Secrets of Eden (2012) - full transcript
"Secrets of Eden" centers on Stephen Drew, an adored small-town minister in Haverhill, Vermont, and the brutal and sadistic murder-suicide of Alice and George Hayward, the town's most beloved parishioners. While the community never imagined such a destiny for the Haywards, dark secrets begin to surface, causing many to realize they may not have been the perfect family everyone thought they were. When evidence of an affair between Alice and Reverend Drew surfaces, Detective Catherine Benicasa suspects that the crime may actually be more complicated than it appeared and sets her eyes on the likable minister as the prime suspect. Now Katie, the Haywards' orphaned 15-year-old daughter, may be the only key to uncover the disturbing secrets of what happened behind closed doors on that fateful night and the suffering they endured as a "not so perfect" family.
GOD HAS
A PECULIAR WAY OF TESTING YOU
WHEN YOU LEAST EXPECT IT.
WHEN I ARRIVED IN HAVERILL,
A SMALL TOWN IN THE GREEN HILLS OF VERMONT,
THE CHURCH WAS DECLINING
AND IN DESPERATE NEED OF HELP.
I HAD PRAYED FOR AN OPPORTUNITY TO GET OUT OF NEW YORK,
WHERE I WAS JUST ANOTHER FACE
IN A CROWD...
STEP INTO A COMMUNITY
THAT NEEDED A RESURGENCE
OF FAITH AND IDENTITY...
...WHERE I COULD MAKE
A REAL DIFFERENCE.
I'VE ALWAYS FELT THAT CHANGE
COMES FROM A GRASSROOTS EFFORT
AND THAT A CONGREGATION GROWS
WITH THE YOUNGER GENERATION.
SO I STARTED A MUSICAL YOUTH
GROUP CALLED THE SERMONS.
WE'D PRACTICE A COUPLE TIMES
A WEEK AND PERFORM REGULARLY
FOR THE TOURISTS WHO VISIT
FOR THE OVERPRICED ANTIQUES,
ICE CREAM, AND MAPLE SYRUP.
DURING THE SUNDAY SERVICES,
CONCERNS STILL
OUTNUMBER THE JOYS,
AND SOMETIMES
I WISH MY CONGREGANTS
WOULD TAKE A LITTLE PROZAC
WITH THEIR PRAYER.
THE DOWNSIDE TO LIFE
IN A SMALL TOWN
IS EVERYONE WANTS TO KNOW
EACH OTHER'S BUSINESS.
SECRETS BEHIND CLOSED DOORS
ARE EVENTUALLY EXPOSED.
TAKE THE HAYWARDS.
THEY APPEARED TO HAVE IT ALL...
THE ALL-AMERICAN FAMILY...
...BLESSED WITH GOOD HEALTH
AND A BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER,
KATIE.
SHE WAS EVERY PARENT'S DREAM...
...KIND-HEARTED, RESPONSIBLE,
AND SMART.
GEORGE OWNED A SUCCESSFUL CHAIN OF SPORTING-GOOD STORES
ACROSS THE STATE...
EVERY WOMAN'S DREAM.
ALICE WAS A HOMEMAKER,
AND SHE WAS ACTIVE IN OUR
CHURCH, LOYAL AND STRONG.
THAT'S THE TROUBLE WITH BEING
ON THE OUTSIDE, LOOKING IN...
YOU NEVER REALLY KNOW.
OH, HEY, EMMET.
HI, CATHERINE.
WHAT DO WE GOT?
GEORGE HAYWARD STRANGLED
HIS WIFE, ALICE,
AND THEN SHOT HIMSELF.
OH, MY GOD.
I DON'T THINK I'VE EVER SEEN YOU
LOOK SHOCKED BEFORE.
THEY SEEMED LIKE
THE PERFECT COUPLE,
LIKE, UH,
REAL NORMAN ROCKWELL STUFF.
DANCE STARTS
IN THE DINING ROOM,
AND IT ENDS RIGHT HERE.
LOOKS LIKE SHE PUT UP QUITE
A FIGHT ALONG THE WAY...
A LOT OF BLOODY SKIN
UNDER HER FINGERNAILS
APPEAR TO MATCH
MARKS ON HIM...
WHAT'S LEFT OF HIM.
THEIR DAUGHTER...
WHERE'S KATIE?
HAS SHE BEEN BY HERE?
SPENT THE NIGHT
AT A FRIEND'S HOUSE... TINA.
TINA'S MOTHER, GINNY,
IS THE ONE WHO ACTUALLY FOUND
THE BODIES.
ALICE WAS APPARENTLY LATE
FOR SOME CHURCH THING,
SO GINNY CALLS, NO ANSWER,
COMES TO CHECK ON HER.
IT SEEMS MR. HAYWARD
WAS QUITE A DRINKER...
BEER BOTTLES EVERYWHERE.
PLACE SMELLS LIKE A FRAT HOUSE
ON A SUNDAY MORNING.
HOW'S THAT FIT INTO YOUR
NORMAN ROCKWELL PICTURE?
IT DOESN'T.
WHAT HAPPENED TO YOUR HAND?
THE DOG BIT ME.
WELL, DID YOU CALL
ANIMAL CONTROL?
NO. I DIDN'T HAVE TO.
PASTOR SHOWED UP.
WHOA. WATCH IT.
DOG DOESN'T SEEM
TO MIND HIM.
MM.
Stand by.
DISPATCH,
THIS IS BURNHAM 23,
LEAVING THE SCENE
IN MAYBE 10 MINUTES.
Stand by.
WATCH THAT DOG, GUYS.
CATHERINE.
PASTOR.
GINNY CALLED, HYSTERICAL.
I THOUGHT I'D COME BY
AND SEE IF THERE'S ANYTHING
I COULD DO TO HELP.
HOW ABOUT GETTING THAT DOG
OUT OF HERE?
NAH, WE'RE GOOD.
ALL RIGHT, I'LL TAKE HER
BACK TO KATIE.
THANKS, PASTOR.
WE APPRECIATE IT.
NEWS TRAVELS FAST.
WELL, SMALL TOWN.
LET'S GO.
OH, I'M SO GLAD
YOU COULD BE HERE FOR ALICE.
THANK YOU.
GOD BLESS YOU.
HELLO, MR. JOHNSON.
THANK YOU GUYS FOR COMING.
THANK YOU.
NOW, KATIE, YOU SURE
I CAN'T TALK YOU
INTO TAKING THE PLUNGE?
TWO FOR THE PRICE
OF ONE TODAY?
YEAH, I THINK
IT'S JUST MOM TODAY.
ALL RIGHT. I'M GONNA STAY
ON YOU, YOUNG LADY.
THANKS.
HE'S SO EXCITED.
I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE HERE,
SWEETIE.
YEAH, ME, TOO.
READY?
YEAH, I AM.
ALICE HAYWARD, DO YOU BELIEVE
IN THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
AS YOUR PERSONAL SAVIOR?
I DO.
AND DO YOU INTEND
TO FOLLOW HIM ALL THE DAYS
OF YOUR LIFE?
I DO.
LEAN BACK.
THERE.
HOW IS SHE?
HER DAD JUST CHOKED
HER MOM TO DEATH
AND BLEW HIS HEAD OFF.
HOW DO YOU THINK
SHE'S DOING?
GINNY, WE HAVE TO STICK
TOGETHER FOR KATIE.
HI, PASTOR DREW.
IN.
I'M SO SORRY.
I'M HERE FOR YOU, KATIE.
I'M HERE FOR YOU.
WE SHARED SOMETHING
DEEPLY PROFOUND TODAY.
I WISH I COULD HUG YOU.
YOU CAN HUG ME, ALICE.
MM.
I'LL GET SOME ICED TEA.
OH!
I AM SO PROUD OF YOU.
I KNOW THIS SORT OF THING
ISN'T VERY COOL.
NO, IT'S COOL IF YOU DO IT.
YOU KNOW WHAT ELSE
IS REALLY COOL?
THE FRAY.
AND, UH, THEY'RE GIVING
A CONCERT TONIGHT IN ALBANY.
WOW.
AND I WON TWO TICKETS.
THAT IS GREAT.
YOU'RE IN ON THIS.
I THOUGHT KATIE COULD STAY
WITH US AFTERWARD.
YOU HAD A BIG DAY.
YOU DESERVE SOME PEACE.
PLEASE?
DID YOU WANT TO CHECK
WITH DAD?
OH, WHY?
I KNOW HE'D SAY YES.
NO. GO. HAVE FUN.
REALLY?
THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
BUT NO DRINKING,
NO SMOKING.
NOPE.
AND GET ME A T-SHIRT.
I LOVE THE FRAY.
YOU'RE THE COOLEST MOM EVER.
I'LL BE CAREFUL
WHEN I DRIVE, OKAY?
OKAY.
ARE YOU SURE YOU'LL BE OKAY
TONIGHT?
YEAH, OF COURSE.
HAVE FUN.
HI, HEATHER.
NICE TO SEE YOU.
YOU DID IT.
NO ONE CAN TAKE THIS
AWAY FROM YOU.
LET'S TALK LATER.
STOP BY NEXT TIME
YOU'RE SHOPPING.
OKAY.
ALICE.
HEATHER. YOU CAME.
I DIDN'T WANT TO MISS
THIS SPECIAL MOMENT FOR YOU.
I STAYED IN THE BACK.
I DIDN'T WANT
TO DRAW ATTENTION.
THIS IS FOR YOU...
A GANESH,
TO HELP REMOVE ALL OBSTACLES
FROM YOUR PATH.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
HEATHER LaROCHE
CAME TO MY BAPTISM.
YES, I SEE.
HELLO, MISS LaROCHE.
HI.
NICE TO MEET YOU.
WHAT DID YOU THINK?
IMMERSION, INCLUSION.
YOU GOT RID OF THE BIBLE.
COULD HAVE BEEN
A PAGAN RITUAL.
DOES THAT MEAN YOU LIKED IT?
IT MEANS OUR BELIEFS
AREN'T ALWAYS AS FAR APART
AS ONE MIGHT THINK.
IS YOUR HUSBAND HERE?
I WANTED TO MEET HIM.
NO, HE, UM... HE WANTED
TO COME, BUT HE HAD TO WORK.
SO WE'LL HAVE A CELEBRATORY
DINNER TONIGHT.
MORE PIE FOR US, RIGHT? YEAH.
SO, YOU GOT BAPTIZED TODAY?
MM-HMM.
REALLY?
THOUGHT
WE HAD DISCUSSED IT.
WE DID.
AND I INVITED YOU.
YOU MUST HAVE
JUST FORGOTTEN.
LET'S EAT.
WHAT,
YOU WENT IN THE RIVER?
YEAH.YOU ACTUALLY GOT
IN THE WATER?
YEAH.
SO, WHO WAS THERE?
UM... THANKS... THE WOMEN'S
CIRCLE FROM THE CHURCH
AND GINNY, OF COURSE.
OF COURSE.
WHO ELSE?
OH, HEATHER LaROCHE.
COME ON.
WHAT, THE CRACKPOT
WHO WRITES ABOUT ANGELS?
WOW.
SO, WHO ELSE?
KATIE.
MM-HMM.
WHO YOU LET GO
TO A CONCERT TONIGHT...
WITHOUT ASKING ME?
IT'S NOT
THE DARK AGES, GEORGE.
I DON'T HAVE TO ASK
YOUR PERMISSION.
EXCUSE ME?
WELL, WHEN IT COMES
TO OUR DAUGHTER,
YOU DO, RIGHT?
JUST GOT USED TO MAKING
DECISIONS ON MY OWN
WHEN YOU WERE AWAY.
WH... WHILE I WAS AWAY?
WHAT?
NO, YOU THREW ME OUT.
REMEMBER?
YOU THREW ME DOWN THE STAIRS
AND BROKE MY ARM.
SO, WHAT, THIS IS HOW
YOU TALK TO ME NOW?
WELL, AT LEAST
I DIDN'T PRESS CHARGES.
YOU KNOW, YOU COULD
THANK ME FOR THAT.
THANK YOU?
WOW.
SO, I GO AWAY FOR, WHAT,
FOUR MONTHS, I COME BACK,
EVERYTHING HERE
IS DIFFERENT.
YOU HAVE A NEW OUTFIT.
YOU HAVE A NEW HAIRDO.
YOU HAVE A NEW ATTITUDE.
IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE?
WHAT WERE YOU WEARING
AT THE BAPTISM?
NEVER MIND. EAT.
I FORGOT THE SALAD.
I SAID,
"WHAT WERE YOU WEARING"?
GEORGE, PLEASE...
JUST TELL ME.
A LONG SHIRT
OVER A BATHING SUIT.
SO YOU MADE A SPECTACLE
OF YOURSELF.
IT WAS A SACRED CEREMONY.
IN FRONT
OF THE ENTIRE TOWN.
IT WAS NOT
THE ENTIRE TOWN.
A WET SHIRT... EVERYONE SEE
HOW TURNED ON YOU WERE?
I WASN'T TURNED ON, GEORGE.
BY HIM, HUH?
BY YOUR PASTOR.
YOU'RE BEING RIDICULOUS.
AAH!
OW.
OKAY.
YOU'RE NOT GOING
TO THAT CHURCH ANYMORE.
AAH!
STOP IT, GEORGE.
PASTOR DREW, YOU'RE BACK.
YEAH, I NEED TO PICK UP
A FEW THINGS FOR KATIE,
AND I THOUGHT I'D CLEAN UP
IF YOU WERE GUYS ARE DONE.
WELL, WE ALREADY ORDERED
A CLEAN-UP FOR TOMORROW.
WELL, I'D LIKE TO GET
IN THERE IF I CAN.
I'D HATE TO RISK KATIE
SEEING IT.
UH...
MY GUYS ARE DONE.
OKAY?
YEAH. IT IS PRETTY GRUESOME
IN THERE.
THERE'S A LOT
OF BLOOD, PASTOR.
I CAN HANDLE IT.
OKAY.
I WISH SOMEBODY
WOULD CLEAN MY HOUSE.
MRS. BENINCASA?
YES?
I'M HEATHER LaROCHE.
I WAS A FRIEND
OF ALICE HAYWARD'S.
AH.
I REALLY NEED
TO TALK TO YOU.
COME IN. SIT DOWN.
THANK YOU.
I JUST FEEL SO SICK
ABOUT THIS.
JUST BEEN TRYING
TO MAKE SENSE OF IT.
I WAS... I WAS HOPING
YOU COULD TELL ME SOMETHING.
I'M SORRY. I CAN'T TALK
ABOUT IT AT THIS TIME.
WERE YOU A FRIEND
OF GEORGE'S, AS WELL?
NO, NO, JUST ALICE.
IN FACT, WE ONLY BECAME FRIENDS
IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS,
BUT I FELT LIKE WE'D KNOWN
EACH OTHER A LONG TIME.
SHE, UM...
SHE CAME TO MY SHOP
ONE AFTERNOON.
SHE APPEARED TO BE LOST,
LOOKING FOR SOMETHING...
OR SOMEONE TO HELP HER.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
WELL, ALICE DIDN'T TALK MUCH
ABOUT HER PRIVATE LIFE.
HER RELATIONSHIP WITH GEORGE
SEEMED OFF LIMITS.
DID SHE SAY WHY?
NO. WE... WHEN ALICE AND I
WERE GETTING
TO KNOW EACH OTHER,
IT WAS WHILE
THEY WERE SEPARATED.
UM, THEY GOT BACK TOGETHER
JUST... JUST
BEFORE HER BAPTISM.
UH, WHEN WAS SHE BAPTIZED?
YESTERDAY.
SHE WAS SO HAPPY.
DO YOU KNOW ANYONE ELSE
WHO COULD TELL US MORE
ABOUT ALICE'S RELATIONSHIP
WITH GEORGE?
GINNY McBRADDEN.
THEY WERE BEST FRIENDS.
WHY?
'CAUSE HE BEAT THE CRAP
OUT OF HER FOR YEARS.
HE WHIPPED HER LIKE A DOG.
I HAD NO IDEA.
NO ONE DID.
SHE WAS EMBARRASSED BY IT,
ASHAMED.
BUT EVENTUALLY SHE'D HAD
ENOUGH AND THREW HIM OUT?
YEAH, AND THEN
AFTER A FEW MONTHS,
SHE LET HIM COME BACK.
AND YOU KNOW THE REST.
SORRY. JUST BE A MOMENT.
I APPRECIATE YOU NOT BOTHERING
KATIE WITH ALL OF THIS.
SHE'S BEEN THROUGH ENOUGH.
DID, UH... DID GEORGE
EVER HIT KATIE?
NO. HE LOVED THAT GIRL.
AND SHE LOVED HIM.
SHE WAS
HIS LITTLE PRINCESS.
HE NEVER EVEN TOUCHED ALICE
WHEN SHE WAS AROUND.
AND THEY CERTAINLY
SEEMED TO KNOW
HOW TO KEEP UP APPEARANCES.
YOU COULD SAY THAT.
SHE DID CONFIDE IN YOU?
SURE.
AND SHE TOLD YOU THE TRUTH
ABOUT HER MARRIAGE?
SOME OF IT.
BUT SHE KNEW I HAD ZERO SYMPATHY
FOR THAT MAN, NONE.
I CHEERED
WHEN SHE KICKED HIM OUT.
AND I CURSED WHEN
SHE BROUGHT HIM BACK,
AT WHICH POINT SHE STOPPED
TALKING TO ME ABOUT IT.
SO THIS WAS A WOMAN WHO HAD
NO ONE TO CONFIDE IN
AND NOWHERE TO GO.
OH, SHE HAD SOMEWHERE TO GO...
PASTORAL COUNSELING.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
ASK STEPHEN DREW.
UM, COME ON.
WE GOT TO GO.
OKAY.
UH, THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FOR YOUR TIME.
YEAH, OKAY,
WE'RE ON OUR WAY.
WELL, THAT'S INTERESTING.
WHAT'S GOING ON?
THAT WAS
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER.
GEORGE HAYWARD
DIDN'T SHOOT HIMSELF.
SOMEONE ELSE DID.
THE ENTRANCE WOUND
HAS A DOWNWARD TRAJECTORY
OF A 90-DEGREE ANGLE.
THE BLOOD SPATTER'S
INCONGRUENT
WITH THE WOUND ENTERING
FROM ANY OTHER ANGLE.
YEAH, BUT THE GUY WAS DRUNK.
THE GUN COULD HAVE SLIPPED.
NOT ALL SUICIDES ARE TEXTBOOK.
THERE WAS NO BLOWBACK
ON THE GUN.
THERE WAS NO RESIDUE
ON HIS HAND.
SO, DO YOU KNOW WHERE
THE SHOT CAME FROM?
THE SHOT CAME IN HERE,
FROM BEHIND AND ABOVE.
OKAY, SO,
THEY'RE HAVING DINNER,
THEY HAVE A FIGHT,
IT ESCALATES,
HE STRANGLES HER,
SOMEONE COMES IN TO STOP IT,
IT'S TOO LATE,
AND THEN...
EXCEPT SHE DIED FOUR HOURS
BEFORE HE DID.
ALL RIGHT, SO, HE KILLS HER,
THEN GETS LOADED
FOR A FEW HOURS...
PASSES OUT.
SOMEONE DISCOVERS THEM...
...AND DECIDES TO EXACT
A LITTLE RETRIBUTION.
WHOEVER DID IT
WIPED THE GUN DOWN
AND PUT IT IN GEORGE'S HAND
BEFORE TAKING OFF.
IT ALL FITS.
YEP.
COOL. UH,
ONE MORE THING...
ALICE'S LOWER BACK WAS COVERED
WITH FRESH CONTUSIONS,
24 TO 48 HOURS OLD.
HER KIDNEYS
ARE BADLY BRUISED.
