I Am a Killer (2018–2020): Season 1, Episode 9 - Living with the Consequences - full transcript

Every once in a while, I'll think about,

you know, how my life
would have been if not for this.

At times, I believe,
I deserve forgiveness.

That I'm redeemable.

I am very, very sorry for what happened.

And I wish that I could take it back.

What I did, it's not who I am.

How could I do something like that?

[man 1]
And I walked up, I fired one shot.

And as I got closer,
I fired one more shot.

[man 2] She was shot through the cheek
and it stopped in her jaw.



[man 3] I drove him around behind a desk
and I stabbed him approximately 25 times.

[man 4] I couldn't believe it.

I just thought I can't believe
I just killed somebody.

[man 5]
I don't feel bad about it. [laughs]

[man 6] I started stabbing him,
stabbing the guy on the couch.

My name is Joshua David Nelson.
I'm 40 years old and I'm on death row.

I've been here 20 years.

And I was 18 and, like, two months
when I caught this case.

My earliest memories
were of my father as an alcoholic.

I was probably four or five,
maybe even younger.

As soon as he came in, my mom
was waiting on him and it would start.

They would argue,
and it would fill the trailer.

And I-- I would run to my room
and hide out in my room,

uh, crying, as I knew what was happening.
He was beating on her.



And I couldn't help her,
but I was also terrified that I was next.

I was probably seven when it happened,
when they eventually got, uh, a divorce.

And then I thought it was gonna get a lot
better, 'cause it's just me and my mom.

But it didn't get better.

[birds chirping]

[Nelson] We came down to Florida.

Within a year, I got, like, arrested
four or five times.

And it was multiple car thefts
and breaking-and-enterings.

I was doing drugs.

I experimented with marijuana, alcohol,

you know, hard alcohol, beer,
uh, some roofies.

I even huffed gasoline a couple of times.

When the courts heard that,
they suggested that I go to a drug rehab.

I just showed up one day, they just
dropped me down in one of those places,

and there's ten other boys your age there,

and they're all there,
more than likely, for the same reason.

And me and Keith,

we just gravitated towards each other,
I guess, and started talking.

Became fast friends, really good friends.

And the friendship built
the longer we spent in that rehab.

We became friends on the streets.

Went to the same high school
and hung out pretty much every day.

Me and Keith started dating two sisters,
and Tina was the youngest sister

and she started dating Keith.

That's how we all came together.

Tommy was brought in to our group
by another friend of ours.

He just rolled up on us
in his car one time, Tommy did,

and I didn't really have much interaction
with him at first.

He seemed like, uh, a decent person.

And, you know,
he was a little bit older than us,

and we just started hanging out.

When me and Keith
was in that rehab together,

we would escape the reality
of our situation by fantasizing about,

yeah, when we get out, we would do all
these things, you know, commit crimes

and we would, you know, better our lives,
we would get away from all these things.

Fast forward to that day,

I don't remember exactly how that came up,
but it came up.

We said we could kill Tommy.

We could take his car, take his money

and do whatever we wanted to do.
Be on our own.

At first, I thought
it was just blowing off steam, at first.

I gave it no mind.

I didn't think
that it was really gonna happen.

I wasn't, you know, in essence,

planning it out as you would, uh...

You know, meticulously planning it out,
I wasn't doing that.

Neither was Keith.

We called him. He came over, picked us up.
We drove around.

Keith said, "You know, um,
we gotta get some money."

So he's like, "Okay."

And Keith says,
"Well, if we give you some of that money,

will you take us to the rendezvous point
so we can pick the money up?"

He was like, "Yeah.
I'll take you there. I'll help."

[Nelson] I still don't have the feeling
like, that's a done deal--

that's gonna happen,
we're gonna kill him.

So, we drive out to this abandoned area,

this undeveloped area in Cape Coral.

We tell him, you know, uh...

we're gonna "wait for them,"
wait for them to come and give us money.

So we get out the car.

Baseball bat came from Tommy.

He carried it around
in the back of his car.

He said for protection.

So, when I got out,
I used that as a premise.

We're standing out in the dark
in the middle of nowhere,

I'm gonna have this bat just in case
somebody comes out of the woods.

