smartest?
And how did they get this way?
Dolphins have long been hailed
as the cleverest creatures
in the sea
There's no doubt
they're quick learners
And in captivity,
they can be trained
to perform stunning tricks
Not only can they follow
hand signals
but they can even learn
the meaning of written symbols
Why would a mammal that spends
most of its time underwater
and has flippers
instead of hands
have these kinds of skills?
Throughout the animal kingdom,
you can find creatures
with extraordinary talents:
elephants with impressive
memories,
birds that solve
complicated puzzles
and tool-making chimpanzees
They inhabit
utterly different worlds
and come in a wide variety
of shapes and sizes
But is it possible
that these animals
could all get their smarts
in similar ways?
Because whether they walk,
swim or fly,
the cleverest animals on earth,
including us humans,
seem to have one thing
in common:
we live in groups
So could social living
be the key
to creating the most
powerful minds?
Around the world,
animal researchers
are trying to find out
And this is one
of their favorite subjects
Everyone knows that dolphins
can put on incredible shows
But their greatest performances
take place far from the crowds
because here in the wild,
these animals execute
the most amazing tricks
when they work as a team
In these shallow waters
off the coast of Florida,
dolphins band together to get
the better of fast-moving fish
Here's how their trickery works
One dolphin swims in a circle
It whips up a wall
of muddy water,
corralling any fish inside
Three other dolphins wait
just outside the ring of mud
As the fish try to leap out
of the muddy ring and escape,
they jump right into the open
mouths of the waiting dolphins
Soon, a dolphin swings around
again to create another corral
They seem in perfect synch,
as if they've planned
every move together
But what's really going on?
Are they strategizing and
communicating with each other
the way we would?
Or are they simply
drawn together on the hunt
by pure instinct?
One big reason to suspect
that something more complex
is going on is this:
the dolphin brain
When you look at the size
of most animal brains,
there's usually
a pretty direct link
to the size of their bodies
The bigger the body,
the bigger the brain
But some animals
defy expectations
Humans have much more
gray matter
than other animals our size
So do chimps and whales
And so do dolphins
So how did their brains get big?
The $6 million question
has always been,
why do dolphins and whales
have such large brains?
Neuroscientist Lori Marino is
trying to answer that question
by hunting down
some very ancient clues
She travels
all over the country,
studying fossils to trace the
evolution of the dolphin brain
One of the things that we wanted
to find out
with this research
was exactly when they got
their large brains
Here at the Smithsonian
Institution,
she and her colleague Mark Uhen
are examining fossil skulls
of the dolphin's
ancient ancestors:
early whales called archaeocetes
Some archaeocetes were huge,
ferocious predators
with gigantic teeth
Compared to modern dolphins,
their bodies were massive
Growing up to 55 feet long,
in their day,
nearly 40 million years ago,
they were the biggest animals
on Earth
Today, examining fossil skulls
of early whales,
Lori is trying to estimate
the size of the brains
that once sat inside
In ancient fossils, the space
where the brain was housed
is often filled with sediment
But a CT scan can see
through the sediment
and reveal the exact dimensions
We were absolutely thrilled
to see the results of the study
because it gave us information
no one had before
When Lori examines the CT scans
of this giant killer's skull,
she discovers
not everything was big
This animal had a very big body
and a very small brain
But a few million years later,
things started to change
Something happened,
and what we see is a shift
When Lori looks at more recent
dolphin ancestors,
dating to about
30 million years ago,
she discovers, in evolutionary
terms, a fairly sudden shift
Bodies and teeth shrank,
but at the same time,
brains got bigger
The brain of the early dolphins
and whales increased in size,
sometimes manyfold
The dolphin brain got big
and stayed that way
In fact, for millions of years,
until early humans came along,
the dolphin had the most
powerful brain on the planet
Up until about
a million years ago,
the brainiest species
on the planet were not primates;
they were dolphins and whales
And we are just a very recent
kid on the block
The question is,
why did the brain change?
Everyone would like to know
why there was this shift
in relative brain size
with dolphins
It really is a mystery
It suggests that they embarked
on a very different evolutionary
path than their ancestors
Lori thinks that path
was a social one
No longer giant, toothy beasts,
individuals could increase
their chances for survival
by joining forces
Perhaps they needed
to hunt together,
to band together
against predators,
so these new animals were
smaller and not as formidable
They kind of needed each other
Today, more than 30 different
kinds of dolphins swim the seas,
including
the bottlenose dolphin,
the spotted dolphin
and the orca, or killer whale,
the largest of all dolphins
Most live in groups, or pods,
usually of a few dozen
individuals
Sometimes, pods will come
together, forming a mega-pod
numbering in the hundreds
or thousands
It seems clear that today's
dolphins need each other,
but why would they need
big brains, too?
