Building Ireland (2017) - full transcript
Dublin Airport is our bridge
to the world
and the busiest place
in the country.
Millions of passengers arrive
and depart here every year.
And right at the heart
of this vast complex
is an 80-year-old modernist gem,
the original Dublin Airport
Terminal Building.
This building is all about
modernity, confidence.
It's a landmark in the history
of Irish aviation
and in the story of
Building Ireland.
(INSTRUMENTAL INTRO MUSIC)
(VO) "In this series,
our team of experts in architecture,
engineering and geography explores
the most amazing stories
of Ireland's building
and engineering heritage.
And in this episode,
we'll discover how Dublin Airport
Terminal became a cultural icon."
Subtitles By
©AMC.Karl63
(VO) "Island nations need
to connect.
In the 20th century, Ireland made
its mark in the development
of the global airline industry.
And an airport would become a
gateway to the outside world."
But what was built in Dublin
wasn't just any airport;
it was a brave, modernist statement
that echoed in a new design ethos
of functionalism, glamour
and dynamism.
(VO) "A building design
of this importance
is bound to have international
influences.
Architectural historian Ellen Rowley
is going to investigate."
What we see here is an openness
to new ideas in modern architecture
driven by clear and simple
principles.
In the 1930s, this building led
a revolution in Irish architecture.
(VO) "Engineer Tim Joyce
is discovering the complicated
mechanical systems at the heart
of a modern airport terminal."
Beneath the striking facade of
Terminal 2 is a complex building
full of clever engineering
and interconnected systems,
geared to process millions
of people, passengers
and all their pieces of luggage.
(VO) "Progress in the development
of air travel is astounding.
Airlines emerged in the 1920s
and daily flights were scheduled
between cities.
By the 1930s, intercontinental air
services had really taken off
and long-haul flights were making
the world a smaller place."
As transatlantic aviation became
a reality,
it was clear that Ireland was going
to have to play a key role;
both to facilitate refuelling
and to keep the journey as short
as possible.
Planes going in either direction
would have to stopover.
(VO) "In 1935, an international
agreement enshrined Ireland
as a key stopover in the emerging
transatlantic airline business.
The airlines and the plane
manufacturers insisted
that landing on runways offered
the most flexibility
and potential for growth."
A Pan Am delegation came to Dublin
in 1936
and their chef technical advisor
Charles Lindbergh
bluntly told the government that
they needed a runway in Ireland
by the following year.
The government was suddenly
under pressure
to build the State's first
international airport.
(VO) "Luckily, the young
Minister for Industry and Commerce,
Seán Lemass, was a fan
of aeroplanes,
and he pushed to make it happen.
The right site was essential.
Shannon in County Clare couldn't
build runways in time
and so attention turned to Dublin.
Sites were considered
at the Phoenix Park
and on reclaimed land
at Sandymount Strand.
But Collinstown north of the city
offered the best option.
It had even been a military air base
during World War I.
To get a sense of the size
of the Collinstown site
and why it was chosen, Dave Allen
from DAA Ground Operations
is going to show me around."
This would have been quite remote
from the city.
Do you think it was the best choice
of airfield?
I suppose it's good that there was
a lot of space here.
Originally when it was built,
it was on over 700 acres.
And as you look around today,
it's on a hell of a lot more than
that now.
It's also important that the terrain
is fairly flat,
well away from mountains and
that type of thing as well.
So there has to be good sightlines,
particularly from air traffic
control,
so that they can see all
the aprons, taxiways and runways.
Because, as you see today,
there's a lot of aircraft
manoeuvring all around
at the same time.
Yeah. So, thinking that 80 years
ago, that the choice of location
was actually well-made for
a 21st century airport as well.
I think it is, obviously,
because the city has come
out towards us.
So if we'd been any closer to
the city back then,
we would have been right in
the middle of the city.
And then you have the noise issues.
Ground Ops 4.
(MUFFLED CHATTER OVER RADIO)
Copy that. Ground Operations 4
is now vacated back onto 121.
I'm out of your hair there
and thanks for your help.
(VO) "The job of constructing
the airport terminal was handed
to the Office of Public Works
and their team of architects faced
a blank page.
Architectural historian Ellen Rowley
investigates the influences
of the day that helped to shape this
iconic building."
(ELLEN) "When the OPW went looking
for a chief architect
for the project, a 26-year-old
put up his hand.
He was Desmond FitzGerald,
the older brother of former
Taoiseach Garrett FitzGerald.
And by chance, Desmond had designed
an airport
as part of his college thesis
two years previously.
So he was very familiar
with modernism -
that hugely influential style of
architecture from the time."
This building has many modernist
elements,
like this uninterrupted space.
Or the visible skeleton structure
which frees up the facade.
And the expanses of glazing bringing
in an abundance of natural light.
Its curved or curving form, draw
and move the traveller in.
And movement and flow continue
to underpin
the experience of the building
once inside.
(ELLEN) "The 1930s saw the
blossoming of a whole new philosophy
of design, and a new movement
in architecture -
the International Style.
Its most famous advocate was
a Swiss-French architect,
Charles-EÉouard Jeanneret,
universally known as Le Corbusier.
This architecture prominently
featured steel and glass
and white rendered concrete."
The curved terrace is a key feature
of early modernist architecture.
It is an inside-out room where flat
roofs become useful and monumental.
Here at the airport terminal
building, curved terraces become
viewing platforms to share
in the excitement of the airfield.
(ELLEN) "Earlier architectural
styles were all about
applied decorative detail
to surfaces -
decoration around doorframes,
decoration around windows.
But here, it's the shape and
structure of the building itself
that matters.
The architects are designing
a building to serve a purpose,
but they give it artistic flair too.
This is the marriage of form
and function -
a key characteristic of
the International Style.
Shane O'Toole writes about
architecture.
We met up to discuss what was so
revolutionary about this building."
Internally the expression
of the building is about the future.
It's about a future that is far away
from the grimy, smut-cloaked
19th century slums of Ireland.
It's white, it's spotless,
it's hygienic, it's clean.
It's a brave new world.
And the white is saying that
the minute you walk in.
What image does this building
inscribe upon the visitor?
This building was described as a
liner by one of the first passengers
to fly in from England, because
people were out on the balconies
like passengers out on the decks
of ship liners.
And remember Le Corbusier had used
ships
as an important metaphor
for modern architecture.
And that placed, for the first time,
an Irish building
at the heart of international
modernism.
And it's incredible that
it's being designed in 1937.
It's finished by 1941.
And you have to think Desmond
FitzGerald, the lead architect,
is only 30 that year.
Yeah, wow!
These are kids.
I mean nobody in their 20s would be
given the opportunity to design
a building of such national
and international significance
in Ireland today.
It was a brave new world where youth
was been given its head,
but understandably so,
because only 20 years earlier,
the revolutionaries themselves
had been kids.
So these people had forged a state
in their 20s.
Why couldn't you give your best
young architects in their 20s
and 30s the most important building
in the State to design?
Because it has to be new.
It has to be international.
And these are the people who will
have the vision for the future.
These young men and women -
give it to them.
(VO) "There was certainly a lot
at stake with this project.
It was the first high-profile
airport building
ever attempted in Ireland
and the OPW design team
led by Desmond Fitzgerald were under
pressure to get it built.
The design specification -
what the building needed to do -
had to be worked out. And the design
itself would have to be special."
So what was finally commissioned
was this,
the original Dublin Airport Terminal
Building.
And you can see from the original
design drawings,
from these elevations, that there's
a crispness of detailing
and lightness of touch.
And you see that in the building
itself that the light
actually reflects off the glassiness
of the building
and gives it a transparency.
The public have access to the ground
floor and then vertically up
through these terraces so they would
have been packed with people.
Making this feel like a really
welcoming building.
(VO) "As so often happens on big
construction projects,
the design specification changed.
What was originally planned
as three storeys
was now to be a four storey
building.
But the curved shape and curtain
wall glazing was retained.
From above, the rounded ends
of the plan resemble wings,
the design responds to the shape of
the aeroplanes themselves."
The shape and form of any building
defines its character
and this building is very much
informed by its curved shape.
But it wasn't just a design
flourish.
Instead it was an inspirational
development,
not of an architect
but by a French naval aviator.
(VO) "Albert-Bernard Duval
realised that airport layouts
would be more efficient if planes
could get close to the building.
and more planes could get closer
if the shape was long and curved.
This "Duval Plan" is evident
in scores of airports
built across the world during the
late 1920s and 30s.
It was clearly on the radar of
Desmond FitzGerald and the OPW Team.
They consulted international
architecture journals,
airports and airlines,
as the terminal at Dublin is a
perfect example of the Duval Plan."
The shape of the building very
clearly illustrates
the logic of air travel.
But it also had to be functional.
And these plans illustrate exactly
how the function worked.
On the ground floor you had
the public areas
where the public arrived into
the building
and travelled out to their
aeroplanes.
And then increasingly as you move up
the building,
it becomes more managerial,
organisational.
The Met Office is on the second
floor,
all the way up to the air traffic
control on the roof.
This was an efficient elegant
design,
and prototypical for the new
industry of international aviation.
(VO) "Construction of the terminal
was more or less complete by 1940,
but the escalation of war in Europe,
or the Emergency in Ireland,
changed everything.
Dublin's brand new state-of-the-art
airport terminal was put on hold.
Three of the four grass runways
were ploughed up
to grow food during the war years."
Normally a building as unique
as this would be published
and circulated in architectural
journals upon completion.
Drawings and photographs of Dublin
Airport however were prohibited
from publication, out of concerns
for national security.
(VO) "And so, this innovative
building stayed out
of the architectural limelight
until after the War,
by which time it was already
6 years old.
Engineer Tim Joyce is over
in Terminal 2
investigating a particular challenge
for modern airports.
When thousands of passengers travel,
they bring thousands of items
of luggage."
The Baggage Handling System
stretches out across
nine football pitches, has more
than six kilometres of conveyors
driven by 1,476 motors.
When you take a plane from
Terminal 2,
your luggage also takes a trip
and it's a fascinating one.
(TIM) "At the turn of the
millennium,
Dublin Airport was bursting
at the seams.
The Dublin Airport Authority took
a decision to double capacity
and build Terminal 2 to handle
15 million passengers a year.
Not only was this the largest
construction project
in the history of the State,
but it had to be completed on a site
that was still functioning
as an airport -
the engineering equivalent
of open-heart surgery."
This building design faced
significant challenges.
One of the first systems that had
to be re-imagined
was the traffic layout
for the entire airport.
Usually you could move a building to
run a road through.
That was not an option for
the country's busiest airport!
(TIM) "Terminal 2 has many systems
engineered to do specific jobs,
and they work like the organs
of a body.
Whether electrical or plumbing,
200 interdependent systems run
the building."
Moving vast volumes of passengers
through Terminal 2 also requires
moving vast volumes of air
as efficiently as possible.
(TIM) "The public areas are designed
to accommodate
thousands of passengers every hour.
They stop at counters, they sit,
they eat, they stand around,
but nobody lives here.
This building is designed to keep
people moving."
And of course the problem of moving
people and passengers
around the 60,000 square meters
of Terminal 2
also needed clever engineering.
To make the best use of this
floor space.
(TIM) "I want to find out more about
the baggage system.
In a building this big, with so many
different check-in desks,
we all worry if our one bag is going
to get lost."
Moving millions of passengers
requires moving millions of pieces
of luggage and the solution
is a spectacular piece
of systems engineering.
I'm checking in to check out
just what happens to your bag.
Hello!
Hi! I want to check in one bag
please.
(TIM) "Luggage is directed from
check-in along a 6 kilometre network
of conveyor belts to collection
areas and then onto the aircraft.
Every item is bar-coded
and the system tracks
every piece individually,
calculating the most efficient route
to get each bag to its destination
on time.
Billy Ennis is bringing me
backstage to get a better view."
Well, Tim, all the bags come through
the central point from check-in.
They're going to come in through
the very centre
of the operation here, and turn left
onto this line.
When they come to this point,
the bags are scanned.
I think there's your bag there. Tim.
Yeah, that's mine.
So that bag is going to be actually
scanned and what happens now
is that it has to go through
the security process
and go into the X-ray machine there.
(TIM) "The bags go on a rip-roaring
journey, heading in all directions,
swerving up, down, left and right
at speed.
I wasn't surprised to learn that
the computer system
controlling all this, is the same
technology used on rollercoasters."
It can handle multiple sizes of bags
here.
You have out of gauge lines that
will handle the bags
that are too big to go in
our normal lines.
(TIM) "We're heading for the
automated sorter.
It's a busy motorway interchange
for luggage.
Each item has its own tray,
so the system knows its exact
position at any time.
Billy claims luggage won't get
lost."
