Dawson's Creek (1998–2003): Season 3, Episode 6 - Secrets and Lies - full transcript

Nominated for Capeside's Homecoming Queen, Jen wins and is put in charge of planning the Annual Homecoming Queen Gala, where she shocks the prim-and-proper committee president, Constance Freckling, and the entire town with the entertainment, while Jen also asks the painfully sky Henry to be her date. After Joey and Pacey save Andie from the libidos Rob, she wants to get back together with Pacey. But Joey becomes suspicious that Andie may have orchestrated the event to make Pacey her savior. Meanwhile, Dawson is distressed with his mother, Gail, unexpectedly returns from Philadelphia, and soon learns that she was fired from her job, while he is torn about telling Jen the scandalous secret he has about the departed Eve.

Genetic inevitability
is what it is.

What's what it is?

The fact that l'm turning
into my mother.

Take this whole
homecoming queen debacle.

Your mom was an HQ?

She was Miss Cape Cod.
Same difference.

Who graduated from
the swimsuit competition...

...to a life of cucumber sandwiches,
high teas and Junior League.

Point being?

That despite all my efforts,
l have managed to reach the pinnacle...

...of Capeside popular culture.

Dawson, l have sold my soul.

l've become that false character
who just follows their name around.

Beat yourself up much, Jen?

Only when l deserve it.

Another character flaw brought
to you from Mommy dearest.

l don't think anybody voted for you...

...because you're like your mom.
You got votes because you're different.

They voted for me because l'm blond
and l fill out my sweater.

That too, but l think--

No, when kids voted for you,
they voted for an outsider, you know?

Provocateur. Messiah to lead
them from the mainstream.

There she is. Miss Lindley,
may we interrupt?

With good news l hope, Mr. Milo.

Allow me to introduce to you
Capeside High's finest.

You are looking at half a century
of homecoming queens.

Ladies, may l present
Miss Jennifer Lindley.

1 999's proud addition to your number.

My name is Constance Freckling.

Of the Mayflower Frecklings.

Famous Freckling's Candies.

l'm the oldest living HQ.

Now, Jennifer, if you'll
extend your index finger...

...along the inside of my wrist,
like this.

Congratulations. You've just
learned the secret handshake.

Welcome to the club.
l've heard all about you.

You guys, it's all so exciting.

Now tell me, whose brilliant
idea was this again?

-Mine.
-Mine.

lt was her idea to craft this place
into a bed and breakfast.

l told her how to do it
for next to nothing.

Pacey, be sure and thank
your dad again for getting us the help.

Please. l finally figured out what the
police auxiliary in this town is for.

-Take it black?
-Yeah.

Okay, Potter, what's up?

Well, considering that...

...a lot of our insurance money
was swallowed up in this...

...l just hope it all works out.

-lt'll work.
-lt better.

l can't go back to the marina gig.

Yeah, whatever happened
with that creep anyhow?

Long story.
He was going out on a date...

...with somebody l know. l was
concerned and l tried to warn her...

...and as a result,
he fired me the next day.

Oh, what a charmer.

So who was the girl?

-No one you know.
-Really?

Yeah, Potter, do yourself a favour.

Don't ever go into politics, okay?

You're constitutionally incapable
of lying with a straight face.

So who was she?

Sorry.

l wasn't going to tell you, Pacey.

l feel like l just
got hit with a sledgehammer.

lf it's any consolation, it won't last.

l mean, Andie's way too smart
to fall for that jerk's act much longer.

lt's okay.

Whatever makes her happy, right?

Dad, l'm home.

Mom?

Hey.

-Oh, honey, l've missed you so much.
-What are you doing home?

-A mother can't surprise her son?
-l'm not complaining.

l can tell you why she's here.

This year's HQ gala.

Your father knows me too well.

Being an HQ from a certain
undisclosed year in the late '7 0s...

...yeah, l thought l'd come home.

Late '7 0s?

Hello, Gale.

Hi, Mitch.

You know, Jen's planning it.

The gala? Jen Lindley?

