Buried in the Backyard (2018–…): Season 2, Episode 4 - Murders in Maine - full transcript
When a young mother in Newport Maine goes missing, the case goes cold until another mom suddenly vanishes, sparking an investigation that leads to a deadly game of cat-and-mouse and grisly discoveries in a rustic backyard.
NARRATOR:
In Newport, Maine,
a young mother of two
goes missing.
[♪♪♪]
FERNAND: A neighbor heard
her screaming,
you know,
"Jimmy, stop, stop."
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: This is not
a missing-persons case.
We got a serious problem.
NARRATOR:
The trail goes cold
until another mother
suddenly vanishes.
JOSEPH: I thought,
"Here we go again."
JAMES:
Well, I knew he was the killer.
NARRATOR: A brother
determined to find the truth.
VANCE: I said,
"Did you kill my sister?"
NARRATOR:
And a race against time
to catch a serial killer.
All about cutting
these people up.
And it was just
a matter of time
before he killed again.
I was scared to death.
[♪♪♪]
[BIRDS CHIRPING]
NARRATOR: It's
a picture-perfect autumn day
in Newport, Maine.
Church steeples
and sunlit farms
sit against blue skies
and red and golden leaves.
It's quintessential
New England.
JAMES:
It's a rural area
with the typical woolen mills,
a lot of small stores,
small businesses.
It has the working class
mill type people,
you know, honest people.
IDA: People are very close
if you're in a small community.
You know each other.
You know things that go on.
Some people
don't even lock their doors.
[SIREN WAILING]
NARRATOR: But it's not
too far outside Newport
in the backyard
of a ramshackle house
that the scene is anything
but picturesque.
JAMES: There were
state troopers and detectives.
They had a backhoe there
and they were
hand-digging as well.
They had just moved
some topsoil.
NARRATOR:
From behind the police tape,
longtime local,
Vance Tibbetts,
has gathered with a crowd
of other townies.
VANCE: I was out there
on the line that day
watching with binoculars,
cameras, you know,
there were
a lot of people there.
NARRATOR: Suddenly...
the digging comes
to an abrupt stop.
VANCE: All of a sudden,
they started looking over at us,
looking around,
one guy jumps out of the hole
and goes to some
superior officer.
And then...
uh, they told us
they had found some remains.
Many people
started crying, you know.
I had the strangest feeling
that that would be my sister.
NARRATOR: Thirty-four-year-old
Jerilyn Towers
is a single working mom
with three kids.
Though she struggles
to make ends meet,
her generous spirit endears her
to everyone she meets.
IDA: Jeri, I mean,
she was a wonderful person.
She really was a kind person.
She had a good heart.
If you wanted somebody
to be friends with,
she's the one you'd want.
VANCE: If you was in a store
ahead of her
and you was 20 cents short,
or a dollar short,
she'd take it right out
and make it up for you.
She worked at a, uh,
nursing facility.
Patients loved her, you know.
She was good to them.
NARRATOR: Jeri has plenty
of love to go around
and an endless reserve
for her three kids.
She was a great mother.
Loved them kids.
They'd go bowling,
fishing, things like that.
She used to keep her
change in a jar,
just a big mayonnaise
jar probably.
There was always, you know,
maybe eight, ten, twelve bucks
in there in change
to spend on her kids
when times got a little tough.
NARRATOR:
On this fall day,
Jeri breaks into the mayo jar
and takes her kids bowling
with her mom and stepdad.
After a few rounds
of knocking some pins down,
Jeri's mom offers
to take the kids home
so Jeri can unwind
after a tough week.
Well, the bowling alley
wasn't too far from the Gateway.
It's a bar and a pizza place.
When they got to the Gateway,
Jeri told our stepfather,
"Drop me off here for a while
and I'll call you
in a couple of hours
to come get me."
NARRATOR:
The call never comes.
But around 1:00 AM,
it sounds like Jeri
makes it home.
VANCE: My stepfather
and, uh, my mother,
they lived in that duplex
with Jeri and three kids.
And, uh, a car
pulled in the driveway,
shut the light
and the engines off
for a long time,
long enough that my stepfather
believed that
Jeri had gotten a ride home,
he wouldn't have to go
to the Gateway and get her.
So, he went to bed.
[CRICKETS CHIRPING]
VANCE: The next day,
I got a call from my mother.
"Jeri didn't come home
last night.
I'm kind of worried about her."
I said, "Geez."
The thing that was really
out of character
with her not coming home
was that she didn't call mom.
That was the only thing
that got people really worried.
No matter where she was,
she always did that.
NARRATOR: After an entire day
of worrying and waiting,
Jeri's family calls
the Newport Police
to report her missing.
But detectives suspect
there's a simple explanation.
JAMES:
There was some thought
that she had left with a man
and just didn't disclose
to her parents
what had happened.
I started to think,
"Is it strange for a woman
to get involved
in a new relationship
and know that
their kids were safe
and leave for a week or so?"
No.
That's not strange at all.
VANCE:
But you think, well, my word.
No. She couldn't.
She-- she would never run off
on her family like that.
No. She loved her kids.
She really did love her kids.
NARRATOR:
Detective Ricker knows
even the most loving parents
sometimes
do the craziest things
and suspects Jeri
will be back in a day or two.
But when she still hasn't
surfaced a few days later,
Ricker heads
to the Gateway Lounge
to try to dig up answers.
JAMES: The bartender says,
"Jerilyn, she was there
and there was a man
in the bar.
And he drank with her."
To quote her, she says,
"I can't remember names,
but I can always
remember a face."
And she said
they did leave together
at 1:00 in the morning.
NARRATOR:
There's no doubt about it.
The man she saw leaving
with Jerilyn that night
is a local named James Hicks.
JAMES:
We got a physical address
on where James Hicks lived
and we went to his residence.
At the door,
I simply identified myself.
He was there
with his girlfriend,
Linda Marquis,
and told him I was there
to investigate
the missing-person case
of Jerilyn Towers
who had disappeared
in the Gateway Lounge.
I thought he was gonna faint.
He gets a glass of water
and his hands were shaking.
And he takes the water
like he's gonna drink
but ends up
pouring it everywhere.
This guy obviously
had something on his conscience
that was really
wearing on him.
And he was physically unable
to control himself.
Suddenly,
he just started blurting out,
"You think I killed
my first wife,
Jennifer Hicks?"
I thought, "Oh, my God.
This is more than
a missing-persons case."
FERNAND: There was no body,
there was no weapon,
and there was no blood.
JOSEPH: She jumped up
and ran out the front door
and immediately called 911.
SUSAN: I was petrified.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Thirty-four-year-old
single mom,
Jerilyn Towers,
mysteriously disappeared
from a local bar in Maine
just five days ago.
And when investigators
show up to question
the man she was seen
leaving with,
they get a most
bizarre response.
JAMES:
James Hicks disclosed
about how you think
I killed my first wife.
He identified her
as Jennifer Hicks.
"Oh, I didn't."
And then I brought him
back that night
Jerilyn was missing
from the bar.
And he was just giving me
this blank stare.
I mean, visibly shaken,
like he was ready
to say something.
And his girlfriend
got between he and I
and said,
"This is my house
and I'm ordering you
out of my house."
It certainly was suspicious.
But we had nothing else
to go on.
So, I thought
you better keep your eyes
on what's going on with him.
NARRATOR:
A baffled Detective Ricker
turns his attention
to Jennie Hicks,
in hopes
it will lead to clues
in the disappearance
of Jerilyn Towers.