Well, what we're looking at here
behind us is
what we call our tilt-tray sorter.
And it's the heart of the baggage
system.
This machine can handle up
to 4,000 bags an hour
when we're at our busiest period,
which is typically in our summer
period.
So when the bag is delivered onto
this sorter,
the bag is put on a tray.
The computer on the sorter then
takes over once that bag is read
by our scanning system
on the sorter.
And that's where the real
intelligence starts.
It tells that tray that that bag
is on, that's your bag.
It's now unique.
I know what flight it's going on.
I know what carousel and what
customer or airline
to deliver to downstairs.
This machine is a finely tuned piece
of apparatus that will deliver
your bags from check-in to the point
of collection by the operator
or the airline in less than
7 minutes on average,
which is pretty impressive.
(VO0 "In 1949, less than a decade
after it opened,
Dublin Airport Terminal was already
dealing with twice the number
of passengers that it was designed
for.
In its design, the building has
the shape and aura
of a majestic ocean liner.
There's no doubt that this building
evokes the excitement
and sophistication that has always
been associated
with international travel."
The sweeping curves and floating
balconies reinforce the theme
of dynamics in the building.
But it's in the detail and materials
that we really see the idea
of travel as glamorous and
luxurious.
The check-in counters were made of
walnut and sycamore.
And these staircases were lined
with travertine marble
with bronze balustrades
and topped off with these lovely
timber handrails.
(VO) "Everything about the building
here suggests quality.
The backroom offices were timber
panelled
but the public areas were really
designed to impress.
There were bars and restaurants
located here, and even a ballroom.
The airport became a go-to
destination for special nights out
and was a fashionable wedding venue
for Dublin's jet-setting socialites.
I met design historian Linda King to
find out more."
So we're here in the ballroom, Orla,
as you know,
which was meant to be a magnificent
space.
Apparently it had an amazing
sprung floor for dancing
and just down the corridor
you would have had the restaurant,
which was run by Johnny Oppermann.
One of the best examples of how
luxurious this was as a space
and as a destination.
If you look at the menu here
and just see...
This menu is from the late '50s,
early '60s.
It's very French, a lot of butter,
a lot a cream.
But there are dishes like
Sole Aer Lingus,
which is the same as Sole Bonne
Femme but with tomato and lobster.
Wow!
Which sounds interesting!
You know, if you wanted to really
impress somebody,
you brought them to the restaurant
at the airport.
So it's a very different concept
to what we would understand about
airports today.
The original design conceived of
more than just the bricks and mortar
of the building. Can you tell me
a little bit about that?
The building is an example of what
we call Gesamtkunstwerk,
which was this German word
that was in circulation
in the late 19th, early 20th
century,
used by a lot of the modern
movements.
It was about designing
a building,
but everything within the building,
doorknobs or furniture or whatever,
you actually thought about the whole
thing from the outset.
So Dublin Airport would be a really
good example of that.
As you've seen, there's some
magnificent details
with the staircases and the marble
and the use of brass.
And why was that important?
I think it's important with a lot
of the early infrastructural
projects of the Free State
that they were landmark buildings
designed to give a message
to the outside world about Irish
progress and modernisation.
And they were also a message to
the population as well,
as to Ireland's independence,
Ireland moving forward.
So in terms of cultural identity,
what do you think the intention
behind the building,
the language of the building
is trying to say?
It was speaking to an Ireland that
had yet to emerge,
creating an infrastructure
that would be more used by future
generations.
I mean, very few people were
travelling
up until the 1950s and 1960s.
So it was very much aspirational.
And it was very much about Ireland's
new place in the world
as a sovereign state.
When countries typically got
independence in the 20th century,
one the first thing they did was
found an airline
because it was such a symbol
of sovereignty
and it was a connection
with the outside world.
And the airports that supported
the aircraft
were very much part of that.
(VO) "For generations,
Dublin Airport has been
one of the most visited places
in the country.
Today, 32 million passengers
pass through it.
The original terminal building
still stands proud
in the middle of the airport,
engulfed by an enormous contemporary
complex.
And yet, its splendour still catches
the eye."
Dublin Airport became a symbol of
Ireland's confidence, independence
and modernity reflecting
the aspirations
of a developing island nation.
Iconic and beautiful in its form,
the terminal building helped build
an image of this nation
as fundamentally modern
and outward looking.
In the world of air travel,
the original Dublin Airport Terminal
Building helped put us on the map.
(VO "Next time on Building Ireland,
engineer Tim Joyce
is on Valentia Island."
The era of instant communication
had arrived
with the electric telegraph
and the rat-a-tat of Morse code.
(TIM) "Brian McManus is
investigating the science
of undersea cables
and Orla Murphy is exploring
the Valentia Telegraph Station."
In the middle of the 19th century,
it took two weeks for news
and information to cross
the wild Atlantic.
However on land the era of
instant communication had arrived
with the electric telegraph
and the rat tat tat of Morse code.
But you would have to cross
the oceans to wire up the world.
(TIM) "Everyone knew that connecting
Europe to North America
with a telegraph line would
transform both continents."
This island, Valentia, just off
the coast of Kerry was a hub
in the extraordinary scientific
and engineering effort to lay
the world's longest telegraph cable;
vital in creating a global economy
and in the story of
Building Ireland.
(VO) "In this series, our team of
experts in architecture, engineering
and geography is exploring the most
amazing stories of Ireland's
building and engineering heritage.
And this time, we've come
to discover how the first
transatlantic telegraph cable
got connected to Valentia.
The electric telegraph was the first
commercial application
of electricity.
The speed and convenience
of messaging changed everything
and a telecommunications industry
was born."
The wires of the electric telegraph
spread like ivy across
the continents.
The Victorian used terms like
"creating a network"
and a "web of communications",
inventing the language of electronic
communications we use today.
(VO) "Cities and countries
had telegraphic links
but linking continents was
the ultimate goal.
Engineer Brian McManus
is investigating
how they got messages across
the oceans."
Sending an electric current
underwater
is a difficult engineering
challenge.
But you can do it if you use
the right kind of cable.
Using the wrong one only leads
to failure
and disaster is a big part
of this story.
(VO) "With the technology up
and running,
a cable station complex
had to be built on Valentia.
Architect Orla Murphy is discovering
more about the buildings
and community that kept
the telegraph humming."
I'm here to explore how architecture
met the brief to accommodate
high-tech workers in one of the most
remote parts of Ireland.
(VO) "Before the arrival of
the telegraph,
electricity was just a novelty
party trick.
But scientists were intrigued
by the potential of this exciting
form of energy."
When scientists and engineers began
experimenting with electricity
at the beginning of the
19th century,
they had loads of ideas that opened
up new technologies.
Electricity was going to change
everything,
and it was going to change
communications
in the most profound way.
(Vo) "Samuel Morse and his practical
coding system helped drive
the expansion of the telegraph
to thousands of cities.
With undersea cables, Valentia would
become a globally significant hub.
Derek Cassidy is a marine telecoms
engineer
and telecoms heritage enthusiast.
He's keen to show me his latest find
as he goes to secure a late
Victorian undersea cable."
Actually here it is here.
I found it the other night.
It's a nice one.
Let's go down and have a look.
See what we see.
The cable development comes
from 1845.
Henry Bewley,
an actual Dublin chemist,
came up with the idea of extruding
gutta percha,
a type of natural rubber insulation,
over copper.
Gutta percha insulates copper
from water.
It's brilliant for sub-cables.
Because before that they had no real
way of making long lengths
of copper wire covered with
gutta percha.
That feat alone opened up
the world to sub-cables.
So the best thing for me to do
is get a piece here and I'll begin
to cut.
(VO) "Getting the right blend
of rubber-like gutta percha
as insulation and the right
protective covering
was no simple task.
If the cable was too heavy,
it would break,
and if it was too light,
it would float."
Right there you go. Through.
Are you ready?
Yeah.
Right, there you go.
There's the cable.
OK, why is it twisted?
It's twisted in such a way that
if it gets any damage
it'll actually tighten. If it's
turned it'll tighten.
Basically, you're allowed to
actually bend the cable.
So if it tightens it gets stronger.
It does yes. And the basic concept
of submarine cables hasn't changed.
They have the armouring,
the insulation and the core.
Very good.
(VO) "Plans for a transatlantic
cable were first hatched in 1854,
when an American entrepreneur
Cyrus Field
believed that the technology
was ready.
A recent survey of the Atlantic
Ocean's sea bed
gave him additional confidence.
The discovery of a natural plateau
or shelf on which
a prospective cable could be laid
meant that the most eastern part
of Newfoundland could link with
the extreme southwest of Ireland.
In July 1857, a cable-laying
expedition of ships
assembled in Valentia Bay and took
delivery of the 2,000 nautical miles
of cable needed for
the transatlantic project."
No ship could carry such
a weighty cable.
So half of it went on
the USS Niagara
and the rest on HMS Agamemnon.
(VO) "The Niagara set sail spooling
out its half of the cable,
and then in mid-Atlantic,
the Agamemnon's cable
would be spliced on and it would
complete the journey.
After just a few days,
the cable snapped
and disappeared into the deep."
A second expedition began
in June 1858.
This time, to speed things up,
the two ships began laying the cable
from the mid-Atlantic and headed off
in opposite directions.
Twice the cable broke
and twice they sailed back to pick
it up and start again.
But when the cable broke
the third time,
they had to head back to Ireland
for provisions.
(VO) "On the fourth attempt,
the cable was finally laid
on the 5th of August 1858.
American President James Buchanan
and Queen Victoria exchanged
telegraph messages and sparked talk
of a new era of world peace.
But then, 27 days later,
the transatlantic chatter fell
completely silent.
Engineer Brian McManus is going
to investigate what went wrong."
(BRIAN) "Getting the telegraph
working underwater
posed a particular set of problems,
because fundamentally electricity
and water are a bad combination.
Those first transatlantic signals
were weak and worsening by the day.
In an attempt to jolt the line into
operation, the voltage was pushed up
from 600 volts to 2,000 volts.
But the small copper wire core
couldn't cope."
Increasing the voltage simply
burnt out the 1858 cable,
but worse still, it showed that they
had an inadequate understanding
of the science of electricity
in seawater.
(BRIAN) "Electrical current weakens
over the length of a wire
because of resistance
and a cable stretching 3,500km
across the Atlantic had never been
attempted before.
Another issue was that salty
seawater got through
the insulating layer and weakened
the current.
And they couldn't understand why
the flow of electricity
seemed to slow down.
So sending a message through a cable
under the Atlantic
was hugely problematic.
The failure of the 1858 cable
was considered a huge scandal
and a Scientific Commission of
Public Enquiry was assembled
with some of the finest minds
of the era.
One of them,
Belfastman William Thomson,
who would later go on to become the
pioneering scientist Lord Kelvin,
questioned whether the cable needed
such a significant
electrical current for messages
to be accurately read."
Thomson confounded everyone
by saying that a big voltage
wasn't needed to send a signal
across the Atlantic.
Yes, he knew that the current would
diminish over the distance
but he had found a genius way of
detecting really small signals.
(BRIAN) "Thompson's radical solution
was based on adapting the prevailing
method of detecting electrical
current at the time,
the galvanometer.
I'm meeting retired marine
communications engineer Brian O'Daly
who can show me exactly
how it worked."
If we agitate a galvanometer with
a power source,
we can see the needle deflects
to one side.
But when the current amplification
was very very small,
you couldn't know whether there was
current flowing or not.
So, Thomson came up with the idea
that he would make,
not a galvanometer,
but a mirror galvanometer,
that he put a mirror into
an instrument like this,
instead of a needle.
And it turns very very slightly when
it is agitated by current.
Thomson's idea was,
he was fiddling with his monocle
and he saw that there was a
reflection on the walls
due to it catching sunlight,
as I would do so with the face
of my watch.
And when I shine the light in
we can see that it's reflected out
and it can be read on an external
surface.
And that could prove that there is
current flowing.
So a very simple solution really,
it's just like, the mirror,
a small deflection in the mirror
from the current
causes a large deflection over here.
That's right.
They needed something that would
amplify the signals
and this was the beginning
of something very very new.
(BRIAN) "The mirror galvanometer
was proven to detect signals
over 1,000 times fainter than
previously possible.
Its success allowed Cyrus Field
to raise money
for a new transatlantic cable
venture."
(TIM) "William Thomson also
recommended that the copper core
was tripled in size, with insulation
100 times more effective.
But it made the giant cable twice
as heavy.
There was only one ship afloat that
could carry such a massive cargo.
The world's biggest ship,
the Great Eastern,
was chartered for the challenge.
In July 1865, thousands gathered
at Foilhommerum Bay
in Valentia Island for the big
send-off."
