Criminal Minds (2005–…): Season 4, Episode 2 - The Angel Maker - full transcript
On the anniversary of a serial killer's execution, a murder spree which appears to be connected to him begins and the team must try and understand his mind in order to stop it.
PREVIOUSLY, ON CRIMINAL MINDS...
OH, MY GOD!
THAT'S HOTCH AND KATE!
[CAR ALARM BLARING]
[MUTED]
HEY, ARE YOU OK?
HOTCHNER--IS HE OK?
HE CAN'T FLY
FOR A LITTLE BIT.
HIS EARS ARE--
BUT HE'S GONNA BE FINE.
[TAPPING]
[CLATTERING]
[CLATTERING]
OH. JEEZ, BO,
YOU SCARED ME HALF TO DEATH.
SUCH A CLICHE.
SEE THAT, BO?
GUESS I'M SUPPOSED TO MAKE
A WISH OR SOMETHING, RIGHT?
[MEOW]
COME ON, BO.
[MECHANICAL HUMMING]
HOW IS THE BUZZING NOW?
IT'S OK. I THINK
I COULD ACTUALLY
GET USED TO THAT PART.
THE PROBLEM IS DEALING
WITH THE PAIN.
YOU'RE EXPERIENCING
HYPERACUSIS.
IT'S CAUSED
BY SUDDEN LOUD NOISES,
LIKE AN EXPLOSION.
SO WHAT DO WE DO
ABOUT IT, DOCTOR?
YOU HAVE A SMALL TEAR
IN YOUR RIGHT EARDRUM.
WE'LL TREAT THAT
WITH A BONDING AGENT.
IT'LL MOST LIKELY HEAL
ITSELF IN A WEEK OR TWO.
MOST LIKELY?
THE CONDITION CAN
SOMETIMES BECOME PERMANENT.
BUT I CAN GO
BACK TO WORK?
PUTTING SOMEONE IN THE FIELD
WITH ACUTE SENSITIVITY
TO SOUND WOULD BE A MISTAKE.
AGENT HOTCHNER,
IF YOU'RE NOT CAREFUL,
YOU COULD LOSE
YOUR HEARING ENTIRELY.
I UNDERSTAND.
GOOD.
BUT YOU'LL...
SIGN MY RETURN TO DUTY?
WHAT IF I SAID I'D...
TAKE IT EASY AND...
LIMIT MY ROLE
IN THE FIELD?
STAY OUT OF LOUD PLACES.
[CELL PHONE RINGING]
YOUR PHONE IS RINGING.
WHAT'S UP, JJ?
THIS IS DELILAH GRENNAN.
SHE WAS BLUDGEONED AND RAPED
DURING THE NIGHT AT HER HOME
IN LOWER CANAAN, OHIO.
LOWER WHERE?
SMALL TOWN 40 MILES
OUTSIDE OF CINCINNATI.
STAGING THE BODY
FACE-UP
WITH THE ARMS ACROSS
THE CHEST LIKE THAT.
RITUAL.
NICE HAIR, BY THE WAY.
AHEM. THANKS.
UH, THERE'S MORE.
SMALL PUNCTURE WOUNDS
ON HER STOMACH.
NOTE THE LACK OF BLOOD.
THEY WERE INFLICTED
POSTMORTEM.
WERE THERE
ANY OTHER VICTIMS?
KIND OF.
VICTIMOLOGY AND SIGNATURE
MATCH A SERIAL KILLER
FROM THE SAME TOWN
10 YEARS AGO--
6 VICTIMS SPANNING
OVER 10 MONTHS.
HE CALLED HIMSELF--
THE ANGEL MAKER.
I REMEMBER THE CASE.
Reid:
THEY CAUGHT THAT GUY.
Rossi: AND EXECUTED HIM.
THAT'S RIGHT.
HE WAS PUT TO DEATH
BY LETHAL INJECTION
A YEAR AGO YESTERDAY.
YESTERDAY.
Morgan: SO WE'RE LOOKING
FOR A COPYCAT.
HONORING THE ANNIVERSARY
OF HIS HERO'S DEATH.
IT SAYS HERE
THEY FOUND SEMEN
AT THE CRIME SCENE.
PERHAPS LOCALS WILL GET
A DNA MATCH WHEN THEY
RUN IT THROUGH VICAP?
WELL, THAT'S
WHERE IT GETS WEIRD.
THEY RAN IT ALREADY
AND THEY GOT A MATCH, TOO.
WELL, IF THEY
ALREADY HAVE A NAME,
WHY'D THEY CALL US?
THEY'VE GOT TO BE KIDDING.
THE MATCH THEY GOT BACK
ON THE DNA
IS TO A CORTLAND BRYCE RYAN,
OTHERWISE KNOWN AS...
THE ANGEL MAKER.
Hotchner: "WE ALL DIE.
"THE GOAL ISN'T TO LIVE FOREVER.
THE GOAL IS TO CREATE
SOMETHING THAT WILL."
CHUCK PALAHNIUK.
Reid: THE ANGEL MAKER'S
VICTIMS WERE BEATEN
WITH THE ASSAILANT'S
BARE HANDS.
AND THEN DELILAH GRENNAN
WAS BLUDGEONED
WITH A HEAVY INSTRUMENT,
MAYBE A HAMMER.
OK, SO THIS UNSUB'S
A WEAKER GUY,
OR AT LEAST SOMEONE
WHO PERCEIVES
HIMSELF THAT WAY.
SO HE BROUGHT ALONG
THE HAMMER TO MAKE CERTAIN
HIS VICTIM WOULDN'T
FIGHT BACK?
THEY HAVE PARACHUTES
ON-BOARD, RIGHT?
THEY SHOULD. IT'S STANDARD
ON ALL FEDERAL AIR TRANSPORT.
MAYBE WE CAN GIVE ONE TO
THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM,
GET HIM OUT OF HERE?
THAT'D BE THE ELEPHANT
WITH THE DEAD MAN'S DNA.
WELL, OBVIOUSLY
SOMEBODY PLANTED THE
SEMEN ON THE VICTIM.
IN THE VICTIM.
THAT'S ONE THEORY.
THERE'S ANOTHER?
THINK ABOUT WHO SHARES
THE EXACT DNA MAKEUP
OF ANOTHER PERSON.
REID, YOU'RE NOT SERIOUSLY
FLOATING AROUND THE IDEA
OF AN EVIL TWIN, ARE YOU?
NO, I'M NOT.
I'M FLOATING THE IDEA
OF AN EVILER TWIN.
TRADITIONALLY, THE
CONCEPT IS A GOOD TWIN
AND AN EVIL TWIN.
BUT IN THIS CASE,
IT'S EVIL TWIN,
EVILER TWIN.
[HIGH-PITCHED TONE]
HOTCH?
YEAH.
YOU HAVE BEEN CLEARED
TO FLY, HAVEN'T YOU?
BEFORE CORTLAND RYAN,
THIS TOWN HADN'T SEEN
A HOMICIDE IN OVER 30 YEARS.
HE DIDN'T JUST KILL
THOSE 6 WOMEN.
HE KILLED A WAY OF LIFE.
NOW THIS THING'S GOT PEOPLE
THINKING HE'S COME BACK.
THEY DON'T
REALLY THINK
THAT, DO THEY?
I GUESS WHEN YOU'VE
BEEN SCARED BY SOMETHING,
I MEAN REALLY SCARED,
THAT FEAR'S IN YOU FOREVER.
LET'S STICK TO THE FACTS.
WERE THERE SIGNS
OF FORCED ENTRY?
NONE THAT WE COULD FIND,
BUT WHOEVER KILLED
DELILAH GRENNAN
OPENED UP EVERY WINDOW
IN THIS HOUSE
BEFORE HE LEFT.
THAT'S A SIGNATURE FROM
THE PREVIOUS MURDERS.
A DETAIL WE NEVER
RELEASED TO THE PUBLIC.
AND IT CAME OUT
AT THE TRIAL?
NO, SIR. PROSECUTION HAD RYAN
NAILED 9 WAYS TO SUNDAY.
DIDN'T NEED IT.
SO I'M HARD-PRESSED TO KNOW
HOW THIS COPYCAT KNEW
ABOUT THOSE WINDOWS.
THE MAN WE'RE LOOKING
FOR IS MOST LIKELY A FAN
WHO EXHAUSTIVELY STUDIED
THE FIRST KILLINGS
AND USED THEM TO FORM
HIS OWN MURDER FANTASIES.
HE KNOWS THIS CASE
AS WELL AS US,
EVEN BETTER, MAYBE,
IF HE HAD ACTUAL CONTACT
WITH RYAN WHILE
HE WAS INCARCERATED.
WE SENT ONE OF OUR AGENTS
TO HAWKESVILLE PRISON
TO LOOK INTO IT.
AND THE SEMEN?
SMUGGLED OUT OF THE PRISON,
KEPT ON ICE, BROUGHT OUT
ON THE ANNIVERSARY
OF THE EXECUTION.
THERE'S AN ENTIRE
COTTAGE INDUSTRY BASED ON
SERIAL KILLER EFFECTS
AND MEMORABILIA.
YOU CAN FIND ABSOLUTELY
ANYTHING IF YOU KNOW
THE RIGHT PEOPLE.
QUESTION IS, IS THIS
A ONE-TIME COMMEMORATION
OR IS IT JUST
THE BEGINNING?
Prentiss: WHAT ABOUT
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS?
MY BEST GUESS IS
A SMALL SCREWDRIVER,
LIKE A PHILLIPS HEAD.
JUST LIKE THE PRIOR MURDERS.
THIS GUY'S A STICKLER
FOR THE DETAILS.
THE GROUPINGS
IN THE PRIOR VICTIMS
WERE ALWAYS DIFFERENT
IN NUMBER AND ARRANGEMENT.
3 WOUNDS ON THIS ONE.
5, 24.
HE WAS ALL OVER THE MAP.
I ALSO FOUND TRACES
OF PAPER IN THE WOUNDS.
PAPER? LIKE TISSUE?
LIKE NOTEBOOK PAPER.
WELL, THAT'S NEW.
UNIQUE TO THE COPYCAT.
I...
WHAT IS IT?
I DON'T KNOW.
IT JUST SEEMS FAMILIAR.
[CART RATTLING]
RYAN DIDN'T HAVE
ANY NEXT OF KIN,
SO AFTER THE EXECUTION,
ALL OF HIS EFFECTS
GOT BOXED AND STORED.
THIS IS ALL
HIS CORRESPONDENCE?
COPIES, AT LEAST.
HELPS THE WARDEN KEEP TABS
ON CERTAIN PRISONERS
IF HE CAN KNOW WHAT'S
IN THEIR MAIL.
THERE'S A LOT
OF LETTERS.
A LOT OF FANS.
REAL LADY KILLER.
WHAT ABOUT MALE FANS?
SOME, YEAH. FREAKS.
THIS ONE KID WOULD COME BY--
MUSICIAN, I THINK--
BLACK CLOTHES AND EYELINER
AND ALL THAT.
HE SENT RYAN HIS DEMO TAPE
AND SOME SHEET MUSIC
HE WROTE IN HIS OWN BLOOD.
DID YOU EVER CATCH RYAN
TRYING TO SMUGGLE
ANYTHING OUT,
TO THIS KID
OR ANYONE ELSE?
THE USUAL PROBLEM
WE HAVE IS STUFF BEING
SMUGGLED IN, NOT OUT.
HIS DNA WAS FOUND
AT A FRESH CRIME SCENE
IN LOWER CANAAN.
WHAT KIND OF DNA
WE TALKING ABOUT?
THE TYPE OF DNA THAT
CATS IN LOCKUP DON'T
HAVE OCCASION TO USE.
ALL RIGHT. WELL, LISTEN,
THANK YOU FOR ALL THIS,
BUT I WANT TO LOOK
AT ALL YOUR VISITOR
LOGS, ALL RIGHT?
[CELL PHONE RINGS]
EXCUSE ME.
YEAH, JJ?
OK, UH...
YEAH, I'M HEADED
RIGHT BACK.
SOMETHING WRONG?
A LOCAL NEWSPAPER
JUST GOT A LETTER
FROM SOMEONE CLAIMING
TO BE THE ANGEL MAKER.
"I GIVE YOU A LEGACY,
A BREATH OF LIFE
"FROM THE ANGEL MAKER HIMSELF.
"THOSE WHO PRAYED TO FORGET ME
WILL ONE DAY SEE MY FACE
AND SHRINK IN FEAR."
THAT'S THE LAST THING
PEOPLE NEED RIGHT NOW.
REID, HOW'S IT COMPARE
WITH THE ORIGINAL
CORRESPONDENCE?
THEY SHARE SOME COMPELLING
CHARACTERISTICS.
I'D OBVIOUSLY LIKE TO LOOK
AT IT UNDER MAGNIFICATION
WITH A BETTER LIGHT.
BEST GUESS, REID?
I'D SAY IT'S AUTHENTIC.
HOW CAN THIS LETTER
BE AUTHENTIC IF THE GUY'S
BEEN DEAD FOR A YEAR?
COULD BE
AN ELABORATE FORGERY.
OR IT COULD BE
THE GENUINE ARTICLE,
JUST WRITTEN
BEFORE HIS DEATH.
WELL, MAIL HERE
ISN'T THAT SLOW.
OR RELEASED THROUGH
AN INTERMEDIARY.
YOU MEAN THE COPYCAT?
WE'RE GOING OVER
THE PRISON VISITOR LOGS
TO CHECK WHO HAD
MULTIPLE VISITS WITH RYAN,
TRY TO NARROW
OUR SUSPECT POOL.
SELA?
WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?
IS IT TRUE?
THERE'S A LETTER?
HOW DID YOU KNOW?
YOU DIDN'T REALLY THINK
YOU COULD KEEP THAT QUIET
AROUND HERE.