SO, YOU'RE SAYING THAT
GEORGE BEAT HER A DAY OR TWO
BEFORE HE KILLED HER?
SON OF A BITCH.
SO, MY DAD DIDN'T
KILL HIMSELF, THEN.
SOMEONE SHOT HIM
WHEN HE WAS ASLEEP.
KATIE, HE WAS UNCONSCIOUS
WHEN HE DIED.
HE WOULDN'T HAVE FELT
A THING.
SO, WHO WOULD WANT
TO KILL MY DAD, THEN?
SOMEONE WHO WAS ANGRY
WITH HIM
FOR WHAT HE DID
TO YOUR MOTHER.
CAN YOU THINK
OF ANYBODY WHO...
LIKE... LIKE A FRIEND
OR SOMETHING, LIKE...
YEAH, SOMEONE WHO WAS CLOSE
TO YOUR MOM.
MOM DIDN'T REALLY HAVE
A LOT OF CLOSE FRIENDS.
NO ONE AT ALL?
THEY LOOK SO HAPPY HERE.
YOU KNOW, I WISH
THAT SOMEBODY HAD A RECORDER
AT MY MOM'S BAPTISM.
SHE WAS SO HAPPY,
AND SHE WASN'T AFRAID ANYMORE.
OF YOUR DAD?
OR ELSE SHE WOULDN'T
HAVE DONE IT, YOU KNOW?
DONE WHAT?
GOT BAPTIZED.
OH.
SHE KNEW THAT HE'D GET MAD,
AND SHE JUST DIDN'T CARE.
AND WHAT DID YOUR DAD THINK
OF STEPHEN DREW?
OH, UH, HE HATED HIM.
COME ON, GIRLS.
WE HAVE TO GO.
KATIE.
WHAT'S WRONG?
I THINK SHE WANTS
TO BE LEFT ALONE.
HTH?
HOW DO WE GATHER IN THE PLACE
WHERE SHE WORSHIPPED,
SHE LOVED SO MUCH,
SHE DID SUCH GOOD WORK,
AND NOT HAVE HER AMONG US?
WELL, SHE IS WITH US.
SHE'S ALL AROUND US.
SHE'S IN OUR HEARTS...
OUR MEMORY...
GOOD WORK...
AND... CERTAINLY IN HER BEAUTIFUL
DAUGHTER, KATIE.
YOU KNOW, YOUR SMILE REMINDS ME
OF ONE OF YOUR MOTHER'S GIFTS.
SHE COULD ALWAYS TAKE A NEGATIVE
AND TURN IT INTO A POSITIVE.
YOU RECALL THE, UM... THE QUILT
THAT THE WOMEN'S CIRCLE MADE.
TOOK THEM ABOUT A YEAR.
IT WAS A BEAUTIFUL QUILT.
AND THEY WERE GONNA RAFFLE IT
OFF AT THE SUMMER FAIR.
AND A FERAL CAT
FROM THE CEMETERY
FOUND ITS WAY TO THAT QUILT,
AND SHE GAVE BIRTH
TO A BEAUTIFUL LITTER.
OF COURSE, THE QUILT WAS RUINED,
BUT ALICE JUST LOOKED AT IT
AND SAID, "THANK GOD
THE KITTENS WERE WARM."
"AND THANK GOD
THE KITTENS WERE SAFE."
I COULD IMAGINE THERE WERE TIMES
IN ALICE'S LIFE
WHERE SHE DIDN'T FEEL SAFE.
BUT I'D LIKE TO BELIEVE
SHE'S SAFE NOW.
YOU ARE WELCOME TO COME UP
AND PAY YOUR RESPECTS
TO OUR BEAUTIFUL ALICE
AFTER THE FAMILY.
HEY, MOM.
I LOVE YOU.
Katie.
HOW YOU HOLDING UP...
ALL RIGHT?
YEAH. THANKS.
HONEY, WHAT'S UP?
HE'S HIDING SOMETHING.
THANK YOU, VICKY.
PASTOR. EXCUSE ME.
WOULD YOU HAVE A MINUTE
TO TALK ABOUT ALICE HAYWARD?
YOU KNOW,
IT'S BEEN A LONG DAY.
I HOPE YOU UNDERSTAND.
I DO.
I'LL JUST WALK WITH YOU,
IF YOU DON'T MIND.
GINNY McBRADDEN SAID
THAT YOU COUNSELED ALICE,
SO I THOUGHT YOU MIGHT BE ABLE
TO PROVIDE SOME INSIGHT.
I'M SORRY.
YOU WERE AWARE THAT ALICE
WAS BEING ABUSED
BY GEORGE, CORRECT?
I COUNSELED HER MANY TIMES
ABOUT HER MARRIAGE.
THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY.
DID YOU EVER DO ANYTHING
TO INTERVENE?
NO.
WAS ALICE SEEING ANYBODY ELSE
WHILE SHE WAS SEPARATED?
I'LL REMIND YOU
ALICE WAS BURIED TODAY.
PLEASE SHOW
A LITTLE RESPECT.
AND I'LL REMIND YOU
THAT WE ARE JUST CONDUCTING
AN INVESTIGATION.
NOW, SOMEBODY SHOT GEORGE
AFTER GEORGE KILLED ALICE,
SO MAYBE SHE MENTIONED
ANOTHER MAN
DURING HER COUNSELING
WITH YOU.
MAYBE HE KNEW SOMETHING
ABOUT IT.
CATHERINE,
I CAN'T SPEAK TO THAT.
ALL RIGHT.
EARLIER LAST YEAR,
ALICE KICKED GEORGE
OUT OF THE HOUSE,
AND THEN SHE TOOK HIM BACK.
BOY, YOU KEEP GOING, HUH? CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT?
THERE'S NO NEED
TO PATRONIZE ME.
BUT HOW DID YOU FEEL
ABOUT THAT,
AFTER ALICE FINALLY GOT
THE COURAGE TO KICK GEORGE OUT
AND THEN SHE TURNED AROUND
AND TOOK HIM BACK?
THAT MUST HAVE UPSET YOU.
GEORGE WAS A DANGEROUS MAN,
AND I TOLD HER THAT
MANY TIMES.
CATHERINE,
THIS IS A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY.
OTHER THAN THAT,
THAT'S ALL I CAN TELL YOU.
ALICE'S SPIRIT
HAS NOW BEEN RELEASED.
SHE'S NOW ONE WITH THE LIGHT,
WITH THE AIR... AND THE SKY.
SHE HAS ENTERED
THE REALM OF ANGELS,
AND THEY HAVE WELCOMED HER.
LET THE GOODNESS OF ALICE'S
HEART EXPAND OUR HEARTS.
LET ALICE AND THE ANGELS
COME TO US, INSPIRE US,
REMIND US THAT THERE IS LIFE
IN THE AIR WE BREATHE...
...LIFE IN THE LIGHT WE SEEK.
LET'S TAKE A MOMENT
TO CLOSE OUR EYES
AND FEEL ALICE'S ENERGY
SURROUND US.
HI, THERE.
HI.
CAN I HELP YOU?
I, UH... I WALK
BY YOUR STORE ALL THE TIME.
I'VE... I'VE NEVER HAD
THE NERVE TO COME IN BEFORE.
WELL, YOU'RE HERE NOW.
COME ON IN.
GREAT.
TAKE A LOOK AROUND.
I'M HEATHER.
YEAH, I KNOW.
WE ALL KNOW.
I'VE READ ALL YOUR BOOKS
AND I'VE SEEN
YOUR INTERVIEWS ON TV
AND ONCE I EVEN... I WROTE
HOW MUCH I LIKED YOUR WORK
ON ONE OF THOSE
ONLINE BOOKSTORES.
OH. THANKS FOR DOING THAT.
I DON'T... I STOPPED
READING THOSE AWHILE AGO.
SOME PEOPLE CAN BE
KIND OF NASTY.
I PROMISE YOU, YOUR BOOKS
HAVE HELPED SO MANY PEOPLE.
IT'S SO BEAUTIFUL IN HERE.
IT'S SO PEACEFUL.
THANK YOU.
I'M SORRY.
I DIDN'T CATCH YOUR NAME.
OH, MY GOD... ALICE,
ALICE HAYWARD.
IT'S SO NICE TO MEET YOU.
HI. IT'S NICE TO MEET YOU,
ALICE.
IT WAS GREAT.
WE TALKED ABOUT SPIRITUALITY
AND ABOUT A LOT
OF DIFFERENT THINGS.
YOU SHOULD READ THE BOOK.
SHE TALKS ABOUT CHRIST
AS A PROPHET,
LIKE BUDDHA OR KRISHNA.
SHE SAYS THAT WE'RE ALL ONE,
ALL A PART OF THE UNIVERSE.
HMM. I DON'T CARE
WHAT THE HELL SHE SAID,
AS LONG AS IT INSPIRED YOU
TO KICK GEORGE OUT.
I STILL THINK YOU SHOULD
GET A RESTRAINING ORDER.
I DON'T NEED TO.
ALICE,
HE'S NOT GONNA CHANGE.
YOU NEED TO START
PROTECTING YOURSELF.
GINNY, HE KNOWS
HE WENT TOO FAR.
HE DOES.
THAT'S WHY HE'S STAYING AWAY.
WHAT IF HE COMES BACK?
IT HASN'T BEEN THAT LONG.
I DON'T WANT
TO PRESS CHARGES.
I DON'T WANT PEOPLE
KNOWING.
OH, PEOPLE KNOW.
GINNY, PLEASE.
NOT FOR MY SAKE,
BUT FOR KATIE'S, OKAY?
THANK YOU
FOR THE PRAYER CIRCLE.
I CAN SEE
WHY ALICE LOVED IT.
WELL, I'M JUST SORRY KATIE
WASN'T ABLE TO MAKE IT.
I ENCOURAGED HER TO COME,
BUT IT'S JUST
TOO SOON FOR HER.
YEAH.
HOW'S SHE DOING, ANYWAY?
WELL, SHE'S A STRONG KID,
BUT SHE'S... SHE'S
REALLY SUFFERING.
SHE WON'T COME OUT
OF HER ROOM.
I-I... I JUST DON'T KNOW
WHAT TO DO FOR HER.
I CAN'T IMAGINE HOW DIFFICULT
THIS MUST BE FOR HER.
PLEASE TELL HER
TO COME BY ANYTIME.
YOU KNOW, YOU AND ALICE
REALLY CONNECTED.
WHY DON'T YOU COME SEE HER?
WELL, I DON'T WANT TO IMPOSE
IF SHE'D RATHER BE ALONE.
SHE WON'T TALK TO ANYONE.
I CAN'T SEEM TO GET
THROUGH TO HER.
MAYBE SHE'LL TALK WITH YOU.
I DON'T KNOW. THERE'S
SOMETHING ABOUT THIS PASTOR.
I DON'T TRUST HIM.
HE'S EDGY WITH ME.
HE'S DEFENSIVE.
WHAT ABOUT
THE BEST FRIEND?
WOULDN'T SHE HAVE
JUST AS MUCH MOTIVE?
WELL, SHE DOES
COME RIGHT OUT
AND SAY HOW MUCH
SHE HATED GEORGE,
BUT THE KIDS WERE BEST FRIENDS,
AND SHE ADORES KATIE.
SO, NO MATTER HOW MUCH
SHE MAY HAVE DESPISED GEORGE,
I DON'T SEE HER DOING THAT
TO KATIE.
MY GUT SAYS STEPHEN DREW.
WELL, DON'T LET YOUR GUT
INTERFERE WITH BUILDING A CASE.
FOCUS ON THE LAW.
WE DON'T WANT A WITCH HUNT.
OH, I FORGOT...
IT'S AN ELECTION YEAR.
YOU'RE JUST WORRIED HOW
IT'LL LOOK TO THE VOTERS.
YOU KNOW, NO ONE ELSE
COULD GET AWAY
WITH SAYING THAT TO ME.
AW, COME ON, JIM.
THAT'S WHY YOU HIRED ME.
CATHERINE,
I'M SERIOUS ABOUT THIS.
SO AM I, JIM.
LOOK... WE ALL KNOW
THAT GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS AN AWFUL MAN.
HE BEAT HIS WIFE, AND THEN HE
KILLED HER, FOR GOD'S SAKE.
BUT HE WAS PASSED OUT
WHEN SOMEONE PUT A BULLET
THROUGH HIS HEAD,
AND I DON'T CARE IF IT WAS
THE COUNTRY PASTOR WHO DID IT.
I CARE THAT SOMEONE
DID IT.
MURDER IS MURDER.
THAT'S WHY I HIRED YOU.
MY MOM WAS CHANGING,
WASN'T SHE?
SHE WAS BECOMING
REALLY INDEPENDENT.
BUT I THINK
THAT'S WHAT PUSHED HER
AWAY FROM MY DAD.
I THINK SO, YEAH.
BUT THEN
SHE GOT TO DISCOVER
SOME OF THE ANGELS
IN HER LIFE.
I THINK THAT'S WHY
SHE HUNG OUT WITH YOU
AND PASTOR DREW SO MUCH.
WELL, IF YOU'RE SUGGESTING
WE WERE HER ANGELS,
I'M AFRAID WE DIDN'T DO
A VERY GOOD JOB.
WELL, I'M GLAD THAT
SHE HAD YOU GUYS, ANYWAY.
ME, TOO.
WHAT IS IT?
YOU KNOW THAT THING YOU GAVE
MY MOM AT THE PICNIC?
YEAH. THE GANESH?
YEAH.
I WAS TALKING TO GINNY,
AND I SAID THAT IT SHOULD GO
IN HER CASKET.
I THINK SHE REALLY
WOULD HAVE LIKED IT THERE.
BUT THE THING IS
PASTOR DREW WANTED HER
TO HAVE HIS BIBLE.
LIKE, HIS PERSONAL BIBLE?
YEAH.
WOW.
I DIDN'T WANT MY MOM
TO LIE THERE FOREVER
WITH A BIBLE IN HER HANDS,
EVEN IF IT WAS HIS.
DOES HE KNOW THAT?
OH, NO.
CAN WE NOT TELL HIM?
'CAUSE, I MEAN, HE THINKS
IT'S WITH HER AND...
I WOULDN'T TELL HIM.
THANKS.
PASTOR.
SO TRANQUIL HERE, SO SAFE.
NO WONDER ALICE LIKED IT.
STEPHEN DREW IN MY SHOP.
HMM. WELL, I WANTED TO COME
AND, WELL, JUST BE
AROUND PEOPLE THAT SHE KNEW,
PEOPLE THAT SHE LIKED.
WELL, GINNY AND ALICE
WERE MUCH CLOSER.
YEAH, BUT ALICE
WAS INSPIRED BY YOU.
I MEAN, SHE SEEMED TO SEE
A CONNECTION
BETWEEN OUR BELIEFS.
I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT THAT IS.
WELL, THEY'RE NOT
SO DIFFERENT.
I COULD START WITH ANGELS.
I THINK YOU AND I
PROBABLY VIEW THEM
IN MUCH THE SAME WAY...
CELESTIAL GUIDES
AND PROTECTORS.
WHERE WERE
ALICE'S ANGELS?
I DON'T KNOW.
I WISH I COULD HAVE
DONE MORE FOR HER.
MM. ME, TOO.
GINNY, EXCUSE ME.
I HAVE SOME MORE QUESTIONS
FOR YOU
ABOUT THE NIGHT
OF THE MURDERS.
FOR ME?
MM-HMM.
WELL, THE PERSON
YOU SHOULD BE SPEAKING TO
IS DOWN AT AURASCAPES,
PAYING A VISIT
TO HEATHER LaROCHE.
HEATHER LaROCHE?
I HONORED STEPHEN'S REQUEST
TO PROTECT KATIE,
BUT I CANNOT GET PAST HIM
FLIRTING WITH HEATHER
ON TOP OF EVERYTHING ELSE.
ALL RIGHT, NOTED, BUT I NEED
TO KNOW WHERE YOU WERE
WHEN GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS KILLED.
IN MY BED, ASLEEP.
CAN ANYONE VERIFY THAT?
WHAT'S THIS ABOUT?
GINNY...
DID ALICE WRITE SOMETHING
ABOUT ME IN HER JOURNAL?
EXCUSE ME?
YOU HAVEN'T FOUND
ALICE'S JOURNAL?
IT'S IN HER HOUSE
SOMEWHERE,
AND I'M SURE WHATEVER
SHE WROTE ABOUT ME
IS MUCH LESS INTERESTING
THAN WHATEVER SHE WROTE
ABOUT THE AFFAIR.
GEORGE WAS HAVING
AN AFFAIR?
HELLO?
ALICE WAS HAVING
AN AFFAIR?
WITH WHO?
TAKE A BIG GUESS.
I'VE BEEN COMING TO YOUR CHURCH
FOR THREE YEARS,
BUT I'VE NEVER REALLY KNOWN
ANYTHING ABOUT YOU
UNTIL NOW.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND.
I'M SURE YOU DON'T.
WHAT IS THAT?
ALICE'S JOURNAL.
SHE STARTED KEEPING IT RIGHT
AFTER SHE THREW GEORGE OUT.
AND IT'S PRETTY CLEAR
THAT, DURING THAT TIME,
PASTORAL COUNSELING
WASN'T THE ONLY THING
SHE GOT FROM YOU.
IS THIS UNCOMFORTABLE
FOR YOU?
I NEVER MEANT FOR THIS
TO HAPPEN.
THAT'S THE TRUTH.
I SWEAR TO GOD.
I KICKED HIM OUT.
BUT I'M SCARED.
OF WHAT?
WHETHER I MADE
THE RIGHT DECISION OR NOT.
MONTHS GO BY,
AND GEORGE IS WONDERFUL.
HE'S TENDER.
LONG STRETCHES
WHERE EVERYTHING'S FINE.
IT COMES
IN PEAKS AND VALLEYS.
HE GETS SO ANGRY.
AND THEN HE CALMS.
BUT HE TRICKS YOU
WITH THAT CALM.
YOU THINK IT'S SAFE,
AND THEN SUDDENLY,
JUST OUT OF NOWHERE, HE RAGES.
I THINK
YOU'RE VERY COURAGEOUS.
I CAN'T HAVE KATIE
THINKING THIS IS NORMAL.
IT'S MY FAULT.
NO.
IT'S DAMAGED HER.
THEY USED TO BE SO CLOSE,
BUT LATELY I FEEL HER
PULLING AWAY.
IT MUST CHIP AWAY
HER LOVE FOR HIM.
I'M SURE IT DOES.
I HATE MYSELF FOR THAT.
NO.
I WANT TO BE
A GOOD EXAMPLE FOR HER.
I DON'T WANT HER
REPEATING MY MISTAKES.
GOOD.
YOU KNOW, UNDER HIS ANGER,
GEORGE... HE'S A GOOD MAN.
ALICE.
NO, HE IS.
I SEE IT IN HIS EYES
WHEN HE APOLOGIZES. HE JUST...
HE WRITES POETRY
ASKING FOR MY FORGIVENESS.
HURTING ME
DOESN'T MAKE HIM FEEL GOOD.
IT JUST MAKES HIM
HATE HIMSELF MORE.
WELL,
I'M SURE HE FEELS THAT,
BUT, ALICE, YOU HAVE
TO TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY
TO STAY STRONG
AND FOLLOW THROUGH.
DON'T TAKE HIM BACK.
I'M SORRY.
IT'S NOT MY PLACE
TO TELL YOU THAT.
OF COURSE IT IS.
I RESPECT YOUR OPINION.
IT'S JUST NOT SO EASY.
I MEAN, HE'S MY HUSBAND.
I MADE VOWS BEFORE GOD.
GOD DOESN'T WANT YOU
IN AN ABUSIVE RELATIONSHIP,
VOWS OR NO VOWS.