There was a party atmosphere,
with singing and dancing
and a large gathering of the great
and the good, the local wealthy,
and probably a lot of the local
poor.
Of course, the cable was at the star
of the event.
From the great ship, it was hauled
by a hundred local men
across a pontoon bridge
of 22 local boats.
With the Irish end secured,
and with speeches and prayers
for a successful voyage,
the Great Eastern headed west into
the Atlantic
with its flotilla of support ships.
(TIM) "The cable was paid out
carefully and tested regularly.
Any faults were repaired on the
spot.
William Thomson was on board and
he refined the paying out mechanism
to prevent the cable snapping.
Then, two-thirds of the way across,
the cable broke
during a splicing operation
and disappeared into the water,
two miles deep.
The Great Eastern was forced
to return to Ireland."
It was yet another failure
for the transatlantic project.
But despite the disappointment,
Cyrus Field raised money for a third
attempt.
The potential profits for cable
companies was so great
that they were lining up to get
involved.
It would take a year to manufacture
the new cable,
and again the Great Eastern was made
ready.
(TIM) "In July 1866, once more,
the Great Eastern departed Valentia
and steamed out into Atlantic with
the giant cable filling its hull.
After two uneventful weeks,
it approached Newfoundland
and 50 men dragged the cable ashore,
including Cyrus Field himself.
A signal was sent and detected
by Thomson's mirror galvanometer.
On its first day of operations,
the transatlantic cable earned
a staggering £1,000.
The business boomed and
a transcontinental web
of communications was created -
an internet for the Victorian Age.
Valentia was one of those places
that really felt the impact.
Architect Orla Murphy is discovering
how the 19th century tech boom
changed the island."
By the 1870s, these once empty
fields were transformed
into a telecommunications hub
and a community.
Subtitles
(ORLA) Once the transatlantic
telegraph cable was operational,
it was clear that a new permanent
station would be needed on Valentia.
In fact, a whole campus would
have to be built for a new community
of up to 200 telegraph operators and
their families."
Despite the remoteness
of the island,
the cable station design wasn't
simply functional and utilitarian.
Instead this new community was to be
accommodated in comfort, elegance
and beauty around the shared
public space
of the gardens and tennis courts.
(VO) "Three separate blocks
of workspace and accommodation
were built.
In the northern block resided
the managerial staff.
These were homes with running water,
electricity
and rooms for domestic servants."
These houses, while quite
metropolitan in character,
also cater for the weather, with
these large glazed entrance porches
where you can take off your boots
and shelter against the wind.
They are sturdy, they're well built,
they're robust.
And they've stood the test of time
to be adaptable
and are still very much loved
on the island.
(VO) "I'm meeting one of
the residents, Gordon Graves,
who can boast a particular
connection to the first days
of the cable station and to the
early cable laying attempts."
Well my connection is from
three generations
to my great-great-grandfather
who came here in 1865 to supervise
the sending of messages
as the cable was being paid out
by the Great Eastern.
So he was operating from a little
wooden hut
on the top of the cliffs
at Foilhommerum
in the middle of nowhere.
And did your great-great-grandfather
then stay on when
the permanent station was set up
and the cable was up and running?
Yes. He stayed on and he was
appointed superintendent.
This was the first of his 44 years
here.
He always signed himself off
as Old Electric.
That was his nom de plume!
So then he persuaded his bosses
that they should build a proper
cable station nearer to more
social activities,
i.e. back at Knightstown,
instead of right out on the cliffs;
because all the operators had
to move backwards and forwards
all the time to Foilhommerum by
horse and cart.
So they knew that it would be
a much better permanent situation
to be located close to Knightstown?
Yes. All the facilities were there,
churches and schools and everything
for the families.
So it was much more compatible
family wise.
(VO) "The urban, cosmopolitan
architecture may seem incongruous
for rural Co. Kerry.
Yet, it is totally in keeping
with the high-tech work
and educated workforce."
Located at the centre of the complex
is the cable station itself.
(VO) Eventually technological
advancements would leave
the building behind and it was put
to other uses in the 1960s.
Michael Lyne worked here for over
40 years
and is showing me where the
"graphers" lived in the old days."
There was no electricity up here
since the cable station closed down.
OK, so this has been empty since
then?
It has been empty since then, yeah.
What was the average day of
a "grapher" like?
Well they worked three shifts here.
From 6 to 2 in the morning.
From 2 to 10, and then you had
the night shift,
started at ten o'clock until
six o'clock in the morning again.
So it would have been a hive
of activity
all the way through the day?
It would indeed, yeah.
I mean, if you were on the early
morning shift,
you were off at two o'clock and then
you had the evening to yourself.
And there was plenty of activity.
There were two nine hole golf
courses.
There were three tennis courts
out front.
They had cricket in a sports field
next door.
Everybody had a sailing boat
and lots of regattas, every week.
How do you think the station
affected the island?
I suppose it had a big influence
on the island
and economically as well
as everything else.
Their wages were supposed to be
equivalent
to that of a bank manager.
So you can imagine 200 bank managers
in Valentia.
Wow!
If you were walking down the village
and you met a local and a "grapher",
you would have no problem
identifying which was the "grapher".
He would be dressed in a suit with
a top hat and a waistcoat
with a gold watch and chain.
The local man then,
he'd be the guy without the shoes.
Or if he was lucky
a pair of hobnail boots maybe.
(VO) "The background chorus of Morse
code is long gone and the houses now
are in private ownership but there
are ambitious plans afoot
to convert the Cable Station into
a UNESCO World Heritage Site."
These buildings in their function
in their role, in their layout,
in their detailed design, have not
just left a mark on the island,
they've played a key role in what
Valentia is today.
(TIM) "Across the Atlantic in
Newfoundland,
the partner cable station for
Valentia is in a little coastal town
called Heart's Content. It too
closed in 1965 and is now a museum.
The Canadian and Irish governments
are working together to secure
UNESCO status as a transboundary
World Heritage Site to celebrate
the vital role of both
Heart's Content and Valentia
in the evolution of global
communications."
On this day, the 27th of July,
over 150 years ago,
a message from Newfoundland made
telecommunication history.
153 years ago, the very first
telegraph message was sent
on the very first commercial
transatlantic telegraph cable
which effectively opened up
communications across the world.
And today, along with Seán,
we are going to be talking
to Heart's Content over Morse code.
Welcome Ireland!
(APPLAUSE)
(RAT-TAT-TAT SOUND)
(TIM) "Seán's Morse message is being
carried via an electrical pulse
down a dedicated line on a sub-sea
cable -
exactly the same as the message
exchanged
with Heart's Content in 1866."
OK, what they said was:
"Our shore end has just been laid.
And a most perfect cable under God's
blessing has completed telegraphic
communication between
Heart's Content and Valentia."
(TIM) "This one simple message, on a
proven and reliable submarine cable,
ushered in a new age.
Within 15 years, there were 100,000
miles of undersea telegraph wires.
And countless telegraph stations
relaying messages,
now called "cables".
The benefits to business and
communication were obvious.
But increased international
cooperation had unforeseen benefits.
Units of electricity had to be
agreed upon,
like the watt, volt, ohm and ampere.
(TIM) "Telegraph technology
continued to develop and advance,
from manual Morse code messaging to
ticker tape, to automated readers,
to telephone and eventually radio
communications.
Societies and economies were
affected
at a most fundamental level."
This telegraph cable was a tiger
let loose in the business jungle.
Companies had to run with it or die.
The resultant stampede of
transatlantic messaging has driven
technological advances to this day.
(TIM) "I'm on my way to meet someone
who believes our communications
history and industry owes a debt of
gratitude to Valentia.
Leonard Hobbs is Trinity College
Director of Research and
Innovation."
When we look at what it was,
a telegraphic system,
how has that helped bring us
to where we are now?
What we now live with today
is instant communication.
There's 188 million emails sent
in a minute,
compared to when this cable
started in Valentia in 1866,
there was maybe four words could be
sent in a minute.
So it made the world a smaller
place.
But what also began here was
engineering,
electrical engineering
in particular.
So the world has been transformed
by communication,
by this kind of internet
connectivity technology
and it all began here on Valentia.
What are the impacts to Ireland
from the developments
that were made here on Valentia?
It was the start of Ireland's
technical journey really,
that today, you know, has led us to
the point where we've got
every multinational in the US
now has a place in Ireland.
And it all began again with I think
here,
when established a kind of a
confidence and a competence
in this new thing called engineering
and technology.
(TIM) "Today 99% of the world's
international data traffic
is carried not on satellites
but on 400 sub-sea cables
that span the world's great oceans."
The telegraph made the world
both faster and smaller,
and launched us on the trajectory
of the modern age
of digital communication.
The transatlantic telegraphic cable
was the wire that changed the world.
(TIM) "Next time on Building
Ireland, geographer Susan Hegarty
is on the Beara Peninsula looking
for copper.
The industrial archaeology
is everywhere.
(SUSAN) "Engineer Tim Joyce
is discovering the impact
of steam engines and geographer
Mary Greene
is investigating a mining boom
town."
This is the tip of
the Beara Peninsula.
It's a landscape that is stunningly
beautiful.
But its geography can make it
difficult to survive on.
In the middle of the 19th century,
the natural resources of this area
produced great wealth
and employment.
Not from the land, not from the sea,
but from the copper in those
mountains.
These hills once echoed with the
sound of heavy industry
which changed the community,
the landscape itself
and helped with Building Ireland.
(INSTRUMENTAL INTRO MUSIC)
(VO) "In this series, our team of
experts in architecture, engineering
and geography is exploring
the most amazing stories
of Ireland's building
and engineering heritage.
And in this episode,
we've come to rediscover
the Copper Mines of Beara."
Copper mining has a long history
in the area
but the boom came when new
technologies, capital and markets
brought a whole new industry.
(VO) "When the Industrial Revolution
thundered into remote West Cork,
it changed everything, and Engineer
Tim Joyce is investigating
the transformative technology."
Steam powered machinery dramatically
accelerated productivity.
There was a huge steam engine here
and this engine house
is one of the finest examples
left anywhere in the world.
(VO) "In the foothills of the
Caha Mountains,
heavy industry had a big impact
on the remote fishing village
of Allihies.
The story of this community is being
explored by Geographer Mary Greene."
It's difficult to imagine now,
but the prospect of work
brought thousands of miners here
from all over Munster.
This tiny rural village became
the new Wild West mining town
and brought stories of success,
struggle and strikes.
(VO) "The geology here is full of
tell-tale signs
of a mineral rich area.
These red sandstone mountains were
formed 400 million years ago,
when the area was covered by red
desert sands.
Later, after these hardened,
the rocks buckled
and folded under tectonic pressure.
Cracks were filled with mineral rich
fluids,
which in turn formed copper rich
quartz veins."
Copper mining has been going on for
around 4,500 years in Ireland
and some of the earlier workings are
found here on the Beara Peninsula.
And those early miners knew exactly
where to find the copper deposits.
(VO) "The Beara coastline is dotted
with stunning geological features
but the mark a copper miner needed
to look for was green.
Malachite is the characteristic
green for oxidised copper
and a sure sign that embedded within
the quartz deposit is chalcopyrite -
the copper bearing ore.
To extract the valuable chalcopyrite
you would have to dig deep
into the vein, often going below
sea level.
I'm heading down to meet
mining heritage expert Theo Dahlke.
He says it is easy to find
the copper.
I'm just having difficulty finding
him."
Hiya, Theo. I followed your
directions but it took me a while.
How are you doing?
Excellent, great to meet you.
You really found me here.
I did! It's a fabulous setting.
It's special and on a day like
this, it's just stunning.
So Theo, where are we now?
We sit at the foot of a nearly
50 metres high quartz vein.
This is actually the place where,
in 1812,
Berehaven mines was opened up
to reach the copper ore that they
were after.
I picked up a sample in there for
you and on this side,
we have it all, the white quartz,
and here the golden bits.
Oh wow!
This is the chalcopyrite.
Some say fool's gold for it,
or Peacock Ore,
because it has this shiny lovely
glimmer.
Within here you have the
speckles of green/greyish
that would be the malachite,
a staining from the copper ore.
The rain and the water transports
the copper and it builds
these green layers and the green
was always a sign for a miner.
The green was telling him that this
is where you can find some copper.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
Can we have a look inside?
You want to go with me inside?
I would love to have a look!
Jeez, you are brave!
Come on, I bring you.
Brilliant, fabulous!
(VO) "Cutting into the quartz vein
to extract the ore was done by hand
using picks, chisels and wedges.
They chased the streaks of colour
in the rock face
and advanced deeper and deeper
inside the vein."
Well this is absolutely incredible!
Look at all of this green staining.
Yeah, it's amazing yeah.