I thought, "I've got to find
this first wife."
I quickly found out
that Jennifer Hicks'
maiden name was Cyr,
so I just took a stab
in the phonebook
and called the only Cyr
I could find
and I believe
it was Claude Cyr.
Told him who I was
and asked him if he was familiar
with Jennifer Hicks.
He starts crying on the phone.
Basically, what I learned
was in family of Jennie Hicks,
these people were just sitting
for five or six years
wanting to tell a story
they never had a chance to tell,
'cause nobody asked.
NARRATOR:
In the summer of 1977,
23-year-old Jennie Hicks
is married to her
high school sweetheart,
James.
SUSAN: She was tall.
She was very pretty.
She could cook
like you wouldn't believe.
James, he'd come up
right behind her
and whisper in her ear,
see what she was cooking.
I mean, you could see
that he did love her
and she loved him.
NARRATOR:
The young couple is busy
trying to raise
two adorable kids.
SUSAN:
She loved her kids to death.
She really, really did.
She'd do anything
for her kids.
But she didn't spoil them,
you know.
She would teach them to count,
at the same time
teaching them to share.
And she's just
a wonderful person.
NARRATOR: Susan Matley
is just 15 years old
when she comes to live
with the Hicks family.
SUSAN:
I was in foster care
and I didn't like
the foster home
that I was living in.
I had found out that Jennie
was looking for a babysitter
and we talked and everything
and she liked me.
So then she called
my caseworker
and made arrangements for me
to move in there with her.
Jennie was like
a second mom to me.
NARRATOR:
As the kids get older
and the money tighter,
the once blissful marriage
starts to crack.
SUSAN:
I think James wasn't happy.
Well, at finally,
you know, at one point,
Jennie told me that James
was gonna be moving out.
NARRATOR: Days later,
James Hicks frantically calls
the sheriff's department.
His wife, Jennie, is missing.
When the deputy responded,
James said that his wife
ran off with another man
and she wanted to break off
the relationship.
SUSAN: I didn't think Jennie
would cheat on her husband.
Jennie would never
leave her kids.
Jennie would never leave
without saying anything.
NARRATOR:
Investigators think otherwise,
suspecting Jennie ran off
to escape an unhappy marriage.
Sadly,
they have neither the time
nor resources
to devote to her case.
JOSEPH: Missing-persons cases
have a way
of getting put
on the back burner.
You got no witnesses,
you got no crime scene.
So, what are you gonna do?
NARRATOR: Jennie's family
can't get anyone
to pay attention.
That all changes
six years later in 1982,
when Detective Ricker
is trying to find
Jerilyn Towers
and learns about
Jennie Hicks instead.
JOSEPH: Jennie Hicks'
family was basically
telling the police,
"Hey, you know, uh,
he was abusive,
he was controlling.
She'd made up her mind
that she was gonna have
to leave him."
FERNAND:
And then the following morning,
she's not there,
where was she?
So the sense you got
was that something happened.
NARRATOR: Suspecting
there's a serious problem,
state investigators
review the evidence
and don't hesitate to reopen
the closed case
of Jennie Hicks.
Police quickly identify
potential witnesses.
One in particular
has never spoken to anyone
about Jennie's disappearance.
JOSEPH:
There was a live-in babysitter,
so the state police detective
tracked her down
out of state.
SUSAN: I was working
and these gentlemen
come walking up there,
flash their badge and say,
"We believe you have
something to tell us
about James Hicks
and Jennie Hicks."
And I just wanted
to fall to my knees.
I just fell back
against the wall
and I said, "Yes, I do."
I was scared to death.
JOSEPH:
She said, "Oh, yeah.
I never dared to talk
to the police before
because I was scared of--
of Hicks."
SUSAN:
And I told them, the night
that Jennie disappeared,
I was preparing the meal
for Jennie
before she came home
and all of a sudden,
James just grabbed me
and tried to make
advances at me
and I'm, like,
"No, no, leave me alone,"
and he took his cigar
and burnt me.
When James left to go
to work the next day,
I talked to Jennie
and I told Jennie exactly
what had happened
and everything
and that's when
she had asked me
to go out that night
because she was gonna
ask James for a divorce
and have him leave.
NARRATOR:
Later that night,
Susan comes home
to an unsettling scene.
SUSAN:
James was just sitting there
in the chair watching TV,
but there was nothing
on the TV screen,
but there was just white fuzz.
I looked over at Jennie
and she was laying
like this and her hand
was over like this
and her hair
was all blocking her face.
You could see
something wasn't right
and he told me
she was sleeping
and nobody can sleep
in that position.
NARRATOR:
Susan is terrified,
and when she wakes up
the next morning,
both Jennie and James
are gone.
Her purse was there,
her glasses were there.
I knew something terrible
had happened.
I thought if I say anything
and anything happens,
James would kill me.
JAMES: After the state police
interviewed Susan,
there was no doubt in my mind,
I was absolutely convinced
he killed Jennie Hicks.
NARRATOR:
If Jennie Hicks is dead,
where on earth is her body?
JAMES: I, uh, searched
around different swamps
and these old dry wells.
We searched everywhere.
We found nothing.
NARRATOR: With evidence
mounting that James Hicks
murdered his wife, Jennie,
detectives now worry
that Jerilyn Towers
may have suffered
a similar fate.
JAMES:
Everybody suspected James
of killing Jerilyn Towers.
It was a matter
of how do we prove this?
NARRATOR:
Maine investigators now suspect
missing mothers,
Jennie Hicks and Jerilyn Towers
are the unfortunate victims
of James Hicks.
By September 1983,
they've compiled a mound
of circumstantial evidence
against the 48-year-old.
JAMES:
The Jennifer investigation
had a lot more evidence
than Jerilyn did
basically
on the preponderance
of the verbal testimony
by the babysitter.
FERNAND:
There was no body,
there was no weapon,
and there was no blood
but we had
circumstantial
pieces of evidence
that led us to believe
that she was dead
and that, uh, James, uh,
was the one responsible
for her death.
NARRATOR: Six years
after Jennie Hicks vanished,
James Hicks is finally arrested
for her murder.
In March 1984,
his trial begins.
FERNAND:
It was the first case
in the State of Maine
to be tried without a body.
JAMES: It was very
emotionally charged.
NARRATOR:
The prosecution's key witness
is 22-year-old Susan Matley,
the Hicks' former babysitter.
She's panic-stricken
and reluctant to testify.
SUSAN:
I was petrified.
And they had to keep
reassuring me that they--
he can't touch me,
he can't do nothing to me.
I think I finally grew up
at that point and said,
"Enough.
Enough of being scared.
I got to help do something
and put him away
to stop him."
NARRATOR:
The prosecution argues
that an unhinged Hicks
killed Jennie,
and that she was already dead
when Susan came home,
to find her lying
eerily still on the couch.
SUSAN: I looked at him
and I said to myself,
"You bastard,
you're finally gonna get it."
NARRATOR:
After a 10-day trial
and deliberating
for just nine hours,
the jury reaches a verdict.
James was convicted
of fourth degree murder.
FERNAND:
It's a form of manslaughter.
It's a non-intentional killing.
JAMES:
He was sentenced to 10 years.
SUSAN:
I was sad because I thought
he'd get more than 10 years,
but I was happy
that everyone finally knew.
NARRATOR: With James Hicks
finally behind bars,
detectives turn up the heat
on the missing-persons case
of Jerilyn Towers.
After 18 long months
of dead end leads,
police now suspect
the 35-year-old mother
may have met
the same tragic demise
as Jennie Hicks.