Me and Keith are outside and we're kind
of talking about what's gonna happen.

I say, 'I'll hit him first.
If I knock him out,

you gotta finish him off."

"You gotta kill him."

Then we talk about,
"How are we gonna get him out the car?"

We knew how much he valued that car.

He loved that car.

Keith had the box cutter.

We cut the bumper with the cutter
and told him,

"Hey, when you was driving back here,
you must've hit something

or something happened,
and there's a cut on this bumper."

He got out.

He looked at the bumper.

I felt, like, this rush of adrenaline.
I was trying to get myself to do it.

And I just couldn't do it.

And then I just stepped past that...

that part of me that wasn't allowing me
to do that

and I hit him with the baseball bat.

He fell down.

And then I tried to hit him again.

And...

then I hit-- I definitely hit him,
and he's...

and he was just crying and scream--

not screaming, but like,
you know, moaning and saying,

"Stop." You know, "Stop, stop.
Please stop. Please stop."

Begging.

And then...

he said he-- that's when he said,

"Take the car.
Take the car, take the money."

And we kind of walked off
to the side and said, you know,

"Is that a possibility?"

Kind of talked amongst ourselves and said,
"That's not... that's never--

You know, we're gonna get in trouble
for this."

Keith says, "We had that agreement."

If I'd knock him out, he would finish him.

So, I hit him with the bat.

I hit him again with the bat.

And he stopped making noise.
He stopped begging, he stopped talking.

And Keith pulled out
one of his shoestrings from his shoes

and tied him up.

I said, "Keith, you know, it's on you.
He's out."

That's when Tommy said,
"I'm not out! I'm not out!"

And then I walked over there

and I hit him with the bat
several more times.

Really hard.

Everything that I had dealt with
my entire life came out at that moment

and all those feelings,
all that anger, and--

It just...

It just-- it just all happened
in that moment and--

He didn't make-- he wasn't--
he was out then, 'cause he didn't...

he didn't say anything else, he didn't...

he didn't resist.

And then Keith went over there and started
cutting his throat with a box cutter.

[Nelson] We drug him to an area

with more, like, shrubs and ground cover,
I guess you would say,

instead of just next to a road.

We took a big piece of wood
and put it over him.

And when we drove off, we threw the bat
in the water and the razor away.

We got rid of the clothes we were wearing
because we were covered in blood.

[voice altered] My sister
had met Josh through McDonalds

'cause he was working there.

I met Keith through Josh,

and shortly after, we started dating.

All of us had problems in our families.

And we had all been talking
for quite some time

about wanting to run away together.

And our biggest problem
was how any of us were gonna go anywhere.

And Keith and Josh had said,

"You know, don't worry about it,"
that they would get a car.

That particular day, they had called
and said, "We're leaving tonight."

We said okay.

So we just waited around
for the phone call

to leave our house and walk down
the street to be picked up.

As soon as we seen Tommy's car,
we knew something was wrong.

We didn't know if they had, somehow,
convinced Tommy to give up his car

or what was going on.

They were both very quiet,
and we asked, "Where's Tommy?"

And Keith responded with, "We killed him."

[woman] This is a picture of Tommy
when he was about 18.

And this is Tommy
when he worked at Winn-Dixie.

He was about 16 then.

And, um, this here
was the last picture taken.

That's, uh, Tommy.

That was the Thursday night
before he died, and my sister.

That was the car,
the Ford Probe that they wanted.

I took the picture of him and my sister.

He was tickling her ribs.

And then the following night
is when he... he got killed.

So I know that was the last picture
taken of him.

Tommy was a very happy, energetic person.

He liked cars, installing stereos.

Always on the go, liked to make friends.

Um, I don't think he had any enemies.

Never drank, smoked.
Couldn't find a better person.

He was going to community college.

He'd just started taking up criminal law.
He wanted to be a cop.

And he said, "I'll buy a duplex."

And he'll live in one end with his family
and I'll live in the other end.

And he was gonna have his Lamborghini
in the driveway.

I said, "Okay."

Sounded fine at the time.

We didn't know at first
what... what had happened.

We never thought it would turn to this.

Um, we had gone to Josh's house,
talked to his stepfather.