Yeah, Capeside's newest
homecoming queen.

How on earth did that happen?

Nobody's sure, though l'm interpreting
it as an early sign of the Armageddon.

Well, at the very least, that should
make for a fun time for us.

Were you actively looking in my
direction when you said '' us''?

Honey, l need an escort.

Hi.

l just remembered l got some
French vocab to study for.

-You don't take French.
-Well, all the more reason, right?

You told him.

Slipped out over breakfast.

Breakfast?

Yeah, Pacey's been helping
Bessie and me with the addition.

The one we're investing every
spare cent we have to build...

...so we can open soon and
financially barely scrape by.

Look, Joey, it wasn't
my fault that you got fired...

...and even if it was,
which it wasn't...

...you can't stay mad
at me forever, okay?

Not forever, but...

...a few solid months.

Okay, l don't know what Rob and l are.

All l know is, l can't help it.
l like him.

For now.

But l can promise you this:

You're going to get
a big, fat '' l told you so.''

Don't slouch, young lady.

Square your shoulders
and face the world.

What do you think?

Excuse me?

The dress.
lt's nearly finished.

l make a new one every year
for tomorrow's gala celebration.

Oh, that's what l wanted to--

One must remain modern, after all.
l'm thinking of lifting the hem...

...and softening the neckline a little.

Softening would be good.

-Listen, Mrs. Freckling--
-Miss Freckling.

l never married.

Oh. What in the...

-...world was that?
-Hank.

-Hank?
-My handyboy.

Lovely child.
Lives right down the road.

Presently, he's hanging extra
twinkle bulbs on my roof.

Yeah, about that party.

l hope that you don't mind, but...

...it's just that l've been through
this before with my mother...

...and she was constantly trying
to turn me into a debutante.

lt's just not really my thing.

Oh, but l do mind.

You have a responsibility, young lady...

...as the newly crowned queen,
to help me host this event.

l never asked for any of this.

Nor did l ask for you, Jennifer.

Most girls who walk through this door
are pleased as punch to be here.

They're sweet, upstanding,
enthusiastic girls...

...who relish the chance
to be role models.

They tend to stand up straight...

...comb their hair...

...and wear brassieres.

Am l making myself clear?

Crystal.

You're Hank?

Quick. Bees. Run for your life!

Just like the cops to disappear
when the going gets tough.

Some of them do have wives
and children to get home to.

Besides, we're almost done,
and l was thinking...

...you're gonna need a name
for this addition when we finish...

...so a suggestion, if l may.

How does the '' Pacey J. Witter Wing''
strike you?

Keep talking,
it'll be a memorial dedication.

You know, Potter, sometimes
your lack of gratefulness--

lt borders on unappealing.

Joey, it's for you.

And whoever it is, she sounds upset.

Hello?

Hello?

Joey?

Andie, is that you?

Joey, please help me.

Andie, what happened?

l don't wanna talk about it.
l just wanna go home.

Andie, you gotta tell us
what happened first.

Pacey, please.

Andie, what did he do?
Did he try to hurt you?

Andie, you gotta tell us.
What did this guy do to you?

We were upstairs in the bedroom...

...and we were just kissing.

And then he started trying to....

l kept saying no,
and he kept trying.

l managed to get away before
anything else happened...

...and that's when l came down
and called Joey...

...and can we just go now, please?

Where is he?

-Don't worry about it.
-ls he in there?

-Let's just go.
-l'm not leaving until l talk to him.

Pacey, no!

But l tell him, it is easy.

Hey, Rob.

You're here with Andie, right?

-What did you do?
-l didn't do anything!

That's why she's outside
bawling, right?

-Where is she?
-You're not going near her.

-Get out of my face, man.
-Chill out.

lf you so much as touch her again,
l am gonna nail you to a cross.

Wait a minute.
l didn't even lay a hand on her.

-Hey, save it for the judge, Logan.
-Get out of my house!

She probably made it up.

lt's really beautiful in here.

lsn't it?