So it's almost like we're in
the heart of this vein
and it's just permeated through
with this ore.
Absolutely, this is the heart
of the vein.
And it goes on this side,
it goes on that side and it's deep,
maybe another 1,000 metres,
we really don't know.
It's absolutely incredible.
It really is like Aladdin's cave
in terms of colours.
It is, it really is.
It's a playground for geologists.
(VO) "The quartz deposits,
also known as lodes,
are hidden underground but in places
are revealed on the surface
of this valley.
In 1810 when the scale of the copper
ore deposit was first reported,
the local land agent John Lavallin
Puxley saw an opportunity.
The tiny fishing village of Allihies
was about to become the centre
of a mining boom
and Geographer Mary Greene
is discovering what happened."
The Puxley family were the local
gentry
who arrived in Ireland during
Cromwellian times.
The local community were poor,
Irish speaking Roman Catholic
subsistence farmers with little
if any education.
But with the arrival of copper
mining,
everything changed dramatically.
(VO) "Puxley's Berehaven Copper
Mines attracted hundreds of people
from all over Munster. There was
work for men, women and children.
At its peak the company had work
for 2,000 people,
with twice that number living off
the proceeds."
This town was quite literally built
on copper.
But there was nowhere to house
everyone.
Irish families shared accommodation
with instances of dozens of people
living in two-room cottages.
The pubs were packed and there was
a continuous scramble to get work.
(VO) "In 1835 the most valuable
import landing into Castletownbere
was 15,000 gallons of whiskey
and Allihies was awash with cheap
labour.
But whiskey wasn't the only
valuable import.
I'm chatting with Tadhg O'Sullivan
who runs
the local Copper Mine Museum to get
a better picture of what else
was arriving in Allihies to change
the village."
John Puxley was known as
Copper John.
He was the dominant character
on the Beara Peninsula.
He was the land agent.
He was all powerful,
but he was also what you might
describe nowadays
as an entrepreneur, he was
a chancer, he took risks.
Very early on John Puxley knew that
he had to bring in expertise.
He had to bring in people who knew
how to mine.
And he went to Cornwall where
the Cornish Mine Captains
had been mining copper and tin
for many years.
These were men who were bred to be
Mine Captains.
They were the men that he depended
on to make this show work,
to make it run as he wanted it to
run.
They decided on a Monday morning who
was going to work and who was not.
So that would have created divisions
on an everyday level?
Yes, there was constant strife,
as you might say.
There was always a division.
They had their own Mine Captains
houses.
They're still in Allihies,
they're still to be seen.
They were different to the hovels
that the Irish were living in.
There was a big difference.
There was a huge difference between
the Cornish
and the local population.
(VO) "At the southern tip of the
village, the old Methodist church,
built for Cornish miners and
their families
is still part of the mining story
in Allihies.
It's now the Mining Museum and holds
a fascinating piece of archive."
This is the cost book of
John Puxley's mining operation.
And it contains an exact record of
the profits and expenditures here
at the mines.
But these accounts contain a lot
more than just facts and figures.
They provide a window into the
cut-throat nature
of the mining economy here
in Allihies.
(VO) "There was no direct employment
here.
Miners worked essentially as
freelance contractors
paying the Mining Company a rental
for tools, gunpowder
and the transport of ore.
Even their shovels were weighed
for wear and tear.
Mine Captains auctioned jobs of work
or bargains as they were called.
Miners then bid for jobs.
There was good money for difficult
or dangerous bargains,
but less for something easier.
The lowest bids always won.
Historian Ciara NiíRiain has
researched the Irish workforce
in the Berehaven Mining Company."
In the 1850s there was peak
employment in the mines
but the working conditions
themselves were very detrimental
to the Irish, people were dying.
So for example there's eh,
old miners would refer
to timber props and how timber props
that were used in mines
were actually more valuable to
the mine owners
than the Irish miners themselves
because the Irish miners
were replaceable.
And so the Irish had enough.
And they decide in 1864 to strike.
How did the owners respond
to this new retaliation from
the Irish community?
At the time there was a decline
in the demand for copper
and so the mining owners didn't
necessarily need those miners
who went out on strike and so they
kept the Cornish employed.
And the Irish decided they would
rather seek opportunities abroad
than stay with the mines themselves.
What is the legacy of the Irish
mining community's experience here,
do you think?
Well, I think they came here and
they learned a valuable skill set
that they could then bring abroad
and also how to retaliate against
these unfair working conditions.
And we see later on in the 70s/80s
when they are working in the US
and in the mines over there we see
them going out quite frequently
on strikes as miners in the US
to fight for safe and fair working
conditions.
(VO) "There were five mines working
in the Allihies area,
each with a massive complex of sheds
and buildings.
This was one of the biggest mining
operations ever seen
in these islands."
Allihies is full of signs of mining.
Within 10 metres of where I'm
standing,
there are four mine shafts,
some of which are collapsed.
The industrial archaeology
is everywhere.
(NO) "The Berehaven Mining Company
created a landscape
of industrial buildings,
from stables to dressing floors
for rock breaking to forges
and kilns for metal work.
Gunpowder was stored in magazines
with internal blast walls
to prevent catastrophic explosions.
Huge reservoirs were constructed
high up in the mountains
and provided a continuous supply of
water for processing the ore
and for powering stamps that crushed
large rocks.
Extracting the ore from the
mine shafts
was just the start of the process."
Boys were employed in this task
of landing the ore,
and they toppled their buckets into
wooden carts
that ran on tramlines down
for sorting.
(VO) "The rock was brought in
wheelbarrows to long low sheds
where women and children sorted it
for crushing and washing.
I met up with Theo Dahlke again
to get an idea of how
this backbreaking world of work was
changing during the 19th century."
In the early beginnings, the
women got the lumps of ore out
from the mine, crushing it with
her hammer and the kids,
all the kids were sitting around
her, picking up through the rubble,
getting out the bits of usable
copper.
So this gives you an idea of
how important
child labour was at the time.
And we might think, it's awful,
it's awful
but they were contributing
to the surviving of the family.
The whole village would have changed
dramatically with the introduction
of steam engine and heavy machinery
that processed the ore.
For most of the families here,
it was a disaster
because all the women and children
they lost their jobs.
And this thing here what we found
you know,
it just came out of the rubble.
This iron kibble was travelling
up and down the mine shaft,
all day long.
Where it would be filled up with the
ore that the miners broke down below
with their borers and chisels
and hammers.
We just found it here as in
two weeks ago.
This might be the only one
in Ireland.
It's a piece of history then?
It's a big piece of history.
So Susan, everything was really,
really heavy.
There was heavy steel,
there were heavy machinery,
there were heavy carts to tow.
It would look like hell.
There was fire everywhere.
There was smoke everywhere.
And you would have noise,
unbelievable noises.
That was really the sound of the
industrial revolution.
(VO) "19th century technological
advances revolutionised
the mining operations in Allihies.
Engineer Tim Joyce is on a mission
to discover
the transformative power of steam."
(VO) "The rugged Beara landscape
presented a formidable challenge to
any industry attempting to exploit
a natural resource,
especially mining."
The Cornish Mine Captains
of 19th century Allihies,
like engineers today, didn't get
to choose where they went.
Sinking a mine shaft this close to
the sea with its vast volume
of water was a risk.
The last thing you want to do
is go below sea level.
(VO) "Underground water and its
potential for flooding
has always been a danger in mining.
Thomas Newcomen's early steam
engines had become highly advanced
by the 1780s, making for a powerful
technology.
High-pressure steam in a cylinder
pushes a piston up,
moving a solid iron beam supported
on the thick walls
of the engine house.
This see-saw motion drives a set of
suction pumps
that reach deep down into the mine."
The Newcomen Steam Engine was
at the cutting edge
of industrial coal-fired technology
when John Puxley
made his business plan to advance
his mining operations.
These machines totally changed the
scale of production at Allihies.
And more copper meant more wealth.
(VO) "As more mineshafts were sunk
and as profits rose,
the Berehaven Copper Mines were
reported
in international mining journals.
Speculative investors got involved.
All year round, barges left
West Cork,
laden with copper ore for the
smelters in Swansea.
Those barges returned to
Ballydonegan Bay
bringing coal to fuel
the engine houses.
I'm with Brendan Morris,
a former Mine Manager who has a keen
interest in mining heritage
and the revolutionary impact
of steam technology."
During the industrial Revolution
copper was king.
And everybody wanted copper.
The UK needed copper,
the world needed copper.
So steam allowed them to de-water
the mines and it allowed the owners
of the mines to extract the ore
in an economically viable manner.
Because prior to this, some of these
mine weren't viable.
So they could now mine down at much
deeper levels.
What that did for them was it gave
them access to more working faces;
more working faces meant higher
productivity.
It also allowed them reduce the
costs of shipping by doing some
of the crushing underground and some
of the crushing on the surface,
to minimize the amount of rock
that actually travelled from here
to Swansea, and optimise what went
onto the ships.
So, the advent of the steam engine
allowed them to get production and
productivity to a level here where
the owners could make serious money.
(V)) "The biggest, deepest, and most
productive of all ventures
in Allihies was Mountain Mine.
It was central to the operations and
success of Berehaven Copper Mines."
Around 1856, this Mountain Mine
reached down
320 metres underground - 1,000 foot.
Puxley calculated it took a man
10 seconds to climb down one metre
by ladder and far longer to come up.
As far as he was concerned, this was
a huge waste of valuable time.
(VO) "Puxley's solution was a
Cornish invention, The Man Engine,
which was installed in a purpose
built shaft
at the mountain mine in 1862.
Hundreds of miners could be
transported hundreds of metres
but the real genius of the system
was that it could move men up
and down at the same time.
And yet each movement was only
12 feet with miners
stepping on and off as you would
with an escalator.
This Man Engine House is the finest
surviving example in the world."
(When was this mine opened?)
(VO) "There's only one way to really
understand
what this deep vein mining was like
in the middle of the 19th century.
I've been given special permission
to go underground
and University College Cork
geologist Bettie Higgs
is coming with me."
And this was one of the original
adits.
(V) "Adits, or horizontal passages,
burrow in towards the vertical
shafts,
allowing access for men, machinery
and animals."
Oh wow!
When you shine the light down, you
can see how deep these shafts go.
And the ladder there is looking very
ghostly
but that is how the miners
went down to other adits,
following the seam around. They had
to think in three dimensions.
(VO) "The workings at Mountain
Mine are a vast subterranean network
of adits, shafts, caverns
and chambers
that plunge 280 metres below
sea level, at its deepest point.
Vast quantities of rock were blasted
and removed
from inside this mountain
by hundreds of miners.
The majority of the mine is now
flooded but I'm hoping to see
what they were after,
and what they've left behind."
There's a particularly nice piece
here.
As you walk past,
look at the amazing colours of the
copper ore here.
This is one of the original
19th century adits.
So you can imagine the miners
crouching down.
So it was claustrophobic,
it was dark.
But these adits helped the miners to
get along to the main quartz seam.
Well, Bettie, what was this space?
Well this is a large cavern.
A horse would have been walking
around here driving a windlass,
which was winching material from
lower levels up to the surface.
So the ore could be brought up. It
was the beginning of mechanisation.
These horses would need looking
after though?
These horses needed looking after,
so there would be blacksmiths,
there would be tools needing
sharpening.
It was essentially a
whole subterranean world here,
practically 24 hours a day.
Amazing. It's absolutely amazing.
Bettie, what are we looking at at
this point?
The importance of this part of
the mine cannot be overestimated.
The fact that these levels and
ladders are still in place,
we can see how the miners had to
climb up, go across the platforms,
blasting above their heads,
climb up other ladders.
And with men standing below you
and you're trying to blast roof
material out, what we call stoping;
taking away more of the roof, more
of the roof, working off the ladder,
bringing the material down to this
rock level,
carting it away and then going back
up.
Again, gunpowder blasting;
extremely dangerous work.
And this stope is almost unique
in the way it is preserved,
and heading up almost to the surface
of the mountain mine.
Amazing.
(VO) "The average life expectancy of
a miner in Allihies was 32 years."
Here we are with the rock pillars.
It's amazing. Oh wow!
Wow. Yes.
It's amazing.
So here we are, Susan.
We've come to the largest cavern
in the Mountain Mine.
We are 50 metres below the surface.
So Mountain Mine was the most
productive
of all the mines around here.
And the intersection of the faults
and fractures caused perhaps
more mineralisation here than it did
in some of the other mines.
But you can imagine just working
away, in the darkness.
And at its peak there would have
been 1,500 or more miners, in teams,
bringing the ore in and out.
It's wonderful for geologists to
come in and learn more about
what happened in that century
but it's a fantastic resource
for future geologists, engineers,
social scientists,
to be able to come in here and learn
and understand
how the miners went about this.