And we went to the high school,
we were talking to friends.

They assumed
they all went to Fort Lauderdale.

We thought the worst thing was that,
being he was not a drug user,

they got him on some kind of drug

and he's just forgetting to call home.

That was about the worst thing
we thought.

But it took 11 days before we knew
what had happened.

They did the positive ID's
through the dental records

because of the decomposition.

Eleven days in a field,
in Florida, in the heat.

[man] He should have been able to do
everything that he was gonna do.

And he didn't get to do it.

All over a stupid car.

I mean, all I have to do
is think about it,

and I start crying like a little baby.

[sniffs, clicks tongue]
And believe me, I'm pissed.

He's lived all this time
as my family dies.

Coming from a peaceful hippie,
this is saying a lot.

But I ain't that peaceful.

Peace, love and happiness forever,
until you brutally murder my brother.

I will dedicate my life.

I will dedicate my life!

They will wish they never-- They're better off where they're at

because they will not wanna meet me
when they get out.

[Owens] This is, uh, Tommy's dad.

He died on December 4th of '04. Cancer.

And, um, yeah, he was hoping

he... he could be there at the execution.

He was gonna eat popcorn in the front row.

That was his-- what he said
to the reporters back then.

But as he got sicker and sicker,

you know, we knew
he wasn't gonna be there.

It's just, you know, 22 years
is a long time to wait, you know?

And he's definitely should have been
put to death a long time ago.

[Owens] In their minds, they had a reason.
They planned.

But thinking back, no, there was...
there was absolutely no reason.

Tommy was trying to just tell them,
"Take the car, take the car."

You know, he knew they were killing him.

But they continued.
They made the decision to kill him.

They could have just taken the car
and left.

But they made the wrong choice.
And now they're paying for it.

And one's gonna pay with his life.

[Stewart] When I was 19,
I was married to Peggy,

and she is the mother of Heather,
our daughter.

And Peggy is also the mother
of Josh Nelson.

I think I was divorced at 21.

And, uh...

Josh came along about three years later.

I can remember, uh,
as Heather was six months old

feeling just concerned on a bigger level

as to the maternal care
that Peggy was able to give to her.

I can remember I could hear Heather crying
in the back of the house.

And I might go and check on Heather,
and she'd quiet down.

And then, uh, once Peggy got up

and I heard her go to the back
of the trailer,

and the crying stopped quite suddenly,

to a point
that I was just conscious of it.

It just seemed different.

And I got up to walk back
just to see what was going on.

And as I went into the room,

Peggy stepped back from Heather, the baby,
and had a pillow in her hand.

And it appeared as if Peggy was holding
the pillow over Heather's face.

When she stepped back,
Heather started crying again.

And I couldn't see it directly,

but it just, it felt very much, to me,
as if that's what was going on.

And I questioned Peggy about it.

And she denied it.

She said she was just, you know,
she was just trying to comfort Heather.

Um, and there were... there were
a few incidents similar to that.

[Stewart]
When I did get custody of Heather,

I can remember asking Heather,

"Is this something that you want?"

Because, you know, you don't know for sure
how kids feel about this.

And I can remember Heather saying,

well, yes, she did want to come
to Michigan and stay with me,

but she was very concerned about Josh.

She said, "I don't wanna
leave Josh there by himself."

[Heather] My mom was not nurturing.

I would say that she did not have
the mothering ability.

I think that there was just a void
inside of her

that she wasn't able to be the mother

that myself and Josh needed,

that children are supposed to have.

[Heather] Alan, Josh's dad--

the alcoholic part, I think,
is what defined him,

'cause I know
that he was physically abusive to Josh.

I mean, he spanked him a lot.
Um, he yelled at him a lot.

Um...

but I guess I don't know
how much of that went on more

when I wasn't there,

than when I was visiting.

You know, if that's one of those things
that people, behind closed doors...

I don't know.

[quavering] It's kind of hard now.

[Heather] I think that that kind
of an environment destroyed Josh.

He was never given the values, the morals.

I don't think he was ever taught
how to love.

Um, and when you don't have that,
you can't give that.

And you can't, um--

There's just nothing at--

Like I said, I mean, I just don't think
that he ever had a chance.