I'M SO WEAK.
NO, YOU'RE NOT WEAK.
YOU ARE STRONG.
YOU ARE INCREDIBLY STRONG.
THANK YOU.
HOW DOES
YOUR WRIST FEEL?
STIFF, BUT AT LEAST
IT'S OFF, RIGHT?
OH, SINGLE LIFE SUITS YOU.
I'm not single.
I'M SEPARATED.
OKAY. WHATEVER YOU ARE,
YOU'RE LOOKING GREAT.
I FEEL GREAT.
IT'S SUCH A LUXURY,
NOT BEING AFRAID.
YOU KNOW, PEOPLE TAKE
THIS SORT OF THING FOR GRANTED.
I WANT TO CELEBRATE.
I JUST DON'T WANT ANYTHING BAD
TO HAPPEN TO YOU.
NOTHING'S GONNA HAPPEN.
ALL THE BAD STUFF
IS BEHIND ME.
I CAN FEEL IT.
HAS HE CONTACTED YOU?
NO. NO, HE'S BEING
VERY RESPECTFUL.
LET'S HAVE A SUNDAE.
COME ON!
HI, HONEY.
HOW WAS SCHOOL?
SIT DOWN.
I GOT YOU A SNACK.
WHAT'S WRONG?
IS HE COMING BACK?
YOU WANT HIM TO?
YEAH.
HERE.
THANKS.
IT'S SO NICE TO SEE YOU
WITHOUT YOUR iPOD AND THOSE
THINGS IN YOUR EARS AND...
HEADPHONES?
YEAH.
YEAH.
THEY BLOCK US OUT.
I'M SORRY.
OH, HONEY, IT'S MY FAULT.
MOM, IT'S NOT
YOUR FAULT, OKAY?
OKAY.
THINGS ARE GONNA BE
DIFFERENT FROM NOW ON, BABY.
I PROMISE YOU.
OKAY.
- HI.
- HI.
HOW WAS THE BOOK SIGNING?
GOT HER TO AUTOGRAPH IT
FOR YOU.
"TO PASTOR DREW,
"MAY YOUR AURA
FOREVER GLOW BRIGHTLY
AND ILLUMINE THE SKY."
"THE SKY."YES, YES, "THE SKY."
THIS SKY? THE SKY OR...
THIS SKY... DON'T DISMISS IT
OUT OF HAND.
I READ IT, AND IT'S EXPANSIVE
AND THRILLING
'CAUSE IT'S NOT PUNITIVE.
YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT BASED
IN REDEMPTION OR GUILT.
IT'S JUST ABOUT BEING PRESENT,
HERE AND NOW.
MM-HMM.
OH...
YOU SHOULDN'T DO THAT.
YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW HER.
WANT SOME TEA?
YES, PLEASE.
YOU KNOW I WANT
A SPIRITUAL CONNECTION,
AND I'M JUST NOT
COMPLETELY FULFILLED
BY THE CHRISTIAN TEACHINGS.
WELL, YOU CAN'T LEAVE
THE CHURCH.
I'D QUIT THE PARISH
IN TWO SECONDS.
REALLY?
MM-HMM.
YOU WOULD QUIT?
BECAUSE I COULDN'T
BEAR THE FACT
OF LOOKING OUT
OVER THAT PULPIT
AND NOT SEEING YOUR FACE,
THAT'S WHY.
WHERE WOULD YOU GO?
I DON'T KNOW.
DESERTED ISLAND SOMEWHERE.
MM-HMM.
TALK TO COCONUTS.
I'LL PREACH TO COCONUTS.
HOW'S KATIE DOING?
HOW'S SHE ADJUSTING?
SHE'S HELD SO MUCH IN
FOR SO LONG.
NOW WHEN I SEE HER,
SHE'S LIKE A LITTLE FLOWER
JUST READY TO BLOSSOM.
I COULD SAY THE SAME THING
ABOUT YOU.
ANYWAY...
WE'RE DOING MOTHER
AND DAUGHTER THINGS TOGETHER
FOR THE FIRST TIME
SINCE SHE WAS A LITTLE GIRL.
THAT'S AMAZING.
SOMETHING SO SMALL
CAN SEEM SO BIG.
I'VE BEEN PRAYING FOR YOU
A LOT.
GOD, IT JUST ALWAYS
MAKES ME WANT TO CRY,
TALKING ABOUT IT.
ALICE, I CAN'T SEE HOW ANYONE
WOULD WANT TO HURT YOU, EVER.
I'M SO SORRY.
NO.
OH, MY GOD,
I'M SO EMBARRASSED.
IT'S OKAY. NO, IT'S OKAY.
I'M NOT GONNA LIE.
IT'S... IT'S NOT LIKE
I'M NOT ATTRACTED TO YOU.
LET'S JUST FORGET
THIS EVER HAPPENED.
NO.
MMM.
PLEASE REMIND ME WHO I AM.
YOU SLEPT
WITH STEPHEN DREW?
THERE IS A WOMAN
UNDER THESE FRUMPY CLOTHES.
YEAH, YEAH, YEAH, YEAH.
SO, UH, DETAILS?
AMAZING!
HE WAS SO GENEROUS
AND SO PRESENT AND SO HOT.
I DON'T THINK
I'LL EVER BE ABLE TO LOOK
AT HIM THE SAME WAY.
ME, EITHER.
IT'S ABOUT TIME.
OH, GOD, THANK YOU.
YOU KNOW, I NEVER THOUGHT OF
MYSELF AS THE SORT OF WOMAN
WHO GETS TO TAKE A LOVER.
MMM.
"TAKE A LOVER."
I TOOK A LOVER.
AND IT WAS GOOD.
IN MY LIFE, THINGS HAVE
BEEN SO MUCH BETTER.
I'M ABLE TO LAUGH
AND PLAY WITH KATIE.
WE'RE SPENDING
SO MUCH MORE TIME TOGETHER.
♪ I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM
♪ YOU CAN SEE,
BUT DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY ♪
♪ OH, I BET YOU WANT ME
♪ I'M IN A LOVE AFFAIR
WITHOUT A LOVE SONG ♪
♪ I'M IN THE HABIT
OF HAVING WHAT I DON'T WANT ♪
I NEVER REALIZED HOW MUCH I WAS MISSING, HOW MUCH I SHUT DOWN.
NOW I'M BEGINNING TO FEEL
ALL THE JOY
THAT COMES WITH BEING PART
OF MY DAUGHTER'S LIFE.
♪ I'M IN A LOVE AFFAIR
WITHOUT A LOVE SONG ♪
♪ I'M IN THE HABIT
OF HAVING WHAT I DON'T WANT ♪
♪ I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM
♪ YOU CAN SEE,
BUT DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY ♪
♪ OH, I BET YOU WANT ME NOW
♪ DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY,
I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM ♪
I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU CAME
TO ONE OF MY GAMES.
WHAT, YOU KIDDING ME?
I LOVE WATCHING YOU PLAY.
YOU KNOW WHAT?
YOU ARE GETTING PRETTY GOOD
WITH THAT LEFT FOOT.
WELL, I'VE BEEN WORKING
ON IT.
YEAH?
SO, WHAT'S IN THE BAG?
WHAT, THIS BAG?
A LITTLE SOMETHING FOR YOU.
HELP MAKE YOU PLAY BETTER.
OKAY.
THESE ARE LIKE 200 BUCKS.
ONLY THE BEST FOR MY BABY,
RIGHT?
OH, THANK YOU!
YOU'RE WELCOME.
I MISS YOU, DAD.
I MISS YOU, TOO.
INVITE ME
TO YOUR NEXT GAME?
NOPE.
HEY.
HEY, PASTOR DREW.
WHAT YOU DOING?
WORKING ON YOUR MOM'S CAR,
YOU KNOW, DOING MANLY STUFF.
STEPHEN?
TIME FOR A BREAK.
HEY, BABE.
HOW WAS SOCCER?
GOOD.
ICED TEA?
UM, I'LL... I'LL BE FINE.
THANKS, THOUGH.
YOU GONNA JOIN US?
I GOT SOME HOMEWORK AND STUFF
TO DO, BUT YOU GUYS HAVE FUN.
ISN'T THAT SO NICE OF STEPHEN
TO HELP ME WITH MY CAR?
DAD'S BEEN TEXTING ME.
OH, GOOD. I'M GLAD.
REALLY?
YEAH.
HE'S YOUR DAD.
YOU NEED TO KNOW
HOW MUCH HE LOVES YOU.
YOU WANT TO KNOW A SECRET?
HE'S BEEN WRITING ME
POETRY.
YEAH, I KNOW.
YOU DO?
UM, I THINK IT MEANS
THAT HE MISSES YOU.
IS IT ANY GOOD?
IT'S TERRIBLE!
WE SHOULDN'T LAUGH.
IT'S A REALLY SWEET SIDE
OF YOUR DAD.
IT REALLY IS.
I LOVE YOU, MOM.
I LOVE YOU, TOO.
COME HERE.
MWAH!
I DON'T THINK KATIE
SUSPECTS ANYTHING,
BUT I WON'T LIE IF SHE ASKS.
THANK YOU.
WOULDN'T IT BE NICE
IF WE DIDN'T HAVE TO HIDE?
YES, IT WOULD.
WHAT WOULD GEORGE SAY?
LET'S NOT THINK
ABOUT THAT.
IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM.
READ THE LAST LINE
ON THAT PAGE RIGHT THERE,
THAT LINE, OUT LOUD.
"AND THEN STEPHEN
SAID TO ME..."
PASTOR.
"STEPHEN SAID..."
PASTOR.
"AND THEN STEPHEN
SAID TO ME..."
"IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM."
"IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM."
ARE YOU ACTUALLY DENYING
THAT YOU TOLD ALICE
YOU'D KILL GEORGE
IF HE EVER
TOUCHED HER AGAIN?
JUST BECAUSE
I SAID SOMETHING
DOESN'T MEAN
I ACTUALLY DID IT.
HOW DID THE AFFAIR END?
READ FOR YOURSELF.
WELL, ACTUALLY SHE DIDN'T WRITE
ABOUT IT IN HER JOURNAL.
I'M GUESSING SHE LOVED YOU
TOO MUCH
TO WRITE ANYTHING BAD
ABOUT YOU.
YOU DIDN'T KNOW
ABOUT THE JOURNAL, DID YOU?
OTHERWISE, YOU SURELY
WOULD HAVE GRABBED IT
WHEN YOU WENT TO,
UH, CLEAN THE HOUSE.
YOU KNOW, YOU HAVE NO RIGHT
BARGING INTO A HOUSE
OF WORSHIP,
TREATING ME
LIKE I'M ON TRIAL.
I DON'T HAVE TO ANSWER
YOUR QUESTIONS.
I'VE GOT NEWS FOR YOU...
THE WORLD'S TIRED
OF CLERGYMEN TAKING SEXUAL
ADVANTAGE OF THEIR FLOCK.
I DIDN'T TAKE ADVANTAGE
OF HER.
YOU OUTRIGHT LIED ABOUT
YOUR INVOLVEMENT WITH HER.
WHAT ELSE
ARE YOU LYING ABOUT?
I DID NOT KILL GEORGE.
I DON'T BELIEVE YOU.
HUH.
YOU'VE GOT BLOOD
ON YOUR HANDS.
AND IN TIME, I'LL PROVE IT.
GINNY, YOU TOLD
CATHERINE BENINCASA
ABOUT ALICE AND ME,
DIDN'T YOU?
ALL I SAID IS
THAT ALICE KEPT A JOURNAL.
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?
YOU DON'T TRUST ME?
NO. I DON'T TRUST YOU.
YOU CONDEMNED HER TO DIE.
OH, GINNY, DON'T SAY THAT.IT'S TRUE.
YOU DAMN WELL KNOW IT.
SHE WOULD HAVE LEFT HIM
FOR YOU.
SHE'D STILL BE WITH US.
WE'D ALL STILL HAVE HER...
YOU, ME, KATIE.
SHE LOVED YOU.
I KNOW.
THERE.
THERE.
THERE.
THERE.
PLEASE TELL ME SHE WASN'T
PREPARING TO DIE.
WHAT HAVE I DONE?
LORD, HELP ME.
THANK YOU.
THE JOURNAL PROVES
HE'S LYING, EMMET.
- LET'S DO IT.
- You sure about this?
YEAH.
GET A SEARCH WARRANT.
LET'S SEE WHAT ELSE
STEPHEN DREW IS HIDING.
You got it.
WHOA.
THIS PLACE IS A MESS.
WHAT HAPPENED?
UNEXPECTED VISITORS.
THE POLICE?
COME ON. SIT DOWN.
TELL ME.
TELL ME... HOW ARE YOU?
I'M FINE.
KATIE.
I REALLY MISS MY MOM.
AND MY DAD.
PASTOR DREW.
I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR YOU.
I JUST WENT BY YOUR PLACE.
YEAH.
I HEARD ABOUT THE POLICE
GOING THROUGH IT.
WHAT WAS THAT ALL ABOUT?
CATHERINE BENINCASA HAS ME
IN HER CROSS HAIRS.
THERE'S NOTHING WRONG.
SHE HAS NO EVIDENCE,
BUT SHE NEEDS A VILLAIN,
AND, UH, APPARENTLY
SHE'S CHOSEN ME.
NOT LIKE I HAVEN'T MADE MISTAKES
IN MY LIFE, BUT I'M NO CRIMINAL.
OF COURSE
YOU'RE NOT A CRIMINAL.
I'M GOING UP TO MY CABIN
ON THE LAKE FOR A LITTLE WHILE.
YOU SHOULD COME UP
SOMEDAY THIS WEEK.
YOU LOOK LIKE
YOU COULD USE A BREAK.
THANKS. THAT'S SWEET.
YOU SHOULD THINK ABOUT IT.
OKAY.
YOU EXECUTED A WARRANT,
AND IT TURNED UP NOTHING.
ABSOLUTELY UNTRUE.
WE FOUND HIS LAPTOP,
AND WE DISCOVERED
THAT HE SEARCHED WEBSITES
LIKE, UM, "HOW TO REMOVE
BLOOD STAINS,"
"THE BEST WAY TO CLEAN
FINGERPRINTS,"
"GUN BLOWBACK."
WE HAVE MOTIVE.
WE HAVE FORENSIC EVIDENCE.
YEAH, BUT NONE OF IT
TIES HIM TO THE MURDER.
AND HE WAS MERELY SEARCHING
FORENSIC WEBSITES.
HIS DNA, HIS FINGERPRINTS
ARE ALL OVER THE HAYWARD HOUSE.
CATHERINE, HE WAS SLEEPING
WITH HER.
THERE'S NOTHING ON THE GUN.
HE SEARCHED THOSE WEBSITES
AT 2:30 IN THE MORNING,
AN HOUR AFTER GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS SHOT.
WHAT MORE DO I NEED?
A WITNESS?
A CONFESSION?
EVERYTHING YOU HAVE
IS CIRCUMSTANTIAL.
WE HAVE GOTTEN CONVICTIONS
WITH LESS, AND YOU KNOW IT.
AND WE WON'T WITH THIS ONE,
NOT WITH STEPHEN DREW.
YOU KNOW,
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT HIM
LIKE HE'S SOME KIND OF SAINT,
I MEAN, LIKE HE'S UNTOUCHABLE.
IF YOU GET THIS TO TRIAL,
THE JURY WILL INTERPRET
YOUR PASSION
AS A PERSONAL VENDETTA
BECAUSE THEY'LL TAKE
ONE LOOK AT THAT GUY,
AND YOU KNOW WHAT
THEY'RE GONNA SEE?
THEY'RE GONNA SEE A HANDSOME,
DECENT, HARDWORKING PASTOR
WHO'S A BIG PART
OF THIS COMMUNITY
AND WHO'S DONE NOTHING
BUT GOOD WORK HERE.
HE'S GONNA WALK.
AND YOUR REPUTATION AND MINE
WILL TAKE A BIG HIT.
YOU SHOULD COME UP
SOMEDAY THIS WEEK.
YOU SHOULD THINK ABOUT IT.
HEY, THERE YOU ARE.
I WAS GETTING WORRIED.
YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO PICK ME UP
AN HOUR AGO.
DON'T WORRY.
I LEFT MY SUITCASE
IN THE TRUNK.
NO ONE SAW ME COME IN.
I, UH...
I CALLED THE HOTEL.
I GOT US AN UPGRADE.
WHY NOT, RIGHT... OUR FIRST
NIGHT AWAY TOGETHER?
WHY DON'T I HELP YOU PACK?
ALICE, SIT DOWN.
ALICE... WE CAN'T CONTINUE.
WHY NOT?
WELL, IT'S...
IT'S JUST ALL SO COMPLICATED.
I MEAN, I'M SUPPOSED TO BE
A MAN OF GOD.
MAYBE IT'S GOD WILL.
YOU'RE STILL MARRIED.
AND THERE'S KATIE
AND... AND THE CONGREGATION.
I MEAN, WHAT WOULD
THE CONGREGATION THINK OF ME?
GEORGE HAS BEEN CALLING.
HE WANTS TO COME HOME.
NO, ALICE.
HE AND I PROBABLY
BELONG TOGETHER.
I WON'T BE THE KIND OF WOMAN
WHO SAYS
SHE HAD NO IDEA
WHEN SHE MARRIED
THAT HER HUSBAND
MIGHT BEAT HER.
IT'S NAIVE.
IT'S A COP-OUT.
DON'T BE SO HARD
ON YOURSELF.
I'M NOT BEING HARD
ON MYSELF.
I'M JUST BEING REALISTIC.
ALICE, YOU CAN
LIVE WITHOUT HIM.
YOU'VE PROVEN THAT.
YOU KNOW WHAT ATTRACTED ME
TO GEORGE IN THE FIRST PLACE?
HE COULDN'T LIVE
WITHOUT ME.
HE MADE ME FEEL SPECIAL.
HE NEEDED ME.
YOU DON'T.
HE'S A DANGEROUS MAN.
WE CAN SAY A LOT OF BAD THINGS
ABOUT GEORGE, COULDN'T WE?
BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY,
HE LOVES ME.
PLEASE DON'T GO BACK.
IF THERE'S ONE THING
I'VE LEARNED ABOUT
BEING WITH YOU...
IT'S THAT...
I NEED TO BE LOVED.
GEORGE HAS BEEN CALLING ME,
PLEADING WITH ME TO GIVE HIM
ANOTHER CHANCE.
SO MUCH PAIN IN HIS VOICE.
I DON'T WANT TO PUT HIM
THROUGH THAT ANYMORE.
I CAN'T HELP BUT THINK
IT COULD BE DIFFERENT,
BUT I COULD MAKE IT WORK.
JUST A LITTLE BIT FURTHER.
EYES CLOSED, RIGHT?
EYES CLOSED, EYES CLOSED.
GEORGE, YOU KNOW
I DON'T LIKE SURPRISES.
NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO,
YOU'RE GONNA LOVE THIS.
TRUST ME.
OKAY, A LITTLE FURTHER,
A LITTLE FURTHER.
AND OPEN YOUR EYES.
I LOVE IT.
YOU DO?
WOW.
SIT.
AND I MADE THAT MYSELF.
IT DIDN'T COME FROM A JAR.
UH... OH, NO. WHAT?
WHAT?
IS IT TOO MUCH LIME?
YOU KNOW, IT'S THE THOUGHT
THAT COUNTS.
OKAY.
WELL, WINE, RIGHT?
THANK YOU.
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
HONEY, I, UH...
I NEVER MEANT TO HURT YOU.
YOU KNOW THAT, RIGHT?
BUT I KNOW THAT I HAVE,
OVER AND OVER AGAIN,
AND I... IT MAKES ME
HATE MYSELF.