(VO) "When the copper mines started
to close in the 1870s,
the majority of the population
in Allihies emigrated.
During the 70 years they operated in
19th century,
the Berehaven Copper Mines were the
biggest mining operation in Ireland.
Small-scale farmers and agricultural
labourers became industrial workers
in the harshest of conditions."
Geological good fortune is key
to the story of mining in Allihies.
New ideas and new machines developed
in the pursuit of profit
brought the industrial revolution
to this remote part of West Cork.
And the industrial legacy ingrained
in its community
is now being explored by new waves
of visitors.
(VO) "Next time on Building Ireland,
Engineer Tim Joyce is discovering
what's inside a Wicklow mountain."
It's one of the most magnificent
feats of Irish engineering,
fuelled by the power of Wicklow
waters.
(VO) "Susan Hegarty is exploring
the landscape,
while Engineer Brian McManus
is investigating
pumped storage power generation."
Lake Nahanagan - way up in
the Wicklow Mountains.
That's Gaelic for
"Lake of the River Monster".
And today, it does hold immense
power.
600 metres deep inside this
granite mountain
is a hydroelectric generating
station fuelled
by the power of Wicklow waters.
It is one of the most magnificent
feats of Irish engineering.
Built in the 1960s, this entirely
manmade complex
can unleash over 290 million Watts
of power
into the National Grid in seconds.
It's a crucial piece of national
infrastructure
and vital to the story
of Building Ireland.
(VO) "In this series, our team of
experts in architecture, engineering
and geography is exploring
the most amazing stories
of Ireland's building
and engineering heritage.
And this time, we've come to
discover
the Power of Turlough Hill.
Hidden away inside this mountain
at the end of a half kilometre long
tunnel,
is Ireland's only pumped
hydro station.
Four massive turbines sit in a huge
chamber carved out of Wicklow rock.
They're driven by the force of
millions of tonnes of water
that surge down from a colossal
man-made reservoir.
And because of brilliant Irish
engineering, with one gearshift,
these turbines go into reverse and
pump water from Lough Nahanagan
back up the mountain, to generate
electricity again.
Geographer Susan Hegarty is going
to explore what's special
about this area and why the
landscape has the perfect features
needed for the power station
project."
Mountain waters have sustained human
activity in harsh and rugged terrain
for thousands of years but I want to
explore how granite and glaciation
are key to understanding the power
and beauty of this landscape.
(VO) "Engineer Brian McManus is
going to discover more about
the technology and engineering that
make this scheme possible."
I want to explore the
electro-mechanical systems
in this subterranean cavern and
understand how this complex plays
a vital role in meeting and managing
the country's electricity demands.
(VO) "Building the Turlough Hill
power station
was the biggest Irish civil
engineering project of the time.
It was the 1960s, and ESB engineers
had to come up with a plan to meet
Ireland's growing industrial and
consumer demands for electricity.
The idea to harness the power of
a natural resource wasn't new
but what they proposed was
visionary.
By reusing the raw energy
of millions of tonnes of water,
they could deliver hundreds of
megawatts of electrical power
to hundreds of thousands of homes
just in time for peak demand
at tea time.
And then put the water back at
low demand times,
an economic bargain.
This tunnel was the first thing
constructed and they had to bore
into the hard granite rock to get
inside the mountain."
Wicklow granite is particularly
hard.
Cutting a tunnel into the heart of
this mountain was a painstaking
process of drilling bores, packing
in explosives and blasting the rock.
(VO) "The access tunnel needed to be
big enough to deliver
the heavy equipment that would be
buried inside this mountain.
With the tunnel complete, hundreds
of thousands of tonnes of granite
were excavated to create the Cavern
Chamber.
After 40 years in engineering,
it's a great privilege for me to
finally get to step inside.
This cathedral size space lies
at the heart of the complex
and descends through three main
operational levels
below this turbine hall floor."
The Cavern would have to hold
four turbines, their generators,
transformers and switchgear and
cranes, all on different levels.
It's ten stories tall. That's a
stack of seven double-decker buses.
(VO) "This was a complex project
that required the skills of civil,
mechanical and electrical engineers.
Different teams of engineers
co-ordinated work on 10 separate
aspects of the project - all working
to a central design.
They had to be precise, accurate and
synchronized for the plan to work.
350 workers lived on site in
temporary accommodation,
working above and below ground.
In all, 500 workers were involved
during the six years of construction
until it went into operation
in 1974.
Water holds the key to this site
and geographer Susan Hegarty
is uncovering the geological story
of this landscape
and how human activity has harnessed
the power of a glaciated valley."
(SUSAN VO) "420 million years ago,
colliding continental plates
and cooling magma formed the granite
rock of the Wicklow Mountains -
part of the largest mass of granite
in Northwestern Europe.
Much later, the Glendasan Valley
was carved out through the slow
but powerful force of a massive
glacier.
The sheltered and fertile landscape
it left behind
attracted the early settlers,
including St Kevin,
who founded the world famous
Glendalough Monastery.
In geological terms, this landscape
was also mineral rich
so the remote location of the valley
didn't deter industrial scale
mining.
Copper, silver, lead and zinc were
mined across Wicklow,
over hundreds of years, right into
the middle of the 20th century."
This site is known as the
Miners Village
and it is just one of many lead
and silver ore processing sites
that dot these mountains.
This is part of the Glendalough
Mines
and here on this dressing floor,
rock was crushed and transported
down the valley.
A process all powered by water.
(VO) "Stamping mills and crushing
rollers were all powered
by Wicklow waters flowing down the
valley,
through the narrow gorges of
the upper range.
Gravel deposits appear as natural
features
but are actually mine tailings and
waste materials from old mine works.
When searching out and surveying
the landscape,
ESB engineers were looking for a
site with the right features
for a modern, pumped hydro
power station.
And where they were going to bury it
was critical."
The most common type of bedrock
in Ireland is limestone
which is soft and easy to cut and
shape.
Granite on the other hand,
like most of the igneous rocks,
is hard and crucially
it's relatively impermeable.
Robbie, how are you going?
Susan, how are you?
(VO) "I'm meeting geologist Robbie
Meehan who knows how Ireland's
last ice age helped determine
the location of the Turlough Hill
project."
What we have is, we have this deep
armchair shaped depression
and that's a result of the ice
gauging out the bowl
that the lower lake sits in.
And it gave a natural landscape
within which you could actually
construct a pumped hydro scheme.
That back wall of the cliff there is
a couple of hundreds of metres high.
So you are looking at something
that looks like it's man-made
but it's natural.
This huge big corrie that the lake
sits in
was the birthplace of the
glacial system.
It is the area within which the ice
starts to flow out
over the landscape. And it would
have covered everything.
So the tops of the mountains were
planed, they were ground down.
They've been almost bulldozed
by the ice.
So the power of that ice is quite
incredible.
And what's unique about Lough
Nahanagan is that during the
construction of the pumped hydro
scheme, the lower lake was drained.
And there were sediments there,
layers there,
that had organic remains in them
that could be dated by scientists
to 11,500 years ago.
And that was the first time that we
had a dated layer
in the Irish landscape to that time.
And that was the last time ice was
ever on this island?
That was. The ice died off at that
time, and the climate warmed,
and the climate started to get quite
wet.
So what we've got here then is this
bog forming.
It's called blanket bog.
It envelopes and covers completely
all of the terrain underneath it.
As the vegetative remains don't
fully decompose,
they become compressed.
What that means is that over time,
peat can form.
The peat grows at a rate of, on
average, about a millimetre a year.
So if we go back down here to the
base of the peat sequence,
about a metre down, we're probably
going back about a thousand years.
And Ireland is kind of unique.
Over 10% of the country
is blanket peat.
And Ireland as well has about 8% of
the blanket peat resource
of the entire world.
And because the peat itself is a
record of past environments,
it's a really important resource.
(TIM VO) "To get water from the
reservoir on top of the mountain
to the chamber 300m below,
the tunnellers faced into the hard
Wicklow mountain once again.
This time a "pressure shaft"
was cut.
I've been given access into
the very first test tunnels sunk
into Turlough Hill so I can get an
idea of how the ESB engineers
tackled this job from both ends."
They bored 50 metre straight down
from the upper reservoir
and from below, they drilled and
blasted over half a kilometre
at an angle of 28 degrees to form
a shaft for the water.
(VO) "Excavating the raw rock, the
drilling teams tunnelled towards
each other to cut a vital artery
into the centre of the mountain.
Once the teams broke through and
connected,
they set about lining the entire
bore with steel."
The steel tube sections were
assembled on site
and carefully lowered into the
shaft.
They used a really clever rail
system to angle them
into position, section upon section.
(VO) "The rails carried the weight
of each 10m long section
and allowed for slow and careful
positioning
with millimetre accuracy.
60 steel tubes were positioned
in this way.
Welding and painting had to be
completed with the great care.
The tube would have to be ready for
the enormous force of the waters
cascading through it, so X-ray scans
were used to check the seals.
The space around the pipe was then
encased in concrete.
The pressure shaft narrows from
a diameter of 5 metres,
like this test tunnel, to 3.4
metre as it nears the turbines.
This ramps up the power of the flow,
to drive the four turbines embedded
at the bottom of the cavern."
The entire cavern is below the water
level of Lough Nahanagan.
It's a vitally important design
feature.
(VO) "It means that the turbines in
the cavern are always primed;
water pressure is constantly bearing
down on the system,
so it is never empty.
The turbines can be put into reverse
in a matter of seconds
and start pumping water back up
the mountain,
ready to start the cycle
all over again.
Curiously, before the power station
was built,
the mountain here didn't have a name
on the Ordnance Survey Map.
The engineer who recommended
the site, John O'Riordan,
decided to name the hill after his
son, Turlough.
It was a good choice.
A turlough is a lake that loses
water through a swallow hole.
Just like this lake but everything
here is man-made.
Engineer Brian McManus is
investigating how the water pressure
is harnessed with mechanical and
electrical engineering."
These valves are designed to
intercept in full flow
the torrent of water surging through
the system.
Robust engineering and clever design
underpin every moving part
in this complex.
(BRIAN) "Deep inside Turlough Hill
are the electro-mechanical systems
at the heart of this pumped-storage
generating station.
It's all located in a multi-storey
complex in the underground cavern.
I'm right down at the bottom of the
chamber.
This is where the waters surge down
from the upper reservoir
and into the inlet pipes that drive
the four giant turbines."
Each turbine has its own spherical
valve 1.7 metres in diameter
which has to absorb the 500 tonnes
of water
bearing down on it every minute.
There is no margin for error
in the engineering required to
control this flow.
(VO) "The high pressure flow of
water provides the energy
that then gets converted into
electrical power.
And this is where big engineering
kicks in.
The moving water pushes a turbine
that spins a shaft
that turns the electrical generator.
And the entire system can also be
put into reverse,
to pump water back up the mountain.
Above the turbines are the shafts
that connect
to the electrical generators
on the level above."
This shaft is now helping to pump
water uphill.
You can really feel the power.
The ground is literally shaking.
Whether it's helping to pump water
uphill or generating electricity,
it always rotates at 500rpm.
(VO) "With underground space at a
premium,
mounting everything vertically makes
for a very compact design.
The size of the cavern was
determined solely by the space
needed for these mighty machines."
Here on the top floor of the
Generating Hall we can see the apex
of the reverse pump turbine which is
assembled vertically below.
Each one consists of a turbine,
connected to this generator
by a shaft with what's called a pony
motor on top.
At the heart of each one
is a stator, a static part,
and a rotor, a spinning part.
(VO) "When the system here was being
assembled, you could see
the essential elements of
electricity generation.
The stator is made up of a ring of
wire coils.
Into that is lowered a spinning
part, the rotor,
which is made up of a ring
of magnets.
The interaction of the wire coils
in a magnetic field
produces a flow of electricity.
Turlough Hill power station can only
stay operating
for four and a half hours.
The flow of water powering the
generators stops
when the upper reservoir has been
emptied.
For every three units of electricity
generated on the way down,
Turlough Hill uses four units
to pump water back up.
To understand how this can still be
an efficient use of electricity,
I'm meeting Martin Stronge,
Hydro Stations Manager for ESB."
So, Martin, we're in the control
room here of Turlough Hill.
Can you tell me a bit about what
these screens mean
and what this room actually does?
Okay, Brian, this is not just the
control room for Turlough Hill,
it's the control room for all the
ESB hydro stations.
And you can see on this screen the
breakdown of the different types
of generation that are available
on the system.
You can see in the green,
41% of the system at the moment
is made up of renewables,
which is wind and ESB's hydro
stations.
Turlough Hill is a really,
really unique facility.