To find out, we need to dive
deep into the dolphin world
Here, in the Caribbean waters
near the island of Bimini
Okay, Al, we're ready
when you are!
Researchers Kathleen Dudzinski
and Kelly Melillo Sweeting
have spent years tracking
wild spotted dolphins,
carefully observing and
recording their interactions,
trying to decipher the secrets
of dolphin society
Today, the scientists encounter
a gathering of dolphins
swimming together
There are about 16,
of mixed sexes and ages
What we definitely saw was a
socializing group of dolphins
They were interacting, playing,
they were affectionate
with one another
By observing these dolphins
year after year,
researchers are beginning
to get a clearer picture
of what dolphin society
is really like
Compared to many land mammals,
dolphin society is extremely
complex and dynamic,
and many of the relationships
they form might surprise you
The only connection that follows
a predictable pattern
is the one between a mother
and her calf
Among spotted dolphins,
the two will stay together
for about three years,
until the youngster is weaned
After that, almost anything goes
Males and females who mate don't
form long-term relationships
But sometimes adult females do
and help each other out
with babysitting duties
"White Blotch"
was one adult female
that we saw very consistently
for ten years,
and she was notorious
as what appeared to be
a babysitter
She'd come to the boat
with her own calf
and she'd have two or three
extras in tow
And we know they only have
one calf at a time,
so it was a very clear example
of that babysitting
and taking turns
And it's not just the females
who form close relationships
and collaborate
to make life easier
Male dolphins compete
with one another to find mates,
but sometimes two or three males
will form an alliance
to work together, to hunt
and to attract females
Often these relationships
last for many years,
even entire lifetimes
I do believe that dolphins
have friendships and favorites
and that their social
interactions
are developing the friendships
that they might have
that might last a lifetime
Those in close relationships
keep in touch... literally...
By tapping each other's
pectoral fins
But even if they're in some kind
of alliance or friendship,
dolphins like these will
regularly mingle with others
This flexible social structure
is known as
a "fission-fusion" society
Human society
is also fission-fusion
During an average day,
we will move
from small family groups
to larger groups of colleagues
to mid-size gatherings
of friends
Dolphins form
all sorts of relationships,
just like we do
And they change over time
It's a complicated
and bustling social world
And it's this social complexity
that some scientists think
could hold the key to the
evolution of bigger brains
When you're a social animal,
there's a lot that you need
to keep track of
There's all kinds
of relationships,
all kinds of interactions,
hierarchies,
collaborations that may occur
There's a very nice relationship
between social complexity
that you observe
in a species organization
and the size of their brain
So how do dolphins
use their big brains
to navigate their social lives?
Is it possible
that some of that brain
is powering a complex system
of communication?
After all, whenever
dolphins get together,
the water can get very noisy
Dolphins make
all kinds of sounds:
fast-paced clicks
that sound like a creaky door
Loud outbursts that resemble
squawking birds
And high-pitched whistles
For decades, researchers
have been trying to figure out
what it all means
But in the 1960s,
one controversial scientist
took an alternative approach
Neuroscientist John Lilly
was convinced that dolphins
were much more intelligent than
people had previously thought
John Lilly was
a neurophysiologist
who was the first
to really suggest
that dolphins might be
highly intelligent
He was the first to really
sort of light the fire
and get a lot of us interested
He talked about them
as humans of the sea
And I just want to talk
to such ancient characters
and find out, you know,
if they have any wisdom for us
Rather than deciphering
their language,
Lilly decided the quickest route
to communicating with dolphins
would be to teach one of them
how to speak English
And he set out to do just that,
with one of the strangest
animal experiments ever devised
John Lilly did an experiment
that involved building
a dolphin house
And what he did was
he bought property
and he flooded the first floor
so the dolphin could actually
live in this first floor area
With the dolphin, named Peter,
living in less than
four feet of water,
it wasn't a very humane approach
But the idea was to keep Peter
in close contact
with his teacher
He actually had a woman
living there with the dolphin
in a very intense time,
where she tried to teach
this dolphin English
The young woman
was Margaret Howe,
and she lived, ate and slept
here for two and a half months,
trying to teach Peter every day
This is a sound recording
of Margaret counting while
Peter attempts to imitate her
One, two, three, four, five.