THE LETTER'S NOT FROM HIM,
NOT THE WAY PEOPLE
MIGHT BE SAYING.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
IT...
IT MEANS WE THINK
HE HAS SOMEONE ON
THE OUTSIDE, A FRIEND.
WHAT IF YOU'RE WRONG?
WHAT IF--
THERE'S NO SUCH THING
AS GHOSTS, SELA.
I'M NOT TALKING
ABOUT A GHOST.
I AM TALKING
ABOUT THOSE RUMORS
ABOUT THE EXECUTION,
HOW THERE WERE PROBLEMS,
HOW IT DIDN'T WORK RIGHT.
WHAT ARE YOU SUGGESTING?
WHAT IF HE'S STILL
OUT THERE?
DON'T DO THAT.
YOU THINK
I'M THE ONLY ONE?
LOOK OUTSIDE.
THEY WANT PROOF
THAT HE'S DEAD.
I HAVE TO ADVISE
AGAINST THIS.
WELL, DUE RESPECT,
BUT THIS ISN'T YOUR TOWN.
I HAVE TO CONVINCE THEM
THAT CORTLAND RYAN
IS DEAD AND BURIED.
BUT YOU'RE INDULGING
THIS KILLER BY PERPETUATING
THE RUSE HE'S CREATED.
HE'S RIGHT.
IT MAY EMBOLDEN HIM,
PROMPT MORE MURDERS.
SELA LOST HER ONLY DAUGHTER
TO THAT BASTARD.
WE MET WHEN I WAS WORKING
THE CASE, GREW CLOSE.
I THOUGHT WE'D GOTTEN
PAST ALL THIS,
BUT I GUESS I WAS
KIDDING MYSELF.
[TRACTOR ENGINE TURNS OVER]
[HIGH-PITCHED TONE]
HOTCH?
HOTCH?
[MUTED] IS THERE
ANYTHING I CAN DO?
HOTCH, ARE YOU
ALL RIGHT?
CAN I DO ANYTHING?
YEAH, I'M OK,
I'M OK, I'M OK. OK.
MY GOD.
CORTLAND RYAN IS DEAD.
THERE'S NO TWO WAYS
ABOUT IT.
WE'RE JUST TRYING TO BE
THOROUGH, DR. HAGEN.
WE HEARD THAT THERE MAY
HAVE BEEN IRREGULARITIES
WITH THE EXECUTION.
HIS HEART WAS STOPPED.
HIS PUPILS WERE
NONRESPONSIVE.
TRUST ME.
THIS IS NOT THE FIRST EXECUTION
I'VE PRONOUNCED AT.
BUT IT WAS THE LAST.
DID SOMETHING HAPPEN
THAT DAY
TO PROMPT YOUR
RESIGNATION FROM THE
CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT?
EVERYONE DIES DIFFERENT.
RYAN WENT HARD, IS ALL.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN, DOCTOR?
Doctor: AFTER WE CYCLED
THE DRUGS, WE REALIZED
HE WAS STILL ALIVE.
WE WEREN'T PREPARED FOR THAT.
HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?
THE CATHETER DISLODGED.
WE REINSERTED IT,
STARTED
THE POTASSIUM CHLORIDE.
HE STARTED...SHAKING.
[WHIMPERING]
SPITTING.
HE WAS SUFFOCATING.
CATHETER FAILED AGAIN.
TOOK HIM ALMOST
AN HOUR TO DIE,
ALMOST AS IF SOMETHING
WERE KEEPING HIM HERE.
HE SAID THIS WAS GOING
TO HAPPEN, YOU KNOW.
THAT WHAT WAS GONNA HAPPEN?
HIS LAST WORDS--
HE SAID HE'D COME BACK.
YOU MAY THINK YOU'VE SEEN
THE LAST OF ME,
BUT DEATH CANNOT
TAKE ME FROM YOU.
I WILL BE BORN AGAIN.
TODAY YOU MAKE ME A LEGEND.
ALWAYS HAD A FLAIR
FOR THE DRAMATIC.
SET THE STAGE PERFECTLY--
A LATTER-DAY LAZARUS
RETURNING TO
DELIVER HELL ON EARTH.
WE NEED TO DEBUNK THIS,
OR THE WHOLE TOWN'S
GONNA PANIC.
A LITTLE LATE
FOR THAT.
THE GRAVE-ROBBING
WE CAN EXPLAIN.
IT HAS TO BE A FAN.
YOU THINK
THE SAME PERSON
THAT DID
THE COPYCAT MURDER
TOOK RYAN'S BODY?
IT'S POSSIBLE.
HE HAD TO HAVE HELP.
SOMEONE ON THE INSIDE.
I SUPPOSE YOU'RE
GONNA TELL ME
THERE'S A COTTAGE
INDUSTRY FOR THAT, TOO.
Garcia: DID YOU KNOW
THAT JOHN WAYNE GACY
PAINTED CLOWNS?
A MURDERING PEDOPHILE
PAINTS CLOWNS,
AND PEOPLE HANG THEM
ON THEIR WALLS.
IT'S CREEPY ON SO MANY LEVELS.
I MEAN, CLOWNS--
GARCIA, I DIDN'T KNOW
YOU HAD THAT HANG-UP.
COULROPHOBIA--
ABNORMAL FEAR OF CLOWNS.
Garcia: OH, NO, THERE IS
NOTHING ABNORMAL ABOUT IT.
WHEN I WAS 12, A HOBO CLOWN
GROPED MY BREAST
AT A BIRTHDAY PARTY
AND MADE THIS OLD-TIMEY
HONKING NOISE WHEN HE DID IT.
APPARENTLY MAKING IT FUNNY
MAKES IT OK.
WERE YOU ABLE TO FIND
ANY AUCTIONS ON ANGEL MAKER
MEMORABILIA?
OH, MY VISION.
I FOUND A TON.
MR. MAKER WAS QUITE
THE SELF-PROMOTER.
HE AUTOGRAPHED EVERYTHING--
PHOTOS, PANTIES,
AND FOR THE DISCERNING
COLLECTOR, SCREWDRIVERS.
YOU GOT TO BE
KIDDING ME.
Garcia: YEAH.
HE ALSO MADE THESE LITTLE
ORIGAMI FIGURINES OUT OF
CIGARETTE BOXES,
WHICH, I HATE TO SAY,
ARE REALLY CUTE.
DID YOU PINPOINT
THE MOST ACTIVE
COLLECTORS?
THAT WOULD BE
HIS OVERSEAS FANS.
WHAT ABOUT
LOCAL BUYERS
WHO ALSO TURNED UP
ON THE PRISON
VISITOR LOG?
ZILCH.
WHAT ABOUT SELLERS?
A HIGH-VOLUME BROKER MIGHT KNOW
A BROADER SPECTRUM OF FANS.
Garcia: THERE IS ONE GUY
IN PARTICULAR WHO SEEMS TO BE
THE LOCAL DISTRIBUTOR,
AS IT WERE.
YOU GOT A NAME?
SHEBANG!
SID RUTLEDGE.
RUTLEDGE?
YOU KNOW HIM?
HE'S A GUARD
AT HAWKESVILLE.
SID RUTLEDGE, FBI.
OPEN UP.
JUST WANT TO TALK.
I CAN'T SEE ANYONE.
OH, GUY'S GOT TWO DEADBOLTS,
HE DOESN'T USE EITHER?
Morgan: SID?
SID,
WE'RE COMING IN.
WAKEY, WAKEY,
MY MAN.
DAMN.
ONE TO THE GRILL,
ONE TO THE GROIN.
THAT'S PERSONAL.
YEAH, WELL, IF RUTLEDGE WAS
SELLING THE UNSUB MEMORABILIA,
HE KNEW HIS IDENTITY.
NOW THE UNSUB'S
COVERING HIS TRACKS.
RUTLEDGE PROBABLY
CONTACTED HIM
AFTER YOU PAID A VISIT
TO THE PRISON.
HE LET HIM IN,
LET HIS GUARD DOWN,
BOOM.
WHEW. A LITTLE, UH,
HEAVY ON THE OLD SPICE.
STRIKES ME
AS AN AQUA VELVA GUY.
OH! MAN, YOU'RE GOOD.
HEY, IT LOOKS LIKE
HE TOOK SOMETHING.
HELLO.
I THINK WE'VE GOT
THIS UNSUB ALL WRONG.
THERE HAVE BEEN
SOME STRANGE HAPPENINGS
IN THIS CASE,
BUT I URGE YOU NOT TO
ABANDON REASON IN
THE SEARCH OF THE TRUTH.
THIS IS NOT THE WORK
OF A GHOST,
AND IT'S NOT THE WORK
OF A KILLER COME BACK
FROM THE DEAD.
THIS IS THE WORK OF SOMEBODY
WHO LIVES RIGHT HERE
IN LOWER CANAAN,
AND THIS PERSON
IS A WOMAN.
HER LAST VICTIM,
SID RUTLEDGE--
HE WAS THE ANGEL MAKER'S
MULE.
HE SMUGGLED ITEMS
OUT OF HAWKESVILLE PRISON,
INCLUDING THE SEMEN
THAT WAS PLANTED AT
THE FIRST CRIME SCENE.
SHE KILLED RUTLEDGE
BECAUSE HE KNEW
SHE WAS THE COPYCAT,
AND ALSO BECAUSE HE WAS
BLACKMAILING HER.
SO I'M THINKING YOU
AND I NEED TO TALK.
WE NOW KNOW THAT
RUTLEDGE WAS TRANSFERRED
TO HAWKESVILLE
FROM A FEMALE PRISON,
IN THE WAKE OF ALLEGATIONS
THAT HE WAS USING
HIS POSITION
TO LEVERAGE SEXUAL FAVORS
FROM INMATES.
AND WE THINK HE DID
THE SAME THING TO OUR UNSUB--
IN EXCHANGE FOR HIS SILENCE,
HE WANTED SEX.
BECAUSE SHE SHOT HIM
IN THE JUNK, RIGHT?
THAT AND THE FACT
THAT HE TOOK A PDE-5 INHIBITOR
SHORTLY BEFORE HIS MURDER.
A WHAT?
VIAGRA.
WE'RE LOOKING
FOR A WHITE WOMAN
IN HER MID-30s,
AND SHE'S HIGHLY
INTELLIGENT.
AND SHE'S NOT JUST
A FAN, SHE'S A GROUPIE.
NOW, SHE'S NOT WHAT
YOU WOULD NORMALLY EXPECT.
MORE OFTEN THAN NOT,
THEY'RE ATTRACTIVE,
THEY'RE WELL-EDUCATED,
THEY'RE SUCCESSFUL.
SOME ARE EVEN MARRIED.
GENERALLY,
THEY FALL INTO TYPES.
SOME ARE REFORMERS.
THEY'RE ON A MISSION
TO SAVE OR RESCUE
THESE MURDERERS.
OFTEN, THIS TYPE
OF GROUPIE HAS BEEN
RAISED IN A REPRESSIVE,
RELIGIOUS ENVIRONMENT
AND SPECIFICALLY
HAVE BEEN EXPOSED
TO THE IDEALS OF
SEXUAL REPRESSION AND
SUBJUGATION OF WOMEN.
OUR UNSUB IS
A DIFFERENT TYPE,
ONE WHO SUFFERS
FROM HYBRISTOPHILIA.
IT'S A SEXUAL ATTRACTION
TO MEN WHO COMMIT
VIOLENT CRIMES.
THEY GIVE HER A POWER
THAT SHE LACKS,
WHICH STEMS FROM
LOW SELF-ESTEEM
AND A NEED FOR
A FATHER FIGURE.
WELL, THE VICTIMS WERE RAPED.
HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN THAT?
SHE'S USING AN INSTRUMENT
TO SIMULATE THE SEXUAL
ASSAULT.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT SHE KEEPS
IN HER RAPE KIT,
ALONG WITH THE WEAPON
THAT SHE'S USING
TO BLUDGEON HER VICTIMS.
THIS IS A LIST OF WOMEN
WHO VISITED AND WROTE
THE ANGEL MAKER
WHILE HE WAS IN PRISON.
WE'VE STARTED TO TRACK
THESE LEADS, BUT THE LIST
IS EXTENSIVE,
SO WE'RE GONNA NEED
YOUR HELP.
HEY, YOU EVER GET GROUPIES
AT YOUR BOOK SIGNING?
SOMETIMES,
IF BARRY MANILOW
ISN'T IN TOWN.
ANY OF THEM
LOOK LIKE THAT?
SHARA CARLINO.
SHE VISITED RYAN
OVER 70 TIMES.
WAITS AN AVERAGE
OF 3 HOURS FOR
A 10-MINUTE VISIT,
MANDATORY STRIP SEARCH.
WOULD YOU ENDURE
THAT FOR A GUY?
FOR BARRY MANILOW,
MAYBE.
SHE WAS A MARKETING VP
IN CINCY TILL '99,
MOVED HERE, TOOK
AN OUTSIDE SALES JOB,
COMMISSION ONLY--
SERIOUS PAY CUT.
I'M GUESSING SHE CAME
FOR THE VIEW.
ACCORDING TO THESE LOGS,
YOU WERE THE ANGEL MAKER'S
NUMBER-ONE FAN.
HIS NAME IS CORTLAND,
AND I WASN'T A FAN.
HOW WOULD YOU
CHARACTERIZE
YOUR RELATIONSHIP?
WE WERE LOVERS.
LAST TIME I CHECKED,
THEY DIDN'T ALLOW
CONJUGAL VISITS
ON DEATH ROW.
IT WASN'T ABOUT
PHYSICAL INTERACTION.
WHEN YOU TAKE AWAY
THE FLESH,
THERE'S ONLY THE SOUL.
EVERYTHING WAS UNDERSTOOD.