When there is a surplus of
generation on the system,
a lot of wind blowing across the
island,
it takes all of that wind
generation, it pumps the water up,
up the hill into the upper
reservoir.
And then later on when the wind has
fallen away,
it can then use all of
that water to generate again.
So the red line on the top here is
the demand
and the blue line is wind
generation.
What you can actually see is that as
the as the demand was rising,
the wind generation was falling away
and Turlough Hill would have been
called on then to meet some of the
gap there.
An its speed allows it to deliver
292 megawatts,
which is enough power for 300,000
homes.
It can deliver that in 70 seconds.
It's much faster than thermal
generation, which is, by and large,
what you have elsewhere in the
country.
So can you tell me what the role
of Turlough Hill
will look like in the future?
As we move into more and more
renewables on the system,
there will be more and more
intermittency where generation
is going up and down as the wind
changes across the day.
And Turlough Hill's speed allows us
to get the most out of
the renewable generation that's
available to us.
(TIM VO) "When searching for a site
for a pumped storage power station,
the ESB engineers knew exactly what
was needed -
a mountain with a deep natural
corrie lake at its base,
close to Ireland's biggest city."
For this mountain site to work as
pumped hydro scheme,
its natural features would require
structures of such scale
that the project team would have
to engineer the landscape itself.
(VO) "The first challenge was to
construct
one of the highest roads in Ireland.
It would have to snake up 3
kilometres through the blanket bog.
To ensure pristine views of the
surrounding landscape,
the initial stretch of high voltage
transmission cable
was buried underground.
Heather was carefully extracted and
stored, and a million tonnes of peat
removed to expose the mountain's
granite peak.
Making the upper reservoir was a
monumental task.
The granite peak was blasted flat
and the rock was used to build up
the bowl shaped reservoir's edge.
An asphalt factory was also built on
site to produce a waterproof
membrane for the inner lining
of the reservoir.
The first time the technique was
used in Ireland."
It took 2 million tonnes of
quarried granite
to make this rock-filled embankment.
It is 1.5 kilometres long
and 34 metres high.
It was designed and engineered for
one purpose:
to hold 2.3 million tonnes of water.
That's an immense weight with
immense power.
(VO) "The reservoir simply stores
potential energy.
It's ready to be released when the
engineers below
decide to fire up the generators.
Holding up water like this, is still
the best way we know to store power.
I'm heading for an artificial island
in an artificial lake
to see how that energy is released."
This is the central control tower.
It has one of the most important
functions.
Directing the flow of
this vast body of water.
It's effectively a giant tap.
(VO) "The control tower sits above
the plug hole
at the bottom of the reservoir.
This is where the stopper opens and
closes
to control the flow of water
into the pressure shaft.
Storing and releasing such vast
volumes of water
would put pressure on any system.
Michael Bruen is a fellow
engineering hydrologist
and we met up to discuss the forces
at work when you've got
2.3 million cubic metres of water
sitting on top of a mountain."
So 300 meters up, down there what
kind of pressure will it give you?
Every 10 meters of water
is equivalent
to the pressure of one atmosphere.
So, this is about 300m above
so that means that you have
the pressure of 30 atmospheres.
Plus this atmosphere here.
Plus the one that's above us, so 31.
And one way to visualize it...
Everybody has seen films about
submarines,
particularly some of the war films,.
Well the First World War submarines
would have been crushed
by the pressure at the bottom of
this pipeline.
They could go as deep as 100 meters.
Even with all the improvements
between the wars,
most of the Second World War
submarines could go to 200 meters.
They would be crushed at the bottom
of this pipeline at the turbine.
So the pressure is immense.
And part of the genius of this
design,
by building it inside a mountain is
that the granite of the mountain
is helping the pipeline contain
the pressure,
because this water is trying to
escape.
(VO) "Any leakage here could be
disastrous but this reservoir
has a special inbuilt drainage
gallery, or tunnel,
for regular inspections."
This underground drainage gallery
circles the entire reservoir
along the inner slope of the
embankment.
It collects seepage from
the concrete-asphalt lining.
(VO) "Anyone who works with water
knows
there is no such thing as 100%
waterproof."
Under the immense water pressure
bearing down on the embankment,
seepage is constantly monitored.
Incredibly almost 50 years since
its construction,
seepage is only a quarter litre per
second.
Testament to the design, civil works
and labour that constructed
this reservoir.
(VO) "This project is one of the
great feats of Irish engineering,
but it is effectively hidden away,
buried deep within this Wicklow
mountain, unseen and unheard."
This power station is an integral
part of Ireland's
modern sustainable transmission
system.
You might think this is the
future of electricity generation,
but Turlough Hill has been up
and at it since 1974.
(VO) "Next time on Building Ireland,
geographer Susan Hegarty
is investigating the secrets behind
planning Ireland's
first new town in 300 years."
Constructing a new town at Shannon
to service global industry
was a turning point in rural
development.
(VO) "Architect Orla Murphy explores
the radical 1960s housing
that was built.
And geographer Mary Greene discovers
how the first pioneering settlers
built a community."
In the bleak 1950s, amid economic
stagnation and emigration,
they started building factories
and a brand new town
on the northern marshy bank of the
Shannon Estuary.
It seemed like a crazy scheme -
Project X -
an urban development in rural
County Clare,
and the world's first air-age
industrial estate.
And it was an idea that didn't stop
there.
(SUSAN VO) "International industries
arrived and created work.
This led to an economic development
model
that helped change the global
economy."
Constructing a new town at Shannon
to service global industry
was a turning point in rural
development and in Building Ireland.
(SUSAN VO) "In this series, our team
of experts in architecture,
engineering and geography examines
some of the amazing stories
of Ireland's building and
engineering heritage.
And this time, we've come to
discover
the origin of Shannon Newtown."
In a little under 10 years, this
landscape was totally transformed.
And that's really interesting for me
as a geographer.
Shannon Newtown was built on
a radical vision...
..for economic development using
the latest ideas in town planning.
(VO) "This was a project full of
ambition;
factories, offices, shops, homes
and schools
were built on a green field site.
There were even plans for futuristic
office blocks.
Shannon was a model for rapid
development
and the idea would reverberate
all around the world,
and it transformed the lives
of millions, especially in China.
Shannon was Ireland's first new town
in 300 years and architect
Orla Murphy is investigating what
exactly was built."
The first housing development here
didn't just have to build homes
for Shannon's new workers.
It had to lure them here.
Drumgeely Hill was a bold statement
of intent that this town was going
to be different and fundamentally
modern for 1960s rural Ireland.
(SUSAN VO) "How a community of
pioneering settlers took root here
is being explored by geographer
Mary Greene."
Flash economics and fancy new flats
are all very well but how do you
build community in a town where
everybody is from somewhere else?
(SUSAN VO) "Shannon Airport
was a beacon of modernity
in a depressed west of Ireland.
With the arrival of the jet engine
in the 1950s,
the activity and jobs here were
suddenly under threat.
If planes didn't have to stop-off to
refuel, maybe the jetliners
could be encouraged to stop-off for
other reasons.
That was the idea of the catering
manager at the airport,
Brendan O'Regan; a man with a vision
to transform Shannon."
On a research trip to America by
boat, another idea occurred to him.
If ships could have duty free,
why couldn't planes?
Shannon Airport became the first
airport in the world
to have a duty free shop. And that
inspired an even bigger idea.
(SUSAN VO) "O'Regan wanted to do for
industry
what duty free had done for
shopping.
He envisioned a special
manufacturing zone
attached to the airport where
international companies could make
and export their goods -
all tax free.
With political backing, the Shannon
Free Airport Development Company
was established in 1959 and was soon
offering hundreds of jobs.
And the new workers were promised
housing."
The very first factories that came,
there were eight companies that set
up here initially.
(SUSAN VO) "I'm meeting Olive Carey
to learn about the first wave
of residents who put down roots
here."
Some were from the surrounding
areas, of course,
but a lot of them were returned
immigrants from England,
in particular.
People who had emigrated in the
1950s looking for work saw
the opportunity presented here
at Shannon, jobs and houses,
and my own family being one of those
who came back in the very early
1960s.
And what was it like growing up in
this area then?
I loved my time here in Shannon
growing up.
First of all, there was great
freedom.
So coming to Shannon was
just open countryside.
Our playmates were the children of
the industrialists
who came here first.
So my schoolmates were Dutch
children, American,
English, South African.
It was a very cosmopolitan group
of people who were the pioneers
who came to live in Shannon
in the beginning.
And were people taking a risk
to come back here?
They certainly were, especially in
the early days,
because this was an experiment
really.
It wasn't known if it was going
to succeed or not.
But they were willing to take
the chance.
(SUSAN VO) "By 1961, the Rippen
Piano Factory, Sony
and diamond company De Beers had all
moved into Shannon's new factories.
463 workers were employed in the
trade zone,
with plans for many more.
Housing these workers was a priority
for the development company;
attractive, modern accommodation
suitable for families
and single people was needed.
Orla is discovering what was built,
and why."
It was the 1960s, international
architecture was modern, functional,
minimal, influenced by the likes of
Le Corbusier and Mies Van Der Rohe.
Multi-storey apartment living was
simple in form and function.
It was a new type of housing that
could be constructed quickly
and cheaply.
(ORLA VO) "Large scale construction
in concrete was all the rage
at the time, in an architectural
style that was called Brutalism.
Some said the apartments built here
were like workers' housing
from the Soviet bloc.
It was certainly an unusual
development in Ireland.
and it was unprecedented in a rural
context."
In the 1960s there were still houses
in County Clare
without electricity
or running water.
Stepping into one of the new homes
here in Drumgeely Hill
was like stepping into another
world.
One that was warmer, drier,
more convenient, more elegant.
One that was ultra-modern.
(ORLA VO) "The new residents of
Shannon had to learn the features
of apartment living, sharing
conveniences like laundry rooms
and rubbish chutes.
The one-bedroomed apartments were
dubbed 'bachelor flats'
and families were enticed here with
the latest in mod-cons."
You know, it's hard to imagine it
now,
but when these flats were built
they were the height of modernity.
So much so that the ESB even made
their own handbook for tenants
to advise them how to use the new
technology in their apartment.
It's called Welcome to your
All-Electric Flat.
And it details how tenants can use
the infra-red heating
in their bathroom.
How they are advised to de-frost
their refrigerator regularly.
The flats have lovely timber parquet
floors
and they have electric underfloor
heating and tenants were advised
to only switch them on in October
and then switch them off again at
the end of April.
So it is wonderful to see how
tenants were advised
how to use this new technology.
(ORLA VO) "The apartments had
built-in wardrobes
and fitted kitchens.
Every block had a mixture of one,
two and three bedroomed apartments.
All of the accommodation was
subsidised
and only available to those working
on the industrial estate.
The housing for this new workforce
was managed by Shannon Development's
Cian O'Carroll."
Why did they decide to build
multi-storey housing
here on Drumgeely Hill?
It was simply because a very quick
solution had to be found
to the housing problem.
A number of the early industries
here felt that they couldn't succeed
unless people came to live within
walking distance
of their place of employment,
particularly as many
of these companies operated
on a 24-hour shift basis.
And they came to us in Shannon
Development who had of course
sponsored the industrial estate,
and said, look,
their industries would fail unless
this kind of accommodation
was provided, and this was the only
piece of land readily available
at that time.
And it was very attractive from the
point of view
that it commanded beautiful views
of the estuary.
Private enterprise wouldn't have
been a viable option.
So we developed Shannon because
really there was nobody else there
available, and we had the ability
and the drive to get things done.
This was architecture as an
expression of the brave new world.
One where calling into your
neighbour for a drop of milk
for your tea, would bring you out
into a walkway in the sky
with a magnificent view out over
the Shannon. It was a nice idea.
(SUSAN VO) "As the industrial estate
expanded,
so too did plans for a whole new
town.
Building a town from scratch was not
at all unusual
in an international context
at the time.
Urban planning was actually a
thriving new international practice,
fuelled by the need to rebuild
after the devastation of the Second
World War.
Plans for Shannon's new town were
shrouded in mystery
because of its enigmatic code name:
Project X.
Fergal McCabe is one of Ireland's
foremost experts in town planning
and is familiar with the Shannon
Town project.
He knows why it was called
Project X."
It was a secret. Brendan O'Regan's
vision was for a new town
and there was a lot of local
opposition.
People naturally wanted the housing
to be in Newmarket-on-Fergus
or Clarecastle. But O'Regan wanted
a new plan for Shannon.
So he worked with the architect
and town planner Frank Gibney,
and it was kept firmly under wraps
and known only as Project X.
And what was unique about that
particular plan?
Well it differed from the Shannon of
today in the sense
that it was inspired by the Shannon
itself.