GEORGE, YOU DON'T HAVE TO...
NO, I DO, OKAY?
FROM THE FIRST MOMENT
I SAW YOU,
I KNEW THAT SOMEHOW,
SOMEWAY WE HAD TO BE TOGETHER,
I... I HAD TO HAVE YOU.
AND I CROSSED THE LINE
IN TRYING TO MAKE THAT HAPPEN,
TRYING TO KEEP YOU.
GEORGE.
HOW CAN YOU DO THIS?
WHAT IS THE MATTER
WITH YOU?
KATIE WANTS HIM
TO COME HOME.
KATIE IS A CHILD.
SHE DOESN'T UNDERSTAND.
HE'S MADE CHANGES.
HE'S HAD COUNSELING.
THAT KIND OF BEHAVIOR
DOESN'T CHANGE
WITH A LITTLE COUNSELING.
TWO WEEKS AGO, YOU SAID
YOU WERE FALLING IN LOVE
WITH STEPHEN DREW.
DOESN'T MATTER ANYMORE.
HE DUMPED YOU, DIDN'T HE?
SON OF A BITCH.
DON'T.
DON'T RUIN IT.
IT WAS BEAUTIFUL.
I'VE NEVER HAD ANYTHING
LIKE THAT BEFORE.
I'M GRATEFUL.
I WISH YOU'D WAKE UP.
I AM AWAKE, GINNY,
WIDE AWAKE.
THIS IS WHERE
I'M SUPPOSED TO BE.
HEY, MOM,
WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT
TAKING CHINESE FOOD
OUT TONIGHT?
SWEETIE, YOUR DAD AND I
HAVE BEEN TALKING.
WE'RE GONNA TRY
TO WORK IT OUT.
LOOK...
I PROMISE YOU
IT'S GONNA BE OKAY.
NO, I-I'M REALLY GLAD
THAT YOU'RE TAKING HIM BACK.
YOU ARE?
YEAH.
AND HE PROMISED ME THAT
HE WOULDN'T HURT YOU AGAIN.
OKAY.
YEAH.
GO ORDER.
YEAH.
I AM NOT A VICTIM.
MAYBE IT LOOKS LIKE I AM.
I KNOW PEOPLE IN TOWN
MIGHT THINK SO
IF THEY KNEW WHAT'S HAPPENED
IN THIS HOUSE.
BUT DEEP INSIDE ME,
I KNOW I'M NOT.
GEORGE DOESN'T BEAT ME
BECAUSE HE WANTS TO HURT ME.
HE DOES IT 'CAUSE
HE'S AFRAID TO LOSE ME.
WOW.
THE THING ABOUT GEORGE IS,
I UNDERSTAND HIM.
WE ALL NEED TO BE UNDERSTOOD.
I'LL NEVER
LET YOU GO AGAIN.
HELLO?
Stephen? Aaron Lance.
OH, HEY, AARON. THANKS SO MUCH
FOR CALLING ME BACK.
LISTEN... YOU REMEMBER
YOU TOLD ME
IF I EVER NEEDED A LAWYER
TO GIVE YOU A CALL?
I'm at your service, pastor.
What's up?
YEAH, WELL...
I'M CALLING YOU.
I'M GONNA BE LEAVING TOWN
FOR A WHILE.
HELLO, JIM.
HELLO, AARON.
AND HERE'S HAVERILL'S
FAVORITE SPITFIRE.
HELLO.
WHERE'S YOUR CLIENT?
OH, HE'S NOT COMING BACK
UNTIL HE'S ASSURED
HE WON'T BE ARRESTED.
WELL, THEN,
WE'LL JUST FIND HIM.
CATHERINE, WE ALL KNOW
YOU DON'T HAVE ENOUGH
TO GET EVEN AN INDICTMENT.
THIS ONLY GOES FORWARD
IF HE CONFESSES,
AND HE'S NOT GONNA CONFESS
TO A CRIME HE DID NOT COMMIT.
NOW, I UNDERSTAND
YOU'RE VERY PASSIONATE
ABOUT THIS CASE,
AND I COMMEND YOU FOR IT.
YOU'RE JUST WRONG.
WELL, WE'LL SEE.
IT'S ALWAYS VERY NICE
TO SEE YOU.
MM-HMM.
OH. OOH.
LULA, NO.
HEY. HEY.
OH, KATIE, HI.
I'M REALLY SORRY
TO JUST STOP BY LIKE THIS,
BUT I REALLY NEED YOUR HELP.
IT'S ABOUT PASTOR DREW,
ISN'T IT?
YES.
LISTEN, UM...
COULD YOU JUST COME OUTSIDE?
CAN WE... CAN WE TALK?
YEAH. YEAH, SURE.
I MEAN, I'M NOT SURPRISED.
I KNOW YOU GUYS SEARCHED HIS
HOUSE AND EVERYTHING, BUT...
PASTOR DREW? REALLY?
ANYTHING YOU CAN THINK OF,
KATIE, ANYTHING AT ALL.
ALL I CAN THINK OF
IS HOW MUCH SHE LIKED HIM.
I MEAN,
SHE... REALLY LIKED HIM.
YOU KNEW ABOUT THE AFFAIR?
SHE TRIED TO HIDE IT,
BUT, I MEAN, I FIGURED IT OUT.
IS THAT WHY
YOU GUYS THINK IT'S HIM?
WELL, IT CERTAINLY
GIVES HIM MOTIVE, YES.
I HAD THIS, UH, DREAM
A COUPLE OF NIGHTS AGO.
AND, UM,
MY PARENTS WERE DEAD.
AND THEN LULA WAS LAPPING
THE BLOOD OFF MY DAD'S HEAD.
AND IT WAS REALLY DISGUSTING
AND IT FELT REALLY REAL
AND THEN WHEN I WOKE UP,
IT JUST... I GOT SICK AND...
KATIE, LISTEN.
WHEN THE POLICE GOT HERE,
LULA WAS OUTSIDE, OKAY?
SO, EVEN IF THAT SEEMED REAL
IN YOUR DREAM...
MM-HMM.
...IT DIDN'T HAPPEN
IN REAL LIFE, OKAY?
WAIT. OKAY.
LULA'S NEVER OUTSIDE
UNLESS SHE'S ON A LEASH.
SO, WHOEVER SHOT YOUR DAD
MUST HAVE LET HER OUT.
SHE WOULD HAVE ATTACKED
SOMEBODY THAT SHE DOESN'T KNOW,
ESPECIALLY AT THE HOUSE.
SHE DOESN'T LIKE STRANGERS,
AND SHE HATES MEN,
EXCEPT FOR DAD
AND PASTOR DREW.
SO, YOU'RE SAYING SHE WOULD
HAVE ATTACKED A STRANGER.
YEAH, SHREDDED THEM.
MY PARENTS
ALMOST GOT SUED ONCE.
BUT THE ONLY BLOOD IN THE HOUSE
BELONGED TO YOUR PARENTS.
KATIE...
LULA MUST HAVE KNOWN
YOUR FATHER'S KILLER.
SHE MUST HAVE.
OH.
DON'T LET IT,
LIKE, BE HIM 'C...
I'm so sorry.
PLEASE DON'T LET IT BE HIM.
YOU MADE IT.
YEAH.
THANKS FOR THE INVITE.
THANKS FOR COMING.
I'LL TAKE THAT.
SURE.
SO, COME ON BACK.
THIS PLACE IS AWFUL.
I MEAN,
IT LOOKS LIKE A SHACK.
IS IT HAUNTED?
IT'S MY REFUGE.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
REALLY BEAUTIFUL.
OH, I READ YOUR BOOK.
UH-HUH?
AND I LIKED IT.
BUT...?
WELL, YOU TALK A LOT
ABOUT ILLUMINATION
AND CHERUBS AND SERAPHIM
AND FLYING MONKEYS.
IS THAT REALLY ALL YOU GOT
FROM MY BOOK?
YOU KNOW, I TALK ABOUT
GRIEF AND CLOSURE, TOO.
YEAH, I KNOW.
I LIKED THAT PART.
BUT YOU CAME.
SO YOU DON'T THINK
I'M A COMPLETE PHONY.
I DON'T THINK
YOU'RE A COMPLETE PHONY.
WHO AM I TO TALK?
I DON'T HAVE ANY ANSWERS.
I SPEND MY DAYS
COUNSELING PEOPLE,
AND I CAN BARELY
MANAGE MY OWN LIFE.
MM.
YEP.
LET'S GO FOR A WALK.
I'M GLAD YOU CAME.
I'M GLAD I CAME, TOO.
ALICE.
YOU JUST CALLED ME ALICE.
DON'T.
I'M SORRY.
DID YOU LOVE HER?
I DID.
I DID LOVE HER.
AND YOU THOUGHT
YOU COULD SAVE HER.
I THOUGHT SHE WAS SAVING HERSELF
WHEN SHE LEFT GEORGE.
I JUST...
I COULDN'T HANDLE THAT.
I... I DON'T KNOW.
ALICE WAS PART
OF THE CONGREGATION.
SHE WAS IN THIS ABUSIVE
RELATIONSHIP.
SEEING THOSE SCARS...
THE BOTTOM LINE IS
THAT... I BROKE IT OFF,
SHE WENT BACK TO GEORGE,
AND HE KILLED HER.
THE TRUTH IS, I GUESS,
I DIDN'T REALLY REALIZE
THAT I TRULY LOVED HER
UNTIL IT WAS TOO LATE.
BEING IN THAT HOUSE,
ALL THE BLOOD,
LIFE DRAINED FROM HER BODY,
ALL I COULD THINK OF
WAS KATIE
AND HOW HER LIFE
AS SHE KNEW IT WAS OVER.
I HAD TO HELP HER.
EVEN IF MEANS
GOING TO JAIL, I...
I'M SORRY.
I SHOULD GO.
NO. STAY.
IS THAT ALL RIGHT?
YEAH, OF COURSE.
IT'S ALMOST MORNING.
WE'LL TALK MORE THEN.
THANK YOU.
MY BAG IN THE CAR.
MRS. BENINCASA?
AH.
GOOD MORNING, PASTOR.
WE NEED TO TALK.
EMMET.
GENTLEMEN.
STEPHEN DREW,
YOU ARE UNDER ARREST FOR
THE MURDER OF GEORGE HAYWARD.
STEPHEN,
WILL YOU BAPTIZE ME?
DID YOU HEAR ME?
SORRY. YES.
ALICE, I THINK ABOUT YOU
ALL THE TIME.
DON'T.
THIS ISN'T ABOUT YOU AND ME.
IT'S ABOUT A RECOMMITMENT
TO MY FAITH.
WHAT ABOUT GEORGE?
WHAT WILL HE THINK?
I DON'T GIVE A DAMN
WHAT GEORGE THINKS.
SO, YOU'LL TELL HIM?
IF HE ASKS.
YOU THINK THAT'S SMART?
I'M THE MASTER
OF MY OWN DESTINY, STEPHEN...
NOT YOU AND NOT GEORGE.
SO, WILL YOU BAPTIZE ME?
YES, ALICE,
I'LL BAPTIZE YOU.
CAN I HELP YOU?
YEAH, YOU CAN STAY AWAY
FROM MY WIFE.
HOW ABOUT THAT?
OH, THERE'S SO MANY THINGS
I'D LIKE TO SAY TO YOU
RIGHT NOW.
YEAH?
SO, WHAT'S STOPPING YOU?
RESPECT FOR YOUR WIFE.
I SAW YOU TALKING
TO HER TODAY IN TOWN.
I FOLLOWED HER.
YOUR COWARDICE
ASTONISHES ME.
THE MORE INVOLVED SHE'S GOTTEN
WITH YOU AND YOUR CHURCH,
THE MORE DISRESPECTFUL
SHE'S GOTTEN AT HOME.
CHERISH WHAT YOU HAVE.
YOU PUT ANY MORE IDEAS
INTO MY WIFE'S HEAD,
AND I SWEAR TO GOD
I WILL KILL YOU.
HOW YOU DOING THESE DAYS?
I ACTUALLY FEEL PRETTY GUILTY
MOST OF THE TIME.
HOW COME?
SO, I JUST KEEP THINKING
THAT IF I DIDN'T GO
TO THAT CONCERT
AND IF I DIDN'T
LEAVE HER ALONE...
THEN THEY WOULDN'T
HAVE FOUGHT?
AND YOUR MOTHER
WOULD STILL BE ALIVE?
BUT THEY'D BOTH BE ALIVE,
YOU KNOW?
I MEAN, I COULDN'T BE THERE
ALL THE TIME.
AND THEY'D ACTUALLY
STOPPED FIGHTING,
SO I FIGURED JUST ONE NIGHT OUT
WITH MY FRIENDS WAS...
OF COURSE YOU DID, KATIE.
YOU'RE A KID.
YOU DESERVE THAT.
KATIE, IT WASN'T YOUR FAULT.
IT WASN'T.
MRS. BENINCASA, YOU THINK
THAT PASTOR DREW SHOT MY DAD,
DON'T YOU?
I'M SURE HE DID.
IT'S RIGHT AROUND HERE.
LET ME CHECK WITH THE OFFICE
AND I'LL GET BACK TO YOU.
I CAN'T BELIEVE
YOU'RE LETTING HIM GO.
YOU'VE GOT NO CONFESSION,
AND HE'S MADE BOND.
WE HAVE NO CHOICE
BUT TO LET HIM GO.
WE'LL NEVER BE ABLE
TO CONVICT HIM FOR MURDER
WITH WHAT WE HAVE.
I'M SORRY, CATHERINE.
SO, WHAT, ARE YOU GONNA
PRESS CHARGES NOW?
IS THAT PART
OF YOUR NEW ATTITUDE?
I SHOULD.
YOU GOT BAPTIZED
TO SPITE ME?
OH, GOD, HOW MANY TIMES
DO I HAVE TO TELL YOU?
THIS HAD NOTHING TO DO
WITH YOU.
IT WAS ABOUT ME,
GEORGE, ME!
YOU DID IT TO PLEASE HIM,
AND YOU DID IT TO MOCK ME.
WELL, GUESS WHAT.
A MAN LIKE THAT DOESN'T
WANT A WHORE LIKE YOU!
YES, HE DID!
HE WANTED ME!
AND HE HAD ME IN THIS HOUSE,
IN THIS KITCHEN,
IN THE BEDROOM!
AND GUESS WHAT!
I LIKED IT!
AH!
WHORE!
SHUT UP!
HELLO, PASTOR.
YOU HAVE NO EVIDENCE,
CATHERINE.
DON'T YOU THINK IT'S TIME
TO LET IT GO?
NO, BECAUSE I THINK YOU'RE
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER.
BUT I WON'T GIVE UP ON KATIE
LIKE YOU DID ON ALICE.
I'LL BE WATCHING YOU.
WITH SUMMER ALMOST OVER,
LIFE SEEMS TO BE
RETURNING TO NORMAL.
THE CASE IS COLD, AND NO OTHER
SUSPECTS WERE EVER NAMED.
I DON'T SEE MUCH OF CATHERINE BENINCASA THESE DAYS.
NOT SURPRISINGLY, SHE NO LONGER
ATTENDS MY CHURCH.
I STILL THINK OF ALICE
EVERY DAY.
I NOW KNOW THAT WHAT I DID
WAS PART OF GOD'S PLAN.
MANY OF MY CONGREGANTS
HAVE STRUGGLED
TO PUT THE EVENTS OF THE PAST
MONTHS BEHIND THEM,
BUT WE'RE BEGINNING
TO FIND OUR WAY AGAIN.
HEALING HAS A FUNNY WAY
OF FINDING ITS WAY
THROUGH DARKNESS.
KATIE HAS A LOT OF GRIEVING
TO DO,
BUT LIVING AT GINNY'S
HAS DONE HER SOME GOOD.
FOR WHAT IT'S WORTH, SHE KNOWS
I'LL ALWAYS BE THERE FOR HER.
HEY, PASTOR DREW.
THANKS AGAIN FOR EVERYTHING.
PROMISE ME
YOU'LL LET US KNOW
IF THERE'S ANYTHING YOU NEED.
NO, I WILL. I PROMISE.
OKAY.
GIVE ME THIS.
THANKS.
I AM GONNA MISS YOU
SO MUCH.
I'M GONNA MISS YOU, TOO.
DRIVE SAFE.
I'M GONNA MISS YOU
THE MOST.
YEAH.
THANKS FOR DRIVING ME.
YOU KIDDING ME?
IT'S MY HONOR.
YOU MUST BE EXCITED...
COLBY.
YEAH.
MMM.
BYE.
GUYS?
MOM?
DAD?
THE HAYWARDS...
THEY APPEARED
TO HAVE IT ALL...
MOM?
...BLESSED WITH GOOD HEALTH...
MOM?
MOM?! MOM?!
MO...
MO...
...AND A BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER,
KATIE...
DAD?
DAD? DAD, IT'S... DA...
...EVERY PARENT'S DREAM,
KIND-HEARTED, RESPONSIBLE,
AND SMART.
GEORGE OWNED A SUCCESSFUL CHAIN OF SPORTING-GOOD STORES
ACROSS THE STATE...
EVERY WOMAN'S DREAM.
ALICE WAS A HOMEMAKER,
AND SHE WAS ACTIVE IN CHURCH.
THE ALL-AMERICAN FAMILY.
BUT THAT'S THE TROUBLE OF BEING ON THE OUTSIDE, LOOKING IN...
YOU NEVER REALLY KNOW.
I DIDN'T KNOW
WHERE ELSE TO GO.
I COULDN'T GO BACK TO TINA'S.
YOU'RE SAFE HERE.
YOU'RE SAFE HERE.
YOU CAN TRUST ME.
PUT YOUR HANDS UNDER THERE.
SO, ARE WE... ARE WE
SUPPOSED TO CALL THE POLICE?
NO, NO, NO,
NO, NO, NO, NO.
WE'RE NOT GONNA CALL
THE POLICE.
YOU'RE NOT GONNA GO
TO JAIL.
I WON'T LET YOU RUIN
THE REST OF YOUR LIFE.
I'LL MAKE IT LOOK LIKE
YOUR FATHER SHOT HIMSELF.
YEAH, BUT WHAT IF THEY
FIND OUT THAT HE DIDN'T?
IF THEY SUSPECT ANYONE,
WE'LL LET THEM SUSPECT ME.
THEN YOU'LL GO TO JAIL,
RIGHT?
I KNOW.
ALL RIGHT, NOW,
WHAT ABOUT TINA?
DOES SHE KNOW YOU'RE GONE?
NO, SHE WAS ASLEEP
WHEN I LEFT.
I JUST WANTED TO GET
MY COMPUTER.
ALL RIGHT, THEN YOU NEED
TO GET BACK TO TINA'S,
AND I'LL TAKE CARE OF THIS.
YOU'D DO THAT FOR ME?
I WOULD.
AND I WILL.
THE POLICE ARE STARTING
TO SUSPECT ME,
WHICH IS A GOOD THING.
SO, IF THEY QUESTION YOU,
INCRIMINATE ME.
YEAH, BUT THEN
YOU'RE GONNA GET ARRESTED.
THEN YOU'RE GOING TO JAIL,
AND I DON'T WANT THAT.
THIS WHOLE THING'S MY FAULT,
ANYWAY.
THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH EVIDENCE
TO CONVICT ME,
BUT I WANT THEM TO THINK
THAT I DID IT.
LISTEN... THE ONLY WAY THAT
YOUR MOM WON'T DIE IN VAIN
IS IF YOU LIVE A HAPPY LIFE.
I WANT TO GIVE YOU
THAT CHANCE.
YEAH, BUT...
JUST DO WHAT I TELL YOU.
THANKS AGAIN FOR EVERYTHING,
PASTOR DREW.