JOSEPH: Jerilyn and Hicks
are at the bar,
they're drinking together,
they leave together,
and then she disappeared.
JAMES:
Obviously at that point,
I think he murdered
Jerilyn Towers.
I, um, got a hold
of the state police
and we all started...
everything, all over again
with Jerilyn.
They went back
and re-interviewed
everybody I interviewed
and more.
I've searched these old farms,
these old estates.
Did I think
that she would be buried
on the property?
Quite possibly.
The clock is ticking,
days are passing,
we had to work
very quickly because,
you know, go figure,
he gets a 10-year sentence,
but he might get out early.
NARRATOR:
In a bizarre twist,
James Hicks is sent
to the same prison
where Jerilyn Tower's brother,
Vance Tibbetts,
is serving time
on an assault charge.
I said,
"Did you kill my sister?
You SOB?"
I said "Well, look at me,
tell me about it.
Was she begging for her life?
Was you trying to have sex
with her?
You just go crazy?
What happened?"
He looked right at me.
He said "No, I had nothing
to do with it."
But I felt he was guilty.
Well, you can tell.
I thought about killing
that son of a bitch
right in prison, you know.
Man.
He's a lucky bird.
NARRATOR: Surprisingly,
Hicks becomes a model prisoner
and after spending less
than seven years behind bars,
he's released
on good behavior.
SUSAN: I never ever thought
that he would get free.
Never did.
And I was scared to death.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Hicks moves to the small town
of Brewer, Maine
hoping to stay off
the cop's radar.
James Ricker
quietly keeps tabs on him
and he's not the only one.
VANCE: I was already out
waiting for that
son of a bitch.
JOSEPH: Vance, he would
setup a video camera
and film him leaving home,
film him going to work,
running errands,
and wave to him,
stuff like that,
which Hicks found
very intimidating.
VANCE: I wanted to be arrested.
I did.
That's what I wanted.
To get him
to bring the charge
against me,
harassment or whatever,
to get him on the record
anyway I could.
NARRATOR: The plan works
and Hicks shows up
at the police department.
JOSEPH:
Back in 1995, James Hicks
had made a formal complaint
to the Brewer Police Department
that he was being stalked
and harassed
by a Vance Tibbetts.
NARRATOR:
His girlfriend, Lynn Willette
comes with him to the station.
JOSEPH: So, I had
the opportunity to talk about
the disappearance
of Jerilyn Towers
while Lynn Willette
is sitting there
listening to all this.
Hmm, I'm pretty sure
that over time
it started
to make her think.
Who is this guy
I'm living with?
What's he actually done
or hasn't done?
I was trying to warn her,
it's all I can do.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
It's been five years
since James Hicks
was released from prison
for the murder
of his wife Jenny
and many more
since Jerilyn Towers
mysteriously vanished
from the Gateway Lounge.
JAMES:
He's 28 miles away.
He's in the city of Brewer.
That was not
my jurisdiction, obviously.
But I would talk
to the different detectives
on that region.
We always would be
watching him.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Now, while being eyed
in Towers' disappearance,
Hicks makes a stunning call
to police.
JOSEPH: I got a call
from the state police barracks
and they said that James Hicks
had reported
that his girlfriend
Lynn Willette was missing.
Here we go again.
JAMES: Why is it
of all the people in Maine,
only James Hicks's
girlfriends disappear?
God, he had a lot of bad luck
when it comes to girlfriends.
Really, who believes this?
After everything
we have gone through.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: I went to James Hicks
and I said, uh,
"So tell me what happened."
He said they had separated,
she had moved back home
with her mother
at that point in time,
there was some kind of
family gathering that day.
When she didn't show up
at the barbecue
then it was like
"Well, this isn't right."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Investigators fear
another woman
has been swept up
in Hicks deadly web.
Hicks, calmly lays out
his own version of events.
JOSEPH: He gave me
a long story
about the last time
he saw her
and he basically made
the argument
that she had been really
despondent lately
and he was really worried
that she might've killed
herself.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: So that gave me
an excellent opportunity
to work with him
to help find where she is.
We searched
the Hicks apartment.
She lived there, right?
So, anything you found,
hair, fibers, fingerprints
wouldn't help you
not unless you found
some mass amount of blood.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: You know, we didn't--
there's nothing.
[♪♪♪]
My first thought
is James Hicks
killed another woman.
Cut and dry.
Circumstances were the same,
the woman left,
no correspondence,
just disappeared.
I'm thinking
he's a serial killer.
No doubt in my mind
what he had done,
I just couldn't prove it.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Overworked investigators
are feeling the heat
to find two bodies
and get the potential
serial killer
back behind bars
before he kills
another innocent woman.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: The families,
and now the general public,
they're like "Number three?
A third woman has disappeared
and you don't have anybody
under arrest?"
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:I reached the point where
I had really had it.
Nothing was happening.
Nothing.
I mean, I would be so depressed
when you don't think
it'll ever end.
I mean, sometimes
I couldn't control the tears,
you know, I just--
big tough man,
big tough outlaw,
but, you know, you got--
just, uh,
just the way it is.
I missed her awful.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Despite his grief,
Jerilyn Towers' brother,
Vance Tibbetts is so desperate
to find his sister.
He takes matters
into his own hands.
VANCE: I searched far and wide,
backyards everywhere.
I'd ask people
"Do you mind
if I take a look out there?"
I was so tired,
but I will not quit
and I never did.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: The pressure
apparently gets to Hicks too.
JOSEPH: He was feeling
ostracized from the community
because there've been
so much publicity
about the case
that he was starting
to feel uncomfortable.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: So he left
and moved to Texas.
Now I can't stop by
and talk to him anymore.
I just lost that opportunity.
NARRATOR:
With a potential serial killer
leaving their own backyard,
concerned investigators
have to do something.
And decide to write
authorities in Texas
to warn them about Hicks.
JAMES: He went on their radar
very quick.
A guy who had moved
into their town
with no local ties
just somehow picked out
Levelland, Texas,
a convicted murderer,
seemingly on the run
from two other homicides.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
For the next two years,
authorities in Texas and Maine
keep close tabs
on James Hicks.
JAMES: In my soul I knew
and it was just
a matter of time
before he killed again.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Then, on an otherwise
gorgeous spring day,
a frantic 911 call is fielded
in Lubbock County, Texas.
An unsuspecting
elderly woman claims
she's been attacked
by her handyman.
JOSEPH: The Lubbock police
told me all the details.
After listening to them,
it was pretty clear to me,
he obviously
was gonna kill her.
[♪♪♪]
I mean, that was his plan.
Oh my God,
I can't believe it.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: A 67-year-old widow
in Lubbock, Texas
has just fallen prey
to a ruthless attacker.
JOSEPH: June Moss
that hired a handyman,
he had done
some work for her
and this one day
he comes in
and he's acting
kind of unstable.
[♪♪♪]
And he pulls out the gun
and he pointed it at her.
NARRATOR: The woman's story
goes from bad
to completely bizarre.
JOSEPH: He had made her drink
the bottle of cough syrup
and he made her write out
a handwritten document
basically giving
her car to him.
He'd also unplugged
the phone lines,
he had pulled down
the shades,
and the windows,
and then at one point
he asked her
if she had any guns,
so she pointed
out the bedroom
and he went in the bedroom
and started rifling
through the closet.
At that point she
had the presence of mind,
she jumped up
and ran out the front door
and ran
to her neighbor's house.