The whole centre was to be on the
banks of the river facing south,
taking in the whole history,
the romance of the Shannon,
and then build backwards
to the airport,
unlike the plan that got
implemented,
which was starting in the airport
and working back to the river.
What was the thinking in town
planning at that time
that influenced this layout?
Certainly the dominance of the car
is a consideration. It was a grid.
It was a rectangular grid laid
on the landscape,
designed to accommodate cars,
large avenues
anticipating high volumes of cars.
They imported what's called
the Radburn system
from the English new towns whereby
the housing is grouped around
a little green, the car parking
is separate;
It tends to give you a large areas
of rather bleak car parking
at the rear.
The peculiar thing is that the
individual houses
have very little private space,
whereas there is an awful lot of
public space.
So that tends to give a rather
windswept appearance.
A little, I would even call it
lonely.
In Gibney's plan, the avenues
were all curved.
You'd never actually have the long
vistas that you get here.
There would have been more of a
sense of enclosure
and probably more interesting.
And not as windswept.
Not as windswept!
(SUSAN VO) "As you walk around
Shannon's housing estates,
it's easy to see how pedestrian
walkways allow movement
away from streets.
But when you really get moving
around,
all the open space reminds you just
how close you are
to the Shannon Estuary.
The regular southwesterly gales
howling in from the Atlantic
needed another intervention.
The planners couldn't change
the wind
but they could provide shelter
from it.
And nature's way of doing
that is trees.
In 1968, 28,000 trees were planted
to protect the town.
(SUSAN VO) Landscaping the
neighbourhood became a priority.
Locals also saw growth in the
industrial estate
and thousands of jobs materialising.
But the 300 families now living in
Shannon
were still in search of a
town centre.
Housing estates sprung up everywhere
but it meant that early residents
arrived into a new town lacking
crucial facilities."
Town planning may have become a
science.
But building a community is
always a more chaotic affair.
The story of that community is the
story
of the next couple of decades
in Shannon town.
(SUSAN VO) Geographer Mary Greene
is going in search of that story."
Nothing about Shannon's development
was haphazard.
Critical to the project's
sustainability
was its new community. And there was
a plan for that also.
Building a new town on an open plain
beside the Shannon Estuary
was a huge project.
The tax-free industrial zone
operated by Shannon Development
attracted international companies;
factories were built and jobs
created.
Accommodating workers meant
building new houses.
All the elements were there to build
a new town
but this mightn't be enough to build
a new community.
Planning consultants, mindful from
the British experience of setting up
new towns, advised Shannon
Development on the social needs
of new residents.
A community officer was appointed
to welcome newcomers,
iron out any difficulties they may
have and promote
and co-ordinate activities for the
community.
(VO0 "Wolfe Tones GAA club was
founded in the late 1960s
with the support of Shannon
Development.
It was an initiative that helped
create an identity in a new town.
Some of Shannon's first residents
recall the earliest days
of the community here."
My father used to always call it
Tií na nOÓ
because there were no old people.
I came here with four children
and they always enjoyed their
childhood in Shannon
where I watched everything grow,
as Seaá did.
It was like the building site,
it was just mud. No trees, no grass.
As I said, my kids lived in
wellingtons for a long time
because there was nothing.
What was it that attracted you to
Shannon?
In the '50s, we were caught very
badly on the economic scene.
It was so bad that, you know,
one thought in terms
of "pull the plug out of the Bog of
Allen and let the place go down."
Emigration was fierce.
Out of the blue was this story of
hope, change, a house and a job.
And to be able to do that as part of
an overall regional development,
it was stirring stuff.
It was practical patriotism then.
Being part of creating the
resurrection of the country.
How did the community start to
build itself?
The people who moved into Shannon,
they got together and decided
that we are a community,
we're not just a housing estate.
We have a wonderful musical society,
drama groups
organized here in the town.
And I suppose central to everything
really has been
this wonderful club here,
the GAA club.
So through the schools and through
the GAA club
and the various clubs in the town,
we have managed to knit a whole
community together.
That is where our strength really
is.
The Shannon Town Project Plan
highlighted the development
company's preoccupation with
advancing a sense of community
among its town's population of
1,600 people.
As stated in the plan, "within a few
years Shannon will be a town
in the full sense with a population
of 6,000 people.
It will be a place which many Irish
people will regard as their home.
The development company is aware of
its heavy responsibility and plans
to develop the town so that its
residents and Ireland
as a whole will be proud of it."
(MARY VO) "Interestingly, the
leadership on this pioneering
project came, not from central
or local government,
but from a regional development
company.
I'm discussing the New Town
experiment with Fr Harry Bohan,
a sociologist with a longstanding
commitment
to community development."
Well, I suppose if I was to put it
in a nutshell now,
Shannon and the developments that
took place here were to be
the countergrowth area to Dublin's
growth.
And the people who drove it
were local people,
committed to the area and committed
to what Shannon was all about.
So, community then is much more
than just building houses
for industrial workers.
Absolutely. That's what I learned
and brought back
from my studies in England.
That I saw the massive housing
estates that were bringing about
serious damage to family life.
The concept here in Shannon wasn't
just about housing people,
it was about building community
as well.
This was the first school,
there was a community centre built.
There were a lot of services like
playing pitches
and things like that.
They all grew up.
And a lot of that was the initiative
of local people.
I'm a deep believer, you cannot have
economic development
without social development, because
we're talking about people,
and people need people, and
community.
These concepts have to be as much
part of economic development
as the economy itself.
You can't measure the health of a
nation by GNP or GDP,
you can't measure the health
of children or families
or anything in that kind of way.
(SUSAN VO) "An increasingly
globalised world
brought with it external threats.
Shannon's special tax status became
increasingly irrelevant
after Ireland joined European
Economic Community in 1973.
The oil crisis in the '70s
restructured global economics
and Ireland became less attractive
as a source of cheap labour."
As Shannon entered its second decade
in the 1970s, there were great plans
for innovation and growth
in the Free Zone and in the town.
(SUSAN VO) "In reality, the growth
of Shannon had more or less stalled
by the early 1970s.
But plans were still drawn up for a
futuristic new town centre.
A modern and bold statement of
intent for the civic ambitions
of Ireland's newest town.
But the plan was shelved because the
population didn't grow as expected.
At a time when its socio-economic
achievements should have been
more carefully nurtured,
many feel Shannon was overlooked."
As the flow of new investment into
Shannon slowed,
the flow of ideas out of Shannon
gathered pace.
Word began to spread around the
world
of the success of the Shannon model.
(SUSAN VO) "The Industrial
Development Organisation
of the United Nations became very
interested in Shannon's story
and how it might be relevant to
countries of the developing world.
Shannon was an example of how
populations
might be lifted out of poverty.
Courses were run to share the
Shannon success story
with foreign visitors.
Now retired, Brian Callanan was a
Shannon Development executive
at the time."
People like Columbia in South
America, Sri Lanka in Asia,
Egypt in the '60s and early '70s
began to look at Shannon more
carefully.
The big breakthrough was
the involvement of China,
because they wanted to find a way
to combine the Communist system
with the free market system.
And I remember vividly, we had a
group over
and it was a training course
in 1980,
led by a man called Jiang Zemin,
who actually subsequently became
President of China.
He was a senior minister
and he meant business.
And the training course involved use
of incentives.
How do you manage your customs
procedures?
But then as we began to talk more
and more,
the talk turned to rural poverty.
And then we told about the Irish
Famine,
and the rural poverty and the rural
emigration
that our great-grandparents and
grandparents experienced.
And they understood that because we
were sharing a similar cultural
experience and they saw it like we
did as a way out of rural poverty.
(SUSAN VO) "The Chinese immediately
followed Shannon's example
and set up a Special Economic Zone
in Shenzhen,
a small town of 30,000 people.
Today it's a Chinese super-city
of 10 million people
with an economy bigger than
Ireland's.
There are 20 such Chinese Special
Economic Zones,
and they generate nearly a quarter
of China's GDP.
The Shannon Model has been central
to China's transformation
into an economic superpower."
So Shannon therefore has a special
place among China's leaders?
Yes, Shannon is like a kind of a
holy grail because this was the area
where the Chinese special economic
zones originated.
And I think there was maybe three or
four deputy presidents,
senior ministers who come here just
to see
where the Chinese special economic
zones came from.
(SUSAN VO) "The Shannon model has an
impressive legacy.
More than 110 overseas companies
have opened subsidiaries here
since 1959.
And today, Shannon Group is still
a powerful driver
of economic growth for the region."
The idea of the Shannon Free Zone
and its purpose-built town
travelled far and wide.
And it was crucial in building the
Ireland of today,
and in changing the global economy.
It did achieve its purpose.
Thousands of people are still living
and working in rural County Clare
at the cutting edge of innovation
and enterprise.
Next time on Building Ireland,
Orla is exploring the Marino
housing schem in Dublin.
It remains a prime example
of the garden suburb idea.
A public housing development
designed with people in mind.
Susan investigates the geography
of the area and its people.
And Ellen Rowley discovers just
what's so special about these houses.
In 1922, the new Irish government
set about solving its capital city's
appalling housing crisis.
Dublin had some of the worst slums
in Europe and a radical housing
scheme would have to be built within
walking distance its city centre.
1,500 homes were built in Marino,
on Dublin's Northside,
and they are just as desirable today
as they were in the 1920s.
These homes offered comfort and
dignity through clever design.
And above all else, a bright future
for Dublin's working classes.
What they built here in Marino was
a landmark public housing initiative
and vitally important to the story
of Building Ireland.
Building Ireland explores some
of the most exciting stories
from Ireland's building and
engineering heritage.
And this time, we've come to explore
the Garden Suburb of Marino.
This suburban public housing scheme,
inspired by radical town planning
ideas from the Garden City movement
was the first of its kind in Ireland
and one of the first in Europe.
It remains a prime example
of the Garden Suburb idea -
a public housing development
designed with people in mind,
with access to nature, public space
and facilities.
Innovative features like indoor
toilets and front and back doors
for everyone were new to Irish
public housing.
Architectural historian Ellen Rowley
is discovering
what was so special about these
houses.
There was an elaborate master plan
for Marino,
but despite this common approach,
there was great variety and detail,
and 10 different house types
were built.
But Marino wasn't just houses.
Geographer Susan Hegarty
is looking into what was done
to build a community.
Schools, shops, a library and
a health centre were all built
as part of an ambitious master plan.
I want to explore the rural
and urban landscapes
that put Marino on the map.
At the turn of the 20th century,
Dublin, then the second
city of the British Empire, was
notorious for its tenement housing
and poor sanitation.
The crumbling Georgian mansions of
the gentry were now occupied
by thousands of casual workers and
their families
who struggled to earn a decent wage.
In 1913, during a year of industrial
strife, seven people were killed
and 100 left homeless when
two tenement houses
on Dublin's Northside collapsed.
The Church Street collapse caused
public outrage
and led to an inquiry.
It reported that 20,000 families
were living
in one-room flats in tenements.
A tenement museum is now located
at 14 Henrietta Street,
itself a notorious tenement back in
the day.
I'm meeting housing policy analyst
Rhona McCord.
A place like this, you could have
over 100 people living,
with families all basically in one
room.
They found 36% of people were living
in tenements,
no running water and very little
heat.
And most of these people would have
been considered the working poor.
As the city has been drained of
resources and more and more people
are being crowded in, you have an
increase in diseases,
things like tuberculosis and very
high infant mortality rates.
So it's all to do with the
cramped nature of housing.
Disease doesn't know class,
it just spreads.
And at the same time,
there was no alternative
accommodation being built.
So you ended up with the density
increasing and people living in more
and more poor conditions as time
went on.
So the political pressure around
housing, it wasn't just a question
of people campaigning for housing.
It was it was a question also
of people being worried
about the issue. The middle classes
and the political classes
and thinking that living so close
together in tenements,
this industrial class, if you like,
the transport workers and so on,
who were being organized into
trade unions,
were talking to each other.
There was a bit of a red scare, if
you like, going on.
And they wanted those people
dispersed.
They figured if they housed people,
that this threat would subside.
So you've a city that is gaining in
population, but at the same time
is becoming poorer.
So the challenge to rehouse people,
then becomes huge, actually.
Yes. There was obviously a huge
need.
And I think from the start
of the century,
up until around the housing inquiry
in 1913,
there was a gradual understanding of
what that need was and a political
pressure growing to find some
solutions to the housing crisis.
Dublin Corporation wanted to build
houses and had acquired 50 acres
of rural land on the northern edge
of the city, at Marino.
Exciting plans for a large housing
scheme were drawn up in 1914,
but nothing happened.
World War One interrupts momentum,
the Easter Rising destroys the city
centre,
and the War of Independence
paralyses progress to build housing.