I'D DO IT AGAIN
IN A HEARTBEAT.
IF I LIVE TO BE OLD, I KNOW
I'LL HAVE A TON OF REGRETS,
BUT PUTTING A BULLET
IN MY DAD'S HEAD
WON'T EVER BE ONE OF THEM.
A PECULIAR WAY OF TESTING YOU
WHEN YOU LEAST EXPECT IT.
WHEN I ARRIVED IN HAVERILL,
A SMALL TOWN IN THE GREEN HILLS OF VERMONT,
THE CHURCH WAS DECLINING
AND IN DESPERATE NEED OF HELP.
I HAD PRAYED FOR AN OPPORTUNITY TO GET OUT OF NEW YORK,
WHERE I WAS JUST ANOTHER FACE
IN A CROWD...
STEP INTO A COMMUNITY
THAT NEEDED A RESURGENCE
OF FAITH AND IDENTITY...
...WHERE I COULD MAKE
A REAL DIFFERENCE.
I'VE ALWAYS FELT THAT CHANGE
COMES FROM A GRASSROOTS EFFORT
AND THAT A CONGREGATION GROWS
WITH THE YOUNGER GENERATION.
SO I STARTED A MUSICAL YOUTH
GROUP CALLED THE SERMONS.
WE'D PRACTICE A COUPLE TIMES
A WEEK AND PERFORM REGULARLY
FOR THE TOURISTS WHO VISIT
FOR THE OVERPRICED ANTIQUES,
ICE CREAM, AND MAPLE SYRUP.
DURING THE SUNDAY SERVICES,
CONCERNS STILL
OUTNUMBER THE JOYS,
AND SOMETIMES
I WISH MY CONGREGANTS
WOULD TAKE A LITTLE PROZAC
WITH THEIR PRAYER.
THE DOWNSIDE TO LIFE
IN A SMALL TOWN
IS EVERYONE WANTS TO KNOW
EACH OTHER'S BUSINESS.
SECRETS BEHIND CLOSED DOORS
ARE EVENTUALLY EXPOSED.
TAKE THE HAYWARDS.
THEY APPEARED TO HAVE IT ALL...
THE ALL-AMERICAN FAMILY...
...BLESSED WITH GOOD HEALTH
AND A BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER,
KATIE.
SHE WAS EVERY PARENT'S DREAM...
...KIND-HEARTED, RESPONSIBLE,
AND SMART.
GEORGE OWNED A SUCCESSFUL CHAIN OF SPORTING-GOOD STORES
ACROSS THE STATE...
EVERY WOMAN'S DREAM.
ALICE WAS A HOMEMAKER,
AND SHE WAS ACTIVE IN OUR
CHURCH, LOYAL AND STRONG.
THAT'S THE TROUBLE WITH BEING
ON THE OUTSIDE, LOOKING IN...
YOU NEVER REALLY KNOW.
OH, HEY, EMMET.
HI, CATHERINE.
WHAT DO WE GOT?
GEORGE HAYWARD STRANGLED
HIS WIFE, ALICE,
AND THEN SHOT HIMSELF.
OH, MY GOD.
I DON'T THINK I'VE EVER SEEN YOU
LOOK SHOCKED BEFORE.
THEY SEEMED LIKE
THE PERFECT COUPLE,
LIKE, UH,
REAL NORMAN ROCKWELL STUFF.
DANCE STARTS
IN THE DINING ROOM,
AND IT ENDS RIGHT HERE.
LOOKS LIKE SHE PUT UP QUITE
A FIGHT ALONG THE WAY...
A LOT OF BLOODY SKIN
UNDER HER FINGERNAILS
APPEAR TO MATCH
MARKS ON HIM...
WHAT'S LEFT OF HIM.
THEIR DAUGHTER...
WHERE'S KATIE?
HAS SHE BEEN BY HERE?
SPENT THE NIGHT
AT A FRIEND'S HOUSE... TINA.
TINA'S MOTHER, GINNY,
IS THE ONE WHO ACTUALLY FOUND
THE BODIES.
ALICE WAS APPARENTLY LATE
FOR SOME CHURCH THING,
SO GINNY CALLS, NO ANSWER,
COMES TO CHECK ON HER.
IT SEEMS MR. HAYWARD
WAS QUITE A DRINKER...
BEER BOTTLES EVERYWHERE.
PLACE SMELLS LIKE A FRAT HOUSE
ON A SUNDAY MORNING.
HOW'S THAT FIT INTO YOUR
NORMAN ROCKWELL PICTURE?
IT DOESN'T.
WHAT HAPPENED TO YOUR HAND?
THE DOG BIT ME.
WELL, DID YOU CALL
ANIMAL CONTROL?
NO. I DIDN'T HAVE TO.
PASTOR SHOWED UP.
WHOA. WATCH IT.
DOG DOESN'T SEEM
TO MIND HIM.
MM.
Stand by.
DISPATCH,
THIS IS BURNHAM 23,
LEAVING THE SCENE
IN MAYBE 10 MINUTES.
Stand by.
WATCH THAT DOG, GUYS.
CATHERINE.
PASTOR.
GINNY CALLED, HYSTERICAL.
I THOUGHT I'D COME BY
AND SEE IF THERE'S ANYTHING
I COULD DO TO HELP.
HOW ABOUT GETTING THAT DOG
OUT OF HERE?
NAH, WE'RE GOOD.
ALL RIGHT, I'LL TAKE HER
BACK TO KATIE.
THANKS, PASTOR.
WE APPRECIATE IT.
NEWS TRAVELS FAST.
WELL, SMALL TOWN.
LET'S GO.
OH, I'M SO GLAD
YOU COULD BE HERE FOR ALICE.
THANK YOU.
GOD BLESS YOU.
HELLO, MR. JOHNSON.
THANK YOU GUYS FOR COMING.
THANK YOU.
NOW, KATIE, YOU SURE
I CAN'T TALK YOU
INTO TAKING THE PLUNGE?
TWO FOR THE PRICE
OF ONE TODAY?
YEAH, I THINK
IT'S JUST MOM TODAY.
ALL RIGHT. I'M GONNA STAY
ON YOU, YOUNG LADY.
THANKS.
HE'S SO EXCITED.
I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE HERE,
SWEETIE.
YEAH, ME, TOO.
READY?
YEAH, I AM.
ALICE HAYWARD, DO YOU BELIEVE
IN THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
AS YOUR PERSONAL SAVIOR?
I DO.
AND DO YOU INTEND
TO FOLLOW HIM ALL THE DAYS
OF YOUR LIFE?
I DO.
LEAN BACK.
THERE.
HOW IS SHE?
HER DAD JUST CHOKED
HER MOM TO DEATH
AND BLEW HIS HEAD OFF.
HOW DO YOU THINK
SHE'S DOING?
GINNY, WE HAVE TO STICK
TOGETHER FOR KATIE.
HI, PASTOR DREW.
IN.
I'M SO SORRY.
I'M HERE FOR YOU, KATIE.
I'M HERE FOR YOU.
WE SHARED SOMETHING
DEEPLY PROFOUND TODAY.
I WISH I COULD HUG YOU.
YOU CAN HUG ME, ALICE.
MM.
I'LL GET SOME ICED TEA.
OH!
I AM SO PROUD OF YOU.
I KNOW THIS SORT OF THING
ISN'T VERY COOL.
NO, IT'S COOL IF YOU DO IT.
YOU KNOW WHAT ELSE
IS REALLY COOL?
THE FRAY.
AND, UH, THEY'RE GIVING
A CONCERT TONIGHT IN ALBANY.
WOW.
AND I WON TWO TICKETS.
THAT IS GREAT.
YOU'RE IN ON THIS.
I THOUGHT KATIE COULD STAY
WITH US AFTERWARD.
YOU HAD A BIG DAY.
YOU DESERVE SOME PEACE.
PLEASE?
DID YOU WANT TO CHECK
WITH DAD?
OH, WHY?
I KNOW HE'D SAY YES.
NO. GO. HAVE FUN.
REALLY?
THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
BUT NO DRINKING,
NO SMOKING.
NOPE.
AND GET ME A T-SHIRT.
I LOVE THE FRAY.
YOU'RE THE COOLEST MOM EVER.
I'LL BE CAREFUL
WHEN I DRIVE, OKAY?
OKAY.
ARE YOU SURE YOU'LL BE OKAY
TONIGHT?
YEAH, OF COURSE.
HAVE FUN.
HI, HEATHER.
NICE TO SEE YOU.
YOU DID IT.
NO ONE CAN TAKE THIS
AWAY FROM YOU.
LET'S TALK LATER.
STOP BY NEXT TIME
YOU'RE SHOPPING.
OKAY.
ALICE.
HEATHER. YOU CAME.
I DIDN'T WANT TO MISS
THIS SPECIAL MOMENT FOR YOU.
I STAYED IN THE BACK.
I DIDN'T WANT
TO DRAW ATTENTION.
THIS IS FOR YOU...
A GANESH,
TO HELP REMOVE ALL OBSTACLES
FROM YOUR PATH.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
HEATHER LaROCHE
CAME TO MY BAPTISM.
YES, I SEE.
HELLO, MISS LaROCHE.
HI.
NICE TO MEET YOU.
WHAT DID YOU THINK?
IMMERSION, INCLUSION.
YOU GOT RID OF THE BIBLE.
COULD HAVE BEEN
A PAGAN RITUAL.
DOES THAT MEAN YOU LIKED IT?
IT MEANS OUR BELIEFS
AREN'T ALWAYS AS FAR APART
AS ONE MIGHT THINK.
IS YOUR HUSBAND HERE?
I WANTED TO MEET HIM.
NO, HE, UM... HE WANTED
TO COME, BUT HE HAD TO WORK.
SO WE'LL HAVE A CELEBRATORY
DINNER TONIGHT.
MORE PIE FOR US, RIGHT? YEAH.
SO, YOU GOT BAPTIZED TODAY?
MM-HMM.
REALLY?
THOUGHT
WE HAD DISCUSSED IT.
WE DID.
AND I INVITED YOU.
YOU MUST HAVE
JUST FORGOTTEN.
LET'S EAT.
WHAT,
YOU WENT IN THE RIVER?
YEAH.YOU ACTUALLY GOT
IN THE WATER?
YEAH.
SO, WHO WAS THERE?
UM... THANKS... THE WOMEN'S
CIRCLE FROM THE CHURCH
AND GINNY, OF COURSE.
OF COURSE.
WHO ELSE?
OH, HEATHER LaROCHE.
COME ON.
WHAT, THE CRACKPOT
WHO WRITES ABOUT ANGELS?
WOW.
SO, WHO ELSE?
KATIE.
MM-HMM.
WHO YOU LET GO
TO A CONCERT TONIGHT...
WITHOUT ASKING ME?
IT'S NOT
THE DARK AGES, GEORGE.
I DON'T HAVE TO ASK
YOUR PERMISSION.
EXCUSE ME?
WELL, WHEN IT COMES
TO OUR DAUGHTER,
YOU DO, RIGHT?
JUST GOT USED TO MAKING
DECISIONS ON MY OWN
WHEN YOU WERE AWAY.
WH... WHILE I WAS AWAY?
WHAT?
NO, YOU THREW ME OUT.
REMEMBER?
YOU THREW ME DOWN THE STAIRS
AND BROKE MY ARM.
SO, WHAT, THIS IS HOW
YOU TALK TO ME NOW?
WELL, AT LEAST
I DIDN'T PRESS CHARGES.
YOU KNOW, YOU COULD
THANK ME FOR THAT.
THANK YOU?
WOW.
SO, I GO AWAY FOR, WHAT,
FOUR MONTHS, I COME BACK,
EVERYTHING HERE
IS DIFFERENT.
YOU HAVE A NEW OUTFIT.
YOU HAVE A NEW HAIRDO.
YOU HAVE A NEW ATTITUDE.
IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE?
WHAT WERE YOU WEARING
AT THE BAPTISM?
NEVER MIND. EAT.
I FORGOT THE SALAD.
I SAID,
"WHAT WERE YOU WEARING"?
GEORGE, PLEASE...
JUST TELL ME.
A LONG SHIRT
OVER A BATHING SUIT.
SO YOU MADE A SPECTACLE
OF YOURSELF.
IT WAS A SACRED CEREMONY.
IN FRONT
OF THE ENTIRE TOWN.
IT WAS NOT
THE ENTIRE TOWN.
A WET SHIRT... EVERYONE SEE
HOW TURNED ON YOU WERE?
I WASN'T TURNED ON, GEORGE.
BY HIM, HUH?
BY YOUR PASTOR.
YOU'RE BEING RIDICULOUS.
AAH!
OW.
OKAY.
YOU'RE NOT GOING
TO THAT CHURCH ANYMORE.
AAH!
STOP IT, GEORGE.
PASTOR DREW, YOU'RE BACK.
YEAH, I NEED TO PICK UP
A FEW THINGS FOR KATIE,
AND I THOUGHT I'D CLEAN UP
IF YOU WERE GUYS ARE DONE.
WELL, WE ALREADY ORDERED
A CLEAN-UP FOR TOMORROW.
WELL, I'D LIKE TO GET
IN THERE IF I CAN.
I'D HATE TO RISK KATIE
SEEING IT.
UH...
MY GUYS ARE DONE.
OKAY?
YEAH. IT IS PRETTY GRUESOME
IN THERE.
THERE'S A LOT
OF BLOOD, PASTOR.
I CAN HANDLE IT.
OKAY.
I WISH SOMEBODY
WOULD CLEAN MY HOUSE.
MRS. BENINCASA?
YES?
I'M HEATHER LaROCHE.
I WAS A FRIEND
OF ALICE HAYWARD'S.
AH.
I REALLY NEED
TO TALK TO YOU.
COME IN. SIT DOWN.
THANK YOU.
I JUST FEEL SO SICK
ABOUT THIS.
JUST BEEN TRYING
TO MAKE SENSE OF IT.
I WAS... I WAS HOPING
YOU COULD TELL ME SOMETHING.
I'M SORRY. I CAN'T TALK
ABOUT IT AT THIS TIME.
WERE YOU A FRIEND
OF GEORGE'S, AS WELL?
NO, NO, JUST ALICE.
IN FACT, WE ONLY BECAME FRIENDS
IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS,
BUT I FELT LIKE WE'D KNOWN
EACH OTHER A LONG TIME.
SHE, UM...
SHE CAME TO MY SHOP
ONE AFTERNOON.
SHE APPEARED TO BE LOST,
LOOKING FOR SOMETHING...
OR SOMEONE TO HELP HER.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
WELL, ALICE DIDN'T TALK MUCH
ABOUT HER PRIVATE LIFE.
HER RELATIONSHIP WITH GEORGE
SEEMED OFF LIMITS.
DID SHE SAY WHY?
NO. WE... WHEN ALICE AND I
WERE GETTING
TO KNOW EACH OTHER,
IT WAS WHILE
THEY WERE SEPARATED.
UM, THEY GOT BACK TOGETHER
JUST... JUST
BEFORE HER BAPTISM.
UH, WHEN WAS SHE BAPTIZED?
YESTERDAY.
SHE WAS SO HAPPY.
DO YOU KNOW ANYONE ELSE
WHO COULD TELL US MORE
ABOUT ALICE'S RELATIONSHIP
WITH GEORGE?
GINNY McBRADDEN.
THEY WERE BEST FRIENDS.
WHY?
'CAUSE HE BEAT THE CRAP
OUT OF HER FOR YEARS.
HE WHIPPED HER LIKE A DOG.
I HAD NO IDEA.
NO ONE DID.
SHE WAS EMBARRASSED BY IT,
ASHAMED.
BUT EVENTUALLY SHE'D HAD
ENOUGH AND THREW HIM OUT?
YEAH, AND THEN
AFTER A FEW MONTHS,
SHE LET HIM COME BACK.
AND YOU KNOW THE REST.
SORRY. JUST BE A MOMENT.
I APPRECIATE YOU NOT BOTHERING
KATIE WITH ALL OF THIS.
SHE'S BEEN THROUGH ENOUGH.
DID, UH... DID GEORGE
EVER HIT KATIE?
NO. HE LOVED THAT GIRL.
AND SHE LOVED HIM.
SHE WAS
HIS LITTLE PRINCESS.
HE NEVER EVEN TOUCHED ALICE
WHEN SHE WAS AROUND.
AND THEY CERTAINLY
SEEMED TO KNOW
HOW TO KEEP UP APPEARANCES.
YOU COULD SAY THAT.
SHE DID CONFIDE IN YOU?
SURE.
AND SHE TOLD YOU THE TRUTH
ABOUT HER MARRIAGE?
SOME OF IT.
BUT SHE KNEW I HAD ZERO SYMPATHY
FOR THAT MAN, NONE.
I CHEERED
WHEN SHE KICKED HIM OUT.
AND I CURSED WHEN
SHE BROUGHT HIM BACK,
AT WHICH POINT SHE STOPPED
TALKING TO ME ABOUT IT.
SO THIS WAS A WOMAN WHO HAD
NO ONE TO CONFIDE IN
AND NOWHERE TO GO.
OH, SHE HAD SOMEWHERE TO GO...
PASTORAL COUNSELING.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
ASK STEPHEN DREW.
UM, COME ON.
WE GOT TO GO.
OKAY.
UH, THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FOR YOUR TIME.
YEAH, OKAY,
WE'RE ON OUR WAY.
WELL, THAT'S INTERESTING.
WHAT'S GOING ON?
THAT WAS
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER.
GEORGE HAYWARD
DIDN'T SHOOT HIMSELF.
SOMEONE ELSE DID.
THE ENTRANCE WOUND
HAS A DOWNWARD TRAJECTORY
OF A 90-DEGREE ANGLE.
THE BLOOD SPATTER'S
INCONGRUENT
WITH THE WOUND ENTERING
FROM ANY OTHER ANGLE.
YEAH, BUT THE GUY WAS DRUNK.
THE GUN COULD HAVE SLIPPED.
NOT ALL SUICIDES ARE TEXTBOOK.
THERE WAS NO BLOWBACK
ON THE GUN.
THERE WAS NO RESIDUE
ON HIS HAND.
SO, DO YOU KNOW WHERE
THE SHOT CAME FROM?
THE SHOT CAME IN HERE,
FROM BEHIND AND ABOVE.
OKAY, SO,
THEY'RE HAVING DINNER,
THEY HAVE A FIGHT,
IT ESCALATES,
HE STRANGLES HER,
SOMEONE COMES IN TO STOP IT,
IT'S TOO LATE,
AND THEN...
EXCEPT SHE DIED FOUR HOURS
BEFORE HE DID.
ALL RIGHT, SO, HE KILLS HER,
THEN GETS LOADED
FOR A FEW HOURS...
PASSES OUT.
SOMEONE DISCOVERS THEM...
...AND DECIDES TO EXACT
A LITTLE RETRIBUTION.
WHOEVER DID IT
WIPED THE GUN DOWN
AND PUT IT IN GEORGE'S HAND
BEFORE TAKING OFF.
IT ALL FITS.
YEP.
COOL. UH,
ONE MORE THING...
ALICE'S LOWER BACK WAS COVERED
WITH FRESH CONTUSIONS,
24 TO 48 HOURS OLD.
HER KIDNEYS
ARE BADLY BRUISED.
SO, YOU'RE SAYING THAT
GEORGE BEAT HER A DAY OR TWO
BEFORE HE KILLED HER?
SON OF A BITCH.
SO, MY DAD DIDN'T
KILL HIMSELF, THEN.
SOMEONE SHOT HIM
WHEN HE WAS ASLEEP.
KATIE, HE WAS UNCONSCIOUS
WHEN HE DIED.
HE WOULDN'T HAVE FELT
A THING.