Well, the neighbors
immediately called 911.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Police are quick
to arrive to the neighborhood
where June Moss is shaken
but grateful to be alive.
June Moss was able
to tell the police
that it was James Hicks
who had done this.
NARRATOR: Remembering
the dire warnings about Hicks
from investigators in Maine,
Texas Police raced
through the streets of Lubbock
to chase him down.
[HELICOPTER WHIRRING]
JOSEPH: My contact
down in Lubbock called me.
He said, "Good news.
We arrested James Hicks today
for robbery
of an elderly person."
He said, "Which is
a very serious crime
in the state of Texas,
so he's gonna be locked
up for a while.
We got a really good case."
Zamboni called
and said what had happened.
And that Hicks was
in deep trouble.
I was so happy.
That son of a bitch.
[LAUGHS]
NARRATOR: Because Hicks
was a convicted felon
and used a gun
in committing his latest crime,
police finally have him
where they want him,
facing a life sentence.
JOSEPH: He'd been in jail
for a week or two I think
and he was complaining
that he really hated
being in jail in Texas.
He felt very uncomfortable
in the jail.
He thought maybe
he could get hurt
and he's saying,
"You got to get me out of here."
And I said "Oh, I'll get you
out of there."
And said, "But, you know,
it's gonna cost you."
I said, "You're gonna have
to cooperate with us.
You're gonna have to,
you know,
basically tell us
what you did
and then you can do
your time in Maine
instead of Texas."
He said,
"That's what I wanna do."
NARRATOR: Detective Zamboni
is on the next flight
to Texas
banking on the fact
Hicks really will cop
to his crimes.
We met him at the jail
and talked to him.
He said, "I will tell you
that I killed Lynn Willette,
but that's all
I'm telling you.
I'm gonna tell you
any details
until I'm back in Maine.
When I get to Maine,
I'll cooperate
with the grand jury,
you know, and you.
To show you evidence
and everything it needs to--
to give you closure
on those cases
that we talked about
or you know about.
DETECTIVE: Is it likely
after you cooperate
that remains from the other two
will be found also?
Oh, the other ones?
Yeah.
I'll cooperate
in all three of them.
NARRATOR: James Hicks a master
player of cat and mouse
is on his way back to Maine.
But will there finally be
justice for Jerilyn Towers
and answers
about the bodies of Jerilyn,
Lynn Willette,
and Jennie Hicks?
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: We go back to Maine,
sat down with him
for lengthy interviews,
detailing what he did,
where he did it,
how he did it.
He's calm. He's very
matter-of-fact about it.
He's not emotional.
NARRATOR: In a stunning moment,
Hicks goes on to describe
the night in 1982
when Jerilyn Towers
disappeared.
He said that he left the bar.
We talked a few minutes
and I thought,
are you sure
you don't need a ride?
Yeah. I'll take one.
And he said,
they were arguing
about something.
Then he said he grabbed her.
I remember her back,
to me like that.
And the next thing I remember
she was dead.
DETECTIVE:
How did you kill her?
I think I strangled her
with my hands.
And then he said,
"I, uh, buried her
under the dirt floor
in the chicken coop
in the backyard,
[INDISTINCT] in my house."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Investigators
can hardly believe
what they're hearing,
but Hicks is far from finished
with his horrific stories.
JOSEPH:
So regarding Jennie Hicks,
he said that
they'd had a argument.
He got mad.
He grabbed a belt.
Well, I was getting ready
for bed and like that.
DETECTIVE:
Undressing?
But I was still dressed
when I knew it
started happening.
DETECTIVE:
So you basically strangled her?
Yeah.
And then he took her
out of the trailer.
He dismembered her
and he scattered her
in the woods.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
What Hicks admits to next
is beyond gruesome.
JOSEPH: He did say
that he had taken her head
and put it in a cooler,
ice chest type cooler.
DETECTIVE: So once you get
the cooler full
then what do you do?
Just leave the cooler there.
DETECTIVE:
Where did you leave it?
JAMES:
Right there.
DETECTIVE:
The head-- the head's there?
You believe the hands
are in the cooler as well?
Yeah.
He toted that ice chest
around with him.
He made his kids,
Jennifer's kids,
sit on it
at the kitchen table.
So for years,
they were sitting
on their mother's head
as a chair.
I mean what a sick bastard
would do that?
JOSEPH: And then he took
the cement at some point
out of the cooler
and buried it in his backyard.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Hicks also admits
to strangling his girlfriend,
Lynn Willette
and dismembering her body
before disposing of it
a hundred miles away.
[♪♪♪]
It's, like,
it's all automatic.
It's, like,
I know what I'm doing
and I'm supposed
to be doing it.
Like I say, it's, like,
I've-- I've done it before.
JOSEPH: He says, "You know,
I really do miss her,
but the part about killing her
and cutting her up
in little pieces,
that wasn't a big deal."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Detectives
in Central Maine
may be about to unearth
a horrific secret,
buried in the backyard
of presumed serial killer,
James Hicks.
JOSEPH: Once Hicks told us
exactly what he did,
I said, "Take us
to where you disposed
of these bodies
and show us
and we'll dig them up
and we'll confirm that
you're telling the truth."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Investigators are teeming
all over Hicks' backyard.
From a distance,
Jerilyn's brother,
Vance Tibbetts
watches in anticipation.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE: I was hoping
very strongly
they would find my sister
and then...
they found her.
JOSEPH:
They found a skeleton,
just bones at that point.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:
Many people...
started crying
because, you know,
that was Jeri.
My mother's ring
was still on her finger.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:
The reality hits you.
It's, like, I mean, I--
it's so hard
to describe that feeling
of it's almost
a hopeless feeling,
you know, just, man,
it's just very hard to take.
Very hard to take.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Moments later,
the scene turns
more surreal still
as detectives unearth
a cement block.
JOSEPH:
It was a perfect mold
of the inside
of a cooler.
You know, the little ribs
and a little drain hole,
it's all there.
And then, of course,
they chink it open
with a hammer and chisel
and there's
Jennie's skull head.
SUSAN: I was just numb
from head to toe
that he could actually
take a woman
and chop her up.
Let me stop for a minute.
WOMAN:
Okay.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Dental records and DNA
later confirmed the identities
of all three women.
Jennie Hicks,
Jerilyn Towers,
and Lynn Willette.
IDA:
The community was shocked.
They were in horror.
People that didn't
go to church that much
started going back to church.
They were totally devastated,
in our town?
Not our town.
These victims were buried
in his backyard...
like it was nothing.
It was horrific.
I'm...
[SIGHS]
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Eighteen years
after Jerilyn Towers vanished,
will justice finally be served
for the women
and their families?
JOSEPH: He was charged
with the murder
of Lynn Willette
and the murder
of Jerilyn Towers.
He plead guilty to both,
he was sentenced
to two life terms.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH:
I had a conversation with James
at the courthouse
and I said to him,
"You know, it's good
that you're going to jail,
because if you don't go to jail
another woman is gonna die."
And he said,
"Yeah. I think you're right."
[♪♪♪]
VANCE: I know
he had been convicted
of murder times twice.
I know he'll never
breathe free air again,
but...
it's not enough.
I mean, I don't feel
any closure.
I never have.
I know where she is.
[♪♪♪]
SUSAN: The only good outcome
of the whole thing
is that they could finally
put Jennie to rest.
I want Jennie
to be remembered
as a proud mother,
a loving mother,
and a loving person.
She took people
into her heart
and helped them
like me.
VANCE: I would love to have
Jerilyn be remembered
as a good mom,
a loving mom.
She loved her family.