THERE WERE NO SECRETS.
CORTLAND MADE ME
FEEL ALIVE,
IN A WAY
NO FREE MAN EVER COULD.
WHERE WERE YOU ON
THE 16th OF THIS MONTH?
WHY?
WE BELIEVE
THIS COPYCAT KILLING
WAS COMMITTED
BY A FEMALE FAN,
SOMEONE WHO KNEW
CORTLAND VERY WELL.
I WAS OUT OF TOWN
WITH THE COMPANY.
ASK ANYONE HERE.
DO YOU KNOW ANOTHER WOMAN
CORTLAND--
THERE WERE NO OTHERS.
I CAN SHOW YOU
LOGS, PHOTOCOPIES
OF FAN LETTERS,
WOMEN WHO SENT
CORTLAND PICTURES,
THEIR UNDERWEAR--
THEY DIDN'T MEAN
ANYTHING TO HIM.
BUT WHATEVER
CONNECTION YOU HAD
WITH CORTLAND
WAS SEVERED
WHEN HE DIED.
NOT THE COPYCAT'S.
EVERY TIME
SHE KILLS,
IT REINFORCES
THEIR LOVE.
THAT IS, OF COURSE,
UNLESS YOU HELP US STOP HER.
HE SENT ME A LETTER
A FEW MONTHS
BEFORE HE--HE WAS...
I KNEW IT WASN'T
MEANT FOR ME,
BECAUSE IT WAS ADDRESSED
TO..."MY DOVE."
HE NEVER CALLED ME THAT.
DO YOU STILL HAVE IT?
NO.
I BURNED IT.
DID THE TEXT REVEAL ANYTHING
ABOUT THE WOMAN?
THE TEXT WAS A JOKE.
USUALLY HIS PROSE WAS
SEAMLESS
AND BEAUTIFUL, BUT...
THIS WAS...
PEDESTRIAN AND CRUDE.
YOU NEVER ASKED HIM
WHO THIS DOVE WAS?
I THOUGHT THERE WERE
NO SECRETS BETWEEN YOU.
YOU'VE NEVER BEEN
IN LOVE, HAVE YOU?
VICTIM'S
MAXINE CHANDLER.
NEIGHBORS SAY
SHE'S LIVED HERE
HER WHOLE LIFE,
ALL 28 YEARS
OF IT, ANYWAY.
HOW MANY KIDS DOES SHE HAVE?
WELL, NONE
OF HER OWN.
RUNS A DAY CARE.
THE GUY WHO CALLED 911
CAME HERE TO DROP OFF
HIS TODDLER,
FOUND MAXINE IN HER BEDROOM.
CORONER'S IN THERE WITH HER NOW.
YOU CHECK ALL ENTRY POINTS?
YEAH. NO DAMAGE,
NO TOOL MARKS.
SAME AS THE FIRST.
NOW THAT WE HAVE
TWO VICTIMS, WE HAVE
DATA WE CAN COMPARE.
WE SHOULD SEE
WHAT VICTIMOLOGY
CAN TELL US.
I'LL GET JJ
TO BRING US THE FILES
ON THE FIRST VICTIM.
WHAT'D YOU FIND?
WELL, I PUT THE TIME
OF DEATH AROUND 2 A.M.
VICTIM WAS STRUCK
MULTIPLE TIMES WITH
A BLUNT OBJECT.
SIGNS OF PENETRATION,
FLUIDS.
SAME POSTMORTEM
MUTILATION?
SAME, BUT, UH,
DIFFERENT.
9 PUNCTURE MARKS
THIS TIME.
I WISH I COULD SAY
THIS WAS ABOUT THE UNSUB'S
DISORGANIZED BEHAVIOR
OR MOUNTING RAGE.
IT DOESN'T FEEL
THAT WAY.
NO, THEY DEFINITELY
MEAN SOMETHING.
CAN I HAVE YOUR PEN?
YEAH. WHAT IS IT?
I'M NOT SURE.
SHE DID THIS.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
THE UNSUB.
SHE MADE THESE DOTS
LIKE THIS
BEFORE SHE MADE
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS.
THAT'S WHY THE CORONER
FOUND PAPER IN THE WOUNDS.
IT WAS A TEMPLATE.
THE ANGEL MAKER DID IT
FROM MEMORY,
BUT SHE NEEDED A GUIDE
TO GET IT RIGHT.
WE NEED TO GO BACK
AND RE-EXAMINE EACH OF
THE PATTERNS. WHERE'S REID?
HERE'S ANOTHER ONE TO DOVE--
NOVEMBER 2, 2006.
SAME THING?
YEAH.
"WEATHER IS GOOD HERE.
OUT IN THE GARDEN ALL DAY.
BIRDS LAND ON THE FENCE.
THE MOON IS FULL NOW."
HE GOT AN HOUR A DAY
IN A CONCRETE YARD.
THERE WAS NO GARDEN.
THERE WERE NO BIRDS.
DEATH ROW HAIKU.
I MEAN, YOU HAVE TO TRY
TO WRITE THIS BAD.
I THINK HE DID.
HE TRIED VERY HARD
TO PUT EACH WORD,
EACH LETTER, EVEN,
IN THE RIGHT ORDER.
SO IT'S A CODE.
THIS STEGANOGRAPHIC
METHOD WOULD ALLOW HIM
TO WRITE LETTERS
THAT DON'T APPEAR
ENCIPHERED.
THE REAL MESSAGE
WOULD BE HIDING
IN PLAIN SIGHT.
WHAT DO YOU NEED
TO CRACK IT?
THE ABILITY
TO CLONE MYSELF
AND A YEAR'S SUPPLY
OF ADDERALL.
I'LL PUT ON THE COFFEE.
SMALL TOWNS SUCK
FOR VICTIMOLOGY.
TOO MUCH OVERLAP.
I'VE GOT BOTH WOMEN
AT THE SAME CHURCH,
SAME DOCTOR,
SAME GROCERY STORE.
SHE'S MIMICKING
THE ANGEL MAKER.
MAYBE WE SHOULD LOOK
AT HIS VICTIMS.
Hotchner: YEAH,
BUT THERE'S A DISCONNECT.
THE ANGEL MAKER CHOSE WOMEN
BECAUSE THEY EXCITED HIM
SEXUALLY.
THE COPYCAT'S SATISFACTION
ISN'T SEXUAL.
NOW IT'S IN PERFECTLY
RE-CREATING THE MURDERS.
SO WHAT SHE LOOKS FOR
IN A VICTIM IS SOMEONE
WHO'S EASY TO KILL.
WHICH, FOR HER,
MEANS EASY ACCESS
TO THEIR HOMES.
WHAT DID
DELILAH GRENNAN
DO FOR WORK?
JJ: SHE MADE JEWELRY,
SOLD IT OUT OF HER HOME.
Morgan: SO THEY BOTH HAD
HOME-BASED BUSINESSES.
A STRANGER COULD WALK IN
OFF THE STREET AND BE
A PROSPECTIVE CUSTOMER.
Prentiss:
UNSUB POSES AS A CLIENT,
MAYBE USES THE BATHROOM,
CRACKS THE WINDOW
SO SHE CAN GET
BACK IN LATER.
LET'S CHECK THEIR
BUSINESS RECORDS
AND SEE WHO CAME BY
ON THE DAY
OF THE MURDERS.
NO MATCHING NAMES.
SKY'S SO CLEAR
HERE, HUH?
NEVER SEE STARS
LIKE THIS IN D.C.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
OH, MY GOD.
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS
ON THE VICTIMS' STOMACHS
REPRESENT CONSTELLATIONS.
CONSTELLATIONS?
DON'T TELL ME THIS GUY
WAS FOLLOWING THE ZODIAC.
NO, THESE ARE FROM A FAMILY
OF CONSTELLATIONS KNOWN
AS THE HEAVENLY WATERS.
WELL, I GUESS
WE KNOW HOW HE CAME UP
WITH THE NICKNAME.
THAT'S WHY HE'D OPEN UP
ALL THE WINDOWS
AFTER EACH KILL,
SO THEIR SOULS COULD
BE RELEASED INTO THE SKY.
DELPHINUS, THE DOLPHIN.
EQUULEUS, THE LITTLE HORSE.
ANYTHING SOUND FAMILIAR?
HIS ORIGAMI THINGS.
Hotchner: THERE ARE
9 CONSTELLATIONS IN
THE HEAVENLY WATERS.
THE ANGEL MAKER
KILLED 6.
YEAH, OUR UNSUB CONTINUED
WHERE HE LEFT OFF.
FIRST SHE DID VELA,
AND THEN LAST NIGHT
SHE DID CARINA.
THE ONLY ONE LEFT
IS COLUMBA, THE DOVE.
ONE MORE KILL
AND SHE COMPLETES HIS SET.
SHE KNEW THE MEANING
OF THE STOMACH WOUNDS,
SOMETHING EVEN
WE DIDN'T KNOW.
SHE MUST HAVE BEEN
A LOT CLOSER TO RYAN
THAN WE THOUGHT.
THEY WEREN'T
JUST CLOSE.
THEY WERE IN LOVE.
HOW'D YOU CRACK IT?
I PROFILED THE AUTHOR.
CORTLAND RYAN WAS ON DEATH ROW
WITH SEVERAL
HIGH-RANKING MEMBERS
OF THE ARYAN BROTHERHOOD.
HE GOT THE CODE
FROM THE ARYANS?
EITHER THAT OR HE READ A LOT
OF 16th-CENTURY LITERATURE.
THE ARYANS LIKED
TO USE A CIPHER BASED
ON A 400-YEAR-OLD CODE
WRITTEN BY
SIR FRANCIS BACON.
Morgan: SO IT'S
A BINARY CODE.
YEAH.
BACON USED
A 21-LETTER ALPHABET.
THIS ONE'S 24.
EACH LETTER IS
ASSIGNED A BIT STRING
OF 5 BINARY DIGITS.
THIS COMBINATION YIELDS
32 POSSIBLE ENCODINGS.
NORMALLY YOU'D USE
A COMPUTER TO RUN
ALL THESE COMBINATIONS,
BUT IT WAS QUICKER JUST
TO DO IT LONGHAND UNTIL
I FOUND THE RIGHT ONE.
HE'S SO LIFELIKE.
WE DON'T HAVE
A COMPLETE RECORD
OF THEIR CORRESPONDENCE,
BUT I WAS ABLE TO MAKE
A CHRONOLOGY.
THE WOMAN HE CALLS "DOVE"
ESTABLISHED CONTACT SHORTLY
AFTER THE TRIAL.
"MY DEAREST CORTLAND,
THANK YOU FOR WRITING
BACK TO ME.
THE DAY THE VERDICT WAS READ,
WE SHARED A SILENT MOMENT..."
Woman: "I KNEW THEN THERE WAS
A FORCE WILLING US TOGETHER.
"EVERY TIME I SEE YOU,
I FEEL WARMED AS IF BY THE SUN,
"YET I FEAR
IF I COME TOO CLOSE,
I'LL BE CONSUMED
BY YOUR FIRE."
Cortland: "EVER SINCE
YOUR VISIT, I AM CRAZED
WITH THOUGHTS OF YOU.
"ALREADY YOU'VE ENTERED
MY DREAMS.
"EACH TIME YOU APPEAR TO ME,
"I'M EMBRACED BY A FEELING
OF TRUST AND BELIEF,
AS IF I'VE KNOWN YOU
ALL MY LIFE."
Woman: "AS ALWAYS,
I AM TOUCHED BY YOUR WORDS,
"BUT I LONG TO SEE YOU AGAIN.
"DAYS PASS QUIETLY,
ONE INTO THE NEXT..."
"MY DOVE..."
"I CAN THINK
OF LITTLE ELSE..."
"MY SECRET WIFE..."
"IF ONLY THEY WOULD
LET US MARRY..."
"ALL APPEALS ARE LOST..."
"I COULD FINALLY
HOLD YOUR HAND..."
"THE GUARDS CELEBRATED
MY DEFEAT BY CLEARING
OUT MY CELL..."
"HERE IS MY FACE..."
"POSSESSIONS MATTER LITTLE
TO A CONDEMNED MAN..."
"THEY DIE WITH YOU,
THE ONLY MAN WHO WILL
EVER TRULY SEE ME."
"TAKE HEART, MY LOVE... *
"BUT I CAN'T LEAVE
THIS WORLD... "
"BEFORE SEEING YOUR FACE
ONE LAST TIME."
"I WILL BRING
A PART OF YOU BACK
INTO THE WORLD,
AND FOREVER YOU WILL
WATCH OVER US
FROM THE STARS."
WHAT DO YOU THINK SHE MEANT
BY THAT LAST LINE,
"I WILL BRING A PART
OF YOU BACK"?
Morgan:
THE MURDERS?
SHE BROUGHT HIM
BACK TO LIFE.
JJ: WHAT IF SHE WAS
TALKING ABOUT HIS CHILD?
Reid: WELL,
SHE DID SAY "US"--
"WATCH OVER US
FROM THE STARS."
SHE USED
THE SEMEN SAMPLES
TO PLANT EVIDENCE,
NOT TO GET PREGNANT.
WHAT IF SHE DID BOTH?
WELL, IF SHE ACTUALLY
HAD HIS KID,
WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO TRACK HER
THROUGH BIRTH RECORDS.
Sheriff: AGENT HOTCHNER--
WE JUST GOT A REPORT
OF A WOMAN ATTACKED
IN HER HOUSE
BY A FEMALE ASSAILANT.
IS SHE OK?
SOUNDS LIKE IT,
BUT I CAN'T SAY THE SAME
FOR THE ATTACKER, THOUGH.
NEIGHBORS HEARD CRIES
FOR HELP, PRETTY SOON HALF
THE BLOCK WAS ON HER.