SO, WHO WOULD WANT
TO KILL MY DAD, THEN?
SOMEONE WHO WAS ANGRY
WITH HIM
FOR WHAT HE DID
TO YOUR MOTHER.
CAN YOU THINK
OF ANYBODY WHO...
LIKE... LIKE A FRIEND
OR SOMETHING, LIKE...
YEAH, SOMEONE WHO WAS CLOSE
TO YOUR MOM.
MOM DIDN'T REALLY HAVE
A LOT OF CLOSE FRIENDS.
NO ONE AT ALL?
THEY LOOK SO HAPPY HERE.
YOU KNOW, I WISH
THAT SOMEBODY HAD A RECORDER
AT MY MOM'S BAPTISM.
SHE WAS SO HAPPY,
AND SHE WASN'T AFRAID ANYMORE.
OF YOUR DAD?
OR ELSE SHE WOULDN'T
HAVE DONE IT, YOU KNOW?
DONE WHAT?
GOT BAPTIZED.
OH.
SHE KNEW THAT HE'D GET MAD,
AND SHE JUST DIDN'T CARE.
AND WHAT DID YOUR DAD THINK
OF STEPHEN DREW?
OH, UH, HE HATED HIM.
COME ON, GIRLS.
WE HAVE TO GO.
KATIE.
WHAT'S WRONG?
I THINK SHE WANTS
TO BE LEFT ALONE.
HTH?
HOW DO WE GATHER IN THE PLACE
WHERE SHE WORSHIPPED,
SHE LOVED SO MUCH,
SHE DID SUCH GOOD WORK,
AND NOT HAVE HER AMONG US?
WELL, SHE IS WITH US.
SHE'S ALL AROUND US.
SHE'S IN OUR HEARTS...
OUR MEMORY...
GOOD WORK...
AND... CERTAINLY IN HER BEAUTIFUL
DAUGHTER, KATIE.
YOU KNOW, YOUR SMILE REMINDS ME
OF ONE OF YOUR MOTHER'S GIFTS.
SHE COULD ALWAYS TAKE A NEGATIVE
AND TURN IT INTO A POSITIVE.
YOU RECALL THE, UM... THE QUILT
THAT THE WOMEN'S CIRCLE MADE.
TOOK THEM ABOUT A YEAR.
IT WAS A BEAUTIFUL QUILT.
AND THEY WERE GONNA RAFFLE IT
OFF AT THE SUMMER FAIR.
AND A FERAL CAT
FROM THE CEMETERY
FOUND ITS WAY TO THAT QUILT,
AND SHE GAVE BIRTH
TO A BEAUTIFUL LITTER.
OF COURSE, THE QUILT WAS RUINED,
BUT ALICE JUST LOOKED AT IT
AND SAID, "THANK GOD
THE KITTENS WERE WARM."
"AND THANK GOD
THE KITTENS WERE SAFE."
I COULD IMAGINE THERE WERE TIMES
IN ALICE'S LIFE
WHERE SHE DIDN'T FEEL SAFE.
BUT I'D LIKE TO BELIEVE
SHE'S SAFE NOW.
YOU ARE WELCOME TO COME UP
AND PAY YOUR RESPECTS
TO OUR BEAUTIFUL ALICE
AFTER THE FAMILY.
HEY, MOM.
I LOVE YOU.
Katie.
HOW YOU HOLDING UP...
ALL RIGHT?
YEAH. THANKS.
HONEY, WHAT'S UP?
HE'S HIDING SOMETHING.
THANK YOU, VICKY.
PASTOR. EXCUSE ME.
WOULD YOU HAVE A MINUTE
TO TALK ABOUT ALICE HAYWARD?
YOU KNOW,
IT'S BEEN A LONG DAY.
I HOPE YOU UNDERSTAND.
I DO.
I'LL JUST WALK WITH YOU,
IF YOU DON'T MIND.
GINNY McBRADDEN SAID
THAT YOU COUNSELED ALICE,
SO I THOUGHT YOU MIGHT BE ABLE
TO PROVIDE SOME INSIGHT.
I'M SORRY.
YOU WERE AWARE THAT ALICE
WAS BEING ABUSED
BY GEORGE, CORRECT?
I COUNSELED HER MANY TIMES
ABOUT HER MARRIAGE.
THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY.
DID YOU EVER DO ANYTHING
TO INTERVENE?
NO.
WAS ALICE SEEING ANYBODY ELSE
WHILE SHE WAS SEPARATED?
I'LL REMIND YOU
ALICE WAS BURIED TODAY.
PLEASE SHOW
A LITTLE RESPECT.
AND I'LL REMIND YOU
THAT WE ARE JUST CONDUCTING
AN INVESTIGATION.
NOW, SOMEBODY SHOT GEORGE
AFTER GEORGE KILLED ALICE,
SO MAYBE SHE MENTIONED
ANOTHER MAN
DURING HER COUNSELING
WITH YOU.
MAYBE HE KNEW SOMETHING
ABOUT IT.
CATHERINE,
I CAN'T SPEAK TO THAT.
ALL RIGHT.
EARLIER LAST YEAR,
ALICE KICKED GEORGE
OUT OF THE HOUSE,
AND THEN SHE TOOK HIM BACK.
BOY, YOU KEEP GOING, HUH? CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT?
THERE'S NO NEED
TO PATRONIZE ME.
BUT HOW DID YOU FEEL
ABOUT THAT,
AFTER ALICE FINALLY GOT
THE COURAGE TO KICK GEORGE OUT
AND THEN SHE TURNED AROUND
AND TOOK HIM BACK?
THAT MUST HAVE UPSET YOU.
GEORGE WAS A DANGEROUS MAN,
AND I TOLD HER THAT
MANY TIMES.
CATHERINE,
THIS IS A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY.
OTHER THAN THAT,
THAT'S ALL I CAN TELL YOU.
ALICE'S SPIRIT
HAS NOW BEEN RELEASED.
SHE'S NOW ONE WITH THE LIGHT,
WITH THE AIR... AND THE SKY.
SHE HAS ENTERED
THE REALM OF ANGELS,
AND THEY HAVE WELCOMED HER.
LET THE GOODNESS OF ALICE'S
HEART EXPAND OUR HEARTS.
LET ALICE AND THE ANGELS
COME TO US, INSPIRE US,
REMIND US THAT THERE IS LIFE
IN THE AIR WE BREATHE...
...LIFE IN THE LIGHT WE SEEK.
LET'S TAKE A MOMENT
TO CLOSE OUR EYES
AND FEEL ALICE'S ENERGY
SURROUND US.
HI, THERE.
HI.
CAN I HELP YOU?
I, UH... I WALK
BY YOUR STORE ALL THE TIME.
I'VE... I'VE NEVER HAD
THE NERVE TO COME IN BEFORE.
WELL, YOU'RE HERE NOW.
COME ON IN.
GREAT.
TAKE A LOOK AROUND.
I'M HEATHER.
YEAH, I KNOW.
WE ALL KNOW.
I'VE READ ALL YOUR BOOKS
AND I'VE SEEN
YOUR INTERVIEWS ON TV
AND ONCE I EVEN... I WROTE
HOW MUCH I LIKED YOUR WORK
ON ONE OF THOSE
ONLINE BOOKSTORES.
OH. THANKS FOR DOING THAT.
I DON'T... I STOPPED
READING THOSE AWHILE AGO.
SOME PEOPLE CAN BE
KIND OF NASTY.
I PROMISE YOU, YOUR BOOKS
HAVE HELPED SO MANY PEOPLE.
IT'S SO BEAUTIFUL IN HERE.
IT'S SO PEACEFUL.
THANK YOU.
I'M SORRY.
I DIDN'T CATCH YOUR NAME.
OH, MY GOD... ALICE,
ALICE HAYWARD.
IT'S SO NICE TO MEET YOU.
HI. IT'S NICE TO MEET YOU,
ALICE.
IT WAS GREAT.
WE TALKED ABOUT SPIRITUALITY
AND ABOUT A LOT
OF DIFFERENT THINGS.
YOU SHOULD READ THE BOOK.
SHE TALKS ABOUT CHRIST
AS A PROPHET,
LIKE BUDDHA OR KRISHNA.
SHE SAYS THAT WE'RE ALL ONE,
ALL A PART OF THE UNIVERSE.
HMM. I DON'T CARE
WHAT THE HELL SHE SAID,
AS LONG AS IT INSPIRED YOU
TO KICK GEORGE OUT.
I STILL THINK YOU SHOULD
GET A RESTRAINING ORDER.
I DON'T NEED TO.
ALICE,
HE'S NOT GONNA CHANGE.
YOU NEED TO START
PROTECTING YOURSELF.
GINNY, HE KNOWS
HE WENT TOO FAR.
HE DOES.
THAT'S WHY HE'S STAYING AWAY.
WHAT IF HE COMES BACK?
IT HASN'T BEEN THAT LONG.
I DON'T WANT
TO PRESS CHARGES.
I DON'T WANT PEOPLE
KNOWING.
OH, PEOPLE KNOW.
GINNY, PLEASE.
NOT FOR MY SAKE,
BUT FOR KATIE'S, OKAY?
THANK YOU
FOR THE PRAYER CIRCLE.
I CAN SEE
WHY ALICE LOVED IT.
WELL, I'M JUST SORRY KATIE
WASN'T ABLE TO MAKE IT.
I ENCOURAGED HER TO COME,
BUT IT'S JUST
TOO SOON FOR HER.
YEAH.
HOW'S SHE DOING, ANYWAY?
WELL, SHE'S A STRONG KID,
BUT SHE'S... SHE'S
REALLY SUFFERING.
SHE WON'T COME OUT
OF HER ROOM.
I-I... I JUST DON'T KNOW
WHAT TO DO FOR HER.
I CAN'T IMAGINE HOW DIFFICULT
THIS MUST BE FOR HER.
PLEASE TELL HER
TO COME BY ANYTIME.
YOU KNOW, YOU AND ALICE
REALLY CONNECTED.
WHY DON'T YOU COME SEE HER?
WELL, I DON'T WANT TO IMPOSE
IF SHE'D RATHER BE ALONE.
SHE WON'T TALK TO ANYONE.
I CAN'T SEEM TO GET
THROUGH TO HER.
MAYBE SHE'LL TALK WITH YOU.
I DON'T KNOW. THERE'S
SOMETHING ABOUT THIS PASTOR.
I DON'T TRUST HIM.
HE'S EDGY WITH ME.
HE'S DEFENSIVE.
WHAT ABOUT
THE BEST FRIEND?
WOULDN'T SHE HAVE
JUST AS MUCH MOTIVE?
WELL, SHE DOES
COME RIGHT OUT
AND SAY HOW MUCH
SHE HATED GEORGE,
BUT THE KIDS WERE BEST FRIENDS,
AND SHE ADORES KATIE.
SO, NO MATTER HOW MUCH
SHE MAY HAVE DESPISED GEORGE,
I DON'T SEE HER DOING THAT
TO KATIE.
MY GUT SAYS STEPHEN DREW.
WELL, DON'T LET YOUR GUT
INTERFERE WITH BUILDING A CASE.
FOCUS ON THE LAW.
WE DON'T WANT A WITCH HUNT.
OH, I FORGOT...
IT'S AN ELECTION YEAR.
YOU'RE JUST WORRIED HOW
IT'LL LOOK TO THE VOTERS.
YOU KNOW, NO ONE ELSE
COULD GET AWAY
WITH SAYING THAT TO ME.
AW, COME ON, JIM.
THAT'S WHY YOU HIRED ME.
CATHERINE,
I'M SERIOUS ABOUT THIS.
SO AM I, JIM.
LOOK... WE ALL KNOW
THAT GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS AN AWFUL MAN.
HE BEAT HIS WIFE, AND THEN HE
KILLED HER, FOR GOD'S SAKE.
BUT HE WAS PASSED OUT
WHEN SOMEONE PUT A BULLET
THROUGH HIS HEAD,
AND I DON'T CARE IF IT WAS
THE COUNTRY PASTOR WHO DID IT.
I CARE THAT SOMEONE
DID IT.
MURDER IS MURDER.
THAT'S WHY I HIRED YOU.
MY MOM WAS CHANGING,
WASN'T SHE?
SHE WAS BECOMING
REALLY INDEPENDENT.
BUT I THINK
THAT'S WHAT PUSHED HER
AWAY FROM MY DAD.
I THINK SO, YEAH.
BUT THEN
SHE GOT TO DISCOVER
SOME OF THE ANGELS
IN HER LIFE.
I THINK THAT'S WHY
SHE HUNG OUT WITH YOU
AND PASTOR DREW SO MUCH.
WELL, IF YOU'RE SUGGESTING
WE WERE HER ANGELS,
I'M AFRAID WE DIDN'T DO
A VERY GOOD JOB.
WELL, I'M GLAD THAT
SHE HAD YOU GUYS, ANYWAY.
ME, TOO.
WHAT IS IT?
YOU KNOW THAT THING YOU GAVE
MY MOM AT THE PICNIC?
YEAH. THE GANESH?
YEAH.
I WAS TALKING TO GINNY,
AND I SAID THAT IT SHOULD GO
IN HER CASKET.
I THINK SHE REALLY
WOULD HAVE LIKED IT THERE.
BUT THE THING IS
PASTOR DREW WANTED HER
TO HAVE HIS BIBLE.
LIKE, HIS PERSONAL BIBLE?
YEAH.
WOW.
I DIDN'T WANT MY MOM
TO LIE THERE FOREVER
WITH A BIBLE IN HER HANDS,
EVEN IF IT WAS HIS.
DOES HE KNOW THAT?
OH, NO.
CAN WE NOT TELL HIM?
'CAUSE, I MEAN, HE THINKS
IT'S WITH HER AND...
I WOULDN'T TELL HIM.
THANKS.
PASTOR.
SO TRANQUIL HERE, SO SAFE.
NO WONDER ALICE LIKED IT.
STEPHEN DREW IN MY SHOP.
HMM. WELL, I WANTED TO COME
AND, WELL, JUST BE
AROUND PEOPLE THAT SHE KNEW,
PEOPLE THAT SHE LIKED.
WELL, GINNY AND ALICE
WERE MUCH CLOSER.
YEAH, BUT ALICE
WAS INSPIRED BY YOU.
I MEAN, SHE SEEMED TO SEE
A CONNECTION
BETWEEN OUR BELIEFS.
I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT THAT IS.
WELL, THEY'RE NOT
SO DIFFERENT.
I COULD START WITH ANGELS.
I THINK YOU AND I
PROBABLY VIEW THEM
IN MUCH THE SAME WAY...
CELESTIAL GUIDES
AND PROTECTORS.
WHERE WERE
ALICE'S ANGELS?
I DON'T KNOW.
I WISH I COULD HAVE
DONE MORE FOR HER.
MM. ME, TOO.
GINNY, EXCUSE ME.
I HAVE SOME MORE QUESTIONS
FOR YOU
ABOUT THE NIGHT
OF THE MURDERS.
FOR ME?
MM-HMM.
WELL, THE PERSON
YOU SHOULD BE SPEAKING TO
IS DOWN AT AURASCAPES,
PAYING A VISIT
TO HEATHER LaROCHE.
HEATHER LaROCHE?
I HONORED STEPHEN'S REQUEST
TO PROTECT KATIE,
BUT I CANNOT GET PAST HIM
FLIRTING WITH HEATHER
ON TOP OF EVERYTHING ELSE.
ALL RIGHT, NOTED, BUT I NEED
TO KNOW WHERE YOU WERE
WHEN GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS KILLED.
IN MY BED, ASLEEP.
CAN ANYONE VERIFY THAT?
WHAT'S THIS ABOUT?
GINNY...
DID ALICE WRITE SOMETHING
ABOUT ME IN HER JOURNAL?
EXCUSE ME?
YOU HAVEN'T FOUND
ALICE'S JOURNAL?
IT'S IN HER HOUSE
SOMEWHERE,
AND I'M SURE WHATEVER
SHE WROTE ABOUT ME
IS MUCH LESS INTERESTING
THAN WHATEVER SHE WROTE
ABOUT THE AFFAIR.
GEORGE WAS HAVING
AN AFFAIR?
HELLO?
ALICE WAS HAVING
AN AFFAIR?
WITH WHO?
TAKE A BIG GUESS.
I'VE BEEN COMING TO YOUR CHURCH
FOR THREE YEARS,
BUT I'VE NEVER REALLY KNOWN
ANYTHING ABOUT YOU
UNTIL NOW.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND.
I'M SURE YOU DON'T.
WHAT IS THAT?
ALICE'S JOURNAL.
SHE STARTED KEEPING IT RIGHT
AFTER SHE THREW GEORGE OUT.
AND IT'S PRETTY CLEAR
THAT, DURING THAT TIME,
PASTORAL COUNSELING
WASN'T THE ONLY THING
SHE GOT FROM YOU.
IS THIS UNCOMFORTABLE
FOR YOU?
I NEVER MEANT FOR THIS
TO HAPPEN.
THAT'S THE TRUTH.
I SWEAR TO GOD.
I KICKED HIM OUT.
BUT I'M SCARED.
OF WHAT?
WHETHER I MADE
THE RIGHT DECISION OR NOT.
MONTHS GO BY,
AND GEORGE IS WONDERFUL.
HE'S TENDER.
LONG STRETCHES
WHERE EVERYTHING'S FINE.
IT COMES
IN PEAKS AND VALLEYS.
HE GETS SO ANGRY.
AND THEN HE CALMS.
BUT HE TRICKS YOU
WITH THAT CALM.
YOU THINK IT'S SAFE,
AND THEN SUDDENLY,
JUST OUT OF NOWHERE, HE RAGES.
I THINK
YOU'RE VERY COURAGEOUS.
I CAN'T HAVE KATIE
THINKING THIS IS NORMAL.
IT'S MY FAULT.
NO.
IT'S DAMAGED HER.
THEY USED TO BE SO CLOSE,
BUT LATELY I FEEL HER
PULLING AWAY.
IT MUST CHIP AWAY
HER LOVE FOR HIM.
I'M SURE IT DOES.
I HATE MYSELF FOR THAT.
NO.
I WANT TO BE
A GOOD EXAMPLE FOR HER.
I DON'T WANT HER
REPEATING MY MISTAKES.
GOOD.
YOU KNOW, UNDER HIS ANGER,
GEORGE... HE'S A GOOD MAN.
ALICE.
NO, HE IS.
I SEE IT IN HIS EYES
WHEN HE APOLOGIZES. HE JUST...
HE WRITES POETRY
ASKING FOR MY FORGIVENESS.
HURTING ME
DOESN'T MAKE HIM FEEL GOOD.
IT JUST MAKES HIM
HATE HIMSELF MORE.
WELL,
I'M SURE HE FEELS THAT,
BUT, ALICE, YOU HAVE
TO TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY
TO STAY STRONG
AND FOLLOW THROUGH.
DON'T TAKE HIM BACK.
I'M SORRY.
IT'S NOT MY PLACE
TO TELL YOU THAT.
OF COURSE IT IS.
I RESPECT YOUR OPINION.
IT'S JUST NOT SO EASY.
I MEAN, HE'S MY HUSBAND.
I MADE VOWS BEFORE GOD.
GOD DOESN'T WANT YOU
IN AN ABUSIVE RELATIONSHIP,
VOWS OR NO VOWS.
I'M SO WEAK.
NO, YOU'RE NOT WEAK.
YOU ARE STRONG.
YOU ARE INCREDIBLY STRONG.
THANK YOU.
HOW DOES
YOUR WRIST FEEL?
STIFF, BUT AT LEAST
IT'S OFF, RIGHT?
OH, SINGLE LIFE SUITS YOU.
I'm not single.
I'M SEPARATED.