One, two, three,
four, five, six.
It's safe to say
the dolphin house experiment
was both unethical
and a complete failure
What the dolphins did
was not English
They could imitate the numbers
of syllables they were hearing,
but they couldn't
formulate English
They don't have the same kind of
articulatory system we have
In spite of its shortcomings,
Lilly's work
got a lot of attention
and inspired the Hollywood film
The Day of the Dolphin.
What do you know
about linguistics?
The fictional scientist,
played by George C Scott,
seemed to have better luck
teaching his dolphin
to count "one, two, three"
in English
than John Lilly ever did
One
Two
Three!
For real-life scientists,
Lilly's work
showed that any idea
of teaching dolphins human
language was probably a fantasy
Today, researchers are focused
intently on trying to decipher
the dolphin's own system
of communication,
and they've been using
underwater microphones
to record all those clicks,
squawks and whistles,
hoping to find patterns
and discover
what they actually mean
But there's a problem
Dolphins make sounds underwater
by vibrating tissues
in their nasal cavities,
a bit like the way we humans
vibrate our vocal cords
They usually don't
open their mouths
or make any visible signs
Dolphins are essentially
ventriloquists
They produce sound
and you can't see anything
Nothing changes
on their facial expression,
or even their blowholes
So they can be making sounds
without moving,
and you have no idea
who made the sound
But now researchers have come up
with a pioneering new technique
to listen in
on dolphin conversations
We're going out today
to try to find wild dolphins
and attach tags to them
Biologist Vincent Janik
is on a quest
to eavesdrop on wild dolphins
and try to decipher
the dolphin communication code
They are little recording tags
that can give us information
about their sounds
that they're making
and also give us information
about their behavior
as they're in the bay,
their own wild environment
Today, a bottlenose dolphin's
been captured in shallow water
Are you going to put
the acoustic on?
The researchers work rapidly to
minimize distress to the animal
To solve the problem
of capturing the exact sounds
made by a particular dolphin,
Vincent's team uses suction cups
to attach a recording device
directly to the animal's head
It's small enough
for a dolphin to ignore
Nicholas, Nicholas, get signal?
Roger that
Okay
If it were uncomfortable,
the dolphin could easily use
the seabed to knock it off
It will now record all the
sounds that the dolphin makes
and, using GPS, will keep track
of its movements
The dolphin's released
and soon joins some other
tagged dolphins
The scientists will
constantly observe them
so later they'll be able
to match their behavior
to the sounds they're making
What's going on over there?
There's lots of splashing
I think that's a dorsal fin
Yeah, they're two dolphins
What we can look at is
what the animal's doing...
Whether it's traveling,
whether it's foraging,
whether it's socializing
with others
Those kinds of things
we can observe from the surface
After a few hours, the devices
fall off on their own
and float to the surface
so the team can retrieve them
and begin analyzing
the dolphin's sounds
At first hearing,
it's a cacophony:
a whole range of dolphin clicks,
whistles and pulses
Today, we know that
the creaky-door clicks
are the sounds dolphins use
for echolocation
They work like sonar pings
Dolphins listen for the echoes
of the clicks
as they bounce off objects
in their environment
This plays a crucial role in
helping them locate their prey
and navigate in murky water
But Vincent is interested in
other kinds of dolphin sounds:
the ones they use
for communication
Sometimes, there are patterns:
certain sounds consistently made
when a dolphin is doing
a particular action,
like this one
One sound that we've found
is the so-called bray sound,
which dolphins produce
when they find fish
And it's a sound that brings in
other dolphins as well
And when dolphins are
aggressive, playful or not,
they often produce
lower frequency sounds
known as burst pulses
These kinds of calls are common
in the animal kingdom
But there is one kind of sound
dolphins make
that is much more unusual
It's called
the signature whistle
Every dolphin
has its own signature whistle
that's different from all others
So within a population,
you have very,
very different whistles
for every animal
The function of the whistle
really is to broadcast
its identity
and also to stay in touch
with other group members
The closest
in our language perhaps
is really if I would say,
"I'm Vincent and I'm over here"
Dolphins have good vision,
but if the water is murky
or individuals get separated,
Vincent believes they use
signature whistles
to help keep a group together
If an animal gets lost,
it will also produce
that whistle
to try to make contact again,
and that's something
that we often see
between mothers and calves
When the calf wanders off
and is far away
and eventually wants to get back
to the mother,
what it does is it starts to
produce its signature whistle
It is rare for animals
to have unique calls
that correspond
to particular individuals,
but dolphins aren't
the only animals
to use vocal calls as a way
of identifying each other
One other animal
known to do this
inhabits a world
completely different
from the dolphins'
underwater domain
The Amboseli National Park
in Kenya
is home to some of the most
social animals on the planet:
elephants
KAREN McCOMB:
The thing about this park
that's outstanding is the
visibility of the elephants,