[POLICE RADIO, INDISTINCT]
THE VICTIM WAS
COMING HOME FROM WORK,
SAID THE SUSPECT
APPROACHED HER
IN HER DRIVEWAY.
ASKED TO USE THE PHONE
TO CALL A TOW TRUCK.
SHE LET HER
IN THE HOUSE?
THAT'S WHEN
THE SUSPECT JUMPED HER.
THAT'S NOT
OUR UNSUB'S M.O.
MAYBE SHE WAS RUSHING IT,
TRYING TO FINISH OFF
THE LAST VICTIM.
THAT'S SHARA.
YOU KNOW HER?
SHARA CARLINO.
ROSSI AND I ALREADY
INTERVIEWED HER.
SHE'S CORTLAND'S
NUMBER-ONE FAN.
HER ALIBI IS SOLID.
SHE'S NOT OUR UNSUB.
SHARA...WHY?
IT WORKED FOR HER.
WHY NOT FOR ME?
I JUST WANT US TO BE
TOGETHER AGAIN.
Garcia: OK, THERE WERE
463 CHILDREN BORN
IN THE LOWER CANAAN AREA
BETWEEN 2006 AND 2008,
SO IF YOU WANT ME TO FIND
BABY ANGEL MAKER, WE'RE GONNA
HAVE TO NARROW THIS DOWN.
JJ: ALL RIGHT,
WELL, REID STILL HAS
MORE LETTERS TO DECODE,
BUT HE DID FIND
A PHRASE.
"I KNEW EVEN BEFORE THEY
TOLD ME THAT THE FUTURE
HAD TAKEN ROOT."
TAKEN ROOT?
SOUNDS LIKE SOMEONE
GOT GOOD NEWS.
DATE OF CONCEPTION.
AND THE DATE
OF THAT LETTER?
UH, JANUARY 7, 2007.
OK, SO WE FAST-FORWARD
9 MONTHS.
UH, 10 MONTHS, ACTUALLY.
REALLY?
I KNOW.
IT WAS NEWS TO ME, TOO.
HUH! OK.
SO WE'LL SEARCH BIRTH RECORDS
FROM AUGUST TO SEPTEMBER 2007.
HOW'S THAT? WE'LL DO
SINGLE MOTHERS ONLY,
IN CASE SHE WANTED TO KEEP
THE FATHER A SECRET,
YOU KNOW, DIDN'T WANT TO BRAG--
"OH, YOUR BABY DADDY'S
A THIRD-GRADE TEACHER?
WELL, MINE LIKES TO
POKE PEOPLE IN THE STOMACH
WITH TOOLS, SO THERE."
THERE. 9 NAMES.
NOW, THAT'S A LITTLE
MORE MANAGEABLE.
HANNAH DREYFUS
WAS IN AN AUTO ACCIDENT.
SHE COULD BARELY WALK.
SHANNON CONWAY MOVED AWAY
WHEN THE PLANT CLOSED
A YEAR AGO.
ANY OTHER NAMES
YOU RECOGNIZE?
NO, I DON'T--WHOA.
WHAT IS IT?
WELL, THIS ONE HERE
SOUNDS FAMILIAR,
BUT I CAN'T REALLY PLACE IT.
CHLOE KELCHER.
CHLOE KELCHER.
THAT IS FAMILIAR.
CHLOE KELCHER.
SHE WAS ON THE JURY.
WELL, THAT MAKES SENSE.
SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN EXPOSED
TO THE CASE EVIDENCE,
SEEN FIRSTHAND
WHAT HE DID TO HIS VICTIMS.
THAT'S WHEN SHE FELL
IN LOVE WITH HIM,
SITTING ACROSS
THE COURTROOM
EVERY DAY.
WELL, IT'S ONE THING
TO HAVE A RELATIONSHIP
WITH A KILLER,
IT'S ANOTHER TO BECOME ONE.
Reid: THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN
AN INCIDENT THAT PROMPTED
THE TRANSFORMATION.
I THINK I KNOW
WHAT IT WAS.
IT'S A DEATH CERTIFICATE.
MICROVESICULAR STEATOSIS.
HER BABY DIED
AT THE HOSPITAL.
CLEAR!
CLEAR.
SHE'S NOT HERE.
ALL RIGHT.
WE ALL KNOW WHAT
THE END GAME IS.
SHE'S LOOKING
FOR HER FINAL VICTIM.
SHE MAY HAVE ALREADY CHOSEN ONE.
LET'S TEAR THIS PLACE APART.
LOOK FOR ANYTHING THAT MIGHT
TELL US WHO SHE'S TARGETED.
LOOK AT THIS.
SHE DID EVERYTHING SHE COULD
TO DENY THE TRUTH.
WHAT, THAT HE WAS
A KILLER?
THAT THEY'D NEVER
BE TOGETHER.
NOTE THE VIEW.
DADDY'S WATCHING.
IT MUST HAVE
DEVASTATED HER TO THINK
THAT SHE COULD HOLD ON
TO RYAN BY HAVING HIS CHILD
AND THEN LOSE THE BABY.
COMPLETING HIS MURDERS
BECAME THE ONLY WAY
SHE COULD HOLD ON TO HIM.
NOT THE ONLY WAY.
WELL...
GUESS THAT ANSWERS THAT.
I ASSUME THAT'S
WHO I THINK IT IS.
GOT AN APPOINTMENT
BOOK HERE.
MEETINGS
WITH DELILAH GRENNAN
AND MAXINE CHANDLER
THE DAY OF EACH MURDER.
SHERIFF, HAVE YOU FOUND
HER TOOLS OR THE GUN?
NOTHING YET.
SHE HAS SOMETHING
THIS MORNING--
"FAYE LANDREAUX,
162 NORTH--"
NORTH RED RIVER
DRIVE.
SHE'S A CPA.
SHE DOES MY TAXES.
Hotchner:
SHE WORK OUT
OF HER HOUSE?
YEP.
LET'S GO.
THAT'S IT.
'85 VOLKSWAGEN.
CHLOE'S HERE.
CAR'S STILL WARM.
WE GOT TO BE RIGHT
BEHIND HER.
HER WINDOWS ARE CLOSED.
THAT'S A GOOD SIGN.
WELL, MY TEAM'S READY.
LET'S GET IN THERE.
SHERIFF, WE DIDN'T
RECOVER A GUN
AT CHLOE'S HOUSE.
WE HAVE TO ASSUME
SHE'S ARMED.
WELL, SO ARE WE.
IF YOU STORM IN NOW,
SHE'LL SHOOT,
AND CHANCES ARE
SHE'LL START WITH
YOUR ACCOUNTANT.
WHAT DO YOU THINK, GUYS?
I THINK YOU SHOULD LOOK
FOR AN OPEN WINDOW.
SHERIFF, I NEED YOU
TO BRING ALL YOUR VEHICLES
AROUND TO THE FRONT,
FACING FORWARD
WITH LIGHTS OFF,
AND I NEED A MEGAPHONE.
ALL RIGHT.
HOTCH, I DON'T
THINK YOU CAN GET
THROUGH TO HER.
NO, BUT MAYBE YOU CAN.
PROFILE'S CLEAR.
YOU CAN'T TALK
THIS WOMAN DOWN.
NO, BUT JUST TO OCCUPY HER.
IF WE'RE RIGHT ABOUT THE M.O.,
SHE'S LEFT A WINDOW OPEN
SOMEWHERE.
MORGAN WILL FIND A WAY IN.
WE JUST NEED TO BUY HIM
SOME TIME.
HIT THE LIGHTS.
[SIREN]
CHLOE,
THIS IS THE FBI.
WE KNOW
YOU'RE IN THERE,
AND WE KNOW WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO.
WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
DON'T MOVE, BITCH,
OR I SWEAR TO GOD,
I WILL SPLIT YOU IN TWO.
PLEASE, DON'T DO THIS.
ROLL OVER. ROLL OVER.
ROLL OVER!
Prentiss: I KNOW YOU THINK THAT
FINISHING WHAT CORTLAND STARTED
WILL BRING YOU CLOSER TO HIM,
BUT FIRST YOU SHOULD KNOW
WHO HE REALLY WAS.
DON'T WORRY.
THERE'S A MUCH
BETTER PLACE FOR YOU.
Prentiss: I KNOW
YOU THOUGHT YOU WERE SPECIAL,
BUT THE TRUTH IS,
THE SAME THINGS HE WROTE TO YOU,
HE WROTE TO MANY OTHER WOMEN.
I'VE SEEN THE LETTERS.
DOZENS READ THE SAME LINES:
"WITHOUT THE FLESH,
THERE IS ONLY THE SOUL."
"YOU DON'T NEED TO TOUCH ME
TO FEEL THE LOVE I HAVE
FOR YOU."
DOES THAT SOUND FAMILIAR?
[BREATHING HARD]
Prentiss: CORTLAND WASN'T
WHO YOU THOUGHT HE WAS.
HE--HE WAS
A NARCISSIST, CHLOE.
HE WASN'T CAPABLE OF LOVING
ANYONE BUT HIMSELF.
TO CARLA KETTINGER,
HE WROTE,
"EVER SINCE YOUR VISIT,
I AM CRAZED WITH THOUGHTS
OF YOU..."
Cortland: "ALREADY YOU HAVE
ENTERED MY DREAMS."
Prentiss: "EACH TIME
YOU APPEAR TO ME..."
Cortland: "I AM EMBRACED
BY A FEELING OF TRUST
"AND BELIEF, AS IF I'VE
KNOWN YOU ALL MY LIFE.
"IT'S CLEAR TO ME NOW
THAT YOU ARE MY FATE.
WE ARE DESTINED
TO BE TOGETHER."
Prentiss: "AND WHEN I AM GONE,
THAT WILL NOT CHANGE.
Cortland: "I WILL LIVE ON
IN YOU.
IN DEATH, OUR UNION
WILL BE ETERNAL."
[FAYE WHIMPERING]
Prentiss:
"ALL APPEALS ARE LOST.
THE GUARDS CELEBRATED MY DEFEAT
BY CLEARING OUT..."
NO, NO, NO.
DON'T SPEAK.
DON'T TALK.
I'M GONNA GET YOU
OUT OF HERE, OK?
Cortland: "POSSESSIONS MATTER
LITTLE TO A CONDEMNED MAN,
"BUT I CANNOT LEAVE THIS WORLD
"WITHOUT SEEING YOUR FACE
ONE LAST TIME.
OK, THAT WINDOW OVER THERE.
I WANT YOU TO GO TO THAT WINDOW.
IT'S GONNA BE OK.
OK, GO, GO, GO.
Prentiss: IT ISN'T YOUR
FAULT THAT HE MADE YOU
FEEL THESE THINGS.
IT ISN'T YOUR FAULT
YOUR BABY DIED.
NO!
IT'S OVER, CHLOE.
WE HAVE FAYE.
[GRUNTING]
Prentiss:
YOU HAVE NOWHERE TO GO.
I THINK WE GOT SOME TEAR GAS.
I'M ASSUMING IT'S STILL GOOD.
WE'RE NOT GONNA NEED IT.
SHE DOESN'T HAVE
ANY PLACE TO GO.
WELL, MAYBE
SHE'LL DO US ALL A FAVOR
AND PUT HERSELF DOWN.
SHE'S NOT GONNA
DO THAT, EITHER.
SHE'S NOT DONE.
CHLOE, DROP THE GUN.
CHLOE,
DROP THE GUN.
DAMN IT, LADY, DROP IT!
I'M COMING TO YOU, BABY.
[HOTCHNER GROANING]
[HIGH-PITCHED SOUND]
OH...
HOTCH.
OH...
[HOTCHNER GROANING]
HOTCH?
OH...
[SIGHS]
WHAT DID SHE DO?
WE TOOK HER VICTIM.
SHE HAD TO COMPLETE
HIS WORK.
Hotchner:
WENDELL BERRY SAID,
"THE PAST IS OUR DEFINITION.
"WE MAY STRIVE WITH GOOD REASON
TO ESCAPE IT
"OR TO ESCAPE WHAT IS BAD IN IT,
BUT WE WILL ESCAPE IT
ONLY BY ADDING SOMETHING
BETTER TO IT."
I MADE THESE
FOR YOUR FLIGHT.
THANK YOU.
IT'S SMALL THANKS, BUT--
MY RECIPE.
I'M SORRY YOU
HAD TO GO THROUGH
ALL THIS AGAIN.
I SUPPOSE WE NEVER STOP
GOING THROUGH IT,
BUT...MAYBE NOW.
HOPEFULLY.
SHE GONNA BE OK?
YEAH, SHE'LL BE FINE.
MAYBE YOU GOT TO SIT
WITH THE PAST BEFORE
YOU CAN WALK AWAY FROM IT.
THANK YOU, SHERIFF.
THANK YOU.
JJ: ANYONE GET DIRECTIONS
BACK TO THE AIRSTRIP?
TOWN'S ONLY GOT ONE ROAD.
WE'LL FIND IT.
YEAH, MORGAN DOESN'T
LIKE TO FOLLOW
DIRECTIONS.
YOU DIDN'T KNOW
ABOUT THAT?
YEAH, HE LIKES TO VIBE IT.
OK, SMART-ASS. YOU DRIVE.
OH, GREAT.
SWEET.
THANK YOU.
FOR THE FLIGHT.
WHAT?
JUST GONNA GRAB MY BAG.
YOU'RE NOT COMING?
I, UH,
THINK I'M GONNA DRIVE.
OH, IT'S OVER 7 HOURS
BACK TO QUANTICO.
I REALLY SHOULDN'T
BE FLYING.
OH.
I'VE DONE
THAT DRIVE BEFORE.
YOU'LL SEE A LOT
OF PRETTY COUNTRY
ALONG THE BYWAYS.