You're looking at over 200 plants.

Bulbophyllum virginalis.

-You're making that up.
-No, l'm not. l swear.

Sometimes they get a little
suggestive with the names.

-Okay, give me another one.
-Okay.

Polystachya pubescens or...

...vanda vaginatum?

ls it hot in here,
or did you just make me blush?

Relax, Henry. lt's gonna take
a lot more than a flower to offend me.

How did you learn
so much about these?

Miss Freckling.

What's the deal with her?

What do you mean?

She's wound so tight,
she's like a violin string.

No, she's just sad.

-Sad?
-She's got no one in her life.

She never had kids, no relatives.

l've lived next door to her for 1 0 years.
l think l'm her best friend.

l don't know who to feel sorrier for,
you or her.

We're gonna have to toughen you up.

You keep wearing your heart on your
sleeve, you're gonna bleed to death.

lt's not me.

lt's her.

You have no idea how much she was
looking forward to meeting you.

-She was?
-l told her all about you.

See, the thing is, she has exactly
two events on her social calendar...

...the WOC in Miami every Spring--

-The WOC?
-The World Orchid Conference.

And in the fall,
the Homecoming Queen Gala.

lt's what she lives for.

Without them...

...she's got nothing at all.

Look...

...you need to go to the station tonight.

No, l can't go to the station.

Andie, you have to.
You have to talk to the police.

Joey, it's not like
he actually did anything.

Well, why don't you stay here? l don't
think you should be alone tonight.

Thanks, but l can't.

l can take care of this, Jo.

You sure?

Yeah.

Okay.

Miss Freckling?

Constance?

-She's got her aid turned off.
-Aid?

Hearing aid. Sometimes she
likes to tune out the world.

Oh, Hank, you startled me.

l ran into Jen outside.

Miss Freckling, l know that
we got off on the wrong foot...

...and l just wanted
to see if we could start over.

He is persuasive when
he wants to be, isn't he?

Well, l--

l'm just getting to know him.

Well, if he likes you,
you can't be all bad.

You know, l was just thinking
the same thing about you.

So should we wait
for the waters to calm...

...or just dive right in
to the party planning?

-l say dive right in.
-Very well.

Entertainment or food?
Take your pick.

-Entertainment?
-Surprise, surprise.

Now...

...since it's my house,
there are some rules.

Surprise, surprise.

No mimes, no magicians,
no Barry Manilow...

...no Elvis look-alikes,
no motivational speakers...

...no comedy troupes,
no break dancing...

...no gangster rap, animal tricks--

No nothing that you might
possibly see on Letterman.

What's Letterman?

How does a string quartet
playing Mozart strike you?

-Perfect.
-Okay, l'll split the difference.

l'm sure you will.

Oh, and there's one more thing.

What's that?

Well, he doesn't know it yet...

...but Hank here...

...is going as my date.

True Love.

That's ironic.

Yeah, well....

l figured since it didn't exist,
l'd try and create it for myself.

Why did you bring me here?

Because....

Well, you said you wanted
to go someplace quiet.

There's lots of quiet places, Pacey.

Yeah, l guess there are.

l guess l just wanted to
show you that l've been okay...

...since we ended things.

l've found a way to turn
what's been killing me...

...into something
potentially beautiful.

l haven't, Pacey.

l'm not over you.

You will be, McPhee.

See, even that. Just you
calling me by my last name....

Do you know how long
l've waited to hear that?

l think you've been through
a lot tonight. Let's not go there.

lf it took what happened tonight
to bring us together, then so be it.

We're not together.

l mean, l'm here for you,
but we're not together.

lf we're not together, then...

...l'm not sitting beside you...

...staring into your eyes...

...and kissing you.

Andie.

Sorry.

We just can't.

We can't.
For so many reasons, we can't.

l'm not asking you
what we can't do, Pacey.

l'm asking you what you want to do.

l want to know that you're okay.
That's all that matters to me now.

That's a shame, because you still
matter to me in every way.

l want to be with you, Pacey.

