Criminal Minds (2005–…): Season 4, Episode 18 - Omnivore - full transcript
After being inactive for 10 years, Hotch's first BAU case, an elusive serial killer known as the Reaper, starts killing again.
MR. HOTCHNER?
YES.
PLEASE, HE'S BEEN WAITING.
THANK YOU.
YOU'RE THE ONLY PERSON
HE'S ASKED FOR.
YOU MUST BE GOOD FRIENDS.
ACTUALLY, WE WORKED
TOGETHER ONCE,
ABOUT 10 YEARS AGO.
UH, HE'LL BE LUCKY IF
HE MAKES IT THROUGH THE NIGHT.
ANYTHING YOU DO TO EASE HIS PAIN
WOULD BE A BLESSING.
[DOOR OPENS]
HI, TOM.
YOU CAME.
THANK YOU.
OF COURSE, TOM,
BUT I DON'T KNOW WHY
YOU ASKED FOR ME.
THE REAPER.
I SHUT DOWN THE INVESTIGATION
WITHOUT AN ARREST.
THE KILLINGS STOPPED,
AND I SENT YOU AWAY.
YOU DESERVE TO KNOW WHY.
OK. TELL ME.
A DEAL WITH THE DEVIL.
"IF YOU STOP HUNTING ME,
I'LL STOP HUNTING THEM.
"FOR AS LONG AS
WE BOTH SHALL LIVE,
"TIL DEATH DO US PART.
"IF YOU AGREE
TO MY TERMS,
TAKE OUT A PERSONAL AD
IN THE MICHIGAN POST."
THIS IS A CONTRACT.
WHICH WE BOTH HONORED.
YOU KNOW WE WEREN'T CLOSE
TO CATCHING HIM.
IF IT DIDN'T WORK,
I COULD HAVE RESTARTED
THE INVESTIGATION,
BUT IT DID.
THE KILLING STOPPED.
I WAITED 6 WEEKS--
6 WEEKS--
BEFORE I SENT YOU AWAY.
BUT, TOM, HOW DO YOU
KNOW HE STOPPED?
HE COULD HAVE JUST
GONE SOMEPLACE ELSE.
NO. I'VE KEPT WATCH.
I KNOW HE STOPPED.
SOONER OR LATER,
WE WOULD HAVE
CAUGHT A BREAK.
HOW MANY PEOPLE
WOULD HE HAVE KILLED
BEFORE WE CAUGHT
THAT BREAK, HUH?
WOULD ALL THOSE LIVES
BE WORTH IT?
WE DON'T GET TO MAKE
THOSE DECISIONS.
WE DON'T LET THEM
GET AWAY WITH IT.
THEN YOU'LL HAVE TO PAY
FOR MY SIN.
HOW DO YOU MEAN?
THE CONTRACT'S
ABOUT TO EXPIRE.
I'VE FELT HIM WATCHING ME.
HE KNOWS.
HE'S BEEN WAITING FOR THIS.
YOU THINK HE'S GONNA
START KILLING AGAIN.
I DID IT TO SAVE LIVES.
PLEASE TELL
THE VICTIMS' FAMILIES
THAT I'M SORRY. PLEASE.
TELL THEM--
TELL THEM I--
I HAD NO CHOICE.
I'LL TELL THEM
YOU'RE SORRY.
YES, THAT'S RIGHT.
AARON HOTCHNER.
SERGEANT O'MARA
HAS THE NUMBER.
THANK YOU.
COME IN.
I THINK I FOUND IT.
MICHIGAN POST,
MARCH 7, 1998.
IS THAT RIGHT?
HUH.
YES.
'CAUSE I FOUND IT,
DO I GET TO KNOW
WHAT IT'S ABOUT?
THE REAPER.
LIKE THE BOSTON REAPER?
I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW
THE B.A.U. WORKED
ON THAT CASE.
1998. IT WAS MY FIRST CASE
FOR THE B.A.U. AS LEAD PROFILER.
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG,
BUT WE DON'T
HAVE A PROFILE
FOR THE REAPER
IN OUR SYSTEM, DO WE?
THAT'LL BE ALL, PENELOPE.
YOU CAN GO HOME NOW.
OK.
GOOD NIGHT, SIR.
GOOD NIGHT.
THIS MORNING.
YES, IT IS A GOOD THING
THAT HE WENT QUICKLY
IN THE END.
WELL, I APPRECIATE
YOU CALLING ME.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
[FLAT TIRE THUMPING]
HOW BAD IS IT?
WE HAVE 2 FLATS.
HOW DID WE GET 2 FLATS?
I DON'T KNOW.
ALL RIGHT,
I'LL CALL TRIPLE-A.
[DIALING CELL PHONE]
[TRUNK CLOSES]
[GRUNTS]
WHAT IF IT WAS US?
YOU'D WANT SOMEBODY
TO STOP, WOULDN'T YOU?
HEY, ARE YOU ALL RIGHT?
UH, NO, I GOT 2 FLATS.
I ONLY GOT ONE SPARE.
NINA HALE.
ROUTE 128.
YOU WANT TO TRY
ONE OF MINE,
SEE IF IT FITS?
OH, THANKS.
MY GIRLFRIEND'S ON
WITH TRIPLE-A.
WELL, I'LL GIVE YOU
MY ADDRESS.
IF IT WORKS,
YOU CAN SEND ME A CHECK.
I MEAN,
IF YOU WANT TO STAY
OUT HERE ALL NIGHT,
THAT'S UP TO YOU.
I JUST WANTED TO
MAKE SURE YOU'RE OK.
HEY, YOU KNOW WHAT? SURE.
LET'S GIVE IT A SHOT, RIGHT?
YOU GOT IT.
OUR CAR HAS 2 FLAT TIRES,
AND WE DON'T HAVE
A SECOND SPARE.
YEAH.
JUST PAST NEEDHAM.
[GROANS]
I REALLY APPRECIATE THIS.
[BEHIND MASK]
MY PLEASURE.
EVAN?
EVAN!
AAH!
GIVE ME YOUR WATCH.
PLEASE.
PLEASE DON'T HURT US.
THIS WON'T HURT.
PLEASE, NO.
SHH.
I'M NOT GONNA SHOOT YOU.
SHH.
THANK YOU.
YOU'RE WELCOME.
AAH!
[GROANING]
OH, NINA...
I HIT MY HEAD.
[GROANS]
NINA'S DEAD.
ARE YOU SCARED?
[WHIMPERING]
YOU SHOULD BE.
[GUNSHOT]
Hotch: "FATE IS NOT SATISFIED
WITH INFLICTING ONE CALAMITY."
ROMAN AUTHOR PUBLILIUS SYRUS.
BYE.
HI. YOU WANTED TO KNOW
IMMEDIATELY
ABOUT ANY UNUSUAL
BOSTON HOMICIDES?
WE'RE GOING TO BOSTON.
WHAT? WAI--SHOULDN'T WE WAIT
FOR THE OFFICIAL REQUEST?
WE HAVEN'T BEEN INVITED--
WE WILL BE.
WELL, IT LOOKS LIKE
WE'RE GOING TO BOSTON.
"THE REAPER IS DRIVEN
BY A NEED TO DOMINATE,
CONTROL, AND MANIPULATE."
SO THEN WHY
WOULD HE OFFER A DEAL
THAT WOULD STOP HIM
FROM DOING THAT?
WELL, KILLING
GAVE HIM POWER,
BUT AFTER SO MANY,
THE PAYOFF BEGAN
TO DIMINISH.
SO HE DECIDED
TO SWITCH TACTICS.
OFFERING THE DEAL GAVE
HIM THE ULTIMATE POWER,
BETTER EVEN
THAN KILLING.
HE MANIPULATED THE POLICE
INTO VOLUNTARILY SURRENDERING.
HE EVEN GOT IT
IN WRITING.
HE WON.
WHY START KILLING AGAIN?
WELL, BECAUSE THE ONLY PERSON
WHO KNEW HE'D WON,
THE PERSON HE MADE
THE DEAL WITH, JUST DIED.
NARCISSISTIC KILLERS
NEED OTHER PEOPLE
TO RECOGNIZE THEIR POWER.
THAT'S WHY
THEY CONTACT THE MEDIA.
SO HOW DID HE STOP
FOR 10 YEARS?
IN NIGHT OF THE REAPER,
THE AUTHOR SUGGESTS
HE HAD BEEN ARRESTED
FOR AN UNRELATED CRIME
OR DIED.
PERHAPS HE'S TRYING TO CORRECT
THAT MISCONCEPTION.
WHAT HAS HE BEEN DOING
ALL THIS TIME?
PLANNING WHAT HE WOULD DO
IF HE STARTED KILLING AGAIN.
SO FROM '95 TO '98,
HE SHOOTS, STABS,
AND BLUDGEONS 21 VICTIMS--
MEN, WOMEN,
ALL AGES, ALL TYPES,
NO SPECIFIC VICTIMOLOGY
OR M.O. HOW DID YOU BUILD
A PROFILE FROM THAT?
WE DIDN'T.
SHAUNESSY SENT US HOME
BEFORE WE HAD A CHANCE.
BTK, THE ZODIAC,
AND THE REAPER ALL
HAVE SIMILARITIES.
THEY'RE ALL
HIGHLY INTELLIGENT,
DISCIPLINED,
SADISTIC KILLERS
WHO NAME THEMSELVES
IN THE PRESS.
HIGHLY INTELLIGENT MAY BE
A BIT OF AN UNDERSTATEMENT.
THE REAPER AND THE ZODIAC
KILLER HAVE NEVER BEEN ARRESTED.
AND THE BTK KILLER WAS ONLY
CAUGHT AFTER 25 YEARS
BECAUSE HE WENT TO THE PRESS
TO COUNTER A BOOK
THAT SAID HE'D DIED, MOVED AWAY,
OR BEEN LOCKED UP,
JUST LIKE THIS ONE.
SPEAKING OF THE MEDIA,
WHEN THIS GETS OUT,
IT'S GOING TO BE A FRENZY.
IF THEY GET WIND OF THIS,
THEY'RE GOING TO BE
ALL OVER THE BOSTON POLICE.
THE LONGER WE CAN FLOAT
THE COPYCAT STORY,
THE BETTER CHANCE WE'LL
HAVE OF CATCHING HIM.
ROSSI, PRENTISS,
AND MORGAN, GO TO
THE FIELD OFFICE,
SET UP SHOP, GO THROUGH
EVERYTHING THERE.
J.J. AND REID, WE'LL GO
TO THE CRIME SCENE.
I WORKED THE REAPER CASE
FOR 18 MONTHS.
IF THERE'S ANY PROOF
THAT THIS HORRIBLE CRIME
IS ANYTHING MORE
THAN A COPYCAT,
I'LL BE THE FIRST ONE
TO LET YOU KNOW.
SORRY I HAVEN'T
CALLED YOU BACK.
AS YOU CAN SEE,
I'M BUSY.
IT'S NOT A COPYCAT, MIKE.
I WISH IT WERE,
BUT IT ISN'T.
YEAH, NO OFFENSE,
YOU DON'T KNOW THAT,
AND I DIDN'T
INVITE YOU IN.
SHAUNESSY DID.
WANT TO INVITE US IN?
WHAT WAS HE THINKING?
THIS COULD DESTROY
THE DEPARTMENT.
I KNOW.
THIS IS S.S.A.
JENNIFER JAREAU,
DR. SPENCER REID.
SERGEANT MIKE O'MARA.
UH, WE'RE SETTING UP
AT THE FIELD OFFICE.
OK. I'M DONE HERE.
GIVE THEM ANYTHING
THEY WANT.
THANK YOU.
NINA HALE, 19,
AND EVAN HARVEY, 23.
NINA'S THROAT
WAS SLASHED,
SHE WAS STABBED
46 TIMES.
EVAN WAS BLUDGEONED
AND THEN SHOT.
NO SHELL CASINGS
WERE FOUND.
HE PREFERRED REVOLVERS,
.44 MAGNUM.
THE YOUNGER THE FEMALE VICTIM,
THE MORE TIME
HE SPENDS WITH THEM,
USUALLY WITH A KNIFE.
TAN LINE ON HER WRIST.
PROBABLY WEARING
A WATCH OF SOME SORT.
DO WE HAVE HIS WALLET?
THE REAPER TOOK ITEMS
FROM EACH VICTIM
AND PLACED THEM ON THE NEXT,
SO AS TO MAKE SURE
WE KNEW IT WAS HIM.