[Heather] When they moved to Florida,
in, like, 1991,

that kind of cut off any communication
or ties to family.

I found out about the sexual abuse
that was going on with him and Greg,

his stepdad, during the trial.

I mean, I had no idea.

From what I read in the reports,

Greg sexually abusing Josh
was a daily thing, a weekly thing.

It was not a...
every-once-in-a-while thing.

It was... It was--
From the way that the reports read,

it was almost that was his entire life.

[Nelson on recording] It first started
where I would be in the shower

and he would come in there and sit down
on the toilet.

And, you know, obviously, I knew
something was not right about that.

Eventually, one night,
he came into my room and...

he started touching me
in my private-- my penis,

and I would try to roll away.

And he was persistent.

And then I would try and roll,
I-- I acted like I was asleep.

I acted like it wasn't existing.
I mean, it wasn't happening.

It couldn't be happening.

And I sunk deeper inside myself,
and, eventually, I got an erection.

I was young and my body responded.

And then he would perform oral sex on me.

When he would do that,

I can't describe what I've...
I can't describe what I felt.

I felt nothing.
I felt absolutely nothing.

And like I said,
I just sunk deeper inside of myself,

running away from myself.

Eventually, I got up the courage
to tell my mom

after it had been happening
for six-- six months, a year.

I sat her down and I looked at her
and I said, "Mom, this is what he's doing to me."

And she called him into the room
and he acknowledged it.

He said he thought that I liked it,
that's why he was doing it.

And she told him
that if he ever did it again,

that she would kill him.

And I'm sitting there
thinking the whole time,

"If he ever does it again?"

What about the times he did it, you know?

What about all those times
that he did it?

[sniffles]

[sniffles]

[sighs]

I find it hard to believe that...

an innocent child

is sitting in death row.

[inhales]

[sighs]

And there is no accountability

for the people
who have put him where he is.

I mean, I wish
that I could have saved him.

[sobs] I wish that somebody
would have just saved him.

[sniffles]

Because nobody deserves that. [sniffles]

[sniffles] There were so many people
who could have saved him.

Adults who should have stepped in.

Whether when he was 2 or 12,

nobody had his back.

And I'm sorry that I didn't.

[Nelson on recording] It made him stop
for a little while, maybe a month or two,

maybe three months.

But yeah, it didn't stop.

Yeah, he approached me again.

By this time, I was 18, and...

I felt like I wasn't gonna let it
happen anymore.

And he didn't react,

but he's like, "You know,
you need to come with me.

We need to go talk to your mom."

I was like, "Yeah.
Let's go talk to my mom."

So-- but he manipulated the situation

where he wanted me
to wait out in the car,

and while he went in
and talked to my mom.

So, in hindsight, who knows?

I just-- I was just trusting
for whatever reason, I don't know.

I just trusted those, and you know,

in that position, I guess,
like an authority figure.

I just trusted him.

And he went in, talked to my mom,
and she came out livid, pissed.

Told me to give her my key.

And I was out. I had to get out.

And I had no job. I had no money.

I had to get my clothes and get--
get out.

So, I was like,
"All right. Well, what can I do?"

[Tina] One night, my sister and I went
to Josh's house to see Keith and Josh,

and Keith was not there.

I was going to walk to a pay phone
to call Keith.

And Tommy was there that night

and he said that I could use the phone
in his car.

When we got into his car, he told me
that we would have to drive up the road

to where he could get service
in order for me to make a call.

And I agreed.

Instead, he drove me to a remote area
where no one else was around

and proceeded to sexually assault me.

And I had no intention of saying anything,

but my sister could tell
there was something wrong with me.

As soon as I told her,

she told Josh everything that happened.

Of course, Josh was furious.

At first, Tommy denied everything,

but later on,
finally admitted what he had done.

[Tina] When I first found out
what happened,

I was glad Tommy was gone.

That was my initial thought--

and I would never have
to deal with him again.

The guilt came afterwards.

Not that I felt they did what they did

simply because of what Tommy did to me.

I knew they both had problems
in their own lives.

But I felt that telling them
what had happened to me

was the straw that broke the camel's back.

A lot of lives were lost that night.