That's how you're feeling now, but
tomorrow could be a different story.

l'm not talking about tomorrow.
l'm talking about right now.

Tonight. You and me together,
under the stars...

...just like it used to be.

l'm talking about a kiss.

That's all l'm asking.

Don't you want to?

Thanks for taking care of me.

Right back at you, Andie.

l just wanna say,
for the record, about last night?

Whatever did or did not
happen between us...

...happened for a reason, and l,
for one, am 1 00 percent okay with it.

And wherever it may lead,
whatever status may result...

-...it's totally--
-Andie.

-l'm rambling.
-Yeah.

lt's an awkward moment and l'm scared,
and in scared moments, l ramble.

Sometimes people ramble
when they're--

Andie.

Rambling again. Right.

l guess l just wanna know that
you're feeling what l'm feeling.

l am.

That makes me so happy.

Okay.

Didn't you read the sign?

No known sex offenders
within 200 yards of my property.

l didn't do it!

Not bad.

You could use a little work
on the delivery, however.

l suggest a less forceful interpretation.

Joey, please, just tell me--

-Tell me she hasn't gone to the police.
-You touch me again...

...and l will scream faster than
you can say ''William Kennedy Smith.''

Look, Joey, she was the one that
wanted to go upstairs, okay?

She practically dragged me
up to that room.

And when we started kissing,
l swear, she just freaked out.

You don't have a lot of
credibility with me.

Fine. l admit it, okay?

But there is a difference between
a workplace flirtation--

And sexual assault?

You draw your own line in the sand,
Rob. They are both against the law.

l have never
forced myself on anyone.

lf you say so.

You know, it's no secret
that she's unstable.

No secret that she spent
some time in a mental hospital.

l'm going to pretend
that you never said that.

Then why would she do this?

That's all l wanna know!
For what possible reason?

Splendid.

Splendid.

l wonder where Jen is.

Don't look. Here comes Marilyn
Mendick and her husband.

-l haven't seen them in years.
-l can't stand that woman.

Gale, Dawson.

Neil, Marilyn.

l heard all about Philadelphia.

l'm sure you did. Excuse us.

We were just gonna get a drink.

-Actually, l'm quite proud of my mom.
-Oh, we all are.

Even if Philadelphia
didn't agree with her.

Honestly, l think it's
perfectly absurd...

...to fire an anchor because the public
felt she was too old to identify with.

You wouldn't hear them
saying that about Diane Sawyer.

Gale, l speak for the
whole county when l say...

...you'd be welcome back
on our airwaves anytime.

-Thank you, Neil.
-Shall we?

Mom, is there something
you want to tell me?

You're late.

The entertainment still isn't here.

And that wardrobe is far
from appropriate attire.

l demand you return home
and change this instant.

l can understand why she would turn
this into a travesty, but you, Henry?

Relax, okay? l put him up to it.

And you haven't seen anything yet.

l swear, it's hotter than a
French prostitute in this dress.

Who and what are they?

They are the entertainment.

l need to sit down.

Andie, have you told your dad?

Why? lt's only gonna upset him...

...and it's not like anything
cataclysmic happened.

Andie, this guy could have hurt you.

You don't know that, Joey...

...and maybe l overreacted.

Do you think you overreacted?

l didn't cry wolf.

-No. That's not what l'm saying.
-Then what are you saying?

l have to tell you something.

What?

Rob stopped by my house
this morning.

He told me his side of the story...

...and he basically got down on his
knees, pleading his innocence.

So that's why you're here.

You, of all people,
are gonna believe that scum.

l didn't say l believed him.

No? You just stopped by
for a friendly little chat.

No. l stopped by to make sure that
we were doing the right thing.

l should've reported the guy myself,
about his behaviour towards me.

l mean, maybe l could've
prevented this whole thing.

l think your water's boiling.

Listen, Joey...

...maybe all of this
happened for a reason.

l mean, maybe something
good came out of it.

What do you mean?

As of last night,
Pacey and l are back together.

l can't tell you how happy l am...