YOU MIGHT CONSIDER...
STRETCHING IT OUT
A DAY OR TWO.
MAYBE I WILL. THANKS.
OH, MY GOD!
THAT'S HOTCH AND KATE!
[CAR ALARM BLARING]
[MUTED]
HEY, ARE YOU OK?
HOTCHNER--IS HE OK?
HE CAN'T FLY
FOR A LITTLE BIT.
HIS EARS ARE--
BUT HE'S GONNA BE FINE.
[TAPPING]
[CLATTERING]
[CLATTERING]
OH. JEEZ, BO,
YOU SCARED ME HALF TO DEATH.
SUCH A CLICHE.
SEE THAT, BO?
GUESS I'M SUPPOSED TO MAKE
A WISH OR SOMETHING, RIGHT?
[MEOW]
COME ON, BO.
[MECHANICAL HUMMING]
HOW IS THE BUZZING NOW?
IT'S OK. I THINK
I COULD ACTUALLY
GET USED TO THAT PART.
THE PROBLEM IS DEALING
WITH THE PAIN.
YOU'RE EXPERIENCING
HYPERACUSIS.
IT'S CAUSED
BY SUDDEN LOUD NOISES,
LIKE AN EXPLOSION.
SO WHAT DO WE DO
ABOUT IT, DOCTOR?
YOU HAVE A SMALL TEAR
IN YOUR RIGHT EARDRUM.
WE'LL TREAT THAT
WITH A BONDING AGENT.
IT'LL MOST LIKELY HEAL
ITSELF IN A WEEK OR TWO.
MOST LIKELY?
THE CONDITION CAN
SOMETIMES BECOME PERMANENT.
BUT I CAN GO
BACK TO WORK?
PUTTING SOMEONE IN THE FIELD
WITH ACUTE SENSITIVITY
TO SOUND WOULD BE A MISTAKE.
AGENT HOTCHNER,
IF YOU'RE NOT CAREFUL,
YOU COULD LOSE
YOUR HEARING ENTIRELY.
I UNDERSTAND.
GOOD.
BUT YOU'LL...
SIGN MY RETURN TO DUTY?
WHAT IF I SAID I'D...
TAKE IT EASY AND...
LIMIT MY ROLE
IN THE FIELD?
STAY OUT OF LOUD PLACES.
[CELL PHONE RINGING]
YOUR PHONE IS RINGING.
WHAT'S UP, JJ?
THIS IS DELILAH GRENNAN.
SHE WAS BLUDGEONED AND RAPED
DURING THE NIGHT AT HER HOME
IN LOWER CANAAN, OHIO.
LOWER WHERE?
SMALL TOWN 40 MILES
OUTSIDE OF CINCINNATI.
STAGING THE BODY
FACE-UP
WITH THE ARMS ACROSS
THE CHEST LIKE THAT.
RITUAL.
NICE HAIR, BY THE WAY.
AHEM. THANKS.
UH, THERE'S MORE.
SMALL PUNCTURE WOUNDS
ON HER STOMACH.
NOTE THE LACK OF BLOOD.
THEY WERE INFLICTED
POSTMORTEM.
WERE THERE
ANY OTHER VICTIMS?
KIND OF.
VICTIMOLOGY AND SIGNATURE
MATCH A SERIAL KILLER
FROM THE SAME TOWN
10 YEARS AGO--
6 VICTIMS SPANNING
OVER 10 MONTHS.
HE CALLED HIMSELF--
THE ANGEL MAKER.
I REMEMBER THE CASE.
Reid:
THEY CAUGHT THAT GUY.
Rossi: AND EXECUTED HIM.
THAT'S RIGHT.
HE WAS PUT TO DEATH
BY LETHAL INJECTION
A YEAR AGO YESTERDAY.
YESTERDAY.
Morgan: SO WE'RE LOOKING
FOR A COPYCAT.
HONORING THE ANNIVERSARY
OF HIS HERO'S DEATH.
IT SAYS HERE
THEY FOUND SEMEN
AT THE CRIME SCENE.
PERHAPS LOCALS WILL GET
A DNA MATCH WHEN THEY
RUN IT THROUGH VICAP?
WELL, THAT'S
WHERE IT GETS WEIRD.
THEY RAN IT ALREADY
AND THEY GOT A MATCH, TOO.
WELL, IF THEY
ALREADY HAVE A NAME,
WHY'D THEY CALL US?
THEY'VE GOT TO BE KIDDING.
THE MATCH THEY GOT BACK
ON THE DNA
IS TO A CORTLAND BRYCE RYAN,
OTHERWISE KNOWN AS...
THE ANGEL MAKER.
Hotchner: "WE ALL DIE.
"THE GOAL ISN'T TO LIVE FOREVER.
THE GOAL IS TO CREATE
SOMETHING THAT WILL."
CHUCK PALAHNIUK.
Reid: THE ANGEL MAKER'S
VICTIMS WERE BEATEN
WITH THE ASSAILANT'S
BARE HANDS.
AND THEN DELILAH GRENNAN
WAS BLUDGEONED
WITH A HEAVY INSTRUMENT,
MAYBE A HAMMER.
OK, SO THIS UNSUB'S
A WEAKER GUY,
OR AT LEAST SOMEONE
WHO PERCEIVES
HIMSELF THAT WAY.
SO HE BROUGHT ALONG
THE HAMMER TO MAKE CERTAIN
HIS VICTIM WOULDN'T
FIGHT BACK?
THEY HAVE PARACHUTES
ON-BOARD, RIGHT?
THEY SHOULD. IT'S STANDARD
ON ALL FEDERAL AIR TRANSPORT.
MAYBE WE CAN GIVE ONE TO
THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM,
GET HIM OUT OF HERE?
THAT'D BE THE ELEPHANT
WITH THE DEAD MAN'S DNA.
WELL, OBVIOUSLY
SOMEBODY PLANTED THE
SEMEN ON THE VICTIM.
IN THE VICTIM.
THAT'S ONE THEORY.
THERE'S ANOTHER?
THINK ABOUT WHO SHARES
THE EXACT DNA MAKEUP
OF ANOTHER PERSON.
REID, YOU'RE NOT SERIOUSLY
FLOATING AROUND THE IDEA
OF AN EVIL TWIN, ARE YOU?
NO, I'M NOT.
I'M FLOATING THE IDEA
OF AN EVILER TWIN.
TRADITIONALLY, THE
CONCEPT IS A GOOD TWIN
AND AN EVIL TWIN.
BUT IN THIS CASE,
IT'S EVIL TWIN,
EVILER TWIN.
[HIGH-PITCHED TONE]
HOTCH?
YEAH.
YOU HAVE BEEN CLEARED
TO FLY, HAVEN'T YOU?
BEFORE CORTLAND RYAN,
THIS TOWN HADN'T SEEN
A HOMICIDE IN OVER 30 YEARS.
HE DIDN'T JUST KILL
THOSE 6 WOMEN.
HE KILLED A WAY OF LIFE.
NOW THIS THING'S GOT PEOPLE
THINKING HE'S COME BACK.
THEY DON'T
REALLY THINK
THAT, DO THEY?
I GUESS WHEN YOU'VE
BEEN SCARED BY SOMETHING,
I MEAN REALLY SCARED,
THAT FEAR'S IN YOU FOREVER.
LET'S STICK TO THE FACTS.
WERE THERE SIGNS
OF FORCED ENTRY?
NONE THAT WE COULD FIND,
BUT WHOEVER KILLED
DELILAH GRENNAN
OPENED UP EVERY WINDOW
IN THIS HOUSE
BEFORE HE LEFT.
THAT'S A SIGNATURE FROM
THE PREVIOUS MURDERS.
A DETAIL WE NEVER
RELEASED TO THE PUBLIC.
AND IT CAME OUT
AT THE TRIAL?
NO, SIR. PROSECUTION HAD RYAN
NAILED 9 WAYS TO SUNDAY.
DIDN'T NEED IT.
SO I'M HARD-PRESSED TO KNOW
HOW THIS COPYCAT KNEW
ABOUT THOSE WINDOWS.
THE MAN WE'RE LOOKING
FOR IS MOST LIKELY A FAN
WHO EXHAUSTIVELY STUDIED
THE FIRST KILLINGS
AND USED THEM TO FORM
HIS OWN MURDER FANTASIES.
HE KNOWS THIS CASE
AS WELL AS US,
EVEN BETTER, MAYBE,
IF HE HAD ACTUAL CONTACT
WITH RYAN WHILE
HE WAS INCARCERATED.
WE SENT ONE OF OUR AGENTS
TO HAWKESVILLE PRISON
TO LOOK INTO IT.
AND THE SEMEN?
SMUGGLED OUT OF THE PRISON,
KEPT ON ICE, BROUGHT OUT
ON THE ANNIVERSARY
OF THE EXECUTION.
THERE'S AN ENTIRE
COTTAGE INDUSTRY BASED ON
SERIAL KILLER EFFECTS
AND MEMORABILIA.
YOU CAN FIND ABSOLUTELY
ANYTHING IF YOU KNOW
THE RIGHT PEOPLE.
QUESTION IS, IS THIS
A ONE-TIME COMMEMORATION
OR IS IT JUST
THE BEGINNING?
Prentiss: WHAT ABOUT
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS?
MY BEST GUESS IS
A SMALL SCREWDRIVER,
LIKE A PHILLIPS HEAD.
JUST LIKE THE PRIOR MURDERS.
THIS GUY'S A STICKLER
FOR THE DETAILS.
THE GROUPINGS
IN THE PRIOR VICTIMS
WERE ALWAYS DIFFERENT
IN NUMBER AND ARRANGEMENT.
3 WOUNDS ON THIS ONE.
5, 24.
HE WAS ALL OVER THE MAP.
I ALSO FOUND TRACES
OF PAPER IN THE WOUNDS.
PAPER? LIKE TISSUE?
LIKE NOTEBOOK PAPER.
WELL, THAT'S NEW.
UNIQUE TO THE COPYCAT.
I...
WHAT IS IT?
I DON'T KNOW.
IT JUST SEEMS FAMILIAR.
[CART RATTLING]
RYAN DIDN'T HAVE
ANY NEXT OF KIN,
SO AFTER THE EXECUTION,
ALL OF HIS EFFECTS
GOT BOXED AND STORED.
THIS IS ALL
HIS CORRESPONDENCE?
COPIES, AT LEAST.
HELPS THE WARDEN KEEP TABS
ON CERTAIN PRISONERS
IF HE CAN KNOW WHAT'S
IN THEIR MAIL.
THERE'S A LOT
OF LETTERS.
A LOT OF FANS.
REAL LADY KILLER.
WHAT ABOUT MALE FANS?
SOME, YEAH. FREAKS.
THIS ONE KID WOULD COME BY--
MUSICIAN, I THINK--
BLACK CLOTHES AND EYELINER
AND ALL THAT.
HE SENT RYAN HIS DEMO TAPE
AND SOME SHEET MUSIC
HE WROTE IN HIS OWN BLOOD.
DID YOU EVER CATCH RYAN
TRYING TO SMUGGLE
ANYTHING OUT,
TO THIS KID
OR ANYONE ELSE?
THE USUAL PROBLEM
WE HAVE IS STUFF BEING
SMUGGLED IN, NOT OUT.
HIS DNA WAS FOUND
AT A FRESH CRIME SCENE
IN LOWER CANAAN.
WHAT KIND OF DNA
WE TALKING ABOUT?
THE TYPE OF DNA THAT
CATS IN LOCKUP DON'T
HAVE OCCASION TO USE.
ALL RIGHT. WELL, LISTEN,
THANK YOU FOR ALL THIS,
BUT I WANT TO LOOK
AT ALL YOUR VISITOR
LOGS, ALL RIGHT?
[CELL PHONE RINGS]
EXCUSE ME.
YEAH, JJ?
OK, UH...
YEAH, I'M HEADED
RIGHT BACK.
SOMETHING WRONG?
A LOCAL NEWSPAPER
JUST GOT A LETTER
FROM SOMEONE CLAIMING
TO BE THE ANGEL MAKER.
"I GIVE YOU A LEGACY,
A BREATH OF LIFE
"FROM THE ANGEL MAKER HIMSELF.
"THOSE WHO PRAYED TO FORGET ME
WILL ONE DAY SEE MY FACE
AND SHRINK IN FEAR."
THAT'S THE LAST THING
PEOPLE NEED RIGHT NOW.
REID, HOW'S IT COMPARE
WITH THE ORIGINAL
CORRESPONDENCE?
THEY SHARE SOME COMPELLING
CHARACTERISTICS.
I'D OBVIOUSLY LIKE TO LOOK
AT IT UNDER MAGNIFICATION
WITH A BETTER LIGHT.
BEST GUESS, REID?
I'D SAY IT'S AUTHENTIC.
HOW CAN THIS LETTER
BE AUTHENTIC IF THE GUY'S
BEEN DEAD FOR A YEAR?
COULD BE
AN ELABORATE FORGERY.
OR IT COULD BE
THE GENUINE ARTICLE,
JUST WRITTEN
BEFORE HIS DEATH.
WELL, MAIL HERE
ISN'T THAT SLOW.
OR RELEASED THROUGH
AN INTERMEDIARY.
YOU MEAN THE COPYCAT?
WE'RE GOING OVER
THE PRISON VISITOR LOGS
TO CHECK WHO HAD
MULTIPLE VISITS WITH RYAN,
TRY TO NARROW
OUR SUSPECT POOL.
SELA?
WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?
IS IT TRUE?
THERE'S A LETTER?
HOW DID YOU KNOW?
YOU DIDN'T REALLY THINK
YOU COULD KEEP THAT QUIET
AROUND HERE.
THE LETTER'S NOT FROM HIM,
NOT THE WAY PEOPLE
MIGHT BE SAYING.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
IT...