Dublin wasn't alone in its
housing problems.
Many of Britain's big industrial
cities had similar issues.
Dickensian slums were a legacy
of the industrial revolution.
One social reformer had a vision
to change all that -
a man with a very Dickensian
sounding name, Ebenezer Howard.
He came up with the idea of
the Garden City -
a combination of the best of town
and country.
Howard argued that the cramped city
slums were morally corrupting
and bad for the productivity of the
working class.
His Garden City would be a new kind
of town with a healthy blend of city
and nature arranged in small
clusters of urban and green space.
After the establishment
of the Irish Free State,
the administration moved quickly on
the social housing issue.
A million pound grant -
a massive commitment -
was approved by the new government
in April, 1922.
Within weeks, contractors broke
ground on the State's
first public housing scheme.
Architectural historian Ellen Rowley
is looking at exactly what they
built.
The Marino scheme had propaganda
value for the new state;
quality housing would be provided
for citizens
to a standard not seen before.
This was going to be an alternative
kind of urban living.
Every family moving here would have
an individual house,
with its own front door and garden.
Suburban living for the masses
was to be the future of housing for
Dublin.
City architects,
like Horace O'Rourke,
were charged with designing mass
housing.
Following the British example,
O'Rourke introduced variety.
There were 10 different house types,
all two storey,
in terraces of four, six and eight
units.
Terraces were staggered and
corners were canted,
breaking the lines of view.
Each terrace has a different outward
design,
a distinct sense of character from
that of its neighbour.
The endless rows of Victorian
housing,
built for workers across
industrial Britain,
would not be repeated here.
All houses had a ground floor living
room, a parlour and kitchen scullery
with a larder and coal cellar.
Depending on the type of house,
there were two, three or four
bedrooms upstairs.
And every house was planned with
a bathroom.
What we see now as ordinary - that
is an indoor toilet -
was in fact extraordinary.
I want to find out more about these
houses, so I'm meeting local
conservation architect Fergal McGirl
at a home he has recently restored.
Cycling around Marino, I noticed a
great variety of detail and colour.
Can you tell us about that?
I think they used a lot of variation
in external finishes to break up
what was effectively a very large
estate of 1,500 houses.
The roofscapes, also I think, are a
particular characteristic of Marino.
For example you see on this house
and other houses in the estate,
where they used the terracotta
pantiles on the roof.
And they are particularly noted at
say corners and intersections,
where they seem to delineate
different parts of the layout.
Slating was engaged or used
extensively
within the estate as well, it's
quite a characteristic of the area,
particularly in the Mansard blocks,
like the block behind me,
where the slating became effectively
the front elevation
of the upper floors of the house.
Marino Estate was built at an
interesting time.
Can you tell us something about the
materials and fabric used?
Well, Ellen, it was a very
interesting time
in terms of construction technology.
We were transitioning from building
in what was called the traditional
way, which was the way the
Victorians and the Georgians
had built with things like solid
leaf brick walls, lime mortars,
lime plasters, and we were
transitioning into the modern era
where we are starting to build
with things like concrete,
concrete blocks, cavity walls.
The cavity wall was a very new
technology at the time.
This house, I was involved in some
of the work on it.
It's got a fair face concrete block
finish.
There is a lot of variation
in the texture of the blocks.
I speculate almost that these blocks
were made on site
because they don't to me look like
a factory made unit.
It looks to me that they were almost
handmade locally.
it was quite a brave and innovative
move for the Irish Free State
to build one of their first major
public housing schemes with this,
I suppose in some ways,
untested technology.
Beyond the masonry and mortar, the
challenge of transforming buildings
into happy and healthy homes also
required planning
and shaping the outdoor space.
Everyone was to be provided with
their own front and back garden
to encourage residents to grow their
own vegetables.
A large proportion of Dublin's
population were migrants
from rural areas.
the thinking was that they had a
deeper connection to agriculture
and to the land.
The approach reflects an Ireland
striving to establish itself
as an independent, self-sufficient
nation.
This was architecture and planning
with a social purpose:
to improve the everyday lives of
working people.
How that environment was shaped
would be crucial to the success
or failure of Marino.
The original 1919 plan for Marino
was greatly influenced
by the fashionable Garden
City philosophy
with housing radiating
from a large central boulevard,
creatively laid out so that
residents
has easy access to parkland.
However, the plans changed, giving
the eventual layout
more of a Garden Suburb identity.
Joe Brady, from UCD's Geography
Department,
has a particular interest in Marino
because he grew up here.
To find evidence of Garden City
thinking,
Joe suggested we get a bird's eye
view.
If I take you back to the 1890s
and say if,
if Dublin Corporation was
building an estate this size,
they would probably have built a
very geometric suburb with all
of the roads at right angles and
running parallel to each other.
But this is a very different
concept.
So here we are right in the Circle.
And you're looking at something
which is quite distinctive.
There's nothing like it. Look at the
geometry of it.
But also look at the variations that
are in it.
What really comes to the fore is
that it changes in colour.
And this is all designed to try and
give you an impression
of the countryside in the city.
So Joe, tell us what we're looking
at here?
These are, in fact, cul de sacs,
an arrangement of houses with their
own green space.
But it's private because there's one
road in, one road out
and the only connectivity is the
interesting connectivity
behind the houses.
You can walk in behind the houses
and do all sorts of things there.
And I must admit, as kids, we did
all sorts of things in the lanes
as we called them.
The whole thing is that this is a
neighbourhood and the circulation
patterns are designed to get people
moving around each other,
meeting each other.
But at the same time, there is no
sense that this is a gigantic suburb
built at all the same time.
What you have are a variety of
different urban spaces,
and each of these little spaces
creates their own community.
The original design for Marino
proposed a sophisticated hierarchy
of public spaces, and a wide array
of different house types.
Due to cutbacks, the final design
was less distinct.
But in spite of that, because
of the scale of the houses,
the arrangement of the public
spaces, and the fact that you can
drive into it but not through it,
gives Marino, as it's built, a real
sense of community.
Geographer Susan Hegarty is
discovering more about the area.
I'm doing a bit of urban
orienteering
and rediscovering the outside edge
of Dublin City.
Before this massive housing scheme
was built,
this area was all wide open
countryside.
The Marino Housing scheme was
largely built on the old estate
lands of the first Earl
of Charlemont, James Caulfeild,
who left us a notable architectural
legacy.
The most famous landmark of the area
is Marino Casino -
a folly built by Lord Charlemont
in the late 1700s.
Like many aristocrats of his
generation, young Lord Charlemont
undertook the Grand Tour
of Europe,
visiting the sites of great art and
architecture of the classical era.
Italy clearly made an impression
on the young lord.
On his return, he remodelled his
house and called it Marino,
and built this little house or
"casa-ino".
It's hard to imagine now,
but even in the 1920s,
this was the edge of the city.
Dublin inner city residents
would have regarded this
as the countryside.
Corporation planners mapped new
access and transport arteries into
the area to give it connectivity
and to help define the shape of the
growing city.
By far the biggest and most
impressive of these access arteries
is this one, Dublin's 100ft
cement highway,
because this was one of the first
places in Ireland
where poured cement was used for
road construction.
The main carriage way is 40 foot
across,
with two particularly wide
30-foot pathways.
We now know it as Griffith Avenue
and it's the longest tree-lined
avenue in Europe.
Once the Marino housing scheme
got underway,
plans were set in motion for public
transport and amenities.
It's no surprise that a brand new
Catholic church was built
for the brand new parish of Marino,
with schools to cater
for 1,500 children.
Other services, including a health
centre, were also built.
I'm heading for The Tuesday Club,
a group for local senior citizens,
to learn more about life here since
the 1920s.
I was born in Marino 85 years ago.
So that was my connection.
And has your family been here
all these years?
My father and mother bought
the house. I think it was 1924.
I came when I was two, 1936.
So, em, we came from Essex Street
It was great to move to.
Especially after being so many
people in the centre of the city.
Like, there was nothing only just
fields all along Fairview.
What makes Marino so special
as a place?
Like, if you were short of sugar,
you'd go next door
and that would be great.
And sure, the lady next door used to
make dresses for my sister
and my cousin, and her daughter,
but like...
It's completely different now.
You see, there was no money really
in those days.
Everybody knew one another.
And as I said, just, kids all played
together in the Green.
We were all reared together,
you know.
Now you didn't go really out of...
We live in a circle, in a green.
And we didn't really leave that.
We all played together and we went
to school together.
It must have been important for the
parents to see this happening?
Of course. Yeah.
You could put your children out
and watch them from the houses.
Because it was absolutely a great
idea.
They all had gardens. We all had
gardens.
The gardens gave, how would I say,
a little bit of dignity.
> Pride.
Yeah, pride. Good girl!
Our parents came from inner city,
out into the suburbs and they were
proud of their houses.
They were very proud of their houses
and their net curtains and...
All things like that were washed
and polished and...
Don't do anything like that now!
After the first phase of 248 houses
was completed,
4,500 families applied for them.
The cheapest house cost £400, about
25,000 euro in today's money.
Distribution was ultimately
by lottery.
But other houses being built in
Marino also attracted attention.
One of the more interesting features
here is that the houses
at the edge of the scheme appear
to be bigger, more impressive
and of a higher architectural
standard.
These are the houses of the
so-called "Reserved Areas".
These Marino Houses were privately
built, for private sale
and they were far more expensive.
Ruth McManus has researched and
written extensively about Marino.
What was the purpose
of the reserved areas?
It was a pragmatic response
to a problem.
The Corporation wanted to build
high-quality housing at the edges
of the scheme - the main roads along
the edges of the scheme,
the main frontages.
It couldn't afford to do it itself
so it decided instead to lay out
these plots and make them available
for other builders.
It was done for the very first time
here at Marino.
It was such a success, not just in
terms of housing quality
but also in adding social mix to the
scheme, that the Corporation decided
to continue with it and it continued
to apply this idea of reserved areas
in all of its schemes
for the next 50 years or so.
So in a sense, it was kind of master
planning the area as a whole,
in terms of both social mix
but also a variety of design?
Yes, they wanted to have
high-quality housing.
This was the sort of the shop front
of the scheme.
It was showing off the best of the
best here.
Only families with a minimum of four
children could apply for houses
under the public allocation scheme.
Dublin Corporation opted for
on a system of rental-purchase.
Residents would ultimately be owners
rather than tenants,
buying their houses with mortgages
lasting over 40 or even 60 years,
paying the Corporation directly.
It meant that only applicants
in regular paid employment
could afford the repayments.
Dublin's tenement poor were
effectively excluded.
Do you think Marino was designed
to be special?
Well, I suppose one of the things
that you find when you come
to Marino, if you're not familiar
with it,
is how quickly you get lost in what
seems to be this maze of streets
and beautiful green areas and so on.
And while that design is not very
useful
if you're trying to get around it,
it actually adds to this sense of
community and enclosure, I think.
And again, I suppose when they were
designing this,
they were drawing on the best of the
Garden City movement.
So they knew... they pretty much
knew what they were doing, I think,
in that respect.
So you get this...
The scale of Marino is manageable,
I think. It's a very human scale.
Everything is sort of nicely
proportioned at this human scale.
And the overall size of the scheme,
I think, works.
1,400 houses - it's big enough to
create a community,
but it's not too big.
And do you think, as a public
housing initiative,
that it was a success?
It had a unique combination of
things that happened
just at the right time in the right
way.
It was the mix and the combination,
I suppose, of the design elements,
the garden suburb idea,
the mix of people who came out here.
They were you know, described as the
aristocracy of the working class
in one of the newspapers.
But what they were doing was taking
that group of people out of mix
in terms of the tenements.
So better houses in town would then
be available.
And it sort of had this filtering
effect
or levelling up it was sometimes
called as well.
It's interesting that that was
by design, you know,
it sounds quite deliberate.
Yeah, I suppose it all came together
so beautifully at Marino.
You might wonder why don't we have
hundreds of places like this?
And I suppose the cost of developing
Marino was very substantial.
So when, when the Corporation
continued its program
in Drumcondra, for example,
they compromised on size.
They later on compromised in terms
of variety and design,
because all of those things add to
the cost.
But here at Marino they wanted to
make it beautiful.
And the best it could be.
So it's sort of a tantalizing image
of what could have been, I guess.
Almost a century after
its construction,
Marino's original home buyers might
not recognize
the half-million price tag
for some houses around here,
but they would have no difficulty
recognizing the streetscape.
It has hardly changed.
Marino was an ambitious development
by a new State
that wanted to house its people
with dignity.
Maybe it was too high a benchmark.
Maybe it was too idealistic.
Maybe it was too expensive.
All we know for certain
was that it was never repeated.