...because now everything can just
go back to the way it was.

Ladies and gentlemen, the moment
that you've all been waiting for.

Please help me in welcoming
the awesome talents of...

...Amanda Reckonwith,
Summer Clearance...

...Megan Whoopie
and Ms. Christy Anity.

Don't tell anyone, but l think
l got the hots for Christy.

l always knew you had
excellent taste in women.

-Constance is gonna kill me.
-Don't be so sure.

Down deep, buried somewhere,
l think that she gets it.

Gets what?

Homecoming queens, drag queens,
what's the difference?

All just people dressing up, pretending
to be something that they're not...

...playing a role.

-Come on.
-What--?

What are we doing?

Dancing, Henry.

ln hopes of performing a miracle
and awakening the dead.

l come bearing gifts.

-Hey, Andie.
-Hey.

l thought that True Love could
use a woman's touch.

What do you think?

To tell you the truth, what she could
use is a new rudder and a keel.

Okay. Would you settle
for a skipper's cap...

...and a pair of my dad's
old Top-Siders?

Very nice.

To be honest...

...l'm really starting to wonder whether
l'm ever gonna finish her at all.

Why do you say that?

Well, because sometimes...

...it's harder to rebuild something
than it is to just start from scratch.

Why?

That picture that you have in your
mind of the way something was...

...it's never gonna be that way again.

Yeah, but it could be better.

Yeah, it could be...

...depending on how badly
damaged it was in the first place.

How badly damaged was it?

lt was pretty much totalled.

Okay, Pacey, could we please stop
beating this metaphor to death...

...and just talk about what
we're actually talking about?

l made a mistake last night, Andie.

We both made a mistake.

What did we do? Nothing.

All l can tell you is
how it made me feel.

How?

Like l went against
what l know is right.

That's funny...

...because today is actually the
first day that l felt really happy...

...since l left the hospital.

lt is funny.

You know, there used to be a time...

...when you and l were so in sync...

...in everything that we did.
Just connected.

Look at us now.

We have the opposite reaction
to the exact same event.

Pacey, please don't do this.

Not now. Don't break up with me.

l never wanted to break up
with you, Andie, never.

l mean, all those months
just waiting, secretly hoping....

You're just--
You're just punishing me.

That's what this is about. You just
need to stop being angry with me.

l'm not punishing you, Andie.

Punishment implies
you did something wrong.

l slept with another guy
six months ago.

l knew it was wrong when l did it.
l keep trying to tell you this...

...and make you understand it.

How many times do l have to say it?

Andie...

...if you wanted to sleep with him...

...if even just for a second...

...then maybe it wasn't wrong.

-Maybe--
-lt was.

Maybe...

...that was just your heart's way of
telling you that l'm not the one.

Because that's what my heart's
telling me right now.

lt's telling me that you're not the one.

You don't mean that, Pacey.

Pacey, you can't mean that.

Andie, l'm sorry.

No. Just--

Just forget it.

Well, Jennifer...

...the evening wasn't a total disaster.

l will say one thing.

They sure do know how to dance.

That they do.

You know, Miss Freckling...

...l believe that l owe you an apology.

Whatever for?
Besides the obvious, that is.

Well, the truth is, is that
l intended to shock you tonight...

...but something
unexpected happened.

For the first time,
l was able to see past the clich?...

...and l actually enjoyed being
a homecoming queen.

Which brings us to one
small unresolved item:

Hank.

He adores you, you know.

lt's just a crush.
lt's completely harmless.

lt's more than that.

He talks about you non-stop.

Your presence in his life
has awakened him somehow.

lt's quite special.

Though my concern is
the sentiment's not mutual.

That would be correct.

l had a beau, once.

Heir to a mattress fortune.

Beautiful man.

l was 1 7.

We courted.

He asked me to marry him.

l remember it like yesterday.

He took off his hat...

...got down on one knee.

lt was at his mother's gravesite,
on the anniversary of her death.

What? He proposed
to you at a cemetery?