IT MEANS WE THINK
HE HAS SOMEONE ON
THE OUTSIDE, A FRIEND.
WHAT IF YOU'RE WRONG?
WHAT IF--
THERE'S NO SUCH THING
AS GHOSTS, SELA.
I'M NOT TALKING
ABOUT A GHOST.
I AM TALKING
ABOUT THOSE RUMORS
ABOUT THE EXECUTION,
HOW THERE WERE PROBLEMS,
HOW IT DIDN'T WORK RIGHT.
WHAT ARE YOU SUGGESTING?
WHAT IF HE'S STILL
OUT THERE?
DON'T DO THAT.
YOU THINK
I'M THE ONLY ONE?
LOOK OUTSIDE.
THEY WANT PROOF
THAT HE'S DEAD.
I HAVE TO ADVISE
AGAINST THIS.
WELL, DUE RESPECT,
BUT THIS ISN'T YOUR TOWN.
I HAVE TO CONVINCE THEM
THAT CORTLAND RYAN
IS DEAD AND BURIED.
BUT YOU'RE INDULGING
THIS KILLER BY PERPETUATING
THE RUSE HE'S CREATED.
HE'S RIGHT.
IT MAY EMBOLDEN HIM,
PROMPT MORE MURDERS.
SELA LOST HER ONLY DAUGHTER
TO THAT BASTARD.
WE MET WHEN I WAS WORKING
THE CASE, GREW CLOSE.
I THOUGHT WE'D GOTTEN
PAST ALL THIS,
BUT I GUESS I WAS
KIDDING MYSELF.
[TRACTOR ENGINE TURNS OVER]
[HIGH-PITCHED TONE]
HOTCH?
HOTCH?
[MUTED] IS THERE
ANYTHING I CAN DO?
HOTCH, ARE YOU
ALL RIGHT?
CAN I DO ANYTHING?
YEAH, I'M OK,
I'M OK, I'M OK. OK.
MY GOD.
CORTLAND RYAN IS DEAD.
THERE'S NO TWO WAYS
ABOUT IT.
WE'RE JUST TRYING TO BE
THOROUGH, DR. HAGEN.
WE HEARD THAT THERE MAY
HAVE BEEN IRREGULARITIES
WITH THE EXECUTION.
HIS HEART WAS STOPPED.
HIS PUPILS WERE
NONRESPONSIVE.
TRUST ME.
THIS IS NOT THE FIRST EXECUTION
I'VE PRONOUNCED AT.
BUT IT WAS THE LAST.
DID SOMETHING HAPPEN
THAT DAY
TO PROMPT YOUR
RESIGNATION FROM THE
CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT?
EVERYONE DIES DIFFERENT.
RYAN WENT HARD, IS ALL.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN, DOCTOR?
Doctor: AFTER WE CYCLED
THE DRUGS, WE REALIZED
HE WAS STILL ALIVE.
WE WEREN'T PREPARED FOR THAT.
HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?
THE CATHETER DISLODGED.
WE REINSERTED IT,
STARTED
THE POTASSIUM CHLORIDE.
HE STARTED...SHAKING.
[WHIMPERING]
SPITTING.
HE WAS SUFFOCATING.
CATHETER FAILED AGAIN.
TOOK HIM ALMOST
AN HOUR TO DIE,
ALMOST AS IF SOMETHING
WERE KEEPING HIM HERE.
HE SAID THIS WAS GOING
TO HAPPEN, YOU KNOW.
THAT WHAT WAS GONNA HAPPEN?
HIS LAST WORDS--
HE SAID HE'D COME BACK.
YOU MAY THINK YOU'VE SEEN
THE LAST OF ME,
BUT DEATH CANNOT
TAKE ME FROM YOU.
I WILL BE BORN AGAIN.
TODAY YOU MAKE ME A LEGEND.
ALWAYS HAD A FLAIR
FOR THE DRAMATIC.
SET THE STAGE PERFECTLY--
A LATTER-DAY LAZARUS
RETURNING TO
DELIVER HELL ON EARTH.
WE NEED TO DEBUNK THIS,
OR THE WHOLE TOWN'S
GONNA PANIC.
A LITTLE LATE
FOR THAT.
THE GRAVE-ROBBING
WE CAN EXPLAIN.
IT HAS TO BE A FAN.
YOU THINK
THE SAME PERSON
THAT DID
THE COPYCAT MURDER
TOOK RYAN'S BODY?
IT'S POSSIBLE.
HE HAD TO HAVE HELP.
SOMEONE ON THE INSIDE.
I SUPPOSE YOU'RE
GONNA TELL ME
THERE'S A COTTAGE
INDUSTRY FOR THAT, TOO.
Garcia: DID YOU KNOW
THAT JOHN WAYNE GACY
PAINTED CLOWNS?
A MURDERING PEDOPHILE
PAINTS CLOWNS,
AND PEOPLE HANG THEM
ON THEIR WALLS.
IT'S CREEPY ON SO MANY LEVELS.
I MEAN, CLOWNS--
GARCIA, I DIDN'T KNOW
YOU HAD THAT HANG-UP.
COULROPHOBIA--
ABNORMAL FEAR OF CLOWNS.
Garcia: OH, NO, THERE IS
NOTHING ABNORMAL ABOUT IT.
WHEN I WAS 12, A HOBO CLOWN
GROPED MY BREAST
AT A BIRTHDAY PARTY
AND MADE THIS OLD-TIMEY
HONKING NOISE WHEN HE DID IT.
APPARENTLY MAKING IT FUNNY
MAKES IT OK.
WERE YOU ABLE TO FIND
ANY AUCTIONS ON ANGEL MAKER
MEMORABILIA?
OH, MY VISION.
I FOUND A TON.
MR. MAKER WAS QUITE
THE SELF-PROMOTER.
HE AUTOGRAPHED EVERYTHING--
PHOTOS, PANTIES,
AND FOR THE DISCERNING
COLLECTOR, SCREWDRIVERS.
YOU GOT TO BE
KIDDING ME.
Garcia: YEAH.
HE ALSO MADE THESE LITTLE
ORIGAMI FIGURINES OUT OF
CIGARETTE BOXES,
WHICH, I HATE TO SAY,
ARE REALLY CUTE.
DID YOU PINPOINT
THE MOST ACTIVE
COLLECTORS?
THAT WOULD BE
HIS OVERSEAS FANS.
WHAT ABOUT
LOCAL BUYERS
WHO ALSO TURNED UP
ON THE PRISON
VISITOR LOG?
ZILCH.
WHAT ABOUT SELLERS?
A HIGH-VOLUME BROKER MIGHT KNOW
A BROADER SPECTRUM OF FANS.
Garcia: THERE IS ONE GUY
IN PARTICULAR WHO SEEMS TO BE
THE LOCAL DISTRIBUTOR,
AS IT WERE.
YOU GOT A NAME?
SHEBANG!
SID RUTLEDGE.
RUTLEDGE?
YOU KNOW HIM?
HE'S A GUARD
AT HAWKESVILLE.
SID RUTLEDGE, FBI.
OPEN UP.
JUST WANT TO TALK.
I CAN'T SEE ANYONE.
OH, GUY'S GOT TWO DEADBOLTS,
HE DOESN'T USE EITHER?
Morgan: SID?
SID,
WE'RE COMING IN.
WAKEY, WAKEY,
MY MAN.
DAMN.
ONE TO THE GRILL,
ONE TO THE GROIN.
THAT'S PERSONAL.
YEAH, WELL, IF RUTLEDGE WAS
SELLING THE UNSUB MEMORABILIA,
HE KNEW HIS IDENTITY.
NOW THE UNSUB'S
COVERING HIS TRACKS.
RUTLEDGE PROBABLY
CONTACTED HIM
AFTER YOU PAID A VISIT
TO THE PRISON.
HE LET HIM IN,
LET HIS GUARD DOWN,
BOOM.
WHEW. A LITTLE, UH,
HEAVY ON THE OLD SPICE.
STRIKES ME
AS AN AQUA VELVA GUY.
OH! MAN, YOU'RE GOOD.
HEY, IT LOOKS LIKE
HE TOOK SOMETHING.
HELLO.
I THINK WE'VE GOT
THIS UNSUB ALL WRONG.
THERE HAVE BEEN
SOME STRANGE HAPPENINGS
IN THIS CASE,
BUT I URGE YOU NOT TO
ABANDON REASON IN
THE SEARCH OF THE TRUTH.
THIS IS NOT THE WORK
OF A GHOST,
AND IT'S NOT THE WORK
OF A KILLER COME BACK
FROM THE DEAD.
THIS IS THE WORK OF SOMEBODY
WHO LIVES RIGHT HERE
IN LOWER CANAAN,
AND THIS PERSON
IS A WOMAN.
HER LAST VICTIM,
SID RUTLEDGE--
HE WAS THE ANGEL MAKER'S
MULE.
HE SMUGGLED ITEMS
OUT OF HAWKESVILLE PRISON,
INCLUDING THE SEMEN
THAT WAS PLANTED AT
THE FIRST CRIME SCENE.
SHE KILLED RUTLEDGE
BECAUSE HE KNEW
SHE WAS THE COPYCAT,
AND ALSO BECAUSE HE WAS
BLACKMAILING HER.
SO I'M THINKING YOU
AND I NEED TO TALK.
WE NOW KNOW THAT
RUTLEDGE WAS TRANSFERRED
TO HAWKESVILLE
FROM A FEMALE PRISON,
IN THE WAKE OF ALLEGATIONS
THAT HE WAS USING
HIS POSITION
TO LEVERAGE SEXUAL FAVORS
FROM INMATES.
AND WE THINK HE DID
THE SAME THING TO OUR UNSUB--
IN EXCHANGE FOR HIS SILENCE,
HE WANTED SEX.
BECAUSE SHE SHOT HIM
IN THE JUNK, RIGHT?
THAT AND THE FACT
THAT HE TOOK A PDE-5 INHIBITOR
SHORTLY BEFORE HIS MURDER.
A WHAT?
VIAGRA.
WE'RE LOOKING
FOR A WHITE WOMAN
IN HER MID-30s,
AND SHE'S HIGHLY
INTELLIGENT.
AND SHE'S NOT JUST
A FAN, SHE'S A GROUPIE.
NOW, SHE'S NOT WHAT
YOU WOULD NORMALLY EXPECT.
MORE OFTEN THAN NOT,
THEY'RE ATTRACTIVE,
THEY'RE WELL-EDUCATED,
THEY'RE SUCCESSFUL.
SOME ARE EVEN MARRIED.
GENERALLY,
THEY FALL INTO TYPES.
SOME ARE REFORMERS.
THEY'RE ON A MISSION
TO SAVE OR RESCUE
THESE MURDERERS.
OFTEN, THIS TYPE
OF GROUPIE HAS BEEN
RAISED IN A REPRESSIVE,
RELIGIOUS ENVIRONMENT
AND SPECIFICALLY
HAVE BEEN EXPOSED
TO THE IDEALS OF
SEXUAL REPRESSION AND
SUBJUGATION OF WOMEN.
OUR UNSUB IS
A DIFFERENT TYPE,
ONE WHO SUFFERS
FROM HYBRISTOPHILIA.
IT'S A SEXUAL ATTRACTION
TO MEN WHO COMMIT
VIOLENT CRIMES.
THEY GIVE HER A POWER
THAT SHE LACKS,
WHICH STEMS FROM
LOW SELF-ESTEEM
AND A NEED FOR
A FATHER FIGURE.
WELL, THE VICTIMS WERE RAPED.
HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN THAT?
SHE'S USING AN INSTRUMENT
TO SIMULATE THE SEXUAL
ASSAULT.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT SHE KEEPS
IN HER RAPE KIT,
ALONG WITH THE WEAPON
THAT SHE'S USING
TO BLUDGEON HER VICTIMS.
THIS IS A LIST OF WOMEN
WHO VISITED AND WROTE
THE ANGEL MAKER
WHILE HE WAS IN PRISON.
WE'VE STARTED TO TRACK
THESE LEADS, BUT THE LIST
IS EXTENSIVE,
SO WE'RE GONNA NEED
YOUR HELP.
HEY, YOU EVER GET GROUPIES
AT YOUR BOOK SIGNING?
SOMETIMES,
IF BARRY MANILOW
ISN'T IN TOWN.
ANY OF THEM
LOOK LIKE THAT?
SHARA CARLINO.
SHE VISITED RYAN
OVER 70 TIMES.
WAITS AN AVERAGE
OF 3 HOURS FOR
A 10-MINUTE VISIT,
MANDATORY STRIP SEARCH.
WOULD YOU ENDURE
THAT FOR A GUY?
FOR BARRY MANILOW,
MAYBE.
SHE WAS A MARKETING VP
IN CINCY TILL '99,
MOVED HERE, TOOK
AN OUTSIDE SALES JOB,
COMMISSION ONLY--
SERIOUS PAY CUT.
I'M GUESSING SHE CAME
FOR THE VIEW.
ACCORDING TO THESE LOGS,
YOU WERE THE ANGEL MAKER'S
NUMBER-ONE FAN.
HIS NAME IS CORTLAND,
AND I WASN'T A FAN.
HOW WOULD YOU
CHARACTERIZE
YOUR RELATIONSHIP?
WE WERE LOVERS.
LAST TIME I CHECKED,
THEY DIDN'T ALLOW
CONJUGAL VISITS
ON DEATH ROW.
IT WASN'T ABOUT
PHYSICAL INTERACTION.
WHEN YOU TAKE AWAY
THE FLESH,
THERE'S ONLY THE SOUL.
EVERYTHING WAS UNDERSTOOD.
THERE WERE NO SECRETS.
CORTLAND MADE ME
FEEL ALIVE,
IN A WAY
NO FREE MAN EVER COULD.