a population of more than
a thousand elephants,
which we know individually
Karen McComb has been observing
elephants here for decades,
trying to unlock the secrets
of elephant society
and communication
McCOMB:
It's being able
to get inside animal minds,
get into a social world
that's actually
rather different from ours
that will tell us what elephants
are really thinking
Elephant society is a family
affair, especially for females
They stay with their mothers,
sisters, aunts and cousins
for their entire lives
The oldest female,
known as the matriarch,
is the leader
Young males stick
with their mothers
until they're
about ten years old,
and then they leave the social
group to live independently
And elephants
are always on the move
Elephants have
this really unusual
and complex social system
So instead of just staying put
and communicating
with their immediate neighbors,
they sort of move
in relation to one another
in a very fluid,
fission-fusion way
Females and young males spend
time with lots of elephants
in groups of different sizes
And they communicate with dozens
of different kinds of calls
Some rumbles
are such low frequency
they're out of range
of human hearing,
but elephants can detect them
from miles away
Karen believes that their calls
are crucial
for the elephants to keep track
of friend and foe
McCOMB:
They'll come into contact
with many, many other families
as they move and feed,
and they will be
making decisions
about which families
it's safe to feed next to
and which they should avoid
To find out how elephants
make those decisions,
Karen designed an experiment
It involves years
of painstaking research
and some very powerful speakers
Karen has made a library
of elephant contact calls
and is going to play some
to a group of elephants
who are on the move
and see how they react
First, she plays a call
from an elephant
from a different group,
but a friendly one
The elephants
just keep on walking
and their behavior
doesn't change
But when Karen plays a call
from an elephant
they don't know well,
their behavior is very different
The elephants abruptly
stop their march
They turn toward
the unfamiliar voice,
gather closer together and move
directly toward the sound
in what Karen says
is a defensive show of force
Karen tested 21 families
and found that the elephants
consistently distinguished
between friend and stranger,
recognizing
up to 100 different voices
She believes that a lot
of their brain power and memory
is going into keeping track
of other elephants:
the ones they do and do not know
Who is safe to be around
and who might pose a threat?
And it could be the same with us
We have these relationships
that we need to maintain
throughout our lives
with friends and enemies
You have to remember
who owes you a favor
And that sort of complexity
seems to go hand in hand
with the evolution
of larger brains
It's not enough
to be simply social
The animal world
is full of social creatures,
and plenty of them have some
of the tiniest brains around
There's lots of different
kinds of social behavior
of social animals
Insects, for example,
termites and ants
are extremely social,
and they can't live
by themselves
They need each other
for everything that they do
Ants live in colonies, sometimes
with millions of members,
and divide labor
between workers and soldiers
The collective might of termites
can result in the construction
of huge, elaborate mounds
And social living,
along with an intricate
communication system,
is crucial to bees,
with tens of thousands
of individuals working together
to find food
and raise their young
All these animals
are highly social,
and together,
they can accomplish wonders
But each individual
has a miniscule brain
Ants are always essentially
working together
toward one goal:
to help each other out
to make the colony a success
Now, dolphins are on the other
end of the spectrum
Sometimes they cooperate,
sometimes they are competing
with each other
So when you enter this element
of both cooperating
and competing at the same time
in order to survive,
this new kind
of social complexity
and intelligence blossoms
Cooperation and competition,
side by side
This is the recipe for a really
complicated social life
And animals who live this way
often have big brains
But whether one leads
to the other is still unclear
Part of the challenge
for scientists is figuring out
how much animals like dolphins
might understand
about their social lives
Dolphin cognition expert
Diana Reiss
has spent years
trying to find out
She works with dolphins at the
National Aquarium in Baltimore
Keeping dolphins in captivity
is controversial,
and aquariums in the U S
haven't captured wild dolphins
for two decades
Diana believes
it's only in the controlled
environment of aquariums
that you can unlock some of the
secrets of the dolphin mind
Here, she can
carry out experiments
not possible in the wild
The aquarium has
an observation chamber,
nicknamed "The Pit"
It's cramped
But from here,
Diana has an excellent view
of the dolphins'
underwater behavior
This dolphin is making
bubble rings,
a behavior observed both
in captivity and in the wild
A dolphin blows out
an air bubble from its blowhole,
then flicks it with its tail
to create a ring shape
Bubble rings appear
to have no practical purpose,
except for entertainment
It's another dolphin behavior
we can relate to:
the ability to play
Diana wants to find out
what else we share
on an even more
fundamental level
She's investigating
whether dolphins
recognize themselves
as individuals
Do they each have
a sense of self?