OKAY. WHATEVER YOU ARE,
YOU'RE LOOKING GREAT.
I FEEL GREAT.
IT'S SUCH A LUXURY,
NOT BEING AFRAID.
YOU KNOW, PEOPLE TAKE
THIS SORT OF THING FOR GRANTED.
I WANT TO CELEBRATE.
I JUST DON'T WANT ANYTHING BAD
TO HAPPEN TO YOU.
NOTHING'S GONNA HAPPEN.
ALL THE BAD STUFF
IS BEHIND ME.
I CAN FEEL IT.
HAS HE CONTACTED YOU?
NO. NO, HE'S BEING
VERY RESPECTFUL.
LET'S HAVE A SUNDAE.
COME ON!
HI, HONEY.
HOW WAS SCHOOL?
SIT DOWN.
I GOT YOU A SNACK.
WHAT'S WRONG?
IS HE COMING BACK?
YOU WANT HIM TO?
YEAH.
HERE.
THANKS.
IT'S SO NICE TO SEE YOU
WITHOUT YOUR iPOD AND THOSE
THINGS IN YOUR EARS AND...
HEADPHONES?
YEAH.
YEAH.
THEY BLOCK US OUT.
I'M SORRY.
OH, HONEY, IT'S MY FAULT.
MOM, IT'S NOT
YOUR FAULT, OKAY?
OKAY.
THINGS ARE GONNA BE
DIFFERENT FROM NOW ON, BABY.
I PROMISE YOU.
OKAY.
- HI.
- HI.
HOW WAS THE BOOK SIGNING?
GOT HER TO AUTOGRAPH IT
FOR YOU.
"TO PASTOR DREW,
"MAY YOUR AURA
FOREVER GLOW BRIGHTLY
AND ILLUMINE THE SKY."
"THE SKY."YES, YES, "THE SKY."
THIS SKY? THE SKY OR...
THIS SKY... DON'T DISMISS IT
OUT OF HAND.
I READ IT, AND IT'S EXPANSIVE
AND THRILLING
'CAUSE IT'S NOT PUNITIVE.
YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT BASED
IN REDEMPTION OR GUILT.
IT'S JUST ABOUT BEING PRESENT,
HERE AND NOW.
MM-HMM.
OH...
YOU SHOULDN'T DO THAT.
YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW HER.
WANT SOME TEA?
YES, PLEASE.
YOU KNOW I WANT
A SPIRITUAL CONNECTION,
AND I'M JUST NOT
COMPLETELY FULFILLED
BY THE CHRISTIAN TEACHINGS.
WELL, YOU CAN'T LEAVE
THE CHURCH.
I'D QUIT THE PARISH
IN TWO SECONDS.
REALLY?
MM-HMM.
YOU WOULD QUIT?
BECAUSE I COULDN'T
BEAR THE FACT
OF LOOKING OUT
OVER THAT PULPIT
AND NOT SEEING YOUR FACE,
THAT'S WHY.
WHERE WOULD YOU GO?
I DON'T KNOW.
DESERTED ISLAND SOMEWHERE.
MM-HMM.
TALK TO COCONUTS.
I'LL PREACH TO COCONUTS.
HOW'S KATIE DOING?
HOW'S SHE ADJUSTING?
SHE'S HELD SO MUCH IN
FOR SO LONG.
NOW WHEN I SEE HER,
SHE'S LIKE A LITTLE FLOWER
JUST READY TO BLOSSOM.
I COULD SAY THE SAME THING
ABOUT YOU.
ANYWAY...
WE'RE DOING MOTHER
AND DAUGHTER THINGS TOGETHER
FOR THE FIRST TIME
SINCE SHE WAS A LITTLE GIRL.
THAT'S AMAZING.
SOMETHING SO SMALL
CAN SEEM SO BIG.
I'VE BEEN PRAYING FOR YOU
A LOT.
GOD, IT JUST ALWAYS
MAKES ME WANT TO CRY,
TALKING ABOUT IT.
ALICE, I CAN'T SEE HOW ANYONE
WOULD WANT TO HURT YOU, EVER.
I'M SO SORRY.
NO.
OH, MY GOD,
I'M SO EMBARRASSED.
IT'S OKAY. NO, IT'S OKAY.
I'M NOT GONNA LIE.
IT'S... IT'S NOT LIKE
I'M NOT ATTRACTED TO YOU.
LET'S JUST FORGET
THIS EVER HAPPENED.
NO.
MMM.
PLEASE REMIND ME WHO I AM.
YOU SLEPT
WITH STEPHEN DREW?
THERE IS A WOMAN
UNDER THESE FRUMPY CLOTHES.
YEAH, YEAH, YEAH, YEAH.
SO, UH, DETAILS?
AMAZING!
HE WAS SO GENEROUS
AND SO PRESENT AND SO HOT.
I DON'T THINK
I'LL EVER BE ABLE TO LOOK
AT HIM THE SAME WAY.
ME, EITHER.
IT'S ABOUT TIME.
OH, GOD, THANK YOU.
YOU KNOW, I NEVER THOUGHT OF
MYSELF AS THE SORT OF WOMAN
WHO GETS TO TAKE A LOVER.
MMM.
"TAKE A LOVER."
I TOOK A LOVER.
AND IT WAS GOOD.
IN MY LIFE, THINGS HAVE
BEEN SO MUCH BETTER.
I'M ABLE TO LAUGH
AND PLAY WITH KATIE.
WE'RE SPENDING
SO MUCH MORE TIME TOGETHER.
♪ I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM
♪ YOU CAN SEE,
BUT DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY ♪
♪ OH, I BET YOU WANT ME
♪ I'M IN A LOVE AFFAIR
WITHOUT A LOVE SONG ♪
♪ I'M IN THE HABIT
OF HAVING WHAT I DON'T WANT ♪
I NEVER REALIZED HOW MUCH I WAS MISSING, HOW MUCH I SHUT DOWN.
NOW I'M BEGINNING TO FEEL
ALL THE JOY
THAT COMES WITH BEING PART
OF MY DAUGHTER'S LIFE.
♪ I'M IN A LOVE AFFAIR
WITHOUT A LOVE SONG ♪
♪ I'M IN THE HABIT
OF HAVING WHAT I DON'T WANT ♪
♪ I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM
♪ YOU CAN SEE,
BUT DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY ♪
♪ OH, I BET YOU WANT ME NOW
♪ DON'T TOUCH ME, BABY,
I'M JUST A HOLOGRAM ♪
I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU CAME
TO ONE OF MY GAMES.
WHAT, YOU KIDDING ME?
I LOVE WATCHING YOU PLAY.
YOU KNOW WHAT?
YOU ARE GETTING PRETTY GOOD
WITH THAT LEFT FOOT.
WELL, I'VE BEEN WORKING
ON IT.
YEAH?
SO, WHAT'S IN THE BAG?
WHAT, THIS BAG?
A LITTLE SOMETHING FOR YOU.
HELP MAKE YOU PLAY BETTER.
OKAY.
THESE ARE LIKE 200 BUCKS.
ONLY THE BEST FOR MY BABY,
RIGHT?
OH, THANK YOU!
YOU'RE WELCOME.
I MISS YOU, DAD.
I MISS YOU, TOO.
INVITE ME
TO YOUR NEXT GAME?
NOPE.
HEY.
HEY, PASTOR DREW.
WHAT YOU DOING?
WORKING ON YOUR MOM'S CAR,
YOU KNOW, DOING MANLY STUFF.
STEPHEN?
TIME FOR A BREAK.
HEY, BABE.
HOW WAS SOCCER?
GOOD.
ICED TEA?
UM, I'LL... I'LL BE FINE.
THANKS, THOUGH.
YOU GONNA JOIN US?
I GOT SOME HOMEWORK AND STUFF
TO DO, BUT YOU GUYS HAVE FUN.
ISN'T THAT SO NICE OF STEPHEN
TO HELP ME WITH MY CAR?
DAD'S BEEN TEXTING ME.
OH, GOOD. I'M GLAD.
REALLY?
YEAH.
HE'S YOUR DAD.
YOU NEED TO KNOW
HOW MUCH HE LOVES YOU.
YOU WANT TO KNOW A SECRET?
HE'S BEEN WRITING ME
POETRY.
YEAH, I KNOW.
YOU DO?
UM, I THINK IT MEANS
THAT HE MISSES YOU.
IS IT ANY GOOD?
IT'S TERRIBLE!
WE SHOULDN'T LAUGH.
IT'S A REALLY SWEET SIDE
OF YOUR DAD.
IT REALLY IS.
I LOVE YOU, MOM.
I LOVE YOU, TOO.
COME HERE.
MWAH!
I DON'T THINK KATIE
SUSPECTS ANYTHING,
BUT I WON'T LIE IF SHE ASKS.
THANK YOU.
WOULDN'T IT BE NICE
IF WE DIDN'T HAVE TO HIDE?
YES, IT WOULD.
WHAT WOULD GEORGE SAY?
LET'S NOT THINK
ABOUT THAT.
IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM.
READ THE LAST LINE
ON THAT PAGE RIGHT THERE,
THAT LINE, OUT LOUD.
"AND THEN STEPHEN
SAID TO ME..."
PASTOR.
"STEPHEN SAID..."
PASTOR.
"AND THEN STEPHEN
SAID TO ME..."
"IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM."
"IF HE EVER HURTS YOU AGAIN,
I'LL KILL HIM."
ARE YOU ACTUALLY DENYING
THAT YOU TOLD ALICE
YOU'D KILL GEORGE
IF HE EVER
TOUCHED HER AGAIN?
JUST BECAUSE
I SAID SOMETHING
DOESN'T MEAN
I ACTUALLY DID IT.
HOW DID THE AFFAIR END?
READ FOR YOURSELF.
WELL, ACTUALLY SHE DIDN'T WRITE
ABOUT IT IN HER JOURNAL.
I'M GUESSING SHE LOVED YOU
TOO MUCH
TO WRITE ANYTHING BAD
ABOUT YOU.
YOU DIDN'T KNOW
ABOUT THE JOURNAL, DID YOU?
OTHERWISE, YOU SURELY
WOULD HAVE GRABBED IT
WHEN YOU WENT TO,
UH, CLEAN THE HOUSE.
YOU KNOW, YOU HAVE NO RIGHT
BARGING INTO A HOUSE
OF WORSHIP,
TREATING ME
LIKE I'M ON TRIAL.
I DON'T HAVE TO ANSWER
YOUR QUESTIONS.
I'VE GOT NEWS FOR YOU...
THE WORLD'S TIRED
OF CLERGYMEN TAKING SEXUAL
ADVANTAGE OF THEIR FLOCK.
I DIDN'T TAKE ADVANTAGE
OF HER.
YOU OUTRIGHT LIED ABOUT
YOUR INVOLVEMENT WITH HER.
WHAT ELSE
ARE YOU LYING ABOUT?
I DID NOT KILL GEORGE.
I DON'T BELIEVE YOU.
HUH.
YOU'VE GOT BLOOD
ON YOUR HANDS.
AND IN TIME, I'LL PROVE IT.
GINNY, YOU TOLD
CATHERINE BENINCASA
ABOUT ALICE AND ME,
DIDN'T YOU?
ALL I SAID IS
THAT ALICE KEPT A JOURNAL.
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?
YOU DON'T TRUST ME?
NO. I DON'T TRUST YOU.
YOU CONDEMNED HER TO DIE.
OH, GINNY, DON'T SAY THAT.IT'S TRUE.
YOU DAMN WELL KNOW IT.
SHE WOULD HAVE LEFT HIM
FOR YOU.
SHE'D STILL BE WITH US.
WE'D ALL STILL HAVE HER...
YOU, ME, KATIE.
SHE LOVED YOU.
I KNOW.
THERE.
THERE.
THERE.
THERE.
PLEASE TELL ME SHE WASN'T
PREPARING TO DIE.
WHAT HAVE I DONE?
LORD, HELP ME.
THANK YOU.
THE JOURNAL PROVES
HE'S LYING, EMMET.
- LET'S DO IT.
- You sure about this?
YEAH.
GET A SEARCH WARRANT.
LET'S SEE WHAT ELSE
STEPHEN DREW IS HIDING.
You got it.
WHOA.
THIS PLACE IS A MESS.
WHAT HAPPENED?
UNEXPECTED VISITORS.
THE POLICE?
COME ON. SIT DOWN.
TELL ME.
TELL ME... HOW ARE YOU?
I'M FINE.
KATIE.
I REALLY MISS MY MOM.
AND MY DAD.
PASTOR DREW.
I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR YOU.
I JUST WENT BY YOUR PLACE.
YEAH.
I HEARD ABOUT THE POLICE
GOING THROUGH IT.
WHAT WAS THAT ALL ABOUT?
CATHERINE BENINCASA HAS ME
IN HER CROSS HAIRS.
THERE'S NOTHING WRONG.
SHE HAS NO EVIDENCE,
BUT SHE NEEDS A VILLAIN,
AND, UH, APPARENTLY
SHE'S CHOSEN ME.
NOT LIKE I HAVEN'T MADE MISTAKES
IN MY LIFE, BUT I'M NO CRIMINAL.
OF COURSE
YOU'RE NOT A CRIMINAL.
I'M GOING UP TO MY CABIN
ON THE LAKE FOR A LITTLE WHILE.
YOU SHOULD COME UP
SOMEDAY THIS WEEK.
YOU LOOK LIKE
YOU COULD USE A BREAK.
THANKS. THAT'S SWEET.
YOU SHOULD THINK ABOUT IT.
OKAY.
YOU EXECUTED A WARRANT,
AND IT TURNED UP NOTHING.
ABSOLUTELY UNTRUE.
WE FOUND HIS LAPTOP,
AND WE DISCOVERED
THAT HE SEARCHED WEBSITES
LIKE, UM, "HOW TO REMOVE
BLOOD STAINS,"
"THE BEST WAY TO CLEAN
FINGERPRINTS,"
"GUN BLOWBACK."
WE HAVE MOTIVE.
WE HAVE FORENSIC EVIDENCE.
YEAH, BUT NONE OF IT
TIES HIM TO THE MURDER.
AND HE WAS MERELY SEARCHING
FORENSIC WEBSITES.
HIS DNA, HIS FINGERPRINTS
ARE ALL OVER THE HAYWARD HOUSE.
CATHERINE, HE WAS SLEEPING
WITH HER.
THERE'S NOTHING ON THE GUN.
HE SEARCHED THOSE WEBSITES
AT 2:30 IN THE MORNING,
AN HOUR AFTER GEORGE HAYWARD
WAS SHOT.
WHAT MORE DO I NEED?
A WITNESS?
A CONFESSION?
EVERYTHING YOU HAVE
IS CIRCUMSTANTIAL.
WE HAVE GOTTEN CONVICTIONS
WITH LESS, AND YOU KNOW IT.
AND WE WON'T WITH THIS ONE,
NOT WITH STEPHEN DREW.
YOU KNOW,
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT HIM
LIKE HE'S SOME KIND OF SAINT,
I MEAN, LIKE HE'S UNTOUCHABLE.
IF YOU GET THIS TO TRIAL,
THE JURY WILL INTERPRET
YOUR PASSION
AS A PERSONAL VENDETTA
BECAUSE THEY'LL TAKE
ONE LOOK AT THAT GUY,
AND YOU KNOW WHAT
THEY'RE GONNA SEE?
THEY'RE GONNA SEE A HANDSOME,
DECENT, HARDWORKING PASTOR
WHO'S A BIG PART
OF THIS COMMUNITY
AND WHO'S DONE NOTHING
BUT GOOD WORK HERE.
HE'S GONNA WALK.
AND YOUR REPUTATION AND MINE
WILL TAKE A BIG HIT.
YOU SHOULD COME UP
SOMEDAY THIS WEEK.
YOU SHOULD THINK ABOUT IT.
HEY, THERE YOU ARE.
I WAS GETTING WORRIED.
YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO PICK ME UP
AN HOUR AGO.
DON'T WORRY.
I LEFT MY SUITCASE
IN THE TRUNK.
NO ONE SAW ME COME IN.
I, UH...
I CALLED THE HOTEL.
I GOT US AN UPGRADE.
WHY NOT, RIGHT... OUR FIRST
NIGHT AWAY TOGETHER?
WHY DON'T I HELP YOU PACK?
ALICE, SIT DOWN.
ALICE... WE CAN'T CONTINUE.
WHY NOT?
WELL, IT'S...
IT'S JUST ALL SO COMPLICATED.
I MEAN, I'M SUPPOSED TO BE
A MAN OF GOD.
MAYBE IT'S GOD WILL.
YOU'RE STILL MARRIED.
AND THERE'S KATIE
AND... AND THE CONGREGATION.
I MEAN, WHAT WOULD
THE CONGREGATION THINK OF ME?
GEORGE HAS BEEN CALLING.
HE WANTS TO COME HOME.
NO, ALICE.
HE AND I PROBABLY
BELONG TOGETHER.
I WON'T BE THE KIND OF WOMAN
WHO SAYS
SHE HAD NO IDEA
WHEN SHE MARRIED
THAT HER HUSBAND
MIGHT BEAT HER.
IT'S NAIVE.
IT'S A COP-OUT.
DON'T BE SO HARD
ON YOURSELF.
I'M NOT BEING HARD
ON MYSELF.
I'M JUST BEING REALISTIC.
ALICE, YOU CAN
LIVE WITHOUT HIM.
YOU'VE PROVEN THAT.
YOU KNOW WHAT ATTRACTED ME
TO GEORGE IN THE FIRST PLACE?
HE COULDN'T LIVE
WITHOUT ME.
HE MADE ME FEEL SPECIAL.
HE NEEDED ME.
YOU DON'T.
HE'S A DANGEROUS MAN.
WE CAN SAY A LOT OF BAD THINGS
ABOUT GEORGE, COULDN'T WE?
BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY,
HE LOVES ME.
PLEASE DON'T GO BACK.
IF THERE'S ONE THING
I'VE LEARNED ABOUT
BEING WITH YOU...
IT'S THAT...
I NEED TO BE LOVED.
GEORGE HAS BEEN CALLING ME,
PLEADING WITH ME TO GIVE HIM
ANOTHER CHANCE.
SO MUCH PAIN IN HIS VOICE.
I DON'T WANT TO PUT HIM
THROUGH THAT ANYMORE.
I CAN'T HELP BUT THINK
IT COULD BE DIFFERENT,
BUT I COULD MAKE IT WORK.
JUST A LITTLE BIT FURTHER.
EYES CLOSED, RIGHT?
EYES CLOSED, EYES CLOSED.
GEORGE, YOU KNOW
I DON'T LIKE SURPRISES.
NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO,
YOU'RE GONNA LOVE THIS.
TRUST ME.
OKAY, A LITTLE FURTHER,
A LITTLE FURTHER.
AND OPEN YOUR EYES.
I LOVE IT.
YOU DO?
WOW.
SIT.
AND I MADE THAT MYSELF.
IT DIDN'T COME FROM A JAR.
UH... OH, NO. WHAT?
WHAT?
IS IT TOO MUCH LIME?
YOU KNOW, IT'S THE THOUGHT
THAT COUNTS.
OKAY.
WELL, WINE, RIGHT?
THANK YOU.
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
HONEY, I, UH...
I NEVER MEANT TO HURT YOU.
YOU KNOW THAT, RIGHT?
BUT I KNOW THAT I HAVE,
OVER AND OVER AGAIN,
AND I... IT MAKES ME
HATE MYSELF.
GEORGE, YOU DON'T HAVE TO...
NO, I DO, OKAY?
FROM THE FIRST MOMENT
I SAW YOU,
I KNEW THAT SOMEHOW,
SOMEWAY WE HAD TO BE TOGETHER,
I... I HAD TO HAVE YOU.