I miss her and love her,
so does everybody.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: For more information
about Buried In The Backyard
[♪♪♪]
In Newport, Maine,
a young mother of two
goes missing.
[♪♪♪]
FERNAND: A neighbor heard
her screaming,
you know,
"Jimmy, stop, stop."
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: This is not
a missing-persons case.
We got a serious problem.
NARRATOR:
The trail goes cold
until another mother
suddenly vanishes.
JOSEPH: I thought,
"Here we go again."
JAMES:
Well, I knew he was the killer.
NARRATOR: A brother
determined to find the truth.
VANCE: I said,
"Did you kill my sister?"
NARRATOR:
And a race against time
to catch a serial killer.
All about cutting
these people up.
And it was just
a matter of time
before he killed again.
I was scared to death.
[♪♪♪]
[BIRDS CHIRPING]
NARRATOR: It's
a picture-perfect autumn day
in Newport, Maine.
Church steeples
and sunlit farms
sit against blue skies
and red and golden leaves.
It's quintessential
New England.
JAMES:
It's a rural area
with the typical woolen mills,
a lot of small stores,
small businesses.
It has the working class
mill type people,
you know, honest people.
IDA: People are very close
if you're in a small community.
You know each other.
You know things that go on.
Some people
don't even lock their doors.
[SIREN WAILING]
NARRATOR: But it's not
too far outside Newport
in the backyard
of a ramshackle house
that the scene is anything
but picturesque.
JAMES: There were
state troopers and detectives.
They had a backhoe there
and they were
hand-digging as well.
They had just moved
some topsoil.
NARRATOR:
From behind the police tape,
longtime local,
Vance Tibbetts,
has gathered with a crowd
of other townies.
VANCE: I was out there
on the line that day
watching with binoculars,
cameras, you know,
there were
a lot of people there.
NARRATOR: Suddenly...
the digging comes
to an abrupt stop.
VANCE: All of a sudden,
they started looking over at us,
looking around,
one guy jumps out of the hole
and goes to some
superior officer.
And then...
uh, they told us
they had found some remains.
Many people
started crying, you know.
I had the strangest feeling
that that would be my sister.
NARRATOR: Thirty-four-year-old
Jerilyn Towers
is a single working mom
with three kids.
Though she struggles
to make ends meet,
her generous spirit endears her
to everyone she meets.
IDA: Jeri, I mean,
she was a wonderful person.
She really was a kind person.
She had a good heart.
If you wanted somebody
to be friends with,
she's the one you'd want.
VANCE: If you was in a store
ahead of her
and you was 20 cents short,
or a dollar short,
she'd take it right out
and make it up for you.
She worked at a, uh,
nursing facility.
Patients loved her, you know.
She was good to them.
NARRATOR: Jeri has plenty
of love to go around
and an endless reserve
for her three kids.
She was a great mother.
Loved them kids.
They'd go bowling,
fishing, things like that.
She used to keep her
change in a jar,
just a big mayonnaise
jar probably.
There was always, you know,
maybe eight, ten, twelve bucks
in there in change
to spend on her kids
when times got a little tough.
NARRATOR:
On this fall day,
Jeri breaks into the mayo jar
and takes her kids bowling
with her mom and stepdad.
After a few rounds
of knocking some pins down,
Jeri's mom offers
to take the kids home
so Jeri can unwind
after a tough week.
Well, the bowling alley
wasn't too far from the Gateway.
It's a bar and a pizza place.
When they got to the Gateway,
Jeri told our stepfather,
"Drop me off here for a while
and I'll call you
in a couple of hours
to come get me."
NARRATOR:
The call never comes.
But around 1:00 AM,
it sounds like Jeri
makes it home.
VANCE: My stepfather
and, uh, my mother,
they lived in that duplex
with Jeri and three kids.
And, uh, a car
pulled in the driveway,
shut the light
and the engines off
for a long time,
long enough that my stepfather
believed that
Jeri had gotten a ride home,
he wouldn't have to go
to the Gateway and get her.
So, he went to bed.
[CRICKETS CHIRPING]
VANCE: The next day,
I got a call from my mother.
"Jeri didn't come home
last night.
I'm kind of worried about her."
I said, "Geez."
The thing that was really
out of character
with her not coming home
was that she didn't call mom.
That was the only thing
that got people really worried.
No matter where she was,
she always did that.
NARRATOR: After an entire day
of worrying and waiting,
Jeri's family calls
the Newport Police
to report her missing.
But detectives suspect
there's a simple explanation.
JAMES:
There was some thought
that she had left with a man
and just didn't disclose
to her parents
what had happened.
I started to think,
"Is it strange for a woman
to get involved
in a new relationship
and know that
their kids were safe
and leave for a week or so?"
No.
That's not strange at all.
VANCE:
But you think, well, my word.
No. She couldn't.
She-- she would never run off
on her family like that.
No. She loved her kids.
She really did love her kids.
NARRATOR:
Detective Ricker knows
even the most loving parents
sometimes
do the craziest things
and suspects Jeri
will be back in a day or two.
But when she still hasn't
surfaced a few days later,
Ricker heads
to the Gateway Lounge
to try to dig up answers.
JAMES: The bartender says,
"Jerilyn, she was there
and there was a man
in the bar.
And he drank with her."
To quote her, she says,
"I can't remember names,
but I can always
remember a face."
And she said
they did leave together
at 1:00 in the morning.
NARRATOR:
There's no doubt about it.
The man she saw leaving
with Jerilyn that night
is a local named James Hicks.
JAMES:
We got a physical address
on where James Hicks lived
and we went to his residence.
At the door,
I simply identified myself.
He was there
with his girlfriend,
Linda Marquis,
and told him I was there
to investigate
the missing-person case
of Jerilyn Towers
who had disappeared
in the Gateway Lounge.
I thought he was gonna faint.
He gets a glass of water
and his hands were shaking.
And he takes the water
like he's gonna drink
but ends up
pouring it everywhere.
This guy obviously
had something on his conscience
that was really
wearing on him.
And he was physically unable
to control himself.
Suddenly,
he just started blurting out,
"You think I killed
my first wife,
Jennifer Hicks?"
I thought, "Oh, my God.
This is more than
a missing-persons case."
FERNAND: There was no body,
there was no weapon,
and there was no blood.
JOSEPH: She jumped up
and ran out the front door
and immediately called 911.
SUSAN: I was petrified.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Thirty-four-year-old
single mom,
Jerilyn Towers,
mysteriously disappeared
from a local bar in Maine
just five days ago.
And when investigators
show up to question
the man she was seen
leaving with,
they get a most
bizarre response.
JAMES:
James Hicks disclosed
about how you think
I killed my first wife.
He identified her
as Jennifer Hicks.
"Oh, I didn't."
And then I brought him
back that night
Jerilyn was missing
from the bar.
And he was just giving me
this blank stare.
I mean, visibly shaken,
like he was ready
to say something.
And his girlfriend
got between he and I
and said,
"This is my house
and I'm ordering you
out of my house."
It certainly was suspicious.
But we had nothing else
to go on.
So, I thought
you better keep your eyes
on what's going on with him.
NARRATOR:
A baffled Detective Ricker
turns his attention
to Jennie Hicks,
in hopes
it will lead to clues
in the disappearance
of Jerilyn Towers.
I thought, "I've got to find
this first wife."
I quickly found out
that Jennifer Hicks'
maiden name was Cyr,
so I just took a stab
in the phonebook
and called the only Cyr
I could find
and I believe
it was Claude Cyr.