Looking back, l should've run
from there screaming...

...like a woman from
a burning house, but....

-But you didn't.
-No, l didn't.

But the wedding
never happened anyway.

He led me on, Jennifer.

Played me for a fool.

And then he ran off to California with
the girl who sold him his Cadillac.

But the point is...

...the heart is a fragile thing.

Break it too badly...

...and it might well never recover.

She calls it the Spotted Heart.

lt's her most sacred blossom.

Took her over 1 5 years
to breed it correctly.

lt's older than you are.

The world's most beautiful things are.

Henry.

l thought we were having fun.

We are.

But not like that.

You asked me
to come with you tonight.

Yes, l did.

Doesn't that count for something?

lt counts for us becoming friends.

Jen, l'm--

l think l'm in love with you.

Henry, you're not in love with me.

You can't say that.
How do you know what l feel?

You don't even know me.
How could you be in love with me?

Because l just-- l am.

-l wish it was that simple.
-lt is that simple.

lf it's age you're worried about, we're
not even two years apart. lt's nothing.

Right now, it's everything.

Do you know how much is gonna
happen to you in the next two years?

Your heart is gonna swell and break
a hundred times before you turn 1 6.

How does that make me
any less ready for you now?

l can still care about you
more than anyone ever has.

No offence,
but that's not saying much.

Then give me a shot.

What do you have to lose?

Listen, Henry,
what you need right now...

...is somebody who can understand
what you're going through...

...and who can also
go through it with you.

Believe me, everything
that you haven't done, l have.

Except fall in love?

You haven't done that.

Or else you'd have someone.

But you don't.

Which leads me to believe...

...that everything you think
you know about love is questionable.

And as long as it is...

...you can't tell me
l'm not the one for you.

Henry, what you need
to know about me...

...and it's something that l'm
just beginning to understand...

...is that until l can look at myself
without judgment or condemnation...

...l'm not ready for anyone.

Let alone you.

You know what you just said...

...about my heart breaking
a hundred times?

Well, there goes number one.

l'm sorry you didn't
feel you could tell me.

How does a mother tell a son...

...whom she's supposed to
be teaching to dream...

...that she failed at her own?

Mom.

First of all, you didn't fail.

And second of all, you don't look old.

You look great.

Thank you, honey.

Now, as for coming home....

Sweetheart, l have my reasons why
l don't want to race back to Capeside.

Right. And that's between you and Dad,
and l don't want to get in the middle.

-But--
-But...

...you think that l should
talk to him, don't you?

l just think you could use
a friend like him now.

lt's not that easy, Dawson.
There's way too much history there.

But there's no law saying that you
can't, you know, lean on him a little.

Tell him the truth.

-What's the worst that could happen?
-He could help me.

We could become friends again.

God help us.

You lied. You told me one thing and
then you went right behind my back.

You were supposed to be my friend.

l am, Andie.

You have such deep feelings...

...you went straight to Pacey
and sabotaged everything?

Pacey? l haven't even talked to Pacey
since you guys dropped me off.

And l'm supposed to believe that?

Well, it's the truth.

So it's just a coincidence
that one minute we're together...

...and the next he never
wants to see me again?

-When did this happen?
-Tonight. An hour ago.

After you told him l made up the entire
story about Rob just to get him back.

Look. Okay, Andie, l admit...

...it did cross my mind.

But l didn't believe it,
not for a minute.

-ls that right?
-Look.

l know you.

l know that you're a good person.

You would never do anything
so hurtful and plainly wrong.

What? What did l say?

Nothing.

-You can tell me, Andie.
-Look, you don't know me, Joey, okay?

You don't know what l'm capable of
when l set my sights on something.

Andie, you're a stubborn
and determined person.

-There's nothing wrong with that.
-No!

lt's more.
lt's like l've got blinders on.

All l can see is what's in front of me,
and everything on the edges just gets...

...blocked out somehow.

What are you talking about?

l'm talking about Pacey.

l love him and l need him.

And the truth is....

l don't know what
the truth is anymore.