Diana places a one-way mirror
inside the observation window
So now we're looking
through a window
and they'll be seeing a mirror
The dolphins can't see people
inside The Pit
All they see
are their own reflections
Dolphins don't behave like this,
staying in one place
and staring,
if they simply meet
another dolphin
Another extremely unusual action
is this curious fin wiggling
This looks nothing like
what they do
when they're socially
interacting with another
They also look inside their
mouths or closely at their eyes
They perform all sorts
of odd behaviors
much like we might do
in front of a mirror
to see what we look like
when we do that new dance step
or when we just want to see
how we look in a new outfit
They seem to be using the mirror
like a tool
to see parts of their bodies
that are usually out of view
This all supports the idea
that dolphins must be aware
they're looking at themselves
Dolphins share this ability to
recognize themselves in a mirror
with just a few other animals
Elephants do it
So do chimpanzees
But the vast majority,
including dogs, don't
And interestingly,
neither do young humans
Before they're 18 months old,
most children fail to point out
a red dot painted on their cheek
This boy assumes
he's looking at another child
Only when they're about two
does a child first realize
that the mark
is on her own cheek
and she knows the reflection
is of herself
Eventually, a human child's
self-awareness
will go far beyond recognizing
her own body in a mirror
She'll be aware
of her own thoughts
and be able to contemplate
the thoughts of others
But is the same true for other
animals, like dolphins?
Diana thinks it might be
Having a sense of self
would go hand in hand,
I could say flipper to flipper,
with complex understanding
of others
So if animals like dolphins
recognize themselves
as individuals,
how much do they understand
about the other creatures
around them?
It's a question debated
by animal researchers
The big question is not,
"Do animals think?"
The big question is, "Do they
think about others thinking?"
"Thinking about others thinking"
is something we humans do
all the time
As humans, we are remarkable
because we can imagine
what it's like,
in some context,
to be someone else
That's an amazing ability
that we see in humans
This ability we have
to imagine what it's like
to be another person
is known as "theory of mind"
The theory of mind is the idea
that all humans normally develop
an understanding
that other people have
different minds than our own:
that what I know is different
than what you know
and that what I want
is different than what you want
And that's a big question
for animal researchers:
whether any non-human animal
also eventually, or at all,
develops a theory of mind
It's extremely difficult
to prove that an animal "thinks"
about other animals' "thoughts,"
but some of the most interesting
research has been done
with our closest relatives:
the chimpanzees
Primatologist Frans de Waal
works with chimpanzees
at the Yerkes Primate Center
in Atlanta
When an animal like a chimp
is aware that another chimp
has a different perspective
on the world,
it could give it an advantage
Chimpanzee groups have a strict
ranking system
At the very top
is the most powerful chimp:
the alpha male
He's in charge of the group,
and every other chimp has
a position of rank below him,
from the most dominant
to the most subordinate
Frans has set up
an interesting experiment
to find out how
a low-ranking animal behaves
when it gets
valuable information
that a more dominant member
does not know
Could one chimp
actively deceive another?