Told him who I was
and asked him if he was familiar
with Jennifer Hicks.
He starts crying on the phone.
Basically, what I learned
was in family of Jennie Hicks,
these people were just sitting
for five or six years
wanting to tell a story
they never had a chance to tell,
'cause nobody asked.
NARRATOR:
In the summer of 1977,
23-year-old Jennie Hicks
is married to her
high school sweetheart,
James.
SUSAN: She was tall.
She was very pretty.
She could cook
like you wouldn't believe.
James, he'd come up
right behind her
and whisper in her ear,
see what she was cooking.
I mean, you could see
that he did love her
and she loved him.
NARRATOR:
The young couple is busy
trying to raise
two adorable kids.
SUSAN:
She loved her kids to death.
She really, really did.
She'd do anything
for her kids.
But she didn't spoil them,
you know.
She would teach them to count,
at the same time
teaching them to share.
And she's just
a wonderful person.
NARRATOR: Susan Matley
is just 15 years old
when she comes to live
with the Hicks family.
SUSAN:
I was in foster care
and I didn't like
the foster home
that I was living in.
I had found out that Jennie
was looking for a babysitter
and we talked and everything
and she liked me.
So then she called
my caseworker
and made arrangements for me
to move in there with her.
Jennie was like
a second mom to me.
NARRATOR:
As the kids get older
and the money tighter,
the once blissful marriage
starts to crack.
SUSAN:
I think James wasn't happy.
Well, at finally,
you know, at one point,
Jennie told me that James
was gonna be moving out.
NARRATOR: Days later,
James Hicks frantically calls
the sheriff's department.
His wife, Jennie, is missing.
When the deputy responded,
James said that his wife
ran off with another man
and she wanted to break off
the relationship.
SUSAN: I didn't think Jennie
would cheat on her husband.
Jennie would never
leave her kids.
Jennie would never leave
without saying anything.
NARRATOR:
Investigators think otherwise,
suspecting Jennie ran off
to escape an unhappy marriage.
Sadly,
they have neither the time
nor resources
to devote to her case.
JOSEPH: Missing-persons cases
have a way
of getting put
on the back burner.
You got no witnesses,
you got no crime scene.
So, what are you gonna do?
NARRATOR: Jennie's family
can't get anyone
to pay attention.
That all changes
six years later in 1982,
when Detective Ricker
is trying to find
Jerilyn Towers
and learns about
Jennie Hicks instead.
JOSEPH: Jennie Hicks'
family was basically
telling the police,
"Hey, you know, uh,
he was abusive,
he was controlling.
She'd made up her mind
that she was gonna have
to leave him."
FERNAND:
And then the following morning,
she's not there,
where was she?
So the sense you got
was that something happened.
NARRATOR: Suspecting
there's a serious problem,
state investigators
review the evidence
and don't hesitate to reopen
the closed case
of Jennie Hicks.
Police quickly identify
potential witnesses.
One in particular
has never spoken to anyone
about Jennie's disappearance.
JOSEPH:
There was a live-in babysitter,
so the state police detective
tracked her down
out of state.
SUSAN: I was working
and these gentlemen
come walking up there,
flash their badge and say,
"We believe you have
something to tell us
about James Hicks
and Jennie Hicks."
And I just wanted
to fall to my knees.
I just fell back
against the wall
and I said, "Yes, I do."
I was scared to death.
JOSEPH:
She said, "Oh, yeah.
I never dared to talk
to the police before
because I was scared of--
of Hicks."
SUSAN:
And I told them, the night
that Jennie disappeared,
I was preparing the meal
for Jennie
before she came home
and all of a sudden,
James just grabbed me
and tried to make
advances at me
and I'm, like,
"No, no, leave me alone,"
and he took his cigar
and burnt me.
When James left to go
to work the next day,
I talked to Jennie
and I told Jennie exactly
what had happened
and everything
and that's when
she had asked me
to go out that night
because she was gonna
ask James for a divorce
and have him leave.
NARRATOR:
Later that night,
Susan comes home
to an unsettling scene.
SUSAN:
James was just sitting there
in the chair watching TV,
but there was nothing
on the TV screen,
but there was just white fuzz.
I looked over at Jennie
and she was laying
like this and her hand
was over like this
and her hair
was all blocking her face.
You could see
something wasn't right
and he told me
she was sleeping
and nobody can sleep
in that position.
NARRATOR:
Susan is terrified,
and when she wakes up
the next morning,
both Jennie and James
are gone.
Her purse was there,
her glasses were there.
I knew something terrible
had happened.
I thought if I say anything
and anything happens,
James would kill me.
JAMES: After the state police
interviewed Susan,
there was no doubt in my mind,
I was absolutely convinced
he killed Jennie Hicks.
NARRATOR:
If Jennie Hicks is dead,
where on earth is her body?
JAMES: I, uh, searched
around different swamps
and these old dry wells.
We searched everywhere.
We found nothing.
NARRATOR: With evidence
mounting that James Hicks
murdered his wife, Jennie,
detectives now worry
that Jerilyn Towers
may have suffered
a similar fate.
JAMES:
Everybody suspected James
of killing Jerilyn Towers.
It was a matter
of how do we prove this?
NARRATOR:
Maine investigators now suspect
missing mothers,
Jennie Hicks and Jerilyn Towers
are the unfortunate victims
of James Hicks.
By September 1983,
they've compiled a mound
of circumstantial evidence
against the 48-year-old.
JAMES:
The Jennifer investigation
had a lot more evidence
than Jerilyn did
basically
on the preponderance
of the verbal testimony
by the babysitter.
FERNAND:
There was no body,
there was no weapon,
and there was no blood
but we had
circumstantial
pieces of evidence
that led us to believe
that she was dead
and that, uh, James, uh,
was the one responsible
for her death.
NARRATOR: Six years
after Jennie Hicks vanished,
James Hicks is finally arrested
for her murder.
In March 1984,
his trial begins.
FERNAND:
It was the first case
in the State of Maine
to be tried without a body.
JAMES: It was very
emotionally charged.
NARRATOR:
The prosecution's key witness
is 22-year-old Susan Matley,
the Hicks' former babysitter.
She's panic-stricken
and reluctant to testify.
SUSAN:
I was petrified.
And they had to keep
reassuring me that they--
he can't touch me,
he can't do nothing to me.
I think I finally grew up
at that point and said,
"Enough.
Enough of being scared.
I got to help do something
and put him away
to stop him."
NARRATOR:
The prosecution argues
that an unhinged Hicks
killed Jennie,
and that she was already dead
when Susan came home,
to find her lying
eerily still on the couch.
SUSAN: I looked at him
and I said to myself,
"You bastard,
you're finally gonna get it."
NARRATOR:
After a 10-day trial
and deliberating
for just nine hours,
the jury reaches a verdict.
James was convicted
of fourth degree murder.
FERNAND:
It's a form of manslaughter.
It's a non-intentional killing.
JAMES:
He was sentenced to 10 years.
SUSAN:
I was sad because I thought
he'd get more than 10 years,
but I was happy
that everyone finally knew.
NARRATOR: With James Hicks
finally behind bars,
detectives turn up the heat
on the missing-persons case
of Jerilyn Towers.
After 18 long months
of dead end leads,
police now suspect
the 35-year-old mother
may have met
the same tragic demise
as Jennie Hicks.
JOSEPH: Jerilyn and Hicks
are at the bar,
they're drinking together,
they leave together,
and then she disappeared.
JAMES:
Obviously at that point,
I think he murdered
Jerilyn Towers.