AND I CROSSED THE LINE
IN TRYING TO MAKE THAT HAPPEN,
TRYING TO KEEP YOU.
GEORGE.
HOW CAN YOU DO THIS?
WHAT IS THE MATTER
WITH YOU?
KATIE WANTS HIM
TO COME HOME.
KATIE IS A CHILD.
SHE DOESN'T UNDERSTAND.
HE'S MADE CHANGES.
HE'S HAD COUNSELING.
THAT KIND OF BEHAVIOR
DOESN'T CHANGE
WITH A LITTLE COUNSELING.
TWO WEEKS AGO, YOU SAID
YOU WERE FALLING IN LOVE
WITH STEPHEN DREW.
DOESN'T MATTER ANYMORE.
HE DUMPED YOU, DIDN'T HE?
SON OF A BITCH.
DON'T.
DON'T RUIN IT.
IT WAS BEAUTIFUL.
I'VE NEVER HAD ANYTHING
LIKE THAT BEFORE.
I'M GRATEFUL.
I WISH YOU'D WAKE UP.
I AM AWAKE, GINNY,
WIDE AWAKE.
THIS IS WHERE
I'M SUPPOSED TO BE.
HEY, MOM,
WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT
TAKING CHINESE FOOD
OUT TONIGHT?
SWEETIE, YOUR DAD AND I
HAVE BEEN TALKING.
WE'RE GONNA TRY
TO WORK IT OUT.
LOOK...
I PROMISE YOU
IT'S GONNA BE OKAY.
NO, I-I'M REALLY GLAD
THAT YOU'RE TAKING HIM BACK.
YOU ARE?
YEAH.
AND HE PROMISED ME THAT
HE WOULDN'T HURT YOU AGAIN.
OKAY.
YEAH.
GO ORDER.
YEAH.
I AM NOT A VICTIM.
MAYBE IT LOOKS LIKE I AM.
I KNOW PEOPLE IN TOWN
MIGHT THINK SO
IF THEY KNEW WHAT'S HAPPENED
IN THIS HOUSE.
BUT DEEP INSIDE ME,
I KNOW I'M NOT.
GEORGE DOESN'T BEAT ME
BECAUSE HE WANTS TO HURT ME.
HE DOES IT 'CAUSE
HE'S AFRAID TO LOSE ME.
WOW.
THE THING ABOUT GEORGE IS,
I UNDERSTAND HIM.
WE ALL NEED TO BE UNDERSTOOD.
I'LL NEVER
LET YOU GO AGAIN.
HELLO?
Stephen? Aaron Lance.
OH, HEY, AARON. THANKS SO MUCH
FOR CALLING ME BACK.
LISTEN... YOU REMEMBER
YOU TOLD ME
IF I EVER NEEDED A LAWYER
TO GIVE YOU A CALL?
I'm at your service, pastor.
What's up?
YEAH, WELL...
I'M CALLING YOU.
I'M GONNA BE LEAVING TOWN
FOR A WHILE.
HELLO, JIM.
HELLO, AARON.
AND HERE'S HAVERILL'S
FAVORITE SPITFIRE.
HELLO.
WHERE'S YOUR CLIENT?
OH, HE'S NOT COMING BACK
UNTIL HE'S ASSURED
HE WON'T BE ARRESTED.
WELL, THEN,
WE'LL JUST FIND HIM.
CATHERINE, WE ALL KNOW
YOU DON'T HAVE ENOUGH
TO GET EVEN AN INDICTMENT.
THIS ONLY GOES FORWARD
IF HE CONFESSES,
AND HE'S NOT GONNA CONFESS
TO A CRIME HE DID NOT COMMIT.
NOW, I UNDERSTAND
YOU'RE VERY PASSIONATE
ABOUT THIS CASE,
AND I COMMEND YOU FOR IT.
YOU'RE JUST WRONG.
WELL, WE'LL SEE.
IT'S ALWAYS VERY NICE
TO SEE YOU.
MM-HMM.
OH. OOH.
LULA, NO.
HEY. HEY.
OH, KATIE, HI.
I'M REALLY SORRY
TO JUST STOP BY LIKE THIS,
BUT I REALLY NEED YOUR HELP.
IT'S ABOUT PASTOR DREW,
ISN'T IT?
YES.
LISTEN, UM...
COULD YOU JUST COME OUTSIDE?
CAN WE... CAN WE TALK?
YEAH. YEAH, SURE.
I MEAN, I'M NOT SURPRISED.
I KNOW YOU GUYS SEARCHED HIS
HOUSE AND EVERYTHING, BUT...
PASTOR DREW? REALLY?
ANYTHING YOU CAN THINK OF,
KATIE, ANYTHING AT ALL.
ALL I CAN THINK OF
IS HOW MUCH SHE LIKED HIM.
I MEAN,
SHE... REALLY LIKED HIM.
YOU KNEW ABOUT THE AFFAIR?
SHE TRIED TO HIDE IT,
BUT, I MEAN, I FIGURED IT OUT.
IS THAT WHY
YOU GUYS THINK IT'S HIM?
WELL, IT CERTAINLY
GIVES HIM MOTIVE, YES.
I HAD THIS, UH, DREAM
A COUPLE OF NIGHTS AGO.
AND, UM,
MY PARENTS WERE DEAD.
AND THEN LULA WAS LAPPING
THE BLOOD OFF MY DAD'S HEAD.
AND IT WAS REALLY DISGUSTING
AND IT FELT REALLY REAL
AND THEN WHEN I WOKE UP,
IT JUST... I GOT SICK AND...
KATIE, LISTEN.
WHEN THE POLICE GOT HERE,
LULA WAS OUTSIDE, OKAY?
SO, EVEN IF THAT SEEMED REAL
IN YOUR DREAM...
MM-HMM.
...IT DIDN'T HAPPEN
IN REAL LIFE, OKAY?
WAIT. OKAY.
LULA'S NEVER OUTSIDE
UNLESS SHE'S ON A LEASH.
SO, WHOEVER SHOT YOUR DAD
MUST HAVE LET HER OUT.
SHE WOULD HAVE ATTACKED
SOMEBODY THAT SHE DOESN'T KNOW,
ESPECIALLY AT THE HOUSE.
SHE DOESN'T LIKE STRANGERS,
AND SHE HATES MEN,
EXCEPT FOR DAD
AND PASTOR DREW.
SO, YOU'RE SAYING SHE WOULD
HAVE ATTACKED A STRANGER.
YEAH, SHREDDED THEM.
MY PARENTS
ALMOST GOT SUED ONCE.
BUT THE ONLY BLOOD IN THE HOUSE
BELONGED TO YOUR PARENTS.
KATIE...
LULA MUST HAVE KNOWN
YOUR FATHER'S KILLER.
SHE MUST HAVE.
OH.
DON'T LET IT,
LIKE, BE HIM 'C...
I'm so sorry.
PLEASE DON'T LET IT BE HIM.
YOU MADE IT.
YEAH.
THANKS FOR THE INVITE.
THANKS FOR COMING.
I'LL TAKE THAT.
SURE.
SO, COME ON BACK.
THIS PLACE IS AWFUL.
I MEAN,
IT LOOKS LIKE A SHACK.
IS IT HAUNTED?
IT'S MY REFUGE.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL.
THANK YOU.
REALLY BEAUTIFUL.
OH, I READ YOUR BOOK.
UH-HUH?
AND I LIKED IT.
BUT...?
WELL, YOU TALK A LOT
ABOUT ILLUMINATION
AND CHERUBS AND SERAPHIM
AND FLYING MONKEYS.
IS THAT REALLY ALL YOU GOT
FROM MY BOOK?
YOU KNOW, I TALK ABOUT
GRIEF AND CLOSURE, TOO.
YEAH, I KNOW.
I LIKED THAT PART.
BUT YOU CAME.
SO YOU DON'T THINK
I'M A COMPLETE PHONY.
I DON'T THINK
YOU'RE A COMPLETE PHONY.
WHO AM I TO TALK?
I DON'T HAVE ANY ANSWERS.
I SPEND MY DAYS
COUNSELING PEOPLE,
AND I CAN BARELY
MANAGE MY OWN LIFE.
MM.
YEP.
LET'S GO FOR A WALK.
I'M GLAD YOU CAME.
I'M GLAD I CAME, TOO.
ALICE.
YOU JUST CALLED ME ALICE.
DON'T.
I'M SORRY.
DID YOU LOVE HER?
I DID.
I DID LOVE HER.
AND YOU THOUGHT
YOU COULD SAVE HER.
I THOUGHT SHE WAS SAVING HERSELF
WHEN SHE LEFT GEORGE.
I JUST...
I COULDN'T HANDLE THAT.
I... I DON'T KNOW.
ALICE WAS PART
OF THE CONGREGATION.
SHE WAS IN THIS ABUSIVE
RELATIONSHIP.
SEEING THOSE SCARS...
THE BOTTOM LINE IS
THAT... I BROKE IT OFF,
SHE WENT BACK TO GEORGE,
AND HE KILLED HER.
THE TRUTH IS, I GUESS,
I DIDN'T REALLY REALIZE
THAT I TRULY LOVED HER
UNTIL IT WAS TOO LATE.
BEING IN THAT HOUSE,
ALL THE BLOOD,
LIFE DRAINED FROM HER BODY,
ALL I COULD THINK OF
WAS KATIE
AND HOW HER LIFE
AS SHE KNEW IT WAS OVER.
I HAD TO HELP HER.
EVEN IF MEANS
GOING TO JAIL, I...
I'M SORRY.
I SHOULD GO.
NO. STAY.
IS THAT ALL RIGHT?
YEAH, OF COURSE.
IT'S ALMOST MORNING.
WE'LL TALK MORE THEN.
THANK YOU.
MY BAG IN THE CAR.
MRS. BENINCASA?
AH.
GOOD MORNING, PASTOR.
WE NEED TO TALK.
EMMET.
GENTLEMEN.
STEPHEN DREW,
YOU ARE UNDER ARREST FOR
THE MURDER OF GEORGE HAYWARD.
STEPHEN,
WILL YOU BAPTIZE ME?
DID YOU HEAR ME?
SORRY. YES.
ALICE, I THINK ABOUT YOU
ALL THE TIME.
DON'T.
THIS ISN'T ABOUT YOU AND ME.
IT'S ABOUT A RECOMMITMENT
TO MY FAITH.
WHAT ABOUT GEORGE?
WHAT WILL HE THINK?
I DON'T GIVE A DAMN
WHAT GEORGE THINKS.
SO, YOU'LL TELL HIM?
IF HE ASKS.
YOU THINK THAT'S SMART?
I'M THE MASTER
OF MY OWN DESTINY, STEPHEN...
NOT YOU AND NOT GEORGE.
SO, WILL YOU BAPTIZE ME?
YES, ALICE,
I'LL BAPTIZE YOU.
CAN I HELP YOU?
YEAH, YOU CAN STAY AWAY
FROM MY WIFE.
HOW ABOUT THAT?
OH, THERE'S SO MANY THINGS
I'D LIKE TO SAY TO YOU
RIGHT NOW.
YEAH?
SO, WHAT'S STOPPING YOU?
RESPECT FOR YOUR WIFE.
I SAW YOU TALKING
TO HER TODAY IN TOWN.
I FOLLOWED HER.
YOUR COWARDICE
ASTONISHES ME.
THE MORE INVOLVED SHE'S GOTTEN
WITH YOU AND YOUR CHURCH,
THE MORE DISRESPECTFUL
SHE'S GOTTEN AT HOME.
CHERISH WHAT YOU HAVE.
YOU PUT ANY MORE IDEAS
INTO MY WIFE'S HEAD,
AND I SWEAR TO GOD
I WILL KILL YOU.
HOW YOU DOING THESE DAYS?
I ACTUALLY FEEL PRETTY GUILTY
MOST OF THE TIME.
HOW COME?
SO, I JUST KEEP THINKING
THAT IF I DIDN'T GO
TO THAT CONCERT
AND IF I DIDN'T
LEAVE HER ALONE...
THEN THEY WOULDN'T
HAVE FOUGHT?
AND YOUR MOTHER
WOULD STILL BE ALIVE?
BUT THEY'D BOTH BE ALIVE,
YOU KNOW?
I MEAN, I COULDN'T BE THERE
ALL THE TIME.
AND THEY'D ACTUALLY
STOPPED FIGHTING,
SO I FIGURED JUST ONE NIGHT OUT
WITH MY FRIENDS WAS...
OF COURSE YOU DID, KATIE.
YOU'RE A KID.
YOU DESERVE THAT.
KATIE, IT WASN'T YOUR FAULT.
IT WASN'T.
MRS. BENINCASA, YOU THINK
THAT PASTOR DREW SHOT MY DAD,
DON'T YOU?
I'M SURE HE DID.
IT'S RIGHT AROUND HERE.
LET ME CHECK WITH THE OFFICE
AND I'LL GET BACK TO YOU.
I CAN'T BELIEVE
YOU'RE LETTING HIM GO.
YOU'VE GOT NO CONFESSION,
AND HE'S MADE BOND.
WE HAVE NO CHOICE
BUT TO LET HIM GO.
WE'LL NEVER BE ABLE
TO CONVICT HIM FOR MURDER
WITH WHAT WE HAVE.
I'M SORRY, CATHERINE.
SO, WHAT, ARE YOU GONNA
PRESS CHARGES NOW?
IS THAT PART
OF YOUR NEW ATTITUDE?
I SHOULD.
YOU GOT BAPTIZED
TO SPITE ME?
OH, GOD, HOW MANY TIMES
DO I HAVE TO TELL YOU?
THIS HAD NOTHING TO DO
WITH YOU.
IT WAS ABOUT ME,
GEORGE, ME!
YOU DID IT TO PLEASE HIM,
AND YOU DID IT TO MOCK ME.
WELL, GUESS WHAT.
A MAN LIKE THAT DOESN'T
WANT A WHORE LIKE YOU!
YES, HE DID!
HE WANTED ME!
AND HE HAD ME IN THIS HOUSE,
IN THIS KITCHEN,
IN THE BEDROOM!
AND GUESS WHAT!
I LIKED IT!
AH!
WHORE!
SHUT UP!
HELLO, PASTOR.
YOU HAVE NO EVIDENCE,
CATHERINE.
DON'T YOU THINK IT'S TIME
TO LET IT GO?
NO, BECAUSE I THINK YOU'RE
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER.
BUT I WON'T GIVE UP ON KATIE
LIKE YOU DID ON ALICE.
I'LL BE WATCHING YOU.
WITH SUMMER ALMOST OVER,
LIFE SEEMS TO BE
RETURNING TO NORMAL.
THE CASE IS COLD, AND NO OTHER
SUSPECTS WERE EVER NAMED.
I DON'T SEE MUCH OF CATHERINE BENINCASA THESE DAYS.
NOT SURPRISINGLY, SHE NO LONGER
ATTENDS MY CHURCH.
I STILL THINK OF ALICE
EVERY DAY.
I NOW KNOW THAT WHAT I DID
WAS PART OF GOD'S PLAN.
MANY OF MY CONGREGANTS
HAVE STRUGGLED
TO PUT THE EVENTS OF THE PAST
MONTHS BEHIND THEM,
BUT WE'RE BEGINNING
TO FIND OUR WAY AGAIN.
HEALING HAS A FUNNY WAY
OF FINDING ITS WAY
THROUGH DARKNESS.
KATIE HAS A LOT OF GRIEVING
TO DO,
BUT LIVING AT GINNY'S
HAS DONE HER SOME GOOD.
FOR WHAT IT'S WORTH, SHE KNOWS
I'LL ALWAYS BE THERE FOR HER.
HEY, PASTOR DREW.
THANKS AGAIN FOR EVERYTHING.
PROMISE ME
YOU'LL LET US KNOW
IF THERE'S ANYTHING YOU NEED.
NO, I WILL. I PROMISE.
OKAY.
GIVE ME THIS.
THANKS.
I AM GONNA MISS YOU
SO MUCH.
I'M GONNA MISS YOU, TOO.
DRIVE SAFE.
I'M GONNA MISS YOU
THE MOST.
YEAH.
THANKS FOR DRIVING ME.
YOU KIDDING ME?
IT'S MY HONOR.
YOU MUST BE EXCITED...
COLBY.
YEAH.
MMM.
BYE.
GUYS?
MOM?
DAD?
THE HAYWARDS...
THEY APPEARED
TO HAVE IT ALL...
MOM?
...BLESSED WITH GOOD HEALTH...
MOM?
MOM?! MOM?!
MO...
MO...
...AND A BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER,
KATIE...
DAD?
DAD? DAD, IT'S... DA...
...EVERY PARENT'S DREAM,
KIND-HEARTED, RESPONSIBLE,
AND SMART.
GEORGE OWNED A SUCCESSFUL CHAIN OF SPORTING-GOOD STORES
ACROSS THE STATE...
EVERY WOMAN'S DREAM.
ALICE WAS A HOMEMAKER,
AND SHE WAS ACTIVE IN CHURCH.
THE ALL-AMERICAN FAMILY.
BUT THAT'S THE TROUBLE OF BEING ON THE OUTSIDE, LOOKING IN...
YOU NEVER REALLY KNOW.
I DIDN'T KNOW
WHERE ELSE TO GO.
I COULDN'T GO BACK TO TINA'S.
YOU'RE SAFE HERE.
YOU'RE SAFE HERE.
YOU CAN TRUST ME.
PUT YOUR HANDS UNDER THERE.
SO, ARE WE... ARE WE
SUPPOSED TO CALL THE POLICE?
NO, NO, NO,
NO, NO, NO, NO.
WE'RE NOT GONNA CALL
THE POLICE.
YOU'RE NOT GONNA GO
TO JAIL.
I WON'T LET YOU RUIN
THE REST OF YOUR LIFE.
I'LL MAKE IT LOOK LIKE
YOUR FATHER SHOT HIMSELF.
YEAH, BUT WHAT IF THEY
FIND OUT THAT HE DIDN'T?
IF THEY SUSPECT ANYONE,
WE'LL LET THEM SUSPECT ME.
THEN YOU'LL GO TO JAIL,
RIGHT?
I KNOW.
ALL RIGHT, NOW,
WHAT ABOUT TINA?
DOES SHE KNOW YOU'RE GONE?
NO, SHE WAS ASLEEP
WHEN I LEFT.
I JUST WANTED TO GET
MY COMPUTER.
ALL RIGHT, THEN YOU NEED
TO GET BACK TO TINA'S,
AND I'LL TAKE CARE OF THIS.
YOU'D DO THAT FOR ME?
I WOULD.
AND I WILL.
THE POLICE ARE STARTING
TO SUSPECT ME,
WHICH IS A GOOD THING.
SO, IF THEY QUESTION YOU,
INCRIMINATE ME.
YEAH, BUT THEN
YOU'RE GONNA GET ARRESTED.
THEN YOU'RE GOING TO JAIL,
AND I DON'T WANT THAT.
THIS WHOLE THING'S MY FAULT,
ANYWAY.
THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH EVIDENCE
TO CONVICT ME,
BUT I WANT THEM TO THINK
THAT I DID IT.
LISTEN... THE ONLY WAY THAT
YOUR MOM WON'T DIE IN VAIN
IS IF YOU LIVE A HAPPY LIFE.
I WANT TO GIVE YOU
THAT CHANCE.
YEAH, BUT...
JUST DO WHAT I TELL YOU.
THANKS AGAIN FOR EVERYTHING,
PASTOR DREW.
I'D DO IT AGAIN
IN A HEARTBEAT.
IF I LIVE TO BE OLD, I KNOW
I'LL HAVE A TON OF REGRETS,
BUT PUTTING A BULLET
IN MY DAD'S HEAD
WON'T EVER BE ONE OF THEM.