Most studies that are
on deception
are observational,
anecdotal studies
But nowadays,
we do experiments also on it,
and so you can,
for example, hide food
One chimp knows where it is,
the other one doesn't know
where it is,
and then you can see if
deception goes on between them
The experiment involves
two chimps: Rita and Missy
Rita is the more dominant
At the start of the experiment,
the chimps are
in their sleeping quarters
One of the keepers goes
into the outdoor enclosure
and hides a banana
under the red tube
Missy is allowed to watch
through a window,
so she sees the keeper
hide the banana
Rita can see Missy watching
through the window,
but she can't see
what's going on outside
Then they let the chimps out
Rita, the dominant chimp,
comes out first
If she knew where
the banana was hidden,
she'd simply help herself
But only Missy, the subordinate,
saw the banana being placed
under the red tube
Rita just saw Missy watching
So the two have very
different perspectives
on the same situation
Missy notices Rita
close to the food
and sits on top of the tube
She seems to be playing it cool
Rita now wanders off
When she's far enough away,
Missy goes for the banana
Frans believes that Missy
has successfully deceived Rita
He's observed
this kind of behavior in chimps,
but it's rare in other animals
So if animals
can deceive others,
what would that say
about their minds?
When we think about deception,
you have to sort of understand
the rules of the game
Deception is manipulating
the rules of the game,
so a highly social animal
who understands
the rules of the game
and then changes it somehow
for its own benefit
or to make a joke, perhaps,
or to achieve something
shows a level of sophistication
We humans are very good at it
So, are the most successful
animals natural born liars?
If you live in a complex
social group,
you're competing against others
who eat the same thing you do,
who mate
with the same individuals
that you might
want to mate with,
so if you can somehow manipulate
the behavior of others,
then you're going
to have potentially
a competitive advantage
But social living is not
just about lies and deceit
Deception can only get you
so far
There's a big disadvantage
to deception
and that's why it is not
so often used,
is that if I do that too often
to you, you may catch on
and at some point,
you don't trust me anymore
Frans believes that primates,
as they negotiate
their social lives,
are very aware
of the competition
And so he's come up
with another experiment,
this one to test
their sense of justice
Do they realize if they're
being treated fairly or not,
compared to others?
Normally, you would think
the only thing an animal
should care about is,
"What do I get for my task?
I work, I get rewards"
But no, they're comparing with
what the other one is getting
Frans begins the fairness test
with the capuchin monkey
These small, clever animals
are kept in large enclosures,
but for the short duration
of the test,
they're in a lab area
Each monkey carries out
a simple task:
they have to give a small stone
to the experimenter
in exchange for a reward
When both get a reward
of cucumber, everyone's happy
But watch what happens
when the one on the right
receives a grape reward instead
FRANS de WAAL:
If you start giving
one of them grapes,
which are far better
than cucumber,
then the one who gets cucumber
becomes very upset
and becomes agitated...
Emotionally agitated
It turns out
quite a few creatures,
including ravens and dogs,
will protest if they get
the short end of the stick,
as if they know that they're
being treated unfairly
But what about a concern
for injustice for the other guy?
Research with one
of our closest relatives,
a highly social chimp
called a bonobo,
is revealing some surprises
At the Lola ya Bonobo orphanage
in the Congo,
animals spend most of their days
in the forest,
but come inside
for short periods of time
for experiments like this
One bonobo is inside
an enclosure
The door is locked and can only
be opened from the other side
Here, another bonobo...
A stranger...
Is given a delicious
pile of fruit
So what will she do?
We recently discovered
that bonobos can share
with strangers...
That they actually
will sacrifice their own food
for the opportunity to interact
with another bonobo
they've never met before
That's not something
that we thought
another species would do
When we think about nature
as red in tooth and claw,
that you would share
with somebody
you don't share any genes with,
that's not in your family,
they're not even in your group?
I thought that was something
that humans did
So the fact that a bonobo
does that is remarkable
It's the closest thing
that you can think of
to doing charity in animals
Among the most social animals,
there's growing evidence
for active concern
for the well-being of others
Recently, it was reported
that elephants
will console an animal
in distress
by gently touching it
with their trunks
And elephants do something else
which might demonstrate
powerful feelings of connection
to others of their species
Elephants,
through observational evidence,
seem to have a really
unusual interest
in the dead
of their own species,
either fresh carcasses or skulls
The very interesting thing
is actually
the interest seems to persist
after death
Karen McComb has devised
an experiment to find out more
She takes the skulls
of elephants killed by poachers
to make a miniature graveyard
in the path
of an approaching herd
Now she just observes
McCOMB:
Yep, I think
we've definitely got
the beginnings
of a reaction here
Some of the younger females
starting to respond
They've picked up a whiff
of the skulls
The male is swinging his trunk
towards the skulls
and the jawbones as well
A few animals, including chimps,
will be curious about the corpse
of a companion,
touching and investigating
the body
But only elephants
take an interest
in the skulls and bones
of their own kind
long after death
McCOMB:
We've got the females
clustering around the skull,
touching the jawbones
You see the way the ends
of the trunks are moist there?