I, um, got a hold
of the state police
and we all started...
everything, all over again
with Jerilyn.
They went back
and re-interviewed
everybody I interviewed
and more.
I've searched these old farms,
these old estates.
Did I think
that she would be buried
on the property?
Quite possibly.
The clock is ticking,
days are passing,
we had to work
very quickly because,
you know, go figure,
he gets a 10-year sentence,
but he might get out early.
NARRATOR:
In a bizarre twist,
James Hicks is sent
to the same prison
where Jerilyn Tower's brother,
Vance Tibbetts,
is serving time
on an assault charge.
I said,
"Did you kill my sister?
You SOB?"
I said "Well, look at me,
tell me about it.
Was she begging for her life?
Was you trying to have sex
with her?
You just go crazy?
What happened?"
He looked right at me.
He said "No, I had nothing
to do with it."
But I felt he was guilty.
Well, you can tell.
I thought about killing
that son of a bitch
right in prison, you know.
Man.
He's a lucky bird.
NARRATOR: Surprisingly,
Hicks becomes a model prisoner
and after spending less
than seven years behind bars,
he's released
on good behavior.
SUSAN: I never ever thought
that he would get free.
Never did.
And I was scared to death.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Hicks moves to the small town
of Brewer, Maine
hoping to stay off
the cop's radar.
James Ricker
quietly keeps tabs on him
and he's not the only one.
VANCE: I was already out
waiting for that
son of a bitch.
JOSEPH: Vance, he would
setup a video camera
and film him leaving home,
film him going to work,
running errands,
and wave to him,
stuff like that,
which Hicks found
very intimidating.
VANCE: I wanted to be arrested.
I did.
That's what I wanted.
To get him
to bring the charge
against me,
harassment or whatever,
to get him on the record
anyway I could.
NARRATOR: The plan works
and Hicks shows up
at the police department.
JOSEPH:
Back in 1995, James Hicks
had made a formal complaint
to the Brewer Police Department
that he was being stalked
and harassed
by a Vance Tibbetts.
NARRATOR:
His girlfriend, Lynn Willette
comes with him to the station.
JOSEPH: So, I had
the opportunity to talk about
the disappearance
of Jerilyn Towers
while Lynn Willette
is sitting there
listening to all this.
Hmm, I'm pretty sure
that over time
it started
to make her think.
Who is this guy
I'm living with?
What's he actually done
or hasn't done?
I was trying to warn her,
it's all I can do.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
It's been five years
since James Hicks
was released from prison
for the murder
of his wife Jenny
and many more
since Jerilyn Towers
mysteriously vanished
from the Gateway Lounge.
JAMES:
He's 28 miles away.
He's in the city of Brewer.
That was not
my jurisdiction, obviously.
But I would talk
to the different detectives
on that region.
We always would be
watching him.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Now, while being eyed
in Towers' disappearance,
Hicks makes a stunning call
to police.
JOSEPH: I got a call
from the state police barracks
and they said that James Hicks
had reported
that his girlfriend
Lynn Willette was missing.
Here we go again.
JAMES: Why is it
of all the people in Maine,
only James Hicks's
girlfriends disappear?
God, he had a lot of bad luck
when it comes to girlfriends.
Really, who believes this?
After everything
we have gone through.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: I went to James Hicks
and I said, uh,
"So tell me what happened."
He said they had separated,
she had moved back home
with her mother
at that point in time,
there was some kind of
family gathering that day.
When she didn't show up
at the barbecue
then it was like
"Well, this isn't right."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Investigators fear
another woman
has been swept up
in Hicks deadly web.
Hicks, calmly lays out
his own version of events.
JOSEPH: He gave me
a long story
about the last time
he saw her
and he basically made
the argument
that she had been really
despondent lately
and he was really worried
that she might've killed
herself.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: So that gave me
an excellent opportunity
to work with him
to help find where she is.
We searched
the Hicks apartment.
She lived there, right?
So, anything you found,
hair, fibers, fingerprints
wouldn't help you
not unless you found
some mass amount of blood.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: You know, we didn't--
there's nothing.
[♪♪♪]
My first thought
is James Hicks
killed another woman.
Cut and dry.
Circumstances were the same,
the woman left,
no correspondence,
just disappeared.
I'm thinking
he's a serial killer.
No doubt in my mind
what he had done,
I just couldn't prove it.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Overworked investigators
are feeling the heat
to find two bodies
and get the potential
serial killer
back behind bars
before he kills
another innocent woman.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: The families,
and now the general public,
they're like "Number three?
A third woman has disappeared
and you don't have anybody
under arrest?"
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:I reached the point where
I had really had it.
Nothing was happening.
Nothing.
I mean, I would be so depressed
when you don't think
it'll ever end.
I mean, sometimes
I couldn't control the tears,
you know, I just--
big tough man,
big tough outlaw,
but, you know, you got--
just, uh,
just the way it is.
I missed her awful.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Despite his grief,
Jerilyn Towers' brother,
Vance Tibbetts is so desperate
to find his sister.
He takes matters
into his own hands.
VANCE: I searched far and wide,
backyards everywhere.
I'd ask people
"Do you mind
if I take a look out there?"
I was so tired,
but I will not quit
and I never did.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: The pressure
apparently gets to Hicks too.
JOSEPH: He was feeling
ostracized from the community
because there've been
so much publicity
about the case
that he was starting
to feel uncomfortable.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: So he left
and moved to Texas.
Now I can't stop by
and talk to him anymore.
I just lost that opportunity.
NARRATOR:
With a potential serial killer
leaving their own backyard,
concerned investigators
have to do something.
And decide to write
authorities in Texas
to warn them about Hicks.
JAMES: He went on their radar
very quick.
A guy who had moved
into their town
with no local ties
just somehow picked out
Levelland, Texas,
a convicted murderer,
seemingly on the run
from two other homicides.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
For the next two years,
authorities in Texas and Maine
keep close tabs
on James Hicks.
JAMES: In my soul I knew
and it was just
a matter of time
before he killed again.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Then, on an otherwise
gorgeous spring day,
a frantic 911 call is fielded
in Lubbock County, Texas.
An unsuspecting
elderly woman claims
she's been attacked
by her handyman.
JOSEPH: The Lubbock police
told me all the details.
After listening to them,
it was pretty clear to me,
he obviously
was gonna kill her.
[♪♪♪]
I mean, that was his plan.
Oh my God,
I can't believe it.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: A 67-year-old widow
in Lubbock, Texas
has just fallen prey
to a ruthless attacker.
JOSEPH: June Moss
that hired a handyman,
he had done
some work for her
and this one day
he comes in
and he's acting
kind of unstable.
[♪♪♪]
And he pulls out the gun
and he pointed it at her.
NARRATOR: The woman's story
goes from bad
to completely bizarre.
JOSEPH: He had made her drink
the bottle of cough syrup
and he made her write out
a handwritten document
basically giving
her car to him.
He'd also unplugged
the phone lines,
he had pulled down
the shades,
and the windows,
and then at one point
he asked her
if she had any guns,
so she pointed
out the bedroom
and he went in the bedroom
and started rifling
through the closet.
At that point she
had the presence of mind,
she jumped up
and ran out the front door
and ran
to her neighbor's house.
Well, the neighbors
immediately called 911.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Police are quick
to arrive to the neighborhood
where June Moss is shaken
but grateful to be alive.
June Moss was able
to tell the police
that it was James Hicks
who had done this.