WHERE WERE YOU ON
THE 16th OF THIS MONTH?
WHY?
WE BELIEVE
THIS COPYCAT KILLING
WAS COMMITTED
BY A FEMALE FAN,
SOMEONE WHO KNEW
CORTLAND VERY WELL.
I WAS OUT OF TOWN
WITH THE COMPANY.
ASK ANYONE HERE.
DO YOU KNOW ANOTHER WOMAN
CORTLAND--
THERE WERE NO OTHERS.
I CAN SHOW YOU
LOGS, PHOTOCOPIES
OF FAN LETTERS,
WOMEN WHO SENT
CORTLAND PICTURES,
THEIR UNDERWEAR--
THEY DIDN'T MEAN
ANYTHING TO HIM.
BUT WHATEVER
CONNECTION YOU HAD
WITH CORTLAND
WAS SEVERED
WHEN HE DIED.
NOT THE COPYCAT'S.
EVERY TIME
SHE KILLS,
IT REINFORCES
THEIR LOVE.
THAT IS, OF COURSE,
UNLESS YOU HELP US STOP HER.
HE SENT ME A LETTER
A FEW MONTHS
BEFORE HE--HE WAS...
I KNEW IT WASN'T
MEANT FOR ME,
BECAUSE IT WAS ADDRESSED
TO..."MY DOVE."
HE NEVER CALLED ME THAT.
DO YOU STILL HAVE IT?
NO.
I BURNED IT.
DID THE TEXT REVEAL ANYTHING
ABOUT THE WOMAN?
THE TEXT WAS A JOKE.
USUALLY HIS PROSE WAS
SEAMLESS
AND BEAUTIFUL, BUT...
THIS WAS...
PEDESTRIAN AND CRUDE.
YOU NEVER ASKED HIM
WHO THIS DOVE WAS?
I THOUGHT THERE WERE
NO SECRETS BETWEEN YOU.
YOU'VE NEVER BEEN
IN LOVE, HAVE YOU?
VICTIM'S
MAXINE CHANDLER.
NEIGHBORS SAY
SHE'S LIVED HERE
HER WHOLE LIFE,
ALL 28 YEARS
OF IT, ANYWAY.
HOW MANY KIDS DOES SHE HAVE?
WELL, NONE
OF HER OWN.
RUNS A DAY CARE.
THE GUY WHO CALLED 911
CAME HERE TO DROP OFF
HIS TODDLER,
FOUND MAXINE IN HER BEDROOM.
CORONER'S IN THERE WITH HER NOW.
YOU CHECK ALL ENTRY POINTS?
YEAH. NO DAMAGE,
NO TOOL MARKS.
SAME AS THE FIRST.
NOW THAT WE HAVE
TWO VICTIMS, WE HAVE
DATA WE CAN COMPARE.
WE SHOULD SEE
WHAT VICTIMOLOGY
CAN TELL US.
I'LL GET JJ
TO BRING US THE FILES
ON THE FIRST VICTIM.
WHAT'D YOU FIND?
WELL, I PUT THE TIME
OF DEATH AROUND 2 A.M.
VICTIM WAS STRUCK
MULTIPLE TIMES WITH
A BLUNT OBJECT.
SIGNS OF PENETRATION,
FLUIDS.
SAME POSTMORTEM
MUTILATION?
SAME, BUT, UH,
DIFFERENT.
9 PUNCTURE MARKS
THIS TIME.
I WISH I COULD SAY
THIS WAS ABOUT THE UNSUB'S
DISORGANIZED BEHAVIOR
OR MOUNTING RAGE.
IT DOESN'T FEEL
THAT WAY.
NO, THEY DEFINITELY
MEAN SOMETHING.
CAN I HAVE YOUR PEN?
YEAH. WHAT IS IT?
I'M NOT SURE.
SHE DID THIS.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
THE UNSUB.
SHE MADE THESE DOTS
LIKE THIS
BEFORE SHE MADE
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS.
THAT'S WHY THE CORONER
FOUND PAPER IN THE WOUNDS.
IT WAS A TEMPLATE.
THE ANGEL MAKER DID IT
FROM MEMORY,
BUT SHE NEEDED A GUIDE
TO GET IT RIGHT.
WE NEED TO GO BACK
AND RE-EXAMINE EACH OF
THE PATTERNS. WHERE'S REID?
HERE'S ANOTHER ONE TO DOVE--
NOVEMBER 2, 2006.
SAME THING?
YEAH.
"WEATHER IS GOOD HERE.
OUT IN THE GARDEN ALL DAY.
BIRDS LAND ON THE FENCE.
THE MOON IS FULL NOW."
HE GOT AN HOUR A DAY
IN A CONCRETE YARD.
THERE WAS NO GARDEN.
THERE WERE NO BIRDS.
DEATH ROW HAIKU.
I MEAN, YOU HAVE TO TRY
TO WRITE THIS BAD.
I THINK HE DID.
HE TRIED VERY HARD
TO PUT EACH WORD,
EACH LETTER, EVEN,
IN THE RIGHT ORDER.
SO IT'S A CODE.
THIS STEGANOGRAPHIC
METHOD WOULD ALLOW HIM
TO WRITE LETTERS
THAT DON'T APPEAR
ENCIPHERED.
THE REAL MESSAGE
WOULD BE HIDING
IN PLAIN SIGHT.
WHAT DO YOU NEED
TO CRACK IT?
THE ABILITY
TO CLONE MYSELF
AND A YEAR'S SUPPLY
OF ADDERALL.
I'LL PUT ON THE COFFEE.
SMALL TOWNS SUCK
FOR VICTIMOLOGY.
TOO MUCH OVERLAP.
I'VE GOT BOTH WOMEN
AT THE SAME CHURCH,
SAME DOCTOR,
SAME GROCERY STORE.
SHE'S MIMICKING
THE ANGEL MAKER.
MAYBE WE SHOULD LOOK
AT HIS VICTIMS.
Hotchner: YEAH,
BUT THERE'S A DISCONNECT.
THE ANGEL MAKER CHOSE WOMEN
BECAUSE THEY EXCITED HIM
SEXUALLY.
THE COPYCAT'S SATISFACTION
ISN'T SEXUAL.
NOW IT'S IN PERFECTLY
RE-CREATING THE MURDERS.
SO WHAT SHE LOOKS FOR
IN A VICTIM IS SOMEONE
WHO'S EASY TO KILL.
WHICH, FOR HER,
MEANS EASY ACCESS
TO THEIR HOMES.
WHAT DID
DELILAH GRENNAN
DO FOR WORK?
JJ: SHE MADE JEWELRY,
SOLD IT OUT OF HER HOME.
Morgan: SO THEY BOTH HAD
HOME-BASED BUSINESSES.
A STRANGER COULD WALK IN
OFF THE STREET AND BE
A PROSPECTIVE CUSTOMER.
Prentiss:
UNSUB POSES AS A CLIENT,
MAYBE USES THE BATHROOM,
CRACKS THE WINDOW
SO SHE CAN GET
BACK IN LATER.
LET'S CHECK THEIR
BUSINESS RECORDS
AND SEE WHO CAME BY
ON THE DAY
OF THE MURDERS.
NO MATCHING NAMES.
SKY'S SO CLEAR
HERE, HUH?
NEVER SEE STARS
LIKE THIS IN D.C.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
OH, MY GOD.
THE PUNCTURE WOUNDS
ON THE VICTIMS' STOMACHS
REPRESENT CONSTELLATIONS.
CONSTELLATIONS?
DON'T TELL ME THIS GUY
WAS FOLLOWING THE ZODIAC.
NO, THESE ARE FROM A FAMILY
OF CONSTELLATIONS KNOWN
AS THE HEAVENLY WATERS.
WELL, I GUESS
WE KNOW HOW HE CAME UP
WITH THE NICKNAME.
THAT'S WHY HE'D OPEN UP
ALL THE WINDOWS
AFTER EACH KILL,
SO THEIR SOULS COULD
BE RELEASED INTO THE SKY.
DELPHINUS, THE DOLPHIN.
EQUULEUS, THE LITTLE HORSE.
ANYTHING SOUND FAMILIAR?
HIS ORIGAMI THINGS.
Hotchner: THERE ARE
9 CONSTELLATIONS IN
THE HEAVENLY WATERS.
THE ANGEL MAKER
KILLED 6.
YEAH, OUR UNSUB CONTINUED
WHERE HE LEFT OFF.
FIRST SHE DID VELA,
AND THEN LAST NIGHT
SHE DID CARINA.
THE ONLY ONE LEFT
IS COLUMBA, THE DOVE.
ONE MORE KILL
AND SHE COMPLETES HIS SET.
SHE KNEW THE MEANING
OF THE STOMACH WOUNDS,
SOMETHING EVEN
WE DIDN'T KNOW.
SHE MUST HAVE BEEN
A LOT CLOSER TO RYAN
THAN WE THOUGHT.
THEY WEREN'T
JUST CLOSE.
THEY WERE IN LOVE.
HOW'D YOU CRACK IT?
I PROFILED THE AUTHOR.
CORTLAND RYAN WAS ON DEATH ROW
WITH SEVERAL
HIGH-RANKING MEMBERS
OF THE ARYAN BROTHERHOOD.
HE GOT THE CODE
FROM THE ARYANS?
EITHER THAT OR HE READ A LOT
OF 16th-CENTURY LITERATURE.
THE ARYANS LIKED
TO USE A CIPHER BASED
ON A 400-YEAR-OLD CODE
WRITTEN BY
SIR FRANCIS BACON.
Morgan: SO IT'S
A BINARY CODE.
YEAH.
BACON USED
A 21-LETTER ALPHABET.
THIS ONE'S 24.
EACH LETTER IS
ASSIGNED A BIT STRING
OF 5 BINARY DIGITS.
THIS COMBINATION YIELDS
32 POSSIBLE ENCODINGS.
NORMALLY YOU'D USE
A COMPUTER TO RUN
ALL THESE COMBINATIONS,
BUT IT WAS QUICKER JUST
TO DO IT LONGHAND UNTIL
I FOUND THE RIGHT ONE.
HE'S SO LIFELIKE.
WE DON'T HAVE
A COMPLETE RECORD
OF THEIR CORRESPONDENCE,
BUT I WAS ABLE TO MAKE
A CHRONOLOGY.
THE WOMAN HE CALLS "DOVE"
ESTABLISHED CONTACT SHORTLY
AFTER THE TRIAL.
"MY DEAREST CORTLAND,
THANK YOU FOR WRITING
BACK TO ME.
THE DAY THE VERDICT WAS READ,
WE SHARED A SILENT MOMENT..."
Woman: "I KNEW THEN THERE WAS
A FORCE WILLING US TOGETHER.
"EVERY TIME I SEE YOU,
I FEEL WARMED AS IF BY THE SUN,
"YET I FEAR
IF I COME TOO CLOSE,
I'LL BE CONSUMED
BY YOUR FIRE."
Cortland: "EVER SINCE
YOUR VISIT, I AM CRAZED
WITH THOUGHTS OF YOU.
"ALREADY YOU'VE ENTERED
MY DREAMS.
"EACH TIME YOU APPEAR TO ME,
"I'M EMBRACED BY A FEELING
OF TRUST AND BELIEF,
AS IF I'VE KNOWN YOU
ALL MY LIFE."
Woman: "AS ALWAYS,
I AM TOUCHED BY YOUR WORDS,
"BUT I LONG TO SEE YOU AGAIN.
"DAYS PASS QUIETLY,
ONE INTO THE NEXT..."
"MY DOVE..."
"I CAN THINK
OF LITTLE ELSE..."
"MY SECRET WIFE..."
"IF ONLY THEY WOULD
LET US MARRY..."
"ALL APPEALS ARE LOST..."
"I COULD FINALLY
HOLD YOUR HAND..."
"THE GUARDS CELEBRATED
MY DEFEAT BY CLEARING
OUT MY CELL..."
"HERE IS MY FACE..."
"POSSESSIONS MATTER LITTLE
TO A CONDEMNED MAN..."
"THEY DIE WITH YOU,
THE ONLY MAN WHO WILL
EVER TRULY SEE ME."
"TAKE HEART, MY LOVE... *
"BUT I CAN'T LEAVE
THIS WORLD... "
"BEFORE SEEING YOUR FACE
ONE LAST TIME."
"I WILL BRING
A PART OF YOU BACK
INTO THE WORLD,
AND FOREVER YOU WILL
WATCH OVER US
FROM THE STARS."
WHAT DO YOU THINK SHE MEANT
BY THAT LAST LINE,
"I WILL BRING A PART
OF YOU BACK"?
Morgan:
THE MURDERS?
SHE BROUGHT HIM
BACK TO LIFE.
JJ: WHAT IF SHE WAS
TALKING ABOUT HIS CHILD?
Reid: WELL,
SHE DID SAY "US"--
"WATCH OVER US
FROM THE STARS."
SHE USED
THE SEMEN SAMPLES
TO PLANT EVIDENCE,
NOT TO GET PREGNANT.
WHAT IF SHE DID BOTH?
WELL, IF SHE ACTUALLY
HAD HIS KID,
WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO TRACK HER
THROUGH BIRTH RECORDS.
Sheriff: AGENT HOTCHNER--
WE JUST GOT A REPORT
OF A WOMAN ATTACKED
IN HER HOUSE
BY A FEMALE ASSAILANT.
IS SHE OK?
SOUNDS LIKE IT,
BUT I CAN'T SAY THE SAME
FOR THE ATTACKER, THOUGH.
NEIGHBORS HEARD CRIES
FOR HELP, PRETTY SOON HALF
THE BLOCK WAS ON HER.
[POLICE RADIO, INDISTINCT]
THE VICTIM WAS
COMING HOME FROM WORK,
SAID THE SUSPECT
APPROACHED HER
IN HER DRIVEWAY.
ASKED TO USE THE PHONE
TO CALL A TOW TRUCK.
SHE LET HER
IN THE HOUSE?
THAT'S WHEN
THE SUSPECT JUMPED HER.
THAT'S NOT
OUR UNSUB'S M.O.
MAYBE SHE WAS RUSHING IT,
TRYING TO FINISH OFF
THE LAST VICTIM.
THAT'S SHARA.
YOU KNOW HER?
SHARA CARLINO.
ROSSI AND I ALREADY
INTERVIEWED HER.
SHE'S CORTLAND'S
NUMBER-ONE FAN.
HER ALIBI IS SOLID.
SHE'S NOT OUR UNSUB.
SHARA...WHY?
IT WORKED FOR HER.
WHY NOT FOR ME?
I JUST WANT US TO BE
TOGETHER AGAIN.
Garcia: OK, THERE WERE
463 CHILDREN BORN
IN THE LOWER CANAAN AREA
BETWEEN 2006 AND 2008,
SO IF YOU WANT ME TO FIND
BABY ANGEL MAKER, WE'RE GONNA
HAVE TO NARROW THIS DOWN.
JJ: ALL RIGHT,
WELL, REID STILL HAS
MORE LETTERS TO DECODE,
BUT HE DID FIND
A PHRASE.
"I KNEW EVEN BEFORE THEY
TOLD ME THAT THE FUTURE
HAD TAKEN ROOT."
TAKEN ROOT?
SOUNDS LIKE SOMEONE
GOT GOOD NEWS.
DATE OF CONCEPTION.
AND THE DATE
OF THAT LETTER?
UH, JANUARY 7, 2007.
OK, SO WE FAST-FORWARD
9 MONTHS.
UH, 10 MONTHS, ACTUALLY.
REALLY?
I KNOW.
IT WAS NEWS TO ME, TOO.
HUH! OK.
SO WE'LL SEARCH BIRTH RECORDS
FROM AUGUST TO SEPTEMBER 2007.
HOW'S THAT? WE'LL DO
SINGLE MOTHERS ONLY,
IN CASE SHE WANTED TO KEEP
THE FATHER A SECRET,
YOU KNOW, DIDN'T WANT TO BRAG--
"OH, YOUR BABY DADDY'S
A THIRD-GRADE TEACHER?
WELL, MINE LIKES TO
POKE PEOPLE IN THE STOMACH
WITH TOOLS, SO THERE."
THERE. 9 NAMES.
NOW, THAT'S A LITTLE
MORE MANAGEABLE.
HANNAH DREYFUS
WAS IN AN AUTO ACCIDENT.
SHE COULD BARELY WALK.
SHANNON CONWAY MOVED AWAY
WHEN THE PLANT CLOSED
A YEAR AGO.
ANY OTHER NAMES
YOU RECOGNIZE?
NO, I DON'T--WHOA.
WHAT IS IT?
WELL, THIS ONE HERE
SOUNDS FAMILIAR,
BUT I CAN'T REALLY PLACE IT.
CHLOE KELCHER.
CHLOE KELCHER.
THAT IS FAMILIAR.
CHLOE KELCHER.
SHE WAS ON THE JURY.
WELL, THAT MAKES SENSE.
SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN EXPOSED
TO THE CASE EVIDENCE,
SEEN FIRSTHAND
WHAT HE DID TO HIS VICTIMS.
THAT'S WHEN SHE FELL
IN LOVE WITH HIM,
SITTING ACROSS
THE COURTROOM
EVERY DAY.
WELL, IT'S ONE THING
TO HAVE A RELATIONSHIP
WITH A KILLER,
IT'S ANOTHER TO BECOME ONE.
Reid: THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN
AN INCIDENT THAT PROMPTED
THE TRANSFORMATION.
I THINK I KNOW
WHAT IT WAS.
IT'S A DEATH CERTIFICATE.
MICROVESICULAR STEATOSIS.
HER BABY DIED
AT THE HOSPITAL.
CLEAR!
CLEAR.
SHE'S NOT HERE.
ALL RIGHT.
WE ALL KNOW WHAT
THE END GAME IS.
SHE'S LOOKING
FOR HER FINAL VICTIM.
SHE MAY HAVE ALREADY CHOSEN ONE.
LET'S TEAR THIS PLACE APART.
LOOK FOR ANYTHING THAT MIGHT
TELL US WHO SHE'S TARGETED.
LOOK AT THIS.
SHE DID EVERYTHING SHE COULD
TO DENY THE TRUTH.
WHAT, THAT HE WAS
A KILLER?
THAT THEY'D NEVER
BE TOGETHER.
NOTE THE VIEW.
DADDY'S WATCHING.
IT MUST HAVE
DEVASTATED HER TO THINK
THAT SHE COULD HOLD ON
TO RYAN BY HAVING HIS CHILD
AND THEN LOSE THE BABY.
COMPLETING HIS MURDERS
BECAME THE ONLY WAY
SHE COULD HOLD ON TO HIM.
NOT THE ONLY WAY.
WELL...
GUESS THAT ANSWERS THAT.
I ASSUME THAT'S
WHO I THINK IT IS.
GOT AN APPOINTMENT
BOOK HERE.
MEETINGS
WITH DELILAH GRENNAN
AND MAXINE CHANDLER
THE DAY OF EACH MURDER.
SHERIFF, HAVE YOU FOUND
HER TOOLS OR THE GUN?
NOTHING YET.
SHE HAS SOMETHING
THIS MORNING--
"FAYE LANDREAUX,
162 NORTH--"
NORTH RED RIVER
DRIVE.
SHE'S A CPA.
SHE DOES MY TAXES.
Hotchner:
SHE WORK OUT
OF HER HOUSE?
YEP.
LET'S GO.
THAT'S IT.
'85 VOLKSWAGEN.
CHLOE'S HERE.
CAR'S STILL WARM.
WE GOT TO BE RIGHT
BEHIND HER.
HER WINDOWS ARE CLOSED.
THAT'S A GOOD SIGN.
WELL, MY TEAM'S READY.
LET'S GET IN THERE.
SHERIFF, WE DIDN'T
RECOVER A GUN
AT CHLOE'S HOUSE.
WE HAVE TO ASSUME
SHE'S ARMED.
WELL, SO ARE WE.
IF YOU STORM IN NOW,
SHE'LL SHOOT,
AND CHANCES ARE
SHE'LL START WITH
YOUR ACCOUNTANT.
WHAT DO YOU THINK, GUYS?
I THINK YOU SHOULD LOOK
FOR AN OPEN WINDOW.
SHERIFF, I NEED YOU
TO BRING ALL YOUR VEHICLES
AROUND TO THE FRONT,
FACING FORWARD
WITH LIGHTS OFF,
AND I NEED A MEGAPHONE.
ALL RIGHT.
HOTCH, I DON'T
THINK YOU CAN GET
THROUGH TO HER.
NO, BUT MAYBE YOU CAN.
PROFILE'S CLEAR.
YOU CAN'T TALK
THIS WOMAN DOWN.
NO, BUT JUST TO OCCUPY HER.
IF WE'RE RIGHT ABOUT THE M.O.,
SHE'S LEFT A WINDOW OPEN
SOMEWHERE.
MORGAN WILL FIND A WAY IN.
WE JUST NEED TO BUY HIM
SOME TIME.
HIT THE LIGHTS.
[SIREN]
CHLOE,
THIS IS THE FBI.
WE KNOW
YOU'RE IN THERE,
AND WE KNOW WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO.
WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
DON'T MOVE, BITCH,
OR I SWEAR TO GOD,
I WILL SPLIT YOU IN TWO.
PLEASE, DON'T DO THIS.
ROLL OVER. ROLL OVER.
ROLL OVER!
Prentiss: I KNOW YOU THINK THAT
FINISHING WHAT CORTLAND STARTED
WILL BRING YOU CLOSER TO HIM,
BUT FIRST YOU SHOULD KNOW
WHO HE REALLY WAS.
DON'T WORRY.
THERE'S A MUCH
BETTER PLACE FOR YOU.
Prentiss: I KNOW
YOU THOUGHT YOU WERE SPECIAL,
BUT THE TRUTH IS,
THE SAME THINGS HE WROTE TO YOU,
HE WROTE TO MANY OTHER WOMEN.
I'VE SEEN THE LETTERS.
DOZENS READ THE SAME LINES:
"WITHOUT THE FLESH,
THERE IS ONLY THE SOUL."
"YOU DON'T NEED TO TOUCH ME
TO FEEL THE LOVE I HAVE
FOR YOU."
DOES THAT SOUND FAMILIAR?
[BREATHING HARD]
Prentiss: CORTLAND WASN'T
WHO YOU THOUGHT HE WAS.
HE--HE WAS
A NARCISSIST, CHLOE.
HE WASN'T CAPABLE OF LOVING
ANYONE BUT HIMSELF.
TO CARLA KETTINGER,
HE WROTE,
"EVER SINCE YOUR VISIT,
I AM CRAZED WITH THOUGHTS
OF YOU..."
Cortland: "ALREADY YOU HAVE
ENTERED MY DREAMS."
Prentiss: "EACH TIME
YOU APPEAR TO ME..."
Cortland: "I AM EMBRACED
BY A FEELING OF TRUST
"AND BELIEF, AS IF I'VE
KNOWN YOU ALL MY LIFE.
"IT'S CLEAR TO ME NOW
THAT YOU ARE MY FATE.
WE ARE DESTINED
TO BE TOGETHER."
Prentiss: "AND WHEN I AM GONE,
THAT WILL NOT CHANGE.
Cortland: "I WILL LIVE ON
IN YOU.
IN DEATH, OUR UNION
WILL BE ETERNAL."
[FAYE WHIMPERING]
Prentiss:
"ALL APPEALS ARE LOST.
THE GUARDS CELEBRATED MY DEFEAT
BY CLEARING OUT..."
NO, NO, NO.
DON'T SPEAK.
DON'T TALK.
I'M GONNA GET YOU
OUT OF HERE, OK?
Cortland: "POSSESSIONS MATTER
LITTLE TO A CONDEMNED MAN,
"BUT I CANNOT LEAVE THIS WORLD
"WITHOUT SEEING YOUR FACE
ONE LAST TIME.
OK, THAT WINDOW OVER THERE.
I WANT YOU TO GO TO THAT WINDOW.
IT'S GONNA BE OK.
OK, GO, GO, GO.
Prentiss: IT ISN'T YOUR
FAULT THAT HE MADE YOU
FEEL THESE THINGS.
IT ISN'T YOUR FAULT
YOUR BABY DIED.
NO!
IT'S OVER, CHLOE.
WE HAVE FAYE.
[GRUNTING]
Prentiss:
YOU HAVE NOWHERE TO GO.
I THINK WE GOT SOME TEAR GAS.
I'M ASSUMING IT'S STILL GOOD.
WE'RE NOT GONNA NEED IT.
SHE DOESN'T HAVE
ANY PLACE TO GO.
WELL, MAYBE
SHE'LL DO US ALL A FAVOR
AND PUT HERSELF DOWN.
SHE'S NOT GONNA
DO THAT, EITHER.
SHE'S NOT DONE.
CHLOE, DROP THE GUN.
CHLOE,
DROP THE GUN.
DAMN IT, LADY, DROP IT!
I'M COMING TO YOU, BABY.
[HOTCHNER GROANING]
[HIGH-PITCHED SOUND]
OH...
HOTCH.
OH...
[HOTCHNER GROANING]
HOTCH?
OH...
[SIGHS]
WHAT DID SHE DO?
WE TOOK HER VICTIM.
SHE HAD TO COMPLETE
HIS WORK.
Hotchner:
WENDELL BERRY SAID,
"THE PAST IS OUR DEFINITION.
"WE MAY STRIVE WITH GOOD REASON
TO ESCAPE IT
"OR TO ESCAPE WHAT IS BAD IN IT,
BUT WE WILL ESCAPE IT
ONLY BY ADDING SOMETHING
BETTER TO IT."
I MADE THESE
FOR YOUR FLIGHT.
THANK YOU.
IT'S SMALL THANKS, BUT--
MY RECIPE.
I'M SORRY YOU
HAD TO GO THROUGH
ALL THIS AGAIN.
I SUPPOSE WE NEVER STOP
GOING THROUGH IT,
BUT...MAYBE NOW.
HOPEFULLY.
SHE GONNA BE OK?
YEAH, SHE'LL BE FINE.
MAYBE YOU GOT TO SIT
WITH THE PAST BEFORE
YOU CAN WALK AWAY FROM IT.
THANK YOU, SHERIFF.
THANK YOU.
JJ: ANYONE GET DIRECTIONS
BACK TO THE AIRSTRIP?
TOWN'S ONLY GOT ONE ROAD.
WE'LL FIND IT.
YEAH, MORGAN DOESN'T
LIKE TO FOLLOW
DIRECTIONS.
YOU DIDN'T KNOW
ABOUT THAT?
YEAH, HE LIKES TO VIBE IT.
OK, SMART-ASS. YOU DRIVE.
OH, GREAT.
SWEET.
THANK YOU.
FOR THE FLIGHT.
WHAT?
JUST GONNA GRAB MY BAG.
YOU'RE NOT COMING?
I, UH,
THINK I'M GONNA DRIVE.
OH, IT'S OVER 7 HOURS
BACK TO QUANTICO.
I REALLY SHOULDN'T
BE FLYING.
OH.
I'VE DONE
THAT DRIVE BEFORE.
YOU'LL SEE A LOT
OF PRETTY COUNTRY
ALONG THE BYWAYS.
YOU MIGHT CONSIDER...
STRETCHING IT OUT
A DAY OR TWO.
MAYBE I WILL. THANKS.