That's enhancing the scent
that they're getting
You wouldn't see that
in any other species,
except for humans
To test whether
this intense response
was specific to elephant skulls
and not just a reaction
to a new object,
Karen has done
exactly the same thing
with skulls from other animals
McCOMB:
If you present elephants
with the skulls
of other large herbivores,
the biggest herbivores
you can get...
Rhino, buffalo skulls...
You do not get
that level of interest
Given the choice
between the three,
they make a beeline
for the elephant skull
And they're particularly
interested actually
in elephant ivory
That, they will spend a massive
amount of time investigating,
picking it up, carrying it off,
touching it
They are definitely able
to recognize,
distinguish the skulls
and other remains of elephants
from other species
This kind of behavior seems
very familiar to us humans
McCOMB:
Obviously, we are intensely
involved and interested in death
in the sense
that our relationships continue
beyond that,
and it's very interesting
that this highly social animal
seems to also have
a social interest
that extends beyond death
As we watch these elephants
gently touch the remains
of their dead,
it's impossible to know exactly
what is driving their curiosity
Or whether these animals
might be experiencing
emotions similar to what
we would feel, like grief
What scientists
like Karen do know
is that for highly
social creatures,
relationships are essential
for survival
So, with so much time
and brain power spent
reading social situations,
could these animals
be better prepared
to gauge an interaction
with another species?
One such interaction
was reported not long ago
in the waters near Hawaii,
where a group of divers
was swimming at night,
photographing manta rays
Unexpectedly, a lone dolphin
swims close to the divers
They notice that the dolphin is
tangled in a thin fishing line
and has a hook stuck in its fin
Without help,
he will probably perish
And it approaches this diver
as if it knows
that the diver can possibly
help out
And that's in fact
what the diver does:
very gently cuts away
the fishing line
It takes quite awhile
The dolphin actually
has to go up for air
and then come back down again
The entire process
takes about seven minutes
So the question is,
what was the dolphin thinking?
My guess is the dolphin
was just approaching the diver
and then probably figured out
that the diver
was intending to help
at that stage
So did it come
swimming out of the deep
to solicit a diver's help?
Probably not, but it certainly
was smart enough
to figure out that
the diver could help
once the diver started helping
When the fishing line has been
removed, he swims away
It is a remarkable encounter
between two species
Witnessing the behavior
of all these social animals,
it's hard not to connect...
To see some parallels
with our own complicated lives
Part of the experience
of being human as a species
is a bit lonely
And I think one
of the really fun things
about studying other animals
is over time,
we learn that actually,
we're not the only
really social species
We're not the only species
that has literally
soap operas going on
every day in their lives,
and we're not the only species
that has many of the same
problems we experience
Whether it's that,
"Oh, my gosh, I have to deal
with my family member
"who is driving me crazy,
but they're my family
so I have to support them,"
or, you know,
"Gosh, I have this friend
that I like to hang out with
but they keep taking
advantage of me,"
or the fact that,
"Oh, this guy who thinks
he's so much bigger than me
"and he can do
whatever he wants,
"I have to get
my friends together
and be nice to them
so they'll help me"
These are all things
that we experience together
with lots of other
social animals on the planet,
so I think it's not just trying
to understand
what the life
of animals are like
I think part of it is that
it makes us feel part of nature
and that we're not here alone
There are other animals
that experience things
that we also experience
And it could be that
these kinds of experiences,
these challenges we face
every day as social animals,
have played a key role
in the evolution
of bigger and smarter brains
Because in certain situations,
the creature who can
cleverly negotiate,
who can lend or extend
a helping hand,
is often the one with the best
chance of survival
I think we often
think about evolution
as always the biggest,
strongest,
most competitive individual
is the one that's going
to survive and reproduce
But I think we see
again and again
and again and again in evolution
that that's not the case at all
Other times,
what's going to be favored
is things that lead
to better cooperation
so that you can work together
to solve problems
you otherwise couldn't solve
on your own
And that requires tolerance
That requires actually
not dominance,
but sometimes
a lack of dominance
So when we study
a wide variety of species,
you see things beyond just "it's
always the big guy that wins"