NO CORRECTIVE LENS
REQUIREMENT.
THE GLASSES AREN'T HIS?
HE ONLY TOOK GLASSES
FROM ONE VICTIM--THE NINTH.
WE SHOULD HAVE FOUND THEM
ON THE TENTH, AND WE DIDN'T.
THEY WERE NEVER FOUND.
WHAT WAS SO SPECIAL
ABOUT THE NINTH VICTIM?
HE SURVIVED.
GEORGE FOYET, 28,
WAS THE NINTH VICTIM
AND THE ONLY ONE
TO SURVIVE THE REAPER.
Rossi:
NOT FOR LACK OF TRYING.
AMANDA BERTRAND, 19,
HIS DATE FOR THE EVENING,
WAS NOT AS LUCKY.
HE LIKES TO ATTACK THEM
INSIDE OR NEAR THEIR CARS,
AT NIGHT, ON POORLY LIT,
LESS POPULATED ROADS.
FOYET SAID HE APPROACHED THEM
PRETENDING TO BE A LOST TOURIST.
IN THE HOSPITAL, WE PUT
FOYET WITH A SKETCH ARTIST.
THE REAPER ALWAYS USES
SOME SORT OF RUSE
TO GET CLOSE TO AND SPEND
TIME WITH HIS VICTIMS.
THE EYE, AS HE DEPICTS IT,
APPEARS TO BE
THE EYE OF PROVIDENCE,
A SYMBOL ADOPTED
BY THE U.S. GOVERNMENT
AND INCORPORATED INTO
THE GREAT SEAL IN 1782
WITH THE WORDS,
"ANNUIT COEPTIS"
INSCRIBED BENEATH.
THAT'S LATIN FOR
"PROVIDENCE"--OR FATE--
"HAS FAVORED
OUR UNDERTAKINGS."
UH, THE REAPER SEEMS
TO SEE HIMSELF
AS THE PERSONIFICATION
OF FATE.
SO, HOW DID FOYET SURVIVE?
Woman:
911. WHAT'S YOUR EMERGENCY?
Man, altered:
I JUST MURDERED 2 MORE.
EXCUSE ME, SIR, DID YOU SAY
YOU MURDERED SOMEONE?
VICTIMS 8 AND 9.
BY A SILVER TOYOTA
ON RIVERTON
PAST THE TYSON QUARRY.
THAT CALL WAS MADE
FROM A PAY PHONE
ABOUT A MILE FROM
THE CRIME SCENE.
E.M.T.s ARRIVED
15 MINUTES LATER.
BERTRAND WAS D.O.A.,
FOYET BARELY BREATHING.
SO THE REAPER
MADE ONE OF THESE CALLS
AFTER EACH OF HIS KILLINGS
TELLING THE POLICE
WHERE TO FIND THE BODIES.
UNTIL THIS ONE,
THE NINTH.
IF HE HADN'T MADE
THIS CALL,
FOYET WOULDN'T
HAVE BEEN FOUND IN TIME.
THE CALL SAVED HIM.
SO THE REAPER DIDN'T
MAKE ANY 911 CALLS
[CELL PHONE RINGS]
AFTER THIS ONE.
YEAH?
LOOKS LIKE HE
LEARNED HIS LESSON.
THERE'S A REASON
HE LEFT FOYET'S GLASSES
AT THE LAST CRIME SCENE.
FOYET COULD BE
IN DANGER.
WE'LL FIND HIM.
UH, HOTCH,
THERE'S A REPORTER OUTSIDE
INSISTING ON
SPEAKING WITH YOU.
ROY COLSON.
HE SAYS HE KNOWS YOU.
ROY.
AGENT HOTCHNER.
SO IF IT'S, UH,
JUST A COPYCAT,
WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?
HELPING THE POLICE
CATCH HIM.
IS THAT YOUR STORY?
COME ON. I WROTE
THE BOOK ON THIS GUY.
I EVEN, UH--EVEN
SENT YOU A SIGNED COPY.
I--I ASSUME YOU GOT IT.
OFFICIALLY, WE HAVE NO REASON
TO THINK THAT HE'S ANYTHING
BUT A COPYCAT.
WELL, HOW ABOUT
UNOFFICIALLY?
WHAT'S MORE IMPORTANT
TO YOU, ROY,
GETTING THE STORY
OR GETTING THE KILLER?
I--I, UH...
I SPENT TIME
WITH THE FAMILIES.
I, UH--I TOLD
THE VICTIMS' STORIES.
NOW, YOU WOULD KNOW THAT
IF YOU READ MY BOOK.
IT'S A GOOD BOOK, ROY.
YOU TREATED THE VICTIMS
WITH RESPECT,
AND YOU TREATED US FAIRLY.
EVERY DIME I MADE
WENT TO THE FAMILIES.
I KNOW. THAT'S WHY
I CAME DOWN.
THE MINUTE I HAVE
SOMETHING I CAN SAY,
I'LL CALL YOU.
THANKS.
IF IT'S HIM,
IT WON'T BE LONG.
[SIREN]
I DON'T BELIEVE IT.
UNBELIEVABLE.
HONEY, PLEASE DON'T.
I'M NOT SPEEDING.
I'M NOT DRUNK.
GOOD EVENING, OFFICER.
LICENSE, REGISTRATION,
AND PROOF OF INSURANCE.
I'LL BE RIGHT BACK.
HE HASN'T EVEN TOLD ME
WHY HE STOPPED US.
LET'S JUST
GET THIS OVER WITH.
[BEHIND MASK]
I'M GONNA LET YOU OFF
WITH A WARNING.
A WARNING? FOR WHAT?
YOU WERE
AT THE WRONG PLACE
AT THE WRONG TIME.
EXCUSE ME?
AAH! AAH!
AND NOW I'M GONNA
KILL YOUR WIFE, ARTHUR.
[SCREAMING]
PLEASE! NO!
[SCREAMING]
[GUNSHOT]
[SIREN]
Rossi: ANOTHER COUPLE.
MUCH OLDER THIS TIME.
ONE SHOT
AND ONE STABBED.
NO REASON
TO STOP OUT HERE.
HIS LICENSE AND REGISTRATION
ARE OUT OF HIS WALLET.
LOOKS LIKE HE USED
A COP RUSE.
GOOD SPOT.
ISOLATED,
FEW DRIVERS.
HE LEFT NINA HALE'S WATCH.
OK. SO WHAT'D HE TAKE?
HIS WEDDING RING.
ARTHUR AND DIANE LANESSA.
WEYMOUTH.
MARRIED 32 YEARS.
THEY WERE COMING HOME
FROM THE ELKS,
WHERE THEY PLAYED BINGO
TWICE A WEEK.
I GOTTA
GO MAKE NOTIFICATION.
YOU WANT COMPANY?
I GOT IT.
LOOKS LIKE
HE WENT THROUGH HER PURSE.
ANY IDEA WHAT
HE WAS LOOKING FOR?
THE QUESTION MARK
IS NEW.
IT'S FOR US.
HE'S SAYING IT'S NOT FATE.
HE'S SAYING WE HAD 10 YEARS
TO SAVE THEM
AND THAT THESE LATEST ONES
ARE ON US.
YOU GOT ALL THAT
FROM ONE QUESTION MARK.
THAT'S IMPRESSIVE.
I MAY KNOW HIM BETTER
THAN I'VE LET ON.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
IT MEANS THAT THERE IS
A PROFILE ON THE REAPER.
I THOUGHT
WE WERE CALLED OFF
BEFORE WE HAD ONE.
WE WERE. I HAD JUST STARTED
THE PROFILE,
AND THEN HE STOPPED KILLING,
SO OFFICIALLY WE WERE DONE.
BUT THIS CASE...
IT STUCK WITH YOU.
I KEPT COMING BACK TO IT
OVER THE YEARS,
AND I WORKED ON IT ALONE.
SO YOU NEVER SHARED IT
WITH ANYONE.
I KNOW I'M ALWAYS PREACHING
THAT PROFILING IS
A COLLABORATIVE EFFORT,
BUT THIS ONE WASN'T.
I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE IF--
IF I WAS WRONG,
I WAS GONNA HEAD US
IN THE WRONG DIRECTION.
NOW YOU THINK
YOU'RE RIGHT.
THE MORE I SEE, THE MORE
ACCURATE I THINK IT MAY BE.
OK.
THEN WE NEED
TO HEAR IT.
THE REAPER FITS A PROFILE
WE REFER TO AS AN OMNIVORE.
UNLIKE MOST SERIAL KILLERS,
AN OMNIVORE DOESN'T TARGET
A SPECIFIC VICTIM TYPE.
ALTHOUGH HE TENDS TO FOCUS
ON HIS YOUNGER FEMALE VICTIMS
WITH HIS KNIFE,
HE ESSENTIALLY IS A PREDATOR
WHO WILL KILL ANYONE.
WHY IS HE SO DEMOCRATIC?
BECAUSE HIS KILLS AREN'T
JUST ABOUT HIS VICTIMS.
HE NEEDS RECOGNITION.
HE NEEDS US TO KNOW.
THE SYMBOLS,
THE PLACEMENT
OF PRIOR VICTIMS'
POSSESSIONS ON
SUBSEQUENT VICTIMS--
IT'S ALL FOR US.
WHY?
POWER.
THE SHAUNESSY LETTER IS
THE CLEAREST EXAMPLE OF THIS.
HE MANIPULATED TOM SHAUNESSY
INTO LITERALLY
SURRENDERING TO HIM.
THE BURDEN
WAS TOO MUCH TO BEAR.
IN A VERY REAL SENSE,
TOM SHAUNESSY WAS
THE REAPER'S 22nd VICTIM.
LIKE BTK KILLER
DENNIS RADER,
THE REAPER IS
EXTREMELY DISCIPLINED.
IN HIS EVERYDAY LIFE,
THIS WILL VERY LIKELY
MAKE HIM SO INFLEXIBLE,
HE CAN'T KEEP CLOSE
RELATIONSHIPS
OR WORK CLOSELY
WITH OTHERS.
I BELIEVE OUR KILLER
HAS ANOTHER INTEREST
THAT MAY GIVE US THE BEST
OPPORTUNITY TO CATCH HIM.
THE REAPER'S LAST VICTIM
WAS AN OLDER WOMAN.
HE KILLED HER QUICKLY,
WITH A SINGLE SHOT.
THE PRIOR, YOUNGER VICTIM,
HE SPENT MORE TIME WITH
AND STABBED 46 TIMES.
WHY?
HE PAYS SPECIAL ATTENTION
TO HIS YOUNGER
FEMALE VICTIMS,
AND HIS WEAPON OF CHOICE
WITH THEM IS THE KNIFE,
A SUBSTITUTE INSTRUMENT
FOR BODILY PENETRATION.
AND THE YOUNGER THE VICTIM,
THE MORE TIME AND
EFFORT HE SPENDS.
I THINK OUR GUY
IS A HEBOPHILE.
HEBOPHILE?
SOMEONE WHO'S ATTRACTED
TO ADOLESCENT
POSTPUBESCENT CHILDREN.
TEENAGERS.
LOOK FOR MEN WITH ACCESS
AND AUTHORITY--
HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS,
COUNSELORS, COACHES--
AND ANYONE WHO'S BEEN
CHARGED WITH SEX CRIMES
AGAINST TEENAGE GIRLS
IN THE LAST 10 YEARS.
THAT'S ALL FOR NOW.
THANK YOU.
GARCIA CAN'T FIND
GEORGE FOYET.
I'VE GOT NOTHING, SIR.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
HE'S GONE. I MEAN,
HE'S COMPLETELY OFF THE GRID,
AND HE'S GONE.
HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?
9 MONTHS AFTER HE WAS
RELEASED FROM THE HOSPITAL,
HE, UH, QUIT HIS JOB,
SOLD HIS CAR,
CLOSED HIS BANK ACCOUNTS,
CANCELED HIS CREDIT CARDS,
CELL PHONE, APARTMENT,
EVERYTHING.
HE HAS NO PAPER,
THUS HE HAS NO TRAIL,
AND I CAN'T FIND HIM
'CAUSE HE'S GONE.
YOU THINK
IT'S INTENTIONAL?
IT'S MORE THAN THAT.
I--EVEN DEAD PEOPLE STAY
ON THE GRID FOR DECADES.
TAKE IT FROM ME,
ERASING YOURSELF LIKE THIS,
I-IT'S EXTREMELY DIFFICULT.
IT TAKES COMMITMENT.
YOU'D HAVE TO BE WILLING
TO CUT EVERY TIE
OF EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE
YOU'VE EVER KNOWN
IN YOUR ENTIRE LIFE.
IT'S LIKE--
IT'S LIKE KILLING YOURSELF.
I GOTTA SAY,
THIS IS IMPRESSIVE.
WELL, AFTER WHAT
THE GUY'S BEEN THROUGH,
CAN YOU BLAME HIM?
I MEAN, FOYET'S
THE ONLY LIVING PERSON
WHO KNOWS WHAT
THE REAPER LOOKS LIKE,
AND HE'S STILL OUT THERE.
BUT IT DOESN'T CHANGE
THE FACT THAT WE STILL
NEED TO FIND HIM.
Garcia: I'LL KEEP LOOKING.
GARCIA, WE DON'T
HAVE MUCH TIME.
I KNOW, SIR.
HE WOULD HAVE
TO COMPLETELY
ISOLATE HIMSELF.
HE'S TOTALLY ALONE.
BUT HOW DO YOU CUT ALL TIES?
YOU'D HAVE TO TALK
TO SOMEONE, RIGHT?
[LINE RINGING]
COLSON.
ROY. AARON HOTCHNER.
I NEED A FAVOR.
HOW DID COLSON
FIND THIS GUY?
HE INTERVIEWED FOYET
EXTENSIVELY FOR HIS BOOK.
THEY KEPT IN TOUCH.
THEY'RE FRIENDS?
SORT OF.
BUT FOYET WOULDN'T GIVE HIM
HIS PHONE NUMBER.
HE GAVE HIM ONE OF
HIS ALIASES, THOUGH.
THAT'S HIM.
GEORGE FOYET?
IT'S OK.
WE'RE F.B.I.
THIS IS AGENT ROSSI.
I'M AGENT HOTCHNER.
WE MET ONCE BEFORE.
DO YOU REMEMBER?
YEAH, I REMEMBER.
WOULD YOU MIND IF WE GET
OFF THE STREET, PLEASE?
SURE.
[COUGHS]
[COUGHING]
HOW'D YOU GUYS FIND ME?
ROY COLSON.
OH.
WELL, IS THIS GONNA
TAKE LONG? 'CAUSE I REALLY
CAN'T BE LATE FOR WORK.
WHAT DO YOU DO?
I'M A FREELANCE
COMPUTER SPECIALIST
WITH THE CITY.
WE'RE SORRY TO BOTHER YOU.
WE'LL MAKE IT AS QUICK
AS POSSIBLE.
THIS YOURS?
I KNEW IT WASN'T A COPYCAT.
[COUGHING]
THANK YOU.
I'M SORRY.
I WAS GONNA PROPOSE
TO HER THAT NIGHT...
AT THE RESTAURANT,
BUT I GOT COLD FEET.
THE RING WAS STILL IN MY POCKET
WHEN HE APPROACHED US.
HE SAID HE WAS LOST.
HE HAD ONE OF THOSE
SIGHTSEEING BOOKLETS.
I WAS LOOKING AT IT
WHEN HE STABBED ME.
YEAH...PERFECT TIMI--
MR. FOYET, YOU DON'T NEED
TO GO THROUGH THIS AGAIN.
I COULDN'T MOVE.
I JUST SAT THERE, BLEEDING.
I WATCHED HIM KILL MANDY.
HE STABBED HER 67 TIMES.
DO YOU KNOW HOW LONG
IT TAKES TO STAB
SOMEBODY 67 TIMES?
I NEVER FOUND THE RING.
HE SHOULD HAVE LEFT
YOUR GLASSES
ON HIS NEXT VICTIM,
BUT HE DIDN'T.
HE HELD ON TO THEM
ALL THIS TIME.
WHAT, YOU THINK HE'S GOT
SOME SPECIAL INTEREST IN ME?
I'VE BEEN LIVING
WITH THAT POSSIBILITY
FOR THE PAST 11 YEARS.
HAVE YOU RECEIVED
ANY STRANGE LETTERS
OR CALLS?
HANG-UPS?
I KEEP RESIDENCES
UNDER DIFFERENT NAMES.
I MOVE BETWEEN THEM RANDOMLY.
HE LIKES TO GET YOU IN A CAR,
SO I TAKE THE BUS.
BELIEVE ME, I'VE GONE
THROUGH GREAT LENGTHS
TO MAKE SURE THAT NONE
OF THE THINGS YOU'VE JUST
MENTIONED EVER HAPPENED.
WE'LL NEED YOUR OTHER
NAMES AND RESIDENCES
SO WE CAN REACH YOU.
WE CAN TAKE YOU
SOMEPLACE SAFE
UNTIL THIS IS OVER.
NO. BOSTON IS MY HOME.
IT'S THE ONE THING
I PROMISED I WOULD
NEVER LET HIM TAKE FROM ME.
THEN WE'LL
PROTECT YOU HERE.
YOU CAN'T PROTECT ME.
NOBODY CAN.
PLEASE BE CAREFUL WITH THIS.
PLEASE.
IT'S SAFE WITH US.
HE'S JUST A MAN,
NOTHING MORE.
THEN WHY CAN'T YOU CATCH HIM?
WE WILL.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
[CAR DOORS CLOSE]
HEY, UH, THIS WAS
DROPPED OFF AT MY OFFICE.
I'LL GET THIS TO THE LAB.
ARE YOU GOING TO RUN
THE STORY, ROY?
YOU KNOW, IF I DON'T,
HE'LL JUST GIVE IT
TO SOMEBODY ELSE.
MAYBE, MAYBE NOT.
TO HIM YOU'RE SPECIAL.
HE WANTS YOU TO KNOW
WHY HE STOPPED.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
YOU WROTE HIS BIOGRAPHY, ROY.
BELIEVE ME, OVER THE LAST
10 YEARS, HE'S READ THOSE WORDS
THOUSANDS OF TIMES.
YOUR BOOK HAS SUSTAINED HIM.
IN HIS MIND, NOBODY KNOWS HIM
BETTER THAN YOU DO.
NOBODY CARES FOR HIM LIKE YOU.
YOU REMEMBER WHAT IT WAS LIKE
HERE 10 YEARS AGO ON THE STREET?
THE FEAR?
AND THAT'S WHEN PEOPLE
TRUSTED THE POLICE.
NOT THIS TIME.
NOT IF YOU TELL THEM
ABOUT SHAUNESSY.
BUT IT'S A HELL OF A STORY.
RUN WITH IT.
DO YOU HAVE
ANY IDEA WHAT YOU'RE
ASKING ME TO DO?
I'M NOT ASKING YOU
TO DO ANYTHING.
THIS IS THE BIGGEST
STORY OF MY LIFE,
AND I-IT'S MINE.
IT'S AN EXCLUSIVE.
I CAN OFFER YOU
FULL AND EXCLUSIVE ACCESS
TO THE F.B.I.'s
BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS UNIT
AFTER WE CATCH HIM.
RIGHT. IF I HOLD
THE STORY.
I DIDN'T SAY THAT.
FULL ACCESS
TO THE ENTIRE UNIT?
NOBODY'S EVER HAD THAT.
I KNOW.
BUT...
BUT, I MEAN, WHAT IF
YOU CAN'T CATCH HIM?
WELL, THAT'S A RISK
YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO TAKE.
[TELEPHONE RINGS]
[RING]
HOTCHNER.
[DEEP BREATH]
WHO IS THIS?
IF YOU STOP HUNTING ME,
I'LL STOP HUNTING THEM.
YOU THINK I'D TAKE THAT?
IT'S A GOOD DEAL.
I'VE MISJUDGED YOU.
I THOUGHT YOU WERE
SMARTER THAN THIS.
YOU SHOULD TAKE IT.
AND YOU'VE MISJUDGED ME.
THIS IS
YOUR LAST CHANCE.
I DON'T MAKE DEALS.
I'M THE GUY WHO HUNTS
GUYS LIKE YOU.
THERE ARE
NO GUYS LIKE ME.
YOU ALL THINK THAT.
YOU'LL REGRET THIS.
I'LL SEE YOU SOON.
ALMOST MISSED YOU.
[BEHIND MASK]
DRIVE.
[WOMAN GASPS]
[GASPS]
MAKE A RIGHT
AT THE NEXT LIGHT.
I WANT YOUR JEWELRY
AND YOUR WALLETS.
PULL OVER RIGHT HERE.
JUST TAKE THE MONEY.
NOBODY NEEDS TO GET HURT.
ACTUALLY, THEY DO.
[PASSENGERS SCREAMING]
6 BODIES, NOT INCLUDING
THE DRIVER.
HE PUT 'EM DOWN
WITH THE GUN--
OR MORE LIKELY GUNS--
AND FINISHED THEM OFF
WITH HIS KNIFE.
ARTHUR LANESSA'S
WEDDING RING.
WHAT'D HE TAKE?
DOES IT MATTER?
HEY. WHAT'S GOIN' ON
WITH YOU?
HE CALLED ME TONIGHT
AT MY HOTEL AND
OFFERED ME THE DEAL.
WHAT DID YOU SAY?
I HUNG UP ON HIM,
AND THEN HE DOES THIS.
SO YOU THINK
THIS IS YOUR FAULT?
IT IS.
WELL, HERE, USE MINE.
YOU CONVINCED ME.
NO, NO,
YOU HUNG UP ON HIM.
YOU PRACTICALLY
KILLED THEM YOURSELF.
GO AHEAD,
GET IT OVER WITH.
DON'T WORRY ABOUT US.
WE'LL GET THIS GUY
WITHOUT YOU.
DAVE, I HAD 10 YEARS
TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
SHAUNESSY MADE THE DEAL.
THE KILLING STOPPED.
HE CLOSED THE CASE AND
SENT THE B.A.U. AWAY.
FOR 10 YEARS,
YOU WORKED ON OTHER
CASES, ACTIVE CASES.
BUT I KEPT COMING BACK
TO THIS ONE.
I KEPT COMING BACK
TO THIS PROFILE.
HEY. I WAS RETIRED.
SHOULD I BLAME MYSELF
FOR EVERY VICTIM
WHO GOT KILLED WHILE
I WAS ON MY BOOK TOUR?
LOOK, IF YOU WANT TO
END UP LIKE SHAUNESSY,
LIKE GIDEON,
BLAMING YOURSELF
FOR EVERYTHING,
YOU GO AHEAD.
BUT THAT VOICE
IN YOUR HEAD,
IT'S NOT
YOUR CONSCIENCE.
IT'S YOUR EGO.
THIS ISN'T
ABOUT US, AARON.
IT'S ABOUT THE BAD GUYS.
THAT'S WHY
WE PROFILE THEM.
IT'S THEIR FAULT.
WE'RE JUST GUYS
DOING A JOB.
AND WHEN WE
STOP DOING IT,
SOMEONE ELSE WILL.
TRUST ME.
I KNOW.
YOU CAN PUT THAT AWAY.
YOU SURE?
IT'S A LITTLE DRAMATIC,
DON'T YOU THINK?
MY WIFE ALWAYS
SAID I HAD A FLAIR
FOR THE DRAMATIC.
WHICH ONE?
ALL OF 'EM.
THANKS.
ANYTIME.
GO AHEAD
AND RUN YOUR STORY.
IT WON'T MATTER
AFTER THIS.
I AM, BUT I'M GONNA LEAVE
THE SHAUNESSY DEAL OUT.
I DON'T THINK THE FAMILIES
NEED TO KNOW,
NOT AT LEAST
UNTIL YOU CATCH HIM.
I APPRECIATE THAT.
FOYET CALLED.
HE, UH, WANTS TO SEE ME.
IS HE MAD THAT YOU
GAVE HIM TO US?
I JUST THINK HE DOESN'T
HAVE ANYONE TO TALK TO,
AND THE REAPER'S KILLING
HIM, TOO, ONLY SLOWER.
HE WOULDN'T BE
THE FIRST.
HE NEVER USED CODE BEFORE.
WHY NOW?
THEY'RE NOT PART OF
A PATTERN OR EQUATION.
I MEAN, MATHEMATICALLY,
THEY'RE INSIGNIFICANT.
MAYBE SO, BUT
I KNOW I'VE SEEN
THEM BEFORE.
FOYET SAID HE LIKES TO ATTACK
PEOPLE IN THEIR CARS.
TONIGHT HE HIT A BUS.
WHICH IS WHY FOYET
ONLY TAKES A BUS.
IT WAS THE NUMBER 7.
AND IT STOPS RIGHT IN FRONT
OF FOYET'S APARTMENT.
HE KNOWS
WHERE FOYET LIVES.
AND HE WANTS US TO KNOW IT.
1439. THE APARTMENT YOU
INTERVIEWED HIM IN TODAY
WAS 1439 YARBROUGH.
THE OTHER ADDRESSES
HE GAVE US.
201 SOUTH BROOKLINE.
1488 EDENHURST.
THE NUMBERS ON THE BUS
ARE FOYET'S ADDRESSES.
WE'LL SPLIT UP
AND COVER EACH ADDRESS.
[SIREN]
I'LL TAKE THE BACK.
THERE'S NO ONE HERE.
WE GOT NOTHING.
SAME THING HERE.
HAVE YOU HEARD FROM MORGAN?
WAKE UP, DEREK.
IT'S TIME TO DIE.
IF IT'S ANY CONSOLATION,
I DON'T THINK
HE KNEW WHAT HIT HIM.
I'LL CALL J.J.
THE BUREAU'S GONNA
HAVE TO MAKE A STATEMENT.
YOU ALL RIGHT?
HE TOOK MY CREDENTIALS.
THE IMPORTANT THING
IS YOU'RE OK.
HE LEFT ME THIS.
POWER AND MANIPULATION.
DON'T LET HIM GET TO YOU.
YEAH, RIGHT.
OW, COME ON, MAN.
SORRY.
PRENTISS, HE'S TELLING ME,
"I HAD YOU."
MORGAN, YOU'RE ALIVE.
YOU KNOW WHY?
IT DOESN'T REALLY MATTER.
I'M SITTING HERE BECAUSE
I WAS KNOCKED OUT COLD.
HE COULDN'T TORTURE ME.
HE LIKES TO INTERACT
WITH HIS VICTIMS,
TO TELL THEM HE'S GONNA
KILL THEM BEFORE HE DOES.
OR BY LETTING THEM KNOW
HE COULD HAVE.
HOTCH IS RIGHT.
HE'S JUST TRYING
TO GET INTO YOUR HEAD.
RIGHT OR WRONG,
HE HAD ME.
O'MARA WAS CLEARLY
KILLED OUTSIDE.
THIS WAS SOMEONE ELSE.
THERE'S SIGNS OF A STRUGGLE
AND A LOT OF BLOOD.
BUT NO BODY.
JUST THE DRAG MARKS.
THE HUMAN BODY
HOLDS 5 QUARTS OF BLOOD.
I'D SAY THERE'S A LITTLE MORE
THAN HALF THAT HERE.
WHOEVER THE BLEEDER WAS,
THEY LOST TOO MUCH TO SURVIVE.
FOYET?
IT WAS HIS WORST FEAR,
THAT THE REAPER
WOULD COME BACK
AND FINISH THE JOB.
WE OFFERED HIM PROTECTION.
HE REFUSED.
IT WAS HIS CHOICE.
WHY IS HE SO FOCUSED ON FOYET?
WHAT'S SO SPECIAL ABOUT HIM?
HE WAS HIS ONLY
SURVIVING VICTIM,
THE ONLY ONE
HE COULDN'T DEFEAT.
BUT HE'S NOT A THREAT.
DEFEATING HIM WOULD BE
NO GREAT ACCOMPLISHMENT.
THERE'S SOMETHING THERE
THAT WE'RE MISSING.
WHAT ABOUT THE GIRLFRIEND,
AMANDA BERTRAND?
WH-WHAT DO
WE KNOW ABOUT HER?
19. A FRESHMAN.
SHE CAME HERE FROM MICHIGAN
TO GO TO SCHOOL.
FOYET WAS A TEACHER'S
ASSISTANT IN ONE
OF AMANDA'S COURSES.
MICHIGAN.
WHERE THE REAPER
HAD SHAUNESSY
POST
THE PERSONAL AD.
THAT CAN'T BE A COINCIDENCE.
HE TOLD US SHE WAS
THE LOVE OF HIS LIFE,
THAT HE WAS GONNA PROPOSE.
BUT SHE JUST GOT HERE
FROM MICHIGAN.
THEY ONLY MET
WHEN THE CLASS STARTED.
HOW LONG HAD SHE
BEEN IN THE CLASS?
4 WEEKS.
SO IT WAS EITHER LOVE
AT FIRST SIGHT, OR WHAT?
FOYET WAS LYING?
HE'S A 28-YEAR-OLD
TEACHER'S ASSISTANT
IN FRESHMAN CLASSES.
THAT GIVES HIM PLENTY
OF ACCESS TO YOUNG GIRLS.
GARCIA.
I'M HERE.
UH, WHAT ARE
FOYET'S ALIASES?
I WANT YOU TO LOOK UP
IN BOSTON CITY RECORDS
KEVIN BASKIN, MILES HOLDEN,
AND WILLIAM PARKER.
TRY THE DEPARTMENT
OF EDUCATION.
WELL PLAYED, SIR.
THEY ALL WORK FOR
THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION,
THEY'RE ALL SUBSTITUTE TEACHERS,
AND THEY ALL TEACH
COMPUTER SCIENCE.
HIGH SCHOOL?
YEAH.
OOPS.
SCRATCH THAT.
THEY'RE NOT ALL WORKING
FOR THE DEPARTMENT
OF EDUCATION.
THEY'RE NOT?
NO. WILLIAM PARKER
WAS FIRED FOR ALLEGED
INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR
WITH HIS FEMALE STUDENTS.
DO YOU KNOW
HOW LONG IT TAKES
TO STAB SOMEBODY
67 TIMES?
Garcia: HOTCH?
WHY CAN'T YOU CATCH HIM?
COLSON WENT TO SEE FOYET.
GARCIA, I NEED YOU TO LOCATE
ROY COLSON'S CELL PHONE.
GEORGE FOYET IS THE REAPER.
OH, GOD. UH--
OK, TRIANGULATING NOW.
I GOT IT.
2633 SOUTH BUDLONG.
Morgan: THAT MUST BE AN ADDRESS
THAT FOYET DIDN'T GIVE US.
[KNOCKS]
HEY, GEORGE.
HEY.
NICE TO SEE YOU.
COME ON IN.
IT'S BEEN A WHILE.
YOU BROUGHT YOUR LAPTOP.
GOOD.
YEAH.
JUST SET IT UP OVER THERE
ON THE TABLE.
OK.
HE STABBED
AMANDA BERTRAND
TO DEATH,
HE DROVE A MILE,
HE CALLED 911,
HE WENT BACK,
AND HE INFLICTED
THOSE WOUNDS ON HIMSELF.
HE KNEW E.M.S. WOULD GET THERE
IN TIME TO SAVE HIM.
BETWEEN THE PHONE CALL
AND THE SEVERITY
OF HIS WOUNDS,
WE NEVER CONSIDERED HIM
AS A SUSPECT.
WHY WOULD HE DO IT?
IT PUT HIM AT THE CORE
OF THE INVESTIGATION.
EVERYTHING WE HAD
CAME FROM HIM.
HE LEFT HIS OWN GLASSES
AT THE CRIME SCENE,
HE POINTED US RIGHT BACK
IN HIS DIRECTION,
AND STILL WE DIDN'T SEE IT.
SO HOW ARE YOU?
HOW YOU--YOU KNOW,
HOW YOU HOLDING UP?
ACTUALLY, UH...
I'M KIND OF ANGRY WITH YOU.
OH, YEAH. 'CAUSE I GAVE
YOUR NAME TO THE F.B.I.?
IS THAT--IS THAT
WHAT THIS IS ABOUT?
NO. NO, IT'S NOT ABOUT
WHAT YOU GAVE THEM.
IT'S WHAT I GAVE YOU.
WHY DIDN'T YOU BREAK
THE STORY I GAVE YOU
ABOUT THE DEAL I MADE
WITH SHAUNESSY?
WHAT?
IT WAS A GIFT.
I GAVE IT TO YOU.
WAIT A MINUTE.
WAIT--STOP.
ALL YOU HAD TO DO
WAS PRINT THE STORY.
NO, THIS CAN'T--THIS--
I COULD HAVE JUST
DISAPPEARED AGAIN.
THIS IS NOT YOU, GEORGE.
THERE'S NO WAY THIS IS--
PLEASE STOP!
STOP, GEORGE!
GEORGE, PLEASE!
THIS CAN'T BE YOU.
THIS CAN'T BE YOU.
IT JUST--
WHAT DO--WHAT DO
YOU WANT ME TO DO?
I WANT YOU TO SIT DOWN
AND GET IT RIGHT.
OK.
YOU WROTE THAT I WAS
EITHER DEAD OR ARRESTED.
WELL, NOW YOU KNOW
THAT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED.
I WON.
I BEAT THEM,
AND I WANT EVERYBODY
TO KNOW THAT.
IT'S OVER.
STOP.
I'LL KILL HIM.
YOU NEED HIM
TO WRITE YOUR STORY.
I'M TAKING HIM WITH ME.
I'LL LET HIM GO
AS SOON AS I'M SAFE.
NO, YOU'RE NOT.
I SAID I'LL KILL HIM.
YOU KILL HIM,
I KILL YOU.
YOU THINK I'M AFRAID TO DIE?
YOU'RE NOT AFRAID.
YOU'RE GREEDY
AND NARCISSISTIC.
YOU WANT
THE RECOGNITION
THAT'S GONNA COME
FROM THE BOOK THAT
HE'S GONNA WRITE.
YOU WANT THE FAME
THAT'S GONNA COME
FROM THE MEDIA.
IT'S GONNA BE
LIKE BUNDY.
I'M GONNA BE BIGGER
THAN BUNDY.
WELL, YOU CAN'T
ENJOY IT IF
YOU'RE DEAD.
IF YOU KNOW ME SO WELL,
HOW COME SOME MANY HAD TO DIE
TO BRING YOU HERE?
THAT'S YOUR CHOICE,
NOT MINE.
YOU'RE
THE SERIAL KILLER.
THAT'S RIGHT.
HELLO, DEREK.
WHERE'S MY BADGE?
WHERE IS IT,
YOU SON OF A BITCH?
I'M GONNA BE MORE FAMOUS
THAN YOU EVEN REALIZE.
KEEP DREAMIN'.
YOU OK, ROY?
[BREATHING HARD]
I'M OK.
YEAH, I'M OK.
YOU?
Hotch: "MEN HEAP TOGETHER
THE MISTAKES OF THEIR LIVES
AND CREATE A MONSTER
THEY CALL DESTINY."
JOHN HOBBES.
THEY DIDN'T FIND
YOUR CREDENTIALS
AT ANY OF THE RESIDENCES.
THE BLOOD AT THE HOUSE
WAS FOYET'S.
REID GUESSED LOW.
THE CORONER SAID
IT WAS 4 QUARTS.
HOTCH, HOW IS
THAT POSSIBLE?
HE'D BE DEAD.
HE'S BEEN PLANNING HIS DEATH
FOR A LONG TIME.
SO, WHAT, HE TOOK
A LITTLE BLOOD AT A TIME
UNTIL HE HAD ENOUGH
TO CONVINCE US
HE WAS DEAD WITHOUT
FINDING HIS BODY?
MORGAN, YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO
FIND A WAY TO LET IT GO.
COULD YOU?
I'D HAVE TO.
[NO AUDIBLE DIALOGUE]
FOYET ESCAPED.
GUARDS FOUND HIM
IN HIS CELL VOMITING
BLOOD AND CONVULSING.
THEY RUSHED HIM
TO THE PRISON HOSPITAL.
GET ME THE U.S. MARSHALS OFFICE.
I ALREADY CALLED DON REILLY.
I OFFERED OUR ASSISTANCE.
HE SAID THEY'D CALL US
IF THEY NEEDED IT.
THE BOSTON FIELD OFFICE
JUST IDENTIFIED DOCUMENTS
FROM FOYET'S HOUSE.
THEY'RE SCHEMATICS
FOR THE ELECTRICAL,
HEATING, AND WATER DUCTS
OF THE EAST WOBURN
CORRECTIONAL FACILITY.
HE HAD THE SCHEMATICS.
AND NOT JUST FOR WOBURN.
FOR EVERY JAIL, PRISON,
AND COURTHOUSE
IN MASSACHUSETTS.
AND 10 YEARS TO PLAN.
THEY'RE GONNA
FIND HIM, RIGHT?
NO, THEY'RE NOT.
HE SAID HE'D
BE MORE FAMOUS
THAN WE KNEW,
AND HE WAS RIGHT.
YES.
PLEASE, HE'S BEEN WAITING.
THANK YOU.
YOU'RE THE ONLY PERSON
HE'S ASKED FOR.
YOU MUST BE GOOD FRIENDS.
ACTUALLY, WE WORKED
TOGETHER ONCE,
ABOUT 10 YEARS AGO.
UH, HE'LL BE LUCKY IF
HE MAKES IT THROUGH THE NIGHT.
ANYTHING YOU DO TO EASE HIS PAIN
WOULD BE A BLESSING.
[DOOR OPENS]
HI, TOM.
YOU CAME.
THANK YOU.
OF COURSE, TOM,
BUT I DON'T KNOW WHY
YOU ASKED FOR ME.
THE REAPER.
I SHUT DOWN THE INVESTIGATION
WITHOUT AN ARREST.
THE KILLINGS STOPPED,
AND I SENT YOU AWAY.
YOU DESERVE TO KNOW WHY.
OK. TELL ME.
A DEAL WITH THE DEVIL.
"IF YOU STOP HUNTING ME,
I'LL STOP HUNTING THEM.
"FOR AS LONG AS
WE BOTH SHALL LIVE,
"TIL DEATH DO US PART.
"IF YOU AGREE
TO MY TERMS,
TAKE OUT A PERSONAL AD
IN THE MICHIGAN POST."
THIS IS A CONTRACT.
WHICH WE BOTH HONORED.
YOU KNOW WE WEREN'T CLOSE
TO CATCHING HIM.
IF IT DIDN'T WORK,
I COULD HAVE RESTARTED
THE INVESTIGATION,
BUT IT DID.
THE KILLING STOPPED.
I WAITED 6 WEEKS--
6 WEEKS--
BEFORE I SENT YOU AWAY.
BUT, TOM, HOW DO YOU
KNOW HE STOPPED?
HE COULD HAVE JUST
GONE SOMEPLACE ELSE.
NO. I'VE KEPT WATCH.
I KNOW HE STOPPED.
SOONER OR LATER,
WE WOULD HAVE
CAUGHT A BREAK.
HOW MANY PEOPLE
WOULD HE HAVE KILLED
BEFORE WE CAUGHT
THAT BREAK, HUH?
WOULD ALL THOSE LIVES
BE WORTH IT?
WE DON'T GET TO MAKE
THOSE DECISIONS.
WE DON'T LET THEM
GET AWAY WITH IT.
THEN YOU'LL HAVE TO PAY
FOR MY SIN.
HOW DO YOU MEAN?
THE CONTRACT'S
ABOUT TO EXPIRE.
I'VE FELT HIM WATCHING ME.
HE KNOWS.
HE'S BEEN WAITING FOR THIS.
YOU THINK HE'S GONNA
START KILLING AGAIN.
I DID IT TO SAVE LIVES.
PLEASE TELL
THE VICTIMS' FAMILIES
THAT I'M SORRY. PLEASE.
TELL THEM--
TELL THEM I--
I HAD NO CHOICE.
I'LL TELL THEM
YOU'RE SORRY.
YES, THAT'S RIGHT.
AARON HOTCHNER.
SERGEANT O'MARA
HAS THE NUMBER.
THANK YOU.
COME IN.
I THINK I FOUND IT.
MICHIGAN POST,
MARCH 7, 1998.
IS THAT RIGHT?
HUH.
YES.
'CAUSE I FOUND IT,
DO I GET TO KNOW
WHAT IT'S ABOUT?
THE REAPER.
LIKE THE BOSTON REAPER?
I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW
THE B.A.U. WORKED
ON THAT CASE.
1998. IT WAS MY FIRST CASE
FOR THE B.A.U. AS LEAD PROFILER.
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG,
BUT WE DON'T
HAVE A PROFILE
FOR THE REAPER
IN OUR SYSTEM, DO WE?
THAT'LL BE ALL, PENELOPE.
YOU CAN GO HOME NOW.
OK.
GOOD NIGHT, SIR.
GOOD NIGHT.
THIS MORNING.
YES, IT IS A GOOD THING
THAT HE WENT QUICKLY
IN THE END.
WELL, I APPRECIATE
YOU CALLING ME.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
[FLAT TIRE THUMPING]
HOW BAD IS IT?
WE HAVE 2 FLATS.
HOW DID WE GET 2 FLATS?
I DON'T KNOW.
ALL RIGHT,
I'LL CALL TRIPLE-A.
[DIALING CELL PHONE]
[TRUNK CLOSES]
[GRUNTS]
WHAT IF IT WAS US?
YOU'D WANT SOMEBODY
TO STOP, WOULDN'T YOU?
HEY, ARE YOU ALL RIGHT?
UH, NO, I GOT 2 FLATS.
I ONLY GOT ONE SPARE.
NINA HALE.
ROUTE 128.
YOU WANT TO TRY
ONE OF MINE,
SEE IF IT FITS?
OH, THANKS.
MY GIRLFRIEND'S ON
WITH TRIPLE-A.
WELL, I'LL GIVE YOU
MY ADDRESS.
IF IT WORKS,
YOU CAN SEND ME A CHECK.
I MEAN,
IF YOU WANT TO STAY
OUT HERE ALL NIGHT,
THAT'S UP TO YOU.
I JUST WANTED TO
MAKE SURE YOU'RE OK.
HEY, YOU KNOW WHAT? SURE.
LET'S GIVE IT A SHOT, RIGHT?
YOU GOT IT.
OUR CAR HAS 2 FLAT TIRES,
AND WE DON'T HAVE
A SECOND SPARE.
YEAH.
JUST PAST NEEDHAM.
[GROANS]
I REALLY APPRECIATE THIS.
[BEHIND MASK]
MY PLEASURE.
EVAN?
EVAN!
AAH!
GIVE ME YOUR WATCH.
PLEASE.
PLEASE DON'T HURT US.
THIS WON'T HURT.
PLEASE, NO.
SHH.
I'M NOT GONNA SHOOT YOU.
SHH.
THANK YOU.
YOU'RE WELCOME.
AAH!
[GROANING]
OH, NINA...
I HIT MY HEAD.
[GROANS]
NINA'S DEAD.
ARE YOU SCARED?
[WHIMPERING]
YOU SHOULD BE.
[GUNSHOT]
Hotch: "FATE IS NOT SATISFIED
WITH INFLICTING ONE CALAMITY."
ROMAN AUTHOR PUBLILIUS SYRUS.
BYE.
HI. YOU WANTED TO KNOW
IMMEDIATELY
ABOUT ANY UNUSUAL
BOSTON HOMICIDES?
WE'RE GOING TO BOSTON.
WHAT? WAI--SHOULDN'T WE WAIT
FOR THE OFFICIAL REQUEST?
WE HAVEN'T BEEN INVITED--
WE WILL BE.
WELL, IT LOOKS LIKE
WE'RE GOING TO BOSTON.
"THE REAPER IS DRIVEN
BY A NEED TO DOMINATE,
CONTROL, AND MANIPULATE."
SO THEN WHY
WOULD HE OFFER A DEAL
THAT WOULD STOP HIM
FROM DOING THAT?
WELL, KILLING
GAVE HIM POWER,
BUT AFTER SO MANY,
THE PAYOFF BEGAN
TO DIMINISH.
SO HE DECIDED
TO SWITCH TACTICS.
OFFERING THE DEAL GAVE
HIM THE ULTIMATE POWER,
BETTER EVEN
THAN KILLING.
HE MANIPULATED THE POLICE
INTO VOLUNTARILY SURRENDERING.
HE EVEN GOT IT
IN WRITING.
HE WON.
WHY START KILLING AGAIN?
WELL, BECAUSE THE ONLY PERSON
WHO KNEW HE'D WON,
THE PERSON HE MADE
THE DEAL WITH, JUST DIED.
NARCISSISTIC KILLERS
NEED OTHER PEOPLE
TO RECOGNIZE THEIR POWER.
THAT'S WHY
THEY CONTACT THE MEDIA.
SO HOW DID HE STOP
FOR 10 YEARS?
IN NIGHT OF THE REAPER,
THE AUTHOR SUGGESTS
HE HAD BEEN ARRESTED
FOR AN UNRELATED CRIME
OR DIED.
PERHAPS HE'S TRYING TO CORRECT
THAT MISCONCEPTION.
WHAT HAS HE BEEN DOING
ALL THIS TIME?
PLANNING WHAT HE WOULD DO
IF HE STARTED KILLING AGAIN.
SO FROM '95 TO '98,
HE SHOOTS, STABS,
AND BLUDGEONS 21 VICTIMS--
MEN, WOMEN,
ALL AGES, ALL TYPES,
NO SPECIFIC VICTIMOLOGY
OR M.O. HOW DID YOU BUILD
A PROFILE FROM THAT?
WE DIDN'T.
SHAUNESSY SENT US HOME
BEFORE WE HAD A CHANCE.
BTK, THE ZODIAC,
AND THE REAPER ALL
HAVE SIMILARITIES.
THEY'RE ALL
HIGHLY INTELLIGENT,
DISCIPLINED,
SADISTIC KILLERS
WHO NAME THEMSELVES
IN THE PRESS.
HIGHLY INTELLIGENT MAY BE
A BIT OF AN UNDERSTATEMENT.
THE REAPER AND THE ZODIAC
KILLER HAVE NEVER BEEN ARRESTED.
AND THE BTK KILLER WAS ONLY
CAUGHT AFTER 25 YEARS
BECAUSE HE WENT TO THE PRESS
TO COUNTER A BOOK
THAT SAID HE'D DIED, MOVED AWAY,
OR BEEN LOCKED UP,
JUST LIKE THIS ONE.
SPEAKING OF THE MEDIA,
WHEN THIS GETS OUT,
IT'S GOING TO BE A FRENZY.
IF THEY GET WIND OF THIS,
THEY'RE GOING TO BE
ALL OVER THE BOSTON POLICE.
THE LONGER WE CAN FLOAT
THE COPYCAT STORY,
THE BETTER CHANCE WE'LL
HAVE OF CATCHING HIM.
ROSSI, PRENTISS,
AND MORGAN, GO TO
THE FIELD OFFICE,
SET UP SHOP, GO THROUGH
EVERYTHING THERE.
J.J. AND REID, WE'LL GO
TO THE CRIME SCENE.
I WORKED THE REAPER CASE
FOR 18 MONTHS.
IF THERE'S ANY PROOF
THAT THIS HORRIBLE CRIME
IS ANYTHING MORE
THAN A COPYCAT,
I'LL BE THE FIRST ONE
TO LET YOU KNOW.
SORRY I HAVEN'T
CALLED YOU BACK.
AS YOU CAN SEE,
I'M BUSY.
IT'S NOT A COPYCAT, MIKE.
I WISH IT WERE,
BUT IT ISN'T.
YEAH, NO OFFENSE,
YOU DON'T KNOW THAT,
AND I DIDN'T
INVITE YOU IN.
SHAUNESSY DID.
WANT TO INVITE US IN?
WHAT WAS HE THINKING?
THIS COULD DESTROY
THE DEPARTMENT.
I KNOW.
THIS IS S.S.A.
JENNIFER JAREAU,
DR. SPENCER REID.
SERGEANT MIKE O'MARA.
UH, WE'RE SETTING UP
AT THE FIELD OFFICE.
OK. I'M DONE HERE.
GIVE THEM ANYTHING
THEY WANT.
THANK YOU.
NINA HALE, 19,
AND EVAN HARVEY, 23.
NINA'S THROAT
WAS SLASHED,
SHE WAS STABBED
46 TIMES.
EVAN WAS BLUDGEONED
AND THEN SHOT.
NO SHELL CASINGS
WERE FOUND.
HE PREFERRED REVOLVERS,
.44 MAGNUM.
THE YOUNGER THE FEMALE VICTIM,
THE MORE TIME
HE SPENDS WITH THEM,
USUALLY WITH A KNIFE.
TAN LINE ON HER WRIST.
PROBABLY WEARING
A WATCH OF SOME SORT.
DO WE HAVE HIS WALLET?
THE REAPER TOOK ITEMS
FROM EACH VICTIM
AND PLACED THEM ON THE NEXT,
SO AS TO MAKE SURE
WE KNEW IT WAS HIM.
NO CORRECTIVE LENS
REQUIREMENT.
THE GLASSES AREN'T HIS?
HE ONLY TOOK GLASSES
FROM ONE VICTIM--THE NINTH.
WE SHOULD HAVE FOUND THEM
ON THE TENTH, AND WE DIDN'T.
THEY WERE NEVER FOUND.
WHAT WAS SO SPECIAL
ABOUT THE NINTH VICTIM?
HE SURVIVED.
GEORGE FOYET, 28,
WAS THE NINTH VICTIM
AND THE ONLY ONE
TO SURVIVE THE REAPER.
Rossi:
NOT FOR LACK OF TRYING.
AMANDA BERTRAND, 19,
HIS DATE FOR THE EVENING,
WAS NOT AS LUCKY.
HE LIKES TO ATTACK THEM
INSIDE OR NEAR THEIR CARS,
AT NIGHT, ON POORLY LIT,
LESS POPULATED ROADS.
FOYET SAID HE APPROACHED THEM
PRETENDING TO BE A LOST TOURIST.
IN THE HOSPITAL, WE PUT
FOYET WITH A SKETCH ARTIST.
THE REAPER ALWAYS USES
SOME SORT OF RUSE
TO GET CLOSE TO AND SPEND
TIME WITH HIS VICTIMS.
THE EYE, AS HE DEPICTS IT,
APPEARS TO BE
THE EYE OF PROVIDENCE,
A SYMBOL ADOPTED
BY THE U.S. GOVERNMENT
AND INCORPORATED INTO
THE GREAT SEAL IN 1782
WITH THE WORDS,
"ANNUIT COEPTIS"
INSCRIBED BENEATH.
THAT'S LATIN FOR
"PROVIDENCE"--OR FATE--
"HAS FAVORED
OUR UNDERTAKINGS."
UH, THE REAPER SEEMS
TO SEE HIMSELF
AS THE PERSONIFICATION
OF FATE.
SO, HOW DID FOYET SURVIVE?
Woman:
911. WHAT'S YOUR EMERGENCY?
Man, altered:
I JUST MURDERED 2 MORE.
EXCUSE ME, SIR, DID YOU SAY
YOU MURDERED SOMEONE?
VICTIMS 8 AND 9.
BY A SILVER TOYOTA
ON RIVERTON
PAST THE TYSON QUARRY.
THAT CALL WAS MADE
FROM A PAY PHONE
ABOUT A MILE FROM
THE CRIME SCENE.
E.M.T.s ARRIVED
15 MINUTES LATER.
BERTRAND WAS D.O.A.,
FOYET BARELY BREATHING.
SO THE REAPER
MADE ONE OF THESE CALLS
AFTER EACH OF HIS KILLINGS
TELLING THE POLICE
WHERE TO FIND THE BODIES.
UNTIL THIS ONE,
THE NINTH.
IF HE HADN'T MADE
THIS CALL,
FOYET WOULDN'T
HAVE BEEN FOUND IN TIME.
THE CALL SAVED HIM.
SO THE REAPER DIDN'T
MAKE ANY 911 CALLS
[CELL PHONE RINGS]
AFTER THIS ONE.
YEAH?
LOOKS LIKE HE
LEARNED HIS LESSON.
THERE'S A REASON
HE LEFT FOYET'S GLASSES
AT THE LAST CRIME SCENE.
FOYET COULD BE
IN DANGER.
WE'LL FIND HIM.
UH, HOTCH,
THERE'S A REPORTER OUTSIDE
INSISTING ON
SPEAKING WITH YOU.
ROY COLSON.
HE SAYS HE KNOWS YOU.
ROY.
AGENT HOTCHNER.
SO IF IT'S, UH,
JUST A COPYCAT,
WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?
HELPING THE POLICE
CATCH HIM.
IS THAT YOUR STORY?
COME ON. I WROTE
THE BOOK ON THIS GUY.
I EVEN, UH--EVEN
SENT YOU A SIGNED COPY.
I--I ASSUME YOU GOT IT.
OFFICIALLY, WE HAVE NO REASON
TO THINK THAT HE'S ANYTHING
BUT A COPYCAT.
WELL, HOW ABOUT
UNOFFICIALLY?
WHAT'S MORE IMPORTANT
TO YOU, ROY,
GETTING THE STORY
OR GETTING THE KILLER?
I--I, UH...
I SPENT TIME
WITH THE FAMILIES.
I, UH--I TOLD
THE VICTIMS' STORIES.
NOW, YOU WOULD KNOW THAT
IF YOU READ MY BOOK.
IT'S A GOOD BOOK, ROY.
YOU TREATED THE VICTIMS
WITH RESPECT,
AND YOU TREATED US FAIRLY.
EVERY DIME I MADE
WENT TO THE FAMILIES.
I KNOW. THAT'S WHY
I CAME DOWN.
THE MINUTE I HAVE
SOMETHING I CAN SAY,
I'LL CALL YOU.
THANKS.
IF IT'S HIM,
IT WON'T BE LONG.
[SIREN]
I DON'T BELIEVE IT.
UNBELIEVABLE.
HONEY, PLEASE DON'T.
I'M NOT SPEEDING.
I'M NOT DRUNK.
GOOD EVENING, OFFICER.
LICENSE, REGISTRATION,
AND PROOF OF INSURANCE.
I'LL BE RIGHT BACK.
HE HASN'T EVEN TOLD ME
WHY HE STOPPED US.
LET'S JUST
GET THIS OVER WITH.
[BEHIND MASK]
I'M GONNA LET YOU OFF
WITH A WARNING.
A WARNING? FOR WHAT?
YOU WERE
AT THE WRONG PLACE
AT THE WRONG TIME.
EXCUSE ME?
AAH! AAH!
AND NOW I'M GONNA
KILL YOUR WIFE, ARTHUR.
[SCREAMING]
PLEASE! NO!
[SCREAMING]
[GUNSHOT]
[SIREN]
Rossi: ANOTHER COUPLE.
MUCH OLDER THIS TIME.
ONE SHOT
AND ONE STABBED.
NO REASON
TO STOP OUT HERE.
HIS LICENSE AND REGISTRATION
ARE OUT OF HIS WALLET.
LOOKS LIKE HE USED
A COP RUSE.
GOOD SPOT.
ISOLATED,
FEW DRIVERS.
HE LEFT NINA HALE'S WATCH.
OK. SO WHAT'D HE TAKE?
HIS WEDDING RING.
ARTHUR AND DIANE LANESSA.
WEYMOUTH.
MARRIED 32 YEARS.
THEY WERE COMING HOME
FROM THE ELKS,
WHERE THEY PLAYED BINGO
TWICE A WEEK.
I GOTTA
GO MAKE NOTIFICATION.
YOU WANT COMPANY?
I GOT IT.
LOOKS LIKE
HE WENT THROUGH HER PURSE.
ANY IDEA WHAT
HE WAS LOOKING FOR?
THE QUESTION MARK
IS NEW.
IT'S FOR US.
HE'S SAYING IT'S NOT FATE.
HE'S SAYING WE HAD 10 YEARS
TO SAVE THEM
AND THAT THESE LATEST ONES
ARE ON US.
YOU GOT ALL THAT
FROM ONE QUESTION MARK.
THAT'S IMPRESSIVE.
I MAY KNOW HIM BETTER
THAN I'VE LET ON.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
IT MEANS THAT THERE IS
A PROFILE ON THE REAPER.
I THOUGHT
WE WERE CALLED OFF
BEFORE WE HAD ONE.
WE WERE. I HAD JUST STARTED
THE PROFILE,
AND THEN HE STOPPED KILLING,
SO OFFICIALLY WE WERE DONE.
BUT THIS CASE...
IT STUCK WITH YOU.
I KEPT COMING BACK TO IT
OVER THE YEARS,
AND I WORKED ON IT ALONE.
SO YOU NEVER SHARED IT
WITH ANYONE.
I KNOW I'M ALWAYS PREACHING
THAT PROFILING IS
A COLLABORATIVE EFFORT,
BUT THIS ONE WASN'T.
I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE IF--
IF I WAS WRONG,
I WAS GONNA HEAD US
IN THE WRONG DIRECTION.
NOW YOU THINK
YOU'RE RIGHT.
THE MORE I SEE, THE MORE
ACCURATE I THINK IT MAY BE.
OK.
THEN WE NEED
TO HEAR IT.
THE REAPER FITS A PROFILE
WE REFER TO AS AN OMNIVORE.
UNLIKE MOST SERIAL KILLERS,
AN OMNIVORE DOESN'T TARGET
A SPECIFIC VICTIM TYPE.
ALTHOUGH HE TENDS TO FOCUS
ON HIS YOUNGER FEMALE VICTIMS
WITH HIS KNIFE,
HE ESSENTIALLY IS A PREDATOR
WHO WILL KILL ANYONE.
WHY IS HE SO DEMOCRATIC?
BECAUSE HIS KILLS AREN'T
JUST ABOUT HIS VICTIMS.
HE NEEDS RECOGNITION.
HE NEEDS US TO KNOW.
THE SYMBOLS,
THE PLACEMENT
OF PRIOR VICTIMS'
POSSESSIONS ON
SUBSEQUENT VICTIMS--
IT'S ALL FOR US.
WHY?
POWER.
THE SHAUNESSY LETTER IS
THE CLEAREST EXAMPLE OF THIS.
HE MANIPULATED TOM SHAUNESSY
INTO LITERALLY
SURRENDERING TO HIM.
THE BURDEN
WAS TOO MUCH TO BEAR.
IN A VERY REAL SENSE,
TOM SHAUNESSY WAS
THE REAPER'S 22nd VICTIM.
LIKE BTK KILLER
DENNIS RADER,
THE REAPER IS
EXTREMELY DISCIPLINED.
IN HIS EVERYDAY LIFE,
THIS WILL VERY LIKELY
MAKE HIM SO INFLEXIBLE,
HE CAN'T KEEP CLOSE
RELATIONSHIPS
OR WORK CLOSELY
WITH OTHERS.
I BELIEVE OUR KILLER
HAS ANOTHER INTEREST
THAT MAY GIVE US THE BEST
OPPORTUNITY TO CATCH HIM.
THE REAPER'S LAST VICTIM
WAS AN OLDER WOMAN.
HE KILLED HER QUICKLY,
WITH A SINGLE SHOT.
THE PRIOR, YOUNGER VICTIM,
HE SPENT MORE TIME WITH
AND STABBED 46 TIMES.
WHY?
HE PAYS SPECIAL ATTENTION
TO HIS YOUNGER
FEMALE VICTIMS,
AND HIS WEAPON OF CHOICE
WITH THEM IS THE KNIFE,
A SUBSTITUTE INSTRUMENT
FOR BODILY PENETRATION.
AND THE YOUNGER THE VICTIM,
THE MORE TIME AND
EFFORT HE SPENDS.
I THINK OUR GUY
IS A HEBOPHILE.
HEBOPHILE?
SOMEONE WHO'S ATTRACTED
TO ADOLESCENT
POSTPUBESCENT CHILDREN.
TEENAGERS.
LOOK FOR MEN WITH ACCESS
AND AUTHORITY--
HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS,
COUNSELORS, COACHES--
AND ANYONE WHO'S BEEN
CHARGED WITH SEX CRIMES
AGAINST TEENAGE GIRLS
IN THE LAST 10 YEARS.
THAT'S ALL FOR NOW.
THANK YOU.
GARCIA CAN'T FIND
GEORGE FOYET.
I'VE GOT NOTHING, SIR.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
HE'S GONE. I MEAN,
HE'S COMPLETELY OFF THE GRID,
AND HE'S GONE.
HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?
9 MONTHS AFTER HE WAS
RELEASED FROM THE HOSPITAL,
HE, UH, QUIT HIS JOB,
SOLD HIS CAR,
CLOSED HIS BANK ACCOUNTS,
CANCELED HIS CREDIT CARDS,
CELL PHONE, APARTMENT,
EVERYTHING.
HE HAS NO PAPER,
THUS HE HAS NO TRAIL,
AND I CAN'T FIND HIM
'CAUSE HE'S GONE.
YOU THINK
IT'S INTENTIONAL?
IT'S MORE THAN THAT.
I--EVEN DEAD PEOPLE STAY
ON THE GRID FOR DECADES.
TAKE IT FROM ME,
ERASING YOURSELF LIKE THIS,
I-IT'S EXTREMELY DIFFICULT.
IT TAKES COMMITMENT.
YOU'D HAVE TO BE WILLING
TO CUT EVERY TIE
OF EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE
YOU'VE EVER KNOWN
IN YOUR ENTIRE LIFE.
IT'S LIKE--
IT'S LIKE KILLING YOURSELF.
I GOTTA SAY,
THIS IS IMPRESSIVE.
WELL, AFTER WHAT
THE GUY'S BEEN THROUGH,
CAN YOU BLAME HIM?
I MEAN, FOYET'S
THE ONLY LIVING PERSON
WHO KNOWS WHAT
THE REAPER LOOKS LIKE,
AND HE'S STILL OUT THERE.
BUT IT DOESN'T CHANGE
THE FACT THAT WE STILL
NEED TO FIND HIM.
Garcia: I'LL KEEP LOOKING.
GARCIA, WE DON'T
HAVE MUCH TIME.
I KNOW, SIR.
HE WOULD HAVE
TO COMPLETELY
ISOLATE HIMSELF.
HE'S TOTALLY ALONE.
BUT HOW DO YOU CUT ALL TIES?
YOU'D HAVE TO TALK
TO SOMEONE, RIGHT?
[LINE RINGING]
COLSON.
ROY. AARON HOTCHNER.
I NEED A FAVOR.
HOW DID COLSON
FIND THIS GUY?
HE INTERVIEWED FOYET
EXTENSIVELY FOR HIS BOOK.
THEY KEPT IN TOUCH.
THEY'RE FRIENDS?
SORT OF.
BUT FOYET WOULDN'T GIVE HIM
HIS PHONE NUMBER.
HE GAVE HIM ONE OF
HIS ALIASES, THOUGH.
THAT'S HIM.
GEORGE FOYET?
IT'S OK.
WE'RE F.B.I.
THIS IS AGENT ROSSI.
I'M AGENT HOTCHNER.
WE MET ONCE BEFORE.
DO YOU REMEMBER?
YEAH, I REMEMBER.
WOULD YOU MIND IF WE GET
OFF THE STREET, PLEASE?
SURE.
[COUGHS]
[COUGHING]
HOW'D YOU GUYS FIND ME?
ROY COLSON.
OH.
WELL, IS THIS GONNA
TAKE LONG? 'CAUSE I REALLY
CAN'T BE LATE FOR WORK.
WHAT DO YOU DO?
I'M A FREELANCE
COMPUTER SPECIALIST
WITH THE CITY.
WE'RE SORRY TO BOTHER YOU.
WE'LL MAKE IT AS QUICK
AS POSSIBLE.
THIS YOURS?
I KNEW IT WASN'T A COPYCAT.
[COUGHING]
THANK YOU.
I'M SORRY.
I WAS GONNA PROPOSE
TO HER THAT NIGHT...
AT THE RESTAURANT,
BUT I GOT COLD FEET.
THE RING WAS STILL IN MY POCKET
WHEN HE APPROACHED US.
HE SAID HE WAS LOST.
HE HAD ONE OF THOSE
SIGHTSEEING BOOKLETS.
I WAS LOOKING AT IT
WHEN HE STABBED ME.
YEAH...PERFECT TIMI--
MR. FOYET, YOU DON'T NEED
TO GO THROUGH THIS AGAIN.
I COULDN'T MOVE.
I JUST SAT THERE, BLEEDING.
I WATCHED HIM KILL MANDY.
HE STABBED HER 67 TIMES.
DO YOU KNOW HOW LONG
IT TAKES TO STAB
SOMEBODY 67 TIMES?
I NEVER FOUND THE RING.
HE SHOULD HAVE LEFT
YOUR GLASSES
ON HIS NEXT VICTIM,
BUT HE DIDN'T.
HE HELD ON TO THEM
ALL THIS TIME.
WHAT, YOU THINK HE'S GOT
SOME SPECIAL INTEREST IN ME?
I'VE BEEN LIVING
WITH THAT POSSIBILITY
FOR THE PAST 11 YEARS.
HAVE YOU RECEIVED
ANY STRANGE LETTERS
OR CALLS?
HANG-UPS?
I KEEP RESIDENCES
UNDER DIFFERENT NAMES.
I MOVE BETWEEN THEM RANDOMLY.
HE LIKES TO GET YOU IN A CAR,
SO I TAKE THE BUS.
BELIEVE ME, I'VE GONE
THROUGH GREAT LENGTHS
TO MAKE SURE THAT NONE
OF THE THINGS YOU'VE JUST
MENTIONED EVER HAPPENED.
WE'LL NEED YOUR OTHER
NAMES AND RESIDENCES
SO WE CAN REACH YOU.
WE CAN TAKE YOU
SOMEPLACE SAFE
UNTIL THIS IS OVER.
NO. BOSTON IS MY HOME.
IT'S THE ONE THING
I PROMISED I WOULD
NEVER LET HIM TAKE FROM ME.
THEN WE'LL
PROTECT YOU HERE.
YOU CAN'T PROTECT ME.
NOBODY CAN.
PLEASE BE CAREFUL WITH THIS.
PLEASE.
IT'S SAFE WITH US.
HE'S JUST A MAN,
NOTHING MORE.
THEN WHY CAN'T YOU CATCH HIM?
WE WILL.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
[CAR DOORS CLOSE]
HEY, UH, THIS WAS
DROPPED OFF AT MY OFFICE.
I'LL GET THIS TO THE LAB.
ARE YOU GOING TO RUN
THE STORY, ROY?
YOU KNOW, IF I DON'T,
HE'LL JUST GIVE IT
TO SOMEBODY ELSE.
MAYBE, MAYBE NOT.
TO HIM YOU'RE SPECIAL.
HE WANTS YOU TO KNOW
WHY HE STOPPED.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
YOU WROTE HIS BIOGRAPHY, ROY.
BELIEVE ME, OVER THE LAST
10 YEARS, HE'S READ THOSE WORDS
THOUSANDS OF TIMES.
YOUR BOOK HAS SUSTAINED HIM.
IN HIS MIND, NOBODY KNOWS HIM
BETTER THAN YOU DO.
NOBODY CARES FOR HIM LIKE YOU.
YOU REMEMBER WHAT IT WAS LIKE
HERE 10 YEARS AGO ON THE STREET?
THE FEAR?
AND THAT'S WHEN PEOPLE
TRUSTED THE POLICE.
NOT THIS TIME.
NOT IF YOU TELL THEM
ABOUT SHAUNESSY.
BUT IT'S A HELL OF A STORY.
RUN WITH IT.
DO YOU HAVE
ANY IDEA WHAT YOU'RE
ASKING ME TO DO?
I'M NOT ASKING YOU
TO DO ANYTHING.
THIS IS THE BIGGEST
STORY OF MY LIFE,
AND I-IT'S MINE.
IT'S AN EXCLUSIVE.
I CAN OFFER YOU
FULL AND EXCLUSIVE ACCESS
TO THE F.B.I.'s
BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS UNIT
AFTER WE CATCH HIM.
RIGHT. IF I HOLD
THE STORY.
I DIDN'T SAY THAT.
FULL ACCESS
TO THE ENTIRE UNIT?
NOBODY'S EVER HAD THAT.
I KNOW.
BUT...
BUT, I MEAN, WHAT IF
YOU CAN'T CATCH HIM?
WELL, THAT'S A RISK
YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO TAKE.
[TELEPHONE RINGS]
[RING]
HOTCHNER.
[DEEP BREATH]
WHO IS THIS?
IF YOU STOP HUNTING ME,
I'LL STOP HUNTING THEM.
YOU THINK I'D TAKE THAT?
IT'S A GOOD DEAL.
I'VE MISJUDGED YOU.
I THOUGHT YOU WERE
SMARTER THAN THIS.
YOU SHOULD TAKE IT.
AND YOU'VE MISJUDGED ME.
THIS IS
YOUR LAST CHANCE.
I DON'T MAKE DEALS.
I'M THE GUY WHO HUNTS
GUYS LIKE YOU.
THERE ARE
NO GUYS LIKE ME.
YOU ALL THINK THAT.
YOU'LL REGRET THIS.
I'LL SEE YOU SOON.
ALMOST MISSED YOU.
[BEHIND MASK]
DRIVE.
[WOMAN GASPS]
[GASPS]
MAKE A RIGHT
AT THE NEXT LIGHT.
I WANT YOUR JEWELRY
AND YOUR WALLETS.
PULL OVER RIGHT HERE.
JUST TAKE THE MONEY.
NOBODY NEEDS TO GET HURT.
ACTUALLY, THEY DO.
[PASSENGERS SCREAMING]
6 BODIES, NOT INCLUDING
THE DRIVER.
HE PUT 'EM DOWN
WITH THE GUN--
OR MORE LIKELY GUNS--
AND FINISHED THEM OFF
WITH HIS KNIFE.
ARTHUR LANESSA'S
WEDDING RING.
WHAT'D HE TAKE?
DOES IT MATTER?
HEY. WHAT'S GOIN' ON
WITH YOU?
HE CALLED ME TONIGHT
AT MY HOTEL AND
OFFERED ME THE DEAL.
WHAT DID YOU SAY?
I HUNG UP ON HIM,
AND THEN HE DOES THIS.
SO YOU THINK
THIS IS YOUR FAULT?
IT IS.
WELL, HERE, USE MINE.
YOU CONVINCED ME.
NO, NO,
YOU HUNG UP ON HIM.
YOU PRACTICALLY
KILLED THEM YOURSELF.
GO AHEAD,
GET IT OVER WITH.
DON'T WORRY ABOUT US.
WE'LL GET THIS GUY
WITHOUT YOU.
DAVE, I HAD 10 YEARS
TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
SHAUNESSY MADE THE DEAL.
THE KILLING STOPPED.
HE CLOSED THE CASE AND
SENT THE B.A.U. AWAY.
FOR 10 YEARS,
YOU WORKED ON OTHER
CASES, ACTIVE CASES.
BUT I KEPT COMING BACK
TO THIS ONE.
I KEPT COMING BACK
TO THIS PROFILE.
HEY. I WAS RETIRED.
SHOULD I BLAME MYSELF
FOR EVERY VICTIM
WHO GOT KILLED WHILE
I WAS ON MY BOOK TOUR?
LOOK, IF YOU WANT TO
END UP LIKE SHAUNESSY,
LIKE GIDEON,
BLAMING YOURSELF
FOR EVERYTHING,
YOU GO AHEAD.
BUT THAT VOICE
IN YOUR HEAD,
IT'S NOT
YOUR CONSCIENCE.
IT'S YOUR EGO.
THIS ISN'T
ABOUT US, AARON.
IT'S ABOUT THE BAD GUYS.
THAT'S WHY
WE PROFILE THEM.
IT'S THEIR FAULT.
WE'RE JUST GUYS
DOING A JOB.
AND WHEN WE
STOP DOING IT,
SOMEONE ELSE WILL.
TRUST ME.
I KNOW.
YOU CAN PUT THAT AWAY.
YOU SURE?
IT'S A LITTLE DRAMATIC,
DON'T YOU THINK?
MY WIFE ALWAYS
SAID I HAD A FLAIR
FOR THE DRAMATIC.
WHICH ONE?
ALL OF 'EM.
THANKS.
ANYTIME.
GO AHEAD
AND RUN YOUR STORY.
IT WON'T MATTER
AFTER THIS.
I AM, BUT I'M GONNA LEAVE
THE SHAUNESSY DEAL OUT.
I DON'T THINK THE FAMILIES
NEED TO KNOW,
NOT AT LEAST
UNTIL YOU CATCH HIM.
I APPRECIATE THAT.
FOYET CALLED.
HE, UH, WANTS TO SEE ME.
IS HE MAD THAT YOU
GAVE HIM TO US?
I JUST THINK HE DOESN'T
HAVE ANYONE TO TALK TO,
AND THE REAPER'S KILLING
HIM, TOO, ONLY SLOWER.
HE WOULDN'T BE
THE FIRST.
HE NEVER USED CODE BEFORE.
WHY NOW?
THEY'RE NOT PART OF
A PATTERN OR EQUATION.
I MEAN, MATHEMATICALLY,
THEY'RE INSIGNIFICANT.
MAYBE SO, BUT
I KNOW I'VE SEEN
THEM BEFORE.
FOYET SAID HE LIKES TO ATTACK
PEOPLE IN THEIR CARS.
TONIGHT HE HIT A BUS.
WHICH IS WHY FOYET
ONLY TAKES A BUS.
IT WAS THE NUMBER 7.
AND IT STOPS RIGHT IN FRONT
OF FOYET'S APARTMENT.
HE KNOWS
WHERE FOYET LIVES.
AND HE WANTS US TO KNOW IT.
1439. THE APARTMENT YOU
INTERVIEWED HIM IN TODAY
WAS 1439 YARBROUGH.
THE OTHER ADDRESSES
HE GAVE US.
201 SOUTH BROOKLINE.
1488 EDENHURST.
THE NUMBERS ON THE BUS
ARE FOYET'S ADDRESSES.
WE'LL SPLIT UP
AND COVER EACH ADDRESS.
[SIREN]
I'LL TAKE THE BACK.
THERE'S NO ONE HERE.
WE GOT NOTHING.
SAME THING HERE.
HAVE YOU HEARD FROM MORGAN?
WAKE UP, DEREK.
IT'S TIME TO DIE.
IF IT'S ANY CONSOLATION,
I DON'T THINK
HE KNEW WHAT HIT HIM.
I'LL CALL J.J.
THE BUREAU'S GONNA
HAVE TO MAKE A STATEMENT.
YOU ALL RIGHT?
HE TOOK MY CREDENTIALS.
THE IMPORTANT THING
IS YOU'RE OK.
HE LEFT ME THIS.
POWER AND MANIPULATION.
DON'T LET HIM GET TO YOU.
YEAH, RIGHT.
OW, COME ON, MAN.
SORRY.
PRENTISS, HE'S TELLING ME,
"I HAD YOU."
MORGAN, YOU'RE ALIVE.
YOU KNOW WHY?
IT DOESN'T REALLY MATTER.
I'M SITTING HERE BECAUSE
I WAS KNOCKED OUT COLD.
HE COULDN'T TORTURE ME.
HE LIKES TO INTERACT
WITH HIS VICTIMS,
TO TELL THEM HE'S GONNA
KILL THEM BEFORE HE DOES.
OR BY LETTING THEM KNOW
HE COULD HAVE.
HOTCH IS RIGHT.
HE'S JUST TRYING
TO GET INTO YOUR HEAD.
RIGHT OR WRONG,
HE HAD ME.
O'MARA WAS CLEARLY
KILLED OUTSIDE.
THIS WAS SOMEONE ELSE.
THERE'S SIGNS OF A STRUGGLE
AND A LOT OF BLOOD.
BUT NO BODY.
JUST THE DRAG MARKS.
THE HUMAN BODY
HOLDS 5 QUARTS OF BLOOD.
I'D SAY THERE'S A LITTLE MORE
THAN HALF THAT HERE.
WHOEVER THE BLEEDER WAS,
THEY LOST TOO MUCH TO SURVIVE.
FOYET?
IT WAS HIS WORST FEAR,
THAT THE REAPER
WOULD COME BACK
AND FINISH THE JOB.
WE OFFERED HIM PROTECTION.
HE REFUSED.
IT WAS HIS CHOICE.
WHY IS HE SO FOCUSED ON FOYET?
WHAT'S SO SPECIAL ABOUT HIM?
HE WAS HIS ONLY
SURVIVING VICTIM,
THE ONLY ONE
HE COULDN'T DEFEAT.
BUT HE'S NOT A THREAT.
DEFEATING HIM WOULD BE
NO GREAT ACCOMPLISHMENT.
THERE'S SOMETHING THERE
THAT WE'RE MISSING.
WHAT ABOUT THE GIRLFRIEND,
AMANDA BERTRAND?
WH-WHAT DO
WE KNOW ABOUT HER?
19. A FRESHMAN.
SHE CAME HERE FROM MICHIGAN
TO GO TO SCHOOL.
FOYET WAS A TEACHER'S
ASSISTANT IN ONE
OF AMANDA'S COURSES.
MICHIGAN.
WHERE THE REAPER
HAD SHAUNESSY
POST
THE PERSONAL AD.
THAT CAN'T BE A COINCIDENCE.
HE TOLD US SHE WAS
THE LOVE OF HIS LIFE,
THAT HE WAS GONNA PROPOSE.
BUT SHE JUST GOT HERE
FROM MICHIGAN.
THEY ONLY MET
WHEN THE CLASS STARTED.
HOW LONG HAD SHE
BEEN IN THE CLASS?
4 WEEKS.
SO IT WAS EITHER LOVE
AT FIRST SIGHT, OR WHAT?
FOYET WAS LYING?
HE'S A 28-YEAR-OLD
TEACHER'S ASSISTANT
IN FRESHMAN CLASSES.
THAT GIVES HIM PLENTY
OF ACCESS TO YOUNG GIRLS.
GARCIA.
I'M HERE.
UH, WHAT ARE
FOYET'S ALIASES?
I WANT YOU TO LOOK UP
IN BOSTON CITY RECORDS
KEVIN BASKIN, MILES HOLDEN,
AND WILLIAM PARKER.
TRY THE DEPARTMENT
OF EDUCATION.
WELL PLAYED, SIR.
THEY ALL WORK FOR
THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION,
THEY'RE ALL SUBSTITUTE TEACHERS,
AND THEY ALL TEACH
COMPUTER SCIENCE.
HIGH SCHOOL?
YEAH.
OOPS.
SCRATCH THAT.
THEY'RE NOT ALL WORKING
FOR THE DEPARTMENT
OF EDUCATION.
THEY'RE NOT?
NO. WILLIAM PARKER
WAS FIRED FOR ALLEGED
INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR
WITH HIS FEMALE STUDENTS.
DO YOU KNOW
HOW LONG IT TAKES
TO STAB SOMEBODY
67 TIMES?
Garcia: HOTCH?
WHY CAN'T YOU CATCH HIM?
COLSON WENT TO SEE FOYET.
GARCIA, I NEED YOU TO LOCATE
ROY COLSON'S CELL PHONE.
GEORGE FOYET IS THE REAPER.
OH, GOD. UH--
OK, TRIANGULATING NOW.
I GOT IT.
2633 SOUTH BUDLONG.
Morgan: THAT MUST BE AN ADDRESS
THAT FOYET DIDN'T GIVE US.
[KNOCKS]
HEY, GEORGE.
HEY.
NICE TO SEE YOU.
COME ON IN.
IT'S BEEN A WHILE.
YOU BROUGHT YOUR LAPTOP.
GOOD.
YEAH.
JUST SET IT UP OVER THERE
ON THE TABLE.
OK.
HE STABBED
AMANDA BERTRAND
TO DEATH,
HE DROVE A MILE,
HE CALLED 911,
HE WENT BACK,
AND HE INFLICTED
THOSE WOUNDS ON HIMSELF.
HE KNEW E.M.S. WOULD GET THERE
IN TIME TO SAVE HIM.
BETWEEN THE PHONE CALL
AND THE SEVERITY
OF HIS WOUNDS,
WE NEVER CONSIDERED HIM
AS A SUSPECT.
WHY WOULD HE DO IT?
IT PUT HIM AT THE CORE
OF THE INVESTIGATION.
EVERYTHING WE HAD
CAME FROM HIM.
HE LEFT HIS OWN GLASSES
AT THE CRIME SCENE,
HE POINTED US RIGHT BACK
IN HIS DIRECTION,
AND STILL WE DIDN'T SEE IT.
SO HOW ARE YOU?
HOW YOU--YOU KNOW,
HOW YOU HOLDING UP?
ACTUALLY, UH...
I'M KIND OF ANGRY WITH YOU.
OH, YEAH. 'CAUSE I GAVE
YOUR NAME TO THE F.B.I.?
IS THAT--IS THAT
WHAT THIS IS ABOUT?
NO. NO, IT'S NOT ABOUT
WHAT YOU GAVE THEM.
IT'S WHAT I GAVE YOU.
WHY DIDN'T YOU BREAK
THE STORY I GAVE YOU
ABOUT THE DEAL I MADE
WITH SHAUNESSY?
WHAT?
IT WAS A GIFT.
I GAVE IT TO YOU.
WAIT A MINUTE.
WAIT--STOP.
ALL YOU HAD TO DO
WAS PRINT THE STORY.
NO, THIS CAN'T--THIS--
I COULD HAVE JUST
DISAPPEARED AGAIN.
THIS IS NOT YOU, GEORGE.
THERE'S NO WAY THIS IS--
PLEASE STOP!
STOP, GEORGE!
GEORGE, PLEASE!
THIS CAN'T BE YOU.
THIS CAN'T BE YOU.
IT JUST--
WHAT DO--WHAT DO
YOU WANT ME TO DO?
I WANT YOU TO SIT DOWN
AND GET IT RIGHT.
OK.
YOU WROTE THAT I WAS
EITHER DEAD OR ARRESTED.
WELL, NOW YOU KNOW
THAT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED.
I WON.
I BEAT THEM,
AND I WANT EVERYBODY
TO KNOW THAT.
IT'S OVER.
STOP.
I'LL KILL HIM.
YOU NEED HIM
TO WRITE YOUR STORY.
I'M TAKING HIM WITH ME.
I'LL LET HIM GO
AS SOON AS I'M SAFE.
NO, YOU'RE NOT.
I SAID I'LL KILL HIM.
YOU KILL HIM,
I KILL YOU.
YOU THINK I'M AFRAID TO DIE?
YOU'RE NOT AFRAID.
YOU'RE GREEDY
AND NARCISSISTIC.
YOU WANT
THE RECOGNITION
THAT'S GONNA COME
FROM THE BOOK THAT
HE'S GONNA WRITE.
YOU WANT THE FAME
THAT'S GONNA COME
FROM THE MEDIA.
IT'S GONNA BE
LIKE BUNDY.
I'M GONNA BE BIGGER
THAN BUNDY.
WELL, YOU CAN'T
ENJOY IT IF
YOU'RE DEAD.
IF YOU KNOW ME SO WELL,
HOW COME SOME MANY HAD TO DIE
TO BRING YOU HERE?
THAT'S YOUR CHOICE,
NOT MINE.
YOU'RE
THE SERIAL KILLER.
THAT'S RIGHT.
HELLO, DEREK.
WHERE'S MY BADGE?
WHERE IS IT,
YOU SON OF A BITCH?
I'M GONNA BE MORE FAMOUS
THAN YOU EVEN REALIZE.
KEEP DREAMIN'.
YOU OK, ROY?
[BREATHING HARD]
I'M OK.
YEAH, I'M OK.
YOU?
Hotch: "MEN HEAP TOGETHER
THE MISTAKES OF THEIR LIVES
AND CREATE A MONSTER
THEY CALL DESTINY."
JOHN HOBBES.
THEY DIDN'T FIND
YOUR CREDENTIALS
AT ANY OF THE RESIDENCES.
THE BLOOD AT THE HOUSE
WAS FOYET'S.
REID GUESSED LOW.
THE CORONER SAID
IT WAS 4 QUARTS.
HOTCH, HOW IS
THAT POSSIBLE?
HE'D BE DEAD.
HE'S BEEN PLANNING HIS DEATH
FOR A LONG TIME.
SO, WHAT, HE TOOK
A LITTLE BLOOD AT A TIME
UNTIL HE HAD ENOUGH
TO CONVINCE US
HE WAS DEAD WITHOUT
FINDING HIS BODY?
MORGAN, YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO
FIND A WAY TO LET IT GO.
COULD YOU?
I'D HAVE TO.
[NO AUDIBLE DIALOGUE]
FOYET ESCAPED.
GUARDS FOUND HIM
IN HIS CELL VOMITING
BLOOD AND CONVULSING.
THEY RUSHED HIM
TO THE PRISON HOSPITAL.
GET ME THE U.S. MARSHALS OFFICE.
I ALREADY CALLED DON REILLY.
I OFFERED OUR ASSISTANCE.
HE SAID THEY'D CALL US
IF THEY NEEDED IT.
THE BOSTON FIELD OFFICE
JUST IDENTIFIED DOCUMENTS
FROM FOYET'S HOUSE.
THEY'RE SCHEMATICS
FOR THE ELECTRICAL,
HEATING, AND WATER DUCTS
OF THE EAST WOBURN
CORRECTIONAL FACILITY.
HE HAD THE SCHEMATICS.
AND NOT JUST FOR WOBURN.
FOR EVERY JAIL, PRISON,
AND COURTHOUSE
IN MASSACHUSETTS.
AND 10 YEARS TO PLAN.
THEY'RE GONNA
FIND HIM, RIGHT?
NO, THEY'RE NOT.
HE SAID HE'D
BE MORE FAMOUS
THAN WE KNEW,
AND HE WAS RIGHT.