Not just Tommy's.

A lot of people were hurt,
a lot of people were destroyed.

Josh, Keith, the entire Owens family.

Nobody will ever be the same
after that night.

Josh will always have
a very special place in my heart.

He's a good-hearted person.

He was a scared kid.

He had a lot of damage done to him
in his life.

And it came out in a terrible way.

[Owens] It could have happened.

We don't know.

Well, I don't think it's relevant.
They, um, mentioned that at trial.

They were all friends

and, um, there was no forcing or rape.

It just wasn't talked about

except brought up that one time,
and that was the end of it.

They planned it, premeditated.
They wanted his car and they killed him.

To lure somebody into the woods,
to lure them out of their own car,

and to beat them with a baseball bat
and slice his throat,

and he's begging for his life
and saying, "Take the car."

And they still, "No we're gonna kill you."
And they did.

And what did-- what did they gain?

They're in prison and my son's gone.

So, no, I... I wouldn't forgive them.

I hope they burn in hell.

[Nelson on recording]
I still can't fully emotionally feel

and understand and comprehend
what I did that night.

How could I...
how could I do something like that?

How could I, especially after being
a victim my whole life,

being other people's victim,
that I would go out

and just brutally victimize
somebody like that?

Because, I mean, I'm--
I'm totally responsible for that.

No one else is responsible for that.
I did that.

And I wanna take it back, so bad.

I wanna remove that pain
that I caused from everybody.

I wanna bring him back to life,
but I can't.

I don't know how...

[quavering]
I don't know how to make amends.

I don't know how to apologize.

[stammers] I don't know how--
I don't know what...

you know, I don't know what to say.

So, he takes responsibility enough,

but that's more or less
all he said, that he...

he's had all these years to think about
that he is responsible for what happened.

But I don't feel any different
towards him.

'Cause of that statement,
it's not like I should forgive him. No.

I think it's the words
he needs to say right now

'cause he knows his execution date
is getting closer.

And he'll say anything to, you know,
to get some sympathy.

But at the time, he didn't say nothing.

He actually made a face at us
leaving the courtroom.

And that was brought up at trial,
that he gave us a smirk.

The only thing he was sorry for
was getting caught.

I-I don't recall that, but I would never
smirk at them about something like that.

I might have smirked about something
that someone was saying on the stand

or something
that I didn't agree with, and...

But even at that time,
I wouldn't do that [stammers] at them.

[Tina on recording]
Not that I felt they did what they did

simply because of what Tommy did to me.

I felt that telling them
what had happened to me

was the straw
that broke the camel's back.

[sighs] I don't-- that's a hard,
you know, that's a hard question to answer

because, you know, uh,
I think things happen--

You know, there are a series of things
that happen that leads up to something.

I don't think
that that was the defining factor

of killing him.

No.

But that was definitely a factor

that...

that made him not so innocent,
you know, to me.

[Nelson] You can't really hide
from yourself,

you know, when you're stuck in a cell
all by yourself.

That's helped me.

That's helped me to change,
to help me to examine who I really am

and not who I am
because of what I went through.

I'm more in touch with my feelings,
in touch with that side of myself

and more...

Yeah, I'm not angry,
I'm not in pain, I'm--

Or those things don't dominate my life,
you know?

Sometimes, I think I deserve to die

because, you know,
that's what our society believes.

That's the, you know,
that's... that's the price you pay

when you commit murder, sometimes.

But at the same time, I don't feel
like that I deserve to die either

because, you know, [stammers]

the death penalty, they say,
is reserved for worst of the worst.

But am I worst of the worst?

I know you can't look at me
without seeing that-- what I've done.

But I would just hope
that people could look at me and see,

not forgetting about that,
but seeing me as more than that.

And I... I know that's extremely hard
for people to do.

I understand that, and... and...

I just wanna-- you know,
I just wanna be seen for all that I am,

not that-- [stammers] that moment.

That one...

un... you know, unbelievable,
terrible, horrific decision.

I'm more than that, and...

Yeah, that was one of the motivators
for doing this, is I want...

I know that it's probably not
gonna matter much,

but I want people to know that,
that... that it's not so simple.

It's not that clear cut. It's... you know?