NARRATOR: Remembering
the dire warnings about Hicks
from investigators in Maine,
Texas Police raced
through the streets of Lubbock
to chase him down.
[HELICOPTER WHIRRING]
JOSEPH: My contact
down in Lubbock called me.
He said, "Good news.
We arrested James Hicks today
for robbery
of an elderly person."
He said, "Which is
a very serious crime
in the state of Texas,
so he's gonna be locked
up for a while.
We got a really good case."
Zamboni called
and said what had happened.
And that Hicks was
in deep trouble.
I was so happy.
That son of a bitch.
[LAUGHS]
NARRATOR: Because Hicks
was a convicted felon
and used a gun
in committing his latest crime,
police finally have him
where they want him,
facing a life sentence.
JOSEPH: He'd been in jail
for a week or two I think
and he was complaining
that he really hated
being in jail in Texas.
He felt very uncomfortable
in the jail.
He thought maybe
he could get hurt
and he's saying,
"You got to get me out of here."
And I said "Oh, I'll get you
out of there."
And said, "But, you know,
it's gonna cost you."
I said, "You're gonna have
to cooperate with us.
You're gonna have to,
you know,
basically tell us
what you did
and then you can do
your time in Maine
instead of Texas."
He said,
"That's what I wanna do."
NARRATOR: Detective Zamboni
is on the next flight
to Texas
banking on the fact
Hicks really will cop
to his crimes.
We met him at the jail
and talked to him.
He said, "I will tell you
that I killed Lynn Willette,
but that's all
I'm telling you.
I'm gonna tell you
any details
until I'm back in Maine.
When I get to Maine,
I'll cooperate
with the grand jury,
you know, and you.
To show you evidence
and everything it needs to--
to give you closure
on those cases
that we talked about
or you know about.
DETECTIVE: Is it likely
after you cooperate
that remains from the other two
will be found also?
Oh, the other ones?
Yeah.
I'll cooperate
in all three of them.
NARRATOR: James Hicks a master
player of cat and mouse
is on his way back to Maine.
But will there finally be
justice for Jerilyn Towers
and answers
about the bodies of Jerilyn,
Lynn Willette,
and Jennie Hicks?
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH: We go back to Maine,
sat down with him
for lengthy interviews,
detailing what he did,
where he did it,
how he did it.
He's calm. He's very
matter-of-fact about it.
He's not emotional.
NARRATOR: In a stunning moment,
Hicks goes on to describe
the night in 1982
when Jerilyn Towers
disappeared.
He said that he left the bar.
We talked a few minutes
and I thought,
are you sure
you don't need a ride?
Yeah. I'll take one.
And he said,
they were arguing
about something.
Then he said he grabbed her.
I remember her back,
to me like that.
And the next thing I remember
she was dead.
DETECTIVE:
How did you kill her?
I think I strangled her
with my hands.
And then he said,
"I, uh, buried her
under the dirt floor
in the chicken coop
in the backyard,
[INDISTINCT] in my house."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Investigators
can hardly believe
what they're hearing,
but Hicks is far from finished
with his horrific stories.
JOSEPH:
So regarding Jennie Hicks,
he said that
they'd had a argument.
He got mad.
He grabbed a belt.
Well, I was getting ready
for bed and like that.
DETECTIVE:
Undressing?
But I was still dressed
when I knew it
started happening.
DETECTIVE:
So you basically strangled her?
Yeah.
And then he took her
out of the trailer.
He dismembered her
and he scattered her
in the woods.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
What Hicks admits to next
is beyond gruesome.
JOSEPH: He did say
that he had taken her head
and put it in a cooler,
ice chest type cooler.
DETECTIVE: So once you get
the cooler full
then what do you do?
Just leave the cooler there.
DETECTIVE:
Where did you leave it?
JAMES:
Right there.
DETECTIVE:
The head-- the head's there?
You believe the hands
are in the cooler as well?
Yeah.
He toted that ice chest
around with him.
He made his kids,
Jennifer's kids,
sit on it
at the kitchen table.
So for years,
they were sitting
on their mother's head
as a chair.
I mean what a sick bastard
would do that?
JOSEPH: And then he took
the cement at some point
out of the cooler
and buried it in his backyard.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Hicks also admits
to strangling his girlfriend,
Lynn Willette
and dismembering her body
before disposing of it
a hundred miles away.
[♪♪♪]
It's, like,
it's all automatic.
It's, like,
I know what I'm doing
and I'm supposed
to be doing it.
Like I say, it's, like,
I've-- I've done it before.
JOSEPH: He says, "You know,
I really do miss her,
but the part about killing her
and cutting her up
in little pieces,
that wasn't a big deal."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Detectives
in Central Maine
may be about to unearth
a horrific secret,
buried in the backyard
of presumed serial killer,
James Hicks.
JOSEPH: Once Hicks told us
exactly what he did,
I said, "Take us
to where you disposed
of these bodies
and show us
and we'll dig them up
and we'll confirm that
you're telling the truth."
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Investigators are teeming
all over Hicks' backyard.
From a distance,
Jerilyn's brother,
Vance Tibbetts
watches in anticipation.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE: I was hoping
very strongly
they would find my sister
and then...
they found her.
JOSEPH:
They found a skeleton,
just bones at that point.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:
Many people...
started crying
because, you know,
that was Jeri.
My mother's ring
was still on her finger.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
VANCE:
The reality hits you.
It's, like, I mean, I--
it's so hard
to describe that feeling
of it's almost
a hopeless feeling,
you know, just, man,
it's just very hard to take.
Very hard to take.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Moments later,
the scene turns
more surreal still
as detectives unearth
a cement block.
JOSEPH:
It was a perfect mold
of the inside
of a cooler.
You know, the little ribs
and a little drain hole,
it's all there.
And then, of course,
they chink it open
with a hammer and chisel
and there's
Jennie's skull head.
SUSAN: I was just numb
from head to toe
that he could actually
take a woman
and chop her up.
Let me stop for a minute.
WOMAN:
Okay.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR:
Dental records and DNA
later confirmed the identities
of all three women.
Jennie Hicks,
Jerilyn Towers,
and Lynn Willette.
IDA:
The community was shocked.
They were in horror.
People that didn't
go to church that much
started going back to church.
They were totally devastated,
in our town?
Not our town.
These victims were buried
in his backyard...
like it was nothing.
It was horrific.
I'm...
[SIGHS]
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: Eighteen years
after Jerilyn Towers vanished,
will justice finally be served
for the women
and their families?
JOSEPH: He was charged
with the murder
of Lynn Willette
and the murder
of Jerilyn Towers.
He plead guilty to both,
he was sentenced
to two life terms.
[♪♪♪]
JOSEPH:
I had a conversation with James
at the courthouse
and I said to him,
"You know, it's good
that you're going to jail,
because if you don't go to jail
another woman is gonna die."
And he said,
"Yeah. I think you're right."
[♪♪♪]
VANCE: I know
he had been convicted
of murder times twice.
I know he'll never
breathe free air again,
but...
it's not enough.
I mean, I don't feel
any closure.
I never have.
I know where she is.
[♪♪♪]
SUSAN: The only good outcome
of the whole thing
is that they could finally
put Jennie to rest.
I want Jennie
to be remembered
as a proud mother,
a loving mother,
and a loving person.
She took people
into her heart
and helped them
like me.
VANCE: I would love to have
Jerilyn be remembered
as a good mom,
a loving mom.
She loved her family.
I miss her and love her,
so does everybody.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
[♪♪♪]
NARRATOR: For more information
about Buried In The Backyard
[